Studies · The Book of Concord for Ordinary Lutherans
Week 1 — Why Lutherans Have Confessions
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
The Book of Concord for Ordinary Lutherans
This week’s reading: The Preface to the Augsburg Confession. If you have time, glance also at the opening of the Formula of Concord (the section titled “Of the Comprehensive Summary, Rule, and Norm”) and at the prefaces to Luther’s Small and Large Catechisms. All are in the Book of Concord.
On the afternoon of June 25, 1530, in the German city of Augsburg, a group of Lutheran princes and theologians stood before Emperor Charles V and had a document read aloud, in German, so that everyone in the hall could understand it. That document was the Augsburg Confession. The men who signed it were not professional revolutionaries; they were governors and electors with a great deal to lose, and they knew it. They had even chosen a verse to set at the front of their cause: “I will also speak of your testimonies before kings and shall not be put to shame” (Psalm 119:46, ESV). Then they did exactly that.
Why would anyone risk so much simply to say out loud what he believed? Because confessing is not an optional extra to the Christian faith. It is part of the thing itself. “If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved” (Romans 10:9–10). Jesus Himself said, “Everyone who acknowledges me before men, I also will acknowledge before my Father who is in heaven” (Matthew 10:32). Faith believes; and faith that truly believes also speaks.
So what is a “confession”? In plain terms, a confession is the Church saying out loud, together and in public, what she has found to be true in the Word of God. The Latin word behind it is confessio — literally, “a saying-together,” an agreement spoken in the open. That is also what the whole collection is named. When the Lutherans gathered their core documents into one book in 1580, they called it the Book of Concord — concord meaning agreement, harmony, hearts in tune. It is the book in which the Church says, with one voice, “We believe, teach, and confess…” — a phrase you will meet again and again as we go, for it is the steady heartbeat of the whole book.
But if every Christian confesses Christ, why are there Lutheran confessions in particular? Because not everything was agreed upon. By the sixteenth century certain teachings — about how a sinner is made right with God, about grace and faith, about Baptism and the Lord’s Supper — had fallen into serious dispute. The men at Augsburg were convinced they were not inventing a new religion or starting a new church. They were holding fast to what the Scriptures and the ancient Church had taught all along, and saying so plainly at exactly the point where it was being denied. A confession, in that sense, is what the Church reaches for when the truth of God’s Word — and the Gospel at its heart — is at stake.
Now here is the point that keeps a confession from ever becoming a problem. A confession does not stand over the Bible. It stands under it. The Confessions never claim to add anything to Scripture or to compete with it; they claim only to repeat, faithfully and clearly, what Scripture already says. The Formula of Concord opens by saying exactly this: the one rule and standard by which every teaching and every teacher must be measured is the prophetic and apostolic Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments — and these alone. Scripture is the judge. The Confessions are the Church’s sworn testimony about what that judge has said — a witness under oath, not a second authority.
In other words, the Bible is the well; the Confessions are the bucket. The water is the same. We hold the bucket because it lets us draw the water cleanly, hand it to a neighbor, and pass it down to our children without spilling the Gospel along the way.
This is why a Lutheran can bind himself to these documents in good conscience. We do not hold the Confessions because they are old, or because Luther wrote them, or because they came to us by family habit. We hold them because we are convinced they explain the Scriptures rightly — that when you read the Augsburg Confession or the Catechism, you are hearing the Bible’s own teaching, faithfully and correctly set out. That is the difference between merely admiring a document and actually confessing it, and it is what makes a church a confessional church.
That last reason mattered enormously to Luther. A year or two before Augsburg, he had traveled through the churches of Saxony and was dismayed to discover how little ordinary people — and even some of their pastors — actually knew of the faith. So he sat down and wrote the Small Catechism, short and simple on purpose, so that the head of a household could teach it to his family at the kitchen table. The Confessions, at their warm center, are not a wall of theology built to keep people out. They are a doorway built to let ordinary people in.
Read the Preface to the Augsburg Confession this week with that in mind. You will notice how its signers bend over backward to be respectful and peaceable. They are not spoiling for a fight. They offer their teaching humbly, in answer to the Emperor’s own request, and they say plainly that they long for unity in the one Christian truth and stand ready to give an account of what they believe. They were trying, as far as it depended on them, to live at peace — and at the same time refusing to fall silent about the Gospel. Both of those things are in the Preface, and both belong together.
That is why we, five centuries later, still have confessions and still bother to read them. Not because old documents are sacred, and not because Lutherans are unusually fond of fine print. We have them because the Gospel is worth getting right, worth saying clearly, and worth handing on.
The Road Ahead
Over the coming weeks you will discover that the Lutheran Confessions are not a heap of disconnected doctrines. They tell a single, unified story — the story of the Gospel itself. God made us. Sin ruined us. Christ redeemed us. The Spirit calls us. God delivers His gifts through Word and Sacrament. Sinners are justified by grace through faith. The freed Christian is loosed to love and serve. The Church gathers around these gifts. And the Gospel is handed on to the next generation. One topic at a time, that is the road we will travel together — and along the way it will answer the plain questions every congregation eventually asks: why we worship as we do, what really happens in Baptism, what we receive at the Lord’s Table.
And through all of it, one theme will return again and again until you cannot miss it: for me. Christ’s gifts are not merely true in general; they are given personally, to actual sinners. The Father made me. The Son redeemed me. The Spirit called me. Baptism named me. Absolution forgives me. The Supper feeds me. Christ justifies me. God chose me in Christ. That little phrase — for me — is the beating heart of the Lutheran confession, and we will hear it beat in every lesson to come. The goal of these weeks is not merely to learn some history, but to hear again the Gospel these documents were written to guard — and to find it spoken, personally, to you.
Remember
- Christians confess what they believe — faith that truly believes also speaks.
- There are Lutheran Confessions because biblical truth came under dispute, and truth matters.
- Scripture alone is the judge of all teaching.
- The Confessions stand under Scripture, never over it.
- We hold the Confessions because they explain Scripture rightly — and that is what makes a church a confessional church.
For Discussion
- When you hear the word confession, what comes to mind first? How is “confessing the faith” both different from and related to “confessing our sins”?
- Romans 10 ties believing in the heart to speaking with the mouth. Where in ordinary life do you actually say out loud what you believe — and where is it hardest to?
- If the Bible alone is the judge, why have confessions at all? Try putting the “well and bucket” picture into your own words.
- All Christians confess Christ. Why might a church still need to put into its own words what it believes about grace, faith, and the Sacraments? What is gained by saying it plainly?
- Luther wrote the Small Catechism so that families could learn the faith at home. Who first handed the faith on to you? To whom are you handing it now?
Closing Prayer
Almighty God, You have not left us to guess at the truth, but have given us Your Word and raised up faithful witnesses to confess it. Grant us grace to believe in our hearts and to speak with our mouths the same Lord Jesus Christ; keep us steadfast in Your Gospel; and let what we confess with our lips be the comfort of our whole lives. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
May the Lord open His Word to you this week and give you joy in confessing His name.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.