Studies · The Book of Concord for Ordinary Lutherans

Week 1 — Why Lutherans Have Confessions (Leader's Guide)

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The Book of Concord for Ordinary Lutherans

This guide is for you, the leader. Hand out the participant lesson (Week 1 — Why Lutherans Have Confessions); keep this one for yourself. It gives you the reading, the aim of the hour, talking points for the teaching, and notes for leading each discussion question.

Reading & preparation. Before the session, read the Preface to the Augsburg Confession in McCain’s Concordia: The Lutheran Confessions — A Reader’s Edition (CPH), along with the opening of the Formula of Concord (“Of the Comprehensive Summary, Rule, and Norm”) and the prefaces to Luther’s two catechisms. You won’t teach all of that, but reading it lets you answer with confidence. The center of gravity for this hour: a confession is the Church publicly saying what Scripture says — under Scripture, never over it.

Aim of the session. By the end, you want people to be able to say, in their own words, (1) what a “confession” is, (2) why confessing belongs to faith and isn’t optional, (3) that the Confessions serve Scripture rather than compete with it, and (4) why there are Lutheran confessions in particular — and that we hold them because we are convinced they explain Scripture rightly. If they leave holding the “well and bucket” picture, you have succeeded.

Leading the teaching (about 15–20 minutes). Open with the scene at Augsburg in 1530 and let the risk land — these were men with much to lose, and they confessed anyway. Define confession plainly: a “saying-together,” agreement spoken in the open. Then make the Scripture/Confession relationship explicit in kitchen-table words: Scripture is the rule that measures everything; the Confessions are measured by it and found faithful. (If anyone knows the Latin, that is norma normans — the norming norm — and norma normata — the normed norm — but you need not use the terms.)

Two threads to plant now, because they run through the whole series. First, why Lutheran confessions: all Christians confess Christ, but these documents arose where specific teachings — justification, grace and faith, the Sacraments — had come into dispute; the confessors were preserving the old faith, not inventing a new one. Second, why we hold them: not because they are old or because Luther wrote them, but because we are convinced they explain Scripture correctly — that is the difference between admiring a document and confessing it (worth saying aloud in class; it captures the purpose of the whole study), and it is the seed of “confessional subscription,” which we’ll meet more fully later. Watch, too, for the recurring refrain “We believe, teach, and confess” — point it out as the heartbeat they’ll hear again and again. Land on the Gospel: all this careful confessing exists for one reason, to keep the Gospel clear and deliverable. Leave at least half the hour for discussion.

Walking through the discussion questions. For each, here is what it is after, what you are likely to hear, a follow-up, and where to land.

  1. “When you hear confession…” — After: most people think first of confessing sins. Draw out: both senses are the same act — saying the same thing God says, agreeing with Him about our sin and agreeing with Him about His truth. Land: confession = agreement spoken aloud.

  2. “Romans 10 — where do you say aloud what you believe?” — After: faith that speaks. Expect: candor about how hard this is at work, with family, with a skeptical friend. Follow-up: “What makes it hard — fear of the wrong words, or fear of the response?” Land: we confess not because we are eloquent but because Christ has promised to acknowledge those who acknowledge Him (Matthew 10:32). Comfort, not pressure.

  3. “If the Bible alone is the judge, why have confessions?” — This is the key teaching question; give it the most time. Expect: “shouldn’t the Bible be enough?” Affirm the instinct — Scripture is enough and is the only judge — then bring the bucket: a confession adds no water, it just draws it cleanly. Watch for the misunderstanding that the Confessions are a second authority alongside Scripture; correct it gently. The Confessions are binding only because, and only insofar as, they are true to Scripture.

  4. “All Christians confess Christ — why might a church still spell out its own beliefs?” — After: the “why Lutheran” thread. Expect a few who feel “labels divide us” or “shouldn’t we just follow the Bible?” Affirm the longing for unity, then distinguish: clarity is not the enemy of unity; vagueness is. A confession says plainly what we have received, so that the Gospel can be guarded and handed on rather than quietly lost. Land: we put it into words because the Gospel is worth getting right — which is exactly what the rest of the series will do, topic by topic.

  5. “Who handed the faith to you? To whom now?” — A heart question to close on. Expect stories — a grandmother, a pastor, a spouse. Let it breathe; don’t rush it. Land: the Confessions exist precisely so the faith can be handed on intact — which is exactly why Luther wrote the Small Catechism for households. This sets up Week 2.

A misunderstanding to watch for. Someone may worry that “having confessions” means Lutherans add to the Bible the way traditions can be piled on top of Scripture. Name the worry kindly and answer it with the well/bucket picture and the Formula’s own insistence that Scripture alone is the rule and norm.

Where traditions differ — set the tone now. This series will touch points where we differ from Rome and from the Reformed. Establish the spirit in week one: we teach our own confession clearly and charitably; the goal is to understand what we believe and why, never to disparage our neighbors.

Closing. Pray the closing prayer from the participant lesson, or your own. Then point ahead: next week we open the Small Catechism with the Ten Commandments — the faith handed down at the kitchen table.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
The Lutheran ConfessionsAnxiety, Fear, and Doubt
Scripture
Romans 10Matthew 10:32
Confessions
SC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.