Pastoral Care · Interim Ministry

Session 10 — Receiving the New Pastor

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“Remember your leaders, those who spoke to you the word of God. Consider the outcome of their way of life, and imitate their faith. Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever.” — Hebrews 13:7–8

“Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls, as those who will have to give an account. Let them do this with joy and not with groaning, for that would be of no advantage to you.” — Hebrews 13:17

Opening Prayer

O God, the giver of every good and perfect gift, you have brought us through this season of vacancy. Where we have failed, you have forgiven; where we have been weary, you have sustained; where we have been confused, you have led. As we prepare to receive the pastor you are sending, make us a glad and ready people. Soften our hearts. Open our hands. Quiet our preferences. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, the Shepherd and Overseer of our souls. Amen.

Scripture Readings

Read aloud, taking turns:

  • Hebrews 13:7–9, 17–21 — Remember your leaders. Obey them. Pray for them.
  • 1 Thessalonians 5:12–13 — “Respect those who labor among you and are over you in the Lord… esteem them very highly in love because of their work.”
  • 1 Timothy 5:17–22 — “Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor.”
  • Acts 20:17–38 — Paul to the Ephesian elders: the pattern of a faithful pastoral handoff.

Teaching: How a Congregation Receives Its Pastor

You are nearing — or have reached — the end of the vacancy. The Lord has, or will soon, send the man he has prepared. The Council has done its part. The district has done its part. The candidate has prayed and accepted.

Now comes the part that congregations consistently underestimate: how the congregation receives the new pastor.

A first pastoral year is often described as a “honeymoon.” This is a misleading metaphor. A first pastoral year is more accurately described as a fitting — a slow, sometimes uncomfortable settling of a man into an office and a congregation into a man’s preaching, teaching, leading, and pastoring. There will be missteps. There will be misreadings. There will be moments when the new pastor does something the previous one did differently and a member’s first reaction is irritation. There will be moments when the congregation does something he expected differently and his first reaction is bewilderment.

All of this is normal. The question is whether you have prepared yourselves to receive the man God sends, or whether you will sabotage the call you spent ten sessions discerning.

The Three Common Failures of the First Year

1. The “but the last pastor…” disease.

Every faithful pastor approaches the work differently. The next man will not preach the same way as the previous one. He will not run a Bible study the same way. He will not visit the same hospitals on the same schedule. He will not handle Christmas Eve the same way. He will not handle conflict the same way.

If a member’s reaction to every variation is “but Pastor So-and-so used to…,” the new pastor will be slowly poisoned. Within a year he will be exhausted from being measured against a ghost.

The discipline: when you notice yourself comparing, stop. Confess the comparison. Receive what this pastor is preaching, doing, leading. He is the one God sent.

2. The unspoken complaint.

A congregation rarely tells its new pastor what it actually needs from him. Instead, the congregation expects him to intuit — and when he fails to intuit (because he is a man, not a mind reader), the congregation complains, in the parking lot, by phone, in private conversation among members.

The new pastor finds out about all of this six months later, in distorted form, often delivered by a member who frames it as “people are saying…” This is gossip dressed up as concern. It is exhausting. It is corrosive. It is sin.

The discipline: speak to the pastor, not about him. If something the pastor does is concerning, ask him directly. He may have a good reason. He may not have realized. He may welcome the correction. The principle of Matthew 18 applies in pastoral relationships as well as among lay members.

3. The slow disinvestment.

Some members, having survived the vacancy, treat the arrival of the new pastor as permission to coast. The lay vocations that were exercised faithfully during the vacancy fade. The prayer practices erode. The attention to the neighbor and the visitation of the sick and the catechizing at home — all of this slowly returns to “that’s the pastor’s job.”

But these were never the pastor’s job alone. The pastor preaches and administers the Sacraments; the congregation lives the Christian life. The arrival of the new pastor is not the end of the priesthood of all believers — it is the resumption of the partnership between the Office and the priesthood.

The discipline: keep doing what you began doing in the vacancy. The visits to the shut-in. The family devotions. The catechizing of grandchildren. The hospitality. The neighbor walks. The prayer. These do not stop because there is a pastor in the office.

A Commitment from the Council to the New Pastor

Before the new pastor’s installation, the Council should make a set of written commitments to him. These should be discussed in this session, drafted between sessions, and presented to him in his first week — and then kept. Suggested commitments:

  1. We will pray for you by name, daily. The Council president will hold the Council to this.

  2. We will speak to you, not about you. If we have concerns, we will bring them directly to you. We will not gossip. We will not triangulate through members or staff.

  3. We will receive your preaching as the Word of God spoken through your office. We will not preach back to you in the parking lot. We will not grade your sermons. If we have questions, we will ask them in private and as catechumens, not as critics.

  4. We will respect the Office. We will honor your call as a call of Christ through this congregation. We will not treat you as a hire.

  5. We will protect your family. We will not demand of your wife the work of an unpaid associate. We will not measure your children against the Council’s expectations. We will give your family the privacy and the welcome that a pastor’s family is entitled to.

  6. We will not impose the previous pastor on you. We will not say “but Pastor So-and-so…” We will not measure you against a man you did not replace by your choosing.

  7. We will allow you to lead. The Council will do its work; we will not do yours. We will not micromanage your sermons, your liturgy, your visitation schedule, your study time.

  8. We will keep doing the work we began in this vacancy. Lay vocation, prayer, catechesis, mission to the neighbor — these did not begin when you arrived and will not end on our part now that you are here.

  9. We will support you financially in accordance with district guidelines and our covenant with the district. Compensation will be reviewed honestly each year. We will not weaponize budget conversations.

  10. We will love you. Not romantically; not unconditionally; not naïvely. We will love you with the love of brothers in Christ, ready to bear with you, forgive you, encourage you, and remain at your side.

The Installation

The installation of a new pastor is a churchly act — usually presided over by the district president or his representative, often with neighboring pastors present. It is the formal beginning of the call.

A few practices for the installation:

  • Invite the wider congregation. Make this a moment for everyone to be present. Print the rite. Explain what is happening.
  • Receive him publicly. The Council president, on behalf of the congregation, should make a brief public commitment to the new pastor in the service or at the reception afterward.
  • Honor those who served in the vacancy. Thank the vacancy pastor or interim. Thank the lay leaders. Thank the Council. Do this in front of everyone. Then close that chapter.
  • Pray for the pastor publicly. Not generically. By name. With his family by name. With the work of the Office named.

The Six-Month and Twelve-Month Check-ins

This course commits the Council to two follow-up meetings: at six months and at twelve months after the new pastor’s installation. The agenda for each:

Six-month check-in (Council, with the new pastor present for part of it):

  • How is the new pastor settling in? What questions does he have about the congregation that we can answer?
  • How is the congregation receiving the new pastor? What conversations need to be had?
  • Where are the commitments above being kept, and where have they slipped?
  • Are there issues that have emerged that need to be addressed directly?
  • Prayer.

Twelve-month check-in (Council, with the new pastor present for the full meeting):

  • A review of the first year, honestly. What has gone well? What has been hard?
  • A review of the congregational profile against the reality of the first year. What did the profile get right? What did it miss?
  • A discussion of the next year — not as a strategic plan but as a conversation about faithfulness.
  • Thanksgiving. Prayer.
  • A formal closing of the work of this course.

Discussion Questions (for the session)

  1. As the vacancy ends, what is your greatest temptation in receiving the new pastor? Comparison? Coasting? Critique? Idealization?
  2. Which of the ten commitments above feels easiest to make and keep? Which feels hardest?
  3. What patterns from previous pastorates in this congregation will the new pastor inherit as expectations unless the Council names and breaks them?
  4. What does it mean to love a pastor in a properly Lutheran way — neither romanticizing him as a hero nor reducing him to an employee?
  5. As you look back over the ten sessions of this course, what has the Lord done in this Council that you did not expect?

Homework for Session 10

Part A: Personal Reception (Individual)

Answer in writing:

  1. What expectations am I carrying into the new pastorate that the new pastor cannot possibly meet — and that I should lay down before he arrives?

  2. Where in the previous pastorate did I, personally, contribute to patterns that I do not want to repeat? Be specific. (For example: complained in the parking lot rather than speaking to the pastor; expected the pastor to read my mind; treated the pastor as an employee rather than as a called and ordained servant.)

  3. What lay vocation, taken up during the vacancy, do I commit to continuing under the new pastorate? Be specific. (For example: continuing visits to a particular shut-in; continuing family devotions; continuing the weekly Bible study; continuing the prayer discipline for the congregation.)

  4. What is one specific way I will honor the new pastor in his first month — beyond the formal hospitality of the installation? (Examples: a written note of welcome and a specific prayer offered for him; an invitation to my home for a simple meal; a commitment to be at every service of his first month, even when it is inconvenient.)

Part B: A Written Commitment (Individual)

Write, in your own hand, a one-page commitment to the new pastor. Use the ten Council commitments above as a starting point, but make them yours, in your words. Sign and date the page.

Keep this commitment in your Bible or your folder for this course. Read it periodically. Especially read it when you are tempted to break it.

Part C: The Council’s Letter of Welcome (Group exercise)

Before the new pastor arrives — ideally to be delivered to him on his first day — the Council together composes a letter of welcome. The letter:

  • Welcomes him by name and by office, in Christ’s name
  • Briefly tells him the work this Council has done during the vacancy (without burdening him with old conflicts)
  • States the commitments above (as the Council, to him)
  • Concludes with a prayer for his ministry and his family

Each Council member signs.

Place a copy of this letter in his office, on his desk, on his first day. Read it aloud at the first Council meeting he attends.

Part D: Read and Reflect

Read each of the following:

  • Hebrews 13 (the whole chapter)
  • 1 Thessalonians 5:12–22 (responsibilities toward leaders and one another)
  • 1 Timothy 5:17–22 (honor of elders)
  • 2 Timothy 4:1–8 (Paul to Timothy — Paul’s last word about his own ministry)
  • Luther’s Small Catechism, the Table of Duties, “What the Hearers Owe Their Pastors”

Write one paragraph in response: “As I close this course, what one prayer do I most want to make for myself, this congregation, and the pastor God is sending?”

Part E: A Lifetime Practice

Pray for your pastor by name. Every day, for the rest of his ministry among you, and beyond.

When you forget — and you will sometimes forget — start again. Do not let it slide into nothing. He will need every prayer that comes from you, whether you ever see the fruit of those prayers or not.

This is the simplest, deepest, and most lasting work of the priesthood of all believers in relation to the Office of the Ministry: ceaseless prayer for the man God has sent.

Closing Prayer (the Council closes the course together)

Almighty God, you have led us through this season of vacancy. You have brought us to repentance, to thanksgiving, to honest grief, to deeper trust in your Word and Sacraments. You have given us one another in this Council and in this congregation. You have promised to send your servant to preach to us, to baptize and commune our families, to absolve our sins, to bury our dead, and to lead us in the ways of life.

Send him in your time. Prepare him for us. Prepare us for him.

Make this congregation a place where the Gospel is preached purely and the Sacraments are administered rightly, where the priesthood of all believers serves the neighbor, and where the Office of the Holy Ministry is honored as the gift of your Son.

To you, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, be glory and honor and dominion, now and forever. Amen.


A Final Word from the Facilitator

You have done a long, hard, often uncomfortable work. The vacancy is not what most congregations make of it. You have refused the easy paths — the rush to a new call, the avoidance of grief, the denial of sin, the substitution of strategy for repentance. You have placed yourselves under the Word of God. You have allowed yourselves to be loved by the Lord into a new chapter.

The pastor the Lord sends will not know all that you have done in these ten sessions. But he will feel it. He will arrive in a congregation that has prayed for him, that knows who it is, that has confessed its sins, that has thanked God for those who came before. He will preach into ground the Holy Spirit has prepared.

That is the most precious gift you can give him.

The Lord watch between us, as in Genesis, while we are absent one from another. And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.

“Now to him who is able to do far more abundantly than all that we ask or think, according to the power at work within us, to him be glory in the church and in Christ Jesus throughout all generations, forever and ever. Amen.” — Ephesians 3:20–21

Topics
Church and Ministry
Scripture
Hebrews 13:7–8Hebrews 13:17Hebrews 13:7–91 Thessalonians 5:12–131 Timothy 5:17–22Acts 20:17–38Matthew 181 Thessalonians 5:12–222 Timothy 4:1–8Ephesians 3:20–21
Confessions
SC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.