Pastoral Care · Interim Ministry
Session 9 — The Call Process and Prayerful Discernment
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“And they prayed and said, ‘You, Lord, who know the hearts of all, show which one of these two you have chosen.’” — Acts 1:24
Opening Prayer
Lord God, you know the heart of every man. You see the pastor you are preparing for this congregation, whom we do not yet see. You see this congregation as it truly is, with its strengths and its weaknesses and its hidden things. Bring us into this call process under your Word. Free us from the politics of preference and the anxiety of haste. Make us a praying people. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who is the Shepherd and Overseer of our souls. Amen.
Scripture Readings
Read aloud, taking turns:
- Acts 1:15–26 — The selection of Matthias: criteria, prayer, and the lot.
- Acts 6:1–7 — The selection of the seven: discernment, qualifications, congregational involvement, prayer, laying on of hands.
- Acts 13:1–3 — The Spirit calls Paul and Barnabas; the Church confirms and sends.
- 1 Samuel 16:1–13 — “The LORD looks on the heart.” Samuel anoints David.
Teaching: The Call Process Is a Churchly Act, Not a Job Search
The work of this session is to enter the call process consciously, under the Word, in cooperation with your district.
It is critical to understand what the call process is and what it is not.
It is not a job search in the secular sense. It is not the congregation acting as employer scanning résumés to find the best candidate for an open position. It is not the congregation choosing the man it prefers. It is not, primarily, a competitive process where candidates audition.
It is the Church’s discernment, under prayer and the Word, of whom the Lord is sending. The verbs in Scripture are discern, receive, call, send. The Church receives from the Lord the man he has prepared. The congregation, the district, and the candidate all participate in the discernment.
This shift in posture changes everything else.
The Structure of the Call (in General)
Specifics vary by church body — LCMS, ELS, WELS, NALC, LCMC, AALC, and so on each have particular polities — but the general shape is consistent across Lutheran practice:
- The congregation prepares. This is the work of Sessions 1 through 8 of this course, culminating in a written congregational profile.
- The district / synod / call body is engaged. The district president (or equivalent) is informed, supplied with the congregational profile, and brings forward candidates.
- Candidates are presented. Depending on polity, this may be a single name, a list of names, a pool to interview, or the assignment of a candidate.
- The congregation interviews / examines / votes. The form varies, but the congregation participates in receiving the candidate.
- The call is issued. A formal call letter is sent to the candidate, signed by the congregation’s authorized officers.
- The candidate prays and responds. The candidate prayerfully considers the call. He may accept, decline, or hold it open while he discerns. This is his discernment to make under the Lord, not the congregation’s pressure to apply.
- The candidate is installed. Upon acceptance, the candidate is installed in his Office by appropriate authorities of the church body, often with neighboring pastors and district leaders.
Each step belongs to specific actors. The Council does not negotiate the candidate’s salary as if it were a market transaction; the Council prepares a faithful and honorable compensation in accordance with district guidelines. The candidate does not “play the field” between multiple congregations as if shopping for the best fit; he discerns one call at a time. The district does not impose a candidate; the district serves the discernment of the congregation under the Word.
The Congregational Profile
In most polities, the congregation produces a congregational profile — a written document that describes who you are and what you need. The profile is the primary input to the candidates and to the district’s recommendations.
A faithful profile, drawing on the work of Sessions 1 through 8, should include:
-
The congregation’s history (drawn from Session 2). Honest, neither idealized nor self-condemning. Founding, key seasons, growth and decline, current state.
-
The most recent pastorate (drawn from Session 3). Briefly. The fact of the previous pastor’s departure, its cause if appropriate to name, and the work the congregation has done to receive and process the ending.
-
The congregation’s identity in Christ (drawn from Session 4). Word and Sacrament. Baptismal identity. The marks of the Church as they are present here.
-
The congregation’s vocational life (drawn from Session 5). The lay leadership, the active members, the gifts present in this body, what the Council does, what the various ministries do.
-
The congregation’s confession of its own sin and the healing it has sought (drawn from Session 6). This may sound surprising in a profile — and that surprise tells you something about how few profiles are written this way. A congregation that names honestly what has wounded it, and has confessed and received absolution, is incomparably more attractive to a faithful pastor than a congregation that pretends to be untroubled.
-
The congregation’s understanding of its mission (drawn from Session 7). The neighborhood, the neighbors, the particular calling of this congregation in this place.
-
The congregation’s understanding of what a pastor is, and the call it is prepared to extend (drawn from Session 8). A theological statement, grounded in AC V and XIV.
-
The practical specifics: size, demographics, finances, facilities, schedule, compensation in line with district guidelines, locale.
This is not the format every district will provide. Use the format the district provides. Fill it with the content from this course.
Prayerful Discernment
The most distinctive feature of a Lutheran call process — when done faithfully — is prayer. Not perfunctory prayer at the opening and closing of meetings, but sustained, daily, named prayer over the course of the discernment.
Establish, before the next session, a Council-wide commitment:
-
Each Council member will pray daily for the call process, for the candidates not yet known to them, and for the pastor God is preparing.
-
The Council will gather at least once between regular meetings, in the sanctuary or chapel, specifically to pray for the call. Not to discuss it. To pray.
-
The wider congregation will be invited into prayer. Bulletin notes. A weekly congregational prayer for the call. A printed prayer card for each household.
-
The work of the call will be paused at moments to pray. When you receive a candidate’s name, before you discuss him: pray. After you have discussed him: pray. Before the vote: pray. After the vote: pray.
Prayer is not a religious frosting on an otherwise procedural cake. Prayer is the form of discernment. The Lord knows the heart; we do not. Prayer is the asking that he show us what he sees.
Discussion Questions (for the session)
- What has been your understanding of “the call process” up until now? Has it been more like a job search, more like a discernment, or more like a vote?
- Where is your district / synod’s call process well understood in this Council, and where are the gaps in your understanding? (Plan to fill the gaps.)
- If the congregational profile faithfully reflects the work of Sessions 1–8, what should it say that a typical profile does not say?
- Where, in past calls at this congregation (or congregations you’ve known), did the call process drift away from prayer and into politics? What was the cost?
- How will you, as a Council, protect this call process from haste — from the urge to “just be done with it”?
Homework for Session 9
Part A: A Personal Prayer Discipline (Individual)
Beginning this week, and continuing through the conclusion of the call, commit to a daily prayer for the call process. A suggested form:
Heavenly Father, you know the man you are preparing for this congregation. We do not yet know him. We do not know his name, his face, his story, his struggles, his gifts, his fears. But you know him. Prepare him for us. Prepare us for him. Free us from the politics of preference. Free him from the anxieties of moving. Bring us together in your time, by your Spirit, for the sake of your Gospel in this place. In Jesus’ name. Amen.
You may adapt the words. Pray it daily, without fail, until the new pastor is installed.
Part B: The Congregational Profile (Council Group Work)
Before the next session, the Council — using whatever subcommittee structure makes sense, and in coordination with the district’s format — drafts a complete congregational profile, drawing on the homework and notes from Sessions 1 through 8.
Each section of the profile should be drafted by a small group (two to three Council members) and brought together for review at the next session.
Suggested division of labor:
- History and heritage (drawing on Session 2 homework) — 2 members
- The previous pastorate and the work of the vacancy (drawing on Session 3 and 6 homework) — 2 members (sensitive; choose wisely)
- Identity, marks of the Church, and ministry life (drawing on Sessions 4 and 5) — 2 members
- Mission in this place (drawing on Session 7, including the neighborhood walks and conversations) — 2 members
- Understanding of the Office and proposed call (drawing on Session 8, including the call letter draft) — 2 members
- Practical specifics (statistics, finances, compensation) — typically the treasurer and one other
Bring the drafts to the next session in writing. Do not bring outlines. Bring drafts.
Part C: A Quiet Conversation with the District (Council President)
The Council president, between sessions, should have a quiet, candid conversation with the district president (or appropriate official) covering:
- The work the Council has been doing through this course
- The current state of the congregational profile
- The expected timeline for the next steps of the call process
- Any specific guidance the district can offer at this stage
This is not a substitute for the formal interactions; it is a conversation to ensure the Council’s work is properly integrated with the district’s.
Part D: Read and Reflect
Read each of the following:
- Acts 1:15–26 (the call of Matthias)
- Acts 6:1–7 (the call of the seven)
- Acts 13:1–3 (the Spirit calls; the church sends)
- 1 Samuel 16 (the Lord looks on the heart)
- Luther’s Small Catechism, the Second Petition (“Thy Kingdom come”)
Write one paragraph in response: “In Acts 6, the criteria for the seven were ‘men of good repute, full of the Spirit and of wisdom.’ If we held our deliberations about the next pastor to that simple standard — repute, Spirit, wisdom — what would we stop talking about, and what would we start talking about?”
Part E: A Daily Practice
In addition to the daily call prayer, each evening this week, read aloud — alone or with family — the daily readings appointed in your church body’s lectionary, or a portion of the Psalms. Let the Word, not your calculations, shape your discernment.
Closing Prayer
O Lord, you knew Jeremiah before you formed him in the womb. You called Samuel by name in the night. You sent your apostles to the ends of the earth. You have not stopped sending faithful men into the Office of the Holy Ministry. We trust you to send the right man to this congregation. We trust you to prepare him. We trust you to prepare us. Hasten the day, but do not let us hasten it apart from your Spirit. In the name of Jesus Christ, our great Shepherd. Amen.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.