Papers · Lutheranism and …

Lutheranism and Roman Catholicism

What We Confess Together, Where We Still Part, and What We Might Learn from One Another

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, eager to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace.” — Ephesians 4:2–3


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921) and cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations (AC, Augsburg Confession; Ap, Apology; SA, Smalcald Articles; Tr, Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope; SC, Small Catechism; FC Ep and FC SD, Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration), with paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions. Words in square brackets inside a Confession are the Triglotta’s own. Roman Catholic teaching is quoted from the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) and the documents of the Second Vatican Council as published on the Vatican’s website, from the Council of Trent in the translation of J. Waterworth (1848), and from the First Vatican Council in the translation edited by Norman P. Tanner.


Augsburg, Reformation Day 1999

On the morning of October 31, 1999, more than two thousand people walked in procession through the center of Augsburg. They had begun the day with services at the city’s Roman Catholic cathedral and they were walking to St. Anna’s, a Lutheran church, which was already full of bishops, church leaders and journalists from every continent, while a crowd outside watched on a large screen in a tent on the city square.1 It was Reformation Day, 482 years to the day after Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses. In front of that congregation Cardinal Edward Cassidy, president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, and Bishop Christian Krause, president of the Lutheran World Federation, signed the statement by which the Roman Catholic Church and the Federation confirmed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. Bishop Krause said, “For the first time in centuries, here in Augsburg, we are again setting foot on common ground.” From Rome, Pope John Paul II called the agreement a “milestone on the not always easy road towards the restoration of full unity between Christians.”2 The city had been chosen on purpose. In 1530 the evangelical princes had read their Confession before the Emperor in Augsburg, and now the two sides said that the doctrine of justification, the subject of its fourth article, no longer divided them as it once had.

What happened in Augsburg that day, and what did not happen? Where do Lutherans and Roman Catholics actually stand with one another now? In my paper Catholic and Reformed I told the story of the sixteenth-century separation and how the Council of Trent made the breach a matter of dogma. I stand by that account and I will not tell it again here. This essay is about the present. It asks what the Roman Catholic Church teaches today, in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, in the Second Vatican Council, and in the Council of Trent (which Rome still holds to be binding), and how a Lutheran who subscribes the Book of Concord should answer it.

Two commitments govern everything that follows. The first is Saint Paul’s: “speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ” (Ephesians 4:15). The second is the Eighth Commandment as Luther explains it in the Small Catechism. “We should fear and love God that we may not deceitfully belie, betray, slander, or defame our neighbor, but defend him, [think and] speak well of him, and put the best construction on everything.”3 A well-taught Roman Catholic should be able to read what I say about his church’s teaching and answer, “Yes, that is what we believe, and that is why we believe it.” Where I disagree, I want to disagree with Rome as it states its own teaching, in its own official words, and never with a caricature or with the worst thing someone once did in its name. Where popular practice differs from official teaching, I will try to say which is which.

In this paper I want to take up five questions. 1) Who are Roman Catholics today, and how have Lutherans and Rome met since the Reformation? 2) What do we confess together? 3) Where do we still part, and why does each side believe what it believes? 4) What might we learn from one another? 5) How, then, should we live with one another in the meantime?


I. Who Roman Catholics Are

It is important to understand that Roman Catholics do not think of their church as one denomination among many. The Second Vatican Council taught that the one Church of Christ confessed in the Creed “subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the Bishops in communion with him, although many elements of sanctification and of truth are found outside of its visible structure.”4 In other words, Rome does not say that other Christians are outside the Church of Christ altogether, but that the Church of Christ is found in its fullness in the communion of bishops gathered around the bishop of Rome. We Lutherans make a similar claim when we locate the Church by the pure Gospel and the right use of the Sacraments. The two claims cannot both be right in the way each intends.

It is the largest Christian body in the world, with about 1.4 billion baptized members.5 Besides the Latin Church, more than twenty Eastern Catholic churches with their own liturgies are in full communion with the pope, who at present is Pope Leo XIV, elected in 2025. A Lutheran who wants to know what Rome teaches should look past the opinions of a particular priest or theologian to the councils, the papal definitions, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which Pope John Paul II published in 1992 as a summary of Catholic faith for the whole world. The Council of Trent (1545–1563) answered the Reformation, the First Vatican Council (1869–1870) defined the primacy and infallibility of the pope, and the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) renewed the liturgy and opened the Church to the ecumenical movement. It is a common mistake to think that the Second Vatican Council quietly set Trent aside. The Catechism quotes Trent again and again as the Church’s teaching, and the faculties of the Missouri Synod’s seminaries observed in 1999 that Vatican II retracted none of it.6 What the Council did give the Church for dialogue was a principle: “in Catholic doctrine there exists a ‘hierarchy’ of truths, since they vary in their relation to the fundamental Christian faith.”7 Although Catholic life is no more uniform than Lutheran life, I describe the official teaching, because that is what binds a Catholic’s conscience.

For four hundred years after Trent the two churches mostly met in polemic. That changed with the Second Vatican Council, whose Decree on Ecumenism (1964) spoke of Protestants as brothers in a sentence a Lutheran can hardly read without being moved: “all who have been justified by faith in Baptism are members of Christ’s body, and have a right to be called Christian, and so are correctly accepted as brothers by the children of the Catholic Church.” The decree also admitted that in the divisions of the past “often enough, men of both sides were to blame.”8 An international dialogue began in 1967, the Joint Declaration grew out of its work, and in 2016 Pope Francis joined the leaders of the Lutheran World Federation for a common service of prayer in Lund Cathedral in Sweden.9 The Declaration was made by the Federation, which most Lutheran churches in the world belong to, and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America adopted it in 1997, while the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods, which do not belong to the Federation, were not parties to it.10 Therefore when someone says that “the Lutherans and the Catholics have agreed on justification,” we should ask which Lutherans and what exactly they agreed to.


II. What We Confess Together

It would be a poor beginning to a conversation between Christians if we skipped over the faith we hold in common to get to the quarrel. In the Smalcald Articles of 1537, which are otherwise some of the sharpest pages in our Confessions, he first set down the articles on the Trinity and on the incarnation, suffering, death, resurrection and return of Christ, and then he wrote, “Concerning these articles there is no contention or dispute, since we on both sides confess them.”11 That sentence is still true.

We confess the three ecumenical creeds, which stand at the front of the Book of Concord. We confess one God in three persons, and one Christ, true God and true man, in one person. We even confess together that Mary is the Mother of God. The Formula of Concord says that she “conceived and bore not a mere man and no more, but the true Son of God; therefore she also is rightly called and truly is the mother of God,” and the Catechism that “the Church confesses that Mary is truly ‘Mother of God’ (Theotokos).”12 We both receive the Holy Scriptures as the inspired Word of God. Our disagreement concerns the relation of Scripture to Tradition and to the Church’s teaching office, not whether Scripture is God’s Word.

We confess that Baptism saves. God “saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5), and at Pentecost Peter joined the forgiveness of sins and the gift of the Holy Spirit to Baptism and said, “the promise is for you and for your children” (Acts 2:39). The Catechism teaches that “Through Baptism we are freed from sin and reborn as sons of God,” and Melanchthon writes in the Apology that “the baptism of children is not in vain, but is necessary and effectual to salvation.”13 Therefore we both baptize infants, we recognize each other’s Baptism, and a Roman Catholic who becomes a Lutheran (or a Lutheran who becomes a Roman Catholic) is not baptized again.

We confess that the body and blood of Christ are truly present in the Sacrament of the Altar. Our Lord said, “Take, eat; this is my body” (Matthew 26:26). The Augsburg Confession teaches “that the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed to those who eat the Supper of the Lord,” and the Catechism that “the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ and, therefore, the whole Christ is truly, really, and substantially contained.”14 On this article Lutherans and Roman Catholics stand together against every teaching that makes the Supper a mere sign. How the bread and wine are related to that presence is another matter, which we will come to.

We share much of the Church’s ordinary life as well. The Augsburg Confession told the Emperor that “the Mass is retained among us, and celebrated with the highest reverence.”15 Lutherans kept the church year, the lectionary, the ancient canticles, vestments, private confession and absolution, and the sign of the cross, and a Roman Catholic who visits a Lutheran Divine Service that follows the historic liturgy will recognize nearly every part of it. In addition, we stand together on the sanctity of human life and of marriage. The Catechism teaches that “Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception,” and confessional Lutherans teach the same from the Fifth Commandment.16 Luther himself, writing against the Anabaptists in 1528, refused to throw away everything that came from the pope. He answered that there is much under the papacy that is Christian and good and that we received the Scriptures, Baptism, the Sacrament, the keys and the Creed through that very Church.17 I believe that is the right place for a Lutheran to begin.


III. Where We Still Part

Although the agreement is real, the disagreement is real too and it is not about trifles. I have chosen six points where the difference touches the Gospel and the comfort of consciences, and on each I will try to say what Lutherans teach and why, what Rome teaches and why, and where the difference really lies.

1. How a sinner is made right with God

Lutherans teach that a sinner is justified before God freely, for Christ’s sake, through faith. Saint Paul writes that all “have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, and are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus” (Romans 3:23–24). “For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Romans 3:28). “And to the one who does not work but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as righteousness” (Romans 4:5). The Apology draws the conclusion: “faith alone justifies, because those reconciled are accounted righteous and children of God, not on account of their own purity, but through mercy for Christ’s sake, provided only they by faith apprehend this mercy.”18 Paul’s verb, dikaioō (“to justify”), is a courtroom word, and Thayer’s lexicon gives its New Testament sense as “to declare, pronounce, one to be just, righteous.”19 The Formula of Concord therefore teaches that “the word justify here means to declare righteous and free from sins, and to absolve one from eternal punishment for the sake of Christ’s righteousness, which is imputed by God to faith.”20 The Apology can also say that by faith we are justified, that is, “of unrighteous men made righteous, or regenerated,” and the Formula explains that it means by this the forgiveness of sins.21 In other words, God’s verdict is not a fiction. It makes the sinner before God what it declares him to be and the renewal of his life follows from it without being its ground.

Why does this matter so much to us? If the righteousness that avails before God is Christ’s, then it is complete and certain and the troubled conscience can rest on it. Luther writes that “this faith alone justifies us,” and then, “Of this article nothing can be yielded or surrendered… Therefore, we must be sure concerning this doctrine, and not doubt.”22 Saint John wrote his letter “to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life” (1 John 5:13). We do not deny that God renews those He justifies; the Augsburg Confession teaches that faith is bound to bring forth good fruits and that through faith the Holy Spirit renews the heart.23 However, this new life, which in this world is always imperfect, is not what we stand on before God. The Christian remains at once righteous in Christ and a sinner in himself until the day he dies.24

The Roman Catholic Church also teaches that justification is by grace through faith and it says so with real force. Trent taught that “we are therefore said to be justified by faith, because faith is the beginning of human salvation, the foundation, and the root of all Justification,” and that we are “said to be justified freely, because that none of those things which precede justification-whether faith or works-merit the grace itself of justification.”25 It named Christ the “meritorious cause” of our justification, “who, when we were enemies, for the exceeding charity wherewith he loved us, merited Justification for us by His most holy Passion on the wood of the cross, and made satisfaction for us unto God the Father.”26 A Lutheran who says that Rome teaches salvation by unaided human effort has broken the Eighth Commandment. The difference lies elsewhere. Trent taught that the righteousness by which God justifies us is a righteousness He puts into us, not Christ’s righteousness counted to us. In its own words, justification is “not remission of sins merely, but also the sanctification and renewal of the inward man,” and its “alone formal cause” (the thing that makes us righteous) is “the justice of God, not that whereby He Himself is just, but that whereby He maketh us just.”27 The Catechism says that justification “conforms us to the righteousness of God, who makes us inwardly just by the power of his mercy.”28 Faith itself justifies, for Rome, when love is joined to it; Trent wrote that “faith, unless hope and charity be added thereto, neither unites man perfectly with Christ, nor makes him a living member of His body.”29 After that first grace the justified can merit. The Catechism teaches that, “Moved by the Holy Spirit and by charity, we can then merit for ourselves and for others the graces needed for our sanctification, for the increase of grace and charity, and for the attainment of eternal life,” and it adds at once that “Man’s merit, moreover, itself is due to God.” Trent had put it more beautifully, that God’s “bounty towards all men is so great, that He will have the things which are His own gifts be their merits.”30

Rome’s reasons come from Scripture. James writes, “You see that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone” (James 2:24), and Trent quoted that verse.31 Paul speaks of “faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6) and writes that if he has “all faith, so as to remove mountains, but have not love, I am nothing” (1 Corinthians 13:2). Above all, a Catholic will say that God’s word is never empty. When God declares a man righteous the man is made righteous, because “if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation” (2 Corinthians 5:17). To a Catholic the Lutheran teaching can sound like a legal fiction and that is why Trent condemned anyone who says that men are justified “by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ … to the exclusion of the grace and the charity which is poured forth in their hearts by the Holy Ghost, and is inherent in them.”32 It is also why Rome rejects the Lutheran “at the same time righteous and sinner.” Catholics believe that Baptism takes away everything that is truly sin. Of the desire that remains in the baptized, which Tradition calls concupiscence, Trent declared that “the Catholic Church has never understood it to be called sin, as being truly and properly sin in those born again, but because it is of sin, and inclines to sin.”33 The Joint Declaration gives the reason in a form anyone can follow: “human sins always involve a personal element,” and this element “is lacking in this inclination,” although Catholics grant that it “is objectively in contradiction to God and remains one’s enemy in lifelong struggle.”34 Lutherans confess that this inclination “is truly sin,” and here the two churches part.35

Where, then, does the difference lie after Augsburg? The Joint Declaration gave both churches a sentence they could say together. “By grace alone, in faith in Christ’s saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while equipping and calling us to good works.”36 On that basis it concluded that “The teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in this Declaration does not fall under the condemnations from the Council of Trent,” and that the Lutheran condemnations do not apply to the Catholic teaching presented there. Even so, it repealed no canon of Trent: “Nothing is thereby taken away from the seriousness of the condemnations,” which remain “salutary warnings.”37 Rome’s official Response of 1998 acknowledged “a high degree of agreement” but said that “we cannot yet speak of a consensus such as would eliminate every difference,” and it called the Lutheran “at the same time righteous and sinner” “not acceptable,” for the reason we have just seen.38 The Annex signed at Augsburg found a way to say the formula together, “despite their different approaches,” but it did not reconcile the two accounts of concupiscence.39 The seminary faculties of the Missouri Synod judged that the central question remained, whether justification is God’s declaration on a sinner for Christ’s sake or an inner process by which he is made more and more righteous, and they called its “non-settlement” the “chief defect” of the Declaration.40 I agree with that judgment. The disagreement is narrower than Lutherans who accuse Rome of works-righteousness suppose. However, it is exactly where the Apology placed it, for the Apology already knew that its opponents ascribed to Christ’s merit the “first grace” infused into us, and it judged that this did not touch the question.41 Both churches say that Christ merited our righteousness. Lutherans say that His own righteousness, reckoned to faith, is the righteousness we stand on before God; Rome says that it is the righteousness He merited and now works within us.

That difference matters most at a deathbed. When a dying Catholic asks whether he may be sure, his Church sends a priest who absolves him, anoints him and gives him the body of Christ as food for the journey, and we should be glad of every one of those gifts. Rome tells him to hope, and by hope it means “placing our trust in Christ’s promises.”42 However, Rome will not let him say that he knows with the certainty of faith that he himself is in God’s grace, because his own disposition is part of the question and perseverance to the end is not promised to any one person.43 A Lutheran pastor at the same bedside tells him that the promise is spoken to him, that it rests on Christ and not on him, and that faith may be as certain as the promise it holds. Those are two different answers. I should add that Lutherans fail here in practice as often as anyone. Many have never heard a pastor absolve them by name, have forgotten their Baptism, and die looking at their own lives. As for James, Melanchthon answered him at length in the Apology and concluded that James speaks of the works that follow faith and that to be justified there means “to be pronounced righteous in a forensic sense,” because “men having faith and good works are certainly pronounced righteous.”44

2. Scripture, Tradition, and the teaching office

The second difference concerns the authority by which the first one is decided. The Formula of Concord confesses that “the sole rule and standard according to which all dogmas … should be estimated and judged are the prophetic and apostolic Scriptures of the Old and of the New Testament alone.”45 Scripture is “breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16–17). This does not make Lutherans enemies of tradition. The Formula receives the writings of ancient and modern teachers “as witnesses” of how the doctrine was preserved after the apostles, and our Confessions quote the fathers on nearly every page.46 In other words, tradition is a ruled rule, precious to us and yet always under Scripture.

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that God’s Word comes to us in two modes of transmission that belong together. Dei Verbum teaches that “it is not from Sacred Scripture alone that the Church draws her certainty about everything which has been revealed.” It adds that “the task of authentically interpreting the word of God, whether written or handed on, has been entrusted exclusively to the living teaching office of the Church.”47 Paul wrote, “So then, brothers, stand firm and hold to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or by our letter” (2 Thessalonians 2:15). He called the church “a pillar and buttress of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:15), and Jesus promised the apostles, “When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth” (John 16:13). A Catholic also asks a fair question. Who told us which books belong in the Bible? The Church received and recognized the canon, and therefore, he will say, the Church guided by the Spirit must be able to say what those books mean.

Part of this difference is not as great as it looks. Dei Verbum says that the teaching office “is not above the word of God, but serves it, teaching only what has been handed on.”48 A Lutheran can say that sentence too. The real question is what happens when the teaching office and the words of Scripture seem to part. For Lutherans, Scripture judges the Church. For Rome, the Church interprets Scripture with authority and its certainty about what is revealed does not rest on Scripture alone; Catholic theologians differ on whether Tradition adds content that Scripture does not contain or unfolds what Scripture implies. The two dogmas about Mary defined in 1854 and 1950, which we come to below, show the difference most clearly. When the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith declined in 2025 to promote certain titles of Mary, it recalled Cardinal Ratzinger’s doubt whether the doctrine they express is present “in Scripture and the apostolic tradition.”49 I believe that is the right question. Rome believes it answered it for the two dogmas, arguing from Scripture and the fathers, and Lutherans do not find that answer in Scripture. I have written about the whole matter in Scripture Alone and Its Interpreter.

3. The bishop of Rome

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that Christ made Peter the rock of His Church and gave him the keys, and that this office continues in Peter’s successors, the bishops of Rome. “And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matthew 16:18–19). Catholics read the keys in the light of Isaiah, where God gives the royal steward of David’s house his office: “And I will place on his shoulder the key of the house of David. He shall open, and none shall shut; and he shall shut, and none shall open” (Isaiah 22:22). The steward’s office passed from one holder to the next, and so, they say, does Peter’s. Matthew names Peter “first” among the Twelve (Matthew 10:2), Jesus told Peter alone, “I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned again, strengthen your brothers” (Luke 22:32), and after the resurrection He told him three times, “Feed my sheep” (John 21:17). The Catechism teaches that Christ entrusted the authority to bind and loose “to the Church through the ministry of the apostles and in particular through the ministry of Peter, the only one to whom he specifically entrusted the keys of the kingdom.”50 The fathers are part of Rome’s case as well. Irenaeus wrote about 180 that “it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority.”51 The Second Vatican Council adds that the pope does not rule alone. The bishops together have “supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.”52 Catholics also argue that a worldwide Church needs a visible center of unity, without which Christians divide without end. Looking at the Protestant world, it is hard to say they are wrong about that.

The First Vatican Council went further. In 1870 it defined that when the pope speaks ex cathedra (“from the chair,” that is, as shepherd and teacher of all Christians defining a doctrine of faith or morals for the whole Church), “he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his church to enjoy,” and that “such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.”53 This does not mean that the pope cannot sin or that every papal sentence is infallible, but it applies only to solemn definitions and extends, as the Catechism says, “as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself.”54 Catholics read the phrase “not by the consent of the church” as a rejection of the view that papal definitions need the later ratification of the bishops, and the Second Vatican Council adds that “To these definitions the assent of the Church can never be wanting, on account of the activity of that same Holy Spirit.”55

Lutherans read the texts differently. Although Rome agrees that binding and loosing were given to all the apostles, the question is whether the keys given to Peter make him and his successors head of the rest by divine right. Jesus says to the apostles together, “Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matthew 18:18), and the Treatise answers that in the passages about Peter “Peter is the representative of the entire assembly of apostles,” and that “the building of the Church is upon this rock of confession; this faith is the foundation of the Church.”56 The Catechism itself can say that “On the rock of this faith confessed by St. Peter, Christ built his Church,” and it is fair to add that the fathers read the text in more than one way and that some honored Peter’s person as well.57 The Smalcald Articles therefore teach that the pope is not “according to divine law or according to the Word of God the head of all Christendom,” but “only the bishop and pastor of the Church at Rome.”58 Luther even considered a head chosen by men and changeable by men, and he judged that it would not help the Church. “Therefore the Church can never be better governed and preserved than if we all live under one head, Christ, and all the bishops equal in office (although they be unequal in gifts), be diligently joined in unity of doctrine, faith, Sacraments, prayer, and works of love.”59 Melanchthon, signing the same articles, added a personal note that he would grant the pope a superiority “by human right” if he would allow the Gospel.60 That note was his own and the article’s judgment stands beside it. Pope John Paul II asked in 1995 for help “to find a way of exercising the primacy which, while in no way renouncing what is essential to its mission, is nonetheless open to a new situation.”61 However, the words “what is essential” are exactly where the disagreement lies.

The Confessions’ sharpest judgment is made for the sake of consciences. Since the papal office claimed that Christians cannot be saved without obedience to it, and condemned the Gospel of justification by faith, the Smalcald Articles call the pope “the very Antichrist, who has exalted himself above, and opposed himself against Christ because he will not permit Christians to be saved without his power,” and the Treatise concludes that “it is necessary to resist him as Antichrist.”62 I subscribe the Smalcald Articles and the Treatise and I confess this judgment with them, as I explained in Catholic and Reformed. It is not a judgment about the faith of Roman Catholic people or of any pope, but about the claims of an office. It is only right to add that Rome today does not say that baptized Christians outside its communion are lost for that reason; it says that “one cannot charge with the sin of the separation those who at present are born into these communities.”63

4. The sacrifice of the Mass and the change of the bread

Although we agree that Christ’s body and blood are present on the altar, we differ over what the Church does with them in the Mass and over what becomes of the bread and wine.

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that the Mass is a true sacrifice, not a second sacrifice but the one sacrifice of the cross made present. The Catechism says that the Eucharist is a sacrifice “because it re-presents (makes present) the sacrifice of the cross, because it is its memorial and because it applies its fruit,” and that “The sacrifice of Christ and the sacrifice of the Eucharist are one single sacrifice.”64 Trent called the Mass propitiatory only because it is that one sacrifice: “The fruits indeed of which oblation, of that bloody one to wit, are received most plentifully through this unbloody one; so far is this (latter) from derogating in any way from that (former oblation).”65 The Church offers, Catholics say, because she is taken up into the offering of her Head. “The Church which is the Body of Christ participates in the offering of her Head… She unites herself to his intercession with the Father for all men.” Therefore “the Eucharist is also offered in reparation for the sins of the living and the dead.”66 Rome points to Malachi’s prophecy that “in every place incense will be offered to my name, and a pure offering” (Malachi 1:11), to the words “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19), which it understands as making the apostles priests to offer.

The Roman Catholic Church also teaches that at the consecration the bread and wine cease to be bread and wine. Trent declared that “a conversion is made of the whole substance of the bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of His blood; which conversion is, by the holy Catholic Church, suitably and properly called Transubstantiation.”67 By “substance” Catholics do not mean the chemistry of the bread, which they say remains the same to every test, but what the thing truly is beneath its appearances. Their reason is our Lord’s word. He said, “This is my body,” and Rome takes Him at His word in a way that leaves nothing of the bread but its appearance.

Lutherans take Him at His word too, which is why we confess the real presence. However, we confess that the bread remains. Luther writes, “As regards transubstantiation, we care nothing about the sophistical subtlety by which they teach that bread and wine leave or lose their own natural substance… For it is in perfect agreement with Holy Scriptures that there is, and remains, bread, as Paul himself calls it.”68 Paul calls it bread even after the blessing: “For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes” (1 Corinthians 11:26). On the sacrifice, Lutherans hold to the Letter to the Hebrews. “For by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14), and “Where there is forgiveness of these, there is no longer any offering for sin” (Hebrews 10:18). The Apology agrees that “there has been only one propitiatory sacrifice in the world, namely, the death of Christ,” and that the sacrifice we offer is one of thanksgiving.69 What it rejects is that the Supper, “when applied on behalf of others, alive or dead,” merits for them “ex opere operato the remission of sins, of guilt or of punishment,” that is, by the mere performance of the act.70 Luther’s article on the Mass makes the same complaint, that it has been held that this work “frees men from sins, both in this life and also in purgatory, while only the Lamb of God shall and must do this.”71

The difference, then, is not where the old caricature put it, since Rome does not teach that Christ is sacrificed again. It is where our Confessions put it. Rome holds that the fruits of the one sacrifice are applied through the Church’s offering, even for those who do not receive the Sacrament, the dead included. Lutherans hold that the Supper is first of all Christ’s gift, “my body, which is given for you” (Luke 22:19), and that its fruits come to us by His promise received in faith. On transubstantiation the difference is real, although Lutherans and Catholics are much closer to each other than either is to those who deny the presence. The Roman Catholic Church does not admit Lutherans to Communion, because, as the Catechism explains, the churches of the Reformation “have not preserved the proper reality of the Eucharistic mystery in its fullness, especially because of the absence of the sacrament of Holy Orders.” Even its exception for grave necessity requires that the other Christian “give evidence of holding the Catholic faith regarding these sacraments.”72 Confessional Lutherans likewise do not commune Roman Catholics at our altars, and both churches understand that to commune together is to confess together.73

5. Purgatory and indulgences

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that “All who die in God’s grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation; but after death they undergo purification, so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven.” It says that this purification, purgatory, “is entirely different from the punishment of the damned.”74 Purgatory is not a second chance for the lost, but the purification of those already saved. Pope Benedict XVI described it in its most searching form: “Some recent theologians are of the opinion that the fire which both burns and saves is Christ himself, the Judge and Saviour. The encounter with him is the decisive act of judgement.”75 Rome’s reasons are these. Nothing unclean will enter the heavenly city (Revelation 21:27) and most Christians die still imperfect. Paul writes that on the last day a man’s work “will be revealed by fire,” and “If anyone’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but only as through fire” (1 Corinthians 3:13, 15). The Church has prayed for the dead from very early times, and Rome counts 2 Maccabees, which tells of a sacrifice offered for the dead, as Scripture.76

Indulgences belong to this teaching. The Catechism explains that “every sin, even venial, entails an unhealthy attachment to creatures, which must be purified either here on earth, or after death,” that these punishments “must not be conceived of as a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without,” and that “a conversion which proceeds from a fervent charity can attain the complete purification of the sinner in such a way that no punishment would remain.”77 An indulgence is “a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven,” granted by the Church from “the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints,” and it “may be applied to the living or the dead.”78 That treasury is first of all “the infinite value, which can never be exhausted, which Christ’s merits have before God.” The saints belong to it only because they lived “by his grace” and “cooperated in saving their brothers in the unity of the Mystical Body.”79 Their text is Paul’s: “in my flesh I am filling up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church” (Colossians 1:24). The sale of indulgences that provoked Luther is long gone, abolished by Trent itself, although indulgences were offered again in the Jubilee Year of 2025.80

Lutherans do not teach purgatory, and the Smalcald Articles reject it, “For it conflicts with the chief article [which teaches] that only Christ, and not the works of men, are to help [set free] souls.”81 Scripture speaks of the believer’s death as going to be with Christ. To the thief Jesus said, “Truly, I say to you, today you will be with me in paradise” (Luke 23:43), and Paul wrote, “My desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better” (Philippians 1:23). John writes that “the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin” (1 John 1:7). Lutherans read 1 Corinthians 3 as the testing of a minister’s work on the last day, and Colossians 1:24 as Paul’s sufferings in his ministry, not a satisfaction applied to others. Even so, the Lutheran Confessions do not forbid every prayer for the dead. Melanchthon writes of the ancient Church, “we know that the ancients speak of prayer for the dead, which we do not prohibit; but we disapprove of the application ex opere operato of the Lord’s Supper on behalf of the dead.”82

Although the language of purification by Christ’s love is far gentler than much medieval preaching, the difference remains. Lutherans also believe that God will finish what He has begun in us and that no one enters glory still clinging to sin. We believe that Christ’s satisfaction covers the punishment of sin as well as its guilt, that death itself ends the old Adam, and that the believer is made perfect in the moment God takes him home. Rome believes that a further purification is needed and that the Church can assist those being purified by her prayers, by the Mass and by indulgences. A Lutheran cannot see that Christ’s satisfaction leaves anything for any member of His body to supply, even by His grace.

6. Mary and the saints

Lutherans honor Mary. We confess her the Mother of God, we sing her song at Vespers, and we call her blessed because she said so: “from now on all generations will call me blessed” (Luke 1:48). The Apology approves a threefold honor of all the saints, namely thanksgiving to God for the gifts He gave them, the strengthening of our faith by their example, and “the imitation, first, of faith, then of the other virtues.” It even grants that “so in heaven they pray for the Church in general.” What it will not grant is that we should call upon them: “since neither a command, nor a promise, nor an example can be produced from the Scriptures concerning the invocation of saints, it follows that conscience can have nothing concerning this invocation that is certain.”83 Of Mary in particular Melanchthon writes, “Granting that the blessed Mary prays for the Church, does she receive souls in death, does she conquer death [the great power of Satan], does she quicken? What does Christ do if the blessed Mary does these things?”84 “For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Timothy 2:5).

The Roman Catholic Church teaches more than this and binds some of it as dogma. In 1854 Pope Pius IX defined that Mary was, “from the first moment of her conception, by a singular grace and privilege of almighty God and by virtue of the merits of Jesus Christ, Saviour of the human race, preserved immune from all stain of original sin” (the immaculate conception), and in 1950 Pope Pius XII defined that she “was taken up body and soul into heavenly glory” (the assumption).85 Catholics argue the first from her share in Christ’s victory as the new Eve, which Irenaeus already taught: “what the virgin Eve had bound fast through unbelief, this did the virgin Mary set free through faith.”86 The Church invokes her “under the titles of Advocate, Helper, Benefactress, and Mediatrix,” and Trent taught that it is “good and useful suppliantly to invoke” the saints and “to have recourse to their prayers, aid, (and) help for obtaining benefits from God, through His Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, who is our alone Redeemer and Saviour.”87 The Second Vatican Council said that Mary’s role “neither takes away from nor adds anything to the dignity and efficaciousness of Christ the one Mediator,” and the Catechism that the devotion given her “differs essentially from the adoration which is given to the incarnate Word and equally to the Father and the Holy Spirit.”88 Catholic theology names the distinction: worship (latria) is given to God alone, while the saints receive honor (dulia) and Mary the highest honor given a creature (hyperdulia). The angel greeted her, “Greetings, O favored one, the Lord is with you!” (Luke 1:28), with a Greek word, kecharitōmenē (“one who has been favored, graced”), that Catholics read as a lasting state of grace. If we may ask a righteous man on earth to pray for us, because “The prayer of a righteous person has great power as it is working” (James 5:16), why not one who is with Christ?

Rome’s own recent teaching shows a care Lutherans should welcome. In November 2025 the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, with the approval of Pope Leo XIV, commended calling Mary the Mother of the faithful and allowed “Mediatrix” only in a subordinate sense, while it judged that “It is always inappropriate to use the title ‘Co-redemptrix’ to define Mary’s cooperation” and that “no human person — not even the Apostles or the Blessed Virgin — can act as a universal dispenser of grace.”89 However, the dogmas of 1854 and 1950 remain, and a Catholic must believe them as revealed by God. Lutherans do not deny that God could have done these things, but we deny that the Church may bind consciences to them when Scripture does not teach them. Mary herself rejoiced “in God my Savior” (Luke 1:47), and her last recorded words to men are “Do whatever he tells you” (John 2:5). The invocation of the saints is the other difference. It is not commanded and no promise is attached to it, and wherever it becomes the ordinary way a Christian approaches God it draws the heart away from the one Mediator who invites sinners to come to Him directly. Rome’s official teaching guards against that, but popular piety has not always heeded the guard, and the Apology’s complaint that “in public opinion the blessed Virgin has succeeded altogether to the place of Christ” was written about real people.90


IV. What We Might Learn from One Another

What can a confessional Lutheran learn from Rome without giving up anything he confesses? I believe the answer is more than we are used to admitting. We can learn 1) seriousness about the visible unity of the Church, which Rome has never made peace with losing, 2) the discipline of one catechism taught to a farmer in Congo and a professor in Rome, 3) reverence for the Sacrament, 4) the remembrance of the saints, and lastly 5) the use of private confession. We have been too content with our divisions and we have the Small Catechism and leave it on the shelf. The care with which a devout Catholic handles the consecrated host rebukes the casual way some Lutherans treat what we confess is the true body of Christ. The Apology approved thanksgiving for the saints and the imitation of their faith, and although we will not invoke them, we have let even that honor fall into disuse while Rome kept it. In addition, our own Confession teaches that “private Absolution ought to be retained in the churches,” and Catholics still go to confession and hear a priest say “I absolve you” while most Lutherans have let the practice lapse.91 The Catechism, teaching on merit, quotes Thérèse of Lisieux, a Doctor of the Church, to show that “the saints have always had a lively awareness that their merits were pure grace”: “In the evening of this life, I shall appear before you with empty hands, for I do not ask you, Lord, to count my works… I wish, then, to be clothed in your own justice.”92 Luther could have prayed that prayer.

In return we have something to bring. Above all we can bring the certainty of the Gospel, the promise spoken to you (pro me, “for me”) so that the conscience may rest in it, without implying that Catholics lack the absolution or the Sacrament in which they hear it. We can bring the distinction of Law and Gospel, which keeps the comfort of the Gospel from being swallowed up by its demands. We can bring our long habit of putting the Bible in the people’s hands, and here Rome has met us, for Dei Verbum says that “Easy access to Sacred Scripture should be provided for all the Christian faithful.”93 The Joint Declaration itself listed the questions that remain open, “the relationship between the Word of God and church doctrine, as well as ecclesiology, ecclesial authority, church unity, ministry, the sacraments.”94 A confessional Lutheran who has done his homework is not an obstacle to that conversation, but a partner in it who brings the questions the Reformation asked and should be ready to hear Rome’s questions in return.

Some who read this have a Catholic husband or wife, Catholic grandchildren, or a Catholic friend of many years. Be glad of what you share with them. Their Baptism is a true Baptism, they hear the Scriptures and confess the Creed every Sunday, and many of them pray more faithfully than we do. Hold fast to what you have been given, the promise of forgiveness for Christ’s sake and the Supper as our Lord gives it. At a Catholic wedding or funeral Mass you will not go forward for Communion, and the Catholic Church does not ask you to, because both churches understand Communion as a confession of one faith. You can pray with your family, say the Lord’s Prayer and the Creed with them, and speak of Christ’s promise when the hard days come. If a Catholic in your family becomes a Lutheran, or a Lutheran becomes a Catholic, neither church will baptize him again.


V. In the Meantime

Where does this leave us? I think it leaves us where the Christians in Augsburg were on that October morning in 1999, glad of what we share and honest about what we do not. We are brothers and sisters in Christ and the Second Vatican Council said so before many Lutherans were willing to say it of Roman Catholics. However, the unity of the Church that our Confession seeks is agreement “concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments,” which the Formula explains as being “agreed with one another in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”95 We still part on the article on which, as Luther said, all things depend, and on the authority by which that article is to be judged. We part on the papal office, on the sacrifice of the Mass, on purgatory and indulgences, and on the Marian dogmas and the invocation of the saints. None of those differences is a quarrel over words.

How can we call Roman Catholics brothers and still keep our Confessions’ condemnations? The Preface to the Book of Concord answers that “it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches.”96 In other words, the Confessions condemn false teachings and those who obstinately teach them. They condemn neither Christians who were taught otherwise nor whole churches. Therefore we should speak of Roman Catholics as the Eighth Commandment requires, defending them against slander and putting the best construction on what they say. We should rejoice wherever the Gospel is heard in their churches, and it is heard there, in the Scriptures read at every Mass, in the Creed, in the absolution, and in the prayers of countless Catholics who trust in Christ. We should also hold fast to what we have received, because the unity Christ prayed for is unity in the truth.

Therefore I pray for the Roman Catholic Church and I ask you to pray for it too. I pray for Pope Leo and for the bishops, that they may preach Christ and Him crucified. I pray for the Catholic parish down the road and for the Lutheran congregation I serve, that both may hear the voice of the Good Shepherd and follow Him. Most of all I pray the prayer our Lord prayed on the night He was betrayed, “that they may all be one, just as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me” (John 17:21). That unity is His to give, in His time and in His truth.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Cited as ESV.)

The Lutheran Confessions

  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text at bookofconcord.org.)
  • The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
  • The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Preface; Augsburg Confession II, VI, VII, X, XI, XX, XXIV; Apology IV, IX, XXI, XXIV; Smalcald Articles I, II.i–iv, III.vi and Subscriptions; Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope; Formula of Concord, Rule and Norm, III, VII, VIII, X; Small Catechism.)

Roman Catholic Documents

  • Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent. Translated by J. Waterworth. London: Dolman, 1848. (Sessions V, VI, XIII, XXII, XXV.)
  • First Vatican Council. First Dogmatic Constitution on the Church of Christ (Pastor Aeternus). 1870. In Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils, edited by Norman P. Tanner. London: Sheed & Ward; Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 1990.
  • Second Vatican Council. Lumen Gentium (1964); Unitatis Redintegratio (1964); Dei Verbum (1965).
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997.
  • John Paul II. Ut Unum Sint. 1995.
  • Benedict XVI. Spe Salvi. 2007.
  • Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith. Mater Populi Fidelis: Doctrinal Note on Some Marian Titles Regarding Mary’s Cooperation in the Work of Salvation. 2025.

Lutheran–Roman Catholic Dialogue

  • Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church. Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. 1999. With the Official Common Statement and Annex.
  • Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity. Response of the Catholic Church to the Joint Declaration. 1998.
  • Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity. From Conflict to Communion. 2013.
  • Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod. The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification in Confessional Lutheran Perspective. St. Louis, 1999.

The Early Church

  • Irenaeus. Against Heresies. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.

Luther

  • Luther, Martin. Concerning Rebaptism. Luther’s Works, vol. 40. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1958.

Reference

  • Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.

Footnotes

  1. Episcopal News Service, press release 99-170 (November 18, 1999): more than 2,000 in procession from the cathedral; 750 church leaders and journalists in St. Anna’s Lutheran Church, among them 50 Lutheran and Roman Catholic bishops; another 2,000 watching on a screen in a tent on the city square. ↩

  2. Episcopal News Service, press release 99-170. Bishop Krause spoke in his sermon at the service; the Pope’s words come from a statement issued in Rome after the signing. The document signed was the Official Common Statement with its Annex, which confirmed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (hereafter JDDJ) as a whole. ↩

  3. SC I, Eighth Commandment. The bracketed words are the Triglotta’s. ↩

  4. Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), 8. ↩

  5. Vatican statistics for 2024, about 1.422 billion baptized Catholics, as reported in October 2026 (Agenzia Fides and the press, citing the Vatican Central Office of Church Statistics). The figure for the end of 2023 was about 1.406 billion. ↩

  6. The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification in Confessional Lutheran Perspective (St. Louis: Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, 1999), Summary ¶11 (paraphrased); the evaluations were prepared by the systematic theology departments of Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne, and Concordia Seminary, St. Louis. Compare CCC 1376, which quotes Trent’s decree on transubstantiation as the Catholic faith. ↩

  7. Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 11. ↩

  8. Unitatis Redintegratio 3. CCC 818 and 1271 quote the same passage. ↩

  9. The first report of the international dialogue was The Gospel and the Church (the “Malta Report,” 1972). See also Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity, From Conflict to Communion (2013), and the Joint Statement signed by Pope Francis and Bishop Munib Younan at Lund, October 31, 2016. ↩

  10. The Lutheran World Federation numbers more than 150 member churches and about 78 million members. The ELCA adopted the JDDJ at its 1997 assembly by a 97 percent majority (JDDJ in Confessional Lutheran Perspective, Summary ¶1). The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod and the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod are not members of the Federation. ↩

  11. SA I.4. ↩

  12. FC Ep VIII.12; compare FC SD VIII.24. CCC 495. ↩

  13. CCC 1213; Ap IX.1 (Triglotta ¶51). ↩

  14. AC X.1–2; CCC 1374, quoting the Council of Trent, Session XIII. Compare FC SD VII.126, which teaches that Christ, “truly and essentially present in the Supper, should be adored in spirit and in truth in the true use of the same.” See also One Body at Many Altars. ↩

  15. AC XXIV.1. ↩

  16. CCC 2270. ↩

  17. Luther, Concerning Rebaptism (1528), LW 40 (paraphrased). ↩

  18. Ap IV.86. ↩

  19. Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. δικαιόω, sense 3. Thayer judges the sense “to make righteous” “extremely rare, if not altogether doubtful” (sense 1). ↩

  20. FC SD III.17. ↩

  21. Ap IV.117; FC SD III.18–19, which explains that the Apology often uses “regeneration” for justification, meaning the forgiveness of sins. ↩

  22. SA II.i.4–5. ↩

  23. AC VI.1; AC XX.29. ↩

  24. See Saint and Sinner. ↩

  25. Council of Trent, Session VI (January 13, 1547), Decree on Justification, ch. VIII. ↩

  26. Trent, Session VI, ch. VII. ↩

  27. Trent, Session VI, ch. VII. ↩

  28. CCC 1992, whose first sentence reads, “Justification has been merited for us by the Passion of Christ.” ↩

  29. Trent, Session VI, ch. VII. ↩

  30. CCC 2010, 2008; Trent, Session VI, ch. XVI. Compare CCC 2009, quoting Augustine: “Our merits are God’s gifts.” ↩

  31. Trent, Session VI, ch. X. ↩

  32. Trent, Session VI, canon XI. Compare canons IX, XII and XXIV. ↩

  33. Trent, Session V (June 17, 1546), Decree concerning Original Sin, 5. Compare CCC 1264 and 1426. ↩

  34. JDDJ 30. ↩

  35. AC II.2; compare Ap II. ↩

  36. JDDJ 15. ↩

  37. JDDJ 41, 42. ↩

  38. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Response of the Catholic Church to the Joint Declaration of the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation on the Doctrine of Justification (1998), Declaration and Clarifications, 1. The Response gives as its reason that “the concupiscence that remains in the baptized is not, properly speaking, sin.” ↩

  39. Annex to the Official Common Statement (1999), 2A; 2B sets out the two meanings of “concupiscence.” ↩

  40. JDDJ in Confessional Lutheran Perspective, Summary ¶4. ↩

  41. Ap IV.17. ↩

  42. CCC 1817. Compare Trent, Session VI, ch. XIII: “all ought to place and repose a most firm hope in God’s help.” ↩

  43. Trent, Session VI, ch. IX and XIII, and canon XIII; compare CCC 2005. ↩

  44. Ap IV.244–252 (Triglotta “Article III,” ¶123–131); the quotations are from Ap IV.252. See also Faith Alone and the Judgment According to Works. ↩

  45. FC Ep, Summary, Rule and Norm, 1. ↩

  46. FC Ep, Summary, Rule and Norm, 2. ↩

  47. Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum (1965), 9, 10. Compare CCC 95. ↩

  48. Dei Verbum 10; compare 21. Vatican II did not settle whether Tradition contains revealed truths not found in Scripture at all. ↩

  49. Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Mater Populi Fidelis (November 4, 2025), recalling a 1996 discussion in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, as quoted in Vatican News, November 4, 2025. ↩

  50. CCC 553. Compare CCC 552 and 881. ↩

  51. Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.3.2, ANF, vol. 1. The Latin is propter potiorem principalitatem, and its exact sense has long been debated. ↩

  52. Lumen Gentium 22. ↩

  53. First Vatican Council, Session 4 (July 18, 1870), First Dogmatic Constitution on the Church of Christ (Pastor Aeternus), ch. 4, in Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils, ed. Norman P. Tanner (1990). ↩

  54. CCC 891. ↩

  55. Lumen Gentium 25. Catholic commentators read the Vatican I clause against the fourth of the Gallican Articles of 1682. ↩

  56. Tr 23, 29. Compare Tr 25–28, which names Origen, Cyprian, Augustine, Hilary, Bede and Chrysostom for this reading. ↩

  57. CCC 424. On the fathers, see Catholic and Reformed. ↩

  58. SA II.iv.1. ↩

  59. SA II.iv.7–9; the quotation is SA II.iv.9. ↩

  60. SA, Subscriptions (Melanchthon). ↩

  61. John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 95. ↩

  62. SA II.iv.10; Tr 57. Compare SA II.iv.4 and Tr 39–41. ↩

  63. CCC 818, quoting Unitatis Redintegratio 3. Compare CCC 838. ↩

  64. CCC 1366, 1367. ↩

  65. Trent, Session XXII (September 17, 1562), Doctrine on the Sacrifice of the Mass, ch. II. ↩

  66. CCC 1368, 1414. ↩

  67. Trent, Session XIII (October 11, 1551), Decree on the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist, ch. IV; CCC 1376. ↩

  68. SA III.vi.5. See also One Body at Many Altars. ↩

  69. Ap XXIV.22; compare XXIV.19. ↩

  70. Ap XXIV.11. ↩

  71. SA II.ii.1. On Malachi 1:11, compare Ap XXIV.31–33. ↩

  72. CCC 1400, quoting Unitatis Redintegratio 22; CCC 1401. ↩

  73. See A Free Gospel and a Guarded Table. ↩

  74. CCC 1030, 1031. ↩

  75. Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (2007), 47. ↩

  76. CCC 1032, citing 2 Maccabees 12:46. CCC 1031 also cites Gregory the Great on Matthew 12:32. ↩

  77. CCC 1472. ↩

  78. CCC 1471, quoting Paul VI, Indulgentiarum Doctrina (1967), Norms 1–3. ↩

  79. CCC 1476, 1477, quoting Indulgentiarum Doctrina 5. ↩

  80. Trent, Session XXV (December 3–4, 1563), Decree concerning Indulgences; Apostolic Penitentiary, norms for the Jubilee indulgence (May 13, 2024), as summarized by Catholic News Service. ↩

  81. SA II.ii.12. ↩

  82. Ap XXIV.94. ↩

  83. Ap XXI.4–6, 9–10. ↩

  84. Ap XXI.27. ↩

  85. CCC 491, quoting Pius IX, Ineffabilis Deus (1854); CCC 966, quoting Lumen Gentium 59, which repeats the definition of Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus (1950). ↩

  86. Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.22.4, ANF, vol. 1. ↩

  87. CCC 969, quoting Lumen Gentium 62; Trent, Session XXV, On the Invocation, Veneration, and Relics, of Saints, and on Sacred Images. ↩

  88. Lumen Gentium 62; CCC 971. Compare Lumen Gentium 60, and Trent, Session XIII, ch. V, on “the worship of latria, which is due to the true God.” ↩

  89. Mater Populi Fidelis 22, 25 and 53, as quoted and summarized in Vatican News, November 4, 2025. The Note was approved by Pope Leo XIV on October 7, 2025. ↩

  90. Ap XXI.28. ↩

  91. AC XI.1. ↩

  92. CCC 2011, quoting Thérèse of Lisieux, Act of Offering to Merciful Love. ↩

  93. Dei Verbum 22. ↩

  94. JDDJ 43. ↩

  95. AC VII.2; FC SD X.31. Compare FC Ep X.7, “agreement among them in doctrine and all its articles.” ↩

  96. Preface to the Book of Concord (Triglotta). The Preface speaks of the controversy over the Lord’s Supper and adds the hope that such Christians, rightly taught, would agree with us. ↩

Topics
Other Churches and TraditionsJustification and Grace
Scripture
Ephesians 4:2–3Ephesians 4:15Titus 3:5Acts 2:39Matthew 26:26Romans 3:23–24Romans 3:28Romans 4:51 John 5:13James 2:24Galatians 5:61 Corinthians 13:22 Corinthians 5:172 Timothy 3:16–172 Thessalonians 2:151 Timothy 3:15John 16:13Matthew 16:18–19Isaiah 22:22Matthew 10:2Luke 22:32John 21:17Matthew 18:18Malachi 1:11Luke 22:191 Corinthians 11:26Hebrews 10:14Hebrews 10:18Revelation 21:271 Corinthians 3:13Colossians 1:24Luke 23:43Philippians 1:231 John 1:7Luke 1:481 Timothy 2:5Luke 1:28James 5:16Luke 1:47John 2:5John 17:21Matthew 12:32
Confessions
SA IEp VIIISD VIIIAp IXAC XSD VIIAC XXIVAp IVSD IIISA IIAC VIAC XXAC IIAp IISA IIIAp XXIVAp XXIAC XIAC VIISD XEp XSC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and Roman Catholicism: What We Confess Together, Where We Still Part, and What We Might Learn from One Another.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/roman-catholicism/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.