Grace Alone and the Lost
Why Some Are Saved and Others Are Not
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast.” — Ephesians 2:8–9
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. Luther’s Bondage of the Will is quoted from Henry Cole’s 1823 translation with the LW volume given for comparison, and Calvin’s Institutes from Henry Beveridge’s translation.
The Question Before Us
Every Lutheran confirmand learns to say that we are saved by grace alone. We are not saved by our works, our decision, our sincerity, or our cooperation. God does it all. However, a thoughtful person who hears this for the first time will often ask a hard question in return. If God does it all, and if the reason I believe lies wholly in God and not at all in me, then why does my neighbor not believe? If salvation does not depend on anything in us, then the difference between the saved and the lost cannot lie in us either. It must lie in God. Did He simply choose not to save some people? Is grace alone just another way of saying that God picks some and passes over the rest?
Some people ask this question because they want to defend God’s goodness. Others ask it because they want to accuse Him. Still others ask it in the middle of the night because they are afraid that they themselves are among those God has passed over. All three deserve a serious answer.
The old theologians had a name for it. They called it the crux theologorum (“the cross of the theologians”), the point at which every system of doctrine is put to the test. In Latin the question is short: Cur alii, alii non? (“Why some, and not others?”).1 Augustine wrestled with it in his last years, Luther debated it with Erasmus, and the Formula of Concord gave a whole article to it.
In this paper I want to take up five questions in order:
- What do the words grace, election, and predestination mean?
- Is our salvation wholly the work of God?
- Is the damnation of the lost wholly their own fault?
- What answers has the Church given to the question “Why some and not others,” and why do the Lutheran Confessions refuse to resolve it by reason?
- Where should a troubled conscience look when it asks, “Am I one of the elect?”
A companion paper, God Wills All to Be Saved, asks a related question: if God desires everyone to be saved, why does He not save everyone? That paper treats God’s universal saving will, 1 Timothy 2:4, and man’s resistance to the Spirit’s work through the Word in detail, so I touch them here only briefly. At each step we will listen first to Holy Scripture, then to the Lutheran Confessions, and then to the fathers and the Reformers who help us hear Scripture rightly.
I. What Do the Words Mean?
Grace
We begin, as always, with the terms. The New Testament word for grace is charis (“grace, favor, kindness”). Thayer explains it as the kindness of God toward men, which gives what has not been deserved.2 In Scripture, then, grace means the undeserved favor of God toward sinners for Christ’s sake, together with the gifts that favor gives, rather than a substance poured into the soul or a power that helps us do our part. Paul draws the line sharply: “But if it is by grace, it is no longer on the basis of works; otherwise grace would no longer be grace” (Romans 11:6). In other words, grace and merit cannot be mixed. As soon as any part of salvation is credited to us, the whole of it stops being grace.
Predestination and election
Webster’s defines predestination as “the act of decreeing or foreordaining events; the decree of God by which he hath, from eternity, unchangeably appointed or determined whatever comes to pass,” and adds that in theology it denotes “the preordination of men to everlasting happiness or misery.”3 The dictionary has already taken a side. It treats predestination as a decree over everything that happens and over the lost as well as the saved. That is the Reformed use of the word and many English speakers have inherited it without knowing it.
Scripture speaks more narrowly. The Greek verb proorizō (“to determine beforehand, to foreordain”) is used of God’s purpose to save in Christ: “In love he predestined us for adoption to himself as sons through Jesus Christ, according to the purpose of his will” (Ephesians 1:4–5). The noun eklogē (“a choosing, election”) and the verb eklegomai (“to pick out, to choose for oneself”) speak of God’s choosing of His people: “he chose us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and blameless before him” (Ephesians 1:4).4 The related word prognōsis (“foreknowledge”) appears beside them (Romans 8:29; 1 Peter 1:2). In the New Testament these words are almost always spoken to believers for their comfort, as words of the Gospel.
Foreknowledge is not election
The Formula of Concord begins its article on election by distinguishing God’s foreknowledge from God’s election. Foreknowledge “extends over all creatures, good and bad.” God sees and knows everything before it happens, the sparrow that falls and the evil that men do. Election, on the other hand, “does not extend at once over the godly and the wicked, but only over the children of God, who were elected and ordained to eternal life before the foundation of the world was laid.”5
The Formula then says something that governs everything else in this paper: “The beginning and cause of evil is not God’s foreknowledge (for God does not create and effect evil, neither does He help or promote it); but the wicked, perverse will of the devil and of men,” and it cites Hosea 13:9. Election, by contrast, is a cause. It “is also, from the gracious will and pleasure of God in Christ Jesus, a cause which procures, works, helps, and promotes our salvation and what pertains thereto.”6 Therefore, from the very first paragraphs the Lutheran Confessions refuse to treat salvation and damnation as two matching halves of one decree. God foreknows both salvation and damnation, yet He causes only the first.
Election includes the whole way of salvation
The Formula also warns against thinking of election as a bare list in God’s head. We are not to imagine that God “only held a [sort of military] muster, thus: ‘This one shall be saved, that one shall be damned.’” Instead, election takes in the whole counsel of God for our salvation. The Solid Declaration lists it in eight points: that the human race is truly redeemed through Christ; that Christ’s merit is offered through Word and Sacraments; that the Holy Spirit works through the Word to convert hearts; that God justifies all who receive Christ by faith; that He sanctifies them; that He protects them in their weakness; that He strengthens to the end the work He has begun; and that He will finally save and glorify those He has elected, called, and justified.7
If election is only a list, then the only question that counts is whether my name is on it, and I have no way to find out. If election is God’s whole purpose to save in Christ through the means of grace, then I find out about my election in the same place I find out about Christ: in the Word and the Sacraments.
II. Salvation Is Wholly God’s Work
The witness of Scripture
The first half of the answer is that our salvation, from beginning to end, is the work of God. Paul says it of our salvation as a whole: “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Ephesians 2:8–9). He says it of our calling: God “saved us and called us to a holy calling, not because of our works but because of his own purpose and grace, which he gave us in Christ Jesus before the ages began” (2 Timothy 1:9). He says it of our new birth: “he saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy” (Titus 3:5). He says it of election in Romans 9: “So then it depends not on human will or exertion, but on God, who has mercy” (Romans 9:16).
Jesus says it of our coming to Him: “No one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him” (John 6:44). He says it of our choosing: “You did not choose me, but I chose you” (John 15:16). Paul says it of our confession: “no one can say ‘Jesus is Lord’ except in the Holy Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:3). He says it even of our willing: “it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Philippians 2:13). Luke says it of the Gentiles at Pisidian Antioch: “as many as were appointed to eternal life believed” (Acts 13:48). The order there is plain: they were not appointed because they believed, but believed because they were appointed.
Then Paul asks the questions that settle the matter: “For who sees anything different in you? What do you have that you did not receive? If then you received it, why do you boast as if you did not receive it?” (1 Corinthians 4:7). If the difference between me and my unbelieving neighbor were something I contributed (my openness, my decision, my not resisting), then I would have something I did not receive, and I would have a reason to boast. Paul says I have neither.
The witness of the Confessions
The Lutheran Confessions say the same with care. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith.” It grants that the human will “has some liberty to choose civil righteousness,” so that a man can keep the outward law, earn a living, and choose a wife. However, “it has no power, without the Holy Ghost, to work the righteousness of God, that is, spiritual righteousness.” Luther put the same thing in words a child can learn: “I believe that I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ, my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Ghost has called me by the Gospel, enlightened me with His gifts, sanctified and kept me in the true faith.”8
The Formula of Concord is more exact still, because by then the question had been fought over. In spiritual things the unregenerate man is “entirely dead to what is good,” so that there is “not the least spark of spiritual power remaining,” by which he could prepare himself for grace or accept it, “either wholly, or half, or in any, even the least or most inconsiderable part.” Before the Holy Spirit converts him, he can contribute to his conversion “just as little as a stone or a block or clay.” The Formula adds that in one respect he is worse than a block, “inasmuch as he is rebellious and hostile to God’s will.” For this reason Scripture ascribes conversion, faith, regeneration, and renewal “not to the human powers of the natural free will,” but to God alone, who “worketh in us both to will and to do.”9
The article on election draws the same line. Because God chose us in Christ “before the foundation of the world was laid, when, of course, we could do nothing good,” the doctrine of election “establishes very effectually the article that we are justified and saved without all works and merits of ours, purely out of grace alone, for Christ’s sake.” The Formula therefore rejects the teaching “that not alone the mercy of God and the most holy merit of Christ, but that also in us there is a cause of God’s election, on account of which God has chosen us to eternal life.” The Epitome lists the same error among those that take from Christians “all the comfort which they have in the holy Gospel.”10
The witness of the early Church
Augustine is the great teacher of the early Church on this point, though he came to it only after correcting an error of his own. As a young man he had thought that faith itself came from us and that by it we obtained God’s other gifts. He tells us that 1 Corinthians 4:7 changed his mind: “it was chiefly by this testimony that I myself also was convinced when I was in a similar error, thinking that faith whereby we believe in God is not God’s gift, but that it is in us from ourselves.” In the same treatise he defines the relation of predestination and grace in one sentence: “predestination is the preparation for grace, while grace is the donation itself.” He also reads John 15:16 exactly as Luke reads Acts 13:48: “For He chose us, not because we believed, but that we might believe.”11
A century later the Second Council of Orange (529) gathered up Augustine’s teaching against those who held that the first movement toward God comes from us. The council taught that the beginning of faith and even the desire to believe are gifts of grace, and that the free will was so weakened in Adam that no one can love God as he ought, or believe in Him, unless the grace of God’s mercy goes before. Orange was careful, however, not to go further than Scripture. In its closing statement it rejected with horror the idea that anyone is predestined to evil by the power of God.12 In other words, the Church of the sixth century held both truths together before the Lutherans ever did: salvation is all of grace, and God is not the author of anyone’s ruin.
III. Damnation Is Wholly Man’s Fault
The witness of Scripture
If Scripture said only what we heard in the previous section, then our questioner’s conclusion would seem to follow. However, Scripture does not say only that. With the same clarity it says that those who are lost are lost by their own fault, and that God did not want it so.
The prophet Hosea puts it in one verse, though the Hebrew is difficult. Hosea 13:9 begins with shichetkha (“it has destroyed you” or “your ruin”), from the verb shachat (“to spoil, ruin, destroy”). The ESV renders it, “He destroys you, O Israel, for you are against me, against your helper.” The older translations that the Confessions used read the verse as a contrast: “O Israel, thou hast destroyed thyself; but in Me is thy help.”13 However the first word is read, the verse gives one reason for Israel’s ruin: Israel had set itself against the Lord who was its only help, and its help was only ever in God.
Jesus says it in His lament over Jerusalem: “O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! How often would I have gathered your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!” (Matthew 23:37). Stephen says it to the council: “you always resist the Holy Spirit” (Acts 7:51). Paul and Barnabas say it at Antioch, in the same chapter that told us the believers were appointed to eternal life: “Since you thrust it aside and judge yourselves unworthy of eternal life, behold, we are turning to the Gentiles” (Acts 13:46). Luke says it of the Pharisees, who “rejected the purpose of God for themselves” (Luke 7:30). And God says it through Ezekiel: “As I live, declares the Lord GOD, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live” (Ezekiel 33:11).
Paul’s own words in Romans 9 must be read with care. He writes, “What if God, desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, has endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, in order to make known the riches of his glory for vessels of mercy, which he has prepared beforehand for glory” (Romans 9:22–23). Of the vessels of mercy Paul says that God “has prepared [them] beforehand for glory.” Of the vessels of wrath he says only that they were “prepared for destruction,” and he does not say by whom. He says God “endured [them] with much patience.”
The witness of the Confessions
The Lutheran Confessions build directly on these texts. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “although God does create and preserve nature, yet the cause of sin is the will of the wicked, that is, of the devil and ungodly men; which will, unaided of God, turns itself from God.” The Formula carries the same principle from sin to its punishment. The reason why not all who hear the Word believe, “and some are therefore condemned the more deeply, is not because God had begrudged them their salvation; but it is their own fault, as they have heard the Word in such a manner as not to learn, but only to despise, blaspheme, and disgrace it, and have resisted the Holy Ghost, who through the Word wished to work in them.”14
On Romans 9:22 the Formula reads Paul exactly as we have. “Here, then, the apostle clearly says that God endured with much long-suffering the vessels of wrath, but does not say that He made them vessels of wrath; for if this had been His will, He would not have required any great long-suffering for it.” It then states the principle in its strongest form: “For all preparation for condemnation is by the devil and man, through sin, and in no respect by God, who does not wish that any man be damned; how, then, should He Himself prepare any man for condemnation? For as God is not a cause of sins, so, too, He is no cause of punishment, of damnation; but the only cause of damnation is sin.”15
What, then, of the hardening of Pharaoh, which Paul also cites (Romans 9:17–18)? The Formula answers that Pharaoh did not perish “because God had begrudged him salvation, or because it had been His good pleasure that he should be damned and lost.” His hardening was “a punishment of his antecedent sin and horrible tyranny.” When Pharaoh “wilfully reared up straightway against all admonitions and warnings, God withdrew His hand from him, and thus his heart became hardened and obdurate.” Paul uses Pharaoh to show the justice of God toward those who despise His Word, not to teach that God ordained anyone to damnation “in His secret counsel” so that he could not be saved.16
The article on free will says the same of everyone who refuses to hear. If a man “despises the instrument of the Holy Ghost, and will not hear, no injustice is done to him if the Holy Ghost does not enlighten him, but allows him to remain in the darkness of his unbelief and to perish,” and once again the Formula cites Matthew 23:37. The Epitome sums it up: that many are called and few chosen “does not mean that God is not willing to save everybody.” The fault lies with those who “wilfully despise” the Word, “stop their ears and harden their hearts,” and for this “not God or His election, but their wickedness, is responsible.”17
The witness of the early Church
The fathers of the East were especially careful to guard human responsibility. John Chrysostom, preaching on Romans 9:22, says that Pharaoh was a vessel of wrath, “that is, a man who by his own hard-heartedness had kindled the wrath of God.” Paul calls him fitted for destruction, “fully fitted indeed, but by his own proper self. For neither had God left out anything of the things likely to recover him.” Preaching on John 6:44, he takes up those who argued from Jesus’ words “that nothing lies in our own power.” Chrysostom answers that the words “do not take away our free will, but show that we greatly need assistance.”18
A Lutheran will want to read Chrysostom with some care here, because he gives the will more room in conversion than the Formula does. However, on the point at issue in this section he and the Formula speak with one voice: the lost are not lost because God made them for destruction. Augustine, who gave far less room to the will, agrees. In his Enchiridion he writes that God “has mercy of His great goodness, He hardens without any injustice; so that neither can he that is pardoned glory in any merit of his own, nor he that is condemned complain of anything but his own demerit. For it is grace alone that separates the redeemed from the lost, all having been involved in one common perdition through their common origin.”19
IV. Why Some and Not Others?
The dilemma reason sets before us
We now stand at the crux. Scripture says two things. Salvation is wholly the work of God’s grace, so that nothing in the believer distinguishes him from the unbeliever. Damnation is wholly the fault of the sinner, so that nothing in God’s will consigns him to it. Our reason looks at these two statements and says that both cannot be true. If the cause of salvation lies only in God, and God does not save all, then the cause of the difference must be God’s will to pass some by. If God truly wills to save all, and not all are saved, then the cause of the difference must lie in something the saved did that the lost did not do.
Is reason right? It is right that we cannot fit the two statements together, but wrong when it concludes that one of them must therefore be given up. Over the centuries the Church has given three answers to the question “Why some and not others?” Two of them resolve the tension by surrendering one half of what Scripture teaches. The third keeps both halves and refuses to resolve the tension at all. We should hear each one fairly, because the men who gave the first two answers were each trying to protect something precious.
The first answer: the difference lies in us
The first answer says that grace is offered to all and the difference lies in how we respond. The Church quickly rejected Pelagius, who taught that man can obey God without any inward help of grace at all. The more lasting form of this answer came from devout monks in southern Gaul, whom later writers called semi-Pelagians. They agreed that we need grace to be saved. However, they taught that the first movement of the will toward God could come from us. John Cassian, the most gifted of them, wrote that God, “when He sees in us some beginnings of a good will, He at once enlightens it and strengthens it and urges it on towards salvation, increasing that which He Himself implanted or which He sees to have arisen from our own efforts.”20 The Council of Orange answered him, as we have seen.
The same answer returned in the sixteenth century in the person of Erasmus of Rotterdam, the finest scholar of his age. In his Diatribe on Free Will (1524) he defined free will as “a power in the human will, by which, a man may apply himself to those things which lead unto eternal salvation, or turn away from the same.” Erasmus was a peaceable man who hated quarrels and he feared that Luther’s teaching would make people careless about godliness. Luther answered him in The Bondage of the Will (1525) and thanked him for going straight to “the grand hinge upon which the whole turned.”21
Sadly, the answer appeared even among the Lutherans. In the later editions of his Loci Communes, Philip Melanchthon spoke of three causes that concur in conversion (the Word, the Holy Spirit, and the assenting human will), and after Luther’s death some of his students went further. The Formula of Concord rejects this “doctrine of the Synergists,” who say that man is not dead in spiritual things but “badly wounded and half dead,” and that the will can “to a certain extent, although feebly, do something towards it.” It rejects as well the phrase facultas applicandi se ad gratiam (“the ability to apply oneself to grace”) as a natural power, and it says plainly that the intellect and will of the unregenerate man are nothing else than subiectum convertendum (“that which is to be converted”).22
In 1610 the followers of Jacobus Arminius in the Netherlands set out a similar answer in the five articles of the Remonstrance. They taught that God from eternity chose to save in Christ those who, by the grace of the Holy Spirit, would believe in Him and persevere, and that this grace may be resisted.23 They meant to defend the goodness of God and His sincere offer of the Gospel to all and on those two points Lutherans stand closer to them than to their opponents.
What is the trouble with this first answer? It protects the truth that the lost are lost by their own fault. However, it pays for it by giving away the first truth. If my faith is the thing that makes the difference, and if my faith is even in the smallest part my contribution, then I have something I did not receive (1 Corinthians 4:7), and election rests in part on me. That is exactly the error the Formula rejects when it denies that “also in us there is a cause of God’s election.” It also takes away the comfort it meant to protect. If my salvation rests even in part in my hands, then, as the Formula says, I “would lose it much more easily than was the case with Adam and Eve in paradise, yea, every hour and moment.”24
Some Lutheran teachers of the seventeenth century, Johann Gerhard among them, spoke of election intuitu fidei (“in view of faith”). They did not mean that faith is a cause of election or a work of ours that God rewards. They meant faith as God’s own gift, which He foresaw in those He would save in Christ, and they rejected the synergists as firmly as the Formula did.25 The Formula itself does not use the phrase. It says only that there is no cause of election “in us” (SD XI 88), and I stay with its words.
The second answer: the difference lies in God’s decree
The second answer runs the other way. It begins from the truth that salvation is all of grace and follows the logic to its end. John Calvin defined predestination this way: “By predestination we mean the eternal decree of God, by which he determined with himself whatever he wished to happen with regard to every man. All are not created on equal terms, but some are preordained to eternal life, others to eternal damnation.” Calvin did not hide the weight of what he was saying. Speaking of the fall of Adam and the ruin it brought on so many, he wrote, “The decree, I admit, is dreadful.”26
We must be fair to Calvin and his heirs. Calvin insisted that man “falls by his own fault,” and he urged his readers to “contemplate the evident cause of condemnation” in the corruption of human nature “rather than inquire into a cause hidden and almost incomprehensible in the predestination of God.” He also told troubled believers to look for their election in Christ: “Christ, then, is the mirror in which we ought, and in which, without deception, we may contemplate our election.” The Canons of the Synod of Dort (1619), which answered the Remonstrants, speak with similar care. They teach that God’s reprobation is a decree “to leave them in the common misery into which, by their own fault, they have plunged themselves,” and they deny that this makes God the author of sin, calling such a thought blasphemous.27
What, then, is the trouble with the second answer? It protects the truth that salvation is all of grace. However, it pays for it by placing in a decree of God, made before anyone had done anything at all, the final reason why some are passed by while others are not. Dort says it directly: “The fact that some receive from God the gift of faith within time, and that others do not, stems from his eternal decree.” The Formula of Concord cannot follow that step. It rejects the teaching “that God is unwilling that every one should be saved, but that some, without regard to their sins, from the mere counsel, purpose, and will of God, are ordained to condemnation so that they cannot be saved.” It also names the deepest danger in the second answer. If God calls all through the Word but in His heart means the call for only a few, then “this would be to assign contradictory wills to God,” and “the necessary consolatory foundation is rendered altogether uncertain and void.”28
The third answer: stop where Scripture stops
The Lutheran Confessions give a third answer and it will not satisfy anyone who is looking for a system. They hold both truths with full force and decline to explain how they fit together. The Formula sets the limit with Paul. In the questions of why one is hardened while “another, who is indeed in the same guilt, is converted again,” we are to see in those who perish “the just judgment of God and the penalties of sins,” and in those who are saved God’s “pure, unmerited grace.” Then it says, “When we proceed thus far in this article, we remain on the right [safe and royal] way, as it is written Hos. 13:9: O Israel, thou hast destroyed thyself; but in Me is thy help.” As for questions that “would soar too high and beyond these limits, we should, with Paul, place the finger upon our lips, and remember and say, Rom. 9:20: O man, who art thou that repliest against God?”29
The Formula does not forbid us to think about it and it is clear that God knows the answer. He “most exactly and certainly foresaw before the time of the world, and still knows, which of those that are called will believe or will not believe.” However, “since God has reserved this mystery for His wisdom, and has revealed nothing to us concerning it in His Word,” we are not to investigate it but to “adhere to His revealed Word, to which He points us.”30 Moses said the same long before: “The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things that are revealed belong to us and to our children forever” (Deuteronomy 29:29). And Paul, after three chapters on this very subject, ends not with an explanation but with a doxology: “Oh, the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments and how inscrutable his ways!” (Romans 11:33).
The Lutherans did not invent this restraint. Augustine reached it himself. Asked why God gives perseverance to one believer and not to another, he answered, “I answer that I do not know,” and he quoted Romans 9:20 and 11:33. Preaching on John 6:44 he told his people, “There is whom He draws, and there is whom He draws not; why He draws one and draws not another, do not desire to judge, if you desire not to err.” In the Enchiridion he called the question of why one child is chosen and another is not “to us an insoluble problem,” which will be made clear only on the Last Day. Prosper of Aquitaine, Augustine’s defender in Gaul, is usually taken to be the author of The Call of All Nations, which teaches God’s general goodness is extended to all men, while a special grace is given to some, and that the reason for the difference lies hidden in the justice of God and is not to be pried into. We should be honest that Augustine at times went further than we can follow, especially in his reading of 1 Timothy 2:4.31 However, at the point where he stopped and confessed “I do not know,” he and the Formula stand together.
Luther and the hidden God
Luther’s answer to Erasmus is often read as though Luther were a predestinarian of the Calvinist kind. He was not. The key is a distinction he drew in The Bondage of the Will between God as He is preached and God as He is hidden. Erasmus had argued from Ezekiel 18 and 33 that God would not deplore the death of His people if He Himself worked it. Luther answered that “we are to argue in one way, concerning the will of God preached, revealed, and offered unto us, and worshipped by us; and in another, concerning God himself not preached, not revealed, not offered unto us.” God hidden in His majesty is not our business. “But we have to do with him as far as he is clothed in, and delivered to us by, his word.” Therefore, “God preached desires this:—that, our sin and death being taken away, we might be saved.”32
Luther did not deny that there is a hidden will of God. He said that “God does many things which he does not make known unto us in his word.” However, he insisted that we are to be guided by the Word and not by the will that is hidden, “for who can direct himself according to a will inscrutable and incomprehensible?” When it is said that “if God does not desire our death, it is to be laid to the charge of our own will, if we perish,” Luther answers, “this, I say, is right, if you speak of God preached. For he desires that all men should be saved, seeing that, he comes unto all by the word of salvation, and it is the fault of the will which does not receive him.”33 Isaiah confessed, “Truly, you are a God who hides himself, O God of Israel, the Savior” (Isaiah 45:15). Luther’s point is that the hidden God and the Savior are one God, and that we meet Him as Savior only where He has made Himself known.
Near the end of the same book Luther spoke of three lights. By the light of nature we cannot understand why the wicked prosper and the good suffer. By the light of grace that question is solved, because there is a life after this one. In the same way, a question that is “insolvable by the light of the word and of grace” will be solved by “the light of glory,” when “the essential Truth itself shall be revealed in the divine Majesty.”34 In other words, Luther did not claim to have solved the crux. He trusted that God would show on the Last Day that He has been just all along.
Late in life Luther returned to the subject in his lectures on Genesis and the Formula of Concord points readers there to learn his mind. Commenting on Genesis 26, he warned against those who reason that if they are predestined they will be saved whatever they do, and he had God say, in effect, that He has revealed Himself so that we might know Him: in His Son, in Baptism, in the Supper, and in the Word. Whoever wants to know his election should begin there and not with speculation about the hidden God. Martin Chemnitz, one of the principal authors of the Formula, taught the same: election is not to be searched out in God’s secret counsel but considered in Christ and in the call that comes through the Word and Sacraments, since God has bound Himself to work through these means.35
V. Where Should a Troubled Conscience Look?
Not into the hidden counsel
The question “Why some and not others?” quickly becomes a more personal one: “Am I one of the elect?” The Formula knew how that question works on people. The careless person reasons, “if I am foreknown to salvation, nothing can injure me with respect to it, even though I practise all sorts of sin and shame without repentance.” The anxious person reasons, “If, however, I am not foreknown, it helps me nothing anyway, even though I would occupy myself with the Word, repent, believe.” The Formula adds that even godly Christians are troubled this way, “especially when they view their weakness and the examples of those who have not persevered.”36
Both conclusions come from looking for election in the wrong place. Therefore the Formula says, “we should accustom ourselves not to speculate concerning the bare, secret, concealed, inscrutable foreknowledge of God, but how the counsel, purpose, and ordination of God in Christ Jesus, who is the true Book of Life, is revealed to us through the Word.” The Epitome is blunter still. We should judge our election “neither from reason nor from the Law of God,” because these lead “either into a reckless, dissolute, Epicurean life or into despair.” Such thoughts, it says, “proceed not from God, but from the suggestion of the Evil Foe.”37
What, then, did Jesus say when someone asked Him, “Lord, will those who are saved be few?” He did not open the hidden counsel. He said, “Strive to enter through the narrow door” (Luke 13:23–24). The Formula cites that very exchange as its model. The anxious reader should hear at once where that door is. Jesus also said, “I am the door. If anyone enters by me, he will be saved” (John 10:9) and He holds that door open in the Word and the Sacraments. To strive to enter is to come where He has promised to be. The Formula also cites Luther’s advice to read Romans in order, learning sin and grace in the first eight chapters before coming to chapters 9 through 11, where one learns “how consolatory predestination is.”38
In Christ, the Book of Life
If not in the hidden counsel, then where? The Formula answers, “this eternal election of God is to be considered in Christ, and not outside of or without Christ.” The whole Holy Trinity “directs all men to Christ, as to the Book of Life, in whom they should seek the eternal election of the Father.” What does Christ say? “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28). “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life” (John 3:16). “Whoever comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6:37). Therefore, “whoever would be saved should not trouble or harass himself with thoughts concerning the secret counsel of God, as to whether he also is elected,” but should hear Christ, who “testifies to all men without distinction that it is God’s will that all men should come to Him who labor and are heavy laden with sin.”39
In other words, the question “Am I elect?” is answered by the question “Who is Christ, and what has He promised me?” Christ is the Book of Life, and the Formula sends us to no other book.
In the means of grace
Christ does not speak to us from a distance. He speaks through His Word and seals His promise in the Sacraments. The Formula says that “God does not call without means, but through the Word.” The call that comes through the preaching of the Gospel is not “jugglery,” but God’s real will that “in those whom He thus calls He will work through the Word, that they may be enlightened, converted, and saved.” Then the Formula adds, “Christ causes the promise of the Gospel not only to be offered in general, but He seals it through the Sacraments which He attaches as seals of the promise, and thereby confirms it to every believer in particular.” The same is true of Holy Absolution. We are to believe it and regard it as sure that, “when we believe the word of absolution, we are as truly reconciled to God as though we had heard a voice from heaven.”40
The Epitome says that God “has not only promised this gracious election with mere words, but has also certified it with an oath and sealed it with the holy Sacraments, which we can call to mind in our most severe temptations, and take comfort in them, and therewith quench the fiery darts of the devil.” The anxious Christian does not need to wonder whether the Father will draw him. The Formula answers that the Father draws “by the hearing of His holy, divine Word, as with a net, by which the elect are plucked from the jaws of the devil.” So it says, “Every poor sinner should therefore repair thereto [to holy preaching], hear it attentively, and not doubt the drawing of the Father.”41 When the Word is preached to you, the Father is drawing you. When the water was poured on you in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, God put His name on you. When the pastor places the body and blood of Christ in your hand and says “given and shed for you,” that “for you” is God’s election spoken aloud in time.
The comfort of election
When election is taught this way, the Formula says, it becomes “a very useful, salutary, consolatory doctrine.” It means that God “was so greatly concerned about the conversion, righteousness, and salvation of every Christian” that “before the foundation of the world was laid, He deliberated concerning it,” and ordained how He would bring me to salvation and keep me in it. Because our salvation “could easily be lost from our hands,” God “placed it for preservation in the almighty hand of our Savior Jesus Christ, from which no one can pluck us.”42 Jesus says it Himself: “My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me. I give them eternal life, and they will never perish, and no one will snatch them out of my hand” (John 10:27–28).
Then the Formula gives a test that every preacher and teacher of this doctrine should keep in front of him. “If any one presents the doctrine concerning the gracious election of God in such a manner that troubled Christians cannot derive comfort from it, but are thereby incited to despair, or that the impenitent are confirmed in their wantonness, it is undoubtedly sure and true that such a doctrine is taught, not according to the Word and will of God, but according to [the blind judgment of human] reason and the instigation of the devil.”43
Conclusion: What This Means for Us
Let me gather up what we have heard.
-
Grace is God’s undeserved favor in Christ. Election is His gracious purpose, from eternity, to save His children in Christ through the Word and Sacraments. His foreknowledge of evil is not the cause of evil.
-
Our salvation is wholly God’s work. Faith, conversion, and perseverance are His gifts, and there is no cause of our election in us.
-
The damnation of the lost is wholly their own fault. God does not will it or prepare anyone for it. Its only cause is sin and the refusal of the Word through which the Holy Spirit would have worked faith.
-
Why some are saved and others are not is a question Scripture does not answer and so neither do we. The synergist answer saves God’s goodness by giving up grace alone. The Calvinist answer saves grace alone by placing in God’s decree the final reason why some are passed by. The Lutheran Confessions keep both truths and place a finger on their lips with Paul.
-
The troubled conscience must never look for its election in the hidden counsel of God, but in Christ, who is the Book of Life, and in the Word, Baptism, Absolution, and the Supper, through which He calls and keeps His own.
What does this mean for us? It means, first, that we can give all the glory to God without any embarrassment. Every Christian in our pews is there because God chose, called, and kept him. None of us can look at an unbelieving neighbor and say, “I was wiser, or more open, or more willing.” What do we have that we did not receive?
It means, second, that we can preach the Gospel to everyone without holding anything back. We do not know who the elect are and we are not asked to know. We know that God has “no pleasure in the death of the wicked” and that Christ says “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden.” When we invite a neighbor to church or speak the name of Jesus to a grieving friend, we are not guessing whether the offer is real. God means it and the Holy Spirit works through that very Word.
It means, third, that we can take the warnings of Scripture seriously without being driven to despair by them. The Christian who hears that the Pharisees “rejected the purpose of God for themselves” should not say “that might be me if I am not elect,” but should hear the call to repent and believe today. The Christian who has fallen should hear what the Formula says of God’s children who stumble: when they return to Him in true repentance, “He will always manifest the old paternal heart.”44
Nor does it make us judges of any particular person. When we stand at the grave of someone who seemed to want nothing to do with the Church, we do not know what the Spirit did through a word heard long ago or in a last hour, and we do not pronounce on him. We commend the dead to the mercy of the God who has “no pleasure in the death of the wicked” (Ezekiel 33:11) and we go on preaching to the living.
Lastly, it means that the question which troubles so many in the middle of the night has an answer, though not the one reason is looking for. Am I one of the elect? Look at the font where you were baptized, where God spoke His will toward you by name, and believe it today. Election is sought in Christ and in His call, not read off a date in the past.45 Listen to the words of absolution, “I forgive you all your sins in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.” Come to the altar and receive what is “given and shed for you.” These are God’s own answer. The secret things belong to the LORD our God. The things that are revealed belong to us and to our children, and what He has revealed is that He chose us in Christ “before the foundation of the world,” in love, “to the praise of his glorious grace, with which he has blessed us in the Beloved” (Ephesians 1:4–6).
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- Triglot Concordia: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by F. Bente and W. H. T. Dau. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text as published at bookofconcord.org.)
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Augsburg Confession IV, XVIII, XIX; Small Catechism, Creed; Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration II and XI.)
- Bente, F. Historical Introductions to the Book of Concord. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
The Early Church
- Augustine. On the Predestination of the Saints. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 5.
- Augustine. On Rebuke and Grace. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 5.
- Augustine. Enchiridion. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 3.
- Augustine. Tractates on the Gospel of John. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 7.
- John Cassian. Conferences. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 11.
- John Chrysostom. Homilies on Romans. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 11.
- John Chrysostom. Homilies on the Gospel of John. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 14.
- Prosper of Aquitaine (attributed). The Call of All Nations. Translated by P. De Letter. Ancient Christian Writers 14. Westminster, MD: Newman, 1952.
- Second Council of Orange (529). In John H. Leith, ed., Creeds of the Churches. 3rd ed. Atlanta: John Knox, 1982.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. The Bondage of the Will. Translated by Henry Cole. London, 1823. Compare Career of the Reformer III, Luther’s Works, vol. 33. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1972.
- Luther, Martin. Lectures on Genesis, Chapters 26–30. Luther’s Works, vol. 5. St. Louis: Concordia, 1968.
- Luther, Martin. Preface to the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans (1522). Luther’s Works, vol. 35. Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1960.
- Erasmus, Desiderius. On the Freedom of the Will (1524).
- Melanchthon, Philip. Loci Communes (editions of 1535 and 1543).
- Chemnitz, Martin. Ministry, Word, and Sacraments: An Enchiridion. Translated by Luther Poellot. St. Louis: Concordia, 1981.
- Chemnitz, Martin. Loci Theologici. Translated by J. A. O. Preus. 2 vols. St. Louis: Concordia, 1989.
- Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Translated by Henry Beveridge. Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845.
- The Remonstrance (1610). In Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3. New York: Harper, 1877.
- The Canons of Dort (1619). Christian Reformed Church in North America translation, 2011.
- Pieper, Francis. Christian Dogmatics. 3 vols. St. Louis: Concordia, 1950–1953.
- Schmid, Heinrich. The Doctrinal Theology of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Translated by C. A. Hay and H. E. Jacobs. Philadelphia: United Lutheran Publication House, 1899.
Reference
- Brown, Francis, S. R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs. A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament. Oxford: Clarendon, 1906.
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.
Footnotes
-
The question is also put as cur alii prae aliis? (“why some rather than others?”). Francis Pieper takes it up as the crux theologorum in his treatment of conversion: Christian Dogmatics, vol. 2 (St. Louis: Concordia, 1951). ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. χάρις. The summary here is a paraphrase. ↩
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “predestination.” ↩
-
Thayer, Greek-English Lexicon, s.v. προορίζω, ἐκλογή, ἐκλέγομαι, πρόγνωσις. ↩
-
SD XI 4–5, citing Matthew 10:29 and Psalm 139:16. Compare Ep XI 2–5. ↩
-
SD XI 7–8, citing Hosea 13:9, Matthew 16:18, John 10:28, and Acts 13:48. ↩
-
SD XI 9 (the bracketed words are in the Triglot text). The eight points are at SD XI 15–22, within SD XI 13–24. ↩
-
AC IV 1–2; AC XVIII 1–2; SC II 6, the explanation of the Third Article. AC XVIII quotes the Hypognosticon (attributed to Augustine in the sixteenth century) for its examples of civil righteousness. ↩
-
SD II 7, 24, and 25–26, citing Philippians 2:13, Ephesians 2:8, and John 6:44. ↩
-
SD XI 43, citing Romans 9:11 and 2 Timothy 1:9; SD XI 88, citing Romans 9:11–13; Ep XI 20–21 (Negative Thesis 4 and the conclusion). ↩
-
Augustine, On the Predestination of the Saints 7 [III], 19 [X], and 38 [XIX], NPNF¹, vol. 5. ↩
-
Second Council of Orange (529), canons 5–7 and the concluding statement. An English translation is in John H. Leith, ed., Creeds of the Churches, 3rd ed. (Atlanta: John Knox, 1982); the Latin is in Denzinger. The wording here is a paraphrase. ↩
-
Francis Brown, S. R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (Oxford: Clarendon, 1906), s.v. שָׁחַת. The ESV gives “I will destroy” as an alternative rendering in its note. The older reading is at SD XI 7 and 62. The Formula follows Luther’s German Bible here, and the King James Version reads the verse the same way. ↩
-
AC XIX, citing John 8:44; SD XI 78. ↩
-
SD XI 80–81, citing Romans 6:23, Ezekiel 33:11, and 2 Peter 3:9. Compare SD XI 82 on 2 Timothy 2:21: the damned “themselves, and not God, have prepared themselves as vessels of damnation.” ↩
-
SD XI 84–86. ↩
-
SD II 58; Ep XI 12. ↩
-
John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans 16, on Romans 9:22–24, NPNF¹, vol. 11; Homilies on the Gospel of John 46, on John 6:44, NPNF¹, vol. 14. Chrysostom names the Manichaeans as those who argued “that nothing lies in our own power.” ↩
-
Augustine, Enchiridion 99, NPNF¹, vol. 3. ↩
-
On Pelagius see Augustine’s anti-Pelagian writings in NPNF¹, vol. 5; the Augsburg Confession condemns the Pelagians by name at AC II 3 and AC XVIII 8. John Cassian, Conferences 13.8, NPNF², vol. 11. Compare Conferences 13.7 and 13.11, where Cassian tries to hold both possibilities together. ↩
-
Erasmus’s definition as Luther quotes it: Martin Luther, The Bondage of the Will, trans. Henry Cole (London, 1823), sect. XLI. The “grand hinge” is in Luther’s closing address to Erasmus in the same work. Compare LW 33. ↩
-
Melanchthon’s language about the three causes appears in the later editions of the Loci Communes (from 1535 on); the controversy among his students after 1546 is called the synergistic controversy. See the historical introduction to FC II in F. Bente, Historical Introductions to the Book of Concord (St. Louis: Concordia, 1921). This summary is a paraphrase. The Formula’s rejection is at SD II 77–78 and 90. ↩
-
The Remonstrance (1610), articles 1 and 4. An English translation is in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3 (New York: Harper, 1877). The summary here is a paraphrase. ↩
-
SD XI 88 and 90; Ep XI 20. ↩
-
See the statements of Gerhard and the other dogmaticians on predestination collected in Heinrich Schmid, The Doctrinal Theology of the Evangelical Lutheran Church, trans. C. A. Hay and H. E. Jacobs (Philadelphia: United Lutheran Publication House, 1899), and Francis Pieper’s account of the controversy over the phrase among American Lutherans in the 1880s in Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (St. Louis: Concordia, 1953), on eternal election. ↩
-
John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion III.21.5 and III.23.7, trans. Henry Beveridge (Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845). The Latin of III.23.7 is decretum quidem horribile, fateor, which the Battles translation renders “The decree is dreadful indeed, I confess.” ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes III.23.8 and III.24.5, trans. Beveridge. Canons of Dort, First Main Point of Doctrine, Article 15, in the translation adopted by the Christian Reformed Church in North America (2011). ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Main Point of Doctrine, Article 6; compare Article 5, which places “the cause or blame for this unbelief” not in God “but in humanity.” Ep XI 19 (Negative Thesis 3); SD XI 34–36. ↩
-
SD XI 57–63. ↩
-
SD XI 54–55, citing Romans 11:33. Compare SD XI 53, which observes that we cannot harmonize these things and have not been commanded to. ↩
-
Augustine, On Rebuke and Grace 17 [VIII], NPNF¹, vol. 5; Tractates on the Gospel of John 26.2, NPNF¹, vol. 7; Enchiridion 95, NPNF¹, vol. 3. Prosper of Aquitaine (attributed), The Call of All Nations, trans. P. De Letter, Ancient Christian Writers 14 (Westminster, MD: Newman, 1952), especially Book II; the summary is a paraphrase. On 1 Timothy 2:4 see Augustine, Enchiridion 97 and 103, where he reads “all” as “all kinds of men.” The companion paper, God Wills All to Be Saved, takes up that verse. ↩
-
Luther, The Bondage of the Will, trans. Cole, sect. LXIV. Compare LW 33:138–140. ↩
-
Luther, The Bondage of the Will, trans. Cole, sect. LXIV. Compare LW 33:139–140. ↩
-
Luther, The Bondage of the Will, trans. Cole, sect. CLXVI. Compare LW 33:292. ↩
-
SD II 44 directs the reader to Luther’s Bondage of the Will and to “his glorious exposition of the book of Genesis, especially of Gen. 26.” See Luther, Lectures on Genesis, on Genesis 26:9, LW 5; Martin Chemnitz, Ministry, Word, and Sacraments: An Enchiridion, trans. Luther Poellot (St. Louis: Concordia, 1981), in the questions on predestination; and Chemnitz, Loci Theologici, trans. J. A. O. Preus (St. Louis: Concordia, 1989). The summaries of Luther and Chemnitz here are paraphrases. ↩
-
SD XI 10–11. ↩
-
SD XI 13; Ep XI 9 and 13. ↩
-
SD XI 33, citing Luke 13:24 and quoting Luther’s Preface to the Epistle to the Romans (1522). Compare LW 35. ↩
-
SD XI 65–70, citing Matthew 11:28. ↩
-
SD XI 27, 29, 37, and 38. SD XI 38 refers to AC XI and the Apology on private absolution. ↩
-
Ep XI 13; SD XI 76–77. ↩
-
SD XI 43 and 45, citing John 10:28. ↩
-
SD XI 91. Compare Ep XI 16. ↩
-
SD XI 75, citing Jeremiah 3:1. ↩
-
SD XI 26–33. The Formula sends us to the call that comes through the Word and Sacraments, and not to our reason or “any external appearance” (SD XI 26). On those who receive the Word with joy and afterward fall away, see SD XI 42 and the companion paper Baptism and Falling Away. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Grace Alone and the Lost: Why Some Are Saved and Others Are Not.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/grace-alone-and-the-lost/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.