God Wills All to Be Saved
Why, Then, Are Not All Saved?
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“This is good, and it is pleasing in the sight of God our Savior, who desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.” — 1 Timothy 2:3–4
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation.
The Question Before Us
If God desires everyone to be saved, why does He not save everyone? The question is an old one and it is an honest one. A child asks it the first time she hears that some people will not go to heaven. A grieving family asks it at the grave of someone who wanted nothing to do with the Church. A skeptic asks it as an argument and he thinks it settles the matter. His reasoning runs like this: Scripture says that God wants all people to be saved. Scripture also says that God is almighty and does whatever pleases Him (Psalm 115:3). Scripture also says that not all are saved. Therefore one of those three statements must give way. Either God does not really want all to be saved, or He is not really able to save them, or in the end all will be saved after all.
Some have kept God’s will and God’s power and let go of the lost, so that in the end everyone is saved. Others have kept God’s power and the reality of the lost and quietly narrowed God’s will, so that “all people” means all kinds of people or only the elect. Still others have kept God’s will and the reality of the lost and placed the deciding cause in the human will, so that God does everything except the one thing that finally makes the difference. Each answer is held by serious Christians, yet each gives up something the Bible will not let us give up.
The Lutheran Confessions answer the question differently. They hold all three statements together, and the key lies in what God wills and in how He saves. In this paper I want to take up five questions in order: 1) Does God really desire the salvation of every person? 2) How does God save, and can His work be resisted? 3) Why, then, are some lost? 4) How do the other answers (universalism, Calvinism, and Arminianism) handle the question, and where do they fall short? 5) What may we know of God’s will, and what has He kept hidden? We will close by asking what all of this means for us, both for our mission to the world and for the comfort of our own consciences.
The companion paper, Grace Alone and the Lost, takes up the doctrine of election and what the old theologians called the crux theologorum (“the cross of the theologians”) in depth. Here we come at the same mystery from the other side, beginning with God’s will toward all people and the means by which He carries it out.
I. Does God Really Desire Everyone to Be Saved?
The words themselves
We begin with the words. In 1 Timothy 2:4 Paul says that God “desires all people to be saved.” The Greek reads hos pantas anthrōpous thelei sōthēnai. The verb thelō means “to will, to wish, to have in mind, to intend.” It is the ordinary New Testament word for what a person wants and purposes. The object is pantas anthrōpous (“all human beings”), the widest phrase Paul could have chosen. In the very next verses he adds that Christ Jesus “gave himself as a ransom for all” (1 Timothy 2:6).
Peter uses a different verb to say the same thing. The Lord “is patient toward you, not wishing that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance” (2 Peter 3:9). Here the verb is boulomai (“to will deliberately, to purpose, to desire”).1 God’s patience in delaying the Last Day has a purpose and the purpose is repentance. In other words, the time between the Ascension and the Second Coming exists so that more people may hear and turn.
The Old Testament speaks with the same voice. Through Ezekiel the Lord asks, “Have I any pleasure in the death of the wicked, declares the Lord GOD, and not rather that he should turn from his way and live?” (Ezekiel 18:23). At the end of the same chapter He says, “For I have no pleasure in the death of anyone, declares the Lord GOD; so turn, and live” (Ezekiel 18:32). And again: “As I live, declares the Lord GOD, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live; turn back, turn back from your evil ways, for why will you die, O house of Israel?” (Ezekiel 33:11). The Hebrew verb is chaphets (חָפֵץ, “to delight in, to take pleasure in”).2 God delights in repentance and not in death, and He swears it by His own life, which is the strongest oath Scripture knows.
The texts that will not be narrowed
These are not isolated verses. They belong to a pattern that runs through the whole Bible. “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through him” (John 3:16–17). John the Baptist points to “the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world” (John 1:29). The apostle John writes that Christ “is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only but also for the sins of the whole world” (1 John 2:2). The word for propitiation is hilasmos (“the means by which wrath is turned away”) and its reach is holou tou kosmou (“the whole world”).3 Jesus Himself says, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28).
The most moving of these texts is our Lord’s lament over Jerusalem: “O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, the city that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it! How often would I have gathered your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!” (Matthew 23:37). The Greek uses the same verb twice: ēthelēsa (“I willed”) and ouk ēthelēsate (“you did not will”). The Son of God wanted to gather them. They did not want to be gathered. Luke tells us that when He came near the city “he wept over it” (Luke 19:41). Therefore any account of God’s will that would make those tears insincere must be set aside.
What the Confessions say
The Formula of Concord takes up this question directly. “Therefore, if we wish to consider our eternal election to salvation with profit, we must in every way hold sturdily and firmly to this, that, as the preaching of repentance, so also the promise of the Gospel is universalis (universal), that is, it pertains to all men.”4 It then gathers the texts we have just read (John 3:16; John 1:29; 1 John 2:2; Matthew 11:28; Romans 11:32; 2 Peter 3:9) into one paragraph and lets them stand side by side. The Epitome says the same thing more briefly: Christ “calls to Himself all sinners and promises them rest, and He is in earnest [seriously wills] that all men should come to Him and suffer themselves to be helped.”5 In the article on free will the Formula puts it as plainly as it can be put: “It is not God’s will that any one should be damned [perish], but that all men should be converted to Him and be saved eternally.”6
The Formula goes further and rejects the contrary teaching by name. Among the errors it condemns are these: “that God is unwilling that all men repent and believe the Gospel”; “that when God calls us to Himself, He is not in earnest that all men should come to Him”; and “that God is unwilling that every one should be saved, but that some, without regard to their sins, from the mere counsel, purpose, and will of God, are ordained to condemnation so that they cannot be saved.” It calls these “blasphemous and dreadful erroneous doctrines” because they take away all the comfort Christians have in the Gospel and the Sacraments.7 Later Lutheran teachers summed up this whole doctrine as gratia universalis (“universal grace”) and they described it in three parts: the Father’s gracious will toward all, the merit of Christ that covers all, and the call of the Holy Spirit through the Word that goes out to all.8
The witness of the fathers
The early Church read these texts the same way. John Chrysostom, preaching on 1 Timothy 2 at Antioch, drew the practical conclusion at once: “Imitate God! If He wills that all men should be saved, there is reason why one should pray for all, if He has willed that all should be saved, be thou willing also; and if you wish it, pray for it, for wishes lead to prayers.”9 For Chrysostom the universal will of God was not a puzzle to be solved but the reason the congregation prayed for the emperor, for pagans, and even for heretics.
John of Damascus, gathering up the teaching of the Greek fathers in the eighth century, made a distinction that has served the Church ever since: “God’s original wish was that all should be saved and come to His Kingdom. For it was not for punishment that He formed us but to share in His goodness, inasmuch as He is a good God. But inasmuch as He is a just God, His will is that sinners should suffer punishment.” He then names the two: “The first then is called God’s antecedent will and pleasure, and springs from Himself, while the second is called God’s consequent will and permission, and has its origin in us.”10 In other words, what God wills first and from Himself is the salvation of all. What He wills as a consequence (because of what we do) is the just punishment of those who refuse Him. The cause of the second lies in us, not in Him. Lutheran theologians of the seventeenth century took up this distinction gladly, because it says in technical language what the Formula says in plain language.11
Ambrose of Milan taught that Christ brought the remedy of healing to all, so that whoever perishes must lay the cause of his death on himself, since he would not be healed when the cure was at hand.12 In the fifth century a whole book was written on this question, The Call of All Nations, which is usually attributed to Prosper of Aquitaine. Its author was a devoted disciple of Augustine, yet he insisted that 1 Timothy 2:4 must be taken at its word. He taught that God’s goodness has always been extended to all people in some measure, that the Gospel is now sent to all nations, and that God sincerely wills all to be saved. When he came to the question of why some are not saved, he declined to search the hidden judgments of God and was content to confess that the fault is never God’s.13
Augustine, honestly read
We must be honest about Augustine, because he is the father who wrestled with this text the hardest and did not always land in the same place. In his Enchiridion he asked directly how God can will all people to be saved “when, as a matter of fact, all are not saved.” His answer narrowed the text. He proposed that “all men” may mean “that no man is saved unless God wills his salvation,” or that it may mean “the human race in all its varieties of rank and circumstances,” so that God wills some from every class and nation to be saved.14 In On Rebuke and Grace he offered the same reading: “He wills all men to be saved, is so said that all the predestinated may be understood by it, because every kind of men is among them.”15
However, Augustine said other things as well. In an earlier work, On the Spirit and the Letter, he wrote: “God no doubt wishes all men to be saved and to come into the knowledge of the truth; but yet not so as to take away from them free will, for the good or the evil use of which they may be most righteously judged.” Unbelievers, he said, “do contrary to the will of God when they do not believe His gospel.”16 Even in On Rebuke and Grace he drew a pastoral conclusion that we can receive without reservation: “as far as concerns us, who are not able to distinguish those who are predestinated from those who are not, we ought on this very account to will all men to be saved.”17 Augustine’s restrictive readings are part of the record and we should not hide them. Yet the Church did not finally follow them on this point. The Call of All Nations softened them within a generation and the Lutheran Confessions plainly read 1 Timothy 2:4 and 2 Peter 3:9 as meaning all people without exception.
II. How God Saves: Through Means, Not by Force
God works through the Word and the Sacraments
If God wills the salvation of all, how does He go about it? Scripture answers that He saves through means. “How then will they call on him in whom they have not believed? And how are they to believe in him of whom they have never heard? And how are they to hear without someone preaching?” (Romans 10:14). “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:17). God does not ordinarily reach into a human heart from the sky. He sends a preacher, He pours water with His Word and He gives the body and blood of His Son into the mouth.
The Augsburg Confession puts this at the foundation of the Church’s ministry: “For through the Word and Sacraments, as through instruments, the Holy Ghost is given, who works faith; where and when it pleases God, in them that hear the Gospel.”18 Luther said the same thing with great force in the Smalcald Articles: “we ought and must constantly maintain this point, that God does not wish to deal with us otherwise than through the spoken Word and the Sacraments.”19 The Formula of Concord applies this directly to our question. “And by this means, and in no other way, namely, through His holy Word, when men hear it preached or read it, and the holy Sacraments when they are used according to His Word, God desires to call men to eternal salvation, draw them to Himself, and convert, regenerate, and sanctify them.”20
God’s will to save all is therefore not a vague wish. It takes the form of preaching, Baptism, absolution, and the Supper. When the Gospel is preached to a congregation, God is not acting out a script in which He secretly means something else. The Formula calls the Word “a ministration of the Spirit” and “a power of God unto salvation.”21
The call is serious
The Formula denies that God says one thing outwardly and means another inwardly. “And this call of God, which is made through the preaching of the Word, we should not regard as jugglery, but know that thereby God reveals His will, that in those whom He thus calls He will work through the Word, that they may be enlightened, converted, and saved.”21 The Formula then states the opposite view in order to reject it. It would be wrong to imagine God saying, “Outwardly, through the Word, I indeed call to My kingdom all of you to whom I give My Word; however, in My heart I do not mean this with respect to all, but only with respect to a few.” That, the Confession says, “would be to assign contradictory wills to God.” It would make God, “who surely is Eternal Truth,” contrary to Himself, although He rebukes this very dishonesty in us.22
Why does this matter so much? Because our comfort depends on it. The Formula ties it directly to absolution: we “teach that it is God’s command that we believe such absolution, and should regard it as sure that, when we believe the word of absolution, we are as truly reconciled to God as though we had heard a voice from heaven.” Then it adds: “This consolation would be entirely taken from us if we were not to infer the will of God towards us from the call which is made through the Word and through the Sacraments.”23 In other words, the seriousness of God’s universal call is the very ground on which each of us stands when we hear “I forgive you all your sins.”
The Spirit’s Work Through the Word Can Be Resisted
If God works through means, then it follows that the Holy Spirit’s work through the Word can in this life be resisted. Scripture says so plainly. Stephen told the council, “You stiff-necked people, uncircumcised in heart and ears, you always resist the Holy Spirit. As your fathers did, so do you” (Acts 7:51). The verb is antipiptō (“to fall against, to oppose, to resist”). Luke records that “the Pharisees and the lawyers rejected the purpose of God for themselves, not having been baptized by him” (Luke 7:30). The verb there is atheteō (“to set aside, to reject, to nullify”) and the object is tēn boulēn tou theou (“the counsel” or “purpose of God”).24 God had a purpose for these men. They set it aside. And we have already heard our Lord’s own words over Jerusalem: “How often would I have gathered your children together… and you were not willing!” (Matthew 23:37).
The Formula of Concord quotes this very verse when it explains why some perish. “But when such a person despises the instrument of the Holy Ghost, and will not hear, no injustice is done to him if the Holy Ghost does not enlighten him, but allows him to remain in the darkness of his unbelief and to perish; for regarding this matter it is written: How often would I have gathered thy children together, even as a hen gathereth her chickens under her wings; and ye would not!” It adds that “God does not force man to become godly (for those who always resist the Holy Ghost and persistently oppose the known truth, as Stephen says of the hardened Jews, Acts 7:51, are not converted).”25
Irenaeus of Lyons, writing in the second century, used the same verse to make the same point. Jesus’ words over Jerusalem, he said, “set forth the ancient law of human liberty,” for God made man to obey “voluntarily, and not by compulsion of God. For there is no coercion with God, but a good will [towards us] is present with Him continually.”26 Irenaeus was not writing about the bondage of the will as the Formula would later define it, and a Lutheran will want to say more than he does about our inability to turn ourselves. Yet on this one point he is right: God does not drag people into His kingdom against their will.
Resistible, yet not our work
At this point a careful reader will ask whether Lutherans have simply become Arminians. If the Spirit’s work can be resisted, then does not the person who does not resist deserve some credit? The Formula of Concord says no and it says it with equal force. On the one hand, the natural man cannot convert himself or even cooperate in his conversion. “Therefore it is teaching incorrectly to assert that unregenerate man has still so much power as to desire to receive the Gospel and to be comforted by it, and that thus the natural human will cooperates somewhat [in a manner] in conversion.”27 Conversion “is only and solely the work of God (just as also the resuscitation in the resurrection of the body must be ascribed to God alone).”28 The Formula even rejects the old saying “God draws, but He draws the willing,” because it makes the human will the deciding factor.29
On the other hand, the natural man is fully able to resist. The Formula says that a stone does not resist the one who moves it, whereas man before his conversion “is in this respect much worse than a stone and block; for he resists the Word and will of God, until God awakens him from the death of sin, enlightens and renews him.”30
How do these two belong together? The power to resist and the power to believe are not equal powers lying side by side in the human heart. We have the first by nature and the second only as a gift. Therefore if a sinner is saved, the whole credit belongs to God, and if he is lost, the whole fault is his own. Hosea 13:9 holds both sides in one verse. The ESV reads, “He destroys you, O Israel, for you are against me, against your helper” (Hosea 13:9). Israel’s ruin came because Israel set itself against the One who was its only help. The Formula quotes the older form of that verse as the “right [safe and royal] way” through this whole question: “O Israel, thou hast destroyed thyself; but in Me is thy help.”31
III. Why, Then, Are Some Lost?
The fault is ours, not God’s
We are now in a position to answer the question in the title. Why does God not save everyone? The Formula of Concord gives a direct answer and it is worth hearing in full. “But the reason why not all who hear it believe, and some are therefore condemned the more deeply, is not because God had begrudged them their salvation; but it is their own fault, as they have heard the Word in such a manner as not to learn, but only to despise, blaspheme, and disgrace it, and have resisted the Holy Ghost, who through the Word wished to work in them.”32
The Formula then takes up Romans 9, the chapter most often used to argue that God wills the damnation of some. Paul says that God “has endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (Romans 9:22), and the Formula observes that if God had made them vessels of wrath He would have needed no patience with them. Then it states the principle: “For all preparation for condemnation is by the devil and man, through sin, and in no respect by God, who does not wish that any man be damned; For as God is not a cause of sins, so, too, He is no cause of punishment, of damnation; but the only cause of damnation is sin.”33
What about Pharaoh, whose heart God hardened? The Formula answers that Pharaoh “perished, not because God had begrudged him salvation, or because it had been His good pleasure that he should be damned and lost. For God is not willing that any should perish, 2 Pet. 3:9.” The hardening was a just judgment on a man who had heard God’s Word and set himself against it again and again, so that at last God withdrew His hand from him.34 The Epitome says the same about the many who are called and the few who are chosen (Matthew 22:14). This “does not mean that God is not willing to save everybody”; rather, they “wilfully despise” His Word, “stop their ears and harden their hearts, and in this manner foreclose the ordinary way to the Holy Ghost.”35
The ancient Church said the same. The Second Council of Orange (529), which affirmed Augustine’s teaching on grace against those who credited the human will with the beginning of faith, nevertheless refused to follow anyone who taught that God predestines people to evil. Its conclusion declares that it does not believe any are foreordained to evil by the power of God, and that anyone who would believe so evil a thing is anathema.36
Judgment as the refusal of the Gospel
This changes how we ought to think about hell. Hell is not a place God built because He wanted to fill it. Our Lord says the eternal fire was “prepared for the devil and his angels” (Matthew 25:41), not for human beings. John explains the judgment in the same chapter that gives us John 3:16. “Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only Son of God. And this is the judgment: the light has come into the world, and people loved the darkness rather than the light because their works were evil” (John 3:18–19). In other words, the judgment is not that God withheld the light, but that the light came and was refused.
This does not make hell any less real or any less terrible. Jesus speaks of “eternal punishment” (Matthew 25:46) and Paul writes of “the punishment of eternal destruction” for “those who do not know God and on those who do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus” (2 Thessalonians 1:8–9). Yet the lost are not lost because God’s love failed or because Christ’s blood did not reach them, but because they would not have the One who came for them. C. S. Lewis, who was an Anglican and no Reformer, put the same thought in a well-known line: there are in the end only two kinds of people, those who say to God, “Thy will be done,” and those to whom God says, in the end, “Thy will be done.”37 The first half needs a Lutheran correction (no one says “Thy will be done” unless the Holy Spirit has taught him), yet the second half is true to John 3:19.
Why one and not another?
Someone will press further. If two people hear the same sermon, and both are equally dead in sin, and one believes while the other does not, why? If the believer cannot take credit and the unbeliever is equally guilty, why was one converted and not the other? Here the Formula of Concord stops. It names this as the place where we must lay our finger on our lips. “Likewise, when we see that God gives His Word at one place, but not at another; removes it from one place, and allows it to remain at another; also, that one is hardened, blinded, given over to a reprobate mind, while another, who is indeed in the same guilt, is converted again, etc.,—in these and similar questions Paul fixes a certain limit to us how far we should go.” On the one side we see God’s judgment, which is what all of us deserve. On the other side we see God’s pure and unmerited grace. Beyond that, the Formula says, we should “with Paul, place the finger upon our lips, and remember and say, Rom. 9:20: O man, who art thou that repliest against God?”38
This is the crux theologorum, and Grace Alone and the Lost treats it at length. For our purpose it is enough to say that the Lutheran Church does not solve the mystery by sacrificing any of the texts. Salvation is entirely God’s work and damnation is entirely man’s fault. Both are taught in Scripture. Reason cannot harmonize them and the Formula frankly admits that God has not commanded us to do so.38
IV. Three Other Answers
Before we go further, it is only fair to hear the other answers Christians have given. Each deserves a careful and charitable hearing.
The universalist answer
The first answer is that God’s will cannot finally be frustrated, so in the end all will be saved. The great early representative of this view is Origen of Alexandria (c. 185–254). In On First Principles he speculated that the end will be like the beginning, and that all rational creatures, perhaps even the devil, will at last be restored to God through long ages of purifying discipline. The Greek word for this restoration is apokatastasis (“restoration, re-establishment”), borrowed from Acts 3:21. Gregory of Nyssa, one of the great defenders of the Trinity, also hoped that the fire of judgment would in the end purify all and that evil would be wholly abolished.39 We should not caricature these men. They were moved by a sincere conviction that God’s love is stronger than human sin.
However, the Church did not accept their conclusion. The Emperor Justinian’s edict against Origen (543) included this anathema: “If anyone says or thinks that the punishment of demons and of impious men is only temporary, and will one day have an end, and that a restoration (apokatastasis) will take place of demons and of impious men, let him be anathema.” The anathemas against Origen associated with the Fifth Ecumenical Council (553) likewise condemned “the monstrous restoration” that Origen’s system implied.40 The Augsburg Confession stands in the same line. In the article on Christ’s return to judgment it says: “They condemn the Anabaptists, who think that there will be an end to the punishments of condemned men and devils.”41
A gentler form of this view appeared in the twentieth century. Karl Barth, the great Reformed theologian, taught that in Jesus Christ God has elected all humanity and that Christ is both the elect and the rejected one in our place. Barth would not teach universal salvation as a doctrine but he refused to rule it out and left the door open as a hope. The Roman Catholic theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar went further in his little book Dare We Hope “That All Men Be Saved”? He argued that while we cannot know that all will be saved, we are permitted and even obliged to hope it.42
How should we answer? First, the universalist texts usually offered (Romans 5:18; 1 Corinthians 15:22; Colossians 1:20; Philippians 2:10–11) speak of what Christ has accomplished for all and of the universal acknowledgment of His lordship on the Last Day. They do not teach that every person will believe and be saved. Second, Jesus Himself speaks of eternal punishment in the same breath as eternal life (Matthew 25:46) and says “whoever does not believe will be condemned” (Mark 16:16). Third, and most important for our question, universalism solves the problem by quietly abolishing the means. If all will be saved whether or not they hear the Word, then the Word and Sacraments are not the means of salvation after all and the urgency of the apostles becomes hard to understand. We can and should pray for all people (1 Timothy 2:1), yet we may not preach as a hope what Christ Himself did not promise.
The Calvinist answer
The second answer comes from our Reformed brothers and sisters and it is the opposite of the first. It keeps God’s sovereignty and the reality of the lost, and it reads the universal texts more narrowly. John Calvin, in his commentary on 1 Timothy, wrote that “the present discourse relates to classes of men, and not to individual persons,” and that “the Apostle simply means, that there is no people and no rank in the world that is excluded from salvation.” He added that although God’s will should not be judged from His secret decrees, “it does not therefore follow that he has not determined with himself what he intends to do as to every individual man.”43 The Synod of Dort (1618–1619) gave this view confessional form. It affirmed that Christ’s death is of infinite worth and sufficient for the whole world, yet it taught that God’s will was that Christ “should effectively redeem from every people, tribe, nation, and language all those and only those who were chosen from eternity to salvation.”44
We should be fair here. Calvin and Dort did not teach that God is indifferent to the lost. Dort explicitly said that the promise of the Gospel “ought to be announced and declared without differentiation or discrimination to all nations and people.” It also said that those who perish in unbelief do so “not because the sacrifice of Christ offered on the cross is deficient or insufficient, but because they themselves are at fault.”45 On that last point Lutherans and the Reformed agree. The Reformed reading of “all people” as “all kinds of people” also has a real basis in Augustine.
However, the Lutheran Confessions cannot accept it, for the reason we heard in Section II. If God calls all people outwardly through the Word but wills in His heart to save only some, then God has two contradictory wills and the outward call cannot be trusted. That is the very teaching the Formula rejects when it refuses to “assign contradictory wills to God.”22 Furthermore, the texts themselves resist the narrowing. “The sins of the whole world” in 1 John 2:2 is set in deliberate contrast to “our sins.” Ezekiel’s “I have no pleasure in the death of anyone” (Ezekiel 18:32) is addressed to individual sinners, not to classes. And our Lord’s tears over Jerusalem were shed over the very people who would reject Him.
The Arminian answer
The third answer arose within the Reformed churches themselves. Jacob Arminius (1560–1609) and his followers, the Remonstrants, objected to the doctrine that would later be confessed at Dort. In their Five Articles of 1610 they taught that Christ died for all people and for every person, obtaining forgiveness for all, though only believers actually enjoy it. They also taught that the grace of God is necessary for every good thing, yet that this grace is not irresistible. Rome had taught something similar at the Council of Trent, which said that a sinner is moved by God’s prevenient grace and may either assent to it and cooperate with it or reject it.46
Lutherans share a great deal with this answer. With the Arminians we confess that God wills the salvation of all, that Christ died for all, and that the Holy Spirit working through the Word can be resisted. However, the difference is real and it touches the heart of the Gospel. In the Arminian account (and in Trent’s), the human will, once assisted by grace, makes the final decision. Two people receive the same grace and the difference between them lies in what each one does with it. The Formula of Concord rejects exactly this when it rejects the teaching that “also in us there is a cause of God’s election, on account of which God has elected us to everlasting life.”47 It also refuses to say that “the natural human will cooperates somewhat” in conversion.27 For a Lutheran, everything good in our salvation, including the very willingness to receive it, is God’s gift. “For it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Philippians 2:13). In other words, the Arminian answer keeps the universal will of God and the reality of the lost but it pays for this by giving the believer a share of the credit.
V. The Hidden God and the Revealed God
What God has kept to Himself
Why do the Confessions refuse to go further? Because Scripture itself tells us not to. “The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things that are revealed belong to us and to our children forever” (Deuteronomy 29:29). Paul, after three chapters wrestling with the unbelief of Israel, ends not with an explanation but with a doxology: “Oh, the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments and how inscrutable his ways!” (Romans 11:33).
In The Bondage of the Will (1525), answering Erasmus’s use of Ezekiel 18:23, Luther distinguished between “God preached” and “God not preached,” that is, between God as He has revealed Himself in His Word and God as He is hidden in His majesty. We are to deal with God as He has clothed Himself in His Word and offered Himself to us. We are to leave God hidden in His majesty to Himself, because He has not willed that we should have dealings with Him there. The God who is preached, Luther said, desires that all should be saved, since He comes to all with the word of salvation. Of the hidden God we know only that He is just and that His ways are beyond us.48
Then Luther turned to Matthew 23:37. It belongs to God incarnate, he said, to weep and lament over the perdition of the ungodly, for the incarnate Son was sent to will, speak, do, suffer, and offer to all people everything necessary for salvation. Luther did not try to reconcile these tears with the hidden majesty of God, nor would he let the hidden God cancel what the revealed God has said.49 The Formula of Concord commends The Bondage of the Will by name and reads it together with Luther’s later exposition of Genesis, especially of chapter 26. Written half a century later, the Formula keeps his essential point and makes plain that God does not secretly will the damnation of anyone. It distinguishes God’s foreknowledge, which “extends over all creatures, good and bad,” from His election, which is “a cause which procures, works, helps, and promotes our salvation.” God foresees evil, but “the beginning and cause of evil is not God’s foreknowledge … but the wicked, perverse will of the devil and of men.”50
Where to look for God’s will
The practical result of this teaching is that we must never try to read God’s will toward us from the hidden places. The Formula warns against picturing election as though God “only held a [sort of military] muster, thus: ‘This one shall be saved, that one shall be damned.’” Such thinking leads either to carelessness or to despair. Instead, the Formula says, “we should accustom ourselves not to speculate concerning the bare, secret, concealed, inscrutable foreknowledge of God, but how the counsel, purpose, and ordination of God in Christ Jesus, who is the true Book of Life, is revealed to us through the Word.”51
The Formula recalls Luther’s counsel from his preface to Romans: concern yourself first with Christ and His Gospel and with the struggle against sin (chapters 1–8), and only after you have been tried under the cross will chapters 9–11 teach you “how consolatory predestination is.” When someone asked Jesus, “Lord, will those who are saved be few?” He did not answer the question but said, “Strive to enter through the narrow door” (Luke 13:23–24). The Formula cites this exchange as our model.52 Yet the one who is anxious should hear where that door is. Jesus says, “I am the door. If anyone enters by me, he will be saved” (John 10:9) and He keeps that door open in the Word and the Sacraments. To strive to enter is to come where He has promised to be found.
In other words, if we want to know what God wills toward us, we do not climb into the hidden counsel of God. We look to the cross and the empty tomb, and we listen for Him where He has promised to be found: in the sermon, at the font, and at the altar. There God has told us plainly what He wills and He has sworn by His own life that He has no pleasure in our death.
VI. The Love That Does Not Coerce
Why God does not simply force the matter
Someone may still ask why an almighty God does not simply override every resisting will and bring all people in. Scripture does not tell us why God does not convert all and we will not guess. It tells us how He does convert: through a Word that calls, invites, and pleads, by which He makes the unwilling willing. Scripture describes His work in the human heart with words of drawing and calling: “I led them with cords of kindness, with the bands of love” (Hosea 11:4).
This does not mean God is weak. The conversion of a sinner is as much God’s work as the resurrection of the body.28 God has bound Himself to work this miracle through the Word, and those whom He converts are not forced. The Formula says the Holy Spirit’s work in the converted is “not a coactio, or coercion,” for “the converted man does good spontaneously, as David says, Ps. 110:4 [110:3 in English Bibles]: Thy people shall be willing in the day of Thy power.” God does not drag the will but renews it, turning “stubborn and unwilling into willing men through the drawing of the Holy Ghost.”53
The love that does not coerce is also a patient love. Paul asks the self-righteous man, “Or do you presume on the riches of his kindness and forbearance and patience, not knowing that God’s kindness is meant to lead you to repentance?” (Romans 2:4). Then he quotes Isaiah to describe the posture of God toward a rebellious world: “All day long I have held out my hands to a disobedient and contrary people” (Romans 10:21).
However, patience has an end. “Behold, now is the favorable time; behold, now is the day of salvation” (2 Corinthians 6:2). The Formula warns that God may finally withdraw His hand from those who harden themselves against Him, as He did with Pharaoh.34 In other words, the Law tells the secure sinner that he may not treat God’s patience as permission, and the Gospel tells the frightened sinner that God’s patience is still extended to him today. Anyone who is afraid that he has been hardened shows by that very fear that the Spirit is still calling him. Pharaoh never worried that he had been hardened.
What This Means for Us
The urgency of the mission
If God wills all people to be saved, and if He saves them through the Word, then the Church’s mission is not optional, since it is the very form God’s universal will takes in the world. “How are they to hear without someone preaching?” (Romans 10:14). Our Lord sent His apostles to “make disciples of all nations” (Matthew 28:19). Paul described his own ministry this way: “Therefore, we are ambassadors for Christ, God making his appeal through us. We implore you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God” (2 Corinthians 5:20).
The Formula of Concord draws the same conclusion. Since God has not told us when He will convert any particular person, “we have the command always to keep urging the Word, but to entrust the time and hour [of conversion] to God.”54 We do not know who belongs to God’s elect and we are not asked to know. We are asked to pray and to speak. Chrysostom told his congregation to imitate God by willing what God wills and praying for all people.9 Augustine told his readers that because we cannot tell the predestined from the rest, “we ought on this very account to will all men to be saved.”17 Paul himself begins 1 Timothy 2 not with a doctrine but with a command: “First of all, then, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people” (1 Timothy 2:1).
This should shape our life as a congregation. Every person who walks through our doors, and every neighbor who has no interest in the Church, is someone for whom Christ died. Our prayers for the world in the Divine Service are therefore not a formality, and our support of missions, our hospitality to visitors, and our willingness to speak a word about Christ to a friend are part of how God carries out His will. Yet we do not need to manipulate or pressure anyone. We speak the Word, we pray, and we leave the outcome to the Holy Spirit, who works “where and when it pleases God, in them that hear the Gospel.”18
This brings us back to the family at the grave of someone who wanted nothing to do with the Church. We do not see the heart and we do not pronounce on any particular person. God willed that man’s salvation as truly as He wills ours, and Christ died for him. We do not know what the Spirit did through a word heard long ago or in a last hour. We commend him to the mercy of God in Christ and the family need not carry the weight of a faith that only the Holy Spirit can give.
The assurance that God’s will toward you is good
Lastly, this doctrine is meant to comfort us. Some Christians lie awake wondering whether they are among the elect. They look at their weak faith and their stubborn sins and they ask whether God has secretly passed them by. The Formula says that troubled consciences should not “trouble or harass” themselves “with thoughts concerning the secret counsel of God, as to whether he also is elected and ordained to eternal life, with which miserable Satan usually attacks and annoys godly hearts.” Instead, they “should hear Christ,” who “testifies to all men without distinction that it is God’s will that all men should come to Him who labor and are heavy laden with sin, in order that He may give them rest and save them.”55
What, then, is God’s will toward you? He has told you. He wants you to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth (1 Timothy 2:4). He has no pleasure in your death (Ezekiel 33:11). He gave His Son for the sins of the whole world, and you are part of that world (1 John 2:2). He has promised that “whoever comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6:37). He put His name on you in Baptism. He speaks His forgiveness to you in the absolution, and the Formula tells us to believe that word “as though we had heard a voice from heaven.”23 He places the body and blood of His Son into your mouth “for the forgiveness of sins.” As the Formula says, His call is not jugglery but the revealed will of God for you.
The Formula says that this doctrine “gives the most enduring consolation to all troubled, afflicted men, that they know that their salvation is not placed in their own hands … but in the gracious election of God, which He has revealed to us in Christ, out of whose hand no man shall pluck us, John 10:28.”56 We cannot answer every question about why some refuse the Gospel, and we are not asked to. God wills all people to be saved, God has done everything necessary for their salvation in Christ, and God has come to us in His Word and Sacraments with that salvation in His hands. Therefore we hear the Word gladly, we receive the Sacraments often, we pray for all people, and we tell our neighbors what God has done. And when the hidden things trouble us, we turn again to the revealed God, the Lord Jesus, who wept over Jerusalem and who still says to every weary sinner, “Come to me… and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28).
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text as published at bookofconcord.org.)
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Augsburg Confession V and XVII; Smalcald Articles III.viii; Formula of Concord, Epitome XI and Solid Declaration II and XI.)
The Early Church
- Irenaeus. Against Heresies. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Origen. On First Principles. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4.
- Gregory of Nyssa. The Great Catechism. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 5.
- Ambrose. On Cain and Abel. In Hexameron, Paradise, and Cain and Abel. Translated by John J. Savage. Fathers of the Church 42. New York: Fathers of the Church, 1961.
- John Chrysostom. Homilies on First Timothy. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 13.
- Augustine. Enchiridion. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 3.
- Augustine. On the Spirit and the Letter and On Rebuke and Grace. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 5.
- Prosper of Aquitaine (attributed). The Call of All Nations. Translated by P. De Letter. Ancient Christian Writers 14. Westminster, MD: Newman Press, 1952.
- Second Council of Orange (529). Canons and Conclusion.
- Second Council of Constantinople (553), with the Anathemas against Origen. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 14.
- John of Damascus. An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 9.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. The Bondage of the Will. Luther’s Works, vol. 33. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1972.
- Luther, Martin. Preface to the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans. Luther’s Works, vol. 35. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1960.
- Calvin, John. Commentaries on the Epistles to Timothy, Titus, and Philemon. Translated by William Pringle. Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1856.
- Canons of the Synod of Dort (1618–1619).
- The Five Articles of the Remonstrants (1610). In Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3. New York: Harper, 1877.
- Council of Trent. Decree on Justification (Session VI, 1547).
- Gerhard, Johann. Theological Commonplaces: On Election and Reprobation. Translated by Richard J. Dinda. St. Louis: Concordia.
- Schmid, Heinrich. The Doctrinal Theology of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Translated by C. A. Hay and H. E. Jacobs. Philadelphia: United Lutheran Publication House, 1899.
Later Theology
- Barth, Karl. Church Dogmatics II/2. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1957.
- Lewis, C. S. The Great Divorce. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1946.
- von Balthasar, Hans Urs. Dare We Hope “That All Men Be Saved”? San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1988.
Reference
- Brown, Francis, S. R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs. A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament. Oxford: Clarendon, 1906.
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
Footnotes
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. thelō and boulomai. Thayer discusses at length the relation of the two verbs; for our purpose it is enough that both describe what God purposes and desires. ↩
-
Francis Brown, S. R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (Oxford: Clarendon, 1906), s.v. chaphets. ↩
-
Thayer, Lexicon, s.v. hilasmos. ↩
-
FC SD XI 28. ↩
-
FC Ep XI 8. ↩
-
FC SD II 49, citing Ezekiel 33:11 and John 3:16. ↩
-
FC Ep XI 17–19, 21. ↩
-
Heinrich Schmid, The Doctrinal Theology of the Evangelical Lutheran Church, trans. C. A. Hay and H. E. Jacobs (Philadelphia: United Lutheran Publication House, 1899), on the gracious will of God and the universality of grace. Compare Johann Gerhard, Theological Commonplaces: On Election and Reprobation, trans. Richard J. Dinda (St. Louis: Concordia). ↩
-
John Chrysostom, Homilies on First Timothy, Homily 7 (on 1 Timothy 2:2–4), NPNF¹, vol. 13. ↩ ↩2
-
John of Damascus, An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith II.29, NPNF², vol. 9. ↩
-
Schmid, Doctrinal Theology, on the antecedent and consequent will of God. Thomas Aquinas had already taken up the same distinction from the Damascene in the Western Church (Summa Theologiae I, q. 19, a. 6, ad 1). ↩
-
Ambrose, On Cain and Abel, book II. Paraphrased. ↩
-
Prosper of Aquitaine (attributed), The Call of All Nations, especially book II, trans. P. De Letter, Ancient Christian Writers 14 (Westminster, MD: Newman Press, 1952). Paraphrased. ↩
-
Augustine, Enchiridion 97, 103, NPNF¹, vol. 3. ↩
-
Augustine, On Rebuke and Grace 44, NPNF¹, vol. 5. ↩
-
Augustine, On the Spirit and the Letter 58, NPNF¹, vol. 5. ↩
-
Augustine, On Rebuke and Grace 49, NPNF¹, vol. 5. Compare 46–47. ↩ ↩2
-
SA III.viii.10. Compare SA III.viii.3. ↩
-
FC SD II 50. ↩
-
Thayer, Lexicon, s.v. antipiptō and atheteō. ↩
-
FC SD II 58, 60. Compare SD XI 41, which cites the same verse. ↩
-
Irenaeus, Against Heresies IV.37.1, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
FC SD II 86. ↩
-
FC SD II 59. ↩
-
FC SD XI 62. Compare FC SD XI 7. ↩
-
FC SD XI 78. ↩
-
FC SD XI 79–81, citing Romans 9:22–23, Romans 6:23, Ezekiel 33:11, and 2 Peter 3:9. ↩
-
FC Ep XI 12. ↩
-
Second Council of Orange (529), Conclusion. Paraphrased from the conciliar text. ↩
-
C. S. Lewis, The Great Divorce (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1946), ch. 9. ↩
-
Origen, On First Principles I.6.1–3; III.6.5–6, ANF, vol. 4; Gregory of Nyssa, The Great Catechism 26, NPNF², vol. 5. ↩
-
“The Anathemas of the Emperor Justinian against Origen,” anathema 9; “The Anathemas against Origen,” anathema 1, in NPNF², vol. 14 (the documents of the Second Council of Constantinople, 553). Historians debate whether the fifteen anathemas were formally adopted in the council’s sessions or in a meeting just before it; either way, the Church’s rejection of the apokatastasis dates from this period. ↩
-
AC XVII 4. ↩
-
Karl Barth, Church Dogmatics II/2, The Doctrine of God, trans. G. W. Bromiley et al. (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1957); compare Church Dogmatics IV/3. Hans Urs von Balthasar, Dare We Hope “That All Men Be Saved”?, trans. David Kipp and Lothar Krauth (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1988). ↩
-
John Calvin, Commentaries on the Epistles to Timothy, Titus, and Philemon, trans. William Pringle (Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1856), on 1 Timothy 2:4. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Second Head of Doctrine, Articles 3 and 8. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Second Head of Doctrine, Articles 5 and 6. ↩
-
The Five Articles of the Remonstrants (1610), Articles II and IV, in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3 (New York: Harper, 1877); Council of Trent, Session VI, Decree on Justification, chapter 5 and canon 4. Both paraphrased. ↩
-
FC Ep XI 20; compare SD XI 88. ↩
-
Luther, The Bondage of the Will (1525), LW 33:138–140, on Ezekiel 18:23. Paraphrased; the phrases “God preached” and “God not preached” are Luther’s own terms in the American Edition. ↩
-
LW 33:145–146, on Matthew 23:37. Paraphrased. ↩
-
FC SD II 44; SD XI 4, 7–8. Compare Ep XI 2–4. ↩
-
FC SD XI 9, 13. ↩
-
FC SD XI 33, citing Luther’s Preface to the Epistle to the Romans (1522), LW 35, and Luke 13:23–24. ↩
-
FC SD II 64, 88. ↩
-
FC SD XI 56. ↩
-
FC SD XI 70. ↩
-
FC SD XI 90. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “God Wills All to Be Saved: Why, Then, Are Not All Saved?.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/god-wills-all-to-be-saved/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.