Baptism and Falling Away
Why the Baptized Can Lose the Faith
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ.” — 1 Peter 3:21
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. The Babylonian Captivity of the Church is quoted in the Steinhaeuser translation of the Philadelphia Edition, and the Council of Trent in Waterworth’s.
The Question Before Us
If Baptism saves, why do baptized people fall away from the faith? Every pastor hears this question and he usually hears it from someone who is not asking for the sake of argument. A mother asks it about a son who was carried to the font as an infant, confirmed, and now says he does not believe any of it. A thoughtful member asks it after reading Hebrews 6 for the first time. A Baptist friend asks it as an objection to the whole Lutheran teaching on Baptism: “You say Baptism regenerates. Then explain the people who were baptized and live and die as unbelievers.”
The question deserves an honest answer because it has real force. We confess with the Small Catechism that Baptism “works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation.”1 Yet we all know baptized people who have walked away. It seems that something must give. Either Baptism does not really save, or those who fall away were never really saved by it, or the salvation it gives can be lost and must then be won back in some other way. Each of these answers has been given by a large and serious body of Christians. The Baptist says the first. The Reformed say the second. Rome says the third. What do we say, and why?
In this paper I want to take up five questions in order:
- Does Baptism really save?
- Does Scripture really teach that the baptized can fall away?
- How can both be true at once?
- How have other Christians answered the question, and where do we agree and differ?
- Is there a way back for the one who has fallen, and what is it?
At each step we will listen first to Holy Scripture, then to the Lutheran Confessions, and then to the fathers of the early Church and the Reformers who help us hear Scripture rightly. We will close with what this means for us, and especially for parents whose children have wandered.
I. Does Baptism Really Save?
The words themselves
The Greek verb baptizō means “to dip, to immerse, to wash.” In the New Testament it is used of ordinary ceremonial washings (Mark 7:4; Luke 11:38) as well as of the Sacrament the Lord instituted.2 The word does not by itself settle what Baptism does. For that we have to listen to what God says He does through it.
Titus 3:5 calls Baptism loutron palingenesias. A loutron is a “bath” or “washing,” and palingenesia means “new birth, regeneration,” literally a “being born again.” The same word palingenesia is used in Matthew 19:28 of the renewal of all things at the end of the age. In other words, Paul uses for Baptism the word the Lord used for the new creation. Peter, for his part, calls Baptism the antitypos of the flood (1 Peter 3:21), the thing that corresponds to the type and fulfills it.3 Noah and his family were “brought safely through water,” and Peter says that Baptism, “which corresponds to this, now saves you.”
What Scripture says
The New Testament speaks of Baptism with a directness that surprises many modern Christians. “Baptism … now saves you” (1 Peter 3:21). “He saved us … by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off” (Acts 2:38–39). “Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved” (Mark 16:16). “Unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God” (John 3:5). “As many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Galatians 3:27).
Paul gives the deepest account of it in Romans 6. “Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:3–4). Baptism joins us to the death and resurrection of Christ. What happened to Him on Good Friday and Easter morning is given to us at the font. Paul says the same in Colossians 2:12: we were “buried with him in baptism, in which you were also raised with him through faith in the powerful working of God.”
None of these texts treats Baptism as a symbol of something that happened somewhere else. Each one says that God does something in it: He saves, washes, regenerates, forgives, gives the Spirit, puts Christ on us, and buries and raises us with Him.
What the Confessions say
Our Confessions say what Scripture says. The Augsburg Confession teaches that Baptism “is necessary to salvation, and that through Baptism is offered the grace of God, and that children are to be baptized who, being offered to God through Baptism are received into God’s grace.” The Small Catechism asks, “What does Baptism give or profit?” and answers: “It works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this, as the words and promises of God declare.”4
Luther’s Large Catechism is even plainer. “Therefore state it most simply thus, that the power, work, profit, fruit, and end of Baptism is this, namely, to save. For no one is baptized in order that he may become a prince, but, as the words declare, that he be saved.” A little later he lists what Baptism brings: “victory over death and the devil, forgiveness of sin, the grace of God, the entire Christ, and the Holy Ghost with His gifts.” Luther then draws the comfort that every baptized Christian is meant to draw from this: “when our sins and conscience oppress us, we strengthen ourselves and take comfort and say: Nevertheless I am baptized; but if I am baptized, it is promised me that I shall be saved and have eternal life, both in soul and body.”5
The Confessions also make clear why this is not salvation by a human work. “Baptism … is not our work, but God’s,” says the Large Catechism. We do not save ourselves by getting wet. God saves us by His Word joined to the water. That is why the Small Catechism says that “it is not the water indeed that does them, but the word of God which is in and with the water, and faith, which trusts such word of God in the water.”6 It names both the giving and the receiving.
The witness of the early Church
The early Church spoke of Baptism the same way. Around the year 200 Tertullian wrote the first treatise we have on the subject. Against a teacher who scorned the font, he wrote: “But we, little fishes, after the example of our ΙΧΘΥΣ Jesus Christ, are born in water, nor have we safety in any other way than by permanently abiding in water.”7 (The Greek word ichthys, “fish,” was an early Christian acrostic for “Jesus Christ, God’s Son, Savior.”) Christians, he says, are born in the water and they are safe only by remaining in it. He already saw that the question was not only whether we had been baptized, but whether we abide in what Baptism gave.
In the fourth century Cyril of Jerusalem explained the rite to the newly baptized in the week after Easter. He told them that when they went down into the water three times and came up again, they were being joined to the three days of Christ in the tomb. “We did not really die, we were not really buried, we were not really crucified and raised again; but our imitation was in a figure, and our salvation in reality.”8
Therefore the first answer to our question is clear. Baptism does save, and any answer to the falling away of the baptized that requires us to say Baptism does not really do what Scripture says it does must be set aside.
II. Do the Baptized Really Fall Away?
The words themselves
Webster defines apostasy as “an abandonment of what one has professed; a total desertion, or departure from one’s faith or religion.” The New Testament uses several words for it and each paints a slightly different picture. In Luke 8:13 the verb is aphistēmi, “to stand away from, to withdraw, to fall away.” It is the root of our word apostasy.9 In Hebrews 6:6 the word is parapiptō, “to fall beside, to fall away.” In Galatians 5:4 Paul uses ekpiptō, “to fall out of, to lose one’s hold on”: “you have fallen away from grace.” In 1 Timothy 1:19 he uses nauageō, “to suffer shipwreck.” Each describes a person who was standing in a place and is no longer standing there, which is more than a stumble.
What Scripture says
The Lord Himself teaches it in the parable of the sower. “The ones on the rock are those who, when they hear the word, receive it with joy. But these have no root; they believe for a while, and in time of testing fall away” (Luke 8:13). The Lord does not say that they pretended to believe. He says that they believed, and that they believed for a while. Their faith was real and it did not last.
Paul warns the Corinthians with the history of Israel. “Our fathers were all under the cloud, and all passed through the sea, and all were baptized into Moses in the cloud and in the sea, and all ate the same spiritual food, and all drank the same spiritual drink. For they drank from the spiritual Rock that followed them, and the Rock was Christ. Nevertheless, with most of them God was not pleased, for they were overthrown in the wilderness” (1 Corinthians 10:1–5). Paul uses the language of both Sacraments here: a baptism and a spiritual meal. He is speaking to baptized people who receive the Lord’s Supper, and he tells them that Israel had its own baptism and its own meal and still perished in the desert. Then comes the application: “Now these things happened to them as an example, but they were written down for our instruction. … Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (1 Corinthians 10:11–12).
The letter to the Hebrews speaks most severely. “It is impossible, in the case of those who have once been enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift, and have shared in the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, and then have fallen away, to restore them again to repentance, since they are crucifying once again the Son of God to their own harm and holding him up to contempt” (Hebrews 6:4–6). The early Church commonly heard “once been enlightened” as a reference to Baptism, which was called “enlightenment.”10 Whatever else this passage means, it describes people who had received real gifts from God and then turned their backs on them. The same letter warns, “Take care, brothers, lest there be in any of you an evil, unbelieving heart, leading you to fall away from the living God. … For we have come to share in Christ, if indeed we hold our original confidence firm to the end” (Hebrews 3:12, 14).
Paul writes to the Galatians, who had been baptized into Christ (Galatians 3:27) and were now being persuaded that they must also be circumcised to be saved: “You are severed from Christ, you who would be justified by the law; you have fallen away from grace” (Galatians 5:4). He tells Timothy to keep “holding faith and a good conscience. By rejecting this, some have made shipwreck of their faith, among whom are Hymenaeus and Alexander” (1 Timothy 1:19–20). Peter speaks of those who “have escaped the defilements of the world through the knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ” and “are again entangled in them and overcome.” Of them he says, “the last state has become worse for them than the first,” and he applies the hard proverb: “the sow, after washing herself, returns to wallow in the mire” (2 Peter 2:20, 22).
The Book of Acts gives us a baptized man by name. “Even Simon himself believed, and after being baptized he continued with Philip” (Acts 8:13). Yet a few verses later Peter tells him, “You have neither part nor lot in this matter, for your heart is not right before God. Repent, therefore, of this wickedness of yours, and pray to the Lord that, if possible, the intent of your heart may be forgiven you” (Acts 8:21–22).
The witness of the early Church
The early Church did not need to be persuaded of this. It lived through it. In the persecution under the emperor Decius in A.D. 250, many baptized Christians in North Africa offered sacrifice to the gods or bought certificates saying they had done so. Cyprian, bishop of Carthage, wrote his treatise On the Lapsed when the persecution ended. He rejoiced over the confessors who had stood firm and then he turned to those who had fallen: “the hostile violence has torn away a part of our own bowels.” He wrote as a pastor, not as a judge: “I grieve, brethren, I grieve with you … since it is the shepherd that is chiefly wounded in the wound of his flock.”11
Cyril of Jerusalem used Simon Magus as a warning to those preparing for Baptism. “Even Simon Magus once came to the Laver: he was baptized, but was not enlightened; and though he dipped his body in water, he enlightened not his heart with the Spirit.”12 Cyril’s point is that Simon came to the font with a heart that did not receive what was given there, not that Baptism failed.
Therefore the second answer is just as clear as the first. Baptized people can and do fall away. Scripture does not hide it and the early Church did not deny it.
III. How Can Both Be True?
We now have two things that Scripture teaches plainly. Baptism saves. The baptized can fall away. How do they fit together?
Baptism gives what it promises, and faith receives it
The answer begins with the sentence from the Small Catechism we have already quoted: it is “the word of God which is in and with the water, and faith, which trusts such word of God in the water.”13 Baptism is God’s Word of promise joined to water. A promise is given in order to be believed. It gives what it says, and faith is the hand that receives it.
The Lord’s own words in Mark 16:16 show this. “Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved, but whoever does not believe will be condemned.” The Lord does not say “whoever is not baptized” in the second half of the verse, but “whoever does not believe.” The Large Catechism draws the conclusion: “faith alone makes the person worthy to receive profitably the saving, divine water. For, since these blessings are here presented and promised in the words in and with the water, they cannot be received in any other way than by believing them with the heart. Without faith it profits nothing, notwithstanding it is in itself a divine superabundant treasure.”14
Luther is careful here and we should be careful too, because faith does not make Baptism what it is. “My faith does not make Baptism, but receives it.” Baptism is God’s work, complete and valid because God’s Word is in it, whether or not the one baptized believes. Luther uses a plain illustration: “gold is not the less gold though a harlot wear it in sin and shame.” However, a gift that is real can still be refused, and a treasure that is genuine can still be thrown away. “The treasure is not wanting,” Luther says, “but this is wanting that men apprehend it and hold it firmly.”15
What remains and what is lost
This is the heart of the matter. When a baptized person falls away, what is lost? The Lutheran answer is that faith is lost, and with faith everything faith had received. What is not lost is Baptism itself, because Baptism belongs to God and not to us.
Augustine saw this clearly in his controversy with the Donatists. He pointed out that when someone who had abandoned the faith returned to the Church, no one baptized him again. “No one of the Donatists themselves denies that even apostates retain the grace of baptism; for when they return within the pale of the Church, and are converted through repentance, it is never given to them a second time, and so it is ruled that it never could have been lost.”16 The apostate’s Baptism was not undone. It was profiting him nothing while he lived apart from it, and it began to profit him again when he returned.
The Large Catechism says the same in its own words: “Baptism always remains true, retains its full essence, even though a single person should be baptized, and he, in addition, should not believe truly. For God’s ordinance and Word cannot be made variable or be altered by men.”17 In other words, God does not take back His promise when we stop believing it. The promise stands and it is we who walk away from it.
Faith can be lost
The Lutheran Confessions teach without hesitation that a true believer can lose the faith. The Augsburg Confession condemns “the Anabaptists, who deny that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost.” This is not an incidental line. It stands in the article on repentance, right beside the promise that “for those who have fallen after Baptism there is remission of sins whenever they are converted.”18
In the Smalcald Articles Luther describes a teaching he had met among some of the radical reformers in the time of the Peasants’ War. They held “that all those who had once received the Spirit or the forgiveness of sins, or had become believers, even though they should afterwards sin, would still remain in the faith, and such sin would not harm them.” Luther adds that “they say, besides, that if any one sins after he has received faith and the Spirit, he never truly had the Spirit and faith.” Against this he writes that “when holy men … happen to fall into manifest sins, as David into adultery, murder, and blasphemy, … then faith and the Holy Ghost has departed from them. For the Holy Ghost does not permit sin to have dominion … But if it does what it wishes, the Holy Ghost and faith are [certainly] not present.”19
The Formula of Concord says the same with great precision. It rejects as an “Epicurean delusion” the idea “that faith and the righteousness and salvation which they have received can be lost through no sins or wicked deeds, not even through wilful and intentional ones, but that a Christian although he indulges his wicked lusts without fear and shame, resists the Holy Ghost, and purposely engages in sins against conscience, yet none the less retains faith, God’s grace, righteousness, and salvation.” The Formula then quotes the Apology on 2 Peter 1:10: “faith does not remain in those who lead a sinful life, lose the Holy Ghost, and reject repentance.”20
What kind of sin do the Confessions have in mind? They do not say that every sin of weakness drives out faith. If that were so, no one would remain a believer through a single afternoon. They speak of sin that rules, sin that is willed and kept against the conscience, sin that is not repented of. David is their example. He lost the faith when he fell into manifest sin and let it rule, and not merely because he was a sinner. God sent Nathan to call him back (2 Samuel 12). Lastly, a person can lose the faith in a quieter way, by simply neglecting the Word through which the Spirit keeps faith alive, as the seed on rocky ground withered for lack of root.
This is a warning and not a diagnosis. The Christian who hates his sin and keeps fighting it, even when he loses, is not the one the Confessions describe. The Smalcald Articles speak of holy men who are “daily repenting of and striving with” their sin, and they do not say that faith has departed from them.21 Neither is the Christian who has drifted and now wants to come back. That wanting is the Spirit’s call.
The cause lies with us, and never with God
Why do some fall away while others persevere? This is where the question becomes painful and the Confessions answer with great care. The Formula of Concord, in its article on election, takes up Luke 8:13 directly: “Thus many receive the Word with joy, but afterwards fall away again, Luke 8:13. But the cause is not as though God were unwilling to grant grace for perseverance to those in whom He has begun the good work, for that is contrary to St. Paul, Phil. 1:6; but the cause is that they wilfully turn away again from the holy commandment [of God], grieve and embitter the Holy Ghost, implicate themselves again in the filth of the world, and garnish again the habitation of the heart for the devil.”22
In other words, when a person falls away, it is not because God gave him a Baptism that was weaker than someone else’s, or because God withdrew His promise, or because God never meant it. The Formula insists that it must not be said “that it never had been God’s good pleasure that such persons should come to the knowledge of the truth and be saved.”23 God’s will toward the baptized is the same as His will toward all sinners: “Have I any pleasure in the death of the wicked, declares the Lord GOD, and not rather that he should turn from his way and live?” (Ezekiel 18:23).
Yet the Confessions are equally clear that the one who perseveres cannot take credit for it. Perseverance is God’s gift. Augustine wrote: “I assert, therefore, that the perseverance by which we persevere in Christ even to the end is the gift of God.” He also said: “he who falls, falls by his own will, and he who stands, stands by God’s will.”24 This is the same pair of truths the Formula of Concord holds. Our salvation is entirely God’s work; our damnation is entirely our own fault. Our Confessions do not try to reconcile these two statements by a theory that would explain how both are true. We simply confess both, because Scripture teaches both.
Augustine admitted that this was a mystery that left him astonished. “It is, indeed, to be wondered at, and greatly to be wondered at, that to some of His own children, whom He has regenerated in Christ, to whom He has given faith, hope, and love, God does not give perseverance also.” He answered his own astonishment with Paul’s doxology in Romans 11:33. Yet Augustine, who taught predestination as strongly as anyone in the ancient Church, still spoke of fallen people as having been truly regenerated and as having received faith, hope, and love. He wrote that a man who “being already regenerate and justified, … relapses of his own will into an evil life … has lost the grace of God, that he had received.”25
Where the comfort lies
If faith can be lost, how can any Christian have assurance? Does this teaching leave us looking anxiously inward, wondering whether our faith is strong enough to last?
The Formula of Concord answers by pointing us away from ourselves. “Since our election to eternal life is founded not upon our godliness or virtue, but alone upon the merit of Christ and the gracious will of His Father, who cannot deny Himself, … therefore, when His children depart from obedience and stumble, He has them called again to repentance through the Word.”26 Our comfort lies in Christ rather than in how firmly we hold on. He prayed for Peter “that your faith may not fail” (Luke 22:32) and He says of His sheep, “no one will snatch them out of my hand” (John 10:28). Our comfort lies also in God’s promise, which “remains faithful” even when “we are faithless” (2 Timothy 2:13). It lies in Baptism, where that promise was spoken to us by name. Scripture speaks its warnings to the secure so that they will not presume, and its promises to the frightened so that they will not despair.
The Formula also ties this to election. Those who “believe for a while” truly believed, and yet “many are called, but few are chosen,” because “few receive the Word and follow it.”27 The elect God keeps to the end, for He has placed their salvation “in the almighty hand of our Savior Jesus Christ, from which no one can pluck us.”28 How then does a Christian know that he is among them? The Formula does not send him into God’s hidden counsel or into the strength of his own faith. It sends him to “the revealed will of God” in the Word through which God called him, and there he is to hear the promise and believe it today.29 In other words, the font answers the question “Am I elect?” because God spoke that Word there to me by name.
IV. How Other Christians Have Answered
Each of the three other answers deserves a fair hearing. Each holds onto something true and our disagreements are real but should be stated without caricature.
The Reformed answer: perseverance of the saints
The Reformed churches teach that those who are truly regenerated can never finally fall away. The Westminster Confession of Faith (1647) says: “They, whom God hath accepted in his Beloved, effectually called, and sanctified by his Spirit, can neither totally nor finally fall away from the state of grace, but shall certainly persevere therein to the end, and be eternally saved.”30 The Canons of Dort (1619) say that God “does not take the Holy Spirit from his own completely, even when they fall grievously.” How then do the Reformed explain the baptized who fall away? They answer that such people were never among the elect and never truly regenerate. Their faith was a temporary faith, which Dort says differs from saving faith not only in its duration but in its root and its fruit, appealing to the same parable of the sower.31 Calvin had already taught that the reprobate can have a kind of temporary faith and a taste of grace that is not the regenerating work of the Spirit.32 The Reformed also separate the gift of Baptism from the moment of Baptism. The Westminster Confession says that “the efficacy of baptism is not tied to that moment of time wherein it is administered,” and that its grace is conferred “to such (whether of age or infants) as that grace belongeth unto, according to the counsel of God’s own will, in his appointed time.”33
There is much here that we should honor. The Reformed rightly want the believer’s comfort to rest on God’s faithfulness and not on human strength. They rightly teach that perseverance is God’s gift, as Augustine did and as our own Formula of Concord does. Their favorite text is a real text: “They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us” (1 John 2:19). Augustine himself read it in nearly this way.34
However, we cannot follow them on the main point, for three reasons. First, the Smalcald Articles reject in so many words the claim that “if any one sins after he has received faith and the Spirit, he never truly had the Spirit and faith.”35 Luther wrote those words against sectarians who cried, “Do whatever you please,” and the Reformed do not draw that licentious conclusion. Yet the doctrine he rejected is the same one. Our Confessions take the language of Scripture at face value when it speaks of people who “believe for a while” (Luke 8:13), who “shared in the Holy Spirit” (Hebrews 6:4), and who “escaped the defilements of the world through the knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ” (2 Peter 2:20). Second, if those who fall were never regenerated, then the warnings of Scripture are not really addressed to believers at all, and Paul’s “take heed lest he fall” (1 Corinthians 10:12) becomes a warning to someone else. Third, and most important for pastoral care, if Baptism gives its grace only to the elect “in his appointed time,” then no one can look at his own Baptism and say with certainty, “God spoke this promise to me.” The comfort Luther pointed to (“Nevertheless I am baptized”) is weakened at exactly the moment it is needed. The Reformed point the troubled conscience to the decree of election; the Lutheran Confessions point it to the font, where the decree was revealed and applied to us by name.36
The Baptist answer: Baptism does not save
The second answer is that of our Baptist brothers and sisters, and of most American evangelicals. The Baptist Faith and Message (2000) describes Baptism as “an act of obedience symbolizing the believer’s faith in a crucified, buried, and risen Saviour.” On this view Baptism is something the believer does to confess what God has already done in his heart. The falling away of a baptized person therefore poses no problem for the doctrine of Baptism, because Baptism was never thought to save in the first place. The same confession teaches, much like Westminster, that “all true believers endure to the end” and “will never fall away from the state of grace.”37 In popular preaching this is often called “eternal security” or “once saved, always saved.”
Here too there is something to honor. Baptists rightly insist that a person must believe in Christ and they rightly fear a Christianity of names on a membership roll and water on a forehead with no living faith behind it. Lutherans share that fear. Luther himself complained that the devil had so obscured Baptism that “scarcely anyone calls to mind their baptism and still fewer glory in it.”38 We should also say plainly that responsible Baptist teachers do not hold the careless version of “once saved, always saved” that the Smalcald Articles describe (“Do whatever you please”). Their confession says that believers who fall into sin grieve the Spirit and bring judgments on themselves.
Yet the Baptist answer resolves the difficulty by setting aside the plain words of the texts we have read. Scripture does not call Baptism our act of obedience. It calls it “the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5), and it says that it “now saves you” (1 Peter 3:21). The Augsburg Confession condemns the Anabaptists “who reject the baptism of children, and say that children are saved without Baptism,”39 and the Formula of Concord rejects the teaching “that the water of Baptism is not a means whereby God the Lord seals the adoption of sons and works regeneration.”40 We do not believe that Baptism saves without faith. However, we also do not believe that faith saves by setting aside the means God has given for it to cling to. As the Large Catechism puts it, “faith must have something which it believes, that is, of which it takes hold, and upon which it stands and rests. Thus faith clings to the water.”41
The Roman answer: the second plank
The third answer is that of the Roman Catholic Church. Rome agrees with us that the justified can fall. The Council of Trent condemns anyone who says “that a man once justified can sin no more, nor lose grace, and that therefore he that falls and sins was never truly justified.”42 That is very close to what the Augsburg Confession and the Smalcald Articles say, and we should be glad of the agreement.
The difference lies in what is lost and in the way back. Trent teaches that “the received grace of Justification is lost, not only by infidelity whereby even faith itself is lost, but also by any other mortal sin whatever, though faith be not lost.” In other words, a person may still believe and yet be out of grace. Then Trent describes the way back: those who have fallen “may be again justified, when, God exciting them, through the sacrament of Penance they shall have attained to the recovery, by the merit of Christ, of the grace lost: for this manner of Justification is of the fallen the reparation: which the holy Fathers have aptly called a second plank after the shipwreck of grace lost.”43 The council made the point sharper in its canons on Penance. It condemned anyone who “saith that baptism is itself the sacrament of Penance, as though these two Sacraments were not distinct, and that therefore Penance is not rightly called a second plank after shipwreck.”44 The present Catechism of the Catholic Church repeats the image: the Fathers present this sacrament as “the second plank [of salvation] after the shipwreck which is the loss of grace.”45
We should again honor what is true here. Rome takes sin after Baptism seriously and it offers the fallen a concrete way back through confession and absolution. Lutherans also prize private confession and absolution, and the Augsburg Confession says that “the Church ought to impart absolution to those thus returning to repentance.” However, Trent’s canon condemns precisely what Luther taught in the Large Catechism, that repentance “is really nothing else than Baptism.”46 The question between us is whether Baptism is a ship that sinks when we sin, so that we must swim to a second plank, or a ship that stays afloat, so that we must be brought back on board.
The ancient background
The question of sin after Baptism troubled the Church from the start. Tertullian, writing On Repentance around A.D. 200, taught that “the gate of forgiveness has been shut and fastened up with the bar of baptism,” yet God “has permitted it still to stand somewhat open,” allowing a “second repentance … but now once for all.” He was so concerned about sin after Baptism that he counseled delay: “the delay of baptism is preferable; principally, however, in the case of little children.”47 In the third century the Novatians refused to restore the lapsed at all. Cyprian took a middle road. He required a long and public penance, but he insisted that the door was not shut: “He can show mercy; He can turn back His judgment. He can mercifully pardon the repenting, the labouring, the beseeching sinner.”48 We should be honest that Cyprian also spoke of the penitent appeasing God’s anger by his own atonement, and on that point we would want to speak differently. Yet the Augsburg Confession stands with Cyprian against the Novatians, condemning those “who would not absolve such as had fallen after Baptism, though they returned to repentance.”49 The Church of England, in its Thirty-Nine Articles, says much the same: “After we have received the Holy Ghost, we may depart from grace given, and fall into sin, and by the grace of God we may arise again, and amend our lives.”50
V. The Ship That Does Not Break
Jerome’s plank
The image of the “second plank” comes from Jerome. In a letter of about A.D. 400 he wrote of his own past errors, “After shipwreck one has still a plank to cling to; and one may atone for sin by a frank confession.” In his famous letter to the young virgin Demetrias he said of penitence, “It is a plank for those who have had the misfortune to be shipwrecked; but an inviolate virgin may hope to save the ship itself.”51 Jerome meant to encourage the penitent and to urge the innocent to stay innocent. However, the image took on a life of its own. In the medieval Church it came to mean that Baptism is the first plank, that it carries us only until our first serious sin, and that from then on we must hold onto a second plank of penance, with its satisfactions and works.
Luther’s answer
Luther saw what this did to the consciences of ordinary Christians. In The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520) he called it “that dangerous saying of St. Jerome’s — either unhappily phrased or wrongly interpreted.” The result was that “when men fall into sin, they despair of ‘the first plank,’ which is the ship, as though it had gone under, and fasten all their faith on the second plank, that is, penance.” Then he gave his own picture: “How harmful an error it is to believe that the power of baptism is broken, and the ship has foundered, because we have sinned! No! That one, solid and unsinkable ship remains, and is never broken up into floating timbers. … Many, indeed, rashly leap overboard and perish in the waves. These are they who depart from faith in the promise and plunge into sin. But the ship herself remains intact and holds her steady course. If one be able somehow to return to the ship, it is not on any plank but in the good ship herself that he is carried to life.”52
This picture answers our whole question. The baptized can be lost, for they can leap overboard and drown. However, the ship does not sink and the way back is not to some other means of grace that replaces it. The way back is to Baptism itself. Our Apology even names “Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance,” among the true Sacraments.53 Yet absolution is no second plank floating beside the ship but the Word of our Baptism spoken to us again, as the Large Catechism teaches.54
Luther said the same thing nine years later in the Large Catechism, in words that every Lutheran should know:
“Therefore our Baptism abides forever; and even though some one should fall from it and sin, nevertheless we always have access thereto, that we may again subdue the old man. But we need not again be sprinkled with water; for though we were put under the water a hundred times, it would nevertheless be only one Baptism, although the operation and signification continue and remain. Repentance, therefore, is nothing else than a return and approach to Baptism, that we repeat and practise what we began before, but abandoned.”55
He then turns directly to Jerome. “The ship never breaks, because (as we have said) it is the ordinance of God, and not a work of ours; but it happens, indeed, that we slip and fall out of the ship. Yet if any one fall out, let him see to it that he swim up and cling to it till he again come into it and live in it, as he had formerly begun.” And a little later: “if any one fall away from it, let him again come into it. For just as Christ, the Mercy-seat, does not recede from us or forbid us to come to Him again, even though we sin, so all His treasure and gifts also remain.”56
This is the Lutheran answer to our question. Baptism saves, because it is God’s ordinance. The baptized can fall out of it, because faith can be lost. The way back is to return to the Baptism that never broke.
Daily drowning
This return is not only for those who have fallen away completely. It is the shape of every Christian’s life. The Small Catechism asks what baptizing with water signifies, and answers: “It signifies that the old Adam in us should, by daily contrition and repentance, be drowned and die with all sins and evil lusts, and, again, a new man daily come forth and arise; who shall live before God in righteousness and purity forever.” The Large Catechism adds that “a truly Christian life is nothing else than a daily baptism, once begun and ever to be continued.”57 Paul says the same: “consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus” (Romans 6:11).
In other words, every confession of sins at the beginning of the Divine Service, every absolution spoken by the pastor, and every sign of the cross a Christian makes in the morning is a return to the font. The fallen Christian who comes back is doing the same thing every Christian does each day, only after a longer absence. Luther gives a warning here too: where the old Adam “is left unbridled, so as to continually become stronger, that is not using Baptism, but striving against Baptism.”58
What about Hebrews 6?
Some readers will still ask about Hebrews 6:4–6. Does it not say that for those who fall away it is “impossible … to restore them again to repentance”? It does, and we should not soften it. However, we must read it within the whole letter and the whole of Scripture. The writer speaks of those who, having received these gifts, now hold Christ in contempt; “they are crucifying once again the Son of God to their own harm and holding him up to contempt.” As long as a person stands in that open rejection of Christ, there is no other sacrifice and no other Savior to bring him to repentance. The same writer goes on immediately to say, “Though we speak in this way, yet in your case, beloved, we feel sure of better things” (Hebrews 6:9). The warning is real, and it is spoken to drive the hearers back to Christ, not to tell a frightened sinner that the door is shut. Peter denied the Lord with curses and was restored (Luke 22:32; John 21:15–19). David committed adultery and murder and was told, “The LORD also has put away your sin” (2 Samuel 12:13). The Formula of Concord applies Jeremiah 3:1 to the fallen: “But thou hast played the harlot with many lovers; yet return again to Me, saith the Lord.”59 Anyone who is troubled that he may have fallen too far to return shows by that very trouble that the Spirit is still calling him.
Conclusion: What This Means for Us
Let me gather up what we have heard.
-
Baptism truly saves. It is God’s work, joined to His Word, and it gives forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation.
-
The baptized can truly fall away. Scripture says so plainly and the early Church knew it from bitter experience.
-
Baptism gives what it promises, and faith receives it. When a person falls away, his Baptism is not undone; he has let go of what it gave. The cause lies in human sin and unbelief, never in God’s unwillingness.
-
The Reformed, Baptist, and Roman answers each hold onto something true, but each resolves the tension by giving up something Scripture teaches: the reality of the fall, the power of Baptism, or the sufficiency of Baptism as the way back.
-
The way back is always to Baptism itself, through repentance and faith in the forgiveness that God promised there. The ship does not break.
What does this mean for us? It means, first, that none of us may be careless. “Let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (1 Corinthians 10:12). Our Baptism is no license to neglect the Word and the Sacrament, and faith that is not nourished by the Word can die. It means, second, that none of us need despair. When our sins accuse us, we may say with Luther, “Nevertheless I am baptized,” and we may come back again and again to the promise God has not withdrawn.
It means, third, something for parents and grandparents whose children have wandered. Some who read these words carry this grief. We brought our children to the font, we taught them their prayers, we took them to Sunday School and confirmation, and now they say they do not believe. We ask whether we did something wrong. We ask whether their Baptism meant anything. Cyprian’s words belong to us as much as to any bishop: “it is the shepherd that is chiefly wounded in the wound of his flock.”60
To such parents the Church says several things. First, your child’s Baptism was real. God’s promise was spoken to your child by name, and “our Baptism abides forever.”61 Even when we are faithless, “he remains faithful” (2 Timothy 2:13). Your son or daughter has walked away from the ship, but the ship has not gone down. If and when your child returns, there will be no need to begin again. He or she will come back to a Baptism that has been waiting all along.
Second, faith is God’s gift and not something parents can produce. We do what God gives us to do. We bring our children to Baptism, we teach them, and we pray. The Large Catechism says of infant Baptism, “We bring the child in the conviction and hope that it believes, and we pray that God may grant it faith.”62 That prayer did not end at the font. Keep praying it. The Lord prayed for Peter before Peter fell, and He told him, “when you have turned again, strengthen your brothers” (Luke 22:32). He expected Peter to come back.
Third, the Word does not return empty. “It shall not return to me empty, but it shall accomplish that which I purpose, and shall succeed in the thing for which I sent it” (Isaiah 55:11). The Scripture your child memorized, the hymns he sang, the Creed she confessed at confirmation are still there. We cannot see what the Spirit is doing with them, and we should not presume to know how the story ends. Augustine was raised by a praying mother who had not yet had him baptized, and he wandered for years into a false religion and a dissolute life. When Monica begged a bishop to speak with her son, he sent her away with the words, “it is not possible that the son of these tears should perish.”63 That was not a promise God had made to her, and we must not turn it into a guarantee. However, it was a word of hope, and she lived to see her son come home. Monica’s hope rested on the Word she had planted, and so does yours.
Fourth, the father of the prodigal did not chase his son into the far country, and he did not stop watching the road. “While he was still a long way off, his father saw him and felt compassion, and ran and embraced him and kissed him” (Luke 15:20). Our task is to keep the door open, to speak the truth in love without nagging or despair, and to make sure that when our children turn toward home they find a family and a congregation ready to welcome them. “My brothers, if anyone among you wanders from the truth and someone brings him back, let him know that whoever brings back a sinner from his wandering will save his soul from death” (James 5:19–20).
Lastly, this means something for the one who has wandered and is reading these words. You were baptized. God put His name on you and has not taken it back. You do not need to be baptized again and you do not need to earn your way back onto some second plank. Come back to the ship. Come and talk with your pastor. Confess your sins and hear the absolution, and come back to the Lord’s Table.
In other words, the font is never closed. We were brought to it once and we return to it every day of our lives by repentance and faith. Some of us have stayed close to it and some of us have wandered far, but the promise spoken there has not changed. “Let us hold fast the confession of our hope without wavering, for he who promised is faithful” (Hebrews 10:23).
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Ev. Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text at bookofconcord.org.) (Especially: Augsburg Confession IX and XII; Apology XIII and XX; Smalcald Articles III.iii; Small Catechism, Baptism; Large Catechism, Baptism; Formula of Concord, Epitome XII and Solid Declaration IV and XI.)
The Early Church
- Justin Martyr. First Apology. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Tertullian. On Baptism; On Repentance. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
- Cyprian. On the Lapsed. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5.
- Cyril of Jerusalem. Procatechesis and Mystagogical Catecheses. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 7.
- Jerome. Letters 84 and 130. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 6.
- Augustine. Confessions. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 1.
- Augustine. On Baptism, Against the Donatists. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 4.
- Augustine. On Rebuke and Grace; On the Gift of Perseverance. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 5.
The Reformation and Other Confessions
- Luther, Martin. The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520). Translated by A. T. W. Steinhaeuser. In Works of Martin Luther, vol. 2. Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1915. Also in Luther’s Works, vol. 36. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
- Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Translated by Ford Lewis Battles. Edited by John T. McNeill. Philadelphia: Westminster, 1960.
- Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent. Translated by J. Waterworth. London: Dolman, 1848.
- The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (1571).
- The Canons of Dort (1619).
- The Westminster Confession of Faith (1647).
- The Baptist Faith and Message (2000). Southern Baptist Convention.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997.
Reference
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.
Footnotes
-
SC IV, Second Part. ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. βαπτίζω. ↩
-
Thayer, s.v. λουτρόν, παλιγγενεσία, and ἀντίτυπος. ↩
-
AC IX 1–2; SC IV, Second Part. ↩
-
LC IV 24, 41, 44. ↩
-
LC IV 35; SC IV, Third Part. ↩
-
Tertullian, On Baptism 1, ANF, vol. 3. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 2.5 (Catechetical Lectures 20.5), NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “apostasy”; Thayer, s.v. ἀφίστημι, παραπίπτω, ἐκπίπτω, and ναυαγέω. ↩
-
So Justin Martyr, First Apology 61, ANF, vol. 1, who says that the washing of Baptism “is called illumination.” Compare Hebrews 10:32. ↩
-
Cyprian, On the Lapsed (Treatise 3) 4, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Procatechesis 2, NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
SC IV, Third Part. ↩
-
LC IV 33–34. ↩
-
LC IV 53, 59, 40. ↩
-
Augustine, On Baptism, Against the Donatists I.1.2, NPNF¹, vol. 4. ↩
-
LC IV 60. ↩
-
AC XII 7, 1. ↩
-
SA III.iii 42–44. The Tappert edition numbers this passage 42–45; the Triglotta numbers it 42–43. ↩
-
FC SD IV 31, 33. Paragraph 33 quotes Ap XX 13. See also SD IV 32, which sets 1 Corinthians 6:9, Galatians 5:21, Ephesians 5:5, Romans 8:13, and Colossians 3:6 against this “pernicious delusion.” ↩
-
SA III.iii 43. ↩
-
FC SD XI 42. Compare SD XI 39–41. ↩
-
FC SD XI 83. ↩
-
Augustine, On the Gift of Perseverance 1 and 19, NPNF¹, vol. 5. (New Advent prints the treatise as On the Predestination of the Saints, Book II.) ↩
-
Augustine, On Rebuke and Grace 18 and 9, NPNF¹, vol. 5. ↩
-
FC SD XI 75. ↩
-
FC SD XI 34, 39–42. ↩
-
FC SD XI 45. ↩
-
FC SD XI 26–33. ↩
-
Westminster Confession of Faith XVII.1. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Fifth Main Point of Doctrine, Article 6 and Rejection of Errors VII (Christian Reformed Church translation). See also Articles 7–8. ↩
-
John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion III.2.11–12, trans. Ford Lewis Battles, ed. John T. McNeill (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1960). ↩
-
Westminster Confession of Faith XXVIII.6. ↩
-
Augustine, On Rebuke and Grace 20, NPNF¹, vol. 5. Augustine there says that those who did not persevere were called children of God “while they live piously,” but were not so called in God’s foreknowledge. ↩
-
SA III.iii 42. ↩
-
Compare FC SD XI 26–33, which directs the Christian to seek his election in the revealed Word rather than in the hidden counsel of God, and LC IV 44. ↩
-
The Baptist Faith and Message (2000), Articles VII and V. ↩
-
Luther, The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), 3.2, trans. A. T. W. Steinhaeuser, in Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1915), vol. 2; Project Wittenberg edition, ed. Robert E. Smith. Compare LW 36. ↩
-
AC IX 3. ↩
-
FC Ep XII 23. Compare Ep XII 6–8 on the Anabaptist rejection of infant Baptism. ↩
-
LC IV 29. ↩
-
Council of Trent, Session VI (1547), Canon 23, trans. J. Waterworth (London: Dolman, 1848). ↩
-
Council of Trent, Session VI, chapters 15 and 14. ↩
-
Council of Trent, Session XIV (1551), On the Most Holy Sacrament of Penance, Canon 2. ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997), §1446. ↩
-
AC XII 2; LC IV 74–75. On private confession, see AC XI and SC V. ↩
-
Tertullian, On Repentance 7 and On Baptism 18, ANF, vol. 3. ↩
-
Cyprian, On the Lapsed 36, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
AC XII 9. ↩
-
The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (1571), Article XVI, “Of Sin after Baptism.” ↩
-
Jerome, Letter 84.6, to Pammachius and Oceanus, and Letter 130.9, to Demetrias, NPNF², vol. 6. ↩
-
Luther, The Babylonian Captivity of the Church, 3.2 and 3.9 (Steinhaeuser). Compare LW 36. ↩
-
Ap XIII 4. ↩
-
LC IV 74–79. ↩
-
LC IV 77–79. ↩
-
LC IV 82, 86. ↩
-
SC IV, Fourth Part; LC IV 65. ↩
-
LC IV 68. ↩
-
FC SD XI 75. ↩
-
Cyprian, On the Lapsed 4, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
LC IV 77. ↩
-
LC IV 57. ↩
-
Augustine, Confessions III.12.21, NPNF¹, vol. 1. On the deferral of his Baptism in childhood, see Confessions I.11.17. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Baptism and Falling Away: Why the Baptized Can Lose the Faith.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/baptism-and-falling-away/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.