A Free Gospel and a Guarded Table
Why Lutheran Congregations Restrict Admission to Holy Communion
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“The Spirit and the Bride say, ‘Come.’ And let the one who hears say, ‘Come.’ And let the one who is thirsty come; let the one who desires take the water of life without price.” — Revelation 22:17
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation.
The Question Before Us
If the Gospel is freely offered to all, why do Lutheran congregations restrict admission to Holy Communion? The question is a fair one and it is usually asked in good faith. A visitor comes to a Lutheran service and hears the pastor preach that Christ died for the whole world, that grace cannot be earned, and that God wants every sinner to come home. Then the Sacrament is distributed and the same visitor reads in the bulletin, or hears from the pulpit, that not everyone present is invited to receive it. Is grace free or is it not? If Jesus ate with tax collectors and sinners, why does His Church check names at the rail? In other words, does the Church preach an open door and then keep a locked one?
The question does not only come from visitors. Lutherans ask it of one another and Lutheran church bodies have answered it in more than one way, each believing that it is being faithful to Christ and kind to the guest. That alone tells us the question deserves a careful answer and not a slogan.
The companion paper God Wills All to Be Saved argued from Scripture and the Confessions that God’s will toward every human being is gracious and that His call through the Word is serious and meant for all. The companion paper One Body at Many Altars argued that Christ’s true body and blood are present wherever the Supper is celebrated according to His institution. This paper stands on both. If the first is true the Church must never stop inviting, and if the second is true the Church must never stop taking care.
In this paper I want to take up five questions in order: 1) Is the Gospel really offered to all, and to whom did our Lord give His Supper? 2) Why would love ever restrict the Table? 3) What did the early Church do? 4) What do the Lutheran Confessions and the Reformers teach, and how do Lutherans practice it today? 5) How do other Christians answer the question, and is it truly hospitality to refuse anyone? We will close by asking what all of this means for us, both for our welcome to the stranger and for the comfort of our own consciences.
I. The Free Offer and the Gift Given to the Baptized
The words themselves
We begin with the words. Webster’s defines communion first as “fellowship; intercourse between two persons or more; interchange of transactions, or offices; a state of giving and receiving; agreement; concord.” It then adds a second sense: “mutual intercourse or union in religious worship, or in doctrine and discipline.”1 The English word already carries two things at once. To commune is to receive something and it is also to stand together with others in a shared faith.
The New Testament word behind it is koinōnia. Thayer defines it as “fellowship, association, community, communion, joint participation,” and under its first sense he lists 1 Corinthians 10:16, the share one has in “the blood of Christ” and in “the body of Christ.”2 When Paul asks, “The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ?” he uses that word. The Supper is a koinōnia with Christ (we receive His body and blood) and it is a koinōnia with one another (“we who are many are one body,” 1 Corinthians 10:17). Any honest answer to our question has to keep both in view.
The other word we need is admission, which simply means letting someone in. Every Christian church admits people to the Supper in some way. Therefore the real question is on what basis, by whose judgment, and for whose good.
The offer that goes to all
Scripture could not be plainer that God’s invitation goes out to all people. Isaiah cries, “Come, everyone who thirsts, come to the waters; and he who has no money, come, buy and eat! Come, buy wine and milk without money and without price” (Isaiah 55:1). Our Lord says, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28). He promises, “whoever comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6:37). The last invitation in the Bible is the widest of all: “let the one who is thirsty come; let the one who desires take the water of life without price” (Revelation 22:17).
None of these invitations is narrowed in the Lutheran Church. The Word is preached to everyone who will listen and the prayers of the Church are offered for the whole world. However, the Great Commission has an order to it. The Lord says, “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you” (Matthew 28:19–20). The invitation is to all, yet the invitation has a shape. A person is made a disciple by being baptized and taught. He is not made a disciple by being fed first and baptized later.
To whom the Supper was given
When we turn to the night our Lord instituted His Supper, we find that He did not give it to the crowds. He had fed five thousand on a hillside with loaves and fish, and He welcomed sinners to eat with Him in the homes of Galilee. Yet on the night He was betrayed He gathered the Twelve in an upper room, took bread, and said, “This is my body, which is given for you” (Luke 22:19). The Supper was given to the disciples, to those who had followed Him, heard His teaching and confessed Him as the Christ.
The book of Acts shows the same order. On the Day of Pentecost Peter called a great crowd to “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins” (Acts 2:38). Then Luke records what followed: “So those who received his word were baptized, and there were added that day about three thousand souls. And they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:41–42). Luke does not describe a Church that broke bread with the crowd and baptized whoever stayed.
This was not a new idea. The Passover, which our Lord fulfilled in His Supper, was a meal for the covenant people. The Lord told Moses and Aaron, “This is the statute of the Passover: no foreigner shall eat of it.” Yet He did not shut the foreigner out for good. “If a stranger shall sojourn with you and would keep the Passover to the LORD, let all his males be circumcised. Then he may come near and keep it; he shall be as a native of the land” (Exodus 12:43, 48). In other words, the meal was guarded, yet the way into it was open to anyone who would receive the sign of the covenant, and the stranger was shown how to come in.
Different gifts, different addresses
The Lutheran Church teaches that God gives His grace through means (AC V). All of them give the same Christ and the same forgiveness, yet they are not addressed to people in the same way. The Word is addressed to the world, since faith comes by hearing. Baptism is addressed to all nations, since it is the door into the Church. The Supper is addressed to the baptized who believe, since it is the food of those who have already been born again. Luther asks in the Large Catechism who receives the power and benefit of the Sacrament and answers, “Whoever believes it has what the words declare and bring. For they are not spoken or proclaimed to stone and wood, but to those who hear them, to whom He says: Take and eat.”3 The words “given and shed for you” require someone who can hear them and trust them. That is why the Church has always placed the Supper after Baptism and teaching, and never before.
None of this makes the Supper less a gift of grace. A family meal is no less freely given because it is set before the children of the household. In the same way the free offer of the Gospel and the ordered gift of the Supper do not contradict each other, since the first calls a sinner to Christ and the second feeds him once he has come (John 6:35).
II. Why a Guarded Table Is a Loving Table
The danger of unworthy reception
If the Supper were only a memorial meal, or a symbol of a fellowship we already have, there would be little reason to guard it. We could welcome everyone and let each guest make of it what he will. However, Scripture speaks of the Supper in a way that makes carelessness dangerous. Paul writes, “Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself” (1 Corinthians 11:27–29). The warning is real, yet the same article of the Formula that teaches the unworthy eating calls the weak, the troubled and the terrified “the truly worthy guests” for whom the Sacrament was instituted.4 Paul warns against unbelief and impenitence and not against weakness.
Three Greek words carry the passage. The first is anaxiōs, which Thayer renders simply “in an unworthy manner.”5 The adverb describes the manner of eating, not the merit of the eater. The second is dokimazō (“to test, examine, prove, scrutinize”), the word used of testing metal to see whether it is genuine.6 The third is diakrinō (“to separate, make a distinction, discriminate”), so that to discern the body is to recognize that this bread is not ordinary bread.7 Paul asks the Corinthians to recognize what they are receiving and to come to it in repentance and faith, not to prove that they are good enough.
The Formula of Concord draws the conclusion that follows from the real presence. It says that “not only the godly, pious, and believing Christians, but also unworthy, godless hypocrites, as Judas and his ilk, who have no spiritual communion with Christ, and go to the Table of the Lord without true repentance and conversion to God, also receive orally in the Sacrament the true body and [true] blood of Christ, and by their unworthy eating and drinking grievously sin against the body and blood of Christ.”8 The companion paper One Body at Many Altars shows why the Lutheran Church reads Paul this way. If the body of Christ were not present, no one could sin against it by eating bread.
Augustine said the same about Judas long before the Reformation: the mouthful the Lord gave was not poison. “And yet he took it; and when he took it, the enemy entered into him: not because he received an evil thing, but because he being evil received a good thing in an evil way.”9 In another place he put it more simply: “even good things are hurtful, and evil things are beneficial, according to the character of the recipients.”10
Therefore a church that believes Christ’s body and blood are truly given at its altar cannot be indifferent to who receives them. If the Sacrament can harm the one who comes without faith or repentance, then to hand it to everyone without a word would be as careless as a doctor handing a strong medicine to everyone in the waiting room without asking who has come to be healed and who has come refusing the cure.
Who is unworthy, and who is not
At this point we must be careful, because the warning of 1 Corinthians 11 has frightened many tender consciences away from the very gift meant to comfort them. The companion paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper shows how Chemnitz rebuked any ministry that frightens the penitent away from the Table, and whatever guarding the Church does must never become that. The Confessions are precise about who the unworthy are. The Formula of Concord says that the unworthy guests are “those who go to this Sacrament without true repentance and sorrow for their sins, and without true faith and the good intention of amending their lives.” Then it immediately turns to the troubled: “For Christians who are of weak faith, diffident, troubled, and heartily terrified because of the greatness and number of their sins, and think that in this their great impurity they are not worthy of this precious treasure and the benefits of Christ, and who feel and lament their weakness of faith … they are the truly worthy guests for whom this highly venerable Sacrament [and sacred feast] has been especially instituted and appointed.” To prove it the Formula quotes Matthew 11:28, “Come unto Me, all ye that labor and are heavy laden.”11 The same verse we heard as the free offer of the Gospel is the verse the Formula uses to describe who belongs at the Table. The free invitation and the guarded Table are not two different messages.
The Small Catechism says it in a single sentence: “he is truly worthy and well prepared who has faith in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins. But he that does not believe these words, or doubts, is unworthy and unfit; for the words For you require altogether believing hearts.”12 Luther in the Large Catechism draws the pastoral line clearly. “We must, therefore, make a distinction here among men. For those who are wanton and dissolute must be told to stay away; for they are not prepared to receive forgiveness of sin, since they do not desire it and do not wish to be godly. But the others, who are not such callous and wicked people, and desire to be godly, must not absent themselves, even though otherwise they be feeble and full of infirmities.”13
In other words, the Church guards the Table against unbelief and impenitence, not against weakness. The Lutheran restriction, rightly practiced, never turns a sinner away for his weakness. Where it asks a believing guest to wait, it does so because the altar is a confession we do not yet share (as the next section explains), and not because he is less forgiven.
The Supper as a confession
There is a second reason the Church takes care and it has to do with the second meaning of koinōnia. Paul writes, “For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes” (1 Corinthians 11:26). The word proclaim is a preaching word. Every person who communes is confessing something by the act itself: that Christ died for him, that Christ’s body and blood are given here, and that he stands with this congregation in what it believes. That is why Paul can say, “Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:17).
The early Church in Acts did not separate the breaking of bread from “the apostles’ teaching” (Acts 2:42). Paul also tells the Romans “to watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you have been taught; avoid them” (Romans 16:17). The point is not that Christians of other confessions are not Christians. The Lutheran Church has never taught that. The point is that the Supper is a public act of shared confession, and to commune together while confessing different things about the Supper itself is to say with the mouth what is not yet true in the faith. Altar fellowship expresses a unity that should already exist rather than manufacturing one that does not. Our Lord adds a further care when He says, “First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift” (Matthew 5:24). The Supper is the meal of a reconciled people.
III. The Witness of the Early Church
The Didache
The oldest Christian church order outside the New Testament, the Didache or Teaching of the Twelve Apostles, probably comes from late in the first century or early in the second. After giving the prayers of thanksgiving for the cup and the bread, it says, “But let no one eat or drink of your Thanksgiving (Eucharist), but they who have been baptized into the name of the Lord; for concerning this also the Lord has said, Give not that which is holy to the dogs.”14 The verse it quotes is Matthew 7:6, “Do not give dogs what is holy.” The earliest Christians read our Lord’s saying as applying directly to the Supper. By “dogs” they meant those who would treat the holy things with contempt and not the seeker at the door who wants to learn.
Yet the Didache is not cold about it. The prayer after communion ends with an invitation and a call to repentance in the same breath: “If any one is holy, let him come; if any one is not so, let him repent. Maran atha.”15 It also applies our Lord’s word from Matthew 5:23–24: “But let no one that is at variance with his fellow come together with you, until they be reconciled, that your sacrifice may not be profaned.”16 The guarding is done for the sake of the gift and of the one who might receive it wrongly, while the door of repentance is held open.
Ignatius and Justin
Ignatius of Antioch, writing on his way to martyrdom early in the second century, describes certain heretics who denied that Christ came in the flesh. “They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins, and which the Father, of His goodness, raised up again.”17 Those who did not share the Church’s confession about the Supper understood, as the Church did, that to receive it was to confess it.
Justin Martyr, writing to the Roman emperor around the year 150, gives the fullest early description. After a person is baptized, Justin says, the Church brings him “to the place where those who are called brethren are assembled.”18 Then he says who may receive it: “And this food is called among us Εὐχαριστία [the Eucharist], of which no one is allowed to partake but the man who believes that the things which we teach are true, and who has been washed with the washing that is for the remission of sins, and unto regeneration, and who is so living as Christ has enjoined.”19 Justin names three conditions: faith in what the Church teaches, Baptism, and a life lived as Christ commanded. He was writing to pagans and he did not hide the restriction from them or apologize for it.
The dismissal of the catechumens
By the fourth century the restriction had taken a fixed liturgical form. Those who were preparing for Baptism (the catechumens) attended the first part of the service, heard the Scriptures read and preached, and then were dismissed before the Eucharist began. The Apostolic Constitutions, a church order from the late fourth century, gives the whole rite. The deacon bids the faithful to pray for the catechumens by name, that God would “instruct them in the knowledge of God, teach them His commands and His ordinances,” and “vouchsafe them the laver of regeneration,” so that “they may obtain the forgiveness of their transgressions by their admission, and so may be thought worthy of the holy mysteries.” The bishop blesses them, and then the deacon says, “Go out, you catechumens, in peace.”20 A little later the deacon cries, “Let none of the catechumens, let none of the hearers, let none of the unbelievers, let none of the heterodox, stay here.”21
The dismissal was not a rejection. The whole congregation prayed for those who were leaving, they were blessed before they went, and the prayer asked that they would soon be baptized and admitted. In other words, the Church dismissed the catechumens in the hope of receiving them.
Augustine shows how real the line was in his own preaching. “If we say to a catechumen, Do you believe in Christ, he answers, I believe, and signs himself; already he bears the cross of Christ on his forehead, and is not ashamed of the cross of his Lord. Behold, he has believed in His name. Let us ask him, Do you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink the blood of the Son of man? He knows not what we say, because Jesus has not trusted Himself to him.”22 Augustine did not deny that the catechumen believed. He said that the catechumen had not yet been brought all the way in.
Later scholars called this the disciplina arcani (“the discipline of the secret”). The name is modern and the practice varied from place to place, so it should not be pressed too hard; Justin, as we saw, described the Eucharist openly to the emperor.23 Still, the pattern is clear. The early Church preached to everyone, taught the catechumens patiently, and gave the Sacrament to the baptized faithful.
“Holy things for the holy”
Cyril of Jerusalem, instructing the newly baptized in the middle of the fourth century, explains the words the priest spoke just before communion. “After this the Priest says, Holy things to holy men. Holy are the gifts presented, having received the visitation of the Holy Ghost; holy are you also, having been deemed worthy of the Holy Ghost; the holy things therefore correspond to the holy persons.” Then the people answer, “One is Holy, One is the Lord, Jesus Christ.” Cyril adds, “For One is truly holy, by nature holy; we too are holy, but not by nature, only by participation, and discipline, and prayer.”24
That answer is the Gospel inside the warning. The people do not claim to be holy in themselves. They confess that only Christ is holy and that they are holy because He has made them His own in Baptism. At the end of the same lecture Cyril urges his hearers, “Sever not yourselves from the Communion; deprive not yourselves, through the pollution of sins, of these Holy and Spiritual Mysteries.”25 He guarded the Table and he urged the baptized to come to it.
Chrysostom
John Chrysostom, preaching in Antioch near the end of the fourth century, spoke with great force about the pastor’s duty. He told those who ministered at the altar that they must not give the Sacrament to someone they knew to be coming unworthily, even if he were a general or the emperor himself. “Let no one communicate who is not of the disciples. Let no Judas receive, lest he suffer the fate of Judas.” Then he said of himself, “I would give up my life rather than impart of the Lord’s blood to the unworthy; and will shed my own blood rather than impart of such awful blood contrary to what is meet.”26
We should read Chrysostom as the preacher he was, exhorting his clergy to courage. Yet the conviction underneath is plain. The pastor answers to God for how he gives what God has entrusted to him, and to give the body and blood of Christ to a man who would receive it to his judgment would be the unkind thing.
Werner Elert’s study of the early centuries reached a conclusion that the sources above bear out. In the ancient Church altar fellowship and church fellowship were the same thing. To be received at one altar was to be received in the whole communion of churches that shared the faith, and to be excluded for heresy was to be excluded from them all.27 We may differ over how that applies in a divided Christendom, yet we cannot honestly say that the early Church practiced an open Table.
IV. The Lutheran Confessions and the Reformers
Examined and absolved
At Augsburg in 1530 the Lutherans answered the charge that they had abolished the Mass. They replied that the Mass was “retained among us, and celebrated with the highest reverence,” and they described how the people received the Sacrament: “For none are admitted except they be first examined.”28 In the next article they said the same in connection with confession: “it is not usual to give the body of the Lord, except to them that have been previously examined and absolved.”29
Melanchthon repeated the point in the Apology. “With us many use the Lord’s Supper [willingly and without constraint] every Lord’s Day, but after having been first instructed, examined [whether they know and understand anything of the Lord’s Prayer, the Creed, and the Ten Commandments], and absolved.”30 Again, at the beginning of the article on the Mass: “among us masses are celebrated every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals, in which the Sacrament is offered to those who wish to use it, after they have been examined and absolved.”31
The bracketed words in the Apology tell us that the examination asked whether the communicant knew the basics of the faith. It was catechesis applied, and it was joined to absolution so that the person who came to be examined also went away having heard that his sins were forgiven. In other words, the Reformation examination was a pastoral visit that ended in the Gospel.
Knowing what one seeks
Luther opens his treatment of the Sacrament in the Large Catechism with the same concern. He sets out what the Sacrament is, what it gives and who is to receive it, all of which “every one who desires to be a Christian and go to the Sacrament should know. For it is not our intention to admit to it and to administer it to those who know not what they seek, or why they come.”32 In the preface to the Small Catechism he goes further, saying of those who refuse to learn the catechism that they “should not be admitted to the Sacrament.”33 The tone of that preface is severe and reflects what Luther found in the visitation of the Saxon parishes in 1528 and 1529. Yet the principle is the same as the Didache’s and Justin’s: the Supper is for those who have been taught.
In his Formula Missae of 1523 Luther gave directions for how this should be done in Wittenberg. Those who wished to commune were to make it known to the pastor beforehand, so that he could know who they were and how they lived, and could ask whether they understood what the Supper is and what it gives. Luther wanted the pastor to exclude those who could not give an account of their faith or who were living in open sin, and to receive the rest.34 The practice of announcing for communion, which survived in Lutheran parishes for centuries, comes from this.
The office of the keys
Behind all of this stands the office of the keys. Our Lord gave His Church authority to bind and loose: “Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matthew 18:18). The risen Christ said to the apostles, “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld” (John 20:23). Paul told the Ephesian elders, “Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers” (Acts 20:28), and he described pastors as “stewards of the mysteries of God” (1 Corinthians 4:1).
The Augsburg Confession says that by divine right there belongs “to the bishops as bishops, that is, to those to whom has been committed the ministry of the Word and the Sacraments,” no jurisdiction except “to forgive sins, to judge doctrine, to reject doctrines contrary to the Gospel, and to exclude from the communion of the Church wicked men, whose wickedness is known, and this without human force, simply by the Word.”35 The Smalcald Articles define the only excommunication the Lutheran Church recognizes: “the true Christian excommunication, consists in this, that manifest and obstinate sinners are not admitted to the Sacrament and other communion of the Church until they amend their lives and avoid sin.”36
This is drawn very narrowly. The keys are exercised “simply by the Word,” on sinners who are “manifest and obstinate” and not on the weak or the doubting, with the goal that the sinner “amend” his life and be received again. The process our Lord gives in Matthew 18 begins privately, moves step by step, and has the restoration of the brother as its aim (Matthew 18:15–17). Paul’s word to the Corinthians about not eating with a so-called brother who lives in open sin (1 Corinthians 5:11) was meant to bring that man to repentance. The same letter tells us that even the Lord’s own discipline is given “so that we may not be condemned along with the world” (1 Corinthians 11:32). Lutheran communion practice is first of all an application of the keys, which are given for the salvation of the sinner.
Luther and those who denied the presence
Luther also faced the question of communion with Christians who did not share the Lutheran confession of the Supper. In 1532 he wrote to Duke Albrecht of Prussia, who was being urged to tolerate preachers in his lands who denied the bodily presence. Luther advised him not to, appealing to the unanimous testimony of the whole Church from the beginning that Christ’s body and blood are truly present in the Sacrament.37 The next year, writing to Lutherans in Frankfurt, he counseled that anyone who knew his preacher taught against the true presence should not receive the Sacrament from him, but should rather go without it than receive it with a confession he could not share.38
We should hear Luther in his own setting. He was speaking about preachers who taught the people what the Supper is, not about a visitor from another church who wished to commune at a Lutheran altar (a situation that hardly arose when each territory had one church). Still, his principle is that receiving the Supper is itself a confession.
V. The Range of Lutheran Practice Today
Closed, close, and open
Once Christians of many confessions came to live on the same street, Lutherans had to apply these principles to a new situation and they have not all applied them the same way. Three terms are commonly used, though not always with the same meaning.
Closed communion usually describes the practice of communing only those who are members of the congregation, of its church body, or of church bodies with which it has declared altar and pulpit fellowship. Close communion is used by some to describe a practice that is closed in principle but that leaves room for the pastor, after conversation with a visitor, to admit him. It should be said that the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod does not distinguish the two. Its own explanation speaks of “close, closed or close(d) Communion” as one practice and says that “Members in good standing of the LCMS and her sister church bodies may commune at LCMS congregations,” while adding that “Pastors may, nevertheless, exercise discretion in special cases or emergencies.”39 Its reason is that this preserves “a unity of confession regarding the Sacrament.”40
At the other end of the Lutheran range, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America adopted The Use of the Means of Grace in 1997. It states, “Believing in the real presence of Christ, this church practices eucharistic hospitality. All baptized persons are welcomed to Communion when they are visiting in the congregations of this church.”41 The ELCA statement grounds its welcome in the real presence. It says that “Admission to the Sacrament is by invitation of the Lord, presented through the Church to those who are baptized.” It recommends “a brief written or oral statement in worship which teaches Christ’s presence in the sacrament,” so that guests can decide whether to accept the invitation, and it asks congregations “to be sensitive to the eucharistic practices of the churches from which visitors may come.”42 What bears most on this welcome must also be said. Since 1997 the ELCA has been in full communion with the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), the Reformed Church in America and the United Church of Christ, whose confessions teach about the Supper what the Formula of Concord rejects (SD VII 115–123).43
Between these two stand many Lutheran congregations and church bodies whose practice welcomes baptized Christians who believe that Christ’s body and blood are truly present, or who belong to a Christian congregation, or who have spoken with the pastor, in various combinations. Some ask visitors to speak with the pastor beforehand. Some print a statement of what Lutherans believe about the Sacrament and ask each guest to examine himself in light of it.
Every practice restricts something
No Lutheran church practices an entirely open Table. The ELCA statement itself, the most open of the official Lutheran texts, restricts the Supper to the baptized and speaks of the unbaptized person who is communed by mistake as someone to be “invited to learn the faith of the Church, be baptized, and thereafter faithfully receive Holy Communion.”44 Historic Lutheran practice has restricted the Table in at least these ways: 1) to the baptized; 2) to those who believe in Christ; 3) to those who have been taught to recognize the body (which is why first communion follows instruction); 4) to those who come in repentance; and 5) to those who are not under the discipline of the Church for open and unrepented sin. The third has never meant that the Lord’s own can fail the examination through dementia or disability. The companion paper Infant Faith and the Lord’s Table takes up the saint who can no longer answer and the baptized person who never could.
In other words, the question among Lutherans is not whether the Table should be guarded but how that care should be given, how it should be communicated, and who should apply it. The Confessions give us the principles: the Supper is for the baptized who believe; communicants are to be instructed, examined and absolved; the keys are to be used for the sinner’s good; and the Supper is a confession of one faith. They give no rubric for receiving a visitor from another church, but they do give the principle that the Supper is received in one confession, and that principle is doctrine and not custom. The Formula allows churches to differ in ceremonies without condemning one another only “provided they are otherwise agreed with one another in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”45 Lutherans may differ in how they apply this care (a conversation with the pastor, a printed statement, or announcement beforehand). They may not set aside the confession the care protects.
VI. How Other Christians Answer
Rome and the East
The two largest Christian communions in the world both practice close communion. The Catechism of the Catholic Church speaks of the pain of division: “The more painful the experience of the divisions in the Church which break the common participation in the table of the Lord, the more urgent are our prayers to the Lord that the time of complete unity among all who believe in him may return.”46 However, it says of the churches of the Reformation that they “have not preserved the proper reality of the Eucharistic mystery in its fullness, especially because of the absence of the sacrament of Holy Orders,” and therefore “Eucharistic intercommunion with these communities is not possible for the Catholic Church.”47 Only in grave necessity, and only for those who hold the Catholic faith concerning the sacraments, does it allow an exception.48 A Lutheran visitor at a Roman Catholic Mass is therefore asked not to commune, and Rome asks the same of its own members at a Lutheran altar.
The Orthodox churches are, if anything, stricter. In the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom the deacon still calls out “The doors! The doors!” before the Creed, a remnant of the ancient guarding of the assembly. Orthodox teachers commonly explain that the Eucharist is the expression of a unity in faith that already exists and not a means of creating one, and so the Orthodox commune only Orthodox Christians who have prepared themselves.49 Lutherans do not share all their reasons (we do not believe that the Supper depends on episcopal ordination in apostolic succession), yet we share their conviction that the Supper and the confession of faith belong together.
Canterbury and Geneva
The Anglican tradition has its own form of the same care. The 1662 Book of Common Prayer closes the order of Confirmation with a rubric: “And there shall none be admitted to the holy Communion, until such time as he be confirmed, or be ready and desirous to be confirmed.”50 The Prayer Book also directed the minister to warn any open and notorious evil liver not to come to the Lord’s Table until he had shown his repentance.51 Anglican practice in many provinces is broader today, yet the formularies show that Cranmer’s Church guarded the Table by catechesis, confirmation and discipline.
The Reformed churches of Scotland and the Netherlands practiced what came to be called “fencing the table,” in which the minister before the Supper warned the impenitent away and invited the penitent to come. The Westminster Larger Catechism asks, “May any who profess the faith, and desire to come to the Lord’s supper, be kept from it?” and answers, “Such as are found to be ignorant or scandalous, notwithstanding their profession of the faith, and desire to come to the Lord’s supper, may and ought to be kept from that sacrament, by the power which Christ hath left in his church, until they receive instruction, and manifest their reformation.”52 In fairness to the Reformed, the question before that one is tender toward the doubting. It says that one who doubts of his being in Christ “may and ought to come to the Lord’s supper, that he may be further strengthened.”53 We part from the Reformed on what is received in the Supper (the companion paper One Body at Many Altars treats this), yet on the duty of guarding it we are closer than many suppose.
Open communion
Many evangelical and free churches practice open communion, inviting all who know and love the Lord Jesus to receive, often without asking about Baptism or church membership. They do this in good conscience. Most of them understand the Supper chiefly as a memorial and an act of the believer’s own faith, so they place the self-examination of 1 Corinthians 11:28 entirely on the individual. If the Supper is chiefly the believer remembering Christ then anyone who believes in Christ may remember Him at any table.
Lutherans cannot follow them there, not for lack of love but because we believe something different is happening at the altar. If Christ’s true body and blood are given then the Church that gives them bears a responsibility a memorial meal would not impose. Open communion is also a recent practice. For nearly all of Christian history, East and West, Catholic and Protestant, the Table was guarded in some way.
VII. Is It Hospitality to Refuse?
The honest objection
The strongest form of the objection deserves to be stated plainly. The Pharisees complained about Jesus, “This man receives sinners and eats with them” (Luke 15:2). In the parable of the great banquet the master tells his servant, “Go out to the highways and hedges and compel people to come in, that my house may be filled” (Luke 14:23). Is the Church that restricts its Table not acting more like the Pharisees than like the Lord? Is a restricted Table not a failure of hospitality?
Webster’s defines hospitality as “the act or practice of receiving and entertaining strangers or guests without reward, or with kind and generous liberality.”54 By that definition the Church must be hospitable. Nothing in the Lutheran practice of admission permits coldness toward a visitor, suspicion of a stranger, or a congregation that makes a guest feel unwanted. A church that guards the Table and neglects the guest has kept the first half of its duty and forgotten the second.
Why the restriction serves the guest
Yet hospitality does not mean giving every guest everything without regard to what is good for him. The meals Jesus ate with sinners in Galilee were the table fellowship of His preaching ministry, by which He called them to repentance and faith. The Supper He instituted in the upper room was a different meal, given to the disciples, with His body and blood. The parable of the wedding banquet, which begins with the king’s servants gathering in “all whom they found, both bad and good,” also includes the guest who came without a wedding garment: “Friend, how did you get in here without a wedding garment?” (Matthew 22:10, 12). The point is not that the king is stingy with invitations but that the guest must receive what the king gives, which is the righteousness of Christ received by faith.
Therefore the Lutheran restriction, rightly understood, serves the guest in three ways. First, it protects him. If the Supper can be received to judgment, then a pastor who asks a visitor what he believes before giving him the body and blood of Christ is doing for him what Paul asks every Christian to do for himself. Second, it respects him. A Roman Catholic or Orthodox visitor belongs to a church that asks him not to commune at a Lutheran altar, and a Baptist visitor may not believe that what is given here is Christ’s body. It is no kindness to invite him to make a confession at the altar that his own conscience or his own church does not make. Third, it tells him the truth. The pain of a restricted Table is the pain of a divided Church and it is better felt and prayed over than hidden.
The pastor’s office and the pastor’s heart
This is also why the Lutheran Church gives the oversight of the Table to the pastor and not to a rule alone. The pastor is a steward of the mysteries (1 Corinthians 4:1), one who keeps watch over souls “as those who will have to give an account” (Hebrews 13:17). He holds the keys on behalf of the congregation and the keys exist to loose more than to bind. Luther’s distinction in the Large Catechism is the pastor’s guide. The “wanton and dissolute” are told to stay away and the “feeble and full of infirmities” are urged to come.55 Luther quotes Hilary there: “If any one have not committed sin for which he can rightly be put out of the congregation and esteemed as no Christian, he ought not stay away from the Sacrament, lest he may deprive himself of life.”56
In other words, the purpose of a pastoral conversation before communion is to learn who this person is, what he believes, and how the Lord’s gift can be given to him rightly, whether today at the altar, or after some instruction, or after Baptism. One guest may be ready to commune, another may need to be taught or baptized, and another may hear what Lutherans believe and decide that he cannot yet confess it. In every case the pastor’s work is to bring the person closer to Christ and not to send him away from Him. The Augsburg Confession’s “examined” and the Apology’s “instructed, examined, and absolved” describe exactly this kind of care.
The ancient Church prayed for those who were not yet admitted, by name, that they would “be thought worthy of the holy mysteries, and of constant communion with the saints.”57 That is the posture the Lutheran Church should take toward every person who does not yet commune at its altar. We pray for them, we teach them if they will let us, and we long for the day when they will receive the Sacrament with us.
What This Means for Us
The invitation that goes to all
What, then, should we say to the visitor who asks why he cannot simply come forward? We should say first that he is welcome, sincerely and without reservation, to everything the Church offers to all: the Word preached, the prayers, the hymns, the fellowship and the friendship of the congregation. We should say that the invitation of Isaiah 55 and Matthew 11 and Revelation 22 is for him. We should say that the Lord who gave His Supper also gave His Church the means by which anyone may come to it: Baptism for the one who is not yet baptized, teaching for the one who wishes to learn, and absolution for the one who is burdened by sin.
When the Ethiopian eunuch heard the Gospel from Philip, he asked, “See, here is water! What prevents me from being baptized?” (Acts 8:36). Nothing prevented him and he was baptized that day. The path to the Table runs through the font and through the Word and nothing stands in the way of anyone who wishes to walk it. The Church guards the Table so that those who come to it may receive Christ to their salvation and not to their judgment, never to keep the world away from Him.
The comfort for those who come
For those of us who already commune, this teaching should make us grateful rather than anxious. The Table is guarded because what is set before us there is precious: the body given for us and the blood shed for us, for the forgiveness of our sins.
And if any one of us feels unworthy to come, we should hear again what the Formula of Concord says. The weak in faith, the troubled and the terrified, those who feel and lament their weakness and wish they could serve God better, “are the truly worthy guests for whom this highly venerable Sacrament [and sacred feast] has been especially instituted and appointed.” The Formula adds, “worthiness does not depend upon great or small weakness or strength of faith, but upon the merit of Christ.”58 Whatever care the Church takes at the Table is taken for such people and never against them. The companion paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper said that the Supper, for Luther, “is not a fence to keep the unworthy out; it is the open hand of God, drawing His children in.” Both papers say the same thing. The care described here guards the gift and its right use and never keeps a sinner from Christ, so that what the open hand of God gives may be received for salvation and not for judgment.
When the priest in Cyril’s Jerusalem said, “Holy things to holy men,” the people did not answer by pointing to their own holiness. They answered, “One is Holy, One is the Lord, Jesus Christ.”59 That is our answer too. We come to the Table not because we are holy but because He is holy and He has made us His own. The same Lord who guards His Table is the Lord who says, “whoever comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6:37), and He wants every guest to come in. Therefore we keep the Table with care, we keep the door open with joy, and we keep praying for the day when “Blessed are those who are invited to the marriage supper of the Lamb” (Revelation 19:9) is fulfilled for all who are His.
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text as published at bookofconcord.org.)
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Augsburg Confession V, XXIV, XXV and XXVIII; Apology XV and XXIV; Smalcald Articles III.ix; Small Catechism, Preface and the Sacrament of the Altar; Large Catechism, the Sacrament of the Altar; Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration VII and X.)
The Early Church
- The Didache (Teaching of the Twelve Apostles). In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7.
- Ignatius of Antioch. Epistle to the Smyrnaeans. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Justin Martyr. First Apology. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Apostolic Constitutions. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7.
- Cyril of Jerusalem. Catechetical Lectures (including the Mystagogical Catecheses). In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 7.
- John Chrysostom. Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 10.
- Augustine. Tractates on the Gospel of John. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 7.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. An Order of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (1523). Luther’s Works, vol. 53. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1965.
- Luther, Martin. Letter to Duke Albrecht of Prussia (1532) and letter to the Christians at Frankfurt am Main (1533). D. Martin Luthers Werke (Weimar Edition), vol. 30/III.
- The Book of Common Prayer (1662).
- The Westminster Larger Catechism (1648).
Modern Church Statements and Studies
- Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997.
- Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. The Use of the Means of Grace: A Statement on the Practice of Word and Sacrament. Chicago: ELCA, 1997.
- A Formula of Agreement. Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Reformed Church in America, and United Church of Christ, 1997.
- The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, Commission on Theology and Church Relations. Admission to the Lord’s Supper: Basics of Biblical and Confessional Teaching. St. Louis: LCMS, 1999.
- Elert, Werner. Eucharist and Church Fellowship in the First Four Centuries. Translated by N. E. Nagel. St. Louis: Concordia, 1966.
- Breck, John. “Why Not ‘Open Communion’?” Orthodox Church in America, oca.org.
Reference
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. New York: S. Converse, 1828.
Footnotes
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (New York: S. Converse, 1828), s.v. “communion,” senses 1 and 2. ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. koinōnia. ↩
-
LC V 33–34. ↩
-
FC SD VII 69. See also SD VII 71: “worthiness does not depend upon great or small weakness or strength of faith, but upon the merit of Christ.” ↩
-
Thayer, Lexicon, s.v. anaxiōs. ↩
-
Thayer, Lexicon, s.v. dokimazō. ↩
-
Thayer, Lexicon, s.v. diakrinō. ↩
-
FC SD VII 60. ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 26.11, NPNF¹, vol. 7. ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 62.1, NPNF¹, vol. 7. ↩
-
FC SD VII 68–70. ↩
-
SC V, “Who, then, receives such Sacrament worthily?” ↩
-
LC V 58–59. ↩
-
Didache 9.5, ANF, vol. 7. The translation at newadvent.org is that of M. B. Riddle. ↩
-
Didache 10.6, ANF, vol. 7. ↩
-
Didache 14.2, ANF, vol. 7. ↩
-
Ignatius of Antioch, Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 7, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Justin Martyr, First Apology 65, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Justin Martyr, First Apology 66, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Apostolic Constitutions VIII.6, ANF, vol. 7. ↩
-
Apostolic Constitutions VIII.12, ANF, vol. 7. ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 11.3, NPNF¹, vol. 7. ↩
-
The term disciplina arcani was coined in the seventeenth century. Scholars differ over how widespread and how strict the practice was; the evidence is strongest for the fourth and fifth centuries, in the mystagogical lectures of Cyril of Jerusalem and Ambrose, which explain the Sacraments to the newly baptized only after their Baptism. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures 23 (Mystagogical Catechesis V) 19, NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures 23 (Mystagogical Catechesis V) 23, NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew 82.6, NPNF¹, vol. 10. The section numbering differs slightly between editions; the passage stands near the end of the homily. ↩
-
Werner Elert, Eucharist and Church Fellowship in the First Four Centuries, trans. N. E. Nagel (St. Louis: Concordia, 1966). Paraphrased. ↩
-
AC XXIV 1, 6. ↩
-
AC XXV 1. ↩
-
Ap XV 40. The bracketed words are from the German text as given in the Triglotta. ↩
-
Ap XXIV 1. ↩
-
LC V 1–2. ↩
-
SC Preface 11. ↩
-
Martin Luther, An Order of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (Formula Missae et Communionis, 1523), LW 53. Paraphrased; the passage stands in the section on the communion of the people. ↩
-
AC XXVIII 21. ↩
-
SA III ix. ↩
-
Martin Luther, letter to Duke Albrecht of Prussia, 1532 (Sendbrief an Herzog Albrecht von Preußen), WA 30/III. Paraphrased. ↩
-
Martin Luther, letter to the Christians at Frankfurt am Main, 1533 (Ein Brief an die zu Frankfurt am Main), WA 30/III. Paraphrased. ↩
-
The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, “Who can commune at a Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod congregation?” in “LCMS Views,” Frequently Asked Questions, lcms.org (accessed October 2026). See also the Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Admission to the Lord’s Supper: Basics of Biblical and Confessional Teaching (St. Louis: LCMS, 1999). ↩
-
LCMS, “Who can commune,” lcms.org. ↩
-
Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, The Use of the Means of Grace: A Statement on the Practice of Word and Sacrament (Chicago: ELCA, 1997), Principle 49. ↩
-
ELCA, Use of the Means of Grace, Principle 37 and Application 49A. ↩
-
A Formula of Agreement (1997), between the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), the Reformed Church in America and the United Church of Christ; see ELCA, “Ecumenical and Inter-Religious Relations: Full Communion,” elca.org (accessed October 2026). ↩
-
ELCA, Use of the Means of Grace, Application 37G. ↩
-
FC SD X 31. ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997), §1398. ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1399–1400, the latter quoting the Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio 22. ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church §1401. ↩
-
See, for example, John Breck, “Why Not ‘Open Communion’?” Orthodox Church in America, oca.org. Paraphrased. Orthodox practice is governed by the canons and by the bishop of each jurisdiction, and its details vary. ↩
-
The Book of Common Prayer (1662), “The Order of Confirmation,” closing rubric. ↩
-
The Book of Common Prayer (1662), “The Order for the Administration of the Lord’s Supper, or Holy Communion,” opening rubrics. Paraphrased. ↩
-
Westminster Larger Catechism (1648), Q. 173. ↩
-
Westminster Larger Catechism, Q. 172. ↩
-
Webster, American Dictionary, s.v. “hospitality.” ↩
-
LC V 58–59. ↩
-
LC V 59. ↩
-
Apostolic Constitutions VIII.6, ANF, vol. 7. ↩
-
FC SD VII 69, 71. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catechesis V.19, NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “A Free Gospel and a Guarded Table: Why Lutheran Congregations Restrict Admission to Holy Communion.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/a-free-gospel-and-a-guarded-table/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.