Books · Women and the Pastoral Office

Appendix B: Frequently Asked Questions

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Q: Isn’t this position just a product of ancient culture? Haven’t we simply moved past it?

I hear this question often, and it deserves an honest answer. The short answer is: Paul does not appeal to ancient culture. He appeals to creation — to what God did before any culture existed. When he writes “Adam was formed first, then Eve,” he is pointing to the garden, not to Rome or Corinth. That happened before patriarchy, before Greco-Roman society, before any human institution at all. I think the “it’s just cultural” argument feels compelling because it lets us off the hook from a difficult text. But a norm rooted in the way God made us cannot be dismissed as a relic of the times. If we could set aside every biblical instruction that feels culturally distant, we would have very little Scripture left to obey.


Q: What about Deborah? She was a judge and leader over Israel.

Deborah was a remarkable woman, and the Bible honors her without apology. But she was not a priest — and the question here is about ordained ministry, not civil leadership or prophecy. God clearly works through women in extraordinary ways, and Deborah is one of the finest examples. It is also worth noticing that when Deborah called Barak to lead the army, she fully expected him to do it. His reluctance to go without her was not a model to follow; the text quietly rebukes it. Deborah’s story shows God’s grace in raising up faithful people when others shrink back. It does not rewrite the structure of Israel’s priesthood — which remained entirely male throughout the Old Testament period.


Q: Wasn’t Junia a female apostle? Doesn’t that settle the question?

Junia is greeted in Romans 16:7 as someone “well known to the apostles” — honored, trusted, and deeply respected. Whether Paul means she was among the apostles or simply well regarded by them is genuinely debated among scholars, and I think reasonable people read it differently. But even setting that aside, “apostle” in the New Testament is sometimes used loosely to describe a missionary or church planter — a high and honored calling, but not the same as the governing, preaching office of the ordained elder. Paul elsewhere gives detailed, gender-specific qualifications for that office. In my view, a single ambiguous greeting in a letter’s closing cannot quietly overturn all of that evidence.


Q: Does this position mean women are inferior to men?

Not at all — and I want to say that as plainly as I possibly can. Men and women are equally made in the image of God, equally loved, equally redeemed, equally filled with the Spirit, and equally heirs of eternal life. The restriction on ordination is not a statement about worth, intelligence, or spiritual depth. It is about the shape of a particular office. Think about it this way: the Son of God submitted to the Father’s will — that did not make him less than the Father. Different roles within a relationship of full equality is not a foreign idea; it is woven into the very life of the Triune God.


Q: What about the gifts of the Spirit? If God gives a woman gifts for ministry, who are we to say no?

God’s gifts are real, and a gifted woman ought to be honored and put to work — I believe that deeply. But gifts alone do not constitute ordination; they never have, for men or women. Paul lists detailed qualifications for the elder’s office that go well beyond giftedness: character, household management, doctrinal soundness, and yes, the qualification of being a man. A twenty-year-old with remarkable preaching gifts still needs formation, maturity, and the church’s affirmation before he is ordained. Gifts open doors; they do not automatically determine which doors. The Spirit distributes gifts freely to all; the office is given by the church according to the Lord’s own pattern.


Q: What about Priscilla? She taught Apollos — doesn’t that show women can teach?

Yes, and it is a beautiful moment in Acts. Priscilla and her husband Aquila pulled Apollos aside privately and helped him understand the faith more fully. Nobody in this tradition disputes that. Women can and should teach — their children, other women, individuals in private settings, and in many other contexts. What Paul restricts is the public, authoritative, ongoing teaching of the congregation from the ordained office. Priscilla had a private conversation with a visiting preacher. In my view, that is a long way from standing in the pulpit as the called and ordained shepherd of a congregation.


Q: Doesn’t the church’s past errors on slavery and race show that the traditional position on women might also be wrong?

The church’s failures on slavery and race were real, and they are not to be minimized. But I think the situations are genuinely different. The New Testament itself pushes against slavery and racial hierarchy — Paul tells slaves to seek freedom if they can, treats Onesimus as a brother equal to Philemon, and declares that in Christ there is no Jew or Greek. The biblical current runs against those evils. On the ordination question, the biblical current runs consistently the other direction — through creation, through the apostolic letters, through the practice of Jesus himself. The church did not err on women’s ordination by faithfully reading Scripture for nineteen centuries; it would err by abandoning that reading now.


Q: Why does this matter today? Isn’t this a secondary issue?

I understand why people wish it were secondary. But the question underneath the question is: does the church receive its shape from the Lord, or does it negotiate that shape with each passing generation? How a church answers the ordination question tends to reveal how it handles Scripture, tradition, and authority more broadly. In my experience, this is not a peripheral matter of preference. It touches the church’s identity and its faithfulness to the One who founded it.


Q: What roles can women hold in the church?

More than is often assumed — and I think the church has often done a poor job of answering this question well. The New Testament shows women prophesying, serving as deaconesses, hosting congregations, supporting the apostolic mission, teaching other women, correcting misunderstanding in private conversation, and being praised by Paul as partners and co-laborers in the gospel. Today, women serve faithfully in Christian education, pastoral care, counseling, mercy ministry, evangelism, music, and much more.

The restriction this book defends is narrow and specific: the publicly authoritative, representative, governing office of the ordained minister. Outside that one office, the field is wide. A church that genuinely honors this position will work hard to ensure that the gifts of its women are seen, valued, and fully deployed — not quietly sidelined.

Topics
Church and Ministry
Scripture
Romans 16:7

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.