Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 11—Article XI: Confession

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

There was a young monk who could not stop confessing. He would kneel before his confessor and go over his sins for hours, and then, walking away, remember one he had missed and turn back. He wore his confessors out. The trouble was not that Martin Luther took sin lightly. He took it with terrible seriousness, and he had been taught that forgiveness depended, in part, on the completeness of his confession. He was caught in a question that has no bottom: Have I confessed enough? Have I remembered everything? Was I sorry enough to be forgiven? Anyone who has lain awake replaying a failure knows that question, even if they have never seen a confessional.

The man who finally helped him did not give him a better method for confessing. Johann von Staupitz, Luther’s superior, turned his eyes away from his own sins and toward Christ (stop staring at the wound, and look at the physician; Luther’s Table Talk in the Weimar edition, WA TR 5, no. 5658a, p. 295). Years later, when the Lutherans came to write the Augsburg Confession, one short article distilled what that rescue had taught, and it is the subject of this chapter.

Article XI is about confession, but its heart is absolution, the word of forgiveness God speaks to the penitent. The main point of this chapter is that absolution is the Gospel addressed personally to you. It is not only the general good news that God forgives sinners, true as that is, but the particular word, spoken to you, by name: your sins are forgiven. There is a great difference between believing that forgiveness exists and hearing Christ personally declare that you are forgiven. Article XI moves us across that distance, from the burden of unmeasurable, half-remembered sin to the freedom of hearing forgiveness spoken aloud.

This is the third of three gifts, and they belong together. In Baptism (Article IX) God claims me, and His promise is spoken over me; in the Lord’s Supper (Article X) Christ feeds me, and His body and blood are given to me; in Absolution Christ’s forgiveness is spoken to me. Three times God comes from outside myself and lays His grace where I can take hold of it. The question to keep asking is this: What does Christ say to the troubled conscience?


1. What the Article Says

Most people assume the Reformation abolished confession. It is one of the most common misunderstandings in all of church history, and Article XI corrects it in a sentence:

Of Confession they teach that Private Absolution ought to be retained in the churches, although in confession an enumeration of all sins is not necessary. For it is impossible according to the Psalm: Who can understand his errors? Ps. 19:12. (AC XI)

Two things are said and the second qualifies the first.

“Private Absolution ought to be retained in the churches.” Far from abolishing confession, the Confession insists on keeping it. The Reformers treasured private confession and absolution and wanted it preserved, and Article XXV says so in as many words: “Confession in the churches is not abolished among us” (AC XXV.1). The Smalcald Articles bind the church to keep it, “Confession or Absolution ought by no means to be abolished in the Church, especially on account of [tender and] timid consciences” (SA III.viii.1), though they bind no conscience to use it. Whatever else Article XI does, it rejects the idea that evangelical Christianity (in the Reformers’ sense of the word, the faith centered on the Gospel) has no room for confessing one’s sins to a pastor and hearing forgiveness pronounced.

“An enumeration of all sins is not necessary.” Here is what actually changed. The medieval Church had come to require that a valid confession be complete, with every serious sin that a diligent search could recall recited by kind and number (what sort of sin and how many times). Article XI denies that this listing is necessary and gives a simple reason from Psalm 19:12, “Who can understand his errors?” (in the ESV, “Who can discern his errors?”). In other words, if no one can even know all his sins, no one can confess them all, and a forgiveness that waited on a finished list would never arrive. The psalmist does not stop at the question. He turns it into a prayer, “Declare me innocent from hidden faults” (Psalm 19:12, ESV). In the Reformers’ experience the requirement left some consciences falsely secure and others, like Luther’s, tormented.

I want you to see what this does and does not touch. It leaves confession standing and removes the burden that had been laid on it. The emphasis moves from the penitent’s work (a complete confession) to God’s gift (the word of absolution).

At Augsburg in 1530 the first half of the article was not contested. The Roman Confutation accepted the retention of private absolution “as catholic and in harmony with our faith.” It contested the second half. It asked that the Lutherans enforce the yearly confession required by the Fourth Lateran Council of 1215 (see section 3), and that penitents use diligence to confess every sin they could remember, though it granted that not all sins can be enumerated. Melanchthon’s reply in the Apology (his defense of the Augsburg Confession) goes straight to the conscience. The adversaries, he says, “ought to show from the divine Law that an enumeration of sins is necessary for obtaining their remission” (Ap XI.6). The quarrels over satisfaction (penances assigned to pay off sin’s remaining penalty) and over indulgences belong to chapter 25 (Article XXV), and the inner structure of repentance belongs to chapter 12 (Article XII), the next chapter.


2. Biblical Theology

Where does the Church get the right to forgive anyone’s sins? It has that right only from Christ, who gave it, and the New Testament records the giving three times.

Christ hands the Church the keys. “I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matthew 16:19). The image is domestic: a key opens and shuts a door. To “loose” is to forgive, opening the kingdom to the penitent; to “bind” is to retain, shutting it against the impenitent until they turn. Jesus speaks this authority first to Peter, as the representative of all the apostles (Matthew 16:19; Tr 22–24), then to the gathered church in the context of reconciling a sinning brother (Matthew 18:18), and finally, on Easter evening, to the apostolic company:

“Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld.” (John 20:22–23)

This is the charter of absolution. The word Jesus uses for “forgive” is aphiēmi, whose first sense is “to send away.” Thayer’s lexicon sets this very verse under the meaning “to let go, give up, a debt, by not demanding it,” that is, “to remit, forgive” (Thayer’s, aphiēmi). In the same breath in which He gives the Spirit, the risen Christ authorizes His Church to forgive sins. He sends them to forgive, so that what is loosed on earth is loosed in heaven. When a pastor, on this authority, says “I forgive you all your sins,” it is heaven that forgives. (How the pastor’s word can be Christ’s word is taken up in section 5.)

Confession itself is directed first to God. None of this displaces the most basic movement of the penitent heart, which is toward God. “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1 John 1:9); “I acknowledged my sin to you… and you forgave the iniquity of my sin” (Psalm 32:5). Christians confess to God and God forgives. That is bedrock and no Lutheran would qualify it. Article XI answers a further question: has Christ also given His Church a way to speak that forgiveness to the troubled conscience, so the sinner need not wonder whether God has heard him and forgiven him? He has.

A picture of it: Nathan and David. The Old Testament shows the pattern in the story of David and Nathan. David has sinned against Uriah and Bathsheba and hidden it; the prophet Nathan tells the story of the ewe lamb and then confronts him with “You are the man!” (2 Samuel 12:7). David confesses: “I have sinned against the LORD.” Nathan answers at once with a word David could never have spoken to himself: “The LORD also has put away your sin” (2 Samuel 12:13). There is confession, and then there is absolution, the forgiveness of God spoken to the penitent by another, on God’s behalf. David did not have to wonder whether God had forgiven him, because Nathan told him so. That is the Office of the Keys at work long before it had a name.

A disputed text. “Therefore, confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed” (James 5:16). Christians read this differently. Many read it simply as speaking of mutual confession among believers, and that reading is fair, since “to one another” is reciprocal and the verse does not by itself set up confession to a pastor. It is enough here that Scripture commends confessing our sins to God always, to one another as love requires (SA III.iv, “the mutual conversation and consolation of brethren”), and (as the Keys texts show) to those Christ has authorized to absolve (SA III.vii–viii).


3. Historical Context

The confession Luther knew was not the confession of the early Church, and to see what Article XI reformed we have to watch how the practice changed over fifteen centuries.

From public penance to private confession. In the earliest centuries there was no routine, private confession of ordinary sins to a priest. Grave, public sins such as apostasy, murder, and adultery met a rigorous public discipline the Greeks called exomologesis (“confession, open acknowledgment”). The sinner was enrolled among the “penitents,” did a long and visible penance, and was reconciled by the bishop, often only once in a lifetime. Tertullian describes it around the year 203.

Private, repeatable confession of everyday sins came later. It was spread notably by Irish and Celtic monasticism from the sixth and seventh centuries, with handbooks assigning set penances, and only gradually became general in the West. A telling early step came around 459, when Pope Leo the Great directed that penitents need not recite their sins in public, because it was enough to confess them privately to the priest. In other words, the form of routine private confession is a medieval development and not an apostolic institution. The Catechism of the Catholic Church tells the same history and credits the Irish missionaries (§1447), though Rome holds that the power being exercised is apostolic. That matters for judging both the Roman and the later Protestant positions.

Lateran IV (1215): confession made mandatory. The decisive turn came at the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215, whose canon 21 required every Christian, at least once a year, to confess all his sins to his own priest and to receive Communion at least at Easter. By the late Middle Ages the sacrament of penance had a settled shape, three acts of the penitent completed by the priest’s absolution. The penitent brought contrition (sorrow for sin, or at least attrition, an imperfect sorrow arising chiefly from fear of punishment, which Rome nonetheless counts a gift of the Holy Spirit), confession (of all mortal sins remembered, by kind and number, a mortal sin being a grave sin committed knowingly and freely), and satisfaction (works to pay sin’s remaining penalty). The absolution itself was increasingly understood as a judicial verdict. (Satisfaction, and the indulgences that grew from it, belong to chapters 24 and 25, Articles XXIV and XXV.) It was the requirement of a complete confession, and the anxious accounting it bred, that would later break over Luther’s conscience.

Trent (1551): Rome’s definition. Responding to the Reformation, the Roman Church defined this teaching dogmatically at the Council of Trent, Session XIV (1551). Penance is a true sacrament; confession of all mortal sins remembered after diligent examination, by kind and number, is required by divine law; attrition disposes the penitent to grace within the sacrament; priestly absolution is a judicial act; and satisfaction is required. This is the considered Roman position compared with Article XI in section 6.


4. Early Church Witness

The Fathers do not settle the question for either side.

What they clearly show is that the ancient Church took post-baptismal sin seriously and believed Christ had given it a real ministry of reconciliation. Ambrose of Milan, against the Novatianists in the fourth century, defended the Church’s God-given power to forgive (his argument is followed in chapter 12). That is the Office of the Keys exercised in the early Church, and the Lutheran retention of absolution stands in continuity with it. John Chrysostom, meanwhile, repeatedly urged his hearers to confess their sins to God, stressing the mercy that meets the penitent. The Augsburg Confession itself appealed to that strand, quoting Chrysostom by way of Gratian’s Decretum (the medieval Church’s standard collection of church law): “confess your sins before God, the true Judge, with prayer” (AC XXV.11). The Roman Confutation replied that Chrysostom was speaking there of public confession, not of confession to a priest, and so Chrysostom has to be read in full by both sides rather than used as a slogan.

What the Fathers do not show is the later system. The public, once-only penance of Tertullian’s day is not the mandatory, enumerated, private auricular (spoken into the priest’s ear) sacrament defined at Lateran IV and Trent. It is equally far from a purely inward piety, found in every tradition, that would leave the troubled conscience with no spoken word of forgiveness at all.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The Confession’s own teaching gathers into a few clear affirmations, all serving one pastoral end: that the sinner would hear forgiveness.

Confession has two parts, and the second is the point. In Luther’s Small Catechism, “Confession embraces two parts: the one is, that we confess our sins; the other, that we receive absolution, or forgiveness, from the confessor, as from God Himself, and in no wise doubt, but firmly believe, that our sins are thereby forgiven before God in heaven.” Before God we confess ourselves guilty of all sins, even those we cannot see; before the confessor we confess “those sins alone which we know and feel in our hearts,” which settles the enumeration question at the level of practice. The weight falls on the second part, because the confessing is there for the sake of the absolution.

Absolution is Christ’s own word, spoken through the pastor’s mouth, and it is pure Gospel. When the pastor forgives your sins according to Christ’s command, Christ Himself is speaking His forgiveness. The Apology puts it this way: “the voice of the one absolving must be believed not otherwise than we would believe a voice from heaven” (Ap XII.40–41). Christ said the same of those He sent: “The one who hears you hears me” (Luke 10:16). The absolution is not the pastor’s opinion that God is probably favorable. It is the actual delivery of Christ’s forgiveness to this person now.

Therefore, the pastor’s own worthiness is beside the point. The pastor’s authority is not personal authority; it is borrowed authority, exercised only because Christ has commanded it. Ministers, the Apology says, “represent the person of Christ, and do not represent their own persons” (Ap VII–VIII.28). That one truth guards against two errors at once, the clericalism that would make the minister a lord over consciences and the skepticism that asks, “Who is he to forgive me?” Rome, too, holds that Christ forgives through the priest whatever the priest’s own worthiness. What is distinctly Lutheran is that this word is received by faith alone. Faith trusts that God forgives “for the sake of His own promise, not for the sake of our works, contrition, confession, or satisfactions” (Ap XII.95), and so absolution does not wait on a complete list or on any work or worthiness in the penitent.

Sidebar—The Office of the Keys, and how absolution “works.” The technical question: when the pastor absolves, is he merely announcing a forgiveness God has already granted, or is his word an instrument through which God actually conveys forgiveness? The Lutheran answer is the second. Absolution is a means of grace (one of the ways God actually delivers His gifts, like the preached Word, Baptism, and the Supper), a real delivery of the forgiveness Christ won, received by faith, for the Apology rejects the teaching that it profits “without faith in Christ” (Ap XII.25). The absolution does declare forgiveness and the declaration is itself the gift. This is why the Confessions speak of it alongside the Word and the Sacraments, and the Apology even counts it among them: “Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance, are truly Sacraments” (Ap XIII.4). Elsewhere the Confessions speak of two Sacraments, and the Apology does not quarrel over the number, “provided they still preserve aright the matters handed down in Scripture” (Ap XIII.2). Rome agrees that absolution actually conveys forgiveness, but it frames the priest’s word as a judicial act (a verdict of pardon within the sacrament of penance, given after the penitent’s confession). The Reformed tradition speaks of the minister as declaring God’s forgiveness in the preaching of the Gospel, which it holds truly opens the kingdom, and it keeps no private office of absolution.

The distinction sounds subtle, but it decides everything the troubled conscience cares about: is “I forgive you” a report, or a gift? The Lutheran says it is a gift. Many of us learned this from the “Office of the Keys” questions printed in our catechisms (“What is the Office of the Keys?”). They are not part of the Small Catechism in the Book of Concord. They were drawn from Lutheran catechetical preaching and added later. They teach what Luther taught, but the words are not his own.

The binding key, briefly. The Keys “loose” and also “bind” (Matthew 16:19; John 20:23). To bind is to withhold absolution from the impenitent as a summons to repent. It takes sin seriously enough to refuse to say “peace” where there is no repentance, so that the sinner may turn and be loosed. Binding serves loosing. It is not the emotional center of this article, however, and must not become so; Article XI is overwhelmingly about the open key, the word that sets free.

Absolution belongs among the means of grace. Set Article XI in its place and a pattern appears. Article V taught that God gives the Spirit and faith through the external Word (the Gospel preached, and the Sacraments) and not through inner experience apart from these means. Article XI is that same principle applied to the individual conscience, and the Word, Baptism, Absolution, and the Supper are Christ’s ordinary way of giving Himself. Luther says the same in the Smalcald Articles. The Gospel, he writes, gives “counsel and aid against sin” in more than one way: through the spoken Word, through Baptism, through the Sacrament of the Altar, “through the power of the keys, and also through the mutual conversation and consolation of brethren” (SA III.iv). When he comes to confession he holds firmly, against the “enthusiasts” (those who claimed the Spirit spoke to them directly, apart from the Word), that “God grants His Spirit or grace to no one, except through or with the preceding outward Word” (SA III.viii.3). Absolution is the same Gospel as Baptism and the Supper, delivered by speech to the person who needs to hear it. The keys belong to the whole Church, and so the Treatise can say that “in a case of necessity even a layman absolves, and becomes the minister and pastor of another” (Tr 67).

Confession is a gift, not a law. Finally, the Confessions commend private confession warmly while refusing to make it compulsory. In the Large Catechism’s “Brief Exhortation to Confession,” Luther distinguishes the kinds of confession: to God, to the neighbor we have wronged, and the private confession we make to a brother in order to hear absolution, which in practice is ordinarily made to the pastor (Brief Exhortation 13–14). He presses the last as a treasure while refusing to force it, and he can say that to urge someone to go to confession is simply to urge him to be a Christian (Brief Exhortation 32). He rejects with equal force the tyranny that compels confession and the contempt that despises it. He wanted it used for the relief of consciences and never as a burden on them, which raises a question taken up in section 7, whether a church that has let this gift lapse might do well to recover it.


6. Comparative Theology

Christians differ over confession less bitterly than over the Supper, but the differences are real, and as always each tradition is stated first from its own sources and in its strongest fair form. Several of these traditions guard something the Lutheran gladly honors.

Roman Catholic. The Roman Catholic Church teaches that penance (or reconciliation) is a sacrament in which the penitent’s contrition, confession, and satisfaction, together with the priest’s absolution, restore the grace lost by grave (mortal) sin. A valid confession names all grave sins of which the penitent is conscious after diligent self-examination, by kind and number. Sins honestly forgotten are held to be included in the absolution, and the confession of venial (lesser) sins is recommended but not required (Catechism §§1422–1498, esp. 1456–1458; Trent, Session XIV, ch. 5). A common caricature must be cleared away before any evaluation: Roman Catholics do not believe they earn forgiveness by confessing. Their own teaching is that God forgives, that absolution is Christ’s gift, and that even contrition is prompted by grace; confession and satisfaction are the penitent’s acts within a sacrament whose power they locate in Christ, not in the penitent’s performance. Stated fairly, the Roman position shares much with the Lutheran. Both hold that sin is to be confessed, that absolution truly forgives, and that the Keys are Christ’s gift.

The Lutheran difference is precise, and it is best kept where Luther kept it, on the conscience. The first difference is the requirement to enumerate. Rome concedes that not every sin can be remembered (the Confutation said as much in 1530), and it holds that forgotten sins are forgiven. The Lutheran objection is to the obligation itself, because the conscience is still sent inward to search and can never be sure the search was diligent enough. Article XI denies that a complete list is necessary (Psalm 19:12) and Luther leaves the naming of sins “free to every one” (SA III.viii.2). The second is satisfaction. Works assigned to pay sin’s remaining penalty tend to obscure the freeness of the forgiveness Christ has already won (the fuller reckoning with satisfaction and indulgences belongs to chapters 24 and 25, Articles XXIV and XXV). The third is the judicial framing. Rome also holds that absolution truly forgives. However, it frames the priest’s word as a judge’s verdict, given once the penitent has made a complete confession, and the Lutheran hears that word as a promise to the penitent, to be believed, which waits on no complete list. Confidence: high (a dogmatic council and the universal Catechism).

Eastern Orthodox. The Eastern Orthodox Church receives confession before a priest, often a “spiritual father,” as one of the holy mysteries (sacraments). In many jurisdictions it is expected before Communion, and it ends with a prayer of absolution. In Kallistos Ware’s account, “in the Greek books the formula of absolution is deprecative,” a prayer that God forgive, while the priest’s first-person form in the Slavic books (“I, an unworthy priest, through the power given me by Him, forgive and absolve you from all your sins”) “was originally introduced into Orthodox service books under Latin influence by Peter of Moghila in the Ukraine” (The Orthodox Church, the chapter “Orthodox Worship, II: The Sacraments”; ch. 14 in the new edition of 1993). Its frame is less juridical than the medieval West’s and more therapeutic. The priest is witness and physician of souls, and penances (epitimia) may be given as medicine for healing rather than as satisfaction for a debt. Agreement: the ministry of reconciliation and a real absolution. Divergence: the priest’s different role and the absence of the Western satisfaction system; practice varies by jurisdiction. Confidence: moderate.

Anglican. The Anglican tradition made private confession available but not required, a stance often summed up in a maxim almost tailor-made for this article: “All may. Some should. None must.” The Book of Common Prayer invites anyone who “cannot quiet his own conscience” to “open his grief” to a minister and “receive the benefit of absolution” (1662, the Communion exhortation). In the Visitation of the Sick it directs that a sick person troubled “with any weighty matter” be moved to make a special confession, and the priest absolves him in the first person: “by his authority committed to me, I absolve thee from all thy sins.” The American Prayer Book of 1979 provides a rite for “The Reconciliation of a Penitent.” The range is in the Prayer Book itself. Every priest is ordained with Christ’s words from John 20, “Whose sins thou dost forgive, they are forgiven,” and the daily office’s absolution declares that God has given His ministers power “to declare and pronounce” forgiveness to the penitent. The Thirty-Nine Articles, for their part, count only Baptism and the Supper as “Sacraments of the Gospel,” and Article XXV says that “Those five commonly called Sacraments, that is to say, Confirmation, Penance, Orders, Matrimony, and extreme Unction, are not to be counted for Sacraments of the Gospel.” In practice the tradition ranges from an Anglo-Catholic use near Rome’s to an evangelical one that confesses directly to God. Agreement (close to the Lutheran): confession retained, valued, and never compelled. Confidence: moderate (no single teaching authority; the range is represented).

Reformed, Presbyterian, Methodist, and Baptist / Evangelical. The traditions many of this book’s readers know best confess their sins directly to God, and God forgives them. That is true and biblical (1 John 1:9), and it is not to be belittled. The Reformed churches locate the “keys” chiefly in the preaching of the Word and in the congregation’s discipline rather than in a private priestly absolution (Heidelberg Catechism Q83–85; Westminster Confession, on repentance and church censures). They did not forbid private counsel. The Second Helvetic Confession does “not disapprove” of anyone seeking comfort privately from a minister, and Calvin commended it to troubled consciences. What they refused was to make it a requirement or a sacrament. Methodists inherited the Anglican refusal to count penance a sacrament (their Article XVI keeps Article XXV’s sentence on “Those five commonly called sacraments”), and Wesley’s early band societies practiced mutual confession on the warrant of James 5:16. Baptists and most Evangelicals, holding the priesthood of all believers, confess to God directly and to one another mutually (James 5:16), without a retained office of absolution; where no binding text speaks, this is a broad tendency rather than a single doctrine. Lutherans share that mutual consolation, for Luther counted it among the forms the Gospel takes (SA III.iv).

Having granted the real agreement, I would ask only one further question: What additional gift has Christ given His Church? Alongside confession to God and to one another, Christ has authorized His Church to speak His forgiveness back to us, laying the general Gospel on the individual conscience by name. Nothing in that diminishes confessing directly to God. It adds the comfort of hearing an answer to what we have confessed. Confidence: moderate for the Reformed confessions; limited for the broad Evangelical tendency, which has no binding text.

Each tradition is answering one question (where, and how, does Christ speak His forgiveness?). The Lutheran answer shares the spoken absolution with Rome, the Orthodox, and the Anglicans, and it keeps that word as close to the sinner as it can without laying a burden on him: in the Scriptures, in the sermon to the congregation, and also spoken to him, by name, on Christ’s command, to be received by faith alone.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

Article XI matters most where a conscience is troubled, and few doctrines in this book reach it as directly.

When you cannot stop confessing the same sin, or feel that your repentance is never enough, the worst counsel anyone could give you is to go back inside yourself to try harder and feel more sorrow. That is the road that led the young Luther toward despair, because a troubled conscience can always find one more sin to worry about. Article XI turns you around to face a word spoken to you from outside: your sins are forgiven. You do not have to finish the list, because Christ has already paid for every sin on it, including the ones you cannot remember. You need not feel forgiven before you are told you are, because the telling comes first and faith takes it at its word. If your fear is that you were not sorry enough, the absolution was never a reward for the depth of your sorrow. It asks only that you come wanting to be rid of the sin and wanting Christ’s forgiveness for it, and God does not despise that sorrow, for “a broken and contrite heart, O God, you will not despise” (Psalm 51:17). He forgives for the sake of His promise and not for the sake of your contrition (Ap XII.95). If you fear that your faith is too weak to take hold of it, remember that the gift does not depend on the strength of your grip, for of Christ it is written, “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3). When your conscience will not be quiet, go where Christ has promised to give Himself, to His Word preached and read, to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to His Supper.

Consider a moment most Lutherans have lived through without noticing how remarkable it is. Near the start of the service the congregation makes its general confession together (in many Lutheran churches, “I, a poor, miserable sinner, confess unto You all my sins”), and then the pastor, on Christ’s command, speaks to us what Nathan spoke to David, God’s forgiveness on God’s behalf: “I forgive you all your sins in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.” If you have said those words week after week and heard the absolution as mere routine, Article XI asks you to hear it again for what it is, Christ speaking your forgiveness out loud, to you.

Many Lutherans have forgotten one of the Church’s greatest pastoral treasures. Alongside that general confession, the Lutheran Church has kept the door open to private confession and absolution, as Article XI insists it must. There a person may name, to a pastor bound to secrecy, the specific sin that will not leave the conscience alone, and hear forgiveness spoken for that sin. It is not required; the Confessions will not make it a law and neither will this book. It is offered freely and warmly to any conscience that would be helped by it, because the purpose of private confession is not to burden the conscience but to relieve it. That sin was forgiven on Sunday with all the rest. A troubled conscience may still need to hear the same forgiveness laid on that one sin by name, and Christ has given His Church a way to do exactly that. I would gladly commend it to any reader whose conscience keeps going back to one sin. To make use of it, ask your pastor for a time to make your confession and hear the absolution. The same word has an edge for the careless, though. If you would hear the absolution as leave to go on in a sin you have no wish to give up, hear the other key as well, for what Christ looses for the penitent He binds for the impenitent (Matthew 16:19).

Sidebar—The seal of confession. What is confessed privately to a pastor is not repeated, whether to family, to the congregation, from the pulpit, or under pressure. This confidentiality is called the “seal,” and it exists for the sake of the conscience. A conscience will speak freely only where it is perfectly safe, and the pastor holds what he hears as something spoken, finally, to God. Lutheran church orders and pastoral practice have guarded it with the utmost strictness, though the Confessions themselves do not legislate it. Walther’s Pastoraltheologie holds that a pastor who gossips from the confessional has forfeited his office and deserves to be deposed, and it quotes the Lutheran teacher Johann Fecht that not only Rome but the whole Lutheran Church commands this silence to be kept holy (C. F. W. Walther, Americanisch-Lutherische Pastoraltheologie [St. Louis, 1872], §16, note 7, pp. 165–67). The same note, with the older Lutheran teachers it quotes (Fecht, Deyling, Dannhauer), allows one exception: a confessed intention to commit a grave crime, such as murder, treason, or arson, may be disclosed when warning the penitent has failed.

What does Christ say to the troubled conscience? He says neither “try harder,” nor “remember more,” nor “come back when you are sorrier.” He says, through the mouth He has authorized and on the authority He alone can give, I forgive you all your sins. The Christian does not finally rest in the memory of having confessed well, but in Christ’s Word declaring him forgiven.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article XI confesses that private absolution ought to be retained in the churches, though the enumeration of all sins is not necessary, because no one can discern all his errors (Psalm 19:12). Its heart is God’s speaking rather than the sinner’s. Absolution is the Gospel addressed personally to the penitent, not only the general news that God forgives sinners but the particular word, “your sins are forgiven,” which moves the conscience from silent guilt to spoken forgiveness.

This word rests on the Office of the Keys (Matthew 16:19; 18:18; John 20:22–23), Christ’s gift to His Church to forgive and retain sins. When the pastor absolves on Christ’s command, Christ Himself forgives, for the pastor’s authority is not personal but borrowed, and the word is received by faith alone. Absolution belongs among the means of grace. With the Word, Baptism, and the Supper, it is Christ’s ordinary way of giving Himself, the third of three gifts, in which God’s promise is spoken over me (Baptism), Christ’s body and blood are given to me (the Supper), and Christ’s forgiveness is spoken to me (Absolution).

The Reformation kept confession and freed it by removing the required enumeration and moving comfort from the penitent’s work to Christ’s word. Rome keeps confession as a sacrament in which absolution truly forgives, in the form of a judicial act; it requires the confession of all grave sins remembered after diligent examination and the acceptance of satisfaction, and within the sacrament it accepts an imperfect sorrow (attrition), which it counts a gift of grace. It does not teach that one earns forgiveness by confessing. The Orthodox receive confession as a holy mystery, therapeutic in frame, before a spiritual father. Anglicans hold that “All may. Some should. None must.” The Reformed, Methodists, and most Evangelicals confess directly to God and to one another, and the Reformed locate the keys in preaching and discipline while permitting private counsel with a minister. To all of them the Lutheran grants the real agreement and then offers the added gift of Christ’s forgiveness spoken to the individual.

The Confessions commend private confession warmly but never compel it. It is a treasure worth recovering.

8.2 Tables in this chapter

Table 11.1—Confession: Required, Retained, or Rejected—Five Traditions

Tradition Private confession Enumeration of sins required? Who absolves, and how? Primary source
Roman Catholic Required for grave sins (at least yearly, and before Communion when conscious of mortal sin); a sacrament (CCC §1457) Yes—all mortal sins remembered after diligent examination, by kind and number; venial sins recommended, not required The priest, in the form of a judicial act; with satisfaction CCC §§1422–1498; Trent XIV
Lutheran Retained (the church is bound to keep it: AC XI; SA III.viii.1), commended, not compelled No (Ps 19:12) The pastor, on Christ’s command, delivering Christ’s forgiveness, received by faith (a means of grace) AC XI, XXV; Ap XI–XII; SA III.iv, vii–viii; SC “Confession”; LC “Brief Exhortation”
Eastern Orthodox A holy mystery; often expected before Communion (varies by jurisdiction) Not in the Western enumerated sense The priest, as witness and physician; therapeutic frame The rite of confession
Anglican Available, not required—“All may. Some should. None must.” No A minister, pronouncing absolution; range of views BCP 1662 (exhortation; Visitation of the Sick); BCP 1979 (Reconciliation of a Penitent); 1662 Ordinal; 39 Articles XXV
Reformed / Methodist / Baptist / Evangelical Not a sacrament or office; private counsel with a minister permitted (Reformed) No Confession directly to God; keys in preaching and discipline (Reformed); mutual confession Heidelberg Q83–85; Second Helvetic 14; Westminster; Methodist Articles XVI; 1 John 1:9; James 5:16

*Confidence: high on the Roman Catholic and Lutheran rows; moderate on the Orthodox, Anglican, and Reformed rows (internal range / non-juridical self-understanding); limited on the broad Evangelical tendency (no binding text). *

Table 11.2—The Office of the Keys Across Traditions

Question Lutheran Roman Catholic Reformed Anglican
Where are the keys located? In the ministry of the Word—preaching and private absolution In the ordained priesthood, esp. the sacrament of penance In preaching and in the congregation’s discipline; private counsel permitted In the ordained ministry (given at ordination, 1662 Ordinal); private absolution available
Is absolution effective or declarative? Effective—it declares and delivers Christ’s forgiveness, received by faith Effective, in the form of a judicial act (a verdict of pardon) Declarative—announces God’s forgiveness to the penitent Ranges (declarative to effective)
Is enumeration required? No Yes (mortal sins remembered after diligent examination) n/a No

The Lutheran distinctive: absolution is Christ’s forgiveness delivered to the individual and received by faith, by the same means-of-grace principle as Baptism and the Supper.

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Office of the Keys—the authority Christ gave the Church to forgive and retain sins.
  • Absolution—the forgiveness of sins spoken to the penitent on Christ’s command; in Lutheran teaching, Christ’s own forgiveness, declared and given.
  • Contrition—genuine sorrow for sin (developed in chapter 12).
  • Attrition—imperfect sorrow for sin, arising from fear rather than love (chapter 12).
  • Private, general, and auricular confession—explained in sections 4 and 7.
  • Enumeration and satisfaction—glossed in the text; satisfaction is developed in chapters 24 and 25 (Articles XXIV and XXV).

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XI (and XXV); Apology XI–XIII; the Small Catechism’s “Confession” (and the “Office of the Keys” section, noting its later origin); the Large Catechism’s “A Brief Exhortation to Confession”; Smalcald Articles III.iv and III.vii–viii.
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3; Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions.
  • On the history of penance and confession: Bernhard Poschmann, Penance and the Anointing of the Sick; John T. McNeill & Helena Gamer, Medieval Handbooks of Penance; Thomas Tentler, Sin and Confession on the Eve of the Reformation.
  • On Luther and Staupitz: Heiko Oberman, Luther: Man Between God and the Devil, or Martin Brecht, Martin Luther, vol. 1.
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1422–1498 and Trent, Session XIV; the Heidelberg Catechism (Q83–85), the Second Helvetic Confession (ch. 14), and the Westminster Confession; the Book of Common Prayer (the Communion exhortation and the Visitation of the Sick) and the Thirty-Nine Articles (XXV); for the Orthodox, a service book and a modern treatment (e.g., Ware).
Topics
Sin and RepentanceConfession and AbsolutionForgivenessOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Psalm 19:12Matthew 16:19Matthew 18:18John 20:22–231 John 1:9Psalm 32:52 Samuel 12:72 Samuel 12:13James 5:16Luke 10:16John 20:23Psalm 51:17Isaiah 42:3
Confessions
AC XIAC XXVSA IIIAp XIAp XIIAp VIIAp XIIISCLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.