Chapter 10—Article X: The Lord's Supper (The Holy Supper)
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
There is a question that comes to the communion rail more often than pastors know, and it rarely comes in words. It comes in the eyes of the person kneeling there, someone who has counted up the week and found it wanting, who has come forward mostly out of habit and is half-afraid to. Is this really for me? The question is not about the faithful in general but about me, with my temper, my coldness, and the same confessed sin come back again.
The chapter before this one asked how I can know that God’s promise is really for me, and it answered with Baptism, His promise spoken over us and His name laid upon us before we could do anything to earn it. Article X answers the next question, the one a Christian asks every week for the rest of his life: How does Christ continue to feed me? If Baptism is God’s promise spoken over me, the Lord’s Supper is Christ’s gift placed into my hands, His own body and blood, “Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins” (SC VI). The two sacraments are a matched pair. What matters most is not what we do for God, but what God gives to us in Christ.
Those two words, for you, are the refrain of this chapter. The whole weight of the Supper’s comfort rests there, neither on how worthy you feel nor on how well you prepared, but on what Christ objectively gives and says. The anxious communicant asks, “Am I worthy enough? Did I feel enough?” The Supper answers him, “Take, eat.”
This chapter, then, moves from the terror of unworthiness to the comfort of Christ’s “for you.” The disagreements between Lutherans and the Reformed, or over the real presence and symbolism, are real and we will not pretend they are small. However, the heart of the chapter is Christ’s invitation to sinners to come to His table, and beneath it lies one plain question: What comfort does Christ place into the hands of the communicant? I want you to carry that question through every page that follows.
1. What the Article Says
Article X is the shortest confession of the greatest mystery. It states a fact and draws a line:
Of the Supper of the Lord they teach that the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed to those who eat the Supper of the Lord; and they reject those that teach otherwise. (AC X)1
“The Body and Blood of Christ are truly present.” The Latin word is vere (“truly”). Christ’s body and blood are really present, neither by sign or symbol only nor merely in the sincere memory of the congregation. Christ is there, His true body and blood, under the bread and the wine.
“And are distributed to those who eat.” The body and blood are distributed, handed out and received in the mouth by the people who come. The Supper is something given to you, not chiefly something you do.
“And they reject those that teach otherwise.” Here is the article’s condemnation, aimed chiefly at other Protestants rather than at Rome, where most readers would expect it to fall.
When the Roman theologians answered the Augsburg Confession in 1530, they approved the words of Article X, because Rome, too, confessed a true and bodily presence. They added two conditions, however: that the whole Christ be confessed as present under each kind, and that the bread be confessed as changed into His body. The Apology could still say simply, “The Tenth Article has been approved” (Ap X.1). The Lutheran–Roman quarrels lay elsewhere, over the sacrifice of the Mass (chapter 24), the withheld cup (chapter 22), and transubstantiation as an explanation of the presence. The condemnation points instead at the Swiss reformers and the more radical preachers, who had begun to teach that “this is my body” must mean “this represents my body,” and that Christ’s body, ascended into heaven, cannot be present on ten thousand altars at once. That disagreement would break the Reformation in half.
2. Biblical Theology
2.1 The Words of Institution
Four New Testament witnesses record the words Jesus spoke at the Passover table on the night He was betrayed (Matthew, Mark, Luke, and Paul). Paul, writing to Corinth around AD 54, reports them as tradition he had already received: “For I received from the Lord what I also delivered to you” (1 Corinthians 11:23, ESV). Matthew’s form is the fullest: “Take, eat; this is my body. … Drink of it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins” (Matthew 26:26–28). Matthew alone adds that last phrase and it fixes the Supper’s purpose. Luke records, “This is my body, which is given for you. Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19), and Paul has “This is my body, which is for you” (1 Corinthians 11:24).
These words are a testament, a last will spoken by a man about to die. An heir does not debate how the estate can possibly be his; he receives what the one who died left him.
2.2 The participation: 1 Corinthians 10:16
If one passage carries this chapter, as Romans 3 carried the chapter on justification, it is this one:
The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? (1 Corinthians 10:16)
What does Paul mean by “participation”? The word is koinōnia (“sharing, communion, a real joining”). Thayer defines it as “fellowship, association, community, communion, joint participation,” and gives as its first sense “the share which one has in anything, participation” (Thayer’s Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, s.v. koinōnia). (In this verse Thayer, following the nineteenth-century commentator H. A. W. Meyer, takes the participation to be in the benefits of Christ’s death rather than in His body and blood.) Paul’s own argument, though, needs the word to mean something stronger. He is warning the Corinthians that the one who eats at the idol’s table becomes a participant with the demons behind it (1 Corinthians 10:20–21). The warning collapses unless the parallel holds, unless the cup we bless is a real participation in the blood of Christ and the bread we break a real participation in His body. A symbol cannot join you to anything and a memory cannot make you a partner. The Apology makes the same argument from this verse: if the Lord’s body were not truly present, “the bread is not a communion of the body, but only of the spirit of Christ” (Ap X.1).
If the bread and cup really join us to Christ’s body and blood, His body and blood are really present, and the rest of the chapter is drawn out of that one thing.
2.3 “In an unworthy manner”: 1 Corinthians 11
Paul’s other great Supper text is the warning that keeps anxious Christians away from the altar:
Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself. (1 Corinthians 11:27–29)
First, no one can be “guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord” by mishandling a mere symbol. The passage that frightens people is one of the strongest witnesses to the real presence in the New Testament.
Second, Paul writes “in an unworthy manner,” and the Greek word is an adverb (anaxiōs, “unworthily”). It describes how one eats. Paul is not saying, “Only those who are worthy in themselves may come.” If he were, the table would be empty! The Catechism does call a communicant “truly worthy and well prepared,” but it means the one who “has faith in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins” (SC VI). The Formula of Concord says that “there is only one kind of unworthy guests, namely, those who do not believe” (FC Ep VII.18). Paul is warning against coming carelessly, as the Corinthians did (1 Corinthians 11:20–21). In other words, the unworthy manner is unbelief and a contempt for the gift that has no wish to repent, and it is not a troubled conscience. If you fear that your faith is too weak to count, hear the next article of the Formula: “no true believer, as long as he retains living faith, however weak he may be, receives the Holy Supper to his judgment” (FC Ep VII.19).
2.4 The disputed text: John 6
Many readers expect this chapter to lean on John 6: “unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you” (John 6:53). Some Fathers, and Rome, read it as directly about the Supper, while much of the Lutheran tradition holds that it is primarily about feeding on Christ by faith. Memorialists (those who hold that the Supper is a memorial only) appeal to John 6:63 (“It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh is no help at all”), but that verse is just as disputed. I would rather not rest the doctrine on a passage the Church has never agreed about. It stands on the Words of Institution and on 1 Corinthians 10:16.
2.5 The crux: “is” or “signifies”?
When Jesus says “this is my body,” what does “is” mean? The plain-sense reading, held by Lutherans and in their own ways by Rome and the East, takes the word at face value. The figurative reading (Zwingli’s, and the memorialists’) takes “is” to mean “signifies,” as in “I am the door” (John 10:9), and argues that a body can be in only one place. Calvin read the words as a sacramental figure (the sign called by the name of what it gives), yet taught that the sign truly gives it, more than a symbol but not a bodily presence.
The Lutheran does not claim that “is” can never be figurative. He claims that here, in a solemn testament where nothing in the text signals a figure, we have no authority to make Christ say the opposite of what He said.
3. Historical Context
3.1 One faith, then a fracture
For fifteen centuries the Church, East and West, confessed with rare dissent that Christ is truly present in the Supper. The how was debated, but the that was the common inheritance of Christendom. Luther attacked transubstantiation as a theory in The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), but never the presence it was meant to explain.
Beginning around 1524, Andreas Karlstadt, and then more powerfully Huldrych Zwingli (1484–1531) in Zurich, argued that “this is my body” must be read figuratively. For Zwingli the Supper was chiefly a memorial and a public profession of faith, and Johannes Oecolampadius of Basel argued along the same lines. Luther answered in That These Words of Christ, “This Is My Body,” Still Stand Firm (1527) and the great Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper (1528).
3.2 Marburg, 1529
In October 1529 Philip of Hesse gathered Luther, Melanchthon, Zwingli, and Oecolampadius at his castle in Marburg, hoping to unite the German and Swiss wings of the Reformation against a hostile emperor. By tradition, Luther opened by writing on the table in chalk four Latin words, Hoc est corpus meum (“This is my body”), and refused through days of debate to rub them out.
Marburg was both a tragedy and an act of fidelity. It was a tragedy because the parties drew up fifteen articles and agreed on fourteen. Even on the fifteenth, the Supper, they agreed that the Sacrament is “a sacrament of the true body and blood of Jesus Christ” and that the spiritual eating of that body and blood is necessary for every Christian. On the one point of whether the true body and blood are bodily present in the bread and wine, they could not agree, and the article itself asks each side to show the other Christian love, so far as conscience allows. Luther reportedly told the Swiss (some accounts say Bucer), “You have a different spirit,” and they parted. Men who confessed one Christ and one Gospel could not kneel together at the same table, and it is right to grieve that.
It was also fidelity. Luther would not make “is” mean “signifies,” neither to gain an ally he badly needed nor under the pressure of a prince, because he believed the words belonged to Christ and not to him. It is tragic that brothers could not share the table, and it is also understandable (even admirable) that Luther would not compromise Christ’s words to force a union. Table 10.3 sets out how near and how far the two sides stood.
3.3 Rome defines, and the Lutherans settle
Rome defined its teaching at the Council of Trent, Session XIII (1551): the true, real, and substantial presence of Christ; transubstantiation as the fitting name for the change; and the adoration of the Sacrament.
After Luther’s death (1546) some Lutherans, later called “Crypto-Calvinists,” took up Calvin’s view of the Supper while keeping Lutheran language. The Formula of Concord (1577) settled the matter. Its Article VII reaffirmed the true and substantial presence and the oral reception of Christ’s body and blood, grounding them on Christ’s Word and omnipotence rather than on any theory, and Article VIII set out the teaching about Christ’s person that stands behind it.
4. Early Church Witness
The early Church’s witness to a real presence is strong and early, and the Apology cites the Greek liturgy and Cyril of Alexandria so that readers “may the more clearly perceive that we defend the doctrine received in the entire Church” (Ap X.4).
Ignatius of Antioch, on his way to martyrdom around AD 108, calls the Eucharist “the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins,” and elsewhere “the medicine of immortality” (To the Smyrnaeans 7.1; To the Ephesians 20.2). Justin Martyr, around 150, says that the bread and cup are received “not as common bread and common drink” but as “the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh” (First Apology 66). Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 180) argues against the Gnostics that since the bread and cup, receiving the Word of God, become “the Eucharist, which is the body and blood of Christ,” the flesh is capable of redemption (Against Heresies 4.18.5; 5.2.3).
Cyril of Jerusalem tells the newly baptized, “Consider therefore the Bread and the Wine not as bare elements, for they are, according to the Lord’s declaration, the Body and Blood of Christ” (Mystagogical Catecheses 4.6; these lectures may come from his successor, John). Ambrose of Milan teaches that the word of Christ changes the elements (On the Mysteries 9; On the Sacraments 4), and John Chrysostom preaches a vivid realism in his homilies.
Two cautions follow. First, this early realism is not yet the scholastic doctrine of transubstantiation, with its vocabulary of “substance” (what a thing really is) and “accidents” (how it looks, tastes, and feels). The Fourth Lateran Council (1215) was the first council to use the word “transubstantiated” (transsubstantiatis), and Trent confirmed the doctrine (Session XIII, ch. 4 and can. 2). To read Trent back into Ignatius is as much an error as to read Zwingli back into him.
Second, there is Augustine, and he is the hard case for everyone. Augustine speaks with a strong realism (“That bread which you see on the altar, sanctified by the word of God, is the body of Christ,” Sermon 227), and he also speaks a strong language of sign: the sacrament is “a kind of visible word” (Tractates on John 80.3), and “To what purpose do you make ready teeth and stomach? Believe, and you have eaten already” (Tractates on John 25.12). Rome, the Reformed, and the Lutherans have all claimed him, but he holds the presence and the sign together in a way no side of a sixteenth-century debate can claim alone.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
5.1 The presence is true, bodily, and objective
The Augsburg Confession says the body and blood “are truly present … and are distributed to those who eat.” The Formula of Concord draws out what that means: Christ’s true body and blood are present “under the bread, with the bread, in the bread” (FC SD VII.35), distributed to and received by all who commune. The presence is objective, resting on Christ’s institution. The bread does not become Christ’s body because I believe hard enough. It is Christ’s body because Christ said so, and my believing receives what is already given.
5.2 Sacramental union, not transubstantiation and not “consubstantiation”
Lutherans confess the sacramental union: the true body and blood of Christ present with the bread and the wine, while the bread remains bread and the wine remains wine. This is the meaning of the familiar phrase “in, with, and under,” drawn from the Formula of Concord’s “under the bread, with the bread, in the bread,” which it uses to reject transubstantiation and to indicate “the sacramental union of the unchanged essence of the bread and of the body of Christ” (FC SD VII.35).
Here the Lutheran parts company with Rome over the explanation. Transubstantiation teaches that the whole substance of the bread and wine is changed into the substance of Christ’s body and blood, with only the appearances (the species) remaining. The Smalcald Articles give the Lutheran reason from Scripture: “it is in perfect agreement with Holy Scriptures that there is, and remains, bread, as Paul himself calls it, 1 Cor. 10:16: The bread which we break. And 1 Cor. 11:28: Let him so eat of that bread” (SA III.vi.5).
You may have heard Lutherans described as believing in “consubstantiation.” They do not. The word is not in the Confessions, and Lutherans reject it because it suggests a physical blending, as if bread and body were mixed into a third thing or Christ were enclosed in the bread like contents in a box. The Formula of Concord does say that “the natural bread and the true natural body of Christ” are “present together here upon earth in the appointed administration of the Sacrament” (FC SD VII.37). It calls this the sacramental union, rejects the teaching that the body is “included in the bread localiter, that is, locally” (FC SD VII.14), and declines to explain how. In other words, Lutherans do say that both are there, because Christ’s words say so. What they refuse is a theory of how, whether a mixing of the two or a body shut up inside the bread as in a container.
5.3 The presence rests on the Word, not a theory
How can Christ’s body be present on the altar? The honest answer is that we do not know. We know only that He is present, because He said “this is my body.” Rome explains the how with transubstantiation. The Reformed hold that Christ’s body remains in heaven and that the Spirit unites believers to it. The Lutheran offers no explanation of his own. Every tradition comes to a mystery somewhere, and the Orthodox and Calvin also decline to explain the manner, but the Lutheran places the mystery only in Christ’s words and confesses what He promises without claiming to explain what He has not explained.
There is a difference, then, between trusting Christ’s promise and explaining Christ’s presence. The Supper asks you to trust the One who gives it, not to understand it, and I find that a great mercy. The child, the dying believer, and the simple Christian who could never have followed the arguments at Marburg can all do what the Supper asks, which is to take Christ at His word and eat.
Sidebar—The Christology beneath the Supper. Why do Lutherans think Christ’s body can be present at all, when the objection runs that a body can only be in one place? The short answer is that Christ can keep His promise to be present because He is God and man in one person. In the one person of Christ what belongs to either nature may be said of the whole person (the communicatio idiomatum, “the communication of attributes”), and Formula of Concord VIII holds that Christ’s human nature truly shares in the divine majesty (the genus maiestaticum, “the kind of sharing that concerns majesty”). His body can therefore be present in a way not bound to one place, in what Luther called a mode in which it “neither occupies nor vacates space” (FC SD VII.100). The Formula rests the Supper first on Christ’s words, “the only firm, immovable, and indubitable rock of truth” (FC SD VII.42), and then, with Luther, adds the person of Christ, God’s right hand, and God’s many modes of presence to show that those words are not impossible (FC SD VII.93–103). The Reformed answer that a true human body, even glorified, remains in one place, while the eternal Son, even incarnate, exists also outside (extra) the flesh, which Lutherans called the extra Calvinisticum (“the Calvinist ‘outside’”) (Heidelberg Catechism Q47–48; Calvin, Institutes II.13.4 and IV.17.26–29). The disagreement is finally a question about who Christ is and not about one verse. (See FC SD VIII.27–28, 31–36, 51–67, 76–79.)
5.4 Oral eating, and the hardest test case
Because the presence rests on Christ’s Word, all who commune receive the true body and blood with the mouth (and not only in the heart by faith), believers to their blessing and the impenitent and unbelieving to their judgment (1 Corinthians 11:27–29). The Christian who comes troubled by his sins is not among the “unworthy,” for, as we saw in section 2.3, he is the guest the Supper is for. Faith does not create the presence, but receives its benefit, and this is the sharpest line between the Lutheran view and every “spiritual presence” account. If the gift depended on the strength of my faith, I could never be sure it was there for me. Because it depends on Christ’s Word, I can be sure that He is there offering Himself to me, and the same word “for you” that offers the gift awakens and holds the faith that takes it.
Sidebar—Eating with the mouth: two Latin terms, one comforting point. The Formula of Concord teaches an oral eating (manducatio oralis): Christ’s body and blood are received by the mouth, together with the bread and wine, by everyone who communes, and not only spiritually in the believing heart (FC SD VII.63). It happens “not in a Capernaitic, but in a supernatural, heavenly mode” (FC Ep VII.15), that is, not in the crude sense the hearers at Capernaum took from Jesus’ words (John 6:52, 59), as ordinary food is chewed and digested. From this follows the hard case, the eating by the unworthy (manducatio indignorum). Even an impenitent unbeliever who comes to the altar receives the true body and blood, but to judgment (1 Corinthians 11:29). The Smalcald Articles say the body and blood “are given and received not only by the godly, but also by wicked Christians” (SA III.vi.1). The Reformed and the Anglican Articles agree that the unworthy eat to their condemnation, but say that what such a person eats is the sign and not Christ’s body (the Thirty-Nine Articles say the wicked “in no wise” partake of Christ). The point is not to frighten but to secure: what Christ gives at the altar does not depend on you.
5.5 The benefit: “for you, for the forgiveness of sins”
All of this exists to deliver a gift. The Small Catechism asks, “What is the benefit of such eating and drinking?” It answers, “That is shown us in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins; namely, that in the Sacrament forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation are given us through these words. For where there is forgiveness of sins, there is also life and salvation.” To the question “How can bodily eating and drinking do such great things?” the catechism replies, “It is not the eating and drinking, indeed, that does them, but the words which stand here, namely: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins. Which words are, beside the bodily eating and drinking, as the chief thing in the Sacrament; and he that believes these words has what they say and express, namely, the forgiveness of sins.”
The Large Catechism adds that the worthy communicant is simply the one who believes the words “for you” (LC V.33–36). It calls the Sacrament a daily food and sustenance of the soul, given so that faith, worn down by the fight, may be refreshed and strengthened (LC V.23–24). The faith that receives it does not have to be strong or feel like anything; it has only to take Christ at His word.
5.6 A brief word on who comes to the altar
Because Lutherans believe Christ truly gives His body and blood at this table, admission to the altar is treated with pastoral care rather than casual openness. This is close (or closed) communion, the practice of communing together those who share a common confession of what the Supper is. This practice is intended as pastoral care, not a judgment on another Christian’s salvation. It grows from two of Paul’s own concerns, that the Supper is a confession of a shared faith (1 Corinthians 10:17), and that it should not be received carelessly, “without discerning the body” (1 Corinthians 11:29). A church that believes Christ is truly present handles the table as one handles anything holy and powerful, with care for the consciences of those who come.
6. Comparative Theology
Between Lutherans and the Reformed, the disagreement is not whether Christ is truly received. It is where Christ locates His promise. The traditions answer differently: in the elements given into the hand, in the believer lifted by the Spirit to the ascended Christ, or in the remembering community.
Roman Catholic. Rome confesses that Christ is truly, really, and substantially present, and explains the presence by transubstantiation (Catechism §§1373–1381; Trent, Session XIII). The agreement is large, a true, objective, bodily presence. The divergence lies in the explanation and what follows from it, the bread ceasing to be bread and the adoration of the consecrated bread. Confidence: high.
Eastern Orthodox. The Orthodox confess that the gifts truly become the body and blood of Christ by the Holy Spirit, invoked in the epiclesis (the prayer calling down the Spirit). The Confession of Dositheus (1672) used a Greek equivalent of the Latin term (metousiōsis, “transubstantiation”), and the nineteenth-century Longer Catechism of Philaret uses it while insisting that it does not explain the manner of the change, which God alone understands. Many Orthodox theologians today simply call the change (metabolē) a mystery. As Kallistos Ware puts it, “while Orthodoxy has always insisted on the reality of the change, it has never attempted to explain the manner of the change” (The Orthodox Church, the chapter “Orthodox Worship, II: The Sacraments”; ch. 14 in the new edition of 1993). The Orthodox Church in America’s own catechesis likewise regrets that attempts to explain how the bread and wine become the Body and Blood “often became too rationalistic and too closely connected with certain human philosophies” (Thomas Hopko, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2, Worship, “Holy Eucharist,” https://www.oca.org/orthodoxy/the-orthodox-faith/worship/the-sacraments/holy-eucharist). (Confession of Dositheus, Decree 17; Longer Catechism of Philaret, Q339–340.) The agreement is deep, and the Orthodox reserve before the mystery is close in spirit to the Lutheran refusal to explain it. Confidence: high.
Reformed and Presbyterian. It is not true that the Reformed hold a “merely symbolic” Supper. That is Zwingli’s view, and Calvin explicitly moved beyond Zwingli. For Calvin the Supper was a real communion in which believers are nourished by Christ’s true body and blood, spiritually, by the power of the Holy Spirit, who lifts the believer up to the ascended Christ in heaven (Institutes IV.17; Heidelberg Catechism Q75–79; Westminster Confession ch. 29). This is a high and serious doctrine, and I want a Reformed reader to recognize his own church here before I offer any Lutheran evaluation: Calvin believed Christ is truly received in the Supper.
The difference lies in where Christ locates His promise, and in how and by whom He is received. The Lutheran says that Christ, without leaving the right hand of God, is present where He has promised to be and gives His body with the bread into the mouth, so that all receive it, the unworthy to their judgment. The Reformed say Christ is received by faith, so that unbelievers receive the sign but not Christ. Calvin added that Christ is truly offered to all who come, though only faith receives Him. The disagreement proved church-dividing, yet it lies between two traditions that both confess a true feeding on Christ. Confidence: high.
Anglican. No single teaching authority speaks for the Anglican tradition, but its historic formularies, the Thirty-Nine Articles and the Book of Common Prayer, agree with the Lutheran in much. The Supper is “not only a sign of the love that Christians ought to have among themselves,” but “a Sacrament of our Redemption by Christ’s death,” and to those who “rightly, worthily, and with faith” receive it, “the Bread which we break is a partaking of the Body of Christ” (Article XXVIII), which is Paul’s own koinōnia. The Prayer Book Catechism says that Christ’s body and blood “are verily and indeed taken and received by the faithful.”
Where the Anglican tradition diverges, it follows the Reformed. The body is “given, taken, and eaten … only after an heavenly and spiritual manner,” faith is “the mean whereby” it is received, and transubstantiation is rejected (Article XXVIII). The wicked “in no wise are … partakers of Christ” (Article XXIX). The Prayer Book’s “Black Rubric” (the Declaration on Kneeling in the Communion service) in 1552 denied any “real and essential presence” of Christ’s natural flesh and blood, and in 1662 it was revised to deny only a “Corporal Presence,” leaving room for a real presence that is not bodily. The living tradition runs wider, from Evangelicals who hold closely to the Articles to Anglo-Catholics who teach an objective presence close to Rome’s. Confidence: moderate.
Methodist and Wesleyan. The United Methodist Church confesses a real presence of Christ in the Supper, a true “means of grace,” and leaves its manner a mystery (This Holy Mystery, 2004). The other Wesleyan churches, which share Wesley’s Articles, stand broadly with it. Wesley’s Articles of Religion, his abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, keep the Anglican “heavenly and spiritual manner” (Article XVIII) but leave out the Anglican article denying that the wicked eat Christ, and the Wesley brothers’ Hymns on the Lord’s Supper are boldly realist. Methodists hold the presence to be spiritual rather than bodily. Confidence: moderate.
Baptist, Evangelical, and the memorial view. Many Christians who hold a memorial understanding of the Supper sincerely desire to honor Christ’s command and remember His saving death. When a Baptist congregation passes the bread and cup “in remembrance,” it is obeying Jesus (“Do this in remembrance of me,” where “remembrance” translates the Greek anamnēsis). The Baptist Faith and Message (2000) calls the Supper a “symbolic act of obedience whereby members … memorialize the death of the Redeemer and anticipate His second coming” (Article VII), and most non-denominational churches follow the pattern. Historic Baptist confession can stand higher. In the Second London Baptist Confession (1689), which follows Westminster closely, worthy receivers “spiritually receive, and feed upon Christ crucified,” His body and blood being “not corporally or carnally, but spiritually present to the faith of believers” (ch. 30.7). Reformed Baptists who hold it belong with the Reformed.
Why, then, does the Lutheran not simply keep a memorial? If the Supper is fundamentally our act of remembering, a symbol is enough. If it is fundamentally Christ’s act of giving (“This is my body, which is given for you”), then it is Christ Himself, handing over His body and blood for the forgiveness of sins. The Lutheran thinks the memorialist has been taught to expect too little of what Christ offers. Christ gives even more than a memory, for He gives Himself. The Lutheran therefore presses the question gently back to the words (who has the authority to change “this is” into “this represents”?), not to win, but to keep all that Christ gives at His table. Confidence: moderate for the named Baptist confessions; limited for the non-denominational tendency, which has no binding text.
The comparison, then, is not a ladder with Lutherans at the top but a set of answers to one question (where Christ locates His promise), and the Lutheran answer keeps the promise as close to the sinner as the bread and wine he receives.
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
This doctrine matters most at the communion rail and at the bedside.
If you are the frightened communicant, you are answering a question the Supper never puts to you. You think it asks, “Are you worthy?” and, measuring yourself honestly, you stay in the pew. The Supper does not ask that. It says, “Given for you.” What the catechism looks for is faith in those words, and such faith is an empty hand held out to receive, whatever you feel. The sense of unworthiness that keeps you away is no reason to stay away, because the Supper is medicine for sinners and not a reward for the strong. Jesus said it Himself: “Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick” (Matthew 9:12). The Large Catechism also calls the Sacrament a medicine that brings help and life to soul and body, given for those who feel their weakness (LC V.68–70). Paul’s warning against the “unworthy manner” was aimed at unbelief and careless contempt, never at the trembling. The Formula of Concord says the Supper “was instituted especially for Christians weak in faith, yet penitent, for the consolation and strengthening of their weak faith” (FC Ep VII.19). To the trembling Christ says what He said at the table, “This is my body, which is given for you” (Luke 22:19).
The objectivity of the gift is the dying Christian’s comfort. When memory fails and the mind can no longer follow an argument, the Supper asks only that Christ be faithful to His word, and He is. A dying believer cannot manufacture a worthy frame of mind, and he does not need to. The cup of blessing is still a participation in the blood of Christ (1 Corinthians 10:16) even when the one who drinks it can no longer say so, and the faith Christ gave him still receives it.
When the old fear comes back, as it will, do not go looking for the answer inside yourself. Go where Christ has promised to be found and given, to His Word preached, to your Baptism, to the absolution spoken to you in His name, and to this table, where He puts His body and blood into your hands.
A word is owed, finally, to the reader for whom this chapter has been hardest, the Christian who has always known the Supper as a memorial and who loves the Lord dearly. If you have received the Supper as a memorial, in sincere obedience to “do this in remembrance of me,” then hear the Lutheran as a brother. He believes there is more in Christ’s hands than you have yet been told to expect, the living Christ Himself, giving His body and blood for you. Christ has not been less faithful to you because you were taught to expect less, and His word “for you” is spoken to you too.
Is this really for me? Yes, it is, and not because you have made yourself worthy, or worked up the right feeling, or understood the mystery. It is for you because Christ has spoken over the gift and addressed it to you: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins.
What comfort does Christ place into the hands of the communicant? He places Himself there, His true body and blood, and with them the forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation. The comfort of the Supper rests not in our understanding of the mystery, but in Christ’s promise to be present for us.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article X confesses that Christ’s true body and blood are present in the Supper and distributed to those who eat. The Supper is Christ’s gift placed into our hands, the companion of Baptism’s God’s promise spoken over me. The presence rests on Christ’s Word and not on the communicant’s faith or feeling. Lutherans confess a sacramental union and reject both transubstantiation and the mislabel “consubstantiation.” They distinguish trusting Christ’s promise from explaining Christ’s presence, and the reader needs only this much of the Christology beneath it: Christ can keep His promise because He is God and man in one person. The benefit is forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation, received by a faith that need not be strong.
Rome explains the presence by transubstantiation; the Orthodox confess a true change and hold its manner as mystery; the Reformed (Calvin, not Zwingli) confess a true spiritual feeding on the ascended Christ. Anglicans and Methodists most often hold a spiritual presence to the faithful, and Baptists and most Evangelicals a memorial view, sincerely kept.
8.2 Tables
Table 10.1, Views of the Lord’s Supper: What Is Present, and How, is in Appendix C. It sets seven traditions side by side, with the mode of presence, whether the elements change, and the primary source for each. Every tradition but the memorial view confesses that Christ is truly present or truly received, and only Rome and the Orthodox teach that the elements change. (See Appendix C.)
Table 10.2—What Is Received, and by Whom?
| Question | Lutheran | Reformed / Anglican | Memorial (Baptist / Evangelical) |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is received? | Christ’s true body and blood, with bread and wine | A true spiritual feeding on the ascended Christ | Bread and the cup (BFM: “the fruit of the vine”); Christ remembered and His return anticipated |
| How received? | Orally, by all who commune | Spiritually, by faith | Symbolically, in remembrance |
| Do the unworthy receive the body? | Yes, to judgment (manducatio indignorum) | No; the unworthy receive the sign only, yet eat it to their condemnation (WCF 29.8; Art. XXIX) | n/a (no presence in the elements) |
| Ground of the presence | Christ’s Word / institution | The Spirit’s work, received by faith | Christ’s command to remember (Christ present with His people, not in the elements) |
Because the presence rests on Christ’s Word and not on the recipient’s faith, what Christ offers does not depend on the strength of the communicant’s believing.
Table 10.3—Marburg, 1529: What Was Agreed and What Divided
| Agreed at Marburg (Articles 1–14, and most of Article 15) | Divided (the one point Article 15 left open, and the questions argued behind it) |
|---|---|
| The Trinity; the person of Christ | Whether the true body and blood are bodily present |
| Original sin; justification by faith | Whether Christ is received orally by all, or spiritually by faith |
| Baptism; the word and the Spirit | “This is my body”: literal (Luther) or figurative (Zwingli) |
| That the Mass is not a work that gains grace for another; the Supper in both kinds | Whether Christ’s body can be present outside a local heaven |
| That the Sacrament, like the Word, was given to move weak consciences to faith; that it is a sacrament of Christ’s true body and blood, and the spiritual eating is necessary | Result: agreement on much; no shared table |
The agreements show how near the two wings stood; the single division shows why they could not commune together.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Real presence—Christ’s true body and blood present in the Supper, not merely signified.
- Sacramental union—Christ’s body and blood truly given “in, with, and under” the bread and wine.
- Transubstantiation—the Roman explanation that the substance of bread and wine is changed into Christ’s body and blood.
- Consubstantiation—a label often attached to the Lutheran view, which Lutherans reject.
- Memorialism—the view that the Supper is a remembrance only.
- Communicatio idiomatum—the communication of attributes in the one person of Christ.
- Koinōnia—“participation, sharing” (1 Corinthians 10:16); glossed in the text.
- Anamnēsis—remembrance (“Do this in remembrance of me”); glossed in the text.
- Manducatio oralis and manducatio indignorum—oral eating, and eating by the unworthy; glossed in the sidebar.
- Extra Calvinisticum—glossed in the sidebar.
8.4 Further reading
- The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC X; Apology X; Small Catechism VI; Large Catechism V; Smalcald Articles III.vi; Formula of Concord VII and VIII.
- Hermann Sasse, This Is My Body: Luther’s Contention for the Real Presence in the Sacrament of the Altar.
- Martin Chemnitz, The Lord’s Supper (De Coena Domini), trans. J. A. O. Preus.
- Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3; Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions.
- Luther, Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper (1528), Luther’s Works vol. 37.
- For the comparisons, the sources named in §6, and Kallistos Ware, The Orthodox Church: An Introduction to Eastern Christianity, 3rd ed. (London: Penguin, 2015).
Footnotes
-
The German text of AC X reads: “Vom Abendmahl des Herrn wird also gelehrt, daß wahrer Leib und Blut Christi wahrhaftiglich unter der Gestalt des Brots und Weins im Abendmahl gegenwärtig sei und da ausgeteilt und genommen wird. Derhalben wird auch die Gegenlehre verworfen” (Triglotta, 46). That is, the true body and blood of Christ are truly present in the Supper “under the form of bread and wine” and are there given out and received. The Latin (vere adsint et distribuantur vescentibus) names no elements. The German says where the body and blood are present and that they are received. This book follows the unaltered Confession of 1530. In his altered Latin of 1540 (the Variata), Melanchthon deleted the rejection of those who teach otherwise and wrote that the body and blood are offered “with the bread and wine” (cum pane et vino) (Triglotta, Historical Introductions, 26). ↩
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.