Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 2—Article II: Original Sin

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Having confessed who God is, the Confession turns at once to what we are. Before it speaks of forgiveness and faith, and before it reaches Article IV, on justification, which Lutherans have long called the article on which the church stands or falls, it tells the truth about the human heart. Article II is a single statement followed by a single condemnation and it is one of the most important articles in the Confession, because everything that follows depends on it.

A chapter on sin belongs in this book, and not only in a seminary, for one reason: the Confession never diagnoses sin for its own sake. It diagnoses sin so that grace may be seen for what it truly is. A physician who will not name the disease cannot honestly offer the cure. The Reformers insisted on the depth of sin because they wanted the whole of grace to be believed. In other words, this is a chapter about why grace has to be free.

The whole doctrine can be held in a single comparison the apostle Paul draws between two men. What came to us from the first man, Adam, is answered by what is given to us in the second, Christ. Keep those two in view: what we are in Adam and what we become in Christ.


1. What the Article Says

The text of Article II is brief. In a standard English rendering of the Latin text of 1530, it reads:

Also they teach that since the fall of Adam all men begotten in the natural way are born with sin, that is, without the fear of God, without trust in God, and with concupiscence; and that this disease, or vice of origin, is truly sin, even now condemning and bringing eternal death upon those not born again through Baptism and the Holy Ghost.

They condemn the Pelagians and others who deny that original depravity is sin, and who, to obscure the glory of Christ’s merit and benefits, argue that man can be justified before God by his own strength and reason. (AC II)

The Article makes four plain claims.

The condition is inherited, not merely learned. “Since the fall of Adam all men begotten in the natural way are born with sin.” Original sin is the state we are born in, before we have picked up a single bad habit or done anything at all.

It is a relationship gone wrong at the root. The Article does not describe sin first as a list of forbidden acts but as a heart turned the wrong way: “without the fear of God, without trust in God, and with concupiscence,” that is, with disordered desire. What is concupiscence? The word is the Latin concupiscentia, which the old Latin Bible used for Paul’s Greek epithymia. Thayer’s lexicon defines epithymia as “desire, craving, longing” and then, “specifically, desire for what is forbidden, lust,” and it points to Romans 7:7, where Paul says the commandment against coveting showed him his sin. The broken rules come later. The root of our problem is that by nature we neither reverence God nor trust Him. Sin, at its deepest, is a heart that will not fear, love, and trust God above all things.

It is truly sin and it is deadly. “This disease, or vice of origin, is truly sin, even now condemning and bringing eternal death.” The Confession refuses to soften original sin into a mere weakness or a neutral limitation. It is real guilt before God and it is fatal.

The cure arrives in the same breath. The condemnation falls “upon those not born again through Baptism and the Holy Ghost.” Even in the bleakest sentence in the Confession, the remedy is already named.

Then it draws a boundary, condemning “the Pelagians and others who deny that original depravity is sin.” (Pelagius, whom we will meet below, was a teacher around the year 400 who held that we can obey God by our own power.) Notice why. The reason is not gloom about human beings. The Pelagian teaching serves “to obscure the glory of Christ’s merit and benefits.” If we can heal ourselves, even a little, then Christ is a helper and not a Savior.


2. Biblical Theology

The center of the doctrine is a single passage and everything else in Scripture gathers around it. In Romans 5, Paul sets two men side by side as the two heads of the human family. He writes that “sin came into the world through one man, and death through sin, and so death spread to all men because all sinned” (Romans 5:12, ESV). One man’s trespass “led to condemnation for all men,” and over against him stands another, whose “one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men,” so that “as by the one man’s disobedience the many were made sinners, so by the one man’s obedience the many will be made righteous” (Romans 5:18–19). Paul says the same thing again to the Corinthians: “in Adam all die, so also in Christ shall all be made alive” (1 Corinthians 15:22).

Paul does not treat our ruin as a private tally of wrongs. We are bound up with Adam by birth and that is the ground of our hope, because in the same way we are bound up with Christ through Baptism. However, the two are not evenly matched, for Paul says that “where sin increased, grace abounded all the more” (Romans 5:20).

The rest of Scripture fills in the portrait of what we inherit in Adam. It is a condition present from the very beginning of a life: “Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin did my mother conceive me” (Psalm 51:5). David is confessing that his sin reaches deeper than his particular acts, down to his origin. The verdict is old and sweeping (“the intention of man’s heart is evil from his youth,” Genesis 8:21), and the condition it describes is death: “you were dead in the trespasses and sins,” and we were “by nature children of wrath” (Ephesians 2:1, 3). In other words, Paul places our trouble in what we are by nature, not only in what we have done. A dead person cannot revive himself, and Paul says as much: “the mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God,” and “Those who are in the flesh cannot please God” (Romans 8:7–8).

Therefore Jesus speaks of new birth rather than improvement: “That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit” (John 3:6). We need to be born again, moved out of Adam and into Christ, and that birth is the Holy Spirit’s own work. No one enters the kingdom of God unless he is born “of water and the Spirit” (John 3:5), and that is why the Article names the remedy as “Baptism and the Holy Ghost” together, for the Spirit gives the new birth through the water joined to God’s Word. Paul joins them in the same way when he speaks of “the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5).

Scripture also speaks tenderly of children: “to such belongs the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 19:14). Some read this to mean that children are born innocent. The Lutheran church reads it differently, as a picture of how freely Jesus welcomes those who cannot commend themselves to Him, which is all of us. Children are not the exception to grace; they are its clearest picture.

Sidebar — The Greek of Romans 5:12. Paul writes that death spread to all “eph’ hō [ἐφ’ ᾧ] all sinned.” The old Latin Bible rendered this in quo (“in whom all sinned”), and that phrasing shaped the Western emphasis on our guilt in Adam. Most scholars today judge the Greek to mean “because all sinned” rather than “in whom,” and the Greek-reading East never leaned on the older rendering. The correction matters, but it does not unsettle the doctrine, because Paul’s surrounding argument (verses 15–19) carries the “one man → all” logic on its own. (The Greek text is eph’ hō pantes hēmarton [ἐφ’ ᾧ πάντες ἥμαρτον]; the Vulgate reads in quo omnes peccaverunt. Of the Greek, William Sanday and Arthur C. Headlam write that “there can now be little doubt that the true rendering is ‘because,’” since “in whom” would call for a different preposition and would set the relative too far from its antecedent: A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, ICC [New York: Scribner, 1906], 133. John Meyendorff calls “because” “a meaning accepted by most modern scholars of all confessional backgrounds”: Byzantine Theology, 2nd ed. [New York: Fordham University Press, 1979], 143–145.)


3. Historical Context

The Church did not define original sin carefully until someone denied it. For four centuries the conviction was carried mostly in practice, above all in the baptism of infants for the forgiveness of sins, which assumed the infant had something to be forgiven. It took a controversy to turn that instinct into a confession.

Around the year 400 a British-born teacher of strict, self-denying Christian living named Pelagius, admired for his moral seriousness, taught that people can obey God if only they will. In his account Adam harmed us by his bad example, not by handing down a fallen nature; each of us is born as innocent as Adam was before he fell; and a sinless life is at least possible. It was an encouraging, hopeful message and that was its danger, for it placed the decisive power of salvation in the human will and made Christ, at most, our example.

Against him stood Augustine of Hippo, who had already traced in his own life a will that could not free itself. Augustine answered that the whole race fell in Adam; that we inherit not merely a bad example but a corrupted nature; that the will apart from grace is bound; and that infant baptism is the Church’s standing witness that even the newborn need to be redeemed. His deepest point was not about us at all but about God: salvation is grace from first to last, or it is not grace.

Sidebar — Augustine, Pelagius, and the councils. Augustine’s mature case is spread across a decade of works, including On the Merits and Forgiveness of Sins and Infant Baptism (c. 412), On Nature and Grace (c. 415), and On the Grace of Christ and Original Sin (c. 418). His views sharpened over time, so it is fair to cite the mature works and to date them rather than flattening “Augustine” into one voice. The Church sided with him. Pelagianism was condemned at Carthage (418) and again in the East at Ephesus (431). The Second Council of Orange (529) condemned a milder version (that grace carries the Christian life, but the first step toward God is our own), the view later called “semi-Pelagianism.”

The Reformers, a thousand years later, believed the late-medieval church had drifted back toward that milder error, into a piety in which the sinner takes the first step and grace supplies the rest. The Apology complains that the scholastics ascribe to human nature “unimpaired strength for loving God above all things” (Ap II.8). When Article II condemns “the Pelagians and others,” then, it is naming a temptation that never goes away: the wish to be, in some measure, our own saviors. The Roman answer was fixed afterward, at the Council of Trent’s fifth session (1546), which affirmed much of the ancient consensus but drew one line the Reformers could not accept. Trent taught that the disordered desire remaining in the baptized is not “truly and properly sin” (more on this in §6). Trent did not, however, endorse the “first step” piety the Reformers had attacked. Its next session insisted that even the first stirring toward God is the work of God’s grace, which goes before anything we do (what theologians call prevenient grace). The question underneath the whole history is whether the sinner contributes to his rescue or grace does it all.


4. Early Church Witness

Was the Reformation’s reading of original sin a novelty or the ancient faith? The Confession claims the ancient faith, and I believe the early Church largely bears it out, with one real difference between East and West.

The oldest evidence comes from the baptismal font. By the mid-third century infant baptism was so settled that when a bishop asked whether one should wait until the eighth day, Cyprian of Carthage and a council of African bishops answered (around 253) that God’s grace should not be withheld from a newborn. The very question assumes the infant has something to receive.

In Augustine that instinct became explicit doctrine and he is cited more than any other Father in the Lutheran Confessions. When the Reformers taught inherited corruption and the bound will, they understood themselves not as inventing but as handing on the faith the Western church had held for centuries.

The Christian East traveled a different road and Western books have often gotten it wrong, which is why it is worth hearing from the East’s own teachers. Where the West, following Augustine, emphasized inherited guilt, the Greek Fathers emphasized inherited death. Athanasius, in On the Incarnation, describes the Fall as a slipping back toward the corruption and nothingness out of which we were made. Cut off from the God who alone holds us in being, human nature begins to come apart, and death and decay set in. John Chrysostom, preaching through Romans, reads 5:12 to mean that Adam’s disobedience made all his descendants mortal (it is death that spreads to all), and when Paul says the many “were made sinners,” Chrysostom takes it to mean that they were made liable to death and punishment, not personally guilty of Adam’s act.

Out of this the East developed what it calls ancestral sin. What passes from Adam to us is a nature grown sick, mortal, and bent toward sin (a real and universal corruption), but not the personal guilt of Adam’s act. The nineteenth-century Longer Catechism of the Eastern Church puts the corruption strongly, likening Adam’s posterity to an infected stream flowing from an infected source, born both sinful and mortal. What modern Orthodox theologians decline to call inherited is guilt, not corruption. Salvation is understood to match the diagnosis: less the cancelling of a legal debt than the healing of a dying nature and its raising toward the likeness of God.

East and West differ on inherited guilt, yet both confess that every child of Adam is born needing Christ.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

Article II is compact but the rest of the Book of Concord shows what the Lutheran church meant by it and what it did not.

When the Roman theologians replied to the Augsburg Confession (in the Confutation of 1530), they approved the Article’s main claim, that original sin is truly sin, and joined in condemning the Pelagians. They objected to two things. Being without the fear and trust of God, they said, is an actual sin, something a person does, and so cannot describe the sin we are born with. They also denied that the disordered desire that remains in the baptized (concupiscence) is still sin. In the Apology’s report of their view, it is “a penalty, and not a sin” (Ap II.38). Melanchthon’s answer, the Apology of the Augsburg Confession (an apology in the old sense of a reasoned defense), held firm on both. The Confession, it answered, means not only that we fail to fear and trust God but that by nature we lack the very power to do so (Ap II.3). That inability is the heart of what is wrong with us. Concupiscence, too, is a real disorder rather than a neutral appetite, and it is truly sin even before it is acted upon.

The Apology at once adds the comfort: Baptism takes away the guilt, even though the disordered desire itself is still in us. Luther, it says, “always wrote thus, namely, that Baptism removes the guilt of original sin, although the material, as they call it, of the sin, i.e., concupiscence, remains.” It then cites Augustine: “Sin is remitted in Baptism, not in such a manner that it no longer exists, but so that it is not imputed” (Ap II.35–36). In other words, what still lives in the baptized is truly sin, and for Christ’s sake it is truly forgiven and not counted against them.

Luther writes in the Smalcald Articles that “this hereditary sin is so deep [and horrible] a corruption of nature that no reason can understand it, but it must be [learned and] believed from the revelation of Scriptures” (SA III.i.3). Left to ourselves, we grade on a curve and compare ourselves to worse sinners, and so we always underestimate the disease. Therefore we learn how deep sin goes only from the Word of God.

Sin can be overstated as well as understated. Later Lutherans had to guard the doctrine from an overcorrection of their own. A theologian named Matthias Flacius, eager to honor the seriousness of sin, said that after the Fall sin had become the very substance of human nature, so that we simply are sin. The Formula of Concord said no. Original sin is not the substance of the human being, which remains God’s creature; it is a corruption of that good creation, so deep, the Formula adds against the opposite error, that “nothing healthy or uncorrupt has remained in man’s body or soul” (FC Ep I.8). The distinction is more than hair-splitting, for it guards the goodness of what God made and the hope of the resurrection at once. If sin were our very nature, we could only be saved by being destroyed and replaced. Because sin is a corruption of a good nature, the same creature God made can be healed and raised.

Sidebar — Substance or accident? The Flacian controversy. Flacius borrowed Aristotle’s distinction between a thing’s “substance” (what it essentially is) and its “accidents” (qualities it has), and called original sin the human substance. His opponents answered that this makes God, the maker of every substance, the author of sin, and turns redemption into annihilation. The Formula of Concord (Article I) settled it for Lutheranism: fallen human nature is still God’s creation, and original sin is a corruption of that nature, however complete its reach.

Put together, the Lutheran confession holds that original sin is both inherited guilt and inherited corruption, and that it reaches the whole person. We may as well use the phrase the wider Protestant world uses, total depravity, as long as we define it. It does not mean that people are as evil as they could possibly be, or that unbelievers can do no outward good. It means that sin has touched every part of us (mind, will, and affections alike), so that no part of us is left whole, from which we could begin to raise ourselves to God. I find it helpful to say it this way: the corruption is total in its reach, not in its degree. That is what makes grace necessary. If there were one uncorrupted corner of the soul, we might begin our own rescue there. There is not, and so the rescue must come from outside us, from Christ.


6. Comparative Theology

Nearly every Christian tradition confesses some doctrine of the Fall; almost none says we are simply fine as we are. The real disagreements come down to three questions: What do we inherit—guilt, corruption, mortality, or some combination? Is the disordered desire that remains after baptism itself sin? How bound is the will that results? The traditions spread out along a spectrum.

Roman Catholic. Rome confesses a robust doctrine of original sin: real, inherited from Adam, a loss of the original holiness in which we were made, and washed away in baptism. Rome is careful to say that human nature “has not been totally corrupted” by the Fall but is “wounded” (CCC 405). However, the sharper difference is over what remains. According to the Council of Trent, the concupiscence that persists in the baptized is not “truly and properly sin”; it is called sin only “because it is of sin, and inclines to sin,” that is, because it comes from sin and pulls us toward it. It cannot harm those who do not consent to it but resist it by the grace of Jesus Christ. (Rome also holds one exception to the universal reach of original sin: the Virgin Mary, preserved from it from her conception.) Rome’s concern here is the power of baptism. What God takes away in the font is truly taken away, so that there is “no condemnation” for the reborn (Romans 8:1), and what remains is a wound to be fought, not guilt. The pastoral effect is a more hopeful account of the baptized Christian and, from the Lutheran side, a less searching one, because it does not name our abiding disordered desire as sin in daily need of forgiveness. Lutherans confess the power of Baptism no less. They read Romans 8:1 as the Apology does: what remains in the baptized is truly sin, and yet there is “no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus,” because for Christ’s sake it is not counted against them.

Eastern Orthodox. The East confesses ancestral sin. From Adam we inherit a corrupted, mortal nature (a humanity grown sick and death-bound) but not the personal guilt of his transgression. The difference turns partly on a single word. Where the old Latin Bible read Romans 5:12 as “in whom [Adam] all sinned,” the Greek-reading East heard “because all sinned,” and so was slower to reckon every newborn guilty of Adam’s act, while still confessing that all are born into a fallen, dying condition only Christ can heal. Orthodox writers are careful to add what the doctrine does not mean. In Metropolitan Kallistos Ware’s words, original sin is not to be understood “in juridical or quasi-biological terms, as if it were some physical ‘taint’ of guilt, transmitted through sexual intercourse,” but as the solidarity of a wounded race in its accumulated corruption. Salvation is framed to match: less an acquittal in a courtroom than a healing, and finally theosis, the creature’s transformation into the likeness of God. The common ground with the West is large and real, for both confess a truly fallen nature, the reign of death, and rescue in Christ alone. The genuine divergence is over inherited guilt. In fairness, the Orthodox are not themselves of one mind about how sharply to set their tradition against Augustine; the cleanest antithesis belongs to modern writers such as the Greek theologian John Romanides, while the Fathers are more varied. Older Orthodox standards, such as the Confession of Dositheus (1672), speak of inherited sin more strongly. (Kallistos Ware, The Orthodox Way [London: Mowbrays, 1979], 80–81; Meyendorff, Byzantine Theology, 143–145.)

Reformed and Presbyterian. Here the Lutheran finds his nearest neighbor. The Reformed confess total depravity (the corruption of the whole nature) and, in their confessions, both that corruption and the imputation of Adam’s guilt, that is, his guilt counted to our account (Westminster Confession, chapter 6). They often frame the matter as federal headship: Adam stood as the covenant representative of his people, so his guilt is justly reckoned to them, just as Christ’s righteousness is reckoned to those He represents. Lutherans confess the same twin reality of guilt and corruption, generally without leaning on that framework. On this article the two traditions stand very close.

Anglican. The Church of England’s Articles of Religion descend in part from Augsburg. Article IX opens, as AC II closes, by rejecting the Pelagians, who “do vainly talk” of sin as mere imitation of Adam. It calls original sin “the fault and corruption of the Nature of every man,” says that it “deserveth God’s wrath and damnation,” and holds that “this infection of nature doth remain, yea in them that are regenerated.” On concupiscence it chooses its words with care: “although there is no condemnation for them that believe and are baptized, yet the Apostle doth confess, that concupiscence and lust hath of itself the nature of sin.” That wording is more guarded than Augsburg’s “truly sin,” yet it does not take Trent’s position either. The Articles’ authority varies across the Anglican Communion today, though they remain the tradition’s historic standard.

Wesleyan and Methodist. Readers who expect this tradition to be “soft” on sin are often surprised. Its confessional standards affirm original sin and native corruption in words taken almost directly from the Anglican Articles (Methodist Articles of Religion, Article VII, from Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine Articles). Wesley did, however, leave out the word “fault” and the clauses on God’s wrath and on the sin that remains in those who are born again. The difference lies in grace. Wesley taught prevenient grace, grace that “goes before,” given to all through Christ and restoring a measure of freedom, itself wholly God’s gift and not a natural power, so that a person can respond to the gospel. The Wesleyan does not deny how deep the Fall goes; he holds that God has universally begun to answer it, so that no one is left in sheer inability.

Baptist. There is no single Baptist doctrine of original sin. There are several. Confessional Reformed Baptists (in the tradition of the Second London Confession of 1689) affirm inherited guilt much as the Westminster divines did. Many other Baptists, and much of the wider free-church world, hold instead to an age of accountability. The Southern Baptists’ Baptist Faith and Message (2000) does not use the phrase, but it describes the view: Adam’s posterity “inherit a nature and an environment inclined toward sin,” and “as soon as they are capable of moral action, they become transgressors and are under condemnation.” We inherit a fallen nature and a bent toward sin, on this view, but are not held personally guilty until we are old enough to sin knowingly. Children who die young are safe in God’s mercy, then, not because they are sinless but because guilt requires knowing consent.

The age of accountability deserves a fair and gentle word, because so many sincere Christians hold it, and hold it for a good reason. They want to protect God’s justice and mercy toward children and they cannot bear the thought of a God who would condemn an infant. That instinct is right and Christian. Where the Lutheran confession differs is not in its tenderness toward children but in where it rests their hope. The age-of-accountability view rests a child’s safety on the child’s not yet being accountable. Its defenders point to passages such as Deuteronomy 1:39, where God speaks of Israel’s “children, who today have no knowledge of good or evil,” and to David’s hope for his infant son, “I shall go to him, but he will not return to me” (2 Samuel 12:23). The Lutheran hears real comfort in these texts but no doctrine of a threshold. The Confession rests a child’s hope instead on the mercy of God and the width of Christ’s grace, given through the means He has promised. Grace is the sturdier ground, for it does not depend on a threshold Scripture does not name.

Finally, there is the oldest position of all in modern dress: the quiet cultural creed that people are basically good and simply need better information or better conditions. It is rarely argued; most people simply absorb it. The Confession’s answer is the same it gave Pelagius. This is the most flattering and least honest account of the human heart and it can explain neither the evil in the world nor our own consciences. What we see confirms the doctrine of original sin, though only the Word tells us how deep it goes, and the same Word sends us to Christ.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

Why does this hard doctrine matter for ordinary Christian life? It matters because nearly everything good in the gospel depends on telling the truth about the thing it heals.

First and largest, it makes grace amazing. The person who thinks he is basically fine will hear forgiveness as a courtesy; the person who has understood Article II will hear it as resurrection. This is why the Confession will not soften the diagnosis. The diagnosis does crush, as the Law always does, but God never crushes in order to leave us there. He does it so that when we come to Article IV and hear that we are justified freely, for Christ’s sake, through faith, we will hear the word freely for what it is. If you fear that your faith is too weak to receive it, take heart: Christ is the one of whom Isaiah wrote, “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3).

In addition, it frees us from the exhausting work of justifying ourselves. If I believe I can and must fix myself, I am left with pride when I think I am managing and despair when I know I am not. The doctrine of original sin puts an end to that. It tells me the truth I half-suspected (that I cannot heal myself) and then the truth I could never have guessed, that I do not have to, because Christ has done it. “God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us” (Romans 5:8).

It gives us, too, a patient, clear-eyed charity. If sin runs this deep in every heart, then no one who wrongs you is a special case, and you are not the one innocent party. That does not excuse evil but it dismantles self-righteousness and makes room for a lasting love, including patience with our own slow sanctification. The corruption we fight will not be gone until God raises us, as the Formula says, to “live eternally without original sin” (FC Ep I.10). Until then the work is His, for “he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 1:6).

No question presses on this doctrine harder than the death of a child, and here the chapter must move with great care. The Confession gives us two things and stops. It gives us God’s appointed means—it sends us to bring our children to Baptism and the Word, to the grace God has actually promised. It also refuses to place any limit on the mercy of God. Scripture gives us real certainty about God’s promises; it does not license us to speculate beyond them, in either direction. Where the child was baptized, the parent need not guess, for God has spoken. “For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Galatians 3:27), and “the promise is for you and for your children” (Acts 2:39). Where Baptism could not be had, a pastor offers the grieving parent no formula and pronounces no verdict God has not revealed. He offers instead the character of the God we do know: the God who took children in His arms and blessed them, who is more merciful than we are, and who has never once turned away someone who could not save himself. We entrust the child to that God, and we rest there. That is not evasion; it is the exact shape of Christian hope, which always rests on God’s mercy and not on our knowledge.

The doctrine of original sin, like the Confession itself, refuses to leave us in the diagnosis. Article II tells us unflinchingly what we are in Adam so that the gospel can tell us what we are given in Christ. If this chapter has troubled you, I want to send you where Christ has promised to be found and given to you: in His Word, in your Baptism, in the absolution, and in His Supper. The right response is to turn, as the whole Confession now turns, toward the second Adam.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article II confesses that since the fall of Adam every human being is born in a condition of sin, not merely doing wrong but bent away from God at the root, “without the fear of God, without trust in God, and with concupiscence.” This condition is truly sin and truly deadly, healed only by the new birth God gives through Baptism and the Holy Spirit. What remains in the baptized is still sin, and for Christ’s sake it is forgiven and not counted against them. The Reformers held this not out of gloom but to guard the glory of Christ, for if we could mend ourselves, we would not need a Savior. Against Pelagius, ancient and modern, the Confession insists that salvation is grace from first to last, and it insists on the depth of the disease precisely so that the greatness of the cure can be believed. Paul says that “where sin increased, grace abounded all the more” (Romans 5:20).

8.2 Tables in this chapter

Table 2.1—What Is Inherited? Guilt, Corruption, and Consequence

Tradition Inherited guilt? Inherited corruption of nature? Inherited mortality / death? Is remaining concupiscence itself sin (after baptism)?
Lutheran Yes Yes (total in reach) Yes Yes (but forgiven and not imputed to those in Christ)
Reformed / Presbyterian Yes (often via federal headship) Yes (total depravity) Yes Yes, though “through Christ, pardoned and mortified” (WCF 6.5)
Anglican (Art. IX) Yes Yes Yes Yes, in guarded terms (“hath of itself the nature of sin”), with “no condemnation for them that believe and are baptized”
Roman Catholic Yes: a sin “contracted, not committed” (CCC 404); loss of original holiness and justice Wounded, not totally corrupted (CCC 405) Yes No—remains, “of sin, and inclines to sin,” but not itself sin
Eastern Orthodox Generally no in modern Orthodox theology (ancestral sin, not inherited guilt); older standards (Dositheus, 1672) speak more strongly Yes Yes (the accent falls here) (spoken of as the passions, disordered desires to be healed, not in the Western category of sin)
Wesleyan / Methodist Article VII is silent; Wesley affirmed it, but taught that Christ’s gift cancels it for all (Rom 5:18) Yes Yes Contested: sin remains in believers (“On Sin in Believers”), but Wesley counted as sin “properly so called” only a voluntary breaking of a known law
Baptist (much of the tradition) Often no—condition, not guilt; age of accountability Yes (bent toward sin) Yes (varies)

Table 2.2—Original Sin Across the Traditions (official sources)

Tradition Primary source Position in brief
Lutheran AC II; Apology II; Formula of Concord I Guilt and corruption; concupiscence is sin, though not imputed to those in Christ; corruption of a good nature, not its substance
Roman Catholic Council of Trent, Sess. V; CCC §§396–412 Real inherited sin removed in baptism; nature wounded, not totally corrupted; remaining concupiscence not itself sin; Mary the exception
Eastern Orthodox Philaret, Longer Catechism Q.166–169; Confession of Dositheus (1672), Decree 6; Athanasius, On the Incarnation; Chrysostom on Romans; Meyendorff; Ware Ancestral sin: inherited mortality and corruption, not inherited guilt (older standards speak more strongly)
Reformed / Presbyterian Westminster Confession ch. 6; Belgic 15; Heidelberg Q7–8 Imputed guilt and total depravity; federal headship; remaining corruption truly sin, though pardoned
Anglican Thirty-Nine Articles, Art. IX Guilt and corruption; the infection remains in the regenerate; concupiscence “hath of itself the nature of sin”
Wesleyan / Methodist Methodist Articles of Religion, Art. VII; Wesley, The Doctrine of Original Sin (1757) and “On Sin in Believers” Inherited corruption (Art. VII silent on guilt, which Wesley affirmed elsewhere); universally answered by prevenient grace
Baptist Baptist Faith & Message (2000), Art. III; Second London Baptist Confession (1689), ch. 6 Diverse: from imputed guilt (Second London) to condition-plus-age-of-accountability

Confidence: high for the Lutheran, Reformed, and Roman positions; moderate–high for the Anglican, Eastern Orthodox, and Wesleyan rows, which are drawn from within each tradition (the Thirty-Nine Articles; Philaret’s Longer Catechism*, the Greek Fathers, Meyendorff and Ware; Article VII and Wesley’s own works).*

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Original sin—the inherited fallen condition: in Lutheran teaching, both guilt and corruption.
  • Concupiscence—disordered desire; for Lutherans, truly sin even in the baptized, though forgiven and not imputed for Christ’s sake.
  • Total depravity—sin’s corruption of the whole person; total in reach, not in degree.
  • Ancestral sin—the Eastern Orthodox account: inherited mortality and corruption, not inherited guilt.
  • Imputation—reckoning to one person what belongs to another (Adam’s guilt; Christ’s righteousness).
  • Prevenient grace—in Wesleyan teaching, grace given to all that “goes before” and enables a response to the gospel.

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC II; Apology II; Smalcald Articles III.i; Formula of Concord I.
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb, and James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions: History and Theology of the Book of Concord.
  • Henri Blocher, Original Sin: Illuminating the Riddle.
  • Ian McFarland, In Adam’s Fall: A Meditation on the Christian Doctrine of Original Sin.
  • Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo: A Biography; and B. R. Rees, Pelagius: Life and Letters.
  • John Meyendorff, Byzantine Theology; John Romanides, The Ancestral Sin (for the Orthodox account, from within the tradition).
Topics
Sin and RepentanceBaptismOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Romans 7:7Romans 5:12Romans 5:18–191 Corinthians 15:22Romans 5:20Psalm 51:5Genesis 8:21Ephesians 2:1Romans 8:7–8John 3:6John 3:5Titus 3:5Matthew 19:14Romans 8:1Deuteronomy 1:392 Samuel 12:23Isaiah 42:3Romans 5:8Philippians 1:6Galatians 3:27Acts 2:39Romans 5:18
Confessions
AC IIAp IISA IIIEp I

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.