Chapter 1—Article I: Of God (The Holy Trinity)
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
We begin where the Augsburg Confession begins. When the evangelical princes and theologians came before Emperor Charles V at Augsburg in 1530, they did not open their confession with the doctrines then in dispute (neither justification, nor the Mass, nor the authority of bishops). They opened with God. Article I confesses the Holy Trinity, and it does so by pointing back more than twelve centuries to the Council of Nicaea, so that the first thing the Reformation said at Augsburg was something very old.
That order is not an accident and it sets the tone for this entire book. The Augsburg Confession does not present itself as the charter of a new church. It presents itself as the catholic faith, faithfully held. By confessing the Trinity first, and in the very words the whole Church had received, the Reformers were making a claim about themselves: we are not innovators, for we stand with Nicaea, with the ancient councils, and with the one holy Christian Church of every age. Everything else in the Confession is meant to be read in that light.
1. What the Article Says
The text of Article I is brief. In the Triglotta’s English rendering of the Latin text of 1530 it reads:
Our Churches, with common consent, do teach that the decree of the Council of Nicaea concerning the Unity of the Divine Essence and concerning the Three Persons, is true and to be believed without any doubting; that is to say, there is one Divine Essence which is called and which is God: eternal, without body, without parts, of infinite power, wisdom, and goodness, the Maker and Preserver of all things, visible and invisible; and yet there are three Persons, of the same essence and power, who also are coeternal, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. And the term “person” they use as the Fathers have used it, to signify, not a part or quality in another, but that which subsists of itself.
They condemn all heresies which have sprung up against this article, as the Manichaeans, who assumed two principles, one Good and the other Evil: also the Valentinians, Arians, Eunomians, Mohammedans, and all such. They condemn also the Samosatenes, old and new, who, contending that there is but one Person, sophistically and impiously argue that the Word and the Holy Ghost are not distinct Persons, but that “Word” signifies a spoken word, and “Spirit” signifies motion created in things. (AC I)
Read as it stands, the Article makes four moves, and I want you to see each of them.
First, it defers to Nicaea. The very first thing the Confession does is bind itself to “the decree of the Council of Nicaea.” The Reformers are saying that the touchstone of true teaching about God is the confession the whole Church hammered out in the fourth century, rather than a private opinion or a fresh discovery.
Second, it confesses one divine essence. There is one God, “one Divine Essence which is called and which is God.” The Article piles up the classic attributes: eternal, without body, without parts, of infinite power, wisdom, and goodness, Maker and Preserver of all things visible and invisible. This is the God of Israel and of the Shema, who alone is worshiped.
Third, it confesses three persons. In its words, “yet there are three Persons, of the same essence and power, who also are coeternal, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost.” The three are neither three gods nor three names for one figure. They are co-equal and co-eternal, so that none is greater or earlier than another.
Fourth, it defines its terms and draws its boundaries. The Article explains that “person” (persona, Greek hypostasis) means “that which subsists of itself.” A person in God is neither a part of God nor a passing mood or role, but one who truly is. The Article also names the errors it rejects: the dualism of the Manichaeans, the mythologies of the Valentinians, the Arians and Eunomians (who denied the Son’s full deity), and the “Samosatenes, old and new” (the modalists and adoptionists who collapse the three into one person).
The term “person” needs a word for modern readers. In ordinary speech today a “person” is an independent individual with a separate mind and being, and three “persons,” heard that way, sound like three gods. That is not what the creeds mean. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are truly distinct (they are not masks or modes worn in turn), yet they are not three separate divine beings. Each is the one undivided God, and they are distinguished from one another by their eternal relations: the Father unbegotten, the Son begotten, and the Spirit proceeding. When Article I says “person,” it means one who truly and personally is God, neither a fragment of God nor a role God plays.
A word is also due on the Confession’s sixteenth-century term “Mohammedans.” The vocabulary belongs to its time, and Muslims today should be described according to their own confession. Islam teaches that God is one. It rejects the Christian confession that the one God eternally exists as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, and it denies that Jesus is the eternal divine Son, understanding Him instead as a revered human prophet (see Qur’an 4:171; 5:73). The disagreement, then, is over who the one God has revealed Himself to be, and not over whether there is one God. Christians should state that difference clearly while speaking of their Muslim neighbors with respect and love. (Whether Christians and Muslims “worship the same God” is a further question that needs more distinctions than this article requires, and it is left aside here.)
The plain sense, then, is one God in three co-equal, co-eternal persons, the faith of Nicaea, believed “without any doubting.”
Two features of the Article shape the whole book. The first is its brevity and confidence. The Reformers confessed the Trinity as common ground without arguing it at length, and their Roman opponents agreed, so that Article I is the least controverted article of the Augsburg Confession. The second is its catholic intent. Whatever disagreements follow in the later articles, they unfold within the household of the Nicene faith, and the doctrine of God is the shared floor on which the whole comparison of traditions in this book will stand.
2. Biblical Theology
What is the Trinity? The word itself is not one the Bible uses. Webster’s dictionary of 1828 traces it to the Latin trinitas, built from the words for three and one, and defines it in theology as “the union of three persons in one Godhead, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit” (Webster’s 1828 Dictionary, s.v. “Trinity”). The Church coined the word to hold together everything the Bible says about God, and what the Bible says can be summarized in three affirmations that must all be held at once: God is one; the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are each fully God; and the three are truly distinct. The doctrine of the Trinity is simply the Church’s refusal to drop any of them.
2.1 God is one
The bedrock is the Shema, “Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is one” (Deuteronomy 6:4, ESV). Israel’s faith is relentlessly monotheistic, and the LORD says through Isaiah, “I am the first and I am the last; besides me there is no god” (Isaiah 44:6). The New Testament never retreats from this. Paul insists that “there is one God” (1 Timothy 2:5), and even in the act of confessing Christ’s lordship he preserves the oneness: “for us there is one God, the Father, from whom are all things and for whom we exist, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things and through whom we exist” (1 Corinthians 8:6). Whatever the Church would come to say about Father, Son, and Spirit, it could never mean three gods.
2.2 The Father, the Son, and the Spirit are each God
That the Father is God requires no argument. The startling claim of the New Testament is that the Son shares that same deity. John opens his Gospel by placing the Word both with God and as God: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. … All things were made through him” (John 1:1, 3). Jesus takes the divine name onto His own lips when He says, “before Abraham was, I am” (John 8:58), and His hearers reach for stones, understanding exactly what He claimed. He says, “I and the Father are one” (John 10:30). Thomas, meeting the risen Christ, worships Him with the words “My Lord and my God!” (John 20:28). Paul writes that “in him the whole fullness of deity dwells bodily” (Colossians 2:9), and Hebrews addresses the Son directly: “Your throne, O God, is forever and ever” (Hebrews 1:8).
The Holy Spirit, too, is God and not merely God’s power at work. Scripture speaks of Him as one who teaches, speaks, sends, intercedes, wills, and can be grieved, and these are the marks of a person rather than a force (John 14:26; 16:13; Acts 13:2; Romans 8:26–27; 1 Corinthians 12:11; Ephesians 4:30). He is also spoken of as God. When Ananias lies to the Holy Spirit, Peter says he has “not lied to man but to God” (Acts 5:3–4), and the Spirit “searches everything, even the depths of God” (1 Corinthians 2:10–11), which only God can do. Yet the Spirit is neither the Father nor the Son. He is sent by the Father in the Son’s name, He proceeds from the Father, and He bears witness to the Son (John 14:26; 15:26). The Council of Constantinople in 381 therefore added no new deity to the faith when it confessed the Spirit as “the Lord and Giver of life.”
2.3 The three are truly distinct
Scripture never lets these three collapse into one. At the Jordan the distinction is visible: the Son is baptized, the Spirit descends like a dove, and the Father’s voice speaks from heaven, all three together and at once (Matthew 3:16–17). The Great Commission binds them in a single “name” and yet names them threefold, “baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19). Paul blesses the Corinthians in the same threefold way: “The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all” (2 Corinthians 13:14). In the farewell discourse the persons act toward one another. The Father sends the Son, the Son and the Father send the Spirit, and the Spirit “proceeds from the Father” and bears witness to the Son (John 14–16, esp. 15:26). These are not masks worn in turn by a single actor.
2.4 The Old Testament and the danger of over-reading
Christians have long heard trinitarian overtones in the Old Testament: the plural “Let us make man in our image” (Genesis 1:26), the three visitors to Abraham (Genesis 18), the thrice-holy of the seraphim (Isaiah 6:3), and the LORD, His Word, and His Spirit active together in creation (Genesis 1:1–3; Psalm 33:6). These are worth hearing, but with discipline. The plural of Genesis 1:26 and the plural form of the divine name elohim (“God”) are not, by themselves, proofs of three persons. The right method is the early Church’s, which reads the Old Testament in the light of the New. The Trinity is revealed fully in the coming of the Son and the sending of the Spirit, and then the Church looks back and recognizes the God of the Gospel already at work in Israel’s Scriptures.
2.5 The passages that get disputed
I would rather name the texts that opponents of the doctrine have leaned on than pass over them. Jesus says, “the Father is greater than I” (John 14:28). Read as a statement about deity, it would make the Son a lesser god. Read in context, as the incarnate Son speaking of His mission and of the Father as the unbegotten source within the Godhead, it fits the Nicene faith without strain. Proverbs 8 became an important Arian proof text because the Hebrew verb of Proverbs 8:22 (qanah) can be rendered “possessed,” “acquired,” or, in some contexts, “created,” and the ancient Greek translation used language that could be heard as “created.” However, the passage is a poetic personification of Wisdom, and Christians dispute how directly Wisdom should be identified with the pre-incarnate Son, so the Son’s eternity should not be decided by it. The so-called Johannine Comma (the trinitarian expansion of 1 John 5:7–8 in some older translations) is absent from the earliest and best manuscripts and should not be used as evidence. The doctrine does not need it.
2.6 One God acting: inseparable operations and appropriation
Scripture distinguishes the persons, yet it never divides God’s work as though the Father did one third, the Son another, and the Spirit the rest. Creation is “through” the Son (John 1:3) and by the Spirit hovering over the waters (Genesis 1:2), and still it is the one God who creates. Redemption is the Son’s, yet “in Christ God was reconciling the world to himself” (2 Corinthians 5:19), and Christ offered Himself “through the eternal Spirit” (Hebrews 9:14). Because the three share one nature they share one operation. The Fathers’ word for this mutual indwelling of the persons is perichoresis (“a going around,” hence “interpenetration”), and Jesus says it plainly: “I am in the Father and the Father is in me” (John 14:10). At the same time, Scripture appropriates particular works especially to particular persons: creation to the Father, redemption to the Son, and sanctification to the Spirit. When a Christian receives any gift of God (life, forgiveness, or faith), he receives it from the whole Trinity, though he may rightly thank the Father for making him, the Son for redeeming him, and the Spirit for calling him.
The biblical logic, then, presses toward exactly the confession of Article I. Scripture is too jealously monotheistic to allow three gods, and it shows the three addressing and sending one another too often to allow one person in three costumes. What it gives us is one God, eternally Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
3. Historical Context
If the doctrine is biblical, why did the Church need three centuries and two great councils to state it? The pressure of real questions forced the Church to say carefully what it had always believed.
3.1 Before the crisis
From the beginning, Christians worshiped and baptized in a threefold name (Matthew 28:19). The earliest post-apostolic writers describe trinitarian baptism and worship as ordinary practice (Justin Martyr, First Apology 61, 65–67). However, the vocabulary lagged behind the worship. How could believers say “the Son is God” and “the Spirit is God” without saying “three gods”?
Two wrong turns appeared early. Modalism (also called Sabellianism and, in the West, Patripassianism) protected God’s oneness by making Father, Son, and Spirit merely three modes or roles of a single person, as one man may be father, son, and husband. If the Father and the Son are the same person, then the Father suffered on the cross, and the conversation between Jesus and His Father becomes a kind of theater. Dynamic Monarchianism (or adoptionism) went the other way, treating Christ as a man empowered by God rather than as God the Son from eternity. Its best-known representative, Paul of Samosata, was condemned at a synod in Antioch around 268. (His writings survive mostly through his opponents, but it is clear that he did not confess the Word as an eternal divine person in the Nicene sense.) Both errors tried to guard monotheism, and both failed because they could not hold the biblical data together.
It was Tertullian of Carthage (c. 155–c. 220) who gave the Latin West its enduring words. Writing against the modalist Praxeas, he spoke of one substance in three persons (una substantia, tres personae) and coined the very term Trinitas.
3.2 The Arian crisis
The storm broke in Alexandria around 318, when a presbyter named Arius began teaching that the Son, though the highest of all creatures and the agent of creation, was Himself created, so that “there was once when he was not.” Arius thought he was defending God, since the Son, who is from the Father, seemed to him to belong on the creature’s side of the line between Creator and creation. It was the destruction of the Gospel, for a created Christ cannot join us to God.
Arius’s bishop, Alexander, opposed him, and soon a young deacon named Athanasius took up the fight that would define his life. The controversy threatened the peace of the empire so seriously that the newly converted Emperor Constantine summoned a council of the whole Church. A generation later Gregory of Nyssa would complain (surely with some rhetorical exaggeration) that in Constantinople one could not ask the price of bread or whether the bath was ready without receiving an opinion about the Begotten and the Unbegotten.
3.3 The Council of Nicaea (325)
In 325 some three hundred bishops (tradition says 318) gathered at Nicaea in Asia Minor, many of them bearing in their bodies the scars of the recent persecutions. They produced a creed, and into it they placed a word that is not in the Bible, homoousios (“of the same essence,” or “of one substance” with the Father). The word was chosen precisely because no Arian could say it. To confess that the Son is homoousios with the Father is to confess that He is God in the same sense the Father is God, as the Creed says, “God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father.”
If Scripture alone is the highest authority, how could the Church confess the faith in a term that appears nowhere in the Bible? The answer, which Lutherans affirm, is that a creed adds no new content to Scripture but defends Scripture’s own teaching in words that a false teacher cannot twist. The Arians could quote Bible verses all day, but they could not say that the Son is “of one substance with the Father.” In other words, the extra-biblical word served the biblical truth by closing a loophole. The creeds and the Augsburg Confession are authoritative in the same way, as faithful summaries of Scripture and not as a second revelation, the norma normata (“the normed norm”) serving the norma normans (“the norming norm”).
Nicaea did not end the controversy. For the next half-century there were councils that revised or rejected Nicaea, semi-Arian parties that preferred homoiousios (“of like essence”), and emperors who exiled the defenders of Nicaea. Between homoousios and homoiousios stands one letter, the famous iota, and what a world of difference it makes! Athanasius himself was driven from Alexandria five times, spending more than seventeen years in exile under four emperors. For a time it was “Athanasius against the world” (Athanasius contra mundum).
3.4 The Cappadocians and the Council of Constantinople (381)
The recovery came in the later fourth century, partly through three theologians from Cappadocia: Basil the Great, his friend Gregory of Nazianzus, and his brother Gregory of Nyssa. Earlier Greek writers had sometimes used ousia (“essence”) and hypostasis (“subsistence”) as near-synonyms, which was a recipe for confusion. The Cappadocians fixed the usage that has served the Church ever since: one ousia (essence), three hypostaseis (persons). The Cappadocians also completed the doctrine by defending the full deity of the Holy Spirit against the Pneumatomachi (“Spirit-fighters”), who were willing to honor the Son but hesitated over the Spirit.
In 381 the Emperor Theodosius I convened a council at Constantinople. It reaffirmed Nicaea and expanded the creed’s third article, confessing the Holy Spirit as “the Lord and Giver of life,” who proceeds from the Father and is worshiped and glorified together with the Father and the Son. The resulting text, the Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed, is what most Christians mean when they say “the Nicene Creed,” and it is the creed the Augsburg Confession has in view.
3.5 Augustine, and the seed of a later division
In the Latin West, Augustine of Hippo (354–430) gave the doctrine its most influential Western form in On the Trinity. He explored analogies drawn from the soul (memory, understanding, and will) and, most famously, described the Holy Spirit as the bond of love between the Father and the Son. He also planted a seed that would later divide the Church, a way of speaking about the Spirit as proceeding from the Father and the Son. The phrase (in Latin, Filioque, “and the Son”) entered the Western creed by stages. The Third Council of Toledo used it in 589, the Frankish churches spread it amid controversy in the eighth and ninth centuries, and Rome itself incorporated it into the sung creed only in 1014, in every case without the consent of an ecumenical council. (The Western way of speaking about the Spirit is older than any of these dates, which mark its insertion into the creed.) It became a flashpoint of the schism of 1054, and we return to it in §6.2 and in the note on the Filioque in Appendix B.
The doctrine of God, then, was contended for over generations. When the Augsburg Confession binds itself to Nicaea, it is claiming a hard-won inheritance and placing the Reformation inside that history.
4. Early Church Witness
The Augsburg Confession appeals to “the Fathers,” and I find it helpful to hear them directly, because Article I is essentially a summary of their labor. The purpose is to show that the Reformers’ claim of catholic continuity is true, not to prove the doctrine from the Fathers as if from a second Bible. Tertullian, as we have seen, gave the West its vocabulary. Against Praxeas he insisted that the Father, Son, and Spirit are distinct, “three, not in condition, but in degree; not in substance, but in form,” while remaining “of one substance.”
Athanasius (c. 296–373) is the towering figure. His life’s argument was that our salvation is at stake in the deity of the Son, since only if the Son is truly God can He make us sharers in God’s own life. In his Orations Against the Arians he pressed the point that a created mediator saves no one.
The Cappadocians gave the doctrine its lasting shape. Basil (c. 330–379) wrote On the Holy Spirit to defend the Spirit’s full deity and worship. Gregory of Nyssa (c. 335–c. 395) argued, in a treatise whose title asks That There Are Not Three Gods, that because the Father, Son, and Spirit share one undivided operation they share one nature, and this answered the charge of tritheism. Gregory of Nazianzus (c. 329–390), called simply “the Theologian” in the East, left us one of the most beautiful confessions of the mystery. In his oration on baptism he writes:
No sooner do I conceive of the One than I am illumined by the Splendour of the Three; no sooner do I distinguish Them than I am carried back to the One. (Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 40.41)
That sentence captures the doctrine as prayer rather than puzzle, for the mind cannot rest on the One without being drawn to the Three, nor on the Three without being drawn back to the One.
Finally, the Athanasian Creed (Quicunque vult), which Athanasius did not write but which bears his name because it distills his faith, states the doctrine with great precision, and the Lutheran Confessions receive it among the three ecumenical creeds:
…we worship one God in Trinity, and Trinity in Unity; Neither confounding the Persons, nor dividing the Substance. … So the Father is God, the Son is God, and the Holy Ghost is God. And yet they are not three Gods, but one God. (Athanasian Creed)
When Article I says the Reformers use the word “person” “as the Fathers have used it,” this is the company it means.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
What does the Lutheran confession add to the ancient faith on this article? In one sense it adds nothing, for here at least the Reformers had no correction to offer the catholic tradition, only glad agreement.
5.1 The strategy of beginning here
By opening with the article on which there was no dispute, and by tying it to Nicaea, Melanchthon framed the entire Confession as catholic. The message to Charles V and to Rome was judge us by the ancient faith, for we hold it whole. The Confutation, the official Roman reply drawn up at Augsburg, accepted Article I, and so the Apology treats it briefly: “The First Article of our Confession our adversaries approve” (Ap I.1). On the doctrine of God the evangelicals and their Roman opponents at Augsburg stood together, and this book will find that pattern again: the deepest foundations are shared.
5.2 The Trinity known through the Gospel
Luther’s catechisms teach the Trinity as the God who gives Himself in His works, not as an equation to be solved. In the Large Catechism’s explanation of the Creed, Luther structures the whole confession of God around what each person does for us. The Father creates and preserves, the Son redeems, and the Holy Spirit makes holy and brings us to faith. The Small Catechism says it in the explanation of the First Article, “I believe that God has made me and all creatures,” and of the Third, “I believe that I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ, my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Ghost has called me by the Gospel” (SC, Creed).
This is the Lutheran instinct. We know the Trinity truly by receiving what the triune God does in creation, redemption, and sanctification, and not by climbing up into His hidden majesty. The doctrine is not less than the metaphysics of Nicaea (the Confessions hold that fully), but it is always for us, tied to the Gospel and to faith.
5.3 The creeds as confession
The Book of Concord prints all three creeds (the Apostles’, the Nicene, and the Athanasian) at its head as the Church’s true confession of Scripture. They are norma normata in the sense described above. They say nothing about God that Scripture has not said but they say it in words that guard against distortion.
5.4 A forward link: the Trinity and Christology
Article I’s confession of the Son as true God has a consequence the Confessions develop later. Because the one who was born of Mary and crucified under Pilate is the eternal Son, what is said of God can be said of this man, and what is said of this man can be said of God (the communication of attributes, treated at length in FC SD VIII). This is why the doctrine of God cannot be quarantined from the doctrine of Christ or of the Lord’s Supper.
5.5 The hidden God and the God who is preached
A distinctively Lutheran accent belongs here, though the Confessions state it more fully elsewhere. It is the difference between God as He is in His unapproachable majesty and God as He has revealed Himself for us. Luther warned against clambering up into the “naked” God apart from Christ, because God considered apart from His Word is a consuming fire and offers the sinner no comfort. The God we are to seek, worship, and trust is the God who has clothed Himself in His Word and come to us as Father, Son, and Spirit, the God preached, baptized into, and given in bread and wine. This is no retreat from Nicene metaphysics. Theologians speak of the economic Trinity (God as He reveals and gives Himself in creation and salvation) and the immanent Trinity (God’s own eternal life in Himself as Father, Son, and Spirit). The Confessions hold the full doctrine of the immanent Trinity, for to say only that God acts in three ways would be modalism. The Lutheran accent on the “God for us” is a pastoral discipline about where the sinner should look. Every time the congregation sings the Gloria Patri, confesses the Creed, or receives the Aaronic and apostolic blessings, it is being trained to know the true God in the only place He may be safely known, in His self-giving to us.
6. Comparative Theology
Method note. Each tradition is represented from its own official sources and in its strongest fair form, and a confidence label indicates how firmly the claim rests on binding documents.
6.1 The great agreement
The doctrine of the Trinity is the widest consensus in all of Christianity. Every major tradition compared in this book confesses one God in three co-equal, co-eternal persons on the basis of the Nicene Creed.
- The Roman Catholic Church confesses the Trinity in the same Nicene terms. The Catechism of the Catholic Church devotes its central section on faith in God to “the Holy Trinity” (CCC §§232–267), calling it “the central mystery of Christian faith and life.” (Confidence: high, from a binding magisterial text.)
- The Eastern Orthodox Church holds the Nicene faith with particular intensity, guarding the monarchia of the Father as the single source within the Godhead. (Confidence: high, from the ecumenical councils and the received creed.)
- The Oriental Orthodox Churches, though divided from the rest over the later christological Council of Chalcedon (451), share the trinitarian faith of Nicaea and Constantinople fully. (Confidence: high.)
- Anglican formularies confess the Trinity in the first of the Thirty-Nine Articles (see below). (Confidence: high, from a historic formulary.)
- Lutheran churches confess it in AC I and the three creeds of the Book of Concord. (Confidence: high, from a binding confession.)
- Reformed and Presbyterian churches confess it in the Belgic Confession (Arts. 1, 8–11), the Heidelberg Catechism (Q. 25), and the Westminster Confession (2.3). (Confidence: high, from binding confessions.)
- Methodist churches confess it in the first of the Articles of Religion, Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine Articles. (Confidence: high.)
- Baptist bodies confess it, for example in the Baptist Faith and Message (Art. II) and the Second London Confession (ch. 2). (Confidence: high for these confessions; moderate as a generalization across all autonomous Baptist churches.)
- Pentecostal bodies such as the Assemblies of God confess it in their Statement of Fundamental Truths. (Confidence: high for that statement; see the boundary note below.)
- Seventh-day Adventists now officially confess the Trinity among their Fundamental Beliefs (Beliefs 2–5), a historical development within Adventism, since several early pioneers held non-trinitarian or semi-Arian views. (Confidence: high for the current official statement.)
- Restorationist churches (“no creed but Christ”) generally confess the Trinity in practice while declining formal creeds. (Confidence: limited; a practice, not a binding statement.)
- Non-denominational Evangelical churches are typically and broadly Nicene, though without a shared binding text. (Confidence: limited, since congregational statements vary.)
The Anglican article deserves a closer look. The first of the Thirty-Nine Articles (1571, printed today in the Church of England’s Book of Common Prayer) reads, “There is but one living and true God, everlasting, without body, parts, or passions; of infinite power, wisdom, and goodness; the Maker, and Preserver of all things both visible and invisible. And in unity of this Godhead there be three Persons, of one substance, power, and eternity; the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost.” I want you to notice how closely this follows Article I. The likeness has a history, for the English articles drew on the Augsburg Confession by way of the Thirteen Articles of 1538 and the Forty-Two Articles of 1553. The Methodist Articles of Religion, which are Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, keep the article nearly whole, though they read “without body or parts” and leave out “passions.”
Table 1.1 sets these traditions side by side with each one’s primary official source and its position on the Filioque. Every tradition in it confesses one God in three persons and only the Eastern and Oriental Orthodox churches reject the Filioque. (See Appendix C.) The honest headline is that, on Article I, the Augsburg Confession’s claim to confess with the whole Church is accurate.
6.2 The one live difference among the ancient churches: the Filioque
Within this consensus lies one real, church-dividing difference, which concerns how the Spirit proceeds rather than whether God is triune. The creed of 381 confessed the Spirit as proceeding from the Father, and the Latin West added “and the Son” (Filioque), as §3.5 described.
The Eastern Orthodox objection is twofold. The first concerns authority, since a phrase was inserted into an ecumenical creed without an ecumenical council. The second concerns substance. The East holds that the Father alone is the source (monarchia) within the Godhead, and it worries that the Filioque either introduces two sources or confuses the persons. The Western tradition (Roman Catholic and, by inheritance, most Protestants) reads it as safeguarding the true unity of Father and Son and their joint sending of the Spirit, and it points to texts like John 15:26 and 16:14. Rome denies that this means two sources. The Catechism of the Catholic Church calls the Father “the source and origin of the whole divinity” and teaches that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son “as from one principle.” Modern dialogue has distinguished the Spirit’s eternal procession from His mission in time and has noted Eastern formulations (“from the Father through the Son”) close to Western concerns, but the difference remains real. (Confidence: high that this is the difference. The creed’s history is noted in Appendix B.)
For a confessional Lutheran the Filioque stands in the received Western creeds and is confessed. The Confession’s irenic spirit, and honesty about how the phrase entered the creed, both counsel that it be taught with humility toward the East rather than as a weapon.
6.3 The boundary cases
Because the doctrine of God marks the outer boundary of the Christian confession, we must speak carefully here about groups that stand outside the Nicene faith, describing them from their own sources and classifying them by clear creedal criteria, never by ridicule.
- Oneness Pentecostalism (a stream within the broader Pentecostal movement, not the position of trinitarian bodies like the Assemblies of God) teaches that the one God has revealed Himself as Father, in the Son for our redemption, and as the Holy Spirit, and it typically baptizes “in the name of Jesus” only. This is a modern form of modalistic (Oneness) theology and by the criterion of Nicaea it does not confess three coeternal persons. (Oneness teachers resist a straightforward identification with ancient Sabellianism, so the fairer label is “Oneness” or “modalistic.”)
- Unitarianism denies the full deity of the Son and the Spirit outright.
- Jehovah’s Witnesses teach, in their own official materials, that Jesus is God’s first creation, the one through whom God then made all other things, and not God in the Nicene sense. This is comparable to the ancient Arian position.
- The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints teaches that the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost are three distinct beings, perfectly united in purpose, knowledge, and power. This is not the Nicene doctrine of three persons who share one indivisible divine essence.
To say that these groups fall outside the Nicene confession is a description and not an insult, and it is the same kind of judgment Article I makes when it “condemns” the ancient errors.
6.4 Comparison table
Table 1.1, The Nicene Consensus and the Live Difference, is in Appendix C. Table 1.2 gathers the boundary discussion.
Table 1.2—Anti-Trinitarian Errors, Ancient and Modern (for the boundary discussion)
| Error | Core claim | What it denies | Ancient form | Modern echo |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Modalism / Sabellianism | one person in three modes | the distinction of persons | Praxeas, Sabellius | Oneness Pentecostalism |
| Arianism | the Son is a created being | the Son’s full deity | Arius, Eunomius | Jehovah’s Witnesses |
| Adoptionism | Christ a man empowered by God | the Son’s eternal deity | Paul of Samosata | some liberal Christologies |
| Tritheism | three gods | the oneness of God | (a charge, rarely a program) | popular misunderstanding; the LDS account of three distinct beings differs fundamentally from Nicene monotheism |
| Unitarianism | God is one person only | the deity of Son and Spirit | Socinianism | modern Unitarianism |
How to read this table. Historical labels such as Arian, modalist, and adoptionist identify patterns of doctrine, not the motives or spiritual condition of individual people. The “modern echo” column indicates a meaningful similarity rather than an exact equation and each present-day group should be allowed to describe itself in its own words (as in §6.3).
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
It is tempting to treat the Trinity as the most abstract of doctrines, a mystery for theologians that is safely admired and quietly shelved. However, Article I is the ground on which you actually stand as a Christian, and not a preface to be hurried past on the way to the “practical” articles.
The Trinity is the shape of the Gospel. Your salvation is triune from first to last, for the Father sends, the Son redeems, and the Spirit gives faith. If the Son were a creature, His cross could not reconcile you to God, because no creature can bridge the gulf between the Creator and the sinner. If the Spirit were less than God, faith would rest on something less than God, and no conscience could lean its whole weight on it. To confess the Trinity is to confess that your salvation is entirely God’s work, from the Father’s love to the Son’s blood to the Spirit’s call.
The Trinity secures assurance. Because the Son who died for you is true God, His one sacrifice is of infinite worth, sufficient for the whole world and for you. Because the Spirit who calls you is true God, the faith He works is a gift He guards and not a mood you must sustain. Perhaps your faith seems so weak that you wonder whether it counts at all. The Lord does not turn it away, for “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3). A merely human Christ and a merely creaturely Spirit would leave the conscience to its own resources, which is to say without hope, but the triune God does not leave you there. He comes to you where He has promised to be found: in the Word preached, in your Baptism, in the absolution, and in the Lord’s Supper. When your conscience is troubled, go there, for that is where the Father gives you His Son by the Spirit.
The Trinity is the pattern of prayer and worship. You do not pray into the void. You pray to the Father, through the Son, in the Holy Spirit. Every baptism is administered in the triune name (Matthew 28:19), every benediction breathes the triune blessing (2 Corinthians 13:14), and the Gloria Patri rehearses the doctrine week by week. To worship the triune God is to be drawn into the mystery rather than to solve it, carried, as Gregory said, from the One to the Three and back again.
The Trinity and the life of love, with a caution. Some have drawn from the Trinity a pattern for human community, marriage, and the Church, and there is real truth in it. We are made in the image of the God who is love (1 John 4:8), and the Son prays that His people “may all be one, just as you, Father, are in me, and I in you” (John 17:21). I want to be careful here, though, because the caution matters as much as the truth. Three human “persons” are three beings, while the three divine persons are one God, and analogies from human relationship mislead when they are pressed into tritheism or turned into a political program. The soundest pastoral use is modest. The triune God who is love in Himself is the God who pours His love into your heart by the Spirit (Romans 5:5), and the Christian life is learning to live from that love rather than to manufacture it.
The Trinity teaches humility before mystery. The doctrine confesses God without pretending to comprehend Him. The Athanasian Creed’s careful “Neither confounding the Persons, nor dividing the Substance” is a fence around a mystery rather than a formula for mastering God, and it keeps us from the errors that would make God manageable and small.
The Trinity anchors the Church’s unity and its charity. Because this is the faith of the whole Church of every age, the doctrine of God is where Christians of many traditions can and do stand together, and that is why this book can compare traditions honestly and charitably. The same God is confessed across the divisions we will study and that forbids us to treat other Christians as though they worshiped another God. Where faithful teaching must say that a group stands outside the Nicene faith, the pastoral task is to hold clarity about the truth (a created Christ cannot save, and a modalist God is not the God of the Gospel) together with real love for the people who hold these views. Article I condemns errors, and not people, in order to protect the Gospel.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article I confesses the Holy Trinity in the words of Nicaea, one divine essence in three co-equal, co-eternal persons, and by beginning here the Reformers declared themselves catholic. The doctrine rests on three affirmations of Scripture (God is one; Father, Son, and Spirit are each God; and the three are truly distinct), and it was contended for at Nicaea (325) and Constantinople (381). The Lutheran Confessions add no correction. They receive the three creeds and teach the Trinity as the shape of the Gospel. Nearly all of Christianity stands together here, the Filioque is the one live difference among the ancient churches, and the anti-trinitarian movements fall outside the Nicene faith by clear creedal criteria.
8.2 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Trinity: one God in three persons.
- Essence / ousia: what God is; the one divine being.
- Person / hypostasis: one who subsists of Himself; not a part, mode, or role.
- Homoousios: “of the same essence”; the Son is God as the Father is God.
- Filioque: “and the Son”; the Western addition on the Spirit’s procession.
- Perichoresis: the mutual indwelling of the three persons.
8.3 Tables in this chapter
- Table 1.1: The Nicene Consensus and the Live Difference (Appendix C).
- Table 1.2: Anti-Trinitarian Errors, Ancient and Modern.
8.4 Further reading
Primary: The Augsburg Confession, Art. I, and the three ecumenical creeds, in The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation; Athanasius, Orations Against the Arians; Basil, On the Holy Spirit; Gregory of Nazianzus, Theological Orations; Augustine, On the Trinity.
Lutheran/systematic: Arand, Kolb & Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions; Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 1.
Historical: J. N. D. Kelly, Early Christian Doctrines and Early Christian Creeds; Lewis Ayres, Nicaea and Its Legacy; Khaled Anatolios, Retrieving Nicaea; R. P. C. Hanson, The Search for the Christian Doctrine of God.
On the Filioque: A. Edward Siecienski, The Filioque: History of a Doctrinal Controversy.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.