Books · The Augsburg Compass

Appendix M—Denomination Profiles

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

A one-page profile of each tradition the book compares: its origin, founders, size, the official sources the book uses for it, its distinctives, and where it stands on the articles of the Augsburg Confession, with the chapters that treat it.

How to read these profiles

Each tradition is described in its own terms and from its own official sources, as the chapters do. The summary at the end of each profile gathers what the chapters say about that tradition, article by article, with the chapter where each point is treated. It is a map of the book’s comparisons, not a fresh judgment, and the chapters give the evidence and the nuance. Where a chapter does not compare a tradition on an article, the profile does not supply a position for it.

Two cautions belong at the head. First, most of these traditions are families of churches, not single bodies, and a statement true of one body may not hold for another; the chapters name the body or confession wherever it matters. Second, membership figures are counted differently by different sources (baptized members, adult members, or the whole community) and are given only where a reliable source could be checked, with its date. Where none could be, the profile says “size varies; no single figure.”

The chapters on the articles are numbered from Chapter 1 (AC I) to Chapter 28 (AC XXVIII): the chapter number is the article number.

Ch. AC Ch. AC Ch. AC Ch. AC
6 I God 13 VIII The Church 20 XV Church usages 27 XXII Both kinds
7 II Original sin 14 IX Baptism 21 XVI Civil government 28 XXIII Marriage of priests
8 III Son of God 15 X Lord’s Supper 22 XVII Christ’s return 29 XXIV The Mass
9 IV Justification 16 XI Confession 23 XVIII Free will 30 XXV Confession
10 V Ministry 17 XII Repentance 24 XIX Cause of sin 31 XXVI Foods
11 VI New obedience 18 XIII Use of sacraments 25 XX Faith and works 32 XXVII Monastic vows
12 VII The Church 19 XIV Church order 26 XXI Saints 33 XXVIII Church power

1. The Roman Catholic Church (DEN001)

Origin and date. Ancient. The Catholic Church traces itself to the apostolic Church; its distinct identity sharpened after the East–West schism (1054) and at the Council of Trent (1545–1563). Founders. It understands itself as founded by Christ through the apostles, especially Peter. Polity. Episcopal, under the bishop of Rome. Besides the Latin Church it includes the Eastern Catholic Churches in communion with Rome.

Size. 1,405,454,000 Catholics as of June 30, 2023 (Agenzia Fides, “Catholic Church Statistics 2025,” from the Vatican’s statistical yearbook).

Official sources the book uses. The Council of Trent; the Catechism of the Catholic Church; the First Vatican Council (Pastor Aeternus, 1870); the Second Vatican Council (Lumen Gentium, Dei Verbum, Unitatis Redintegratio, Gaudium et Spes, Dignitatis Humanae, Sacrosanctum Concilium, Presbyterorum Ordinis); Dominus Iesus (2000); the Code of Canon Law; the ecumenical creeds.

Distinctives. Seven sacraments; a teaching office (magisterium) of the pope and the bishops; the primacy and infallibility of the pope; transubstantiation and the Mass as sacrifice; clerical celibacy in the Latin rite as a discipline, not a dogma.

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book finds wide and real agreement: the Trinity, with the Filioque (Ch. 1); the person of Christ (Ch. 3); a real Fall and a real Baptism that regenerates (Chs. 2, 9); grace given through external means (Ch. 5); the rejection of Donatism (Ch. 8); the true presence of Christ’s body and blood (Ch. 10); civil government as God’s ordinance, an article the Confutation accepted (Ch. 16); God in no way the cause of moral evil (Ch. 19); and the goodness of marriage (Ch. 23). Rome is not Pelagian and does not teach salvation by works (Chs. 4, 6, 20).

The differences the book names are these. On justification, Trent teaches an inward renewal by infused grace, the merit of works done in grace, and that no one can know with the certainty of faith that he has obtained grace; the Joint Declaration of 1999 is a “differentiated consensus,” and confessional Lutheran bodies such as the LCMS did not receive it (Chs. 4, 6, 20). Concupiscence in the baptized is not “truly and properly sin” (Chs. 2, 9). Trent rejects that faith alone in the promise receives the sacrament’s gift (Chs. 5, 8, 13). The Church of Christ “subsists in” the Catholic Church (Ch. 7). Penance requires the confession of all mortal sins and satisfaction for temporal punishment (Chs. 11, 12, 25). There are seven sacraments (Ch. 13), and holy orders with apostolic succession is essential to a valid ministry (Ch. 14). The Church may bind its precepts on the conscience (Chs. 15, 26). Purgatory (Ch. 17). The will, moved by prevenient grace, cooperates in conversion (Ch. 18). The saints are invoked, and the Marian dogmas of 1854 and 1950 are held (Ch. 21). The cup may be withheld, though both kinds are now widely given (Ch. 22). Celibacy may be required of Latin-rite priests (Ch. 23). The Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice that makes present the one sacrifice of Calvary (Ch. 24). The consecrated life has “an objective superiority” (Ch. 27). The pope holds primacy of jurisdiction by divine right and is infallible when he defines ex cathedra (Ch. 28).


2. The Eastern Orthodox Church (DEN002)

Origin and date. Ancient. The formal break between East and West is conventionally dated 1054. Founders. Apostolic, in its own understanding; a communion of self-governing (autocephalous) churches with no single head. Polity. Episcopal and conciliar; the Patriarch of Constantinople holds the first place.

Size. Pew Research Center counts “nearly 260 million” Orthodox Christians worldwide (2017). That figure includes the Oriental Orthodox churches (profile 3), which Pew puts at roughly 20 percent of the total; Pew gives no separate count for the Eastern Orthodox.

Official sources the book uses. The seven ecumenical councils; the Nicene Creed without the Filioque; the Confession of Dositheus (Synod of Jerusalem, 1672); the Longer Catechism of St. Philaret; the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom; Patriarch Jeremias II’s reply to the Tübingen theologians (1576); the Russian Orthodox Bases of the Social Concept (2000); the Orthodox Church in America’s catechesis (Hopko, The Orthodox Faith; Essential Orthodox Christian Beliefs, 2023); and, as an interpreter, Kallistos Ware.

Distinctives. The Father as the single source within the Godhead; salvation as theosis (union with God) through synergy; the holy mysteries, including infant communion; icons; a married parish priesthood with celibate bishops; a rich discipline of fasting; monasticism as the heart of the spiritual life.

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book finds deep common ground: the Trinity (Ch. 1) and the person of Christ (Ch. 3); a real change in the Supper, held as a mystery, which stands close to the Lutheran refusal to explain the presence (Ch. 10); the rejection of Donatism (Ch. 8); Baptism of infants (Ch. 9); real absolution (Chs. 11, 25); both kinds for all, never withdrawn (Ch. 22); married priests (Ch. 23); and the rejection of papal supremacy by divine right (Ch. 28).

The differences: the Orthodox reject the Filioque (Ch. 1) and confess ancestral sin without inherited guilt (Chs. 2, 21). Salvation is framed as healing and union rather than a verdict, with grace and the healed will cooperating; Jeremias II answered the Augsburg Confession article by article, and Dositheus taught justification “through faith and works” (Chs. 4, 6, 18, 20). The Church is identified with the Orthodox communion (Ch. 7). Confession and penance are therapeutic, with epitimia as medicine (Chs. 11, 12, 25). The seven mysteries, though many hold the number lightly (Ch. 13). The bishop in succession is necessary to the Church (Ch. 14). Holy Tradition (Ch. 15) and the ideal of symphonia between church and state (Ch. 16). The departed are prayed for, though purgatory is not accepted (Ch. 17). The saints and icons are venerated and invoked (Ch. 21). The Liturgy is a bloodless sacrifice offered for the living and the departed (Ch. 24). Fasting is canonical, though applied pastorally (Ch. 26). Monastic profession is a “second baptism,” though not by the merit of the vow (Ch. 27).


3. The Oriental Orthodox Churches (DEN003)

Origin and date. A distinct communion after the Council of Chalcedon (451). Founders. Apostolic, in their own understanding; the Coptic Church, for example, traces itself to St. Mark. Polity. Episcopal and conciliar. The family includes the Coptic, Syriac, Armenian, Ethiopian, Eritrean, and Malankara (Indian) churches.

Size. Roughly 20 percent of the world’s Orthodox Christians, according to Pew Research Center (2017), out of a total of “nearly 260 million” (see profile 2). Pew gives no separate figure.

Official sources the book uses. The first three ecumenical councils; the Nicene Creed; the christological formula of Cyril of Alexandria (“the one incarnate nature of the Word”); the Agreed Statements of the joint commission with the Eastern Orthodox (1989, 1990); the common declarations with Rome (Coptic, 1973; Syriac Orthodox, 1984; Armenian, 1996).

Distinctives. Miaphysite Christology: one united divine-human nature in Christ, without mixture or change, without separation or division. These churches condemn Eutyches, and the book will not call them “monophysite” (Ch. 3).

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book compares the Oriental Orthodox on two articles. They share fully the trinitarian faith of Nicaea and Constantinople, and they confess the Creed without the Filioque (Ch. 1). On the person of Christ, the joint commission of 1989–1990 concluded that the Eastern and Oriental families confess the same faith in different words; the book’s verdict is that these are “brothers we mislabeled” (Ch. 3). The other articles do not compare them separately.


4. The Anglican Communion (DEN004)

Origin and date. The Act of Supremacy (1534); the formularies 1549–1571. Founders. No single founder: Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformers, under Henry VIII, Edward VI, and Elizabeth I. Polity. Episcopal, keeping the historic episcopate; no central teaching office, and the provinces are self-governing. The Episcopal Church is its province in the United States.

Size. Size varies; no single figure. (The Anglican Communion Office’s own pages could not be reached on the date this appendix was prepared.)

Official sources the book uses. The Thirty-Nine Articles (1571); the Book of Common Prayer (1662), and the American Prayer Book (1979) where it is cited; the Ordinal; the Chicago–Lambeth Quadrilateral (1886–1888); the ecumenical creeds; and, for the modern range, ARCIC’s Eucharistic Doctrine (1971) as received by the Lambeth Conference (1988).

Distinctives. “Two Sacraments of the Gospel” and five “commonly called Sacraments”; the historic episcopate, held by some to be of the Church’s being and by others of its well-being; common prayer in the Prayer Book; a wide range of belief, from Anglo-Catholic to evangelical. The Articles bind differently from province to province.

Against the Augsburg Confession. On many articles the book finds the Anglican formularies standing very near the Lutheran confession, and several of the Articles descend from Augsburg itself. Article I follows AC I (Ch. 1); Article IX rejects the Pelagians as AC II does (Ch. 2); Article II follows AC III almost word for word (Ch. 3). Article XI confesses “that we are justified by Faith only,” and Article XII calls good works the fruits of faith (Chs. 4, 6, 20); the Anglican Consultative Council welcomed the Joint Declaration (2016). Article XXV calls the sacraments “effectual signs of grace” (Chs. 5, 13). Article XIX defines the church by Word and Sacrament (Ch. 7), and Article XXVI rejects Donatism (Ch. 8). Article XXVII retains infant Baptism, and the Prayer Book calls the baptized child “regenerate” (Ch. 9). Confession is available and never compelled: “All may. Some should. None must.” (Chs. 11, 25). Article XVI restores the fallen (Ch. 12). The church may order ceremonies, as AC XV holds (Chs. 15, 26). Articles XXXVII–XXXIX answer the Anabaptist positions that AC XVI condemns (Ch. 16). Article XVII teaches predestination to life and is silent on reprobation (Chs. 18, 19). Article XXX gives both kinds (Ch. 22) and Article XXXII permits clergy to marry (Ch. 23). Article XXXI rejects the “sacrifices of Masses” (Ch. 24), and Article XX limits the church’s authority much as AC XXVIII does (Ch. 28).

The differences the book names: on the Supper, the Articles follow the Reformed, teaching that the body is received “only after an heavenly and spiritual manner” and that the wicked do not partake of Christ (Chs. 7, 10). Article XXV does not count penance a sacrament, where the Apology will call absolution one (Ch. 25). Article XXII rejects the invocation of saints, yet practice ranges widely (Ch. 21). The weight given to the historic episcopate goes further than the Lutheran “the form is free” (Chs. 7, 14, 28), and the catholic wing reads the Eucharist as a sacrifice (Ch. 24). Some Anglicans hold conditional immortality (Ch. 17).


5. The Lutheran Churches (DEN005)

Origin and date. The movement from 1517; the presentation of the Augsburg Confession, 1530. Founders. Martin Luther; Philip Melanchthon, author of the Augsburg Confession. Polity. Mixed: episcopal in some lands (Sweden), consistorial or synodical in others (much of Germany), with “equal conscience” (Ch. 14). The book’s catalog also lists the principal American bodies: the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod (1847), the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (1850), the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (1988), Lutheran Congregations in Mission for Christ (2001), and the North American Lutheran Church (2010).

Size. 78,431,111 members in the 150 member churches of the Lutheran World Federation (2023, LWF membership statistics). Several Lutheran churches, the LCMS and WELS among them, are not members of the Federation and are not counted in that figure.

Official sources the book uses. The Book of Concord (1580): the three ecumenical creeds, the Augsburg Confession and its Apology, the Smalcald Articles and the Treatise, Luther’s Small and Large Catechisms, and the Formula of Concord.

Distinctives. Justification by grace through faith for Christ’s sake as the chief article; the Word and the Sacraments as the means through which the Holy Spirit gives faith; the true body and blood of Christ in, with, and under the bread and wine, received by all who commune; infant Baptism as God’s work; private confession and absolution kept and freed from enumeration; the distinction of Law and Gospel; freedom in ceremonies; the two kingdoms.

Against the Augsburg Confession. This is the book’s own confession, set out in §5 of each chapter. The Lutheran churches differ among themselves in how they subscribe to the Confessions and in matters such as who may be ordained, a question Chapter 14 leaves open. The Lutheran World Federation signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification with Rome in 1999; confessional bodies, the LCMS among them, did not receive it (Ch. 4). In 2010 the Federation asked the Mennonites’ forgiveness for the persecution of the Anabaptists, and the Mennonites accepted (Ch. 9).


6. The Reformed and Presbyterian Churches (DEN011, DEN012)

Origin and date. Zurich, 1519–1523: Zwingli began preaching there in January 1519, and the city council adopted the Reformation after the First Zurich Disputation in January 1523; the Scottish Reformation, c. 1560; the confessions, 1561–1619 and the Westminster Assembly. Founders. Huldrych Zwingli, John Calvin, and Heinrich Bullinger; John Knox in Scotland. Polity. Presbyterian: rule by elders in a ladder of assemblies, with parity among ministers. “Reformed” names the family and “Presbyterian” its polity-named branch.

Size. The World Communion of Reformed Churches describes itself as “100 million Christians from more than 230 member churches in 109 countries” (no year stated; read November 2026).

Official sources the book uses. The Heidelberg Catechism (1563), the Belgic Confession (1561), and the Canons of Dort (1618–1619), together the “Three Forms of Unity”; the Westminster Confession and its Larger and Shorter Catechisms; the Scots Confession (1560); the Second Helvetic Confession; and, as background, Calvin’s Institutes.

Distinctives. God’s sovereignty and monergism in salvation; the sacraments as “signs and seals” of the covenant of grace; a spiritual feeding on Christ in the Supper; the regulative principle of worship; church discipline, in some confessions a third mark of the Church; the Law’s third use as “the principal use.”

Against the Augsburg Confession. On many articles the book calls the Reformed the Lutheran’s “nearest neighbor” or “closest kin.” They confess the Trinity (Ch. 1); total depravity and inherited guilt (Ch. 2); justification as forensic, by faith alone, on Christ’s imputed righteousness (Chs. 4, 20); good works as the fruit of faith and of gratitude (Chs. 6, 20); repentance as an evangelical grace (Ch. 12); the rejection of Donatism (Ch. 8); the magistrate as God’s minister (Ch. 16); the shared creedal hope (Ch. 17); no invocation of saints (Ch. 21); both kinds (Ch. 22); married clergy (Ch. 23); no propitiatory sacrifice in the Supper (Ch. 24); and councils that may err (Ch. 28). They expressly deny that God is the author of sin (Ch. 19). The Reformed associated themselves with the Joint Declaration in 2017 (Ch. 4).

The differences: the extra Calvinisticum against the communication of the divine majesty to Christ’s human nature (Ch. 3), and a definite (particular) atonement (Chs. 3, 18). The sacraments as signs and seals whose grace “is not tied to that moment of time,” so that Baptism does not regenerate all who receive it (Chs. 5, 9, 13). Christ received in the Supper by faith alone, unbelievers receiving only the sign (Chs. 7, 10, 13). Discipline as a third mark of the Church (Chs. 7, 8). The keys located chiefly in preaching and discipline, without a rite of private absolution (Chs. 11, 25). Presbyterian polity held by many as of divine right (Chs. 14, 28). The regulative principle against the Lutheran normative principle (Ch. 15). Double predestination, and a decree that ordains the fall (Chs. 18, 19). The fasting calendar set aside, and the Sabbath command kept on the Lord’s Day (Ch. 26).


7. The Anabaptist and Mennonite Churches (DEN019)

Origin and date. Zurich, January 1525, when the first believers’ baptisms took place. Founders. Conrad Grebel and Felix Manz; later Menno Simons, from whom the Mennonites take their name. Polity. Congregational. The family includes the Mennonites, Amish, Hutterites, and Brethren.

Size. Mennonite World Conference counts a “faith family” of “2.03 million baptized believers in 87 countries” (no year stated), and close to 950,000 baptized believers in its own member churches as of September 2026.

Official sources the book uses. The Schleitheim Confession (1527); the Dordrecht Confession (1632); the Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995); and the Lutheran–Mennonite study Healing Memories: Reconciling in Christ (2010).

Distinctives. Believers’ Baptism; a visible church of committed disciples kept by discipline (the ban); nonresistance and the refusal of oaths; separation from the world. The Augsburg Confession condemns sixteenth-century Anabaptist positions by name in Articles V, IX, XII, XVI, and XVII; the book distinguishes those radicals from today’s Mennonites and from the Baptists (Chs. 5, 9, 12).

Against the Augsburg Confession. On Article V, the Swiss Brethren held fast to Scripture, and today’s Mennonites are not the people the condemnation describes (Ch. 5). On Article VIII, the desire for a regenerate membership is not the Donatist error, though the Lutheran holds that the Church in this age is a mixed body (Ch. 8). On Article IX the difference stands: Mennonites baptize believers only, holding that infants “are safe in the care of God,” and they ordinarily baptize by pouring. The persecution of the Anabaptists, by Lutherans among others, was repented of in 2010 (Ch. 9). On Article XII, their discipline aims at restoration, and no modern Mennonite confession teaches perfectionism (Ch. 12). On Article XVI they are the primary contrast: they hold nonresistance and decline oaths, where the Lutheran holds that a Christian may serve in the civil order; the book begins “with admiration” for their costly obedience (Ch. 16). On Article XVII, today’s Anabaptists and Mennonites are not universalists, and Menno Simons and his heirs repudiated Münster (Ch. 17).


8. The Baptist Churches (DEN014)

Origin and date. c. 1609 at Amsterdam, among English exiles; in America from 1638/39. The Baptists arose from English Separatism, not from the continental Anabaptists (Ch. 9). Founders. John Smyth and Thomas Helwys (General Baptists); the Particular Baptists of London in the 1630s and 1640s. Polity. Congregational, with voluntary associations.

Size. Size varies; no single figure. (The Baptist World Alliance’s own pages could not be reached on the date this appendix was prepared.)

Official sources the book uses. The Second London Baptist Confession (1689); the Baptist Faith and Message (Southern Baptist Convention, 2000); the Standard Confession (1660) and the Orthodox Creed (1679) for the General Baptists; Thomas Helwys, A Short Declaration of the Mystery of Iniquity (1612). There is no single “Baptist position,” and the book names the confession it describes.

Distinctives. Baptism of believers only, by immersion; Baptism and the Supper as “ordinances”; the local gathered congregation and its autonomy; religious liberty and liberty of conscience; both Calvinist (Particular) and Arminian (General) streams.

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book finds agreement on the Trinity (Ch. 1) and the person of Christ (Ch. 3); justification by grace through faith (Chs. 4, 20); the authority of the preached Word (Ch. 5); the rejection of Donatism (Ch. 8); a called and examined ministry without a hierarchy of succession (Ch. 14); liberty of conscience, one of Protestantism’s great contributions (Ch. 16); no invocation of saints (Ch. 21); both kinds (Ch. 22); married clergy (Ch. 23); and no propitiatory sacrifice (Ch. 24).

The differences: Baptists hold several doctrines of original sin, many an “age of accountability” (Ch. 2). Baptism and the Supper are chiefly ordinances of obedience and witness, not means through which God gives forgiveness, so that justification is not tied to them (Chs. 4, 5, 13). The church is chiefly the local congregation of baptized believers (Ch. 7). Baptism is for believers only; the Second London Confession speaks more strongly of it than later practice, though not of Baptism as giving the new birth (Ch. 9). The Baptist Faith and Message calls the Supper a “symbolic act of obedience,” while the Second London Confession teaches a spiritual feeding on Christ (Chs. 10, 24). Confession is made to God and to one another, without an office of absolution (Ch. 11). The Second London Confession adopts the regulative principle (Ch. 15). On free will and election, Baptists hold every shade from Calvinist to Arminian (Ch. 18). Within the wider evangelical world the book notes the “Lordship salvation” debate (Ch. 6) and the danger of resting assurance on the sincerity of one’s repentance or decision (Chs. 12, 20).


9. The Methodist and Wesleyan Churches (DEN013)

Origin and date. John Wesley’s Aldersgate experience, 1738; organization as a church in America, 1784. Founders. John and Charles Wesley; George Whitefield in the early years. Polity. Connectional, with bishops in American Methodism; British Methodism has no bishops and ordains through the Conference (Ch. 14). The family includes the United Methodist Church, the Global Methodist Church, and the Holiness bodies.

Size. The World Methodist Council describes its member churches as “representing over 80 million members in 138 countries” (no year stated; read November 2026).

Official sources the book uses. The Articles of Religion (1784), Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine Articles; Wesley’s Standard Sermons and A Plain Account of Christian Perfection; the General Rules; the Books of Discipline; and the United Methodist statement This Holy Mystery (2004).

Distinctives. Prevenient grace, given to all and restoring the freedom to respond; Christian perfection, which Wesley defined as perfect love and not sinlessness; the inward witness of the Spirit; a high regard for the Lord’s Supper and for fasting.

Against the Augsburg Confession. Through the Articles of Religion the Methodists carry much of the Anglican agreement with Augsburg. They confess the Trinity (Ch. 1), original sin (Ch. 2), the person of Christ (Ch. 3), and justification “by faith, only” (Ch. 4); the Methodists associated themselves with the Joint Declaration in 2006 (Ch. 4). Good works are the fruits of faith (Chs. 6, 20). The church is defined by Word and Sacrament (Ch. 7). Infant Baptism is kept (Ch. 9). The fallen may rise again (Ch. 12). Ceremonies are free (Chs. 15, 26). Christ will return to judge (Ch. 17). The invocation of saints is rejected (Ch. 21). Both kinds (Ch. 22), the marriage of ministers (Ch. 23), and the rejection of the sacrifice of Masses (Ch. 24) all stand in the Articles. Wesley could say that faith is “the only condition” of justification (Ch. 20).

The differences: the Articles call the sacraments only “certain signs of grace” (Chs. 5, 13). The United Methodist Church confesses a real but spiritual presence and leaves out the Anglican article denying that the wicked eat Christ (Ch. 10). Wesley confined sin “properly so called” to the voluntary transgression of a known law, where the Lutheran holds that the inborn disease remains truly sin (Ch. 12). The will, freed by prevenient grace, may accept or refuse God, an Arminian account the Lutheran does not share (Chs. 2, 18, 19). On church order, American Methodism keeps bishops without holding the succession of hands essential, and the Articles leave out Article XXIII on the call (Ch. 14).


10. The Restoration Movement (Stone–Campbell) (DEN016)

Origin and date. c. 1801–1832, from the Cane Ridge revival to the joining of the Stone and Campbell movements. Founders. Barton W. Stone; Thomas and Alexander Campbell. Polity. Congregational. Three main branches: the Churches of Christ, the Christian Churches/Churches of Christ, and the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ).

Size. Size varies; no single figure.

Official sources the book uses. The movement declines binding creeds on principle (“no creed but Christ”). The book draws on its founding texts, among them the Declaration and Address (1809), and on Alexander Campbell, The Christian System (1835). Because there is no binding confession, the book’s confidence in generalizations here is limited.

Distinctives. The restoration of New Testament Christianity; baptism of believers by immersion, tied to the remission of sins; the Lord’s Supper every week.

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book compares the Restoration churches on two articles. They generally confess the Trinity in practice while declining formal creeds (Ch. 1, confidence limited). They share believers’ immersion with the Baptists but, unlike most Baptists, tie the remission of sins to the act of baptism itself, reading Acts 2:38 instrumentally (Ch. 9). The book also cites Everett Ferguson’s Baptism in the Early Church (2009), the work of a scholar from the Churches of Christ (Ch. 9). The other articles do not compare them separately.


11. The Pentecostal and Charismatic Churches (DEN015)

Origin and date. The Azusa Street revival, Los Angeles, 1906; the Assemblies of God organized 1914. Its roots are in the Holiness movement and so in Wesleyan Methodism. Founders. Charles Parham (Topeka); William J. Seymour (Azusa Street). Polity. Varies, from congregational to connectional; the Church of God in Christ is governed by bishops (Chs. 14, 28).

Size. Pew Research Center (2011) estimated about 279 million pentecostal Christians and 305 million charismatic Christians worldwide, figures based on the world Christian population of 2010.

Official sources the book uses. The Assemblies of God Statement of Fundamental Truths, and the statements of faith of other Pentecostal bodies.

Distinctives. Baptism in the Holy Spirit as an experience following conversion; the gifts of the Spirit; worship open to the Spirit’s leading; the “direct witness of the Spirit” as evidence of salvation. Oneness Pentecostalism, which denies three persons in God, is a boundary case and not the position of trinitarian bodies such as the Assemblies of God (Ch. 1).

Against the Augsburg Confession. Trinitarian Pentecostals confess the Trinity (Ch. 1), the person of Christ, and that Christ died for all (Ch. 3). The book insists that the “enthusiasts” condemned in the sixteenth century “cannot simply be equated with modern Pentecostal Christians”: they love the Scriptures, baptize, and celebrate Communion. The difference on Article V lies in assurance and the Spirit’s further work, a baptism in the Spirit after conversion and an inward witness the Lutheran hears instead in the Word and Sacraments; the book calls it “a difference of emphasis among fellow Christians” (Ch. 5). Most Pentecostal churches baptize believers only, by immersion (Ch. 9). The call is tested by credentialing in the larger bodies (Ch. 14), and worship prizes freedom from fixed forms (Ch. 15). The other articles do not compare them separately.


12. The Seventh-day Adventist Church (DEN017)

Origin and date. Formally organized in 1863, from the Millerite movement of nineteenth-century American Adventism. Founders. Ellen G. White, James White, and Joseph Bates. Polity. Connectional, with a representative structure of conferences.

Size. Size varies; no single figure. (The church’s own statistics pages could not be reached on the date this appendix was prepared.)

Official sources the book uses. The 28 Fundamental Beliefs; the writings of Ellen G. White, which the church regards as prophetic counsel; the Seventh-day Adventist Bible Commentary; and the General Conference’s Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists.

Distinctives. The seventh-day Sabbath; the death of the whole person as an unconscious sleep until the resurrection; conditional immortality; the pre-Advent investigative judgment, dated from 1844; the distinction of clean and unclean foods and a “health message.”

Against the Augsburg Confession. Adventists now officially confess the Trinity (Fundamental Beliefs 2–5), a development within their history (Ch. 1). The book treats them on three further articles. They keep the seventh day as a standing command of the Decalogue, “a symbol of our redemption in Christ,” and deny that keeping it earns salvation; the Lutheran reads Colossians 2:16–17 as making the day free (Chs. 15, 26). They teach that the dead sleep until the resurrection, that the wicked are finally destroyed rather than everlastingly punished, and an investigative judgment from 1844, all of which differ from AC XVII (Ch. 17). They abstain from unclean foods as a standard of Christian behavior, not a condition of salvation; the Lutheran difference is exegetical (Ch. 26).


13. The Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) (DEN021)

Origin and date. c. 1652, in England. Founders. George Fox and Margaret Fell. Polity. Associational: yearly meetings. Friends today range from programmed churches with pastors to unprogrammed meetings gathered in silence (Ch. 5).

Size. Size varies; no single figure.

Official sources the book uses. There is no binding confession. The book draws on Robert Barclay’s Apology for the True Christian Divinity (1678), the Declaration to Charles II (1660), and the yearly meetings’ books of discipline, especially Britain Yearly Meeting’s Quaker Faith & Practice.

Distinctives. The Inward Light of Christ; inward baptism and inward communion in place of the outward rites; the peace testimony; affirmation in place of oaths.

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book compares the Friends on three articles. On Article V they are “the clearest case” of the Spirit teaching the soul immediately: they have kept no outward sacraments and hold the Scriptures “a secondary rule, subordinate to the Spirit,” though some evangelical Friends churches now allow water baptism and the Supper. The book honors their concern for the Spirit’s freedom and holds that God has promised to meet us at the means (Ch. 5). On Article XIII they observe no outward sacraments; “neither is careless about grace,” the book says of them and the Salvation Army (Ch. 13). On Article XVI they renounced outward wars and decline oaths, yet Friends governed and judged in colonial Pennsylvania (Ch. 16). The other articles do not compare them separately.


14. The Congregationalist Churches (DEN020)

Origin and date. The English Separatists, c. 1580s; the Cambridge Platform (1648) and the Savoy Declaration (1658). Founders. Robert Browne in the early years; the New England Puritans. Polity. Congregational, from which the tradition takes its name. Many congregations flowed into later bodies such as the United Church of Christ, whose theological range is wide.

Size. Size varies; no single figure.

Official sources the book uses. The Savoy Declaration (1658); the Cambridge Platform (1648); in doctrine, the Reformed confessions of the Westminster family.

Distinctives. Reformed in doctrine and congregational in polity: each local congregation gathered under Christ governs itself, and wider associations advise but do not govern.

Against the Augsburg Confession. The book compares the Congregationalists, with the Baptists, on church order. The local gathered congregation calls, examines, and sets apart its own officers; congregations confer in associations without any body holding jurisdiction over them. Like the Lutheran, they reject a hierarchy of succession and insist that the call come through the Church; the difference is where the call is located and what ordination is (Ch. 14). Authority rests in the local congregation under Christ and His Word (Ch. 28). The book does not compare the Congregationalists separately on the other articles; on doctrine their confessions belong to the Reformed family (profile 6).


15. Non-denominational Evangelical Churches (DEN018)

Origin and date. Twentieth century, accelerating after 1970. Founders. None; a movement of independent congregations drawn from Baptist, Bible-church, and charismatic streams. Polity. Congregational and independent; many congregations are led by elders (Ch. 14).

Size. Size varies; no single figure.

Official sources the book uses. There is typically no binding confession, only each congregation’s statement of faith, often broadly evangelical. The book describes common tendencies, not fixed doctrine, and labels its confidence “limited.”

Distinctives. The local congregation within a universal church of all true believers; light institutional structure; Baptism and the Supper chiefly as ordinances of obedience and remembrance; wide internal diversity.

Against the Augsburg Confession. These churches are typically and broadly Nicene (Ch. 1). Most baptize believers (Ch. 9) and hold a memorial understanding of the Supper (Chs. 10, 24). On the Church, the instinct that “the church is the people” is sound, but where the Sacraments recede as marks the assurance Article VII gives, that the Church can be found, weakens (Ch. 7). Practice in calling ministers varies widely (Ch. 14), and the saints’ days have usually been dropped (Ch. 21). The chapters’ comparisons of “Baptist and Evangelical” Christians on justification, faith and works, confession, and repentance apply to many of these congregations as well (Chs. 4, 6, 11, 12, 20).

Topics
Other Churches and TraditionsBaptismThe Lutheran Confessions
Scripture
Acts 2:38Colossians 2:16–17
Confessions
AC IAC XXVIIIAC IIAC IIIAC XVAC XVIAC XVII

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.