Appendix C—Comparison Charts
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
These charts belong to the chapters named in their headings. Each chapter gives a short summary of its chart and points here. Every tradition is described from its own official sources, which each chart names.
Chapter 1—Article I: Of God (The Holy Trinity)
Chart: The Nicene Consensus and the Live Difference (Table 1.1)
From Chapter 1, §6.1. The consensus is the point of this chart; the one live difference is the Filioque.
| Tradition (ID) | Confesses one God in three persons? | Primary official source | Filioque? | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roman Catholic (DEN001) | Yes | CCC §§232–267; Nicene Creed | Yes (West) | High |
| Eastern Orthodox (DEN002) | Yes | Nicene Creed (381); the councils | No | High |
| Oriental Orthodox (DEN003) | Yes | Nicene Creed; first 3 councils | No | High |
| Anglican (DEN004) | Yes | 39 Articles I, V | Yes | High |
| Lutheran (DEN005) | Yes | AC I; the 3 creeds | Yes | High |
| Reformed (DEN011) | Yes | Belgic 1, 8–11; Heidelberg Q25 | Yes | High |
| Presbyterian (DEN012) | Yes | Westminster 2.3 | Yes | High |
| Methodist (DEN013) | Yes | Articles of Religion I, IV | Yes | High |
| Baptist (DEN014) | Yes | BF&M II; 2LBC 2.3 | Yes (2LBC 2.3; BF&M silent) | High (per confession) |
| Pentecostal (DEN015) | Yes (trinitarian bodies) | AoG Fundamental Truth 2 | Yes | High / see boundary |
| Adventist (DEN017) | Yes | Fundamental Beliefs 2–5 | Not stated | High (note history) |
| Restoration (DEN016) | Yes (in practice) | “no creed but Christ” | n/a | Limited |
| Non-denom. Evangelical (DEN018) | Yes (broadly) | congregational statements | usually | Limited |
Chapter 7—Article VII: The Church
Chart: Where Is the True Church? (Table 7.1)
From Chapter 7, §8.2. Confidence: high on the Lutheran, Roman Catholic, Orthodox, and Reformed rows; moderate on the Anglican and Baptist rows; limited on the non-denominational row.
| Tradition | Where the church is identified |
|---|---|
| Lutheran | The assembly of believers, located by the marks: the Gospel purely preached and the Sacraments rightly administered |
| Roman Catholic | The Church of Christ subsists in the Catholic Church, in hierarchical communion with the pope; elements of sanctification exist beyond her bounds |
| Eastern Orthodox | The one conciliar communion of Orthodox churches that have kept the apostolic faith and the true mysteries (no papacy) |
| Anglican | The congregation where “the pure Word of God is preached, and the Sacraments be duly ministered” (Art. XIX), with the historic episcopate widely prized |
| Reformed | Word, Sacrament, and church discipline (a third mark in the Belgic and Scots Confessions; Calvin names two); the church invisible and visible |
| Baptist | Chiefly the local, gathered congregation of professing, baptized believers, observing the two ordinances; plus a universal (“invisible”) church |
| Non-denominational (tendency) | The local congregation of believers, within a universal church of all true believers; Baptism and the Supper chiefly as ordinances; light structure |
The marks matter because they tell the troubled conscience where Christ has promised to be found: where the Gospel is rightly taught and the Sacraments rightly administered, His Church is there (AC VII.1). For the true unity of the Church “it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments”; human traditions, rites, and ceremonies need not “be everywhere alike” (AC VII.2–3). The Gospel is at stake in the marks; the polity is free.
Chapter 9—Article IX: Baptism
Chart: Baptism: Who, How, and What It Does (Table 9.1)
From Chapter 9, §8.
| Tradition | Who is baptized | Mode | What it does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | Infants and adult converts | Any (water with the Word in the triune name; the mode is not commanded) | Necessary (AC IX.1); a means of grace: it “works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe” (SC IV.6); regenerates (Titus 3:5; SC IV.10); received by faith |
| Roman Catholic | Infants and adult converts | Pouring / immersion | Regenerates; removes all sin (concupiscence not “truly and properly sin”); necessary; ex opere operato (by Christ’s power; fruits depend on disposition) |
| Eastern Orthodox | Infants and adult converts | Triple immersion (+ chrismation and Communion) | Regenerates and incorporates; a mystery |
| Anglican | Infants and adult converts | Dipping (1662 rubric) / pouring | Sign of regeneration “as by an instrument” (Art. XXVII); child declared “regenerate” (BCP); read across a range |
| Reformed / Presbyterian | Infants and adult converts | Pouring / sprinkling | Covenant sign and seal; grace conferred to the elect, not tied to the moment |
| Methodist | Infants and adult converts | Any | “Sign of regeneration” (Art. XVII); prevenient grace; read across a range |
| Baptist | Believers only | Immersion | Ordinance; “an act of obedience symbolizing the believer’s faith” (BF&M VII); faith strengthened (2LBC 14.1) |
| Restoration / Churches of Christ | Believers only | Immersion | Believer’s immersion for the remission of sins (efficacious) |
“Who,” “mode,” and “what it does” are distinct questions, not points on one spectrum. The Anglican and Methodist rows quote those churches’ formularies, which their members read across a wide range. The Restoration churches have no binding creed, so that row describes common teaching. Pentecostal and Anabaptist bodies also practice believer’s baptism, though Mennonite and Amish churches ordinarily baptize by pouring. The Mennonite Confession of Faith (1995) allows that “the church may baptize by pouring, immersion, or the sprinkling of water” (Art. 11, Commentary 2).
Chapter 10—Article X: The Lord’s Supper
Chart: Views of the Lord’s Supper: What Is Present, and How (Table 10.1)
From Chapter 10, §8.2. The rows are not a single spectrum: the Orthodox and the receptionist positions do not sit on one line.
| Tradition | Is Christ truly present? | Mode (how) | Do the elements change? | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roman Catholic | Yes | Substance changed (transubstantiation) | Yes—substance changes; the appearances (species) remain | CCC §§1373–1381; Trent XIII |
| Lutheran | Yes | Sacramental union—“in, with, and under”; received orally by all | Not in substance: bread remains bread, yet by the sacramental union “the bread is the body of Christ” (FC SD VII.14, quoting the Wittenberg Concord) | AC X; FC VII/VIII; SC VI |
| Eastern Orthodox | Yes | The gifts become Christ’s body/blood, by the Spirit—a mystery | Yes—the gifts become Christ’s body and blood; the manner is held as mystery (Dositheus and Philaret use “transubstantiation”; many modern Orthodox do not) | Divine Liturgy; Dositheus, Decree 17; Philaret, Q338–340; modern Orthodox theologians (Ware, The Orthodox Church, 1993 ed., ch. 14; Hopko, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2, OCA) |
| Reformed / Presbyterian | Yes—a true feeding | Spiritually, by the Spirit lifting believers to the ascended Christ; received by faith | No | Calvin Inst. IV.17; Heidelberg Q75–79; Westminster 29; 2LBC 1689 ch. 30.7 (Reformed Baptist) |
| Anglican | Yes (from a spiritual presence to the faithful, to an objective presence in the elements) | “Heavenly and spiritual manner,” received by faith (Articles) | No (Articles); Anglo-Catholics vary | 39 Articles XXVIII–XXIX; BCP 1662 Catechism and Declaration on Kneeling |
| Methodist / Wesleyan | Yes—real spiritual presence | Spiritually, a means of grace | No | Wesley, Articles XVIII; Hymns on the Lord’s Supper; This Holy Mystery (UMC, 2004) |
| Baptist / Evangelical (memorial) | Not in the elements; Christ is remembered and His return anticipated | Symbol / memorial—“a symbolic act of obedience” | No | BFM 2000 VII |
Confidence: high on the Roman Catholic, Lutheran, Orthodox, and Reformed rows; moderate on the Anglican, Methodist, and named-Baptist-confession rows (internal range); limited on the broad non-denominational tendency (no binding text). The Reformed row is Calvin, not Zwingli: a true spiritual feeding, not a bare symbol.
“Truly present” does not mean the same thing in every row. The Formula of Concord warns of those who speak “in our own words” of a true presence while holding that it “occurs spiritually through faith” (FC Ep VII.4–5), and it rejects the teaching that the body of Christ is received “only spiritually by faith” (FC Ep VII.26). In the Lutheran row the body and blood are present in the elements and are received with the mouth by all who eat, by the unworthy to their judgment (FC Ep VII.15–16).
For the Lutheran the question of presence serves the promise. The words “Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins” show “that in the Sacrament forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation are given us through these words” (SC VI.6). That gift is what is at stake.
Chapter 16—Article XVI: Civil Government
Chart: May a Christian…? Civil Life Across the Traditions (Table 16.1)
From Chapter 16, §8.4.
| Hold civil office? | Bear arms / serve as a soldier? | Swear a lawful oath? | Go to court / sit as a judge? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | Yes—a good calling | Yes—in a just cause, in office | Yes—when lawfully required | Yes—justice serves the neighbor |
| Roman Catholic | Yes | Yes (just-war tradition) | Yes | Yes |
| Eastern Orthodox | Yes | Yes (with a tradition of penance) | Yes | Yes |
| Reformed | Yes | Yes (just war) | Yes | Yes |
| Anglican | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Baptist | Yes (with church-state separation) | Generally yes (some dissent) | Generally yes | Yes |
| Anabaptist / Mennonite | Historically no (nonresistance) | No (nonresistance) | No (affirm instead) | Historically no as judge or magistrate (Schleitheim 6); going to court discouraged |
| Quaker | Yes, historically (colonial Pennsylvania); Friends began leaving the Assembly in 1756 rather than vote for war | No, as testimony (peace testimony) | No (affirm instead) | Not forbidden; legal action, especially between Friends, to be avoided if possible |
Confidence: high on the Lutheran, Roman Catholic, and Anabaptist/Mennonite rows (confessional or binding sources); moderate on the others, where practice varies among churches of the same tradition. The Anabaptist/Mennonite row gives the historic confessions; the present-day Mennonite confession (1995) leaves more room for civic participation. The Anabaptist/Mennonite and Quaker rows mark the real divide with AC XVI and are represented from those traditions’ own sources.
Sources for the Quaker row: Britain Yearly Meeting, Quaker Faith & Practice, 4.24 (“Legal action by Friends, and in particular legal disputes between Friends, should if possible be avoided”), https://qfp.quaker.org.uk/passage/4-24/; Isaac Barnes May, “Religious Society of Friends (Quakers),” Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia, https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/essays/religious-society-of-friends-quakers/ (both accessed November 18, 2026).
What AC XVI guards is the Gospel. It condemns those “who forbid these civil offices to Christians” and those who place evangelical perfection “in forsaking civil offices,” for “the Gospel teaches an eternal righteousness of the heart” (AC XVI.3–5). No one is righteous before God by holding an office or by refusing one. The dispute with the Anabaptist and Quaker rows is whether these callings are open to a Christian with a good conscience.
Chapter 21—Article XXI: The Worship of the Saints
Chart: Mary Across the Traditions: Titles, Dogmas, and Devotion (Table 21.2)
From Chapter 21, §8.2. Its sources are listed under the table.
| Lutheran | Roman Catholic | Eastern Orthodox | Reformed / Evangelical | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Theotokos / Mother of God (Ephesus, 431) | Affirmed (FC Ep VIII.12) | Affirmed | Affirmed (central) | Ephesus’s Christology received; the title itself often avoided |
| “Blessed are you among women” / model of faith | Yes (Luke 1:42, 48) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Perpetual virginity (semper virgo) | Luther affirmed it; the Confessions mention it in passing (SA I.iv Lat.; FC SD VIII.24, “remained a virgin”) but do not set it out as an article to be confessed and bound | Dogma (Lateran Synod, 649; CCC 499) | Confessed (Aeiparthenos, Constantinople II, 553; daily in the Liturgy) | Reformers and Second Helvetic Conf. (ch. XI) affirmed it; most modern evangelicals do not |
| Immaculate Conception (defined 1854) | Not confessed; contrary to AC II.1 (“all men begotten in the natural way are born with sin”) | Dogma (Ineffabilis Deus, 1854) | Not accepted (different view of ancestral sin); honored as Panagia | Rejected |
| Assumption (defined 1950) | Not confessed | Dogma (Munificentissimus Deus, 1950) | Held and kept as a Great Feast (the Dormition); not defined in the Roman manner | Rejected |
| Mediatrix / Co-Redemptrix | No (one Mediator, 1 Tim 2:5) | Mediatrix used with qualification (LG 62; CCC 969–970); Co-Redemptrix judged inappropriate (Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Mater Populi Fidelis 22, 2025) | Not a defined title; hymnody calls her “mediation unto the Creator” and intercessor before God | No |
| Invocation of Mary | No | Yes | Yes | No |
Honor Mary as Scripture honors her; do not require of the conscience what Scripture does not require. Dates are of the Roman definitions of 1854 and 1950. Sources: AC II.1; FC Ep VIII.12; FC SD VIII.24; SA I.iv (Lat. semper virgine), Concordia Triglotta; Council of Ephesus (431); Constantinople II (553), anathemas 6 and 14; Lateran Synod (649), can. 3 (DS 503); Ineffabilis Deus (1854); Munificentissimus Deus (1950); Lumen Gentium 62; CCC 499, 969–970; DDF, Mater Populi Fidelis (2025) 22; the Orthodox Theotokion “O protection of Christians” (prayers before Holy Communion); Second Helvetic Confession XI.
Chapter 23—Article XXIII: The Marriage of Priests
Chart: Clergy Marriage Across Traditions (Table 23.1)
From Chapter 23, §8.
| Tradition | May clergy be married? | Marry after ordination? | Are bishops celibate? | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | Yes | Yes | No requirement | AC XXIII; Ap XXIII; SA III.xi |
| Eastern Orthodox | Yes (if married before ordination) | No | Yes (chosen from monastics) | Council in Trullo (692), cann. 6, 12, 13, 48; bishops from monastics by later practice |
| Anglican | Yes | Yes | No requirement | Thirty-Nine Articles, Art. XXXII |
| Methodist | Yes | Yes | No requirement | Articles of Religion, Art. XXI |
| Reformed / Baptist / Evangelical | Yes | Yes | No requirement | Westminster Confession 24.3; Second London Baptist Confession 25.3; common practice |
| Roman Catholic (Latin rite) | Priests: no, celibacy required (a discipline), with dispensation for married convert clergy | No | Yes | Trent Sess. XXIV; Code of Canon Law (1983), can. 277 |
| Catholic (Latin) permanent deacons | Yes (if married before ordination) | No | (not applicable) | Lumen Gentium 29; Code of Canon Law, cann. 1031 §2, 1087 |
| Eastern Catholic churches | Yes, priests and deacons (if married before ordination), where particular law allows | No | Yes | Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (1990), cann. 180, 373, 758 §3; CCC 1580 |
On the practice of clergy marriage the traditions largely agree; the historic exception is the Latin-rite requirement of celibacy, itself qualified by several exceptions.
Chapter 24—Article XXIV: The Mass
Chart: Is the Eucharist a Sacrifice? Across the Traditions (Table 24.2)
From Chapter 24, §8.2.
| Tradition | The Eucharist as sacrifice? | In brief | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | A sacrifice of thanksgiving/praise, yes; a propitiatory sacrifice, no | The Supper is Christ’s gift received; the Church offers thanks, not a propitiation | AC XXIV; Ap XXIV; SA II.ii |
| Roman Catholic | Yes, a true and proper propitiatory sacrifice | The one sacrifice of Calvary made present (not repeated; not a new death); also Christ’s gift received; applied to living and dead | Trent Sess. XXII; CCC 1362–1372 |
| Eastern Orthodox | Yes, the bloodless sacrifice; Dositheus calls it “a true and propitiatory Sacrifice offered for all Orthodox, living and dead” | The Divine Liturgy makes present the one offering of Christ, who offers and is offered, receives and is received; offered for living and departed; no purgatory as Rome defines it, though the departed are helped by the prayers of the priests, by good works, and above all by the unbloody Sacrifice (Decree 18) | Liturgy of St John Chrysostom; Synod of Jerusalem (1672), Decrees 17–18 |
| Anglican | Ranges widely | Article XXXI rejects the “sacrifices of Masses” offered “for the quick and the dead”; BCP 1662 offers praise and self; Anglo-Catholic and ARCIC language of making-present | 39 Articles XXXI; BCP 1662; ARCIC (1971), a dialogue statement |
| Methodist | No propitiatory sacrifice | Christ’s offering once made the only satisfaction; Communion is “a re-presentation, not a repetition, of the sacrifice of Christ” (This Holy Mystery) | Articles of Religion XX; This Holy Mystery (UMC, 2004) |
| Reformed | No propitiatory sacrifice | A commemoration of the one offering and a spiritual oblation of praise; spiritual feeding on Christ | Westminster Confession 29.2, 29.7 |
| Baptist / Evangelical | No propitiatory sacrifice | A memorial; the Second London Confession adds a spiritual oblation of praise and spiritual feeding, the Baptist Faith and Message calls it a symbolic act; confessions differ on what the believer receives | Second London Confession 30.2, 30.7; Baptist Faith and Message (2000) VII |
No tradition here teaches that Christ dies again or that Calvary was insufficient. The real difference is whether the Eucharist, received by all as Christ’s gift, is also a propitiatory sacrifice offered to God for the living and the dead.
Chapter 28—Article XXVIII: Ecclesiastical Power (The Power of Bishops)
From Chapter 28, §8, which summarizes both charts.
Chart: The Papacy: Supreme Jurisdiction / Primacy of Honor / Rejected (Table 28.2)
| Tradition | View of the papacy | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Roman Catholic | Supreme universal jurisdiction; infallible ex cathedra | Matthew 16:18–19; Luke 22:32; John 21:15–17; Vatican I (Pastor Aeternus); Vatican II (Lumen Gentium 22) |
| Eastern Orthodox | Primacy of honor (first among equals), for some also of appeal; not universal jurisdiction | Nicaea canon 6; Constantinople I canon 3; Chalcedon canon 28; conciliarity |
| Anglican | Historic episcopate without the papacy | Thirty-Nine Articles (XX, XXXVII); the Ordinal |
| Lutheran | No papacy by divine right (SA II.iv.1–9; Tr 1–21), and belief in it is not necessary to salvation (Tr 3–4); the Confessions judge that the papal claims of their day bear the marks of Antichrist (SA II.iv.10–11; Tr 39–41), a judgment on the office’s teaching, not on persons. Whether a primacy by human right could be borne they leave unresolved: Melanchthon’s subscription allows it, and Luther doubts it would help (SA II.iv.7–9) | AC XXVIII; SA II.iv; the Treatise |
| Reformed / Presbyterian | No papacy; power in assemblies of elders | Westminster Confession 25.6, 30–31; Belgic Confession 30–32 |
| Baptist / Congregational | No papacy; authority in the local congregation | Second London Confession 26; Baptist Faith and Message VI, XIV |
Chart: Where Authority Sits (Table 28.3)
| Tradition | Locus of church authority |
|---|---|
| Roman Catholic | The pope with the college of bishops, as the teaching office that serves Scripture and Tradition (Dei Verbum 10) |
| Eastern Orthodox | Councils, received by the whole Church; the bishops in communion |
| Anglican | Bishops in synod, under Scripture, creeds, and formularies (Art. XX) |
| Lutheran | The Word alone as rule; the keys given to the whole Church (Tr 24, 67–69) and exercised by divine right through the called ministry (AC XXVIII.5–6, 21); the outward polity by human right (ius humanum) |
| Reformed / Presbyterian | Graded assemblies of elders |
| Baptist / Congregational | The gathered local congregation |
The office of the ministry is Christ’s (divine); the outward structure is, in large part, the Church’s freedom.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.