Books · The Divine Liturgy

The Service of the Sacrament, Part Two

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The Lord’s Prayer and the Verba

The Lord’s Prayer

In the LSB Setting Three (Common Service) order, the Lord’s Prayer is said immediately after the Sanctus and before the Verba. In Settings One and Two, the order may have the Lord’s Prayer after the Verba, following the older Western Roman pattern. Both placements have ancient precedent.

The Lord’s Prayer is, of course, the prayer Jesus Himself taught His disciples (Matthew 6:9–13; Luke 11:2–4). Its inclusion in the eucharistic rite is attested as early as the late fourth century in Cyril of Jerusalem and was universalized in the West by Gregory the Great. Its position in the rite emphasizes that the church approaches the eucharistic mystery in the words Christ Himself gave her — words that include petition for daily bread (with eucharistic resonance), for forgiveness of trespasses (appropriate to the moment of approaching the Sacrament of forgiveness), and for deliverance from evil (appropriate to the moment of approaching the holy gifts unworthily would profane).

Each petition of the Lord’s Prayer is eucharistic in some sense. “Hallowed be Thy name” — the Sacrament hallows the name of the triune God whose gift it is. “Thy kingdom come” — the Sacrament is the foretaste of the messianic banquet of the kingdom. “Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven” — the Sacrament is the union of earth and heaven. “Give us this day our daily bread” — the Sacrament is the supersubstantial bread (cf. Matthew 6:11 with the difficult Greek epiousion, which the Vulgate sometimes translates supersubstantialis). “Forgive us our trespasses” — the Sacrament is given “for the forgiveness of sins.” “Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil” — the Sacrament strengthens the communicant against the powers of evil.

The Lord’s Prayer is also the great prayer of the gathered church. To pray it in unison is to fulfill the apostolic exhortation that the church “with one voice glorify the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 15:6). The Lutheran tradition typically prays the prayer in its full traditional form, including the doxology (“For Thine is the kingdom, and the power, and the glory, forever and ever. Amen”) — a doxology not present in the best Greek manuscripts of Matthew 6 but attested as early as the Didache (8:2) and universally used in Christian liturgy by the fourth century.

The Verba — The Words of Our Lord

We now arrive at the climax of the Divine Service. The pastor, standing at the altar before the bread and wine, speaks the Words of Institution — the Verba Testamenti, the “words of the testament”:

Our Lord Jesus Christ, in the night in which He was betrayed, took bread; and when He had given thanks, He brake it and gave it to His disciples, saying: Take, eat; this is My body, which is given for you. This do in remembrance of Me.

After the same manner also He took the cup, when He had supped, and when He had given thanks, He gave it to them, saying: Drink ye all of it; this cup is the New Testament in My blood, which is shed for you for the remission of sins. This do, as oft as ye drink it, in remembrance of Me.

These words are drawn from four New Testament accounts of the institution: Matthew 26:26–29, Mark 14:22–25, Luke 22:14–20, and 1 Corinthians 11:23–26. The liturgical text harmonizes the four accounts in a form that has stood substantially unchanged in Christian worship since the second century.

The Theological Significance

The Words of Institution are the consecratory action of the Sacrament. When the pastor — the called and ordained servant of Christ — speaks these words over the bread and wine, in the assembly, with the intent to do what Christ instituted, then what Christ said happens: this is His body; this is His blood. The Lutheran Confessions are explicit: “the true body and blood of Christ are truly present under the form of bread and wine in the Lord’s Supper, and are there distributed and received.”³⁶ The mechanism is the divine Word joined to the physical element — the same pattern as in Baptism, where the divine Word joined to water makes the washing a means of grace.

The Verba do four things at once. First, they narrate the institution — recalling the historical event of the Last Supper. Second, they consecrate — making the bread and wine, in the assembly, the body and blood of Christ. Third, they promise — extending Christ’s “for you” to the present communicants. Fourth, they invite — “Take, eat… Drink ye all of it” is direct address to the people who are about to receive.

The “for you” (Greek hyper hymōn, Latin pro vobis) is the most pastorally powerful phrase in the Verba. Luther in the Large Catechism dwelled on it at length: “These words must be diligently considered, observed, and pondered, for upon them the whole power and force, fruit, and benefit of this sacrament depends. They include and embrace what is good for the body and what is good for the soul.”³⁷ The “for you” individualizes the gospel: this is not merely the body and blood of Christ in general; this is His body, given for you, with all the benefits of His passion delivered to you in this Sacrament.

Gestures at the Verba — The Sign of the Cross, the Elevation, and the Bow

The Verba is the most sacramentally significant moment of the Divine Service, and the ceremonial gestures that accompany it are correspondingly substantial. Several traditional practices deserve treatment.

The Pastor’s Sign of the Cross Over the Elements. As the pastor speaks the Verba over the bread and wine, he traditionally makes the sign of the cross over each element at the words of consecration. Specifically: at “This is my body,” the pastor traces a cross over the host (or bread) with his right hand; at “This cup is the New Testament in my blood,” he traces a cross over the chalice. The gesture is not a magical act — the consecration is effected by Christ’s words, not by the pastor’s hand — but a visible confession of what is happening. The sign of the cross marks the elements as Christ’s body and blood, identifying them by the cross on which Christ’s body was given and His blood was shed. The Lutheran Reformers preserved this gesture; Luther’s Formula Missae assumes it, and most confessional Lutheran rites continue it.

The Bow at the Verba. During the speaking of the Verba, the pastor traditionally bows over the elements — a profound bow that confesses the holy mystery being administered. Some pastors bow at the moment of speaking “This is my body” and again at “This is my blood.” Others maintain a continuous slight bow throughout the Verba. The bow is a bodily confession of the reality being administered: the pastor, however many times he has celebrated the Sacrament, approaches each consecration as a sinner ministering the holy gifts, with the reverence appropriate to the body and blood of Christ.

The congregation likewise traditionally bows during the Verba. Some bow profoundly only at the moments of “This is my body” and “This is my blood”; others maintain a continuous slight inclination throughout the Verba. The bow is the universal Christian gesture of reverence in the presence of the holy, and there is no moment in the Divine Service when the holy is more concentratedly present than during the consecration.

The Elevation. The traditional Lutheran practice — following Luther’s own custom in the Formula Missae — included the elevation of the consecrated host and chalice immediately after the Verba. The pastor lifts the consecrated host above the altar with both hands for a brief moment, then lifts the chalice in the same way. The purpose is twofold: (1) to allow the congregation to see what has been consecrated, and (2) to confess publicly that what is held is the body and blood of Christ. The elevation has ancient roots in Western liturgical practice and was retained by Luther despite some Reformed Lutheran objections.

Luther himself defended the elevation in his correspondence and in the Formula Missae: “We hold the elevation… because it signifies that Christ has commanded us to remember Him.” When Karlstadt and other reformers urged its abolition as a “papistic” remnant, Luther refused on the grounds that it was adiaphora and that its retention was a confession of the real presence over against any Reformed reduction. Luther later allowed congregations to discontinue the elevation if local pastoral circumstances warranted (Deutsche Messe permits its omission), but in his own celebrating practice he continued it.

In contemporary LCMS, WELS, and ELS practice, the elevation is preserved in many congregations, particularly those that maintain a more catholic-liturgical sensibility. Where the elevation is practiced, the congregation traditionally bows during the lifting of the host and chalice. Some traditions add the sign of the cross at the moment of elevation. In congregations that do not practice the elevation, the pastor may instead make the sign of the cross over the elements or simply pause briefly before continuing.

Genuflection at the Consecration. Some high-church Lutheran congregations preserve the practice of genuflection at the Verba: the pastor genuflects after the consecration of each element, briefly bending the right knee to the floor in adoration of the consecrated body and blood. This is the principal moment in the Divine Service where Lutheran practice approaches Roman Catholic ceremonial. The Lutheran Confessions do not require genuflection, but they do not forbid it; FC SD VII affirms the genuine presence of Christ in the consecrated elements, and bodily reverence at this moment is a confession of that presence. Most Lutheran practice today substitutes the bow for the genuflection, but the genuflection remains an option for those who wish to preserve the older Western practice.

The Pastor’s Voice and the Chanting of the Verba. A final note bears mention. Luther’s Formula Missae directed that the Verba should be chanted aloud, in the same musical setting as the Gospel — that is, with the same tone of solemn proclamation. This was a deliberate reform: the medieval Roman practice had the Verba spoken silently or in a whisper as part of the silent Canon. Luther insisted that the Verba be heard by the people, because the Verba are the church’s proclamation of Christ’s gift, not the priest’s private prayer to God. In contemporary Lutheran practice, the Verba are typically chanted (or spoken loudly) by the pastor facing the altar or facing the congregation, with the people able to hear every word clearly. The audible chanting or speaking of the Verba is itself a confession of the gift-character of the Sacrament.

The Real Presence Affirmed

The Lutheran tradition has fought tenaciously to preserve the real, bodily, sacramental presence of Christ in the Supper. The classical Reformed objection — that a finite body cannot be in many places at once, and therefore Christ’s body cannot be on every altar where the Supper is celebrated — was met by the Lutheran appeal to the personal union of the natures in Christ and to the divine omnipresence communicated to the human nature (the communicatio idiomatum). The Lutheran position is not that the body of Christ is locally circumscribed in the bread but that the body of Christ is sacramentally present — given in, with, and under the bread, according to His own Word.

The Reformed objection that “this is my body” must be interpreted metaphorically (as Zwingli held) or as a “spiritual” rather than substantial presence (as Calvin held) was answered by Luther’s appeal to the plain force of the dominical words. In the great debate at Marburg (1529), Luther wrote the words Hoc est corpus meum (“This is my body”) in chalk on the table and refused to move from them. The exchange between Luther and Zwingli became proverbial: Zwingli pressed allegorical and grammatical arguments; Luther refused to interpret “is” as anything but “is.” The Lutheran Confessions stand on this point: “We are dealing with the words of Christ’s testament, which He bequeathed and ordained for us, and which therefore cannot be falsely interpreted.”³⁸

The Manducation Question

A further point of Lutheran sacramental theology bears mention. The Lutheran tradition has historically held that the body and blood of Christ are received not only spiritually by the faithful but also physically by the mouth — and that even the unbeliever, by partaking of the Sacrament, receives the body and blood (though to his judgment, 1 Corinthians 11:27–29). This is sometimes called the manducatio oralis (“oral eating”) or manducatio impiorum (“eating by the impious”). It safeguards the objective reality of the Sacrament: what is given is given because Christ has said so, not because the recipient has summoned it by his faith. Faith is the necessary condition for receiving the benefit of the Sacrament, but not for the reality of it.

This is a delicate point that requires careful pastoral application. The doctrine is not designed to terrify Christians but to safeguard the gift. Christ’s body is truly present and truly given — to all who receive, whether they receive in faith for blessing or in unbelief for judgment. Therefore the Sacrament requires preparation: self-examination, faith in Christ, intention to amend the life, and the desire to be reconciled with one’s neighbor. The Lutheran practice of close communion — admitting to the Sacrament only those who confess the same faith as the celebrating church — is rooted in this sacramental realism.³⁹


³⁶ Augsburg Confession, Article X, Latin text, in Book of Concord, ed. Kolb-Wengert, 44. ³⁷ Martin Luther, Large Catechism, V, in Book of Concord, ed. Kolb-Wengert, 469. ³⁸ Smalcald Articles, III.VI, in Book of Concord, ed. Kolb-Wengert, 320. ³⁹ For a recent careful treatment, see Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper: A Report of the Commission on Theology and Church Relations of the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (St. Louis: CTCR, 1983).

Topics
The Lord's SupperChurch and MinistryThe Lord's PrayerWorship and Liturgy
Scripture
Matthew 6:9–13Luke 11:2–4Matthew 6:11Romans 15:6Matthew 26:26–29Mark 14:22–25Luke 22:14–201 Corinthians 11:23–261 Corinthians 11:27–29
Confessions
SD VIIAC XLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.