The Medieval Mass
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Continuity, Accretion, and the Need for Reform
The Stabilization of the Roman Rite
Between the seventh and the sixteenth centuries, the Western Mass underwent a long process of development and accretion. The basic ordo established by the patristic age — Introit, Kyrie, Gloria, Collect, Epistle, Gradual, Alleluia, Gospel, Creed, Offertory, Sursum corda, Sanctus, Canon, Lord’s Prayer, Agnus Dei, Communion, Postcommunion, Dismissal — was substantially in place by the time of Pope Gregory the Great (d. 604), to whom subsequent tradition (rightly or wrongly) ascribed the systematization of the Latin Mass and the development of plainsong (Gregorian chant).
This ordo is recognizably the ordo of the Lutheran Divine Service. The major sections, the major texts (Kyrie, Gloria, Creed, Sanctus, Lord’s Prayer, Agnus Dei, Nunc Dimittis), and the major sequence (entrance, Word, sacrament, dismissal) are continuous from Gregory’s day to ours. When Lutheran Service Book (2006) appoints the same Introit psalmody, the same Kyrie, the same Gloria, the same Sanctus, and the same Agnus Dei that Gregory’s Mass appointed in the early seventh century, this is not antiquarianism. It is catholicity in the proper sense — the church of every age sharing in the same prayer.
The Carolingian and Medieval Developments
The Carolingian period (eighth–ninth centuries) saw the imposition of the Roman rite across western Europe under Charlemagne’s standardization. This produced a relatively uniform Latin Mass throughout the Holy Roman Empire, with regional variants (the Gallican, Mozarabic, and Ambrosian uses) absorbed or marginalized. By the high Middle Ages, the Mass had taken on the elaborate ceremonial familiar from late medieval sources: extensive vesting prayers, multiple Collects, the use of the rood screen separating clergy from laity, the silent recitation of the Canon by the priest, the elevation of the host and chalice after the Verba, the giving of the pax via the pax board rather than direct exchange, and the rise of private and votive Masses celebrated by individual priests for specific intentions.
Several developments in this period would prove deeply problematic. First, the Mass came to be understood increasingly as a propitiatory sacrifice offered by the priest on behalf of the people — a sacrifice distinct from, though related to, the once-for-all sacrifice of Calvary. This understanding underwrote the practice of Mass stipends (payments for the celebration of Mass for specific intentions, including for the souls of the departed) and contributed to the eventual abuse of indulgences. Second, the practice of communion under one kind (bread alone) for the laity, with the chalice reserved for the clergy, developed gradually and was made universal by the Council of Constance (1415). Third, the Latin language, originally the vernacular of the Western Empire, became increasingly opaque to the laity as the Romance languages diverged from it, with the result that the people heard the Mass without understanding the words.
By the fifteenth century, the Western Mass had become, for the average layperson, a ceremony to be observed rather than a service to be participated in. The priest performed the Mass at the altar in a language the people did not speak, with his back to them, often behind a screen, in a low voice for the Canon. The people watched, knelt at the elevation, perhaps recited private devotions, and occasionally (often annually, at Easter) received communion under one kind. The Word was hardly preached at all in most parishes. The sacrament had become a spectacle.
The Theological Distortions
The medieval Mass was theologically compromised at several points. The doctrine of transubstantiation, formally defined at the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) and elaborated by Thomas Aquinas, attempted to safeguard the real presence but did so by importing Aristotelian metaphysics into the sacramental theology of the church.¹¹ The substance of the bread, on this view, was changed into the substance of the body of Christ, while the “accidents” (the visible properties) of bread remained. This produced a series of pastoral and theological problems: the doctrine implied that the consecrated host could be reserved, displayed, and adored as Christ Himself; it underwrote the practice of Eucharistic processions and the festival of Corpus Christi; and it tended to detach the sacramental presence from its sacramental use (eating and drinking).
More serious was the doctrine of the Mass as propitiatory sacrifice. By Luther’s day, the Mass was understood by many theologians to be a sacrifice that the priest offered to God on behalf of the living and the dead. This understanding had the effect of supplementing Calvary — as though the once-for-all sacrifice of Christ on the cross required ongoing supplementation through priestly action. Luther’s outrage at this doctrine was not merely polemical. He understood, correctly, that to make the Mass a propitiatory sacrifice was to undermine the sufficiency of Christ’s atonement and thus the very foundation of the gospel. The Lutheran Confessions are unsparing on this point: “The Mass in the papacy must be regarded as the greatest and most horrible abomination, because it runs into direct and violent conflict with this fundamental article [of justification by faith]” (Smalcald Articles, II.II.1).¹²
The third great distortion was the loss of the Word. The medieval Mass included the readings of the Epistle and Gospel, but the homily had withered to almost nothing in most parishes. The Mass had become almost entirely a sacramental rite without significant verbal proclamation. Luther’s first and deepest insight in his liturgical reform was that the gospel must be preached — that the Word and the Sacrament belong together, and that to celebrate the Sacrament without preaching the Word is to deprive the people of the very means by which faith is created and sustained.
What the Reformation Inherited and What It Refused
When Luther turned to the reform of the Mass, he did not begin from scratch. He inherited a rite of extraordinary depth, beauty, and antiquity — a rite whose substantial shape went back to the apostolic age and whose constituent texts were saturated with Scripture. He also inherited a rite that had accumulated centuries of theological distortion. The Reformation reform of the Mass would therefore be neither a wholesale rejection nor a wholesale endorsement of the medieval rite. It would be a careful, theologically grounded surgery — removing what was incompatible with the gospel while preserving what was apostolic and catholic.
This is a critical point for understanding Lutheran liturgical theology. The Reformed tradition, following Zwingli and to some extent Calvin, would adopt a “regulative principle” that allowed in worship only what was explicitly commanded in Scripture, treating the medieval rite as fundamentally corrupt and starting over from a minimalist baseline. The Lutheran tradition, by contrast, adopted what might be called a normative principle: the Mass was to be retained in its substantial form, with only those elements removed that were demonstrably contrary to the gospel.¹³ The result was the Formula Missae (1523) and the Deutsche Messe (1526), which we will examine in detail in the next chapter.
¹¹ Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, III, Q. 75, Art. 4. For a critical discussion of the development of transubstantiation, see Gary Macy, The Theologies of the Eucharist in the Early Scholastic Period (Oxford: Clarendon, 1984). ¹² Smalcald Articles, II.II.1, in The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church, ed. Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000), 301. ¹³ See Bryan D. Spinks, Luther’s Liturgical Criteria and His Reform of the Canon of the Mass (Bramcote: Grove, 1982); and Frank C. Senn, Christian Liturgy, 271–331.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.