The Negative Side of Denominations
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
If we are going to be honest about the goods, we have to be equally honest about the harms. They are real, public, and serious.
The first and gravest harm is the public contradiction of Christ’s prayer. Jesus prayed that His followers would be one “so that the world may believe.” When the world looks at the Church and sees Christians claiming to follow the same Lord, some refusing one another’s baptisms, many refusing one another’s altars, and a few refusing even to recognize one another as Christians, the world is given a reason to disbelieve. Christians sometimes try to wave this away by saying that the unity Christ prayed for was only spiritual. However, the very next phrase in His prayer (“so that the world may believe”) speaks of a unity the world can see. We have to take seriously the possibility that our divisions have hindered the mission Christ gave us. It grieves us, and still we cannot pretend to agree where we do not.
In addition, the divisions confuse the seeker. When a person who is hungry for God walks into a town with seven churches on seven corners, all claiming to teach the Bible, he is given a hard problem to solve before he can even begin. Which church is preaching the right Gospel? Which pastor can be trusted? An unbelieving seeker should not have to take a course in comparative theology before he can become a Christian.
The harm is felt most sharply at the Lord’s Table. The Church has, from her earliest days, gathered around the body and blood of Christ as the sign and seal of her unity. To eat together at the Lord’s Supper is to confess together one faith (1 Corinthians 10:16–17). The painful fact is that Christians from different traditions often cannot eat together. The historic practice of confessional Lutherans has been close communion, in which Lutherans do not commune at the altars of churches whose confession of the Sacrament differs from theirs, and do not invite Christians of those churches to commune at their own, so that no one confesses at the altar what he does not in fact believe. Lutheran church bodies today do not all practice this in the same way. Either way, the meal that was given to show our unity has become a visible sign of our division and that is a wound at the center of the Church’s worship.
That wound is felt by ordinary members at a Catholic wedding or a Methodist funeral and it deserves a pastoral word. A baptized relative in another church is your brother or sister in Christ, because Baptism is Christ’s work and not ours (SC IV). Refraining from an altar where you cannot share the confession is itself a confession, not a verdict on anyone’s salvation. Christ’s body and blood are still given “for you” at your own altar. The one Church is not less one because we cannot see her unity (Ap VII–VIII).
Likewise, the divisions waste resources. Two struggling congregations of different churches at opposite ends of the same small town, each with a declining membership and an aging building, cannot join together because they cannot in conscience confess the same things. Mission boards duplicate one another in the same country, and publishers produce the same Sunday School curriculum many times over. Resources that could go to the poor or to the unreached go to maintaining parallel structures.
A church identity can also become a tribal identity, in which the believer’s first loyalty is to his denomination rather than to Christ. He becomes a Lutheran first and a Christian second. Whenever a Christian is more interested in defending his church than in following his Lord, or in scoring points against other Christians than in announcing the Gospel to unbelievers, church identity has become idolatry. Closely related is triumphalism, the conviction that my church has it right and the others have it wrong on every point that matters. Triumphalism is not the same as confessional conviction. A Lutheran can be fully convinced that the Augsburg Confession faithfully sets forth the teaching of Scripture without believing that no Christian outside the Lutheran Church has ever understood anything correctly. Triumphalism is the slide from we confess this to we alone are right and it closes the heart against listening and learning.
Lastly, the historic confessions can become mere brands, labels people wear without knowing what is in them. A person can say “I am a Lutheran” without ever having read the Small Catechism, or “I am a Baptist” without having thought about what believer’s baptism is meant to confess. Churches that began as faithful confessional bodies can also drift away from what they once confessed. The confessional documents stay on the shelf while the actual teaching of the church moves somewhere else and the people in the pews are often the last to know.
These harms are the reason to tell the truth about the Church, not to despair of her. The cost of division is borne by the world that watches us divided, by the seeker who cannot find us, by the believer who cannot commune with his brother across the street, and by the witness of the Gospel itself. To love the Church is to grieve over what we have made of her and to rejoice in what Christ still makes of her, for “Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, that he might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word” (Ephesians 5:25–26).
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.