Books · Denominationalism

A Lutheran Perspective: Luther, the Confessions, and the Theologians Who Followed

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The Lutheran Church stands in an unusual position in all of this. We are, by any honest reckoning, a denomination, and in America we are organized into many separate Lutheran church bodies, each with its own history and polity. Yet, the tradition began with a man who never wanted his name attached to a church.

Luther and the Name “Lutheran”

The name Lutheran was first used by Luther’s opponents (Johann Eck among them) as a label for his followers. Luther objected to it. In December 1521, while he was hidden at the Wartburg, he wrote A Sincere Admonition by Martin Luther to All Christians to Guard Against Insurrection and Rebellion, published early in 1522. In it he wrote: “I ask that men make no reference to my name; let them call themselves Christians, not Lutherans. What is Luther? After all, the teaching is not mine. Neither was I crucified for anyone… How then should I—poor stinking maggot-fodder that I am—come to have men call the children of Christ by my wretched name?” (LW 45:70–71).

Luther’s point was not false modesty. The Church belongs to Christ alone and a human name attached to her can obscure that. He was not rejecting the teaching itself, and in another writing of 1522 (Receiving Both Kinds in the Sacrament) he allowed that a person who holds his teaching to be the Gospel should not disown him. The early Lutherans preferred to call themselves evangelisch (“evangelical,” those of the Gospel), because they did not want to be a new church. They wanted to be the catholic Church renewed around the pure Gospel and the rightly administered Sacraments. The name Lutheran stuck because everyone else was already using it.

Augsburg Confession Article VII

When the Lutherans had to write down what they confessed about the Church, they produced the most important single paragraph for thinking about denominationalism. Article VII of the Augsburg Confession (1530) reads, in the translation of the German text found in Tappert’s edition of the Book of Concord:

It is also taught among us that one holy Christian church will be and remain forever. This is the assembly of all believers among whom the Gospel is preached in its purity and the holy sacraments are administered according to the Gospel. For it is sufficient for the true unity of the Christian church that the Gospel be preached in conformity with a pure understanding of it and that the sacraments be administered in accordance with the divine Word. It is not necessary for the true unity of the Christian church that ceremonies, instituted by men, should be observed uniformly in all places.

Several things are claimed here at once. The Church is one and will remain forever. She is defined not by her organization but by the pure preaching of the Gospel and the right administration of the Sacraments. For the true unity of the Church it is sufficient (Latin satis est) to agree on the Gospel and the Sacraments, and uniformity of ceremony is not required.

It is important not to misread sufficient. Article VII is not naming a small doctrinal minimum on which Christians can agree while setting everything else aside. The Formula of Concord explains that churches are not to condemn one another over differences in ceremonies as long as they agree “in doctrine and all its articles” and in the right use of the Sacraments (FC SD X, 31). The Gospel and the Sacraments are not two items on a short list. They are the whole teaching of the Church in its center.

This principle cuts in two directions at once. It cuts against dividing over secondary matters. Two congregations should not split over the color of the altar cloths, the order of the hymns, or the details of synod governance. It also cuts in favor of separation over primary matters. If a church teaches that we are justified by our own works and not by the merits of Christ received through faith, or does not administer the Sacraments according to Christ’s institution, then Lutherans cannot in conscience commune with it or call its teaching pure. Wherever the Gospel and Baptism remain, even amid error, the Holy Spirit is still gathering believers there. That is why confessional Lutherans have not communed at Rome’s altar even while agreeing with Rome about Baptism and the true presence of Christ’s body and blood: the sacrifice of the Mass (SA II, 2; Ap XXIV), communion in one kind (AC XXII), and the doctrine of justification (AC IV) stand between us. Confessional Lutheran practice has historically declined intercommunion with churches of a different confession for the same reason. Where the confession at the altar is different, the communion at the altar is different, until the confession is the same.

This is where the two companion papers meet. The differences between churches over Baptism and the Lord’s Supper are not matters of taste, because they touch what God gives us. “Just Jesus”: The Confession Behind the Claim takes up that point at length.

The Church Hidden and the Church Visible

Building on Article VII, the Lutheran Confessions distinguish between the Church properly speaking (the assembly of true believers, hidden because only God sees faith, but known by the marks of Word and Sacrament) and the Church broadly speaking (the outward assembly in which true believers and hypocrites are mixed together) (AC VIII; Ap VII–VIII). C. F. W. Walther, the first president of the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, wrote at length on this in The Voice of Our Church on the Question of Church and Ministry (Kirche und Amt). He taught that God gathers His elect even in churches where the Word and Sacraments remain only in their essential parts, and so the true Church crosses the lines of the visible bodies (Church, Thesis VII). However, Walther also taught that Christians are bound to avoid fellowship with churches that teach false doctrine (Church, Thesis VIII), and he wrote The Evangelical Lutheran Church the True Visible Church of God on Earth (1866). He distinguished between orthodox churches, which teach the Word purely, and heterodox churches, which mix it with error. Both halves of Walther belong together. A confessional Lutheran is not required to say that every Roman Catholic, Baptist, Pentecostal, and Methodist is outside the Church of Christ, because God’s Word does not return to Him empty (Isaiah 55:11). He is required to say that where the Word is mixed with error, faithfulness requires correction and not fellowship.

Luther’s Marks of the Church

In On the Councils and the Church (1539) Luther described seven marks by which the holy Christian people can be recognized: 1) the holy Word of God, 2) Baptism, 3) the Sacrament of the Altar, 4) the Office of the Keys (the authority to forgive and retain sins), 5) the called and ordained ministry, 6) prayer, public praise, and thanksgiving to God, and 7) the holy cross, that is, suffering for Christ’s sake (LW 41:148–166). These marks are not a checklist for disqualifying other Christians but a description of what the Church always looks like when she is being herself. Where these things are, there she is.

Pieper, Sasse, and Bonhoeffer

Francis Pieper gave this teaching its most systematic American form in his Christian Dogmatics in the early twentieth century. For Pieper the Church is the whole number of those who believe in Christ. She is invisible with respect to her members, who are known only to God, and visible with respect to the means of grace, which can be seen and heard. Pieper refused two opposite errors. He would not say that the Lutheran church body is the only Church and he would not say that all churches are equally true. The Lutheran confession, he taught, is a true and faithful exposition of Scripture, which is why Lutherans subscribe it, while the Church of true believers is found wherever the Gospel and Sacraments are present.

Hermann Sasse wrestled with these questions publicly in the twentieth century, first in Germany and later in Australia. His book Here We Stand (German Was heißt lutherisch?, 1934; translated by Theodore Tappert, 1938) is a sustained defense of the Lutheran confession against liberal Protestantism and against unions of Lutheran and Reformed churches (such as the Prussian Union) that set aside real differences over the Sacrament. Sasse was no stranger to the ecumenical movement; he took part in the Faith and Order conference at Lausanne in 1927. He argued that the most honest service Lutherans could give to the wider Church was to keep confessing what they confessed, even when that kept them separate. His conviction could be summed up as better an honest division than a dishonest union.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer belonged to the Prussian Union church and later to the Confessing Church, not to a confessional Lutheran body, but his Life Together makes a point that confessional Lutherans share. Christian community is a gift God has already given in Christ and not an ideal we construct. We do not create fellowship; we receive it through the means God has appointed.

Adiaphora

Underneath all of this runs the Lutheran teaching on adiaphora, things God neither commands nor forbids. The Formula of Concord, Article X, teaches that in such matters congregations and church bodies are free to follow different customs without breaking the unity of the Church (FC Ep X, 4; SD X, 9). The vestments the pastor wears, the order of the hymns, and the language of the liturgy are examples. However, the Formula adds a crucial qualification. When such things are demanded as if they were necessary, or imposed in a way that would compromise the Gospel, they are no longer free and must be resisted (FC Ep X, 6; SD X, 10, 15). Later Lutherans summed this up in the Latin saying in casu confessionis nihil est adiaphoron (“in a situation calling for confession, nothing is indifferent”). On most matters, freedom. On matters that touch the Gospel, no compromise.

The Ecumenical Movement

The twentieth century saw organized efforts to overcome the divisions among churches (the World Council of Churches, the Lutheran World Federation, and dialogues between Lutherans and Roman Catholics, Reformed, and Anglicans). The best-known result is the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, signed by the Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church at Augsburg on October 31, 1999. The World Methodist Council affirmed it in 2006, the Anglican Communion in 2016, and the World Communion of Reformed Churches in 2017. Some Lutheran bodies have gone further into full communion with other churches. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, for example, is in full communion with the Episcopal Church, several Reformed churches, and the United Methodist Church, and in Europe the Porvoo Communion joins Nordic and Baltic Lutherans with the Anglicans of Britain and Ireland.

Lutherans have been divided in how they receive these efforts. Many welcome them as a means of healing real wounds. Others, including the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod and the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod, have stood apart, arguing that real doctrinal differences cannot be covered by carefully worded statements that each side reads in its own way. The desire behind the ecumenical movement is Christ’s own desire, and no Christian should be indifferent to it. However, the Lutheran Confessions have already named the standard by which any union must be measured. It is Article VII: agreement in the Gospel and the Sacraments, in doctrine and all its articles. A union reached by setting that agreement aside is not the unity Christ prayed for. That leaves Lutherans in an uncomfortable place, confessing that the Church is one while being unable to claim that unity by organization where the confession is not shared. The discomfort is the right response of an honest Christian to the divisions of Christ’s Body.

Lutherans Divided Among Themselves

It must be said, painfully, that the Lutheran Church has not kept a single visible form either. We are divided into many Lutheran church bodies, sometimes over how to confess what we agree to confess, sometimes over how to relate to other churches, and sometimes over the authority of Scripture, the ordination of women, or pastoral practice. The same forces that produced denominationalism in the wider Church have produced it within Lutheranism. That should keep any confessional Lutheran humble.

The Lutheran perspective, then, is neither all churches are basically the same nor only Lutherans are Christians. The Church is one and is found wherever the Gospel is preached and the Sacraments are given, across the lines of every visible body. The Lutheran confession is a true and faithful exposition of what Scripture teaches, which is why we subscribe it. We hold that conviction without apology and without triumphalism, because we ourselves stand under the judgment of the Word we confess and the Word does its work in places we have never been.

Topics
The Lutheran ConfessionsOther Churches and TraditionsLaw and GospelThe Lord's Supper
Scripture
Isaiah 55:11
Confessions
SD XSA IIAp XXIVAC XXIIAC IVAC VIIIAp VIIEp XAC VII

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.