Studies · Catechism Corner

How Often Should I Come?

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The Reformer Luther, in the years immediately after the Reformation had freed the German people from the Roman canon law’s requirement that every baptized Christian commune at least once a year, noticed something that troubled him deeply. The German people, freed from the obligation, had begun to stay away from the Sacrament. The pews were full on Sunday morning, but the rail was empty at communion. The Reformer’s Large Catechism, in its long fifth part, is in many places a sustained pastoral argument against this drift — the drift of the freed Lutheran Christian who, having been told that the Sacrament is not a work he must perform, has settled into the comfortable conclusion that the Sacrament is therefore something he need not bother with. I would have no one forced to come, Luther says in characteristic Lutheran fashion. But I do say that whoever does not seek or desire the Sacrament at least four times a year despises it and is no Christian. Four times. In a year. That is the Reformer’s floor, not his ceiling. The floor is quarterly. The ceiling, in Luther’s reading, is every Lord’s Day.

We come, in this August, to Luther’s last question in the catechism on the Sacrament of the Altar — How often should the Christian come? — and we come also to the end of a long road. Thirty-eight months ago, in June of 2026, I began a small column in this newsletter on the Lord’s Prayer, with no real plan beyond the eleven months it would take to walk through that prayer one phrase at a time. The road kept opening up. The Lord’s Prayer led to a three-month visit to the First Table of the Ten Commandments. The First Table led to twelve months in the Apostles’ Creed. The Creed led, last September, to the three sacramental chief parts. And the road comes to its present end at the Lutheran rail in this August’s article. We have walked, between us, the whole of Luther’s Small Catechism — the six chief parts the Reformer organized in 1529, with the Office of the Keys added in by his followers. The Ten Commandments, the Apostles’ Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, Holy Baptism, the Office of the Keys and Confession, and the Sacrament of the Altar. The small green-bound book on the shelf above my desk has, for thirty-eight months, kept us company. It has not been used up. It will not be, in the years that remain to any pastor or any reader. But we have, between us, opened it.

Begin with the question. How often should I come to the Sacrament? The Lutheran tradition has, since Luther himself, given two answers to that question — one moral and one evangelical — and the two answers, taken together, are the proper Lutheran answer. The moral answer is the answer to the question what is the minimum?, and the Lutheran answer to that question is, as we have just seen, the Reformer’s floor of four times a year. Less than that, in Luther’s reading, is despising the gift, and the baptized Christian who has been despising the gift has been, by the same gift, despising the Lord who has given it. The evangelical answer is the answer to the question what is fitting?, and the Lutheran answer to that question is as often as the Sacrament is offered, and the heart hungers, and the Lord’s table is set. Luther himself in the Large Catechism presses the evangelical answer with more force than the moral. We are to seek the Sacrament, he says, like the hungry seek bread. The Christian who is hungry of soul does not, in the Reformer’s image, ration himself to four bowls a year. The hungry man eats when the food is given.

The argument the Reformer makes for frequent reception in the Large Catechism leans on three small Lutheran observations the modern Christian still needs. The first is that the body of the Christian is in need of food, daily and weekly, because the Christian is still in the body of this death. The Old Adam of the Baptism articles, whom the Christian drowns by daily contrition, keeps climbing out of the water. The new man, whom the same Baptism raised, needs feeding. The Christian who never comes to the Sacrament is the Christian who has decided to fight the old Adam without feeding the new man, and the fight, in Luther’s reading, will go badly. The Sacrament is the most concentrated form in which the Lord has given the gospel for the feeding of His own. To stay away from the rail is to choose to fight on an empty stomach.

The second is that the Christian is not, in his own person, a sufficient defense against the devil. The Sacrament is, in the Reformer’s Large Catechism image, armor. The Christian who has the body and blood of his Lord in his mouth is the Christian who is most fortified against the assaults of the world, the flesh, and the devil. The devil does not run from a Christian on his own strength, Luther warns; the devil runs from a Christian who is carrying the Lord with him. The Sacrament is the Lord placed inside the Christian, week by week, against everything that would pull the Christian away. To skip the Sacrament for months at a time is to fight the devil without the Lord’s company.

The third — and this is the one I find pastorally most pointed — is that the Christian who waits to come until he feels worthy will never come. The Reformer is at his most blunt here. If you wait until you feel free of sin, or strong in faith, or warm in piety, or fit for the company of the saints, Luther says, you will never come at all. The Sacrament is for the sinner who feels the sin. The Sacrament is for the doubter who needs the faith strengthened. The Sacrament is for the cold soul who needs the warm gospel. The Sacrament is for the unfit who need to be fitted. The man who feels nothing on the morning of communion is the man for whom the Sacrament was given. The Lord did not institute the Sacrament for Christians who already had all the spiritual fire they needed. He instituted it for the Christians He saw lying cold in the dust of His upper room. Come, the Reformer says, come precisely when you do not feel like coming. Come because the Word has invited you. Come because the body and blood are there. Come because the for you has your name on it. The feeling will follow the food, not precede it.

In other words, the Lutheran answer to how often is, in the deepest reading, that the Sacrament is the daily bread of the Christian’s life on this side of the grave. We have not been given manna in the wilderness to be hoarded like the Israelites who, in disobedience, tried to keep more than the day’s portion (Exodus 16:19–20). We have been given bread the body’s appetite was made for, week by week, at the same rail, in the same liturgy, in the same parish. The early Church understood this. The book of Acts records, of the very first Christian community in Jerusalem, that they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers (Acts 2:42, ESV). The breaking of bread — the early Christian shorthand for the Sacrament — was part of the daily, devoted rhythm of the Christian life. It was not an occasional festival. It was normal Christian food.

A small word, then, about the road we have walked. Between June of 2026 and August of 2029 we have, in this column, taken up the six chief parts of Luther’s Small Catechism and the Brief Exhortation to Confession that runs as a kind of seventh. We took the Lord’s Prayer one phrase at a time. We took a three-month run through the First Table of the Ten Commandments. We took the Apostles’ Creed one clause at a time. We took Holy Baptism in its institution, its gifts, its application to infants, and its daily renewal. We took the Office of the Keys, private confession, and daily contrition. And we have taken, in the last five articles, the Sacrament of the Altar in its institution, its real presence, its benefit, its worthy reception, and now its frequent practice. Thirty-eight months. Five chief parts plus the Decalogue’s First Table. Some sixty thousand words of catechetical conversation between this small column and you. I am not sure what I have, in those thirty-eight months, done for the catechism. I am sure what the catechism has done for me. The Reformer was patient with me. I hope the Reformer has been patient with us all.

The catechism still has, in fairness, a great deal of room left in it. The Second Table of the Ten Commandments — Commandments Four through Ten and the Conclusion of the Decalogue — is the longest single section of Luther’s Large Catechism, and we have not yet touched it. The Reformer is at his pastoral richest in his exposition of the Fourth Commandment on family, the Fifth on the neighbor, the Sixth on marriage, the Seventh on labor and goods, the Eighth on speech, and the Ninth and Tenth on the longings of the heart. If the Lord wills, and if you will have me in this column for another year, we will take it up beginning in September. Eight more small windows. Eight more months. The book on the shelf is, as the Reformer would say, in no particular hurry to close. Neither am I.

For now, the close of the year and the close of the long catechism walk we have been on. The Reformer’s last word in the Large Catechism on the Sacrament — and the word I will leave you with — is the same word he left his own students with at the close of every catechism sermon he preached. Take, eat. Take, drink. The body of Christ, given for you. The blood of Christ, shed for you. Forgiveness, life, and salvation. The Word does the deed. Baptizatus sum, the Reformer wrote on his desk, and for you, the Reformer heard at every rail, and Amen, the Reformer prayed at the end of every catechism. Three small words that have, in five hundred years of Lutheran life, carried more than their weight in glory.

May the Sacrament that the Lord instituted on the night He was betrayed, that He has given to His Church to be received as long as the Church remains in the world, that He has attached His own body and blood to as a gracious medicine for the daily Christian wound — may that Sacrament be, for every reader of this column, the food of the long Christian journey between the font and the grave. And may the Christ who is the host at the rail be, for every one of us, the Christ who waits for us, in the world to come, at the table of which the rail is only the foretaste.

Amen.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
The Lord's SupperBaptismThe Ten Commandments
Scripture
Exodus 16:19–20Acts 2:42
Confessions
SCLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.