The Real Presence
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
In the early autumn of 1529, in a castle high above the river Lahn in the German town of Marburg, the Reformer Luther sat across a table from another reformer — Huldrych Zwingli of Zurich, who had brought the Reformation to the Swiss cantons — and the two men spent four days arguing over a single small clause of the Words of Institution. The Lord had said, at the Maundy Thursday institution of last month’s article, this is my body. The Reformer Luther held that the small Greek verb is, ἐστιν (estin), meant precisely what it said. The bread the Lord held up at the upper-room table was — truly, bodily, substantially — the same body He would give on the cross the next afternoon. Zwingli held that the verb meant signifies — that the bread symbolized the body, the way a flag symbolizes a country, and that the eating of the bread was a memorial of what had happened on the cross, not a receiving of what was on the cross. Luther, on the fourth day of the colloquy, wrote the four words of the Lord’s institution in chalk on the velvet covering of the table — hoc est corpus meum, “this is my body” — and pointed at them. He would not move from those four words. He could not, in good Lutheran conscience, move from them. The Word does the deed. And five hundred years on, the Lutheran Church still does not move.
We come, in May, to the heart of the Lutheran doctrine of the Sacrament of the Altar — the doctrine of the Real Presence. The Lutheran term is straightforward and the Lutheran insistence is unwavering. The body and blood of Christ are really, truly, bodily present in, with, and under the bread and the wine of the Sacrament. In the bread. With the bread. Under the bread. The little Lutheran preposition triplet — in, with, and under — is not in itself in the New Testament; it is the Lutheran tradition’s attempt to say, with all the precision the doctrine requires, what the Lord’s own words at the institution already said in simpler form. This is my body. The body is there. This is my blood. The blood is there. The Lutheran Reformation took the Lord’s plain words at their plain meaning, and the Lutheran Reformation has been doing so ever since.
Begin with the words themselves. The Greek of the Lord’s institution, in all four New Testament accounts, is τοῦτό ἐστιν τὸ σῶμά μου (touto estin to sōma mou) — this is my body. The verb estin is the ordinary third-person singular form of the Greek verb to be. It is the verb a Greek child would use to say this is bread or that is a horse or Athens is in Greece. There is nothing in the verb itself that requires us to read it as a metaphor. The Reformed and Zwinglian reading — that is must mean signifies in this one place in the New Testament, even though it means nothing of the kind in any other place — runs against the grain of the Greek and against the grain of the Hebrew imagination behind it. This is my body means this is my body. Luther was not, at Marburg, being stubborn. Luther was reading the Lord’s words the way the Lord said them.
The Christian Church for fifteen hundred years before Luther had read them the same way. The early Church Fathers — Ignatius of Antioch in the second century, Justin Martyr in the same century, Irenaeus of Lyon, Cyril of Jerusalem, John Chrysostom — speak of the bread and wine of the Sacrament as truly the body and blood of Christ in language that, on any honest reading, is the language of the Real Presence. Ignatius, writing to the church at Smyrna around the year 110 — within living memory of the apostle John himself — denounces those who abstain from the Eucharist because they do not confess that the Eucharist is the flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ. The flesh of our Savior. That is not symbolic language. The unbroken witness of the Christian Church, for the entire patristic period and through the whole of the Western and Eastern medieval traditions, is that the Lord’s Supper is what the Lord said it is. The Lutheran Reformation, in this respect, was not inventing a doctrine of the Real Presence; the Lutheran Reformation was keeping a doctrine the Christian Church had held without serious dispute for fifteen centuries.
The apostle Paul confirms it in the same letter from which we drew last month’s institution account. The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? (1 Corinthians 10:16, ESV). The Greek for participation is κοινωνία (koinōnia) — fellowship, sharing, communion. The cup is the communion of the blood. The bread is the communion of the body. The word koinōnia, in the apostle’s usage, does not mean a symbolic association. It means an actual sharing in. The Christian who eats the bread actually shares in the body. The Christian who drinks the cup actually shares in the blood. The apostle’s argument in 1 Corinthians 10, in its surrounding context, is that the Christian cannot also eat at the tables of pagan idols because the Christian cannot share in two altars at once. The argument only works if the sharing at the Christian altar is real. If the bread and wine were mere symbols, no argument from idolatry would apply.
And the apostle Paul makes the same point negatively in the same letter, in the very passage that gives us our July article. Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord (1 Corinthians 11:27). Guilty of the body and blood. No Christian could be guilty of a mere symbol. The apostle’s warning only has force if the body and blood are actually present in the bread and the wine — and if a Christian, by eating and drinking in an unworthy manner, can actually sin against them. The presence is real because the warning is real. The Reformed reading, which takes the bread as a symbol and the eating as a memorial, cannot make sense of the apostle’s warning without re-translating it into something the apostle did not say.
The Lutheran Formula of Concord, in its seventh article, takes up this doctrine in great detail. The true and almighty words of Jesus Christ which He spoke at the first institution were not only effectual in the first Supper, but they still retain their validity and efficacious power, the Formula says, so that in all places where the Supper of Christ is celebrated according to the institution of Christ, the body and blood of Christ are truly present, distributed, and received. Three claims in a row. Present. Distributed. Received. The Reformer’s followers, in writing the Formula in 1577, made what Luther had said at Marburg into the permanent confession of the Lutheran Church. The body and blood are present by the power of Christ’s own words; they are distributed in the bread and the wine the pastor gives at the rail; they are received, in the words of the same article, by all who eat and drink, whether they are worthy or unworthy. The body and blood, in the Lutheran reading, are objectively there, given, in the bread and the wine — there for the faithful Christian to receive in faith, and there for the unfaithful Christian to receive to his own judgment. The presence does not depend on the faith of the recipient. The presence depends on the Word of the Lord.
Now: a small word about what the Lutheran doctrine of the Real Presence is not. It is not, in the Lutheran reading, the Roman Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation. Transubstantiation, as the Roman Church formally defined it at the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 and again at Trent, teaches that the substance of the bread and wine cease to exist at the consecration, and that only the body and blood remain, under the outward appearances of the bread and wine. The Lutheran Reformation rejects this — gently but firmly. The Lord at the upper-room table said this is my body, holding up the bread; He did not say this used to be bread but is no longer. The bread remains bread. The wine remains wine. In the bread and with the bread and under the bread is the body of the Lord; both are present in the Sacrament at the same time. The Lutheran Confessions reject transubstantiation as a philosophical overreach — an attempt to explain how the body is present in the bread by means of the medieval Aristotelian categories of substance and accident. The Lord did not, at the supper, explain how. The Lord simply said it was so. The Lutheran Church, in this respect, is content to confess the what without attempting the how. The body is there. The bread is there. The Word makes the union. The Lord asked us to believe it, not to explain it.
In other words, the Real Presence is the Christian Church’s confession that the bread and wine of the Sacrament are, by the Lord’s own Word, what the Lord said they are. We do not, in the Lutheran reading, figure out the Sacrament. We receive it. The doctrine is, in its essence, the doctrine that the Lord meant what He said. This is my body. This is the new covenant in my blood. The body is in the bread because the Word has put it there. The blood is in the cup because the Word has put it there. And the Christian who comes to the rail on a Sunday morning to eat the bread and drink the cup is, in the strongest sense the apostle Paul could find words for, participating in the body and blood of Christ Himself. That, in five hundred years of Lutheran preaching and confessing, is what the Lutheran has held to without flinching, and what the Lutheran will hold to as long as the Lord tarries. Hoc est corpus meum. The Word does the deed.
We will take up next month the benefit of this Sacrament — what gifts the Lord has attached to His own body and blood, given in the bread and the wine. The Reformer’s Small Catechism answers the question in three small words — forgiveness, life, salvation — and the Large Catechism opens those three words into the richest pastoral passage in the entire Lutheran Reformation on the Christian’s daily food. We will turn to that food in June. For now, on the next Sunday in which our liturgy comes to the rail, hear the words of distribution as the Lutheran Church has been hearing them since the Reformation. The body of Christ, given for you. The blood of Christ, shed for you. The for you is the gospel. The body and blood are the gift. The Word does the deed.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.