You Shall Have No Other Gods
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
A year ago this month we began walking through Luther’s Small Catechism together — one phrase a month, all of them taken from the Lord’s Prayer. We took eleven small windows into the prayer most of us have known since childhood, from the Our Father of last July to the Amen of last May. I said then that the catechism still had five chief parts left to give us, and that I was in no particular hurry. So here is what I propose for the year ahead. Beginning in September, and running through next August, we will take up the Apostles’ Creed, which is the second of Luther’s chief parts and the confession the baptized have spoken at the font, around the bedside, and at the open grave for almost as long as there has been a Christian Church. Between now and then — in June, July, and August — I want to spend three small months in the chief part that precedes the Creed in Luther’s ordering: the Ten Commandments, and specifically the first three of them, which the Lutheran tradition calls the First Table. Three commandments that have to do not with our neighbor but with God Himself. They are the doorstep on which the Creed is built. We will not get to the Creed in good order unless we cross the doorstep first.
We begin where Luther begins, at the head of the catechism: You shall have no other gods (Exodus 20:3, ESV). Six small words in our English Bibles. In the Hebrew it is even shorter — לֹא יִהְיֶה־לְךָ אֱלֹהִים אֲחֵרִים עַל־פָּנָי (lo yihyeh-lekha elohim acherim al-panay), seven syllables, the last of them a curious idiom that reads literally “upon my face.” You shall have no other gods upon my face. The picture is of the LORD turning His face toward Israel and finding nothing in front of Him — no rival, no second, no other claim of allegiance — but Himself and His people. The First Commandment, before it asks anything else of us, asks for the field cleared.
Luther’s Small Catechism puts to itself, after this commandment as after every commandment, his characteristic four-word question. Was ist das? “What does this mean?” The answer is one of the shortest sentences he ever wrote and one of the most demanding: “We should fear, love, and trust in God above all things.” Three verbs. Fear, love, trust. The three things human beings cannot help giving to something — we will fear something, we will love something, we will trust something — and the First Commandment names the One to whom all three are owed. Notice the order. Fear before love, because reverence comes before affection. Love before trust, because affection is what makes the trust whole. Trust last, because trust is the heart of the whole thing — what Luther in the Large Catechism will call the cleaving of the heart. “That upon which you set your heart and put your trust,” he writes, “is properly your god.”
In other words, the First Commandment is not principally a commandment about worship in the formal sense. Luther knew his Saxon parishioners; he did not need to tell them to stop sacrificing to Wotan in the back garden. He needed to tell them — and us — something much harder to hear. He needed to tell them that the human heart is a maker of gods. Anything we fear above God, we have made into a god. Anything we love above God, we have made into a god. Anything we trust above God, we have made into a god. The Reformer’s pastoral genius in the Large Catechism is to walk the reader through the long catalogue of these homemade gods — money first (“the most common idol on earth”), then reputation, then favor with the powerful, then ability, then wisdom, then health, then even the family a man loves more than the God who gave him the family. None of those things is, in itself, a bad thing. Money buys bread. Reputation matters. Children are a gift. The First Commandment is not against the gift; the First Commandment is against the moment at which the gift becomes the giver, the creature becomes the Creator, and the heart sets its weight upon what cannot bear the weight.
This is why the First Commandment stands first. Every other commandment in the Decalogue is, in some sense, a working out of this one. If I murder, it is because I have feared, loved, or trusted something — my anger, my honor, my safety — above God. If I steal, it is because I have trusted my pocket above the God who feeds the sparrows. If I lie, it is because I have feared the consequences of the truth more than I have feared the God who is Himself the truth. The Large Catechism puts the point plainly: where the heart is rightly fixed upon God, the keeping of the other commandments follows in its train; where the heart is not, no amount of outward obedience can hold the rest of the Decalogue together. The First Commandment is the load-bearing wall.
Now, I would be a poor pastor if I left you under this commandment alone. The First Commandment, faithfully heard, will accuse every one of us. There is no one in this congregation, and no one in mine, and no one in the pulpit, who has kept it cleanly. We have all of us, at some point, set our hearts on the gift instead of the Giver. That is what the law is for — to show us our sin and the wrath of God against it, so that we may run, not from God, but to Him. The First Commandment, you might say, is the doorway by which the gospel enters. When the law has done its proper work — when the heart has seen its own little workshop of homemade gods and has been broken by the seeing — then the gospel can say what only the gospel can say: that the true God, the One on whose face we have set our other gods, has not turned away from us. He has set His own face toward us in the face of Jesus Christ (2 Corinthians 4:6). The God who says You shall have no other gods is the same God who, on a Friday afternoon outside Jerusalem, refused to leave us to our other gods. Christ has cleared the field at His own cost. The First Commandment, in Him, is no longer principally a demand. It is a promise. You shall have no other gods — because I am yours, and you are Mine.
A small invitation, then, for the month ahead. When you come to church this Sunday and we confess our sins together, listen to what you have actually confessed. Not just the outward sins of the week past — those, too — but the deeper one beneath them. The heart that set itself on something other than God. The heart that feared the cancer scan more than it feared God, or loved the grandchild more than it loved God, or trusted the savings account more than it trusted God. And when the absolution comes — In the stead and by the command of my Lord Jesus Christ, I forgive you all your sins — hear it as an answer to that sin first. Hear it against the First Commandment. They were spoken there first.
We will take up the Second Commandment next month — the Name of God, and what it is to take it in vain. For now, may the God who has set His face toward you in Christ also set your heart, your love, and your trust upon Himself, above all things.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.