Studies · Catechism Corner

Thy Will Be Done on Earth as It Is in Heaven

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

There is no harder line in this prayer to pray honestly than the one we are looking at this month. I have stood at enough hospital bedsides, and sat at enough kitchen tables across from a parishioner who has just lost a husband, to know that Thy will be done is not a line we sail through without flinching. We say it. We mean it. But there is a long, quiet ache between the saying and the meaning, and any pastor who tells you otherwise is not telling you the truth.

Christ Himself prayed this petition in the place where it hurt to pray. In the Garden of Gethsemane, on the night He was betrayed, He fell on His face and prayed: “My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as you will” (Matthew 26:39, ESV). The Greek of the second clause is a near-quotation of the third petition of the Lord’s Prayer. The same Lord who taught us to pray Thy will be done prayed it Himself, in blood and sweat, on the night before His crucifixion. We are not asked to pray anything He has not prayed. We are not asked to mean anything He has not meant.

What, then, does the petition actually ask? Luther in the Small Catechism puts it like this: “The good and gracious will of God is done indeed without our prayer; but we pray in this petition that it may be done among us also. How is this done? When God breaks and hinders every evil counsel and will which would not let us hallow God’s name nor let His kingdom come, such as the will of the devil, the world, and our own flesh; but strengthens and keeps us steadfast in His Word and faith unto our end. This is His gracious and good will.” Three things to notice in that answer, and I will take them in order, because Luther himself takes them in order.

The first thing to notice is that God’s will is going to be done whether we pray for it or not. This is the foundation of the petition, and it is also its comfort. The will of God is not waiting on our consent. He is not a tentative Sovereign whose plans for the universe depend on whether His subjects are agreeable. “Whatever the LORD pleases, he does, in heaven and on earth, in the seas and all deeps” (Psalm 135:6). When we pray this petition, we are not voting on what God should do. We are praying that what He is already doing — in His good and gracious will — be done among us. That, again, is where the petition lands. Among us. In this congregation, in this body, in this stubborn heart of mine.

The second thing to notice is the long list of opponents Luther names: the devil, the world, and our own flesh. The phrase is a Reformation commonplace. Behind every prayer the Christian prays, there are three resisting powers. The devil, who would unmake the kingdom altogether. The world, which would crowd it out with louder concerns. The flesh — our own old Adam — which would rather have its own will done than God’s. When Luther asks how the will of God is done among us, he answers in two motions: God breaks and hinders every evil counsel that would oppose His will, and He strengthens and keeps His people in Word and faith. The will of God is therefore done in us by a kind of double action: the enemy is restrained on the outside, and the saint is preserved on the inside. The pastor who has prayed this petition for forty years has seen the double action up close, and so have you.

The third thing is the last clause: “unto our end.” Luther is telling us, plainly, that the will of God for His people includes their being kept faithful until they die. That is the will we are praying to have done. Not merely that we get through this week’s bad news. Not merely that the cancer scan come back clean — though we may certainly ask for that too. The deepest thing the petition asks is that we be held in Christ until the last hour of our life on this earth, and that we cross over still believing. There are easier prayers. There are not many more important ones.

I will be pastoral with you now. The petition that says Thy will be done does not ask you to enjoy the will of God when it cuts against the grain of your desires. Christ did not enjoy Gethsemane. Christ sweat blood. He asked first that the cup pass; only when the answer came back that the cup would not pass did He drink it. That is the order of the prayer. You may ask the Father, with all your heart, that the cup pass; if it passes, give thanks; if it does not pass, drink it as the Son drank His, and pray not as I will, but as you will. The Father has not promised His children a life without cups. He has promised that no cup put into our hands will be a cup He has not first weighed.

“On earth as it is in heaven.” Notice the geography of the petition. In heaven, the will of God is done immediately, joyfully, perfectly, by angels and by the redeemed who have gone before us. On earth, the will of God is done slowly, painfully, partially, by sinners who are also saints. The petition asks that the earthly congregation be brought, by the Father’s grace, a little closer to the heavenly. We will not be perfectly conformed in this life. We will be sanctified, by stages, by the same Spirit who taught us to pray.

Pray this petition this month with both hands open. Bring Him the thing you want most. Bring Him the thing you are most afraid of. Lay them both down at the rail, and say with Christ: not as I will, but as you will. He has prayed it Himself. He will pray it with you.

Next month: Give us this day our daily bread. Luther’s expansion of that single phrase is one of the most surprising lists in the catechism.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
Resurrection and Last ThingsPrayer
Scripture
Matthew 26:39Psalm 135:6
Confessions
SC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.