Studies · The Book of Concord for Ordinary Lutherans

Week 16 — Free Will

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The Book of Concord for Ordinary Lutherans

This week’s reading: Article XVIII of the Augsburg Confession (“Of Free Will”) and Article II of the Formula of Concord (“Of Free Will,” sometimes titled “Of the Powers of the Human Will”). Both are in the Book of Concord. Behind them stands Luther’s great treatise The Bondage of the Will.

“Do we have free will?” It sounds like a yes-or-no question, and most people answer it as one. The Augsburg Confession answers more carefully — yes and no, depending on what you are asking about. And getting that distinction right turns out to be one of the most freeing things in the whole Christian faith. So we have to ask the question more precisely: free will to do what?

The Confession distinguishes two realms. In earthly matters — the things “below us,” within the reach of ordinary reason — the will has real freedom. You can choose whether to go to work or stay in bed, whether to be outwardly honest or to cheat, whom to marry, what to build, how to treat your neighbor. God governs much of the world’s daily life through these genuine human choices, and we are truly responsible for them. So this is no denial of everyday freedom or accountability. But in spiritual matters — the things “above us,” the matter of coming to God, believing in Christ, putting ourselves right with Him — the Confession says the will has no such power. There it is bound.

Why bound? Because of what Scripture says we are by nature, apart from grace. We are not spiritually healthy people who merely need to make a good decision; we are, the Bible says, “dead in the trespasses and sins” (Ephesians 2:1, ESV). “The mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God” (Romans 8:7). “The natural person does not accept the things of the Spirit of God… and he is not able to understand them” (1 Corinthians 2:14). A dead man cannot decide to come alive; a blind man cannot choose to see; an enemy does not, on his own, lay down his arms. Left to our own will in spiritual things, we would never come.

Now you can see the root beneath much of what we have already studied. Why did we confess, back in the Creed, that “I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ”? Why is justification by grace alone? Why do we baptize infants, who can decide nothing? Because the will is bound in spiritual things, and so we contribute nothing whatever to our own salvation — not even the deciding. Luther thought this so important that he called his book on it, The Bondage of the Will, the truest and best thing he ever wrote. For if we could choose God by our own power, then salvation would be, in the end, partly our own work. The bondage of the will is precisely what makes grace truly grace.

So how does anyone ever come to faith? God does it. The Holy Spirit, through the Word, raises the spiritually dead to life and creates faith where there was none — turning enemies into children, the unwilling into the willing. In our conversion we are, the Formula of Concord says, purely on the receiving end. Think of Lazarus in the tomb: he did not help raise himself; Christ called, and the dead man lived. Or hear the prophet’s promise: “I will give you a new heart, and a new spirit I will put within you” (Ezekiel 36:26). We do not manufacture that new heart; we are given it. As Jesus told His disciples, “You did not choose me, but I chose you” (John 15:16).

But here the Formula is careful to guard against a misunderstanding. To say the will is bound is not to say we are lifeless blocks of wood that God shoves around, or puppets with no will of our own. God drags no one kicking into His kingdom. Rather, through the Word, the Spirit creates a new heart that now gladly believes — so the converted person truly does believe, and truly does will, but that willing is itself the Spirit’s gift, not the cause of his rescue. And once converted, the renewed will really does begin to cooperate in the Christian life — we strive, we resist sin, we obey — yet always by the Spirit’s continuing power at work within us. “It is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Philippians 2:13).

Two questions usually press in here. The first: “But I feel as though I chose to believe — I made a decision.” And in a sense you did; you really do believe, with a will that is genuinely your own now. But ask the deeper question: why did the Gospel win you over, when the very same words left someone else cold? Not because you were wiser or better. The answer, every time, is the Holy Spirit, who drew you. The second: “Doesn’t this make us passive — so why bother doing anything?” Not at all. We are free and responsible in earthly things; we are accountable for our resistance to God; and God works through means — through that Word — so we keep hearing it, keep returning to it, and keep bringing others within its reach, rather than folding our hands.

And here is the comfort, which is the whole point. If your coming to God depended finally on your own free decision, then your salvation would rest on the weakest, most changeable thing about you — your will, which fails you a dozen times before breakfast. But it does not rest there. God Himself sought you, raised you, called you, and gave you the faith to believe. He did not wait for you to choose Him; He chose you. So you cannot boast — and you need never despair. From first to last, your salvation is His doing, and that is exactly why it will hold.

Remember

  • “Do we have free will?” Yes and no — free in earthly matters (reason, daily choices, civil good), but bound in spiritual matters (coming to God, faith) apart from the Holy Spirit (AC XVIII).
  • By nature we are spiritually dead, hostile, unable to receive the things of God (Ephesians 2:1; Romans 8:7; 1 Corinthians 2:14) — a dead man cannot decide to live.
  • The bondage of the will is the root of grace alone: we contribute nothing to salvation, not even the decision — which is what makes grace truly grace.
  • Conversion is God’s work alone: the Spirit, through the Word, raises the dead and creates faith (Ezekiel 36:26; John 15:16). We are not coerced blocks — He gives a willing heart (FC II).
  • This is pure comfort: salvation rests not on our fickle will but on God who chose us — so we cannot boast, and we need never despair.

For Discussion

  • “Free will to do what?” How does splitting the question into earthly and spiritual realms change the way you would answer it?
  • We tend to assume faith is the one thing we contribute. Why is it actually good news that even our coming to God is His gift, not our decision?
  • “I feel like I chose to believe.” How do you hold that real experience together with “you did not choose me, but I chose you”?
  • Does the bondage of the will make you passive — or does knowing God works through the Word make you more eager to hear it and share it? Why?
  • Where would your assurance stand if salvation finally depended on the firmness of your own will? How does “He chose you” steady you?

Closing Prayer

Almighty God, by nature we were dead in our sins — blind, unwilling, and unable to come to You on our own. We thank You that You did not wait for us to choose You, but sought us out, raised us by Your Spirit through Your Word, and gave us faith to believe. Keep us from all pride and from all despair, for our salvation rests not on our wavering wills but on Your unchanging grace. Work in us now both to will and to do what pleases You; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Rest this week not on the strength of your own choosing, but on the God who chose you and will not let you go.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
Christian FreedomThe Holy SpiritThe Lutheran Confessions
Scripture
Ephesians 2:1Romans 8:71 Corinthians 2:14Ezekiel 36:26John 15:16Philippians 2:13
Confessions
AC XVIII

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.