Romans — A Lutheran Leader's Guide
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Soli Deo Gloria
Romans is the charter of the Reformation. It is the longest and most carefully argued of Paul’s letters, written to a church he had not yet visited, setting out — more fully than anywhere else in Scripture — the heart of the Christian Gospel: that a sinner is justified before God not by works of the Law but freely, by grace, through faith, on account of Jesus Christ. Here Paul lays the whole human race, Gentile and Jew alike, under the verdict of sin (1:18–3:20), and then, against that black backdrop, unveils “the righteousness of God” given as a gift in Christ (3:21–26). Here is Abraham justified by faith (ch. 4), peace with God (ch. 5), baptism into Christ’s death and resurrection (ch. 6), the anguished cry of the divided self and the freedom of no condemnation (chs. 7–8), the mystery of Israel and election (chs. 9–11), and the renewed life of the justified (chs. 12–16). It was over Romans 1:17 that Luther’s conscience was set free, and from that liberation the Reformation flowed. Luther’s Preface to Romans (Luther’s Works / American Edition, vol. 35) and his early Lectures on Romans (LW 25) are touchstones of the Lutheran reading; Melanchthon’s Loci Communes began life as a commentary on this letter; and the Book of Concord draws its great article on justification (AC IV; Ap IV) straight from these chapters. This guide leans on those sources, on Chemnitz against Trent, and on the Confessions, so that you can teach Romans the way the Reformers taught it: as Law and Gospel, and as the book in which the Gospel comes to its clearest light.
How to use this guide
This is a leader’s guide. It is written for you, the one preparing to teach — pastor, deacon, or lay leader. Nothing here is handed out. The only thing your people need open in front of them is the Bible. The guide is built as eight one-hour sessions that together cover the whole letter:
- The Gospel and the righteousness of God revealed (1:1–17)
- The whole world guilty: Gentile and Jew under sin (1:18–3:20)
- Justified by faith: redemption in Christ; Abraham (3:21–4:25)
- Peace with God; Adam and Christ; dead to sin, alive in baptism (5–6)
- The Law, the divided self, and life in the Spirit; no condemnation (7–8)
- God’s faithfulness, Israel, and election (9–11)
- The renewed life: living sacrifice, love, and the governing authorities (12–13)
- The weak and the strong; the unity of the church; final greetings (14–16)
Each session has five parts in fixed order: a Leader’s preparation note, Opening Questions, Congregational Study (the teaching body), Closing Questions, and a Closing Prayer. Read the whole passage and the preparation note before the hour. Sessions 3 (justification), 4 (Adam/Christ and baptism), and 5 (Romans 7–8) deserve your slowest, most careful pace; the doctrine here is dense, and your people will need it unpacked patiently. ESV is the default translation; other versions are noted where they serve the point.
A Lutheran orientation to Romans
Romans is the book of justification. If you understand Romans, Luther says in effect, you understand the whole of Scripture; for here the Gospel is set out in full. The governing distinction of the letter — and of all Lutheran theology — is Law and Gospel. Paul spends two and a half chapters (1:18–3:20) doing nothing but the Law’s work: stopping every mouth, holding the whole world accountable to God, so that “by works of the law no human being will be justified in his sight” (3:20, ESV). Only when that work is finished does he turn, with the great “But now” of 3:21, to the Gospel: “the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from the law.” To read Romans as a Lutheran is to keep these two words distinct and to let each do its own work — the Law to accuse and slay, the Gospel to absolve and make alive.
Luther’s breakthrough. No book has been more decisive for the Lutheran tradition, because it was over a single phrase in Romans — “the righteousness of God” (Greek dikaiosynē theou) in 1:17 — that Luther’s evangelical breakthrough came. He had been taught to read that phrase as God’s active righteousness, the righteousness by which God justly punishes sinners, and he confessed that he hated the phrase and hated the God it seemed to reveal. Then, meditating day and night, he saw that Paul means a righteousness God gives — a passive, received righteousness by which the merciful God justifies us through faith. In his 1545 preface to his Latin works Luther wrote that when he grasped this, “all at once I felt that I had been born again and entered into paradise itself through open gates,” and that “this passage of Paul” became to him “the very gate of paradise” (LW 34:337). From that liberation the Reformation flowed. When you teach Romans 1:17, you are standing at the spot where the Reformation began.
The material principle of the Reformation. The doctrine Romans teaches — justification by grace through faith, on account of the imputed (alien) righteousness of Christ, apart from works of the Law — is what the Lutheran Confessions call the article on which the church stands or falls. The Augsburg Confession states it in the very terms of Romans 3–4: we “cannot be justified before God by our own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake through faith… This faith God imputes for righteousness in his sight” (AC IV). The Apology’s defense of Article IV is the longest and weightiest section of the whole Book of Concord, and it is, from start to finish, an exposition of Romans. Have AC IV and the main lines of Ap IV in your head before you teach this book.
Christ in Romans. Romans does not narrate the life of Jesus, but it proclaims him on every page: the Son descended from David and declared Son of God by the resurrection (1:3–4); the propitiation, the hilastērion, set forth in his blood (3:25); the second Adam whose one act of righteousness brings life to all (5:12–21); the one into whose death and resurrection we are baptized (ch. 6); the one who is “the end of the law” for righteousness (10:4) and who now intercedes for us at God’s right hand (8:34). The whole letter is the unfolding of what God has done in Christ for the ungodly.
A pastoral word before you begin: Romans will press hard on the conscience. It is meant to. The Law in chapters 1–3 is relentless, and Romans 7 will lay bare the Christian’s own ongoing struggle with sin. Do not rush past the accusation — but never leave your people there. The whole architecture of the letter moves from condemnation to “no condemnation” (8:1), from the wrath revealed (1:18) to the love of God in Christ from which nothing can separate us (8:38–39). Let the Law do its full work, and then let the Gospel have the last word, every time.
Session 1 — The Gospel and the Righteousness of God Revealed (1:1–17)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 1:1–17, and alongside it Habakkuk 2:4 (the verse Paul quotes in 1:17), AC IV, and the opening of Luther’s Preface to Romans (LW 35:365ff). The theological center of gravity for this hour is the theme verse of the whole letter (1:16–17): the Gospel is the power of God for salvation, because in it “the righteousness of God” is revealed and received by faith. You are laying the foundation for everything that follows, so do not rush; better to teach 1:16–17 deeply than to cover more ground. Have clear in your own mind the difference between God’s active righteousness (by which he judges) and the passive, received righteousness Paul means here — the very distinction that set Luther free. This is the hour to tell your people Luther’s own story of the breakthrough; it will frame the whole study.
Opening Questions
- When you hear the word “gospel,” what do you think it means? Is it good advice, or good news — and what is the difference?
- Paul says he is “not ashamed of the gospel” (1:16, ESV). Why might anyone be tempted to be ashamed of it?
- Paul calls the Gospel “the power of God.” Where do people usually look for power to fix what is wrong with them?
- The phrase “the righteousness of God” — does that sound to you like good news or bad news? Hold the question; this hour will answer it.
Congregational Study
The greeting and the Gospel God promised (1:1–7). Paul opens by identifying himself as “a servant of Christ Jesus, called to be an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God” (1:1) — and then, before he says anything about himself, he says what the Gospel is. It is the gospel “which he promised beforehand through his prophets in the holy Scriptures” (1:2): the Gospel is not a new invention but the keeping of the Old Testament’s promise. Its content is a person: God’s Son, “descended from David according to the flesh” and “declared to be the Son of God in power… by his resurrection from the dead” (1:3–4). Teach this carefully: Paul anchors the Gospel in the two natures of Christ — true man (of David’s line) and true God (Son of God) — and in the great fact of the resurrection. The Gospel is news about Jesus Christ before it is anything about us.
Paul’s longing and the theme (1:8–15). Paul has long wanted to visit Rome and preach the Gospel there (1:13–15). He is “under obligation” to Greeks and barbarians, wise and foolish alike (1:14) — note already the universal reach that will shape the whole letter. This brings him to his thesis.
The theme verse of Romans (1:16–17). Slow down and give the rest of the hour to these two verses; they are the seed of the entire letter. “For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith for faith, as it is written, ‘The righteous shall live by faith’” (1:16–17). Walk through each phrase:
- “The power of God for salvation.” The Gospel is not merely information about God’s power; it is God’s power — the means by which God actually saves. This is a first hint of the Lutheran doctrine of the means of grace: God works salvation through the Gospel, proclaimed and applied. The Word is not a description of the cure; it is the medicine.
- “To everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.” The Gospel is for all, and it is received the same way by all — by faith, not by ancestry or achievement. This “to the Jew first and also to the Greek” pairing runs through the whole letter and sets up chapters 9–11.
- “The righteousness of God is revealed.” Here is the phrase that changed Luther’s life. The Greek is dikaiosynē theou (“righteousness of God”). It can mean God’s own attribute of being righteous — and that is how Luther was first taught it, as the righteousness by which God justly condemns sinners. But Paul means something else: a righteousness that comes from God, that God gives and reckons to the sinner, received “from faith for faith.” It is, as Luther came to see, a passive righteousness — not a righteousness we produce and present to God, but one God produces and credits to us in Christ. Tell your people Luther’s own account: he hated this phrase, believing it meant only God’s punishing justice, until he understood it as the gift God grants by faith — and then, in his words, “all at once I felt that I had been born again and entered into paradise itself through open gates,” and “this passage of Paul” became “the very gate of paradise” (LW 34:337). This is the most important thing you will teach all study.
- “The righteous shall live by faith.” Paul quotes Habakkuk 2:4. Faith is the instrument by which the gift is received and by which the justified person lives. Not faith as a work or a virtue we muster, but faith as the empty hand that takes hold of what God offers.
Make the Lutheran connection explicit with AC IV: we “cannot be justified before God by our own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake through faith, when we believe that we are received into favor and that our sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake” (AC IV). Romans 1:17 is the textual headwaters of that confession.
Where traditions differ — What “the righteousness of God” means in 1:17. The Lutheran (and broadly Protestant) reading takes dikaiosynē theou here as primarily a gift — the righteousness God reckons to the believer, received by faith, the very theme Luther’s breakthrough recovered (the so-called genitive of origin: righteousness from God). The Roman Catholic tradition has historically read God’s righteousness more as the righteousness God works in us (an infused, inherent righteousness by which we are made just), so that justification includes a real moral renewal, not only a declared verdict — a difference we will take up fully in Session 3. The New Perspective on Paul (E. P. Sanders, James Dunn, N. T. Wright) reads “the righteousness of God” largely as God’s own covenant faithfulness — his saving fidelity to his promises — and tends to read “works of the law” later in the letter as Jewish boundary markers (circumcision, food laws, Sabbath) rather than as human moral effort in general; on this reading justification is more about who belongs to God’s covenant people than about how a guilty conscience finds a gracious God. Lutherans gladly affirm that God’s covenant faithfulness is in view, but insist — with Luther’s own breakthrough and with Ap IV — that Paul’s central concern is the terrified conscience and the free gift of an alien righteousness received by faith. Teach the views fairly, then hold the Lutheran center: the righteousness of God in 1:17 is, above all, God’s gift to the ungodly.
Close by returning to where the chapter began: this Gospel is “the power of God for salvation.” Your people are not asked to generate their own righteousness; they are asked to receive God’s. That is good news, and it is the news the whole letter will now unfold.
Closing Questions
- Luther was set free when he stopped hearing “the righteousness of God” as something he had to produce and heard it as something God gives. Which way do you instinctively hear it — as demand, or as gift?
- Paul says the Gospel is the power of God, not merely a report about it. Where in your life are you trusting your own power to fix what only the Gospel can?
- “The righteous shall live by faith.” What would it look like, this week, to live by faith in a promise rather than by sight or by feeling?
- Paul is “not ashamed of the gospel.” Where are you tempted to be ashamed of it — and what does it cost the people around you when you are?
Closing Prayer
Almighty God, in the Gospel of your Son you reveal not a righteousness we must achieve but a righteousness you freely give. As you opened the gate of paradise to your servant Luther through this very word, open our hearts to receive your Son by faith. Make us unashamed of the Gospel, which is your power for our salvation; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 2 — The Whole World Guilty: Gentile and Jew Under Sin (1:18–3:20)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 1:18–3:20 in one sitting; it is a single sustained argument and must be felt as one. Read alongside it AC II (original sin) and Psalm 14 / Psalm 53 (which Paul stitches into his catena in 3:10–18). The theological center of gravity is the Law’s accusing work (the second use): God holds the whole human race — pagan Gentile and religious Jew alike — guilty before him, so that every mouth is stopped and no one can be justified by works of the Law. This is the hardest hour to teach in the right spirit: it is relentless Law, and it must remain Law — do not soften it, and do not yet jump to the Gospel. Your job this hour is to let the Law do its full, terrible work, because only the truly condemned can hear the “But now” of 3:21 as good news. Resolve in advance to end the session under the verdict, with your people longing for the next.
Opening Questions
- Paul says God’s wrath is being revealed against human wickedness (1:18). When you hear “the wrath of God,” what comes to mind — and is it a caricature?
- The pagan world “knew God” but “did not honor him… or give thanks” (1:21, ESV). Is the root problem ignorance, or something else?
- In chapter 2 Paul turns on the religious, moral person who judges others. Why is the respectable person in just as much danger as the obvious sinner?
- “None is righteous, no, not one” (3:10). Do you believe that — about everyone, including yourself? What in you resists it?
Congregational Study
This whole section is one argument with one conclusion: all are under sin, so no one can be justified by the Law. Paul builds it in three movements.
First movement — the Gentile world under wrath (1:18–32). Paul begins with the obvious case: the pagan world. The wrath of God (Greek orgē, settled judicial opposition to evil) is revealed against those “who by their unrighteousness suppress the truth” (1:18). His key point: they are without excuse, because God has made himself known in creation (1:19–20) — “his eternal power and divine nature… have been clearly perceived.” The root sin is not ignorance but refusal: “they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him” (1:21). From that root grows idolatry — exchanging the Creator for created things (1:23, 25) — and from idolatry, God “gave them up” (the refrain of 1:24, 26, 28) to dishonorable passions and a debased mind. Teach the sequence: false worship, then disordered desire, then a darkened mind and a society catalogued in the grim list of 1:29–31. The point is not to single out particular sins for special horror but to show the whole structure of human rebellion. And note the sting in the tail (1:32): they not only do these things but “give approval to those who practice them” — sin defended and celebrated.
Second movement — the moral and religious person under judgment (2:1–3:8). Here Paul springs the trap. Just as his hearer is nodding along at the wickedness of chapter 1, Paul turns: “Therefore you have no excuse, O man, every one of you who judges. For in passing judgment on another you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, practice the very same things” (2:1). The respectable, the moral, the religious — above all the Jew who has the Law (2:17–24) — are not exempt. God “will render to each one according to his works” (2:6), and he “shows no partiality” (2:11). Even having the Law and circumcision is no shelter, because “it is not the hearers of the law who are righteous… but the doers of the law who will be justified” (2:13) — and no one does. Teach this as the Law closing every escape route: the irreligious are condemned by the witness of creation and conscience (2:14–15), and the religious are condemned by the very Law they boast in. Outward religion (“circumcision”) without an inward, Spirit-wrought reality is nothing; “a Jew is one inwardly” (2:29).
Third movement — the verdict on all (3:9–20). Paul gathers it all up: “What then? Are we Jews any better off? No, not at all. For we have already charged that all, both Jews and Greeks, are under sin” (3:9). Then comes the great catena of Old Testament texts (3:10–18), stitched together from the Psalms and Isaiah: “None is righteous, no, not one… All have turned aside… There is no fear of God before their eyes.” This is the Law’s verdict in Scripture’s own words. And then the conclusion that sets up the whole Gospel to come: “For by works of the law no human being will be justified in his sight, since through the law comes knowledge of sin” (3:20). Underline that last clause: the Law’s purpose here is not to make us righteous but to make us know we are not — to bring “knowledge of sin.” This is precisely Luther’s second use of the Law, the Law as mirror and as hammer.
Now teach original sin and total depravity from this section, because the Confessions read them here. Paul’s claim is not merely that everyone happens to sin sometimes; it is that all are “under sin” (3:9) — sin as a ruling power, a condition of the whole person. The Augsburg Confession states it: since the fall, all who are born in the natural way are born “without the fear of God, without trust in God, and with concupiscence,” and this is “truly sin, even now condemning and bringing eternal death upon those not born again through baptism and the Holy Spirit” (AC II). “No fear of God before their eyes” (3:18) is exactly AC II’s “without the fear of God.” This is why no one can be justified by works: the problem is not a deficit of good deeds to be made up, but a corrupt nature that produces no truly God-fearing righteousness at all.
Where traditions differ — Original sin and the human condition. The Lutheran/Augustinian position (AC II; FC/SD I, taken up here from Rom. 3 and later from Rom. 5) is that original sin is a deep, total corruption of human nature, leaving us spiritually dead and unable to fear, love, or trust God by our own powers — hence “none is righteous, no, not one.” The Reformed tradition agrees the corruption is total (total depravity), framing it within Adam’s federal headship. The Roman Catholic tradition holds that original sin is principally the loss of original justice (a supernatural endowment), leaving the nature wounded and inclined to sin but not utterly corrupt; the concupiscence that remains is “tinder for sin,” not sin itself. Arminian theology affirms inherited corruption but couples it with a universal prevenient grace that restores enough ability for all to respond; semi-Pelagian and Pelagian views (the latter condemned by the ancient church and by AC II) minimize or deny inherited sin, holding that fallen people retain a free and healthy will toward God. State the views fairly, then hold the line of the text: all are under sin (3:9), none is righteous (3:10), and through the Law comes only the knowledge of sin (3:20) — not its cure.
End the hour honestly, under the verdict. Do not relieve the pressure prematurely. The Law has done its work: every mouth is stopped (3:19), the whole world is held accountable to God, and no flesh will be justified by works. Let your people sit in that silence. It is the necessary silence before the Gospel speaks.
Closing Questions
- Paul condemns the obvious sinner in chapter 1 and the respectable judge in chapter 2. Which are you more tempted to be — and which condemnation lands harder on you?
- “Through the law comes knowledge of sin.” When has God’s Law made you genuinely aware of your sin, rather than just measuring you against people worse than you?
- If “none is righteous, no, not one,” what does that do to any plan to get right with God by trying harder?
- The Law stops every mouth so that no one can boast or excuse. Are you willing to let your mouth be stopped — to stop defending yourself before God?
Closing Prayer
Righteous God, your Law lays us bare and stops our mouths; we have suppressed your truth, dishonored your name, and judged in others the sins we excuse in ourselves. We confess that none is righteous, no, not one, and we cannot save ourselves. Silence our excuses, that we may hear the word of grace you are about to speak; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 3 — Justified by Faith: Redemption in Christ; Abraham (3:21–4:25)
Leader’s preparation — This is the central hour of the whole guide; teach it slowly and with full preparation. Read Romans 3:21–4:25, and alongside it Genesis 15:6, AC IV, and the main argument of Apology IV (the great Confessional locus on justification). The theological center of gravity is the material principle of the Reformation: justification by grace, through faith, on account of Christ — the imputed (alien) righteousness of Christ received by the empty hand of faith, apart from works of the Law. Have your definitions ready before the hour: dikaioō (“to justify, to declare righteous”), logizomai (“to credit, reckon, impute”), hilastērion (“place/means of atonement”). This is the hour your people most need taught well; it is the doctrine “on which the church stands or falls.” Budget your time so the Gospel of 3:21–26 and Abraham’s faith both get their due.
Opening Questions
- We ended last week with every mouth stopped and none righteous. If that is true, how can anyone ever be right with God? (Let them feel the weight before you answer.)
- The word “justified” is a courtroom word — a verdict of “not guilty,” even “righteous.” How is that different from being made good or gradually improving?
- Abraham is Paul’s great example. Most people assume Abraham earned God’s favor by his obedience. What does Genesis 15:6 actually say?
- Have you ever felt you had to contribute something — even just enough faith, or enough sincerity — to your salvation? Where does that instinct come from?
Congregational Study
“But now” — the turn from Law to Gospel (3:21–26). After two and a half chapters of unrelieved Law, Paul turns on a hinge: “But now the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from the law, although the Law and the Prophets bear witness to it—the righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe” (3:21–22, ESV). Stop and mark the turn. The same phrase, “righteousness of God,” that opened the letter (1:17) returns — and now it is unmistakably a gift, “apart from the law,” received “through faith.” This is the Gospel breaking over the wreckage of chapter 3. Then Paul packs the heart of the doctrine into a few dense verses (3:23–26); walk them slowly:
- “All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (3:23) — the verdict of the last session, restated, so that justification is for all on the same terms.
- “And are justified by his grace as a gift” (3:24). The verb is dikaioō, “to declare righteous, to acquit” — a courtroom verdict, not an inner transformation. And it is “as a gift” (Greek dōrean, “freely, gratis”) and “by his grace.” This is the forensic heart of the doctrine: God declares the ungodly righteous.
- “Through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus” (3:24). The acquittal is not a legal fiction or a winking at sin; it is grounded in redemption (Greek apolytrōsis, a ransoming, a buying back).
- God put forward Christ “as a propitiation by his blood, to be received by faith” (3:25). The word translated “propitiation” (ESV; NIV “sacrifice of atonement”) is hilastērion — “place or means of atonement,” the term used in the Greek Old Testament for the mercy seat, the cover of the ark where the blood was sprinkled on the Day of Atonement. Paul says Christ himself is the hilastērion: the place where God’s wrath against sin is turned away and mercy is met. God justifies freely, but at the cost of his Son’s blood.
- “So that he might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus” (3:26). Here is the marvel: how can God acquit the guilty and still be just? Because the penalty fell on Christ. God is both “just” (his righteousness satisfied at the cross) and “the justifier” (freely acquitting the sinner). The cross is where God’s justice and mercy meet.
Now name the structure of the doctrine plainly, because this is the material principle of the Reformation:
- Justification is forensic — a declaration, a verdict of “righteous,” not an infusion of righteousness that makes us gradually better. God reckons the sinner righteous.
- The righteousness is imputed and alien — credited to us from outside, the righteousness of Christ, not produced within us. It is “alien” (Luther’s term) not because it is foreign to us in the end, but because it originates outside us, in Christ, and is reckoned to our account.
- It is received by faith alone — sola fide. Faith is not a meritorious work we offer; it is the empty hand that receives the gift. Hence Paul’s conclusion: “one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (3:28), and all boasting is excluded (3:27).
Tie this directly to the Confessions. AC IV: we “are freely justified for Christ’s sake through faith, when we believe that we are received into favor and that our sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake… This faith God imputes for righteousness in his sight.” And the Apology, defending Article IV at length, insists that to be justified means “to be pronounced righteous” — a forensic verdict — and that faith justifies not as a virtue but because it lays hold of Christ and his merits. FC/SD III guards the same truth: our righteousness before God is the obedience, suffering, and resurrection of Christ, credited to us — not our renewal or our works, which follow as fruit but never as the ground.
Abraham: justification by faith, proved from the Law itself (ch. 4). Paul now proves his whole case from Scripture, using Abraham — the father of the Jewish nation and the supposed model of works. He quotes Genesis 15:6: “Abraham believed God, and it was counted to him as righteousness” (4:3). The verb “counted” is logizomai, an accounting term — to reckon, to put to one’s account, to impute. Teach Paul’s argument step by step, because it is airtight:
- Not by works, or it would be a wage, not a gift (4:4–5). “Now to the one who works, his wages are not counted as a gift but as his due. And to the one who does not work but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as righteousness.” Note the scandal: God “justifies the ungodly.” Faith is counted as righteousness precisely to the one who does not work. This is the death of all works-righteousness.
- David agrees (4:6–8): the blessing is forgiveness, sins the Lord “will not count” against us (Ps. 32) — justification as non-imputation of sin, the flip side of the imputation of righteousness.
- Before circumcision (4:9–12): Genesis 15:6 (faith counted) comes before Genesis 17 (circumcision). So Abraham was justified as an uncircumcised man; circumcision was a later “seal of the righteousness that he had by faith” (4:11). Therefore he is father of all who believe, circumcised or not.
- Before and apart from the Law (4:13–17): the promise came by faith, not through law, “in order that the promise may rest on grace” (4:16). Law brings wrath (4:15); promise brings grace.
- The nature of Abraham’s faith (4:18–25): “in hope he believed against hope” (4:18) that God would give him a son; he was “fully convinced that God was able to do what he had promised” (4:21). Faith clings to the promise of a God who “gives life to the dead and calls into existence the things that do not exist” (4:17). And then Paul makes it ours: these words were written for us also, for “it will be counted to us who believe in him who raised from the dead Jesus our Lord” (4:24). The same faith that justified Abraham justifies us — now directed to the God who raised Jesus.
Where traditions differ — Justification: forensic and imputed (faith alone) vs. infused righteousness. This is the central Reformation divide. The Lutheran confession (AC IV; Ap IV; FC/SD III) is that justification is a forensic act — God declares the sinner righteous, on the basis of Christ’s righteousness imputed (credited from outside) and received by faith alone, apart from any works. Good works necessarily follow as the fruit of faith, but they are never the cause or ground of the verdict. The Roman Catholic tradition, defined at the Council of Trent (1547), teaches that justification is God making the sinner inwardly righteous by infused grace (poured in, especially through baptism), so that the believer is truly renewed; faith is the beginning, but it is “faith formed by love” that justifies, and good works (themselves the fruit of grace) genuinely increase justification and merit eternal life. Trent’s canons explicitly anathematized justification by faith alone and the doctrine of imputed righteousness in the Lutheran sense. Martin Chemnitz answered Trent point by point in his Examination of the Council of Trent, defending from texts like Romans 3–4 the forensic, imputed character of justification and the distinction between justification (the verdict) and sanctification (the renewal that follows). Note for your people the 1999 Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church), which found a real “consensus on basic truths” — that we are justified by grace through faith in Christ, apart from any merit of our own — while acknowledging that the two communions still describe the relation of faith, grace, works, and merit differently, and that the differences are not merely verbal. Represent Rome fairly: Catholics do not teach crudely “earning heaven,” and the Joint Declaration narrowed real ground. But be clear that sola fide — justification by faith alone, on an imputed and alien righteousness — is the Lutheran confession, and Romans 3:28 and 4:5 (“justifies the ungodly,” faith counted “to the one who does not work”) are its charter.
Where traditions differ — “Works of the law” and the New Perspective. When Paul says no one is justified “by works of the law” (3:20, 28), the traditional Lutheran/Reformation reading takes “works of the law” broadly: any human doing of what the Law commands, all human moral effort offered as a basis for standing before God. The New Perspective on Paul argues that “works of the law” means specifically the Jewish identity markers (circumcision, food laws, Sabbath) that separated Jew from Gentile, so that Paul’s target is ethnic exclusivism and the doctrine is mainly about Gentile inclusion in the covenant people. There is genuine insight here — Paul is concerned that the Gospel is for Jew and Gentile alike (3:29–30) — but the Lutheran answer is that Paul’s argument is plainly broader: he excludes all boasting (3:27), says God “justifies the ungodly” (4:5), and grounds justification in the universal fact that “all have sinned” (3:23), not merely in the breaking down of ethnic barriers. The terrified conscience, not only the ethnic question, is in Paul’s sights.
Land the Law and Gospel of the hour. The Law: we are the ungodly (4:5); we have nothing to offer, no work that can justify, no boast left (3:27). The Gospel: God justifies the ungodly freely, by his grace, through the redemption in Christ the hilastērion, received by faith alone — and credits to us, as he did to Abraham, a righteousness we did not earn and could never produce. This is the gate of paradise.
Closing Questions
- “God justifies the ungodly.” Not the improving, not the trying-hard, but the ungodly. Can you receive that — that God’s verdict over you rests on Christ and not on your progress?
- Justification is a verdict declared, not a process you complete. How would resting in a finished verdict change the way you live with your own failures?
- Abraham’s faith simply clung to God’s promise “against hope.” What promise of God are you being asked to cling to right now against the evidence of your eyes?
- If your righteousness before God is Christ’s, credited to you, then boasting is excluded — and so is despair. Which of those two does your heart need to hear excluded today?
Closing Prayer
Gracious God, you justify the ungodly, declaring righteous those who have no righteousness of their own. We thank you that you set forth your Son as the propitiation, so that you might be both just and the justifier of all who believe. Count to us, as you counted to Abraham, the righteousness of Christ received by faith; and silence both our boasting and our despair in the finished verdict of the cross. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 4 — Peace with God; Adam and Christ; Dead to Sin, Alive in Baptism (5–6)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 5–6, and alongside it AC II (original sin), FC/SD I, the Lectures on Genesis on the fall (or Session 2 of the Genesis guide, if your group used it), and Luther’s treatment of baptism in the Small and Large Catechisms (SC IV; LC IV). The theological center of gravity is twofold: first, the fruit of justification — peace with God, access, hope, and the love of God poured out (5:1–11); second, the two heads of the human race (Adam and Christ, 5:12–21) and what it means that the baptized have died and risen with Christ and are therefore “dead to sin” (ch. 6). This hour ties Romans directly to the doctrine of original sin (Adam) and to the sacrament of baptism. Be ready to teach baptism as God’s saving act, not merely a symbol, and to handle the question of whether grace gives license to sin (Paul’s “By no means!” in 6:2).
Opening Questions
- Paul says we now “have peace with God” (5:1, ESV). Is “peace with God” something you feel you possess — or something you are still hoping to achieve?
- Paul says we even “rejoice in our sufferings” (5:3). How can suffering ever be something to rejoice in?
- “Just as sin came into the world through one man… so” (5:12, 18). Why does Paul put so much weight on one man, Adam — and one man, Christ?
- When someone is baptized, what do you think actually happens? Is it mainly something we do, or something God does?
Congregational Study
The fruit of justification (5:1–11). Paul draws out what justification yields. “Therefore, since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ” (5:1). Teach the chain of blessings: peace with God (the war is over; we are no longer under wrath), access into grace (5:2), and hope of glory (5:2). Then the surprising turn: “we rejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, and endurance produces character, and character produces hope” (5:3–4) — and this hope “does not put us to shame, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit” (5:5). The ground of it all is the cross: “While we were still sinners, Christ died for us” (5:8). Press this: God’s love is proven not by our improvement but by Christ dying for the ungodly (5:6), while we were still sinners (5:8), while we were enemies (5:10). This is the same Gospel of Session 3, now felt as peace and assurance. The certainty of salvation rests not on our feelings but on the objective fact of Christ’s death and the love of God poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit.
Adam and Christ: the two heads (5:12–21). Now Paul reaches one of the most important passages in Scripture for the doctrine of original sin and the doctrine of Christ. “Therefore, just as sin came into the world through one man, and death through sin, and so death spread to all men because all sinned” (5:12). Teach the structure: Adam is the head of the old humanity; through his one sin, sin and death spread to all. Christ is the head of the new humanity; through his one act of righteousness, justification and life come to all who are in him. Paul piles up the parallel: “as one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men” (5:18). The point of the Adam-Christ parallel is the imputation that runs both ways: Adam’s sin is reckoned to his race; Christ’s righteousness is reckoned to his people. The very logic of justification (Session 3) is grounded here in the two heads.
Teach original sin from this text. Paul does not say death came to all merely because each person individually copied Adam; he says “so death spread to all men because all sinned” — sin and death entering the race as a condition through the one man. This is the Scriptural foundation of AC II’s teaching that we are born in sin, not merely that we become sinners by imitation. The Pelagian view (that Adam is only a bad example) cannot account for Paul’s “one man… all.” Note also Paul’s great “much more” (5:15, 17, 20): grace super-abounds over sin — “where sin increased, grace abounded all the more” (5:20). The remedy is greater than the disease.
Where traditions differ — Adam, original sin, and how it is transmitted (5:12–21). The Lutheran/Augustinian reading (AC II; FC/SD I) takes Adam as a real, first man and original sin as a true, inherited corruption and guilt — we are born under sin and death “in Adam,” which is why Paul’s “one man… all” works. The famous textual question is how to read the end of 5:12: the Latin Vulgate rendered the Greek eph’ hō as in quo, “in whom [all sinned],” which Augustine and the medieval/Roman tradition took to mean all sinned in Adam (supporting inherited guilt); most modern translations render it “because all sinned.” Lutherans hold inherited corruption and guilt regardless of the grammatical fine point, on the strength of the whole passage. The Roman Catholic tradition affirms a real Adam and original sin but, as in Session 2, frames it as the loss of original justice rather than total corruption. The Arminian tradition affirms inherited corruption but generally denies inherited guilt, holding that one is condemned only for one’s own sins (often paired with prevenient grace and an “age of accountability”). Many historical-critical scholars treat Adam as symbolic; warn your people that if there is no real Adam, Paul’s entire “one man… one man” parallel — and with it the ground of justification in Christ — loses its footing (cf. 1 Cor. 15:21–22). The Lutheran line: Adam is real, the corruption is real and inherited, and the remedy is the second Adam.
Dead to sin, alive in Christ — baptism (ch. 6). Paul anticipates an objection: if grace abounds where sin increases (5:20), “are we to continue in sin that grace may abound?” His answer is thunderous: “By no means! How can we who died to sin still live in it?” (6:2). And then he grounds the answer in baptism: “Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life” (6:3–4). Teach this carefully and as a Lutheran:
- Baptism unites us to Christ’s death and resurrection. The “old self was crucified with him” (6:6); we are “dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus” (6:11). This is not a metaphor for a decision we made; it is God’s act, joining us to Christ.
- Baptism is therefore the daily pattern of the Christian life. Luther’s Small Catechism draws exactly this from Romans 6: baptism “signifies that the old Adam in us, together with all sins and evil desires, should be drowned by daily contrition and repentance, and die, and that daily a new man should come forth and arise, who shall live before God in righteousness and purity forever” (SC IV). The drowning and rising of Romans 6 is the rhythm of repentance and faith every day.
- And so the answer to “are we to continue in sin that grace may abound?” is not “you’ll lose your reward” but “you have died to that — it is contrary to your new identity.” The justified person is not given a license to sin but a death to it and a new life. “Consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God” (6:11); “present yourselves to God as those who have been brought from death to life” (6:13). The chapter ends with the great contrast: “the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord” (6:23).
Where traditions differ — Baptism: sacramental regeneration vs. symbol. Lutherans confess, from Romans 6 and Titus 3:5 and elsewhere, that baptism is a means of grace — God’s own act, which truly buries us with Christ, works forgiveness, delivers from death and the devil, and grants new life and the Spirit (SC IV; LC IV; AC IX). It is not chiefly our work or testimony but God’s gracious work, which is why we baptize infants. Roman Catholics and the Eastern Orthodox likewise hold baptism to be regenerative. The Reformed/Presbyterian tradition treats baptism as a covenant sign and seal that genuinely conveys grace to the elect by the Spirit, though it tends to distinguish the sign from the thing signified more sharply than Lutherans do. The Baptist and much of the evangelical tradition reads baptism as a symbol — an outward sign of an inward faith already present and a public testimony of the believer — and so practices believer’s baptism only, reading Romans 6 as picturing a union with Christ that occurs at conversion rather than being effected in the water. State the Baptist concern fairly (it guards against an empty, presumptuous reliance on a ritual), but teach the Lutheran confession: in Romans 6 baptism does something — it buries and raises us with Christ — because the Word and promise of God are joined to the water.
Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: we are by nature “in Adam” — under sin and death, and the wages of sin is death (6:23). The Gospel: Christ, the second Adam, has done the one righteous act that brings life; and in baptism God has joined us to his death and resurrection, so that we are dead to sin and alive to God. The justified life is not “now try harder”; it is “now live out the death and resurrection that are already yours.”
Closing Questions
- “While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” Does your sense of peace with God rest on that fact, or on how well you think you are doing? What is the difference on a bad day?
- We are either “in Adam” or “in Christ” — under the old head or the new. Which headship governs how you think about yourself most days?
- Luther says baptism means the old Adam is drowned and a new self rises daily. What would daily repentance and faith — daily returning to your baptism — actually look like this week?
- Paul says we have died to sin. When you are tempted, do you fight as a slave still bound to sin, or as one who has been set free and made alive? How would the second change the fight?
Closing Prayer
Heavenly Father, in baptism you buried us with your Son and raised us to walk in newness of life. We thank you that while we were still sinners Christ died for us, and that nothing in us, but only his blood, is our peace. Drown the old Adam in us by daily repentance, and raise up the new, that being dead to sin we may be alive to you; through Jesus Christ our risen Lord. Amen.
Session 5 — The Law, the Divided Self, and Life in the Spirit; No Condemnation (7–8)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 7–8, and alongside it Luther’s Bondage of the Will (LW 33) on the will’s captivity, FC/SD II (free will) and V (Law and Gospel), and the eighth chapter especially in the Lectures on Romans (LW 25). The theological center of gravity is the move from the anguish of the divided self under sin and the Law (ch. 7) to the liberty, assurance, and glory of life in the Spirit, with its summit in “no condemnation” and the unbreakable love of God (ch. 8). Romans 8 is the high country of the whole letter — the most comforting chapter in Paul; give it room. Be ready to teach the long-debated question of the “I” in Romans 7 (regenerate or unregenerate?) fairly, and to set it in the service of the Lutheran simul iustus et peccator — at once righteous and a sinner. End the hour on the heights of 8:31–39.
Opening Questions
- Paul cries, “I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate” (7:15, ESV). Does that sound like your experience as a Christian — or like someone who isn’t a Christian at all?
- Is the Law our enemy? Paul says the Law is “holy and righteous and good” (7:12) — and yet it cannot save us. How can both be true?
- Romans 8 opens, “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (8:1). What would it feel like to be truly, permanently un-condemned?
- Paul ends the chapter saying nothing “will be able to separate us from the love of God” (8:39). Is your assurance of God’s love that secure — and if not, where do you look for it?
Congregational Study
The Law, sin, and the believer’s struggle (ch. 7). Paul has said we are released from the Law (7:1–6) — but he must immediately defend the Law against the charge that it is therefore sinful. His answer (7:7–13): the Law is not sin; rather, the Law exposes sin and even provokes it (“I would not have known what it is to covet if the law had not said, ‘You shall not covet’,” 7:7). Sin “seizing an opportunity through the commandment” springs to life (7:8). The Law is “holy and righteous and good” (7:12); the problem is not the Law but sin in us, which uses the good Law to condemn and kill. This is a precise statement of the Law’s accusing work: the Law is good, but to a sinner it brings death, because it can only command, never enable.
Then comes the famous and disputed passage, 7:14–25 — the cry of the divided self: “I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate… For I have the desire to do what is right, but not the ability to carry it out… Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?” (7:15, 18, 24). Teach this as the experience of the Christian who knows the Law’s goodness, delights in it “in my inner being” (7:22), and yet finds another law at war in his members. The cry ends in both despair and hope: “Wretched man that I am!” and then “Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (7:24–25).
Where traditions differ — Who is the “I” of Romans 7:14–25? This is both an in-house Lutheran question and a cross-tradition debate. The dominant Lutheran (and Reformed/Augustinian) reading, following the later Augustine and Luther, takes the “I” as the regenerate person — the Christian, who still wars against indwelling sin. This reading grounds the great Lutheran formula simul iustus et peccator: the believer is at the same time fully righteous (in Christ, by imputation) and still truly a sinner (in himself, in this flesh) until death. Romans 7, on this view, is the honest self-portrait of every saint: justified, yet still struggling, still driven to cry for deliverance — which is exactly why the Christian lives by daily repentance and faith (Session 4). The other major reading (held by some Lutherans and by much of the Wesleyan/Arminian and New Perspective scholarship, and by many early Greek fathers) takes the “I” as the unregenerate person — either Paul dramatizing life under the Law before Christ, or humanity in general apart from grace — so that the deliverance of 7:25 and the “no condemnation” of 8:1 mark the passage out of that wretchedness into Christian freedom. Some Wesleyan/Holiness traditions especially resist the regenerate reading because they expect a fuller victory over sin in this life (entire sanctification). Present both readings honestly. The Lutheran instinct, and the pastoral payoff, favors the regenerate reading: it neither flatters the Christian into thinking sin is behind him nor drives him to despair, but teaches him to confess “wretched man that I am” and “thanks be to God” in the same breath — which is the life of faith.
The bondage of the will — a leader’s note. Romans 7 is also where the deeper Lutheran doctrine of the will comes to a head. Against Erasmus, Luther argued in Bondage of the Will (LW 33) that the natural human will, apart from grace, is not free toward God — it is bound, captive to sin, unable to turn itself to God or contribute to its own conversion. The cry “not the ability to carry it out” (7:18) and “none is righteous” (3:10) and “dead in sin” together teach that conversion is God’s work, not a cooperation of a free human will (FC/SD II rejects both Pelagian free will and the notion that man cooperates in his own conversion). Teach this gently but clearly: we are saved monergistically — by God alone — because a will bound by sin cannot free itself. This is the deep ground of grace alone.
No condemnation, and life in the Spirit (8:1–17). Then the sun breaks through: “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death” (8:1–2). This is the answer to the wretched cry of chapter 7. What the Law was powerless to do, “weakened by the flesh,” God did by sending his own Son “for sin” (8:3), so that the righteous requirement of the Law might be fulfilled in us who now walk by the Spirit (8:4). Teach the contrast Paul draws between the flesh and the Spirit (8:5–13): the mind set on the flesh is death and hostility to God (8:7); the mind set on the Spirit is life and peace. And the Spirit assures us of our adoption: “You did not receive the spirit of slavery to fall back into fear, but you have received the Spirit of adoption as sons, by whom we cry, ‘Abba! Father!’” (8:15). We are children, and “if children, then heirs—heirs of God and fellow heirs with Christ” (8:17).
The certainty of salvation (8:18–39). The chapter rises to its climax. The whole creation groans for redemption (8:19–22); we groan, and the Spirit himself groans and intercedes for us “with groanings too deep for words” (8:26) when we do not know how to pray. Then the golden chain (8:28–30): “for those who love God all things work together for good” (8:28), and those God foreknew he predestined, called, justified, and glorified — note the past tense of “glorified,” as though it is already accomplished, so sure is God’s purpose. Then the soaring conclusion (8:31–39): “If God is for us, who can be against us? He who did not spare his own Son… how will he not also with him graciously give us all things?” (8:31–32 — and note the echo of Abraham and Isaac, Gen. 22). “Who shall bring any charge against God’s elect? It is God who justifies. Who is to condemn?” (8:33–34). And the unbreakable promise: nothing — “neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers… nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (8:38–39). Teach this as the high point of Christian assurance. The certainty of salvation rests not on the believer’s performance but on God’s purpose, Christ’s death and intercession, and the Spirit’s seal. Let your people hear that this assurance is theirs.
Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: even the regenerate Christian remains a wretched sinner who cannot carry out the good he wills (7:18, 24); the flesh wars against the Spirit until death. The Gospel: there is now no condemnation for those in Christ (8:1); the Spirit makes us God’s children and seals our hope; and nothing in all creation can separate us from God’s love in Christ. The wretched cry of chapter 7 and the unbreakable love of chapter 8 belong together — simul iustus et peccator — and the Gospel always has the last word.
Closing Questions
- Paul, an apostle, cried “wretched man that I am!” Does it comfort or trouble you that the Christian life includes that struggle — and what does it tell you about anyone who claims to be done with sin?
- “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.” Sit with the word now. Is there a condemnation you are still carrying that the Gospel says is already lifted?
- The Spirit teaches us to cry “Abba! Father!” When you pray, do you come as a slave hoping to earn favor, or as a child who already has it?
- Nothing “will be able to separate us from the love of God.” Name the thing you most fear could separate you from God — and hear Paul say it cannot.
Closing Prayer
O God, who did not spare your own Son but gave him up for us all, we confess that we remain wretched sinners who cannot do the good we will. Yet we thank you that there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. Pour out your Spirit, who teaches us to cry “Abba! Father!” and seal in us the assurance that nothing in all creation can separate us from your love in Christ Jesus our Lord. Amen.
Session 6 — God’s Faithfulness, Israel, and Election (9–11)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 9–11, and alongside it FC/SD XI (eternal election), AC XI, and the careful Lutheran handling of predestination in Walther and the dogmaticians. The theological center of gravity is God’s sovereign, electing grace and his faithfulness to his promises — worked out in the agonizing question of Israel’s unbelief and the inclusion of the Gentiles. This is the hardest section to teach in a balanced, comforting, Lutheran way, because election and predestination have divided the church. Have FC/SD XI clear in your mind: Lutherans confess a single predestination — an election to salvation in Christ, which is pure comfort — and refuse to make it a symmetrical decree of damnation. Resolve to teach election the way the Confessions intend it: not as a riddle to torment the conscience, but as the ground of assurance. End on the doxology of 11:33–36.
Opening Questions
- Paul says he would be willing to be “accursed and cut off from Christ” for the sake of his own people, Israel (9:3, ESV). What does that tell you about the weight of this question for him?
- “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated” (9:13), and God “has mercy on whomever he wills” (9:18). What is your gut reaction to language like that?
- If God chooses, where does that leave human responsibility — and why do people fear this doctrine?
- “All Israel will be saved” (11:26). What do you think Paul means — and what have you heard others say it means?
Congregational Study
The problem: has God’s word failed? (9:1–13). Paul turns from the heights of chapter 8 to grief: his own people, Israel, to whom belong the covenants and the promises (9:4–5), have largely rejected the Christ. Does that mean God’s word has failed? “It is not as though the word of God has failed” (9:6). Paul’s answer: “Not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel” (9:6) — physical descent never guaranteed the promise. He proves it from Israel’s own history: the promise ran through Isaac, not Ishmael; through Jacob, not Esau — and the choice was made “though they were not yet born and had done nothing either good or bad—in order that God’s purpose of election might continue, not because of works but because of him who calls” (9:11–12). Teach this as election by grace: God’s choice rests on his mercy, not on human works or worthiness. This is the same grace that justifies the ungodly (ch. 4), now seen in God’s freedom to call.
God’s mercy and the hard sayings (9:14–29). Paul presses into the hardest territory: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy” (9:15); “he has mercy on whomever he wills, and he hardens whomever he wills” (9:18); the potter and the clay (9:21). Teach this honestly and carefully. Two things must be held together: God is sovereign and free in his mercy (we are saved by grace alone, never by our deserving), and — as Paul will insist — those who are lost are lost by their own unbelief and rebellion (9:32; 10:3; 11:20), never because God delighted to damn them. Do not resolve the tension by denying either truth.
The Gospel for all, and Israel’s stumble (9:30–10:21). Paul diagnoses Israel’s failure precisely: they “pursued a law that would lead to righteousness” but “did not pursue it by faith” (9:31–32); they were “ignorant of the righteousness of God, and seeking to establish their own” (10:3). Here is the whole letter’s theme again — the contrast between a self-made righteousness and the righteousness God gives by faith. Then the great evangelical center of these chapters: “Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to everyone who believes” (10:4); “if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved” (10:9); “everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved” (10:13). And therefore the necessity of preaching: “faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (10:17) — a key Lutheran proof-text for the means of grace: faith is created by the Gospel proclaimed.
Mercy on all: the mystery of Israel (ch. 11). Has God rejected his people? “By no means!” (11:1). There is a remnant “chosen by grace” (11:5), and Israel’s stumble is neither total nor final. Paul uses the olive tree (11:17–24): Gentile believers are wild branches grafted in among the natural branches; let them not be arrogant, for they stand by faith alone and can themselves be cut off (11:20–22). Then the climax: “A partial hardening has come upon Israel, until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in. And in this way all Israel will be saved” (11:25–26). Paul’s conclusion is that “God has consigned all to disobedience, that he may have mercy on all” (11:32) — the whole tangled history of Jew and Gentile serves the triumph of mercy. The section ends not in a system but in worship: “Oh, the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments… For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be glory forever” (11:33, 36). Teach your people that this is where the doctrine of election is meant to land: not in speculation, but in doxology.
Where traditions differ — Election and predestination. This is one of the great dividing lines, and you must teach it with care. The Lutheran confession (FC/SD XI) is a single predestination: God, in eternity, chose his elect to salvation in Christ, out of pure grace and mercy, apart from any foreseen merit. This election is the ground of comfort — it means our salvation rests on God’s eternal purpose, not our frailty. But Lutherans refuse to make it symmetrical: there is no eternal decree predestining anyone to damnation. God “desires all people to be saved” (1 Tim. 2:4); Christ died for all; the lost are lost solely by their own willful rejection of the Gospel (Hos. 13:9 in the older reading: “you have destroyed yourself”). The cause of salvation is God’s grace alone; the cause of damnation is man’s own sin and unbelief — an asymmetry the Confessions hold even though it resists logical tidiness. The Reformed/Calvinist tradition, in its consistent forms, teaches double predestination: God sovereignly elects some to salvation and either passes over (preterition) or actively reprobates the rest, all to his glory; this is logically symmetrical and grounds assurance in God’s decree. The Arminian (and much Baptist and Wesleyan) tradition teaches conditional election: God elects those he foreknew would believe, preserving libertarian free will and a universal, resistible grace. Roman Catholic theology has a range of views (Thomist and Molinist) but generally ties predestination closely to God’s foreknowledge and the cooperation of grace and free will. Present each fairly: the Calvinist guards God’s sovereignty, the Arminian guards human responsibility and God’s universal love, and both are trying to honor real biblical data. Then teach the Lutheran way through: we will not let go of either “saved by grace alone” or “God desires all to be saved,” even though we cannot fully reconcile them — and we direct the anxious conscience not to peer into the hidden decree but to Christ crucified and the means of grace, where God’s gracious will for you is revealed and given. Election, rightly taught, is pure comfort: your salvation is older than the world and rests in God’s hands.
Where traditions differ — “All Israel will be saved” (11:26) and the future of ethnic Israel. Lutherans (and the broader amillennial tradition) generally read “all Israel” in one of two non-dispensational ways: either as the full number of God’s elect, Jew and Gentile together (the “Israel of God,” cf. Gal. 6:16), or as a large-scale future turning of ethnic Jews to Christ through faith in the Gospel — but in either case saved the same way everyone is saved, by faith in Jesus, with no separate covenant or program for ethnic Israel. The dispensational tradition reads 11:26 as promising a distinct future for national, ethnic Israel — a restored kingdom, often tied to a future millennium and the rebuilding of the temple, in which God resumes a separate program for the Jewish people. Lutherans reject the two-track scheme: there is one people of God, one olive tree, and one way of salvation — Christ received by faith. Teach the difference plainly, and note that whatever “all Israel” means, Paul’s point is the triumph of mercy (11:32), not a real-estate or political future.
Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: salvation is not by descent, by works, or by establishing our own righteousness — Israel’s tragedy is the warning to every self-confident heart (11:20–21). The Gospel: salvation is by God’s electing mercy, grounded in his eternal purpose in Christ, offered to all who call on him (10:13), and so secure that the believer’s hope rests in God’s unsearchable, faithful, merciful will. Send your people not to speculation but to Christ, and to worship.
Closing Questions
- Israel was “seeking to establish their own” righteousness instead of receiving God’s (10:3). Where are you still trying to establish your own standing before God rather than receive his gift?
- Does it comfort you or frighten you that your salvation rests on God’s eternal choice rather than your own staying-power? Why?
- The Gentile branches are warned not to be arrogant but to “stand fast through faith” (11:20). How does remembering you were grafted in by sheer mercy guard you from looking down on anyone?
- Paul ends not with a system but with worship: “Oh, the depth of the riches…” When a doctrine is too deep to fully grasp, can you let it drive you to praise rather than to anxiety?
Closing Prayer
O God of unsearchable wisdom, from before the foundation of the world you chose your people in Christ, out of pure mercy and not for any merit of theirs. We thank you that our salvation rests not in our frail grasp but in your eternal, faithful will. Guard us from arrogance and from despair alike; turn the eyes of all who stumble to your Son; and gather Jew and Gentile into one people, that mercy may triumph and you may be glorified forever. Amen.
Session 7 — The Renewed Life: Living Sacrifice, Love, and the Governing Authorities (12–13)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 12–13, and alongside it FC/SD VI (the third use of the Law), AC XVI (civil government and the two kingdoms), and Luther’s Temporal Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (LW 45). The theological center of gravity is the renewed life that flows from the Gospel: the “therefore” of 12:1, in which justified believers offer themselves as living sacrifices, love genuinely, and live rightly under the governing authorities. This is the hour to teach the third use of the Law and the two kingdoms — and above all to keep the ethics tethered to the Gospel that grounds them. Be vigilant: chapters 12–13 can easily be taught as mere moralism. Anchor everything in the “by the mercies of God” of 12:1; this is the response of the justified, never the price of justification.
Opening Questions
- Romans 12 opens with a “therefore.” After eleven chapters of doctrine, Paul finally says “so here’s how to live.” Why does he put it in that order — doctrine first, then life?
- Paul says, “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind” (12:2, ESV). What patterns of “this world” are hardest for Christians to resist?
- Paul tells us to “bless those who persecute you” and “never avenge yourselves” (12:14, 19). Is that realistic? Where does the strength for it come from?
- “Let every person be subject to the governing authorities” (13:1). Does that mean a Christian must always obey the government, no matter what?
Congregational Study
The “therefore” — the living sacrifice (12:1–2). Mark the hinge of the whole letter. “I appeal to you therefore, brothers, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your spiritual worship” (12:1). Everything in the second half of Romans hangs on that “therefore” and that “by the mercies of God.” Teach this as the Lutheran ordering of Gospel and good works: the indicative (what God has done in chapters 1–11) grounds the imperative (how we now live in chapters 12–16). We are not made living sacrifices in order to be justified; we offer ourselves because we have been justified, “by the mercies of God.” Good works are the fruit and response of faith, never its root or cause (cf. Session 3; AC IV; Ap IV). The renewed mind (12:2) is the Spirit’s ongoing work, the daily rising of the new self from baptism (Session 4).
The third use of the Law — a leader’s note. Here is the place to teach the third use of the Law (FC/SD VI). The Law has a first use (a curb, restraining outward evil and keeping civil order) and a second use (a mirror, accusing sin and driving us to Christ — the dominant use in chapters 1–3, 7). But for the baptized, now justified by faith, the Law has a third use: a guide, instructing the new self in the good works God has prepared. Chapters 12–13 are largely third-use instruction — Paul telling the justified what the renewed life looks like. Keep the crucial Lutheran guardrail: even for the Christian, the Law never justifies; it guides the life of those already justified, and it still accuses our remaining sin (we are simul iustus et peccator, Session 5). The believer obeys not to earn God’s favor but freely, out of the favor already given.
Life in the body and genuine love (12:3–21). Paul applies the renewed life. Within the church, we are “one body” with different gifts to be used in humility for one another (12:3–8) — note the echo of justification: “think with sober judgment, each according to the measure of faith that God has assigned” (12:3), for even our place in the body is a gift. Then the marks of genuine love (12:9–21): “Let love be genuine” (12:9); “love one another with brotherly affection” (12:10); “contribute to the needs of the saints” (12:13); “bless those who persecute you” (12:14); “do not be haughty” (12:16); “repay no one evil for evil” (12:17); “never avenge yourselves… ‘Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord’” (12:19); “do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good” (12:21). Teach this as the shape of a Spirit-renewed life — and note that the renunciation of personal vengeance (12:19) sets up the next chapter’s teaching on the government, which does bear the sword.
The governing authorities and the two kingdoms (13:1–7). This is the great New Testament text on the Christian and the state, and it must be taught through the Lutheran doctrine of the two kingdoms (or two governments). Paul: “Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God” (13:1); rulers are “God’s servant for your good” and bear “the sword” to punish wrongdoing (13:4); therefore we submit, pay taxes, and give honor (13:6–7). Teach the two-kingdoms framework (AC XVI; Luther’s Temporal Authority):
- God rules the world in two ways: through his spiritual government (the Gospel, the church, the Word and Sacraments, by which he saves and forgives) and through his temporal government (the civil authority, law, and the sword, by which he restrains evil and preserves outward order and peace).
- Both are God’s; both are good in their place. The Christian lives in both: forgiven and ruled by the Gospel in the kingdom of the right hand, and a citizen subject to the lawful authority in the kingdom of the left. The government’s sword (the first/civil use of the Law) is God’s appointed means to restrain evil in a fallen world — which is why the Christian may, with a clear conscience, serve as a magistrate, soldier, or judge (AC XVI), even though personal vengeance is forbidden him (12:19).
- The submission of 13:1 is not absolute. Lutherans have always held, with Acts 5:29, that “we must obey God rather than men” when the state commands sin or forbids what God commands. The authority is God’s servant for good (13:4); when it sets itself against God, the Christian’s higher obedience is to God. Teach this balance carefully — neither anarchy nor idolatry of the state.
Where traditions differ — Church, state, and the governing authorities. The Lutheran reading frames Romans 13 through the two kingdoms: civil government is God’s good ordinance for the temporal realm, to be honored and obeyed (with the limit of Acts 5:29), while the Gospel rules the spiritual realm; the two are distinct and must not be confused or collapsed. The Reformed tradition has tended toward a more integrated vision in which civil rulers are also charged to uphold true religion and the church may shape the social order (historic establishments, and in some streams theonomy); some Reformed thinkers grant a fuller right of resistance through lesser magistrates. The Anabaptist / radical tradition reads the Sermon on the Mount and Romans 12’s renunciation of the sword as excluding Christians from wielding the state’s sword at all, yielding pacifism and a sharp separation of the church from the coercive state. The Roman Catholic tradition has its own long development of church-state relations and natural-law social teaching. Teach the views fairly, then hold the Lutheran center: government is God’s servant to be honored and obeyed for the sake of order and the neighbor, the church’s weapon is the Word and not the sword, and God alone is to be obeyed absolutely.
Love fulfills the Law; the nearness of the day (13:8–14). Paul gathers the ethics back to one principle: “Owe no one anything, except to love each other, for the one who loves another has fulfilled the law” (13:8); “love is the fulfilling of the law” (13:10). And he grounds the urgency eschatologically: “the hour has come for you to wake from sleep… The night is far gone; the day is at hand” (13:11–12). “Put on the Lord Jesus Christ” (13:14) — the very words that, read aloud in a garden, converted Augustine. Teach the close: the renewed life is lived in love, in the light, and in the expectation of the Lord’s near return.
Land the Law and Gospel. The Law (third use): the justified are called to offer themselves as living sacrifices, to love genuinely, to bless enemies, to submit to lawful authority, and to fulfill the law in love — and where they fall short, the Law still accuses. The Gospel: all of this is “by the mercies of God” (12:1) — the response of those already justified and renewed, who put on Christ (13:14) and live in the light of his coming day. The order is everything: mercy first, then the living sacrifice.
Closing Questions
- Paul says “by the mercies of God” before he asks for a single thing. Why is it spiritually deadly to reverse that order — to try to live the Christian life before resting in the mercy?
- “Be transformed by the renewal of your mind.” Where is the pattern of this world still shaping your thinking more than the Gospel is?
- “Never avenge yourselves… overcome evil with good.” Is there someone you are tempted to repay for a wrong? What would handing that over to God free you to do instead?
- The government is “God’s servant for your good,” yet we must obey God rather than men. How do you honor both truths in a time when Christians disagree about the state?
Closing Prayer
Merciful God, by your mercies in Christ we offer ourselves to you as living sacrifices, knowing that even this offering is your gift. Renew our minds, make our love genuine, and teach us to overcome evil with good. Give us to honor those you have set in authority, to obey you above all, and to put on the Lord Jesus Christ, awake and ready for the day that is near. Through the same Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 8 — The Weak and the Strong; the Unity of the Church; Final Greetings (14–16)
Leader’s preparation — Read Romans 14–16, and alongside it the Formula’s teaching on adiaphora (FC/SD X) and the close of Luther’s Preface to Romans (LW 35). The theological center of gravity is the life of the justified community: how the strong and the weak in faith are to welcome one another over disputable matters, all to the glory of God; and Paul’s closing prayers, plans, and greetings, in which the doctrine becomes a living church. This is also the hour to gather up the whole letter and send your people out with it. Teach the chapter on the weak and the strong (14) as an application of justification (we welcome one another because God has welcomed us, 14:3; 15:7), and the famous greetings of chapter 16 as proof that the Gospel of Romans creates a real, named, diverse community.
Opening Questions
- In chapter 14 some Christians eat anything and observe no special days; others eat only vegetables and keep sacred days. Why does Paul refuse to simply declare a winner?
- Paul calls some believers “weak in faith” (14:1, ESV). Is the “weak” one the one with more rules, or fewer? (It may surprise them.)
- “Why do you pass judgment on your brother? Or you, why do you despise your brother?” (14:10). Which of those two is your temptation — judging the stricter, or despising the freer?
- Romans ends with a long list of names and greetings (ch. 16). Why might that be more important than it looks?
Congregational Study
The weak and the strong (14:1–15:13). Paul addresses a real tension in the Roman church: some (the “strong,” with whom Paul agrees in principle, 15:1) know that all foods are clean and no day is intrinsically holier than another; others (the “weak in faith”) still feel bound to dietary scruples and to observing sacred days. Teach Paul’s even-handed and profound response:
- These are disputable matters (adiaphora). They are not the Gospel itself, not articles of faith, but things neither commanded nor forbidden. Paul will not let either side make them a test of fellowship. “As for the one who is weak in faith, welcome him, but not to quarrel over opinions” (14:1).
- Receive one another, because God has received you. “Let not the one who eats despise the one who abstains, and let not the one who abstains pass judgment on the one who eats, for God has welcomed him” (14:3). Here is justification applied to church life: since God has freely received both, neither may reject the other. Paul makes it explicit at the climax: “Welcome one another as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God” (15:7).
- Do not despise, and do not judge. The strong are tempted to despise the scrupulous as backward; the weak are tempted to judge the free as lax. Both are forbidden, because “we will all stand before the judgment seat of God” (14:10) — each is the Lord’s servant, answerable to him (14:4).
- But do not wound a weak conscience. Though “nothing is unclean in itself” (14:14), love limits liberty: “if your brother is grieved by what you eat, you are no longer walking in love” (14:15). “It is good not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that causes your brother to stumble” (14:21). Freedom is real, but love for the neighbor’s conscience governs its use. “Whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (14:23) — so neither may anyone be forced to act against conscience.
Teach this as a model for the church in every age. The principle is Lutheran to the core (FC/SD X on adiaphora): in matters neither commanded nor forbidden, the church has freedom, no one’s conscience may be bound as though these were the Gospel, and love and the neighbor’s conscience govern the use of liberty — while no one compromises the Gospel itself. Help your people distinguish the article of justification (where there can be no compromise) from disputable matters (where there must be forbearance). Confusing the two has wrecked more congregations than open heresy.
Christ the servant, and the Gospel for the nations (15:1–13). Paul grounds the whole ethic in Christ: “We who are strong have an obligation to bear with the failings of the weak… For Christ did not please himself” (15:1–3). He prays for a unity that glorifies God “with one voice” (15:5–6). And he gathers up a theme that has run through the letter — the Gospel is for Jew and Gentile together — with a chain of Old Testament quotations (15:9–12) showing that the Gentiles’ praise of God was promised all along. The God of hope fills them “with all joy and peace in believing,” so that “by the power of the Holy Spirit” they may “abound in hope” (15:13).
Paul’s plans, prayers, and greetings (15:14–16:27). Paul explains his ministry as “a minister of Christ Jesus to the Gentiles” (15:16), his ambition to preach where Christ is not yet named (15:20), and his plans to visit Rome on the way to Spain (15:24, 28) after delivering the collection to Jerusalem (15:25–27). He asks for their prayers (15:30–33). Then chapter 16: a long, warm list of greetings to named believers — Phoebe the servant and patron (16:1–2), Prisca and Aquila (16:3), and some two dozen more, men and women, Jew and Gentile, slave and free. Do not skip this as a mere address list. Teach it as the embodiment of everything Romans has argued: the Gospel of justification creates a real, named, gloriously diverse community in which the strong and the weak, the Jew and the Gentile, are one in Christ. There is a sharp warning to watch for those who cause divisions contrary to the doctrine (16:17–18) — sound doctrine still matters supremely — and then the great closing doxology: glory to God “who is able to strengthen you according to my gospel… to bring about the obedience of faith—to the only wise God be glory forevermore through Jesus Christ!” (16:25–27). The letter ends where it began — with the Gospel and the obedience of faith among all nations.
Where traditions differ — Adiaphora, Christian liberty, and conscience. Lutherans (FC/SD X) distinguish sharply between matters God has commanded or forbidden (where there is no freedom) and adiaphora — things indifferent, neither commanded nor forbidden (rites, ceremonies, foods, days) — in which the church has liberty, though that liberty must yield to love and must never be surrendered as though indifferent things were essential (especially under persecution, “when confession is required”). Many Reformed churches have historically applied a stricter regulative principle of worship (only what Scripture positively commands may be done in worship), narrowing the realm of indifferent things, especially in the liturgy. Other traditions vary widely in how much they bind or loose on food, drink, days, dress, and entertainment. The Lutheran instinct from Romans 14: do not judge the stricter, do not despise the freer, bind no conscience where God has not bound it, and let love for the neighbor govern your liberty — all because Christ has welcomed you both.
Now gather up the whole letter for your people. Romans began with “the righteousness of God” revealed (1:17) and the whole race condemned under sin (1:18–3:20); it turned on the great “But now” of free justification in Christ (3:21), proved it from Abraham (4) and grounded it in the two heads, Adam and Christ (5); it buried us with Christ in baptism (6), laid bare our struggle and lifted us to “no condemnation” and the unbreakable love of God (7–8); it traced God’s faithful, electing mercy to Jew and Gentile (9–11); and it sent the justified out to live as living sacrifices, in love, under authority, in a community of the weak and the strong (12–16). One thread runs the whole way: a guilty world, and a God who justifies the ungodly freely, for Christ’s sake, through faith. To read Romans as a Lutheran is to be brought, with Luther, through the gate of paradise — and then to live and love on the far side of it, by grace, to the glory of God alone.
Closing Questions
- In disputable matters, are you more tempted to judge those stricter than you or to despise those freer than you? What would it look like to “welcome one another as Christ has welcomed you” instead?
- “Christ did not please himself” but bore with the weak. Whose weakness or scruple is God calling you to bear with patiently, rather than run over in the name of your freedom?
- The letter ends with a roomful of named, ordinary believers. What does it mean that the great doctrine of Romans was written for a real, diverse congregation like yours?
- We have walked the whole letter, from “none is righteous” to “no condemnation.” Which truth of Romans has most gripped you — and how will you carry it out the door?
Closing Prayer
O God of hope, you have justified the ungodly freely by faith and gathered the weak and the strong, Jew and Gentile, into one body in your Son. Fill us with all joy and peace in believing, that we may abound in hope by the power of your Spirit. Make us patient with one another as Christ has welcomed us, and establish us in the Gospel of your grace. To the only wise God be glory forever, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
A closing word for the leader. You have led your people through the charter of the Reformation — the letter over which Luther’s conscience was set free and from which our churches draw the article on which they stand or fall. The whole of Romans is one sustained sermon in Law and Gospel: the Law that holds the whole world accountable to God and stops every mouth, and the Gospel that justifies the ungodly freely, for Christ’s sake, through faith. Keep that distinction clear, here and in every book to come. Let the Law accuse fully, so that the “But now” of free grace lands as it landed on Luther — as the very gate of paradise. And let your people walk out, justified and unafraid, to live by grace, in love, to the glory of God alone. Soli Deo Gloria.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
Scripture quotations marked NIV are taken from the Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.™ Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.