Studies · Bible Studies

1 Samuel — A Lutheran Leader's Guide

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Soli Deo Gloria

First Samuel is the book of the turning of an age. It opens with a barren woman weeping at the door of a shrine and closes with a rejected king falling on his own sword on Mount Gilboa. Between those two scenes Israel passes from the broken, leaderless days of the judges into the age of the monarchy — and the LORD, who alone is Israel’s true King, bends even Israel’s faithless demand for a king “like all the nations” toward his own purpose: the line of David, and through David the King who is to come. The book gives us Hannah’s song, the boy Samuel hearing his name in the night, the ark captured and the glory departed, the people’s fateful “give us a king,” the tall and tragic figure of Saul, and the shepherd boy anointed because “the LORD looks on the heart.” It is a book about who reigns, about grace that lifts up the lowly and brings down the proud, and about the difference between the king men want and the king God gives. This guide leans on Luther — above all his Commentary on the Magnificat (LW 21), where he expounds the very theology of reversal that Hannah sings — on Melanchthon’s Loci and Chemnitz, and on the Book of Concord, so that you can teach 1 Samuel the way the Reformers read the Old Testament: as Law and Gospel, and as a book full of Christ.

How to use this guide

This is a leader’s guide. It is written for you, the one preparing to teach — pastor, deacon, or lay leader. Nothing here is handed out. The only thing your people need open in front of them is the Bible. The guide is built as seven one-hour sessions that together cover the whole book:

  1. Hannah’s prayer, the birth of Samuel, and the call in the night (1–3)
  2. The ark captured and returned: “Ichabod,” and the glory departed (4–7)
  3. “Give us a king”: Israel rejects the LORD’s kingship; Saul anointed (8–10)
  4. Saul’s early reign: the unlawful sacrifice and the rash oath (11–14)
  5. “To obey is better than sacrifice”: Saul rejected, David anointed (15–16)
  6. David and Goliath; David and Jonathan; Saul’s jealousy (17–20)
  7. David the fugitive: sparing Saul, and the medium of Endor (21–31)

Each session has five parts in fixed order: a Leader’s preparation note, Opening Questions, Congregational Study (the teaching body), Closing Questions, and a Closing Prayer. Read the whole passage and the preparation note before the hour. The early chapters (Hannah, Samuel, the ark) move slowly and richly; the long final stretch of David’s wilderness years (21–31) you will teach by selected scenes, not verse by verse. ESV is the default translation; other versions are noted where they serve the point.


A Lutheran orientation to 1 Samuel

First Samuel is the book of the true King and the kings of men. Lutherans read the Old Testament forward, toward Christ, because the New Testament reads it that way (Luke 24:27; John 5:46). The deep question running under every chapter of 1 Samuel is who reigns? — and the answer the book labors to teach is that the LORD alone is King, that the kings Israel sets up are at best his servants and at worst his rivals, and that the only king who will finally do, the king “after God’s own heart,” is given by grace and points beyond himself to “great David’s greater Son” (Matt. 1:1; 22:42–45).

Law and Gospel. The Law in 1 Samuel exposes the heart again and again. It thunders against Eli’s weak indulgence of his sons, against Israel’s superstition in carrying the ark into battle as a talisman, against the people’s craving to be “like all the nations,” against Saul’s self-willed sacrifice and his partial obedience. “To obey is better than sacrifice” (15:22) is Law in its sharpest edge — a word that does not first hand us a program of self-improvement but lays bare a heart that will not simply trust and obey, and so drives us to the One who obeyed in our place. The Gospel sounds first and clearest in Hannah’s song (2:1–10): the God who “kills and brings to life,” who “raises up the poor from the dust,” who “brings low and he exalts” — the God of the great reversal, who saves not the strong and the deserving but the empty and the lowly. To teach 1 Samuel as a Lutheran is to keep asking of every passage: where does this accuse, and where does this lift up the humbled sinner by sheer grace?

Christ in 1 Samuel. The book is full of him. Hannah’s song is the Old Testament Magnificat; Mary will take it up almost line for line (compare 1 Sam. 2:1–10 with Luke 1:46–55), and Luther’s Commentary on the Magnificat is, in effect, a commentary on Hannah’s theology too. Samuel is prophet, priest, and judge — a foreshadowing of the threefold office. Above all the book gives us David, the anointed one (Hebrew mashiach, “anointed”; in Greek Christos), the shepherd-king chosen not for his appearance but by grace, hunted and rejected before he reigns — and the whole New Testament will name Jesus “Son of David” and “the Lord’s Anointed.” When you teach 1 Samuel you are watching God lay the cornerstone of the messianic promise.

The Confessions and 1 Samuel. The book touches confessional doctrine at several points. The institution of kingship and civil government is read in light of the Lutheran doctrine of the two kingdoms and the good order of temporal authority (AC XVI). “The LORD looks on the heart” (16:7) preaches that God receives a person by grace, not by outward appearance or merit (AC IV; Ap IV). And the departure of the Spirit from Saul (16:14), together with his rejection, is a sobering text on the loss of grace — the very point the Augsburg Confession defends when it condemns those “who deny that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost” (AC XII). When you teach 1 Samuel you are teaching the Confessions in narrative.

A pastoral word before you begin. This book is heavy with judgment — a dynasty cut off, a king rejected, a battlefield strewn with the dead. Do not flinch from the Law in it. But keep your eye on the thread of grace that runs the whole length: God hears the barren and the brokenhearted, lifts up the lowly, chooses the unlikely youngest son, and keeps his promise to send a King who will not fail. That King is Christ, and he is the reason 1 Samuel is good news.


Session 1 — Hannah’s Prayer, the Birth of Samuel, and the Call in the Night (1–3)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 1–3 slowly, and alongside it Luke 1:46–55 (the Magnificat) and the opening of Luther’s Commentary on the Magnificat (LW 21) on “he has regarded the low estate of his handmaiden.” The center of gravity for this hour is the God who hears the lowly and reverses their condition by grace — Hannah’s song (2:1–10) as the Old Testament Magnificat. Resist the temptation to make this only a session about prayer and parenting (though both are here). The heart of the chapter is theological: the God who shuts and opens the womb, who “kills and brings to life,” who “brings low and he exalts,” and who is already, in 2:10, looking ahead to “his king… his anointed.” Plan your time so Hannah’s song gets a full share. End with the boy Samuel hearing his name in the night — grace calling a child while the established priesthood is falling under judgment.

Opening Questions

  • Hannah was barren and bitterly provoked for it (1:6–7). Have you ever brought God a grief you could not fix yourself? What did you do with it?
  • When Eli sees Hannah praying, he assumes she’s drunk (1:13–14). What does it tell you that even the priest misjudged a praying woman?
  • Read Hannah’s song (2:1–10) aloud. It is not mostly about her baby — what is it actually about?
  • The book opens with a faithful praying mother and a corrupt priestly household (Eli’s sons, 2:12). Why might Scripture set those two side by side?

Congregational Study

Hannah’s grief and prayer (ch. 1). Begin with the picture: Elkanah has two wives, and Hannah, the loved one, is barren, while Peninnah, who has children, provokes her year after year. Barrenness in Israel was not merely private sorrow; it felt like exclusion from the promise. Hannah does the right thing with her bitterness — she takes it to the LORD at Shiloh, weeping and praying so intensely that Eli mistakes her for a drunk (1:13). Note the shape of her prayer: she pours out her soul, she vows the child to the LORD (the Nazirite vow, 1:11), and she goes away — before any answer is given — and “her face was no longer sad” (1:18, ESV). Teach this as a small picture of faith: she is comforted by the promise and the hearing, not by the having. In time the LORD “remembered her” (1:19) and Samuel is born; his name is tied to her asking (“heard of God” / “asked of God”). And she keeps her vow, weaning him and bringing him to the house of the LORD: “For this child I prayed, and the LORD has granted me my petition that I made to him. Therefore I have lent him to the LORD” (1:27–28). The gift is received and given back.

Hannah’s song — the Old Testament Magnificat (2:1–10). This is the theological summit of the session; slow down. Hannah does not sing about her baby; she sings about her God, and what she sings is the whole gospel of reversal:

  • “My heart exults in the LORD… because I rejoice in your salvation” (2:1). Like Mary after her, Hannah rejoices not in herself but in the God who saves.
  • “The LORD kills and brings to life; he brings down to Sheol and raises up. The LORD makes poor and makes rich; he brings low and he exalts. He raises up the poor from the dust; he lifts the needy from the ash heap” (2:6–8). Here is the God who works by reversal — bringing low and lifting up. This is not random fortune; it is the way the God of grace deals with sinners. He empties the full and fills the empty.
  • “He will give strength to his king and exalt the horn of his anointed” (2:10). Mark this carefully: at the very opening of the book, before there is any king in Israel, Hannah’s Spirit-given song already looks ahead to the king, the anointed — Hebrew mashiach. The whole book is bending toward the LORD’s Anointed even now.

Now make the Magnificat connection explicit, because it is the doctrinal heart of the hour. Set Hannah’s song beside Mary’s (Luke 1:46–55) and let your people see how Mary takes up Hannah’s very theology: “He has brought down the mighty from their thrones and exalted those of humble estate; he has filled the hungry with good things, and the rich he has sent away empty” (Luke 1:52–53). Two women — one barren, one a virgin, both lowly, both passed over by the world’s reckoning — sing the same song because they have met the same God. Luther catches the heart of it in his Commentary on the Magnificat. Expounding “he has regarded the low estate of his handmaiden,” he insists the stress falls not on the lowliness but on God’s regarding it: “when a prince gives his hand to a beggar, the meanness of the beggar is not to be praised, but the graciousness and goodness of the prince” (Luther, Commentary on the Magnificat, LW 21). Apply it to Hannah: her emptiness earns her nothing; God’s gracious regard is everything. That is the doctrine of grace in a sentence — and it is why this song belongs at the head of a book about who truly reigns. The God who lifts the barren woman is the God who will lift Israel by giving a King, and finally the God who lifts the whole sinful race in Christ.

The wickedness of Eli’s sons, and the judgment announced (2:11–36). Against Hannah’s faithfulness, Scripture sets the corruption of the priesthood. Eli’s sons, Hophni and Phinehas, are “worthless men” who “did not know the LORD” (2:12) — they steal the offerings and defile the worship, and Eli, though he rebukes them feebly, is charged with honoring his sons “above me” (2:29). A man of God announces the judgment: this priestly house will be cut off, and God will “raise up for myself a faithful priest, who shall do according to what is in my heart and in my mind” (2:35). Teach the Law here plainly: God will not be mocked, and privilege (even priestly privilege) is no shield against judgment when the heart is far from him. And note the gospel undertone — the promise of “a faithful priest… according to what is in my heart” reaches past Samuel and Zadok toward the one true and faithful High Priest, Christ (Heb. 7:23–28).

The call of Samuel (ch. 3). “The word of the LORD was rare in those days; there was no frequent vision” (3:1). Into that silence, while the boy is sleeping near the ark, the LORD calls his name. Three times Samuel runs to Eli; the third time the old priest discerns it is the LORD and teaches the child to answer, “Speak, LORD, for your servant hears” (3:9). Teach two things. First, the tender grace of it: God calls a child by name and gives him his word, while the established, hereditary priesthood is under sentence — grace raises up the lowly and unlikely, exactly as Hannah sang. Second, the hard word: the first message Samuel must carry is the confirmation of judgment on Eli’s house (3:11–14), and Eli receives it with sober submission (“It is the LORD. Let him do what seems good to him,” 3:18). Samuel grows, “and the LORD was with him” (3:19); all Israel comes to know he is “established as a prophet of the LORD” (3:20).

Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: God’s judgment falls on the proud and the careless — on Peninnah’s cruelty, on Eli’s compromised house, on a priesthood that despised the LORD. The Gospel: the same God hears the weeping of a barren woman, fills the empty, raises the lowly from the dust, calls a child by name in the dark, and is already pointing — in Hannah’s own song — toward his Anointed King. The God of the reversal is the God of grace.

Closing Questions

  • Hannah’s face changed before she had the child — comforted by the promise, not the having. Where do you need to rest in God’s promise before you can see the answer?
  • Luther says the praise belongs not to the beggar’s poverty but to the prince’s kindness. Where are you still tempted to think God regards you because of something in you, rather than purely by his grace?
  • “He brings low and he exalts… he raises up the poor from the dust.” Are you coming to God full of yourself, or empty? Which one does he lift up?
  • God called Samuel by name in the night. Where this week will you be near the Word, ready to say, “Speak, LORD, for your servant hears”?

Closing Prayer

Almighty God, you hear the cry of the barren and the brokenhearted, you bring low and you lift up, and you regard the lowly not for any worth in them but for the sake of your own grace. We confess that we come to you empty, with nothing to plead. Fill us with the good things of your mercy, raise us from the dust, and let us, with Hannah and with Mary, rejoice in God our Savior; through Jesus Christ, your Anointed King, our Lord. Amen.


Session 2 — The Ark Captured and Returned: “Ichabod,” and the Glory Departed (4–7)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 4–7. The unifying thread is the holiness of God and the folly of treating him as a thing to be used. Read alongside Exodus 25:22 (the ark as the place of God’s presence), Psalm 78:56–64 (which retells these chapters), and the First and Second Commandments with their explanations in the Small Catechism. The center of gravity: Israel carries the ark into battle as a good-luck charm and is crushed; the glory departs (“Ichabod”); God defends his own honor among the Philistines without any help from Israel; and at last, under Samuel’s call to repentance, the people put away their idols and are delivered. This is a sharp lesson in the difference between superstition and faith — and a quiet gospel: God’s glory, once departed, returns to a repentant people. Be ready to handle the deaths in these chapters (Eli’s sons, Eli, the men of Beth Shemesh) without softening God’s holiness or hardening his mercy.

Opening Questions

  • When Israel is losing the battle, they fetch the ark from Shiloh, expecting it to save them (4:3). What’s the difference between that and faith in God?
  • The Philistines put the captured ark in the temple of their god Dagon — and find Dagon fallen and broken before it (5:3–4). What is God doing in a pagan temple with no Israelite anywhere near?
  • Phinehas’s widow names her baby “Ichabod,” meaning “the glory has departed” (4:21–22, ESV). What had Israel lost, really?
  • At Mizpah the people finally “put away” their foreign gods and were delivered (7:3–4). Why does deliverance follow repentance and not the other way around?

Congregational Study

The ark used as a talisman (ch. 4). Israel is defeated by the Philistines, and the elders reason: “Let us bring the ark of the covenant of the LORD here from Shiloh, that it may come among us and save us” (4:3). Mark the theology carefully. The ark was the throne of God’s presence (Exod. 25:22), but it was never a magic object that could be wielded apart from the God who claimed his people’s hearts. Israel treats it as a charm — they shout when it arrives (4:5), and Hophni and Phinehas, the corrupt priests, carry it. The result is catastrophe: Israel is routed, the ark is captured, and Eli’s two sons are killed in one day (4:10–11). When Eli hears, he falls and dies (4:18); his daughter-in-law, dying in childbirth, names the baby Ichabod — Hebrew ‘i-kabod, “no glory” or “Where is the glory?” — saying, “The glory has departed from Israel, for the ark of God has been captured” (4:21–22). Teach this as Law against superstition: God will not be reduced to a tool for our purposes. To possess the right objects, the right rituals, even the right religion, while the heart despises the LORD, is not faith but idolatry — a violation of the First Commandment (“You shall have no other gods”) and the Second (not to misuse his name). Press your people gently: we can do the same with the sacraments, the Bible, the cross around the neck — treating holy things as charms while the heart goes its own way.

God defends his own glory (chs. 5–6). Now watch what God does with no Israelite to help him. The Philistines set the ark in the temple of Dagon; in the morning Dagon has fallen face-down before it, and the next morning Dagon’s head and hands are broken off on the threshold (5:3–4). The LORD afflicts the Philistine cities with tumors and panic, and the ark becomes too hot to handle; it is passed from city to city like a live coal until the Philistines beg to send it back. Make the point: God’s glory was never actually at risk. He needs no army, no priest, no Israel to vindicate his honor; he humbles a false god in its own house. This is comfort for your people — the cause of God does not finally depend on us — and it is also a rebuke to the presumption that we manage or protect God. The Philistines, by pagan instinct, send the ark home with a guilt offering (6:3–9), and even the cows, against nature, carry it straight back to Israel. Then a sobering scene: at Beth Shemesh, men look into the ark and are struck down (6:19), and the people cry, “Who is able to stand before the LORD, this holy God?” (6:20). The God who is gracious is also holy; familiarity is not the same as faith.

Repentance and deliverance at Mizpah (ch. 7). The ark comes to rest at Kiriath Jearim, and for twenty years Israel mourns and seeks the LORD. Then Samuel calls the nation to genuine repentance: “If you are returning to the LORD with all your heart, then put away the foreign gods… and direct your heart to the LORD and serve him only, and he will deliver you” (7:3). They put away the Baals and the Ashtaroth, fast, confess, “We have sinned against the LORD” (7:6), and Samuel intercedes for them. When the Philistines attack, the LORD himself thunders against them and routs them; Samuel sets up a stone and names it Ebenezer, “Till now the LORD has helped us” (7:12). Teach the order plainly, for it is the heart of the chapter: the deliverance comes after repentance and through the LORD’s own act, not through Israel’s military strength or their possession of holy hardware. Where chapter 4 shows religion-as-magic and ends in catastrophe, chapter 7 shows repentance and faith and ends in salvation.

Where traditions differ — Holy things, sacraments, and superstition. Lutherans confess that God truly attaches his presence and his grace to physical means — water, bread and wine, the spoken word — so that baptism “now saves” and the Supper truly gives Christ’s body and blood. But that is the opposite of treating holy things as charms: the means of grace work because of God’s word and promise attached to them, received in faith, not as objects we manipulate to get results. The ark in chapter 4, carried into battle without faith or repentance, is precisely the abuse the Lutheran Confessions warn against in teaching that the sacraments are not effective ex opere operato in the sense of a mechanical, faithless rite (Ap XIII; AC XIII). Roman Catholic sacramental theology, rightly understood, also rejects mere superstition, but the older popular piety of relics and objects often drifted toward the talismanic — a drift the Reformers attacked. Reformed and many evangelical traditions guard so hard against superstition that they tend to empty the means of grace of God’s actual giving, reducing them to symbols. The Lutheran path is the narrow one: God really gives himself through his appointed means — and precisely for that reason they dare never be used as magic apart from his word and faith.

Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: God is holy and will not be used; superstition, presumption, and a divided heart bring the glory’s departure and judgment even on the people who carry his name. The Gospel: God defends his own honor without our help, and to a repentant people the glory returns and the LORD himself fights for them — “Till now the LORD has helped us.” The Ebenezer is grace, not reward.

Closing Questions

  • Israel carried the right object into battle with the wrong heart. Where are you tempted to trust religious things — church attendance, a Bible on the shelf, the sacraments treated mechanically — while your heart goes its own way?
  • “Ichabod — the glory has departed.” What would it mean for the glory to depart from a person, a family, a congregation today?
  • God toppled Dagon with no Israelite in the room. Where do you need to rest in the fact that God’s cause does not finally depend on you?
  • Deliverance came only after Israel put away its idols. Is there an idol the Lord is calling you to “put away” before you can know his help?

Closing Prayer

Holy Lord God, you will not be used or managed, and the glory is yours alone. Forgive us for trusting in holy things while our hearts wandered, and for treating your gifts as charms. Topple every idol in us, return your glory to your people, and let us say with grateful hearts, “Till now the LORD has helped us.” Fight for us, O Lord, and deliver us; through Jesus Christ, in whom your glory has come to dwell among us. Amen.


Session 3 — “Give Us a King”: Israel Rejects the LORD’s Kingship; Saul Anointed (8–10)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 8–10, with particular care on 8:4–22 (the demand for a king and the LORD’s response), 9 (Saul found while seeking lost donkeys), and 10:1, 9–24 (Saul anointed and presented). Read alongside Deuteronomy 17:14–20 (the law of the king, which anticipates this), 1 Samuel 12 (Samuel’s farewell, which reflects on it), and AC XVI (Of Civil Affairs) on the two kingdoms. The center of gravity: Israel’s demand for a king “like all the nations” is at bottom a rejection of God’s own kingship (8:7) — and yet God, without excusing the sin, works even through it toward his purposes. This is the great two-kingdoms text of the book; prepare to teach the Lutheran understanding of civil government as God’s good order even when it is sought sinfully. Note the irony you will build the hour on: God gives them what they ask, and it is both a gift and a judgment.

Opening Questions

  • Israel asks for a king so they can be “like all the nations” (8:5, 20, ESV). What’s wrong with wanting to be like everyone else?
  • God tells Samuel, “they have not rejected you, but they have rejected me from being king over them” (8:7). How can asking for a king be rejecting God?
  • Samuel warns them exactly what a king will take (8:11–18) — and they want one anyway. Why do people choose something they’ve been warned will cost them?
  • Saul is found while looking for lost donkeys, hiding among the baggage at his coronation (9:3; 10:22). What kind of king is being set up here?

Congregational Study

The demand for a king (8:1–9). Samuel is old, and his sons, like Eli’s before them, are corrupt judges who “turned aside after gain” (8:3). So the elders come with a request: “appoint for us a king to judge us like all the nations” (8:5). On its face the request even has a basis — Deuteronomy 17 had anticipated a king, and Samuel’s sons really were unfit. But the LORD names the sin underneath it: “they have not rejected you, but they have rejected me from being king over them. According to all the deeds that they have done, from the day I brought them up out of Egypt even to this day… so they are also doing to you” (8:7–8). Teach the heart of it: the sin is not that Israel wants order or leadership, but that they want to be “like all the nations” (8:20) — to trade the invisible kingship of the LORD, who fights for them and to whom they must cling in faith, for a visible king they can see and follow into battle like everyone else. It is the craving to be like the world, to walk by sight rather than by faith. And it is, at root, unbelief: they no longer trust the LORD to be their King. Yet — and this is crucial — God says, “Obey their voice and make them a king” (8:22). He grants the request. The sin is real, and the gift is real, and both are true at once.

Samuel’s warning: the ways of a king (8:10–22). Samuel lays out plainly what a king will do: he will take — sons for his armies, daughters for his service, fields and flocks and a tenth of everything; “you shall be his slaves” (8:17). “And in that day you will cry out because of your king, whom you have chosen for yourselves, but the LORD will not answer you in that day” (8:18). Teach this as Law that exposes the heart: they are told the cost in advance and choose it anyway, because the deeper hunger is not for good government but for conformity to the world. Note for your people the painful realism: God often lets us have what we insist on, and the having of it becomes its own discipline.

Where traditions differ — Kingship, civil government, and the two kingdoms. This is the central denominational flashpoint of the book; teach it with care. The Lutheran doctrine of the two kingdoms holds that God rules the world in two ways: by the Gospel, through the church, granting forgiveness and eternal righteousness; and by the Law and temporal authority, through civil government, restraining evil and preserving order. The Augsburg Confession states it directly: “lawful civil ordinances are good works of God,” and it is right for Christians to hold office, to judge, to punish justly, to serve as soldiers, and to obey magistrates — condemning the Anabaptists “who forbid these civil offices to Christians” (AC XVI). So the Lutheran reading of 1 Samuel 8 makes a careful double move: government itself is God’s good order (Rom. 13:1–7), even the monarchy God is about to grant — yet Israel’s demand for it sprang from unbelief, from the desire to replace trust in God with conformity to the nations. God can give a genuinely good gift (ordered authority) in answer to a sinful request, and judge the sin even while bestowing the gift. Contrast two errors. Theocratic readings (in various Reformed-influenced and modern political-theology forms) tend to collapse the two kingdoms, treating the civil order as itself the kingdom of God to be built. At the opposite pole, anti-government and certain Anabaptist/separatist readings treat 1 Samuel 8 as a wholesale condemnation of human government as such, so that the faithful should withdraw from civil life altogether — which AC XVI explicitly rejects. The Lutheran line to hold: human government is God’s gift and God’s mask (larva Dei) for governing the world, to be honored and served in our callings; but it is never our salvation, and the craving to be “like all the nations” instead of trusting God is sin. Keep the two kingdoms distinct and you can both honor the king God gives and refuse to make a king into a god.

Saul found and anointed (chs. 9–10). Now the narrative turns almost comic, and the comedy is theological. Saul, a tall and handsome young man — “taller than any of the people” (9:2) — is out looking for his father’s lost donkeys, and stumbles into the prophet Samuel, who has been told by the LORD that this is the man. Samuel anoints him privately with oil: “Has not the LORD anointed you to be prince over his people Israel?” (10:1). Note the word: Saul is now the LORD’s anointed, Hebrew mashiach. The Spirit of God rushes upon him, and “God gave him another heart” (10:9); he prophesies among the prophets, so that people marvel, “Is Saul also among the prophets?” (10:11). All the outward signs are favorable. But hold a thread for the next sessions: this is the king the people wanted — tall, impressive, the kind of man the nations would follow. The public presentation underlines it: when Samuel casts lots and Saul is chosen, he cannot be found — he has “hidden himself among the baggage” (10:22) — and when they haul him out, he stands head and shoulders above everyone, and Samuel says, “Do you see him whom the LORD has chosen? There is none like him among all the people” (10:24). The people shout, “Long live the king!” Teach the irony you will need in Session 5: everything commends Saul by appearance. He looks every inch a king. Whether his heart will trust and obey the true King is the question the rest of the book will answer — and it is exactly the question 16:7 (“the LORD looks on the heart”) will throw back at us.

Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: the craving to be “like all the nations,” to walk by sight and replace trust in God with the securities of the world, is a rejection of God’s own kingship — and we do it constantly. The Gospel: God is not defeated by Israel’s unbelief; he takes their faithless demand and bends it toward his own purpose, for the monarchy he now permits will become the channel of the promise to David, and through David to the King who will reign forever and never disappoint his people (Luke 1:32–33).

Closing Questions

  • Israel wanted to be “like all the nations.” Where are you most tempted to measure your life by the world’s standard rather than trust God to be enough?
  • Samuel warned them a king would take, take, take — and they wanted him anyway. What are you tempted to choose even though you’ve been warned what it will cost?
  • Government is God’s good gift and also something we can idolize. How do you honor earthly authority without ever letting it take the place of God?
  • God gave Israel a king in answer to a sinful request, and still worked his purpose through it. Where do you need to trust that God can bring good even out of what you’ve gotten wrong?

Closing Prayer

O Lord, our true King, we confess that like Israel of old we crave to be like the world, to walk by sight, and to trust in what we can see rather than in you. Forgive us for setting up kings in your place. Rule over us by your grace, order our common life by your good gifts of government and calling, and keep us trusting in you alone, until the King who reigns forever, your Son Jesus Christ, comes in his glory. Amen.


Session 4 — Saul’s Early Reign: The Unlawful Sacrifice and the Rash Oath (11–14)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 11–14. Cover Saul’s deliverance of Jabesh Gilead (11), Samuel’s farewell address (12), Saul’s unlawful sacrifice at Gilgal (13:1–14), the Philistine threat and Jonathan’s faith (13:16–14:23), and Saul’s rash oath and its near-fatal cost to Jonathan (14:24–46). This is a large block; teach by the key scenes, giving most weight to chapter 13 (the unlawful sacrifice) and the contrast it sets up between Saul and his son Jonathan. The center of gravity: Saul begins well, but his reign quickly reveals the fatal flaw — a king who will not simply trust and obey the LORD, who acts on his own terms when pressed, and who binds himself and his people with rash religion. This session lays the groundwork for the formal rejection in Session 5. Read Samuel’s chapter 12 carefully: it is the theological hinge, where Samuel both rebukes the sin of wanting a king and holds out grace if king and people will fear the LORD.

Opening Questions

  • Saul’s first act as king is a real victory — he rescues Jabesh Gilead (11). What does he do right here, and where does he give the credit (11:13)?
  • In chapter 12 Samuel makes Israel admit that asking for a king was a sin — and then says, “do not be afraid” (12:20, ESV). Why both?
  • At Gilgal, Saul gets tired of waiting for Samuel and offers the sacrifice himself (13:8–9). It seems so small. Why does Samuel treat it as so serious?
  • Saul makes his army swear not to eat until evening, and it nearly costs his son Jonathan’s life (14:24–45). What’s wrong with a vow like that?

Congregational Study

A good beginning: Jabesh Gilead and Samuel’s farewell (chs. 11–12). Saul starts well. When the Ammonites threaten Jabesh Gilead, the Spirit of God rushes upon Saul, he rallies Israel, and wins a great deliverance (11:6–11). To his credit, when some want to execute those who had earlier doubted him, Saul refuses and gives God the glory: “today the LORD has worked salvation in Israel” (11:13). Then comes Samuel’s farewell (ch. 12), the theological hinge of this whole stretch. Samuel first clears his own name (he has taken from no one, 12:3–4), then rehearses the LORD’s saving history, and brings Israel to confess that in asking for a king “we have added to all our sins this evil, to ask for ourselves a king” (12:19). But notice how Samuel preaches Law and Gospel together. He does not leave them in despair: “Do not be afraid… Yet do not turn aside from following the LORD, but serve the LORD with all your heart… For the LORD will not forsake his people, for his great name’s sake, because it has pleased the LORD to make you a people for himself” (12:20–22). Teach this as the gospel pattern: the sin is named honestly, and the people are not cast off, because the LORD’s faithfulness rests on his own name and good pleasure, not on their worthiness. Samuel pledges to keep praying for them — “far be it from me that I should sin against the LORD by ceasing to pray for you” (12:23) — and calls them to fear and serve the LORD. The monarchy begins, then, under both a verdict and a promise.

The unlawful sacrifice (13:1–14). Now the flaw begins to show. Facing a massive Philistine force, with his army melting away in fear and Samuel not yet arrived at the appointed time, Saul grows impatient and offers the burnt offering himself (13:9). The moment he finishes, Samuel arrives, and his verdict is severe: “You have done foolishly. You have not kept the command of the LORD your God, with which he commanded you… But now your kingdom shall not continue. The LORD has sought out a man after his own heart” (13:13–14). Your people will feel this is harsh — it was just one sacrifice, and under real pressure. Help them see what was actually exposed. Saul’s sin was not a ritual technicality; it was the revelation of a heart that would not wait on and trust the LORD’s word when waiting was hard. He took matters into his own hands, justified himself afterward (“I forced myself,” 13:12), and acted as if the outward act of sacrifice could secure God’s favor apart from obedient faith. This is the same disease as the ark-as-talisman in chapter 4: religion as management, rather than trust. And here, for the first time, the contrast is named: the LORD has sought “a man after his own heart” (13:14) — pointing ahead to David (and ultimately to Christ). Saul is the king of appearances; the coming king will be a king of the heart.

Jonathan’s faith and Saul’s rash oath (13:16–14:46). Set Saul beside his son Jonathan, and the contrast preaches. Jonathan, with only his armor-bearer, climbs against a Philistine garrison on a magnificent confession of faith: “Nothing can hinder the LORD from saving by many or by few” (14:6). Here is true faith — resting everything on what the LORD can do, regardless of the odds. God gives a great victory. But Saul, even amid the triumph, binds the army with a rash oath: a curse on anyone who eats before evening (14:24). The oath exhausts the troops, leads them into sin (eating meat with the blood, 14:32–33), and nearly costs the life of Jonathan, who had not heard the oath and ate a little honey. Saul is even prepared to execute his own son to keep his vow, until the people ransom Jonathan (14:45). Teach this as a portrait of a man whose religion has become self-willed and harsh — quick to bind others, slow to obey God himself. Rash vows, here, are not piety but folly; they entangle the conscience and dishonor God. (You may note Luther’s pastoral concern, voiced often in his teaching on the Catechism and on monastic vows, that vows undertaken presumptuously become snares rather than service.)

Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: Saul shows us a heart that will not wait on God, that grasps at religious acts to secure its own footing, and that binds others with harsh demands while failing to obey — and that heart is in all of us. The Gospel: even as Saul falls, the LORD is already seeking “a man after his own heart,” and Samuel preaches to a guilty people that the LORD “will not forsake his people, for his great name’s sake.” God’s faithfulness rests on his own name, not on the success of our kings or the steadiness of our hearts — which is why, when our Saul-like hearts fail, there is still hope in the King God himself provides.

Closing Questions

  • Saul couldn’t wait, so he took God’s work into his own hands. Where are you tempted to “force the issue” rather than wait on the Lord when waiting is hard?
  • Jonathan said, “Nothing can hinder the LORD from saving by many or by few.” Where do you need that confidence this week — and where are you counting the odds instead?
  • Samuel told a guilty people, “Do not be afraid… the LORD will not forsake his people.” How is that gospel for you when you have to admit your own sin honestly?
  • Saul’s rash oath bound others and dishonored God. Have you ever made a “religious” commitment that became a snare? What does true obedience look like instead?

Closing Prayer

Lord God, you do not need our many or our few, for you save as you please; and you are not honored by religion that will not trust and wait on you. Forgive us when, like Saul, we grasp control and bind ourselves and others with rash and faithless vows. Give us the faith of Jonathan, who knew that nothing can hinder you from saving, and keep us resting on your faithfulness to your own great name; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.


Session 5 — “To Obey Is Better Than Sacrifice”: Saul Rejected, David Anointed (15–16)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 15–16. This is one of the most important sessions in the guide. Cover Saul’s incomplete obedience against the Amalekites and his formal rejection (15), the great word “to obey is better than sacrifice” (15:22, ESV), Samuel’s grief, the anointing of David and “the LORD looks on the heart” (16:7), and the departing of the Spirit from Saul (16:14). Read alongside AC IV / Ap IV (justification by grace, not appearance or merit), AC XII (on the loss of grace), and FC/SD XI (election). The center of gravity, doctrinally, is threefold: (1) “to obey is better than sacrifice” read as Law that exposes the heart and drives to Christ — not as works-righteousness; (2) David chosen by grace, not appearance — “the LORD looks on the heart”; and (3) the sobering departure of the Spirit from Saul. Plan your time carefully; each of the three deserves real attention. This is where the book’s whole contrast — Saul the king men wanted versus David the king God chose — comes to a head.

Opening Questions

  • Saul keeps the best of the Amalekite plunder and says he saved it to sacrifice to the LORD (15:15, 21). Does that sound pious or self-serving to you — and how can you tell?
  • “To obey is better than sacrifice” (15:22). Is that a command telling us to try harder, or does it expose something about the heart? (Hold the question.)
  • Samuel looks at David’s tall, impressive older brother and assumes he’s the one — and God corrects him (16:6–7). When have you judged by appearances and gotten it wrong?
  • “Now the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul” (16:14). What is the most sobering thing about that sentence?

Congregational Study

Saul’s partial obedience and rejection (15:1–35). Saul is commanded to carry out the LORD’s judgment on the Amalekites completely; instead he spares King Agag and the best of the livestock, destroying only “all that was despised and worthless” (15:9). When Samuel confronts him, Saul protests that he did obey — and then blames the people and claims the spared animals were for sacrifice (15:13–21). Here Samuel speaks the great word, and you must teach it precisely:

“Has the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to listen than the fat of rams. For rebellion is as the sin of divination, and presumption is as iniquity and idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of the LORD, he has also rejected you from being king” (15:22–23).

Now guard the doctrine, because this verse is constantly misused. “To obey is better than sacrifice” is not a charter for works-righteousness — as though Saul (or we) could earn God’s favor by trying harder, by perfect performance instead of religious ritual. Read it as Law in its accusing use, and watch what it exposes. Saul’s offer of sacrifice was an attempt to cover disobedience with religion — to keep what God said to destroy, and then buy God off with the leftovers as worship. The Law here strips away that whole maneuver: God is not impressed by sacrifices offered by a heart that will not simply trust and obey him. And the moment you press the verse honestly, it convicts not only Saul but every one of us — for who has rendered God the obedience of the heart? The verse therefore does not leave us with a self-help program; it drives us to despair of our own obedience and to the One who did obey perfectly in our place. The “obedience better than sacrifice” that finally avails before God is the obedience of Christ, the second Adam, who “humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross” (Phil. 2:8) and whose obedience is credited to us by faith (Rom. 5:19). Teach it this way and the Law does its proper work: it accuses, it kills our self-justifying religion, and it sends us to Christ. (Note for your people that Samuel still grieves over Saul, and “the LORD regretted that he had made Saul king” (15:35) — an anthropomorphism describing God’s genuine sorrow over sin, not a change in God’s eternal counsel; FC/SD XI guards us against reading God as fickle.)

David anointed — “the LORD looks on the heart” (16:1–13). Now the great turn, and the doctrinal center of the hour. Samuel is sent to Bethlehem to anoint one of Jesse’s sons. He sees the eldest, Eliab — tall, impressive, the very picture of a king (the Saul-type all over again) — and thinks, “Surely the LORD’s anointed is before him” (16:6). And God corrects him with one of the most important sentences in the Old Testament: “Do not look on his appearance or on the height of his stature… For the LORD sees not as man sees: man looks on the outward appearance, but the LORD looks on the heart” (16:7). One by one, seven sons pass and are rejected, until the youngest, David, is summoned in from the sheep — overlooked, not even invited to the feast — and the LORD says, “Arise, anoint him, for this is he” (16:12). Samuel anoints him, “And the Spirit of the LORD rushed upon David from that day forward” (16:13).

Teach the grace of this. David is chosen not because he is the obvious candidate — he is the least obvious, the forgotten youngest, out with the sheep. Where Saul was the king men would choose by sight (tall, a head above the rest, 9:2; 10:23), David is the king God chooses by grace, looking past appearance to the heart. Make the justification connection explicit: this is exactly how God receives a sinner. He does not weigh our outward credentials, our impressiveness, our record; he justifies the ungodly by grace, for Christ’s sake, received through faith (AC IV; Rom. 4:5). “The LORD looks on the heart” is, at the deepest level, good news — because it means God is not put off by our unimpressiveness, our lowliness, our being overlooked by the world. He chose David; he chooses you; and in both cases the ground is his grace, not our appearance or merit. (Be careful, too, not to let “the heart” become a new work — as if David earned his choosing by having a good heart. David’s heart is not sinless; later chapters prove that. The point is that God’s choice rests on his own gracious purpose, and he looks past the things that men prize.)

Where traditions differ — Grace and election versus merit and appearance. Lutherans confess that God receives and elects sinners by grace alone, for Christ’s sake, apart from any worthiness, foreseen merit, or outward qualification (AC IV; Ap IV; FC/SD XI), and that this election is pure comfort, grounded in Christ. “The LORD looks on the heart” cuts against every religion of appearance and performance. The Roman Catholic tradition affirms that all is by grace, but historically frames justification as God making the sinner inwardly righteous by infused grace cooperating with works; the Lutheran confession is that justification is God’s free forensic declaration, received by faith. Arminian and much evangelical theology tends to ground God’s reception of a person in foreseen faith or response; high Calvinism grounds it in an unconditional decree but extends that to a symmetrical decree of reprobation. The Lutheran line, as in the next callout, holds election by grace as comfort while refusing to make God the author of anyone’s damnation. For this session the pastoral point is plain: God does not choose David — or you — for the things people look at. He looks on the heart, and what he finds there he himself must create and claim by grace.

The Spirit departs from Saul (16:14). End on the most sobering sentence in the book: “Now the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul, and a harmful spirit from the LORD tormented him” (16:14). The Spirit who had come on Saul at his anointing (10:10) now leaves him. Teach this carefully and pastorally. It is a real and frightening text on the loss of grace: a man who had received the Spirit, who had prophesied, who stood as the LORD’s anointed, persisting in rebellion and self-will, is finally given over. Do not rush past the horror of it, but do not leave your people in terror either. The point of warning is to drive us to cling to Christ and his means of grace, never to presume on past experience while the heart hardens. (On the “harmful spirit from the LORD”: Scripture’s way of confessing that even the spirits of judgment serve God’s sovereign purpose — God sends it as judicial chastisement, without being the author of evil; cf. the careful distinctions in FC/SD XI.)

Where traditions differ — Can a believer fall away? Election and perseverance. The departure of the Spirit from Saul, with his rejection, stands at the center of one of the great divides. The Lutheran confession is that a person who has received the Holy Spirit and true faith can fall away and lose grace through impenitence and persistent unbelief — the Augsburg Confession explicitly condemns those “who deny that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost” (AC XII). Faith is not a possession we hold securely by our own strength; it is sustained by the Spirit through the means of grace, and it can be lost when those are despised. This is why Lutheran preaching always carries both warning (to the secure) and comfort (to the terrified). Calvinism / Reformed theology teaches the perseverance of the saints: the truly elect can never finally fall away, and so reads cases like Saul as showing he was never truly regenerate, only outwardly endowed. Arminian and much Baptist/Wesleyan theology agrees with Lutherans that a believer can fall away, but tends to ground perseverance in the believer’s continued cooperation. The Lutheran path is its own: election to salvation is by grace alone and is sure in Christ (FC/SD XI) — assurance is found by looking to Christ and his promise, not to a decree behind God’s back nor to our own steadfastness — and yet the warnings of Scripture are real, and grace can be lost by those who turn from it. Hold both: comfort the broken with the certainty of Christ; warn the presumptuous with the example of Saul.

Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: “to obey is better than sacrifice” strips away every attempt to cover a disobedient heart with religion, and the Spirit’s departure from Saul warns us that grace can be despised and lost — a word that should drive the secure to their knees. The Gospel: “the LORD looks on the heart” — and so he does not pass over the lowly, the overlooked, the unimpressive; he chooses David out of the sheepfold by sheer grace, as he chooses sinners in Christ, and the anointed shepherd-king he raises up points us to the true Anointed One in whom our election is sure.

Closing Questions

  • Saul tried to cover disobedience with worship. Where are you tempted to offer God religious activity instead of the obedience of simple trust?
  • “To obey is better than sacrifice” — if you take it honestly, does it leave you confident or convicted? Where does that conviction send you?
  • “The LORD looks on the heart.” Is that frightening or comforting to you — and why is it, in the end, good news for someone the world overlooks?
  • The Spirit departed from Saul. How does that warning make you treasure the Word and Sacrament through which the Spirit keeps you in Christ?

Closing Prayer

Lord God, you take no delight in sacrifices from a heart that will not trust you, and you look past all that the world admires to the heart itself. We confess that our obedience fails and our hearts are divided. Cover us, not with our own religion, but with the perfect obedience of your Son. Keep us by your Spirit in the faith, that we may never, like Saul, despise your grace; and assure us that in Christ, your true Anointed, our salvation is secure. Amen.


Session 6 — David and Goliath; David and Jonathan; Saul’s Jealousy (17–20)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 17–20. Cover David and Goliath (17), the covenant friendship of David and Jonathan (18:1–4; 20), Saul’s growing jealousy and his attempts on David’s life (18:5–19:24), and Jonathan’s intercession and warning (20). The center of gravity: the LORD saves “not with sword and spear” through his anointed, who fights the battle his people cannot; and the king men chose curdles into jealousy and murder against the king God chose. Give the lion’s share of the early hour to chapter 17 (Goliath), which is rich with the theology of God’s deliverance through his anointed — and resist the moralizing “face your giants” reading. Then trace the contrast: the noble, self-giving love of Jonathan against the corroding envy of Saul. Read alongside Psalm 18 or Psalm 144 (David’s songs of the LORD as deliverer) if time allows.

Opening Questions

  • Everyone in Israel’s army sees Goliath and is “dismayed and greatly afraid” (17:11, ESV). David sees the same giant and asks who this man is to “defy the armies of the living God” (17:26). What’s the difference in how they’re seeing?
  • David refuses Saul’s armor and goes out with a sling and five stones (17:38–40). Why does that matter to the story’s point?
  • Jonathan, the king’s son and natural heir, loves David and gives him his own robe and sword (18:1–4). What does it cost Jonathan to love the man who will take his throne?
  • Saul’s feelings toward David turn from delight to murderous jealousy almost overnight (18:6–9). What flipped him — and where does jealousy like that come from?

Congregational Study

David and Goliath (ch. 17). This is one of the best-known stories in the Bible and one of the most misused, so teach it with care. The popular reading — “face your giants with courage” — turns the story into Law and puts you in David’s place. But the text puts the emphasis somewhere else entirely: on the LORD. Listen to David’s words. To Goliath’s defiance he answers: “You come to me with a sword and with a spear and with a javelin, but I come to you in the name of the LORD of hosts, the God of the armies of Israel, whom you have defied… the battle is the LORD’s, and he will give you into our hand” (17:45, 47). And earlier: “The LORD who delivered me from the paw of the lion and from the paw of the bear will deliver me from the hand of this Philistine” (17:37). The point of the story is not David’s bravery as a model for our self-confidence; it is that the LORD saves his people through his anointed, by means that look like weakness — a shepherd boy, a sling, five smooth stones — so that all the glory is God’s. “…that all this assembly may know that the LORD saves not with sword and spear. For the battle is the LORD’s” (17:47).

Now teach the Christological pattern, which the church has long seen here. David is the LORD’s anointed (mashiach), and he fights the battle the whole army of Israel could not fight; the people stand by trembling while their champion alone goes out to face the enemy on their behalf, and his victory becomes their victory (when Goliath falls, Israel surges forward, 17:52). This is the shape of the Gospel: Christ, great David’s greater Son, goes out alone against the enemy we could not face — sin, death, and the devil — and by what looked like defeat and weakness (the cross) wins the decisive victory, so that his triumph becomes ours. Use this typology, grounded in the New Testament’s own Son-of-David and second-Adam theology (Rom. 5; 1 Cor. 15:21–22), rather than the moralizing “your giants” reading. The Law in the chapter is the terror of all Israel before an enemy they cannot beat; the Gospel is the anointed champion who beats it for them.

David and Jonathan: covenant love (18:1–4; ch. 20). Against Saul’s darkening jealousy, Scripture sets the friendship of David and Jonathan. “The soul of Jonathan was knit to the soul of David, and Jonathan loved him as his own soul” (18:1), and he seals it by giving David his own robe, armor, sword, bow, and belt (18:4). Mark what this gesture means: Jonathan is Saul’s son and the natural heir to the throne, and in handing David his royal robe and weapons he is, in effect, freely yielding his claim to the man God has chosen. This is self-giving, covenant love — Jonathan loves and serves the very one who will receive what would have been his. (A pastoral note: the love of David and Jonathan is the noble loyalty of covenant friendship and brotherhood; resist both the prudishness that fears to call it deep love and the modern eisegesis that sexualizes it. Scripture means us to admire it as faithful, self-sacrificing devotion.) In chapter 20 Jonathan risks his father’s wrath — and his own life (20:33) — to warn and protect David, and they renew their covenant with tears. Teach Jonathan as a quiet picture of the love that lays down its own rights for another’s good — a faint echo of the greater Love who, being in very nature the King, did not grasp his rights but emptied himself for us (Phil. 2:6–8).

Saul’s jealousy and murderous descent (18:5–19:24). When the women sing, “Saul has struck down his thousands, and David his ten thousands” (18:7), Saul is consumed: “They have ascribed to David ten thousands, and to me they have ascribed thousands, and what more can he have but the kingdom?” (18:8). From that day “Saul eyed David” (18:9), and his jealousy curdles into repeated attempts on David’s life — hurling a spear at him (18:11; 19:10), setting deadly bride-prices (18:25), sending men to kill him in his bed (19:11). Teach this as the anatomy of envy, the sin that breaks the Ninth and Tenth Commandments and grows into murder of the heart (compare Matt. 5:21–22; 1 John 3:15). Saul cannot bear that the LORD’s favor has passed to another; his identity rests on his throne and his glory, and so the success of David feels like death to him. Connect it back: this is the bitter fruit of being the king of appearances — when the appearance is threatened, there is nothing underneath but fear and rage. The Spirit has departed (16:14); what fills the vacuum is torment and jealousy. The contrast could not be sharper: Jonathan, who has every earthly reason to envy David, loves him and yields to him; Saul, secure on his throne, hates and hunts him. The difference is the heart — and the grace — that the LORD sees.

Land the Law and Gospel. The Law: Saul’s jealousy is the mirror of every heart that cannot bear another’s blessing, that builds its life on appearance and glory and will kill to protect it. The Gospel: the LORD saves his trembling people not by their strength but through his anointed champion, who fights and wins alone — the very pattern of Christ, who went out against our great enemy and conquered for us, so that his victory is counted ours.

Closing Questions

  • The army saw a giant; David saw “the living God” who would fight for his people. In what part of your life are you measuring the giant instead of trusting the Lord who saves?
  • David said, “the battle is the LORD’s.” Where are you trying to win by “sword and spear” what only God can win — and how does Christ’s victory for you change that?
  • Jonathan loved and served the man who would take his throne. Is there someone whose blessing or success you find hard to celebrate? What would Jonathan’s love look like there?
  • Saul’s jealousy grew because his whole identity rested on his glory. Where is your sense of worth resting on something that another person’s success could threaten — and where should it rest instead?

Closing Prayer

O Lord of hosts, you do not save by sword or spear, but you sent your Anointed to fight alone the battle we could never win, and you have made his victory ours. Deliver us from the envy that cannot bear another’s blessing, and give us the self-giving love of Jonathan, who yielded his own crown in love. Let our worth rest not on our glory but on your grace, that with David we may say, “the battle is the LORD’s”; through Jesus Christ, great David’s greater Son. Amen.


Session 7 — David the Fugitive: Sparing Saul, and the Medium of Endor (21–31)

Leader’s preparation — Read 1 Samuel 21–31. This is the longest block in the guide; teach by selected scenes. Cover David’s flight (21–22, including the slaughter of the priests of Nob), the two great scenes in which David spares Saul’s life (24, in the cave at En Gedi; 26, in the camp at Hakilah), the death of Samuel and the episode of Nabal and Abigail (25) as time allows, Saul and the medium of Endor (28), and the death of Saul on Mount Gilboa (31). The center of gravity: David, hunted and with every chance to seize the throne by force, will not “put out his hand against the LORD’s anointed,” but waits on God to give the kingdom in his own time — while Saul, abandoned by God, descends in desperation to a forbidden medium and finally to death. The contrast between the two men is now complete. Give significant time to the sparing of Saul (the theology of waiting on God’s timing and refusing to grasp) and to the medium of Endor (which raises necromancy, the state of the dead, and a genuine interpretive puzzle you should survey fairly). End by closing the book and pointing to the King who is to come.

Opening Questions

  • David has Saul at his mercy, twice, and his men tell him this is clearly God’s moment to strike (24:4; 26:8). Why won’t he do it (24:6)?
  • David keeps calling Saul “the LORD’s anointed” even while Saul is trying to kill him (24:10; 26:9). What does it cost David to keep honoring an office held by his enemy?
  • Saul, getting no answer from God, goes to a medium at Endor to call up the dead Samuel (28:6–7) — the very thing he himself had outlawed (28:9). Why does a desperate person turn to the very thing they know is forbidden?
  • The book ends with Saul dead on Mount Gilboa (31). Was there anything inevitable about this — or any point along the way it could have gone differently?

Congregational Study

David the fugitive, and the priests of Nob (chs. 21–22). David runs for his life, gathering a band of the distressed and the indebted around him (22:2) — an unlikely kingdom-in-waiting. Along the way he receives bread and Goliath’s sword from Ahimelech the priest at Nob (21:1–9; Jesus will later cite David eating the consecrated bread, Mark 2:25–26, to teach that mercy outranks ritual). But Saul’s paranoia turns murderous: on the word of Doeg the Edomite, Saul orders the slaughter of the priests of Nob — eighty-five priests and the whole town (22:18–19). Teach the horror plainly: this is where Saul’s jealousy has led — to the massacre of God’s priests. The king who once spared even his doubters (11:13) now butchers the innocent. Sin, unrepented, does not stand still; it descends.

David spares Saul — twice (chs. 24, 26). Here is the heart of the session’s theology. Twice the LORD delivers Saul into David’s hands. In the cave at En Gedi (ch. 24), David creeps up and cuts off a corner of Saul’s robe — and is conscience-stricken even for that, refusing to harm him: “The LORD forbid that I should do this thing to my lord, the LORD’s anointed, to put out my hand against him, seeing he is the LORD’s anointed” (24:6, ESV). Again at Hakilah (ch. 26), David and Abishai stand over the sleeping Saul, spear in reach, and Abishai begs to strike — “God has given your enemy into your hand this day” (26:8) — but David refuses: “Who can put out his hand against the LORD’s anointed and be guiltless?… As the LORD lives, the LORD will strike him, or his day will come to die” (26:9–10). Teach the doctrine here, for it is rich:

  • David will not grasp the kingdom; he waits for God to give it. David has been anointed king (16:13); he knows the throne is promised to him. The temptation — pressed by his own men as if it were God’s providence — is to take what God has promised, by his own hand and on his own timing. David refuses. He will receive the kingdom as a gift from God, in God’s time, and not seize it by murder. This is faith over against grasping — the very opposite of Saul, who could not wait at Gilgal (Session 4). Set the two side by side: Saul could not wait and lost the kingdom; David waits and receives it.
  • David honors the office even in his enemy. Saul is a wicked man trying to kill him — yet David honors the office of the LORD’s anointed, leaving judgment to God: “the LORD will strike him, or his day will come” (26:10). This is a striking instance of the Lutheran respect for the divinely-given office of authority (recall AC XVI and Rom. 13) even when the person holding it is unworthy. David distinguishes the office from the man, and leaves vengeance to God (compare Rom. 12:19).

There is gospel comfort and Christ here too: the true Anointed, hunted by those who held power, likewise did not seize his kingdom by force or call down vengeance, but entrusted himself “to him who judges justly” (1 Pet. 2:23) and received the kingdom from his Father by way of the cross. (You may also mention chapter 25, where Abigail’s wise intercession stops David from taking bloody vengeance on the fool Nabal — a smaller picture of the same lesson: vengeance belongs to the LORD, who himself deals with Nabal, 25:38–39.)

Saul and the medium of Endor (ch. 28). Now Saul’s descent reaches its lowest point. Samuel has died (25:1; 28:3); the Philistines mass for battle; and Saul, who “inquired of the LORD” and was not answered “either by dreams, or by Urim, or by prophets” (28:6), does the unthinkable: he disguises himself and goes to a medium (a necromancer) at Endor — the very practice he himself had expelled from the land (28:3, 9). He asks her to bring up Samuel. Teach this on several levels.

First, the sin: consulting the dead is flatly forbidden in the Law. Deuteronomy is explicit: “There shall not be found among you anyone who… practices divination… or a medium or a necromancer or one who inquires of the dead, for whoever does these things is an abomination to the LORD” (Deut. 18:10–12; cf. Lev. 19:31; 20:6). Necromancy is condemned because it turns from the living God to the powers of darkness for guidance. That Saul, the LORD’s once-anointed, ends here — at the door of a witch, seeking the dead because the living God has fallen silent to his impenitence — is the tragic terminus of a heart that would not obey.

Where traditions differ — The medium of Endor: what actually appeared? Faithful interpreters across the traditions have long differed on what happened when the medium “saw” Samuel (28:12–14), and you should survey the views fairly rather than insist on one. (1) Some hold that God permitted the real Samuel to appear — note that the medium herself cries out in genuine alarm (28:12), as if this was not the trick she expected, and the message that follows is a true prophecy of Saul’s doom (28:19), which suggests a word from God, not a fraud. On this view God sovereignly allowed it as a final word of judgment, by no power of the medium’s own. (2) Others hold that what appeared was a demonic impersonation of Samuel — a deception fitting the forbidden setting, since Scripture condemns such consultations precisely as traffic with deceiving spirits; the “Samuel” would then be a lying apparition, even if God overruled it to pronounce true judgment. (3) Some have suggested mere fraud or trickery by the medium, though the text’s own alarm and the accurate prophecy weigh against this. Luther and later Lutheran writers generally inclined to the view that it was not the true Samuel but a satanic specter (consistent with the warning of Deut. 18 and the nature of the sin), while acknowledging God’s overruling. The point you must hold for your people, whatever view they take, is the one the text plainly teaches: necromancy is forbidden and detestable; the living do not rightly seek the dead for guidance but turn to God’s word; and Saul’s recourse to it is the sign of a man given over.

Where traditions differ — The state of the dead. This episode touches the question of what the dead are doing. Lutherans confess that at death the souls of believers are at rest with Christ awaiting the resurrection (Luke 23:43; Phil. 1:23), and the church does not seek to summon or consult them — the relationship with the departed faithful is one of hope in the same Christ, not of communication. Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox piety includes prayers for and (in varying ways) to the saints, though both firmly condemn necromancy as practiced at Endor. Some traditions (certain Adventists and others) hold to soul-sleep, an unconscious state until the resurrection. Whatever one concludes about the mechanics of 1 Samuel 28, all orthodox traditions agree it is no warrant for consulting the dead — that is exactly the sin being condemned. Keep your people’s eyes on the living Word as the place God has promised to speak.

The death of Saul (ch. 31). The book ends in tragedy. On Mount Gilboa the Philistines defeat Israel; Saul’s sons, including the noble Jonathan, are killed; and Saul, gravely wounded, falls on his own sword rather than be captured (31:4). The men of Jabesh Gilead — the town Saul had rescued in his very first act as king (ch. 11) — recover his body and give it honorable burial (31:11–13), a last quiet mercy. Teach the close honestly. Saul is the king the people wanted: tall, impressive, a man of the flesh and of appearances — and his story ends in jealousy, blood, the witch’s house, and suicide on a lost battlefield. It is the full harvest of a heart that would not trust and obey the true King. But the book does not finally end in despair, because the other story is still running underneath it: David, the king God chose by grace, the man after God’s own heart, waits in the wilderness, refusing to grasp, trusting God to give the kingdom in his time. The LORD’s anointed will reign — and through David’s line will come the King whose reign will never end (2 Sam. 7:12–16; Luke 1:32–33).

Land the Law and Gospel for the session and the book. The Law: Saul shows us where a heart that will not trust and obey finally arrives — to envy, to bloodshed, to the forbidden darkness, to death on a hill; and the Law’s warning is real. The Gospel: God keeps and vindicates his anointed. David, hunted and powerless, does not seize the kingdom but waits and is given it — as the true Anointed, rejected and crucified, did not grasp but entrusted himself to the Father and was raised and enthroned for us. The God who lifted Hannah from her barrenness, who chose David from the sheepfold, who saves “not with sword and spear,” is the God who lifts us, by grace, in Christ the King.

Closing Questions

  • David could have taken the throne by his own hand and called it God’s providence — but he waited. Where are you tempted to grab what God has promised rather than wait for him to give it?
  • David honored the office of the king even in an enemy who was trying to kill him. Is there an authority — or a person — you find it hard to honor? How does David’s example, and Christ’s, speak to that?
  • Saul went to the medium because God had fallen silent to his impenitence. When you feel God is silent, where are you tempted to turn instead — and where has God actually promised to speak?
  • We’ve watched two kings: one chosen for appearance who grasped and fell, one chosen by grace who waited and was lifted up. Which pattern is at work in your own heart — and how does the true Anointed, Jesus, rescue you from the way of Saul?

Closing Prayer

Almighty God, you raise up and you bring low, and you give the kingdom not to those who grasp it but to those who wait on you. Keep us from the way of Saul — from envy, from grasping, from turning to darkness when you seem silent — and give us the patient trust of David, who would not lay a hand on what was yours to give. We thank you for your Anointed, who did not seize his crown but received it through the cross, and who reigns now for us forever. Bring us at last into his everlasting kingdom; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.


A closing word for the leader. You have walked your people from Hannah’s song to Saul’s grave — from a barren woman lifted up by grace to a king of appearances brought down by his own unbelief, and through it all the quiet, sovereign work of God preparing his Anointed. Keep before them the one thread that holds the book together: the LORD alone is King, he lifts up the lowly and brings down the proud, and the only King who will finally do is the one he gives by grace — David, and great David’s greater Son. Where 1 Samuel accuses, let it accuse fully; where it lifts up the empty and the overlooked, let that grace be Christ. Soli Deo Gloria.

Scripture
Luke 24:27John 5:46Luke 1:46–551 Samuel 1Luke 1:52–531 Samuel 4Exodus 25:22Psalm 78:56–641 Samuel 8Deuteronomy 17:14–201 Samuel 12Luke 1:32–331 Samuel 111 Samuel 151 Samuel 17Psalm 18Psalm 1441 John 3:151 Samuel 21Mark 2:25–26Luke 23:431 Samuel 28Matthew 1:11 Samuel 2:1–10Hebrews 7:23–28Romans 13:1–7Philippians 2:8Romans 5:19Romans 4:51 Corinthians 15:21–22Philippians 2:6–8Matthew 5:21–22Romans 12:191 Peter 2:23Deuteronomy 18:10–12Leviticus 19:31Philippians 1:232 Samuel 7:12–16
Confessions
AC XVIAC IVAp IVAC XIIAp XIIIAC XIIISD XISC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.