Joshua — A Lutheran Leader's Guide
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Soli Deo Gloria
Joshua is the book of the kept promise. For four hundred years the LORD had sworn a land to Abraham’s children; through slavery in Egypt, through forty years of wilderness wandering, through the death of the whole exodus generation and of Moses himself, the promise hung over Israel unfulfilled. Joshua is the account of God making good on his word. Its hero is not really Joshua the son of Nun but the LORD who fights for Israel, brings down walls, parts a river, and hands over a land no army earned. The book’s own summary verse says it plainly: “Not one word of all the good promises that the LORD had made to the house of Israel had failed; all came to pass” (Josh. 21:45). That sentence — repeated almost word for word at the book’s close (23:14) — is the theological spine of the whole book and one of the clearest declarations of God’s faithfulness in all of Scripture. But Joshua is also the most ethically difficult book in the Old Testament, for the same God who keeps his promise commands the destruction of the Canaanites. A leader who would teach Joshua must hold both together: a God whose Gospel-faithfulness never fails, and a God whose Law-judgment is terrible and real.
There is one more thing a Christian must say at the outset. The name Yehoshua (“Joshua”) means “the LORD saves,” and its later Greek form is Iēsous — Jesus. The man who leads Israel into the promised rest bears the very name of the Savior. The New Testament heard this and would not let it go (Heb. 4:8). To read Joshua as a Christian is to watch a man named “the LORD saves” do what Moses the lawgiver could not — lead the people across the water and into their inheritance — and to see in it a living parable of Christ, who leads his people into the rest that remains.
How to use this guide
This is a leader’s guide, written to equip the person teaching the study — pastor, deacon, or lay leader. Nothing here is handed out. If your group is to read anything, let it be the Bible itself. The guide divides Joshua into six one-hour sessions covering the whole book:
- “Be strong and courageous”: Joshua’s commission, the spies, and Rahab’s faith (1–2)
- Crossing the Jordan, the memorial stones, Gilgal, and the commander of the LORD’s army (3–5)
- Jericho and the sin of Achan: holy war and the cost of disobedience (6–8)
- The Gibeonite deception and the conquest of the land (9–12)
- Dividing the inheritance; the cities of refuge and the Levites (13–21)
- “Choose this day”: the altar of witness and Joshua’s farewell and covenant renewal (22–24)
Each session has five parts in fixed order: a Leader’s preparation note, Opening Questions, Congregational Study (the teaching body), Closing Questions, and a Closing Prayer. Read the assigned chapters and the preparation note before the hour, prayerfully and with the Catechism nearby. An hour will not exhaust any session; choose the emphases that fit your group and let the rest wait. Above all, hand the book over as Law and Gospel — letting the conquest accuse, and letting God’s unfailing promise comfort, so that your people leave both rightly sobered and rightly assured in Christ.
Scripture is cited from the ESV unless otherwise noted. Confessional abbreviations follow the series standard: AC (Augsburg Confession), Ap (Apology), SC (Small Catechism), LC (Large Catechism), FC/SD (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration). LW refers to Luther’s Works, American Edition.
A Lutheran orientation to Joshua
Joshua is the book where the promise lands. Genesis planted the promise of a land (12:7); Exodus redeemed the people to inherit it; Deuteronomy preached the Law on its threshold; Joshua is the giving of the gift. For that reason the dominant note of the book is Gospel: God’s sheer faithfulness to a word he had sworn centuries before. The land is never presented as Israel’s achievement. “It was not by your sword or by your bow” (Josh. 24:12); the LORD drove out the nations, the LORD fought, the LORD gave. Deuteronomy had already cut off all boasting — “Not because of your righteousness… are you going in to possess their land” (Deut. 9:5). The land is grace. Teach your people to hear, in the conquest narratives, the same Gospel grammar that runs through the whole Bible: God gives what God promised, and the receiving of it is by faith, not by merit.
And yet Joshua is also a book of severe Law. The conquest is the execution of God’s long-deferred judgment on the Canaanites (Gen. 15:16 had said the iniquity of the Amorites was “not yet complete” — God waited four hundred years). The command to place the Canaanite cities under herem (Hebrew, “the ban,” “devoted to destruction”) is the hardest thing in the book, and we will face it directly in Session 3. A Lutheran reads it neither by softening God’s judgment into something palatable nor by making it a template for human violence, but through the two kingdoms and through Christ — to whom alone final judgment belongs (John 5:22; Acts 17:31).
Joshua is a type of Christ, and the New Testament says so. His name — Yehoshua, “the LORD saves,” which is Jesus — is itself a sermon. Moses, the lawgiver, dies outside the land; the Law brings you to the border but cannot bring you in. It takes Joshua, “the LORD saves,” to lead the people across the Jordan into their inheritance. The book of Hebrews builds an entire argument on this: “if Joshua had given them rest, God would not have spoken of another day later on. So then, there remains a Sabbath rest [Greek sabbatismos] for the people of God” (Heb. 4:8–9). The earthly nuach (“rest”) Joshua won was real but partial and provisional; it pointed beyond itself to the true and final rest that the greater Joshua, Jesus, gives — the rest of forgiveness and of the world to come. Hold this typology before your people throughout: Joshua is the shadow; Jesus is the substance.
Two figures preach the Gospel of justification by faith in this book. First, Rahab — a Canaanite, a Gentile, a prostitute, the very sort the herem was against — who hears of what the LORD has done, believes, hides the spies, and is saved with all her house (Josh. 2; 6:25). Hebrews 11:31 lists her among the heroes of faith; James 2:25 names her as one shown righteous by her works; Matthew 1:5 puts her in the genealogy of Jesus himself. Rahab is the Old Testament Gentile saved by faith, the firstfruits of the nations being grafted in. Second, the recurring refrain that “not one word of all the good promises… had failed” (21:45; 23:14) is the Gospel of God’s faithfulness preached as historical fact. A leader who keeps Rahab and that refrain in view will never let Joshua collapse into mere conquest narrative.
A pastoral word before you begin. Joshua will raise hard questions — about divine violence, about the historicity of the conquest, about whether God still gives land to a nation. Welcome them; we will face each one in its place. But do not let the difficulties swallow the center. The center of Joshua is the God who keeps every promise, who saves a Canaanite harlot by faith, and who sends ahead of his people one named “the LORD saves” to bring them home.
Session 1 — “Be Strong and Courageous”: The Commission of Joshua, the Spies, and Rahab’s Faith (Joshua 1–2)
Leader’s preparation — Read Joshua 1–2, along with Deuteronomy 31:1–8 (Joshua’s earlier commissioning) and Hebrews 11:31 and James 2:25 (the New Testament on Rahab). The theological center of gravity for this hour is twofold and held in tension: God’s command-with-promise to Joshua (“Be strong and courageous… for the LORD your God is with you,” 1:9, ESV) — where the courage is grounded entirely on God’s presence, not Joshua’s resolve — and Rahab’s faith, the Gentile harlot who believes the report of the LORD and is saved. Plan your time so that you arrive at Rahab with room to dwell on her as a portrait of justification by faith. Be ready to introduce the meaning of the name Yehoshua (“the LORD saves” = Jesus) at the very start, because it governs the whole book.
Opening Questions
- When you hear “Be strong and courageous,” does it sound like a pep talk — something Joshua had to summon from within — or like something else? Where does the strength come from in 1:9?
- Moses, who led Israel for forty years, has just died. What would it feel like to be the one who has to take his place?
- If God were going to save someone from among the enemy nation Israel was sent to destroy, who do you think it would be? (Hold the question; the answer is surprising.)
- Have you ever been afraid to obey God? What did you most need to hear in that moment?
Congregational Study
The death of Moses and the call of Joshua (1:1–9). The book opens on the far side of a grave: “After the death of Moses the servant of the LORD…” (1:1). The lawgiver is gone — he died on Nebo, outside the land (Deut. 34) — and now the LORD speaks to Joshua. Stop here and teach the name. Yehoshua means “the LORD saves”; in Greek it becomes Iēsous, Jesus. The deep logic of the transition is not lost on the New Testament: Moses (the Law) brings the people to the border and dies; another, who bears the name “the LORD saves,” must lead them in. “The law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ” (John 1:17). Let your people feel that this changing of the guard is itself a quiet sermon.
God’s charge to Joshua is a relentless drumbeat: “Be strong and courageous” (1:6, 7, 9). But notice — and this is the whole point — the command is never freestanding. Each time, it rests on a promise: “for you shall cause this people to inherit the land that I swore to their fathers” (1:6); “Have I not commanded you? Be strong and courageous. Do not be frightened, and do not be dismayed, for the LORD your God is with you wherever you go” (1:9). The courage is not self-generated grit; it is the response of faith to the presence and promise of God. This is the Lutheran ordering again: the imperative rests on the indicative. God does not say, “Be brave, and then I might be with you”; he says, “I am with you; therefore do not fear.” Teach your people to hear every divine “be strong” this way — not as a demand thrown at the resources of the flesh, but as a word that comes carrying its own power, the way the Gospel does.
Note too 1:7–8: Joshua is to meditate on “the Book of the Law” day and night and do all that is written in it. The leader of the conquest is placed under the Word — exactly as Deuteronomy 17 required of the king. Even Joshua does not stand above Scripture; he stands beneath it. So must every leader of God’s people.
The spies and Rahab (ch. 2). Joshua sends two spies to Jericho, and they lodge — of all places — in the house of Rahab, a prostitute (2:1). The king’s men come hunting; Rahab hides the spies under flax on her roof and sends the pursuers off on a false trail. Then comes the heart of the chapter — Rahab’s confession of faith:
“I know that the LORD has given you the land, and that the fear of you has fallen upon us… For we have heard how the LORD dried up the water of the Red Sea before you when you came out of Egypt… And as soon as we heard it, our hearts melted, and there was no spirit left in any man because of you, for the LORD your God, he is God in the heavens above and on the earth beneath” (2:9–11).
Slow down and let this land. Rahab is everything the conquest was set against — a Canaanite, a Gentile, a woman of the streets, an inhabitant of a city devoted to destruction. And she is the one who believes. She has only heard a report — about the Red Sea, about the LORD’s deeds — and on the strength of that report she confesses the LORD as “God in the heavens above and on the earth beneath.” This is faith in its essence: hearing the word of what God has done and clinging to it. “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Rom. 10:17). She asks for mercy for her household (2:12–13), and the spies pledge it, tied to a sign: a scarlet cord in her window (2:18, 21).
Teach Rahab as a portrait of the Gospel of justification by faith. She is not saved because she is worthy — she is manifestly unworthy by every measure of the Law. She is saved because she believes the LORD and casts herself on his mercy. The New Testament makes her a permanent monument to this: “By faith Rahab the prostitute did not perish with those who were disobedient, because she had given a friendly welcome to the spies” (Heb. 11:31). She stands in the great roll-call of faith alongside Abraham and Moses. And Matthew puts her in the family tree of the Messiah (Matt. 1:5): the Canaanite harlot is a great-grandmother of King David, and an ancestor of Jesus. Here, at the very start of the conquest of Canaan, God saves a Canaanite — a sign planted in the foundations of the book that his mercy will not finally be bounded by Israel, that the nations will be brought in by faith.
Where traditions differ — Rahab’s faith and works. James points to Rahab as proof that “a person is justified by works and not by faith alone” (James 2:24–25), while Hebrews 11:31 and the whole Pauline gospel insist that we are justified by faith apart from works. Is this a contradiction? Roman Catholic theology has historically read James as teaching that works genuinely contribute to justification. The Lutheran reading, set out in the Apology of the Augsburg Confession (Ap IV), holds that James and Paul use “justify” differently and do not conflict: Paul speaks of how a sinner is first declared righteous before God — by faith alone, for Christ’s sake; James speaks of the works by which a living faith shows itself to be genuine, “of what nature the righteous are after they have already been justified and reborn.” The Apology argues that James commends only “such works as faith produces” — works are the fruit that proves the tree is alive, not the root that makes it alive. Applied to Rahab: she was justified before God by faith (Heb. 11:31), and that faith proved itself real in the risk she took to hide the spies (James 2:25). Her works did not earn her rescue; they were the evidence that her faith was the living kind. This is exactly the position taught in the series guide to James, and it is the line to hold here.
Where traditions differ — the scarlet cord. From the early church (Clement of Rome, late first century; later Origen and others) Christian readers have seen in Rahab’s scarlet cord — the sign that brought salvation to her house — a foreshadowing of the blood of Christ, much as the blood of the Passover lamb on the doorposts brought deliverance in Egypt (Exod. 12). This is an ancient and edifying typological reading, and a leader may offer it as such. A word of caution, though: the text does not itself draw the connection, as Hebrews explicitly does for the Passover and for Joshua-as-Jesus. Present the scarlet cord as a long-cherished devotional reading — the church seeing the scarlet thread of redemption running through Scripture — rather than as a doctrine the text demands. Used this way, it preaches: Rahab and her house were saved by being behind the sign of scarlet, and we are saved by being covered in the blood of the Lamb.
Law and Gospel in these chapters. The Law stands in the background — Jericho is under sentence, the land’s iniquity is full, judgment is coming. But the foreground is sheer Gospel: God’s promise to be with Joshua “wherever you go” (1:9), and the salvation of an unworthy Gentile by faith alone. Teach your people that the first thing the conquest narrative does, before a single wall falls, is save a sinner who believes. That is the key in which the whole book is to be read.
Closing Questions
- God told Joshua “do not be frightened… for the LORD your God is with you.” Where in your life are you trying to be “strong and courageous” on your own strength, rather than resting on God’s promised presence?
- Rahab was saved not for her record — which was shameful — but because she believed the report of what the LORD had done. How is that good news for you, who also know your own record?
- The Canaanite harlot ends up in the family tree of Jesus. What does that tell you about whom God’s mercy can reach — and about anyone you might think is “too far gone”?
- Rahab’s faith showed itself in the risk she took. If your faith were on trial, what works would be brought forward as evidence that it is alive?
Closing Prayer
Almighty God, you raised up Joshua to lead your people where Moses could not, and you have given us a greater Joshua, your Son Jesus, in whose name is our salvation. As you were with Joshua wherever he went, be with us, that we may not fear. We thank you that you saved Rahab by faith, an unworthy stranger covered by a sign of scarlet, and that you have covered us in the blood of your Lamb. Make our faith a living faith, that bears the fruit you have prepared; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 2 — Crossing the Jordan, the Memorial Stones, Gilgal, and the Commander of the LORD’s Army (Joshua 3–5)
Leader’s preparation — Read Joshua 3–5. The theological center of gravity is the crossing of the Jordan as a second Red Sea — a passage through the waters that the church has long read alongside Baptism — together with the acts of remembrance and consecration that follow: the twelve memorial stones (4), the circumcision at Gilgal and the first Passover in the land (5:1–12), and the awesome encounter with “the commander of the army of the LORD” (5:13–15, ESV). Have in mind the pattern: God brings his people through the water, then marks and consecrates them as his own, then reveals that the conquest is his war, not theirs. Be ready to handle the Jordan-as-Baptism typology with care — as the church’s edifying reading, grounded in the parallel with the Red Sea (which 1 Cor. 10 does draw on), not as a one-to-one allegory.
Opening Questions
- Israel crossed the Red Sea coming out of Egypt; now they cross the Jordan going into the land. Why might God bookend their journey with two water-crossings?
- Why would God have them stop, in the middle of a military campaign, to pile up stones and to circumcise an entire generation of fighting men (5:2–8)? What does that delay tell you about God’s priorities?
- When the mysterious “commander of the LORD’s army” appears, Joshua asks, “Are you for us, or for our adversaries?” The answer is “No” (5:13–14). What do you make of that?
- What “memorial stones” — physical reminders of what God has done — do you have in your own life or in the church?
Congregational Study
Crossing the Jordan (ch. 3–4). The priests carry the ark of the covenant into the flooded Jordan at harvest time, and the moment their feet touch the water, the river is cut off upstream and stands in a heap; the whole nation crosses on dry ground (3:13–17). The echoes of the Red Sea are deliberate and unmistakable, and the text says so: God did this “so that all the peoples of the earth may know that the hand of the LORD is mighty, that you may fear the LORD your God forever” (4:24). One generation was brought out through the sea; now the next generation is brought in through the river. The ark — the throne of God’s presence — goes first and stands in the midst of the waters until everyone is safely across. God leads his people through the deep.
The church has long heard in this crossing a foreshadowing of Baptism, and rightly, by way of the Red Sea. Paul reads the Red Sea crossing as a type of Baptism — our fathers were “baptized into Moses in the cloud and in the sea” (1 Cor. 10:1–2) — and Peter reads the flood the same way (1 Pet. 3:20–21). The Jordan belongs to the same family of images: God brings his people through the waters of death into the promised inheritance. Luther loved this baptismal reading of Israel’s water-crossings; in the Large Catechism and the Flood Prayer of the baptismal rite, the church confesses that in Baptism God drowns the old and raises the new, as he led Israel through the sea. Teach it as the church has: not that the Jordan “is” Baptism in some wooden sense, but that the same God who carries his people through judgment-waters into their inheritance does so supremely in the font.
Where traditions differ — the Jordan, the Red Sea, and Baptism. Lutherans gladly follow the New Testament’s own typology (1 Cor. 10:1–2; 1 Pet. 3:20–21) in seeing Israel’s water-crossings as foreshadowings of Baptism, and we confess that Baptism actually delivers — it “now saves you” (1 Pet. 3:21). Reformed and Baptist traditions also see the crossings as pictures of redemption but generally read Baptism as a sign or symbol of grace rather than a means that conveys it. A leader should teach the typology for what it is — an illustration the Spirit gives us of how God saves through water — while keeping the dogmatic weight where the New Testament puts it: in the font, where God’s Word joined to water does what he promises. Do not over-press the details (the Jordan is not in the text labeled a baptism); preach the pattern: God brings his people through the water into the inheritance.
The twelve memorial stones (ch. 4). Before the crossing is even complete, God commands that twelve stones be taken from the riverbed and set up at Gilgal as a memorial. The purpose is catechetical: “When your children ask in time to come, ‘What do those stones mean to you?’ then you shall tell them… So these stones shall be to the people of Israel a memorial forever” (4:6–7). This is the same instinct as the Shema’s “teach them diligently to your children” (Deut. 6:7) and as the Passover’s “when your children say to you” (Exod. 12:26). God plants physical reminders in the world so that the next generation will hear the story of what he has done and believe. Use this to encourage your people: faith lives by remembering and retelling God’s mighty acts. The Lord’s Supper itself is given “in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19) — the church’s great memorial stone, where the story is not merely told but the Savior himself is given.
Circumcision and Passover at Gilgal (5:1–12). Now comes a startling pause. The army is across the river, the enemy is terrified (5:1) — and God halts the campaign to circumcise every male, because the wilderness generation had not been circumcised (5:2–8). They are vulnerable, in enemy territory, and God’s first concern is the covenant sign in their flesh. Only then do they keep the Passover (5:10), and the manna stops the very next day, for now they eat the produce of the land (5:11–12). Teach the order: God consecrates his people as his own — marks them with the covenant sign, feeds them at the covenant meal — before he gives them the land. The gift comes to a people set apart and fed by grace. The name “Gilgal” is tied to God’s word that “today I have rolled away [Hebrew galal, ‘to roll’] the reproach of Egypt from you” (5:9) — the shame of slavery is rolled off, as later the stone will be rolled away from a tomb.
The commander of the LORD’s army (5:13–15). As Joshua surveys Jericho, a man stands before him with a drawn sword. Joshua challenges him: “Are you for us, or for our adversaries?” The answer reframes everything: “No; but I am the commander of the army of the LORD. Now I have come” (5:14). Then: “Take off your sandals from your feet, for the place where you are standing is holy” — the very words spoken to Moses at the burning bush (Exod. 3:5). Teach two things. First, the question “are you on our side?” is the wrong question; the real question is whether we are on the LORD’s side. The conquest is not Israel’s war that God assists; it is the LORD’s war, and Israel is summoned to serve it. This single exchange governs how we must read everything that follows in Session 3 — Jericho falls because God fights, not because Israel is mighty or righteous. Second, the holy-ground command and the divine titles have led many in the church to see here a pre-incarnate appearance of the Son (a Christophany) — the same “angel/commander of the LORD” who is both distinguished from God and worshiped as God. Offer this as the church’s long-held reading, with appropriate restraint: at the threshold of the conquest, Joshua meets the LORD himself, and the campaign begins on holy ground, on the LORD’s terms.
Law and Gospel across these chapters. Gospel: God carries his people through the waters into the inheritance (the Jordan), rolls away the reproach of slavery (Gilgal), feeds them at the Passover, and reveals that the war is his to win. Law: the consecration God requires — the covenant sign, the holy ground, the call to be on the LORD’s side and under his command. All of it runs to Christ: the greater Joshua who leads us through the waters of Baptism, feeds us at his table, and fights for us a battle we could never win.
Closing Questions
- God brought Israel through the water into the promised land. In your Baptism, God brought you through death into life in Christ. When did you last remember your Baptism as the sure ground of your standing with God?
- The memorial stones existed so that children would ask and parents would tell. What is one concrete way you could tell the next generation what “those stones mean” — what God has done?
- The commander said he was on neither side; the question was whether Joshua was on the LORD’s side. Where are you tempted to assume God is simply for your plans, rather than asking whether you are aligned with his?
- God consecrated his people before he gave them the land. How does it change your week to remember that you are already marked and fed as God’s own, before you have done anything?
Closing Prayer
O Lord, you led your people through the waters of the Jordan as you led them through the sea, and you have led us through the water of Baptism into life with you. Roll away from us the reproach of our old bondage to sin; feed us at your table; and make us to know that the battle is yours. We would not ask whether you are on our side, but bow before you as the captain of our salvation, on whose holy ground we stand. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 3 — Jericho and the Sin of Achan: Holy War and the Cost of Disobedience (Joshua 6–8)
Leader’s preparation — Read Joshua 6–8. This is the most theologically and ethically demanding session in the guide. The theological center of gravity is the herem — “the ban,” the devotion of Jericho to destruction — as the LORD’s righteous judgment, set against the sobering counter-story of Achan, whose theft of the devoted things brings defeat at Ai and death on his household. Plan to spend real time on the moral difficulty of the conquest; your people will be carrying it whether they say so or not, and you owe them an honest, confessional answer. Have clearly in mind: (1) the long divine patience that preceded the judgment (Gen. 15:16); (2) the uniqueness and non-repeatability of this command; (3) the two-kingdoms refusal to make it a template for “holy war” today; and (4) Christ, to whom final judgment now belongs. Read alongside Genesis 15:16, Deuteronomy 9:4–6, and Romans 12:19.
Opening Questions
- When you read that God commanded Israel to destroy Jericho — men, women, and children — what is your honest, gut reaction? (Let them say it out loud; do not rush to resolve it.)
- Jericho falls not by a battering ram but by marching and trumpets and a shout (ch. 6). Why might God win it that way?
- After the great victory at Jericho, tiny Ai defeats Israel (7:4–5). What does that reversal teach, before we even learn why?
- Have you ever seen one person’s hidden sin bring trouble on a whole family, congregation, or community?
Congregational Study
The fall of Jericho (ch. 6). The conquest’s first and definitive battle is won in the strangest possible way. For six days Israel marches silently around the city once a day, priests carrying the ark and blowing trumpets; on the seventh day they circle seven times, the people shout, “the wall fell down flat” (6:20, ESV). Teach the obvious point first: this is designed so that no one can credit Israel’s military skill. There is no siege, no assault — there is a procession of worship around a doomed city, and then God brings the walls down. Hebrews names the cause: “By faith the walls of Jericho fell down after they had been encircled for seven days” (Heb. 11:30). The first conquest is won by faith and by God’s act, so that the whole campaign is stamped from the start as the LORD’s gift, not Israel’s achievement. And note: in the midst of the destruction, Rahab and her household are spared (6:22–25), exactly as promised. The one who believed is saved out of the city under judgment. Mercy and judgment stand side by side in the same chapter.
Now we must face the herem. The word (Hebrew herem, “the ban,” “that which is devoted to destruction”) means that Jericho and its inhabitants are placed wholly under God’s claim — not plundered for Israel’s profit but given over entirely, as a kind of judgment-offering, to the LORD. This is the hardest thing in the book, and a faithful leader will not dodge it.
Where traditions differ — the herem and divine violence — the central ethical difficulty. No honest reader can pass over the command to destroy the Canaanites without trouble of conscience. Set out the views fairly. (1) The Marcionite rejection (named for the second-century heretic Marcion, and alive today in any “the God of the Old Testament is a different, crueler God” sentiment) solves the problem by cutting it off — discarding the Old Testament and its God. The church condemned this as heresy: there is one God, and Jesus and the apostles read these very Scriptures as the Word of the God they worship. (2) The pacifist objection holds that any divinely commanded killing is incompatible with the God revealed in Christ, and so reads the conquest accounts as Israel’s misunderstanding of God rather than God’s actual command. (3) Crusading misuse runs the opposite way — seizing on Joshua to justify “holy wars,” conquest, and the slaughter of enemies in God’s name, from the medieval Crusades to colonial atrocities. The historic Christian reading, which the Lutheran tradition shares, holds together several truths the other views pull apart: (a) The conquest is God’s righteous judgment on entrenched, generations-deep wickedness — Canaanite religion included child sacrifice and ritual prostitution — executed only after centuries of divine patience. God told Abraham the conquest would wait four hundred years “for the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet complete” (Gen. 15:16). This is not genocide born of ethnic hatred or land-greed; Deuteronomy is emphatic that Israel does not deserve the land either and is no better than the nations (Deut. 9:4–6). It is the just Judge, who is patient for centuries, finally acting. (b) The command is unique and non-repeatable — given to one nation, at one moment in redemptive history, by direct revelation, for the specific purpose of cleansing the land in which the Messiah’s people would be planted. It is not a standing principle. There is no “Joshua mandate” for any later people. (c) The Lutheran two kingdoms seals this off decisively: God governs the world through civil authority (the left hand, by law and sword, Rom. 13) and his church through Word and Sacrament (the right hand, by the Gospel). The church never wields the sword; the Gospel advances by preaching, not conquest. To turn Joshua into a warrant for Christian violence is to confuse the two kingdoms catastrophically — the very error of the crusades. (d) Finally, and most importantly, final judgment now belongs to Christ (John 5:22; Acts 17:31). The God who judged Canaan is the same God who, in Christ, took judgment upon himself at the cross. We are not commanded to execute his wrath; we are commanded to preach the One who bore it. A leader who presents all of this — God’s patience, the uniqueness of the command, the two kingdoms, and the cross — will not pretend the difficulty away, but will refuse both the Marcionite escape and the crusader’s abuse.
Let your people sit with the weight of it. Two things must be said pastorally at once. First, the herem tells us that God’s holiness against sin is not a metaphor — sin really does deserve death, and a day of reckoning is real. The conquest is a sobering preview of the final judgment, when the wickedness of the whole world will be answered. Second, Rahab’s rescue in the very same chapter tells us that no one under judgment is beyond mercy who turns and believes. The door stood open even in Jericho. These two truths — real judgment, real mercy through faith — are the Law and Gospel of the chapter.
Achan’s sin and the defeat at Ai (ch. 7). Then comes the dark counterpoint. Flush with victory, Israel sends a small force against little Ai — and is routed (7:4–5). Why? Because “the people of Israel broke faith in regard to the devoted things [herem], for Achan… took some of the devoted things. And the anger of the LORD burned against the people of Israel” (7:1). One man had secretly kept plunder that belonged to God alone — a beautiful robe, silver, and gold, buried in his tent (7:21). Teach the corporate dimension carefully: the sin of one man brought defeat on the whole nation, because Israel was a covenant community, bound together before God. When the sin is found out and judged, Achan and his household perish (7:24–26). Modern readers recoil — and should reckon honestly with the severity. But the chapter’s lesson is the seriousness of taking for ourselves what belongs to God, and the deceptive ease of hidden sin: “Be sure your sin will find you out” (Num. 32:23). Achan’s confession is exact and tragic: “I saw… I coveted them and took them… they are hidden” (7:21) — the very anatomy of the fall (Gen. 3:6: she saw, she desired, she took). Sin’s pattern never changes.
The sharpest pastoral point: the same God who gave Jericho withheld victory at Ai because of unconfessed sin in the camp. The Law here searches the believer’s own community. Where sin is cherished and hidden, the people of God are weakened. This is why the church practices confession and absolution — not to wallow in guilt, but to bring sin out of the tent and into the light of God’s mercy, where it is forgiven and its power broken.
The victory at Ai and the covenant at Ebal (ch. 8). With the sin purged, God gives Ai into Israel’s hand (8:1 — note the return of “Do not fear… I have given into your hand” — Gospel after the Law has done its work). The chapter ends, remarkably, not in triumphalism but in worship and the reading of the Law: Joshua builds an altar on Mount Ebal, offers sacrifices, copies the Law on stones, and reads “all the words of the law, the blessing and the curse” to the whole assembly, including “the sojourners who lived among them” (8:30–35), exactly as Moses had commanded (Deut. 27). Even in the middle of the conquest, the people are gathered under the Word, hearing Law and Gospel. Make the point: victory does not put Israel above the Word; it returns them to it.
Law and Gospel across these chapters. Law: the herem as God’s real and righteous judgment; Achan’s sin and its deadly cost; the defeat at Ai when sin is hidden in the camp. Gospel: Jericho given by God’s hand to faith (Heb. 11:30); Rahab spared out of the doomed city; the LORD’s renewed “do not fear… I have given into your hand” once sin is dealt with; and, above all, the cross, where the judgment Jericho previews fell upon Christ, so that for those who believe there is no more herem but only mercy.
Closing Questions
- The herem shows that God’s judgment on sin is utterly real. Does that make the cross — where that judgment fell on Christ in your place — heavier and more precious to you, or do you tend to keep both at arm’s length?
- Rahab was spared in the same chapter Jericho was destroyed. Who in your life seems “inside the doomed city,” and how does Rahab’s rescue change the way you pray for them?
- Achan’s sin was hidden, and it weakened the whole people. Is there a sin you are keeping buried in your tent? Where can you bring it into the light, into confession and absolution?
- After the victory, Israel gathered to hear the Law read, not to celebrate themselves. When God gives you a success, what is your first instinct — and what would it look like to return to the Word instead?
Closing Prayer
Holy and righteous God, your judgment against sin is real, and we tremble to remember it; yet you spared Rahab who believed, and you have spared us, who deserve your wrath, because your Son bore it in our place. Search our camp; bring our hidden sins into the light of your mercy; and let no cherished idol weaken your people. Teach us that the battle is yours and the judgment is yours, and keep us under your Word, through Jesus Christ our Lord, who took our condemnation upon himself. Amen.
Session 4 — The Gibeonite Deception and the Conquest of the Land (Joshua 9–12)
Leader’s preparation — Read Joshua 9–12. The theological center of gravity is, first, the Gibeonite deception (9) — a lesson in failing to “ask counsel from the LORD” (9:14, ESV), and in the surprising way God’s mercy and Israel’s kept oath bring even a deceiving people inside the covenant community; and second, the conquest of the land in the southern and northern campaigns (10–12), held under the refrain that runs through these chapters: “the LORD fought for Israel” (10:14, 42). Have in mind the long-day at Gibeon (10:12–14) and how to handle it pastorally, and keep returning to the theme that the land is God’s gift won by God’s hand. Read alongside the herem discussion from Session 3 (it continues here) and 2 Samuel 21:1–2 (the later consequence of the Gibeonite oath).
Opening Questions
- The Gibeonites trick Israel with moldy bread and worn-out sandals into a peace treaty (9:3–13). What was Israel’s one fatal mistake (look at 9:14)?
- Once Israel discovers the deception, they keep their oath anyway (9:18–19). Was that right? What does it say about the weight of a sworn promise?
- These chapters say again and again that “the LORD fought for Israel.” How does that change the way you read a conquest narrative?
- When you face a big decision, how do you “ask counsel from the LORD” — or do you tend to act first and pray later?
Congregational Study
The Gibeonite deception (ch. 9). Word of Jericho and Ai spreads, and while most of the Canaanite kings gather to fight (9:1–2), the people of Gibeon try a different strategy: deception. They send envoys in worn clothes with moldy provisions, pretending to come from “a distant country” (9:6, 9), so that Israel will make a treaty with them rather than destroy them. And it works. The fatal sentence is 9:14: “So the men took some of their provisions, but did not ask counsel from the LORD.” They examined the evidence — the dry bread, the cracked wineskins — trusted their own assessment, and swore an oath. Three days later the truth comes out: the Gibeonites are neighbors, right in the land.
Teach the first lesson plainly: Israel was deceived because they leaned on their own judgment instead of inquiring of the LORD. The text does not blame them for being outwitted so much as for not asking God. This is a searching word for the people of God in every age: how often do we weigh the visible evidence and decide, without ever bringing the matter before the LORD in his Word and prayer? The Gibeonites’ moldy bread is a parable of how appearances deceive when we do not consult God.
Now the surprising turn. Israel discovers the trick — but having sworn by the LORD, they will not break the oath (9:18–20). “We have sworn to them by the LORD, the God of Israel, and now we may not touch them.” The leaders make the Gibeonites servants — woodcutters and water-carriers “for the house of my God” (9:23, 27). Teach two things. First, the binding weight of a sworn oath: even an oath obtained by fraud, sworn in God’s name, is honored, because to break it would profane the LORD’s name (cf. the Second Commandment, and Ps. 15:4, “who swears to his own hurt and does not change”). Centuries later, when Saul violates this oath and slaughters Gibeonites, God brings famine on Israel for the broken treaty (2 Sam. 21:1–2) — the oath still binding generations on. Second, and as Gospel: notice that the deceiving Gibeonites end up inside the covenant community, serving “the house of my God.” Like Rahab, they are Canaanites who, by seeking peace with Israel’s God rather than war against him, find a place among his people — even through their own crooked means. The pattern of the book keeps reasserting itself: God’s mercy keeps reaching beyond Israel to spare those who, however imperfectly, throw themselves on the LORD rather than against him.
The southern and northern campaigns (ch. 10–11). Five Amorite kings attack Gibeon for making peace with Israel, and Joshua marches to defend his new (if deceptive) allies. Here the dominant theme of these chapters rings out: “the LORD threw them into a panic before Israel… the LORD threw down large stones from heaven on them… for the LORD fought for Israel” (10:10–11, 14). The victories are God’s. Joshua’s role is to obey and to show up; the LORD wins the battles. The summary at the end is unmistakable: “Joshua captured all these kings and their land at one time, because the LORD God of Israel fought for Israel” (10:42; cf. 11:23, “Joshua took the whole land, according to all that the LORD had spoken to Moses”). Keep pressing the Gospel grammar: the land is gift, the war is God’s, the credit is God’s.
The famous “long day” sits in this chapter: “Sun, stand still at Gibeon… And the sun stood still… for the LORD fought for Israel” (10:12–14). A leader will be asked about it.
Where traditions differ — the long day at Gibeon (10:12–14). Christians read this remarkable passage in several ways. Many take it as a straightforward miracle — God extending the daylight (whether by halting the sun’s apparent motion, by some refraction of light, or by other means) so that Israel could complete the victory; on this reading the text records an extraordinary act of the Creator who governs the heavens. Others note that the words are drawn from “the Book of Jashar” (10:13), an ancient poetic source, and read the language as exalted poetry celebrating that God gave Israel all the time and help they needed — the kind of heightened speech the Psalms use of God’s deeds. Confessional Lutherans hold a high view of Scripture’s truthfulness and need not be embarrassed by the miraculous; God who made the sun can certainly govern it. A leader can present both readings without rancor, and keep the text’s own point central: whatever precisely happened in the sky, “the LORD fought for Israel” — the heavens themselves served God’s purpose to give his people victory.
The summary of conquest (ch. 12). Chapter 12 is a king-list — thirty-one defeated kings catalogued like trophies (12:24). It can read as a dry inventory, but teach it as a Te Deum in list form: each name is a monument to a kept promise. The land God swore to Abraham is, kingdom by kingdom, being handed over. This sets up the great pivot of the book in Session 5: now that the land is taken, it must be divided and received as inheritance.
Law and Gospel across these chapters. Law: the failure to ask counsel from the LORD (9:14) and its consequences; the binding seriousness of an oath sworn in God’s name; the reality of God’s judgment on the Canaanite kings. Gospel: God fighting for his people who could not have won alone (10:14, 42); the land given as promised; and — quietly but persistently — the mercy that draws even deceivers, like Gibeon, and harlots, like Rahab, into the household of God. The God who fights for Israel is the God who, in Christ, fought and won our decisive battle while we contributed nothing but the need.
Closing Questions
- Israel was deceived because they “did not ask counsel from the LORD.” Where in your life are you weighing the evidence and deciding without bringing it to God in his Word and prayer?
- Israel kept an oath even though it was obtained by trickery, because it was sworn in God’s name. What does that say about how seriously God takes our words — our vows, our promises, the way we use his name?
- “The LORD fought for Israel.” Where are you exhausting yourself fighting a battle you were never meant to win on your own — and what would it mean to let the LORD fight for you?
- Both Rahab and the Gibeonites, Canaanites under judgment, found a place among God’s people by seeking peace with Israel’s God. Who would you be tempted to write off, whom God may yet be drawing in?
Closing Prayer
O Lord our God, you fought for your people and gave them a land they could not win for themselves. Forgive us when we trust our own judgment and fail to inquire of you; teach us to bring all things before your Word. Make our word truthful and our oaths sacred, for your name’s sake. And as you drew the stranger and the deceiver into your household by mercy, draw in those we would write off, and fight for us the battle we cannot win, through Jesus Christ our Lord, who has overcome for us. Amen.
Session 5 — Dividing the Inheritance; the Cities of Refuge and the Levites (Joshua 13–21)
Leader’s preparation — Read Joshua 13–21. This is a long block of boundary-lists and tribal allotments; do not attempt verse-by-verse coverage. The theological center of gravity is the word inheritance (Hebrew nachalah): the land is parceled out not as wages earned but as an inheritance given — and inheritance is a Gospel word, for an heir receives by sonship, not by labor. Within this block, give real attention to two jewels: Caleb, who at eighty-five claims his portion in full-hearted faith (14:6–14); and the cities of refuge and the Levites’ towns (20–21), where mercy and the priesthood are woven into the map of the land. Plan to land on the book’s great summary verse, 21:45 — “Not one word of all the good promises… had failed.” Read alongside Hebrews 4:8–9 (the rest), Romans 8:17 (heirs with Christ), and 1 Peter 1:4 (an inheritance kept in heaven).
Opening Questions
- The middle of Joshua is mostly maps and boundary lines. Why do you think God devoted so many chapters of Scripture to who got which piece of land?
- What is the difference between something you earn and something you inherit? Which is the land of Canaan (think about who is receiving it)?
- Caleb, at eighty-five, asks for the hardest hill country with the giants still on it (14:12). What kind of faith is that?
- God built “cities of refuge” into the land, where someone who killed accidentally could flee from the avenger. What does it tell you about God that he designed mercy into the very geography?
Congregational Study
Inheritance, not wages (chs. 13–19). The conquest done, the land must now be divided among the tribes. The governing word, repeated dozens of times, is inheritance (nachalah) — “the inheritance of the tribe of the people of Judah,” “the inheritance of the children of Joseph,” and so on. Teach the word as Gospel. An inheritance is not a paycheck; it is received by virtue of belonging to the family, not by virtue of labor performed. The land comes to Israel the way an estate comes to a son — as a gift grounded in the father’s promise. This is precisely how the New Testament speaks of salvation: we are “heirs of God and fellow heirs with Christ” (Rom. 8:17, ESV), and we have “an inheritance that is imperishable, undefiled, and unfading, kept in heaven for you” (1 Pet. 1:4). The endless boundary-lists, tedious as they seem, are the concrete proof of a promise kept: every line drawn on the map is God making good on his oath to Abraham. A leader can lift the whole block by saying to the group: this is what a kept promise looks like when you write it all down — surveyor’s lines and town names, the gift made tangible.
Caleb’s faith (14:6–14). Amid the lists, a man steps forward. Caleb, one of the only two spies forty-five years earlier who had urged Israel to trust God and take the land (Num. 14), now claims his portion. At eighty-five he says, “I am still as strong today as I was in the day that Moses sent me… So now give me this hill country of which the LORD spoke on that day” (14:11–12) — and it is the hardest country, where the formidable Anakites (giants) still dwell. “It may be that the LORD will be with me, and I shall drive them out just as the LORD said” (14:12). Caleb’s reward is named with a refrain: he received his inheritance “because he wholly followed the LORD, the God of Israel” (14:14). Teach Caleb as a model of persevering faith — faith that waited forty-five years for a promise and then claimed it with both hands, undaunted by the giants. Note the Gospel undertone even here: Caleb does not boast in his strength but in the LORD’s promise (“just as the LORD said”), and his wholehearted following is itself the fruit of trusting God’s word.
The cities of refuge (ch. 20). Now one of the most beautiful provisions in the law of Israel is built into the land. Six cities are set apart so that anyone who kills “without intent or unknowingly” may flee there and be safe from the “avenger of blood” until a fair trial (20:1–6, 9). Teach the mercy structured into the geography: in a world of blood-vengeance, God carves out places of asylum where the manslayer is protected from hot-blooded retaliation and given due process. This is the Fifth Commandment built into a map — the protection of life, even the life of one who has taken life by accident. The church has long seen here a picture of Christ as our refuge, the one to whom the guilty flee from the pursuing curse of the broken Law and find safety (cf. Heb. 6:18, “we who have fled for refuge… to hold fast to the hope set before us”). Offer it as a fitting and edifying picture: there is a place to run from judgment, and his name is Jesus. (As with the scarlet cord, present this as the church’s devotional reading rather than a connection the text itself spells out.)
The Levites’ towns (ch. 21). The tribe of Levi, the priestly tribe, receives no territorial inheritance of its own; instead it is given forty-eight towns scattered throughout all the other tribes’ lands (21:1–42). Teach the deep theology of this. Why no land for Levi? Because, as Deuteronomy and Joshua both say, “the LORD is their inheritance” (cf. Josh. 13:33; Deut. 18:2). The priests’ portion is God himself. And their scattering means the worship and instruction of the LORD is woven throughout the whole nation — there is no region without a Levitical presence. This foreshadows the priesthood of all believers, whose inheritance is not earthly real estate but the Lord himself, and who are scattered through the world as salt and light.
“Not one word of all the good promises… had failed” (21:43–45). And now the block — and the heart of the whole book — comes to rest in three verses every leader should commit to memory:
“Thus the LORD gave to Israel all the land that he swore to give to their fathers… And the LORD gave them rest on every side just as he had sworn to their fathers… Not one word of all the good promises that the LORD had made to the house of Israel had failed; all came to pass” (Josh. 21:43–45).
Stop and dwell here. This is the theological summit of Joshua. Two Gospel words leap out. First, rest — “the LORD gave them rest [nuach] on every side” (21:44). The land is rest, the end of wandering, the place to settle in safety. Second, the unfailing promise — “not one word… had failed; all came to pass.” This is the Gospel of God’s faithfulness stated as plain historical fact. Everything God swore to Abraham four hundred years before, he has now done. Teach your people to anchor their assurance here: the God who kept every promise to Israel is the same God who has bound himself to us in Christ, and “all the promises of God find their Yes in him” (2 Cor. 1:20). The Augsburg Confession rests the whole comfort of the Gospel on this: we are received into favor and our sins forgiven for Christ’s sake, through faith in God’s promise (AC IV). Joshua 21:45 is that promise-keeping God, caught in the act.
Where traditions differ — the land promise: amillennial fulfillment vs. dispensational literalism. Here the Lutheran reading parts sharply from one strand of modern evangelicalism. The dispensationalist tradition reads the land promises as still owed, literally and in perpetuity, to ethnic, national Israel — so that the modern political restoration of a Jewish state, and a future earthly millennial kingdom centered on the land, are seen as the promise’s true fulfillment. The Lutheran position (with the broadly amillennial mainstream of the church — Reformed, Roman Catholic, Orthodox) holds that the land promise was already fulfilled in Joshua — Scripture says so flatly: “the LORD gave to Israel all the land… Not one word of all the good promises… had failed” (21:43–45). And it was then transcended and eternalized in Christ. Hebrews makes the move explicit: the rest Joshua gave was not the final rest, “for if Joshua had given them rest, God would not have spoken of another day later on. So then, there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God” (Heb. 4:8–9). The earthly Canaan was always a down payment on a better country — “a heavenly one” (Heb. 11:16) — and the true inheritance of Abraham’s children is not a strip of Middle Eastern real estate but the new creation, received by faith in Christ. The promise to Abraham, Paul says, was that he would be “heir of the world” (Rom. 4:13), and that heir-ship comes to all who share Abraham’s faith, Jew and Gentile alike (Gal. 3:29). So a Lutheran teaches: the land promise did not fail and is not still pending — it was kept in Joshua, and its fullness is Christ and the rest that remains.
Law and Gospel across these chapters. There is little Law here and much Gospel: the land given as inheritance, not earned; Caleb’s faith rewarded; mercy built into the map in the cities of refuge; the priests whose portion is the LORD himself; and the towering declaration that not one good promise failed. The faint Law-note is the reminder, tucked into the lists, that “there remains yet very much land to possess” (13:1) and that some tribes failed to drive out the inhabitants (e.g., 15:63; 16:10) — the gift is given in full, yet must still be possessed by faith, a tension the next session will sharpen.
Closing Questions
- The land was an inheritance, not a wage. How does it change your standing before God to know that salvation comes to you as an heir of the family, not as a worker earning pay?
- Caleb, at eighty-five, still claimed the promise and faced the giants. Where is God calling you to a persevering, undaunted faith in a promise you have waited a long time to see?
- God built cities of refuge into the land — places to flee from judgment. Have you fled to Christ, your refuge, from the pursuing curse of the Law? What does it mean to live “in the city of refuge”?
- “Not one word of all the good promises… had failed.” Which of God’s promises are you most tempted to doubt right now — and how does this verse, and the cross, answer that doubt?
Closing Prayer
Faithful God, you gave your people their inheritance not as wages but as a gift, and you kept every promise you had sworn. We thank you that you have made us heirs with Christ of an inheritance that can never perish. Give us the wholehearted faith of Caleb, who claimed your promise against the giants; let us flee always to Christ our refuge; and assure our doubting hearts that not one of your good promises will ever fail. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, in whom every promise is “Yes.” Amen.
Session 6 — “Choose This Day”: The Altar of Witness and Joshua’s Farewell and Covenant Renewal (Joshua 22–24)
Leader’s preparation — Read Joshua 22–24. This is the book’s close, and its emotional and theological climax. Three movements: the near-civil-war over the altar of witness at the Jordan (22), where a misunderstanding nearly fractures Israel and is healed by careful inquiry rather than rash judgment; Joshua’s first farewell address, again sounding the unfailing-promises refrain (23); and the great covenant renewal at Shechem (24), with Joshua’s thunderous “Choose this day whom you will serve… But as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD” (24:15, ESV). The theological center of gravity: God’s faithfulness has been proved (“not one… has failed,” 23:14, the refrain returning), and so the people are summoned to wholehearted covenant loyalty — yet Joshua’s own startling words “You are not able to serve the LORD” (24:19) keep the “choice” from collapsing into works-righteousness. Be ready to teach “choose this day” the same careful way the Deuteronomy guide taught “choose life” — as earnest Law that drives the helpless to grace, not as a celebration of free will. Read alongside Deuteronomy 30:15–20 (the parallel “choose life”) and FC/SD II (free will).
Opening Questions
- The eastern tribes build a great altar by the Jordan, and the rest of Israel almost goes to war over it (22:11–12). What do you think was really at stake for them?
- Before attacking, Israel sends a delegation to ask what the altar means (22:13–16). How might a lot of church conflict be avoided by that one step?
- “Choose this day whom you will serve.” When you hear that, does it sound like a free choice you make, or like something else? (We’ll test it against 24:19.)
- “As for me and my house, we will serve the LORD.” What would it look like for your household to say that and mean it?
Congregational Study
The altar of witness (ch. 22). With the conquest complete, the eastern tribes (Reuben, Gad, half of Manasseh) are sent home across the Jordan — and on the way they build “an altar of imposing size” by the river (22:10). The western tribes hear of it and assume the worst: a rival altar, a breach of the central-sanctuary law (Deut. 12), apostasy — and the whole assembly gathers for war against their own brothers (22:12). But before the first sword is drawn, they do the right thing: they send Phinehas and a delegation of leaders to ask (22:13–20). And the answer dissolves the crisis. The altar is not for sacrifice at all; it is a witness, a memorial, built precisely so that future generations on the west bank will not say to the eastern tribes’ children, “You have no portion in the LORD” (22:24–28). It was an altar of unity, not division — and they nearly slaughtered each other over a misunderstanding.
Teach this as a profound lesson for the church. First, on the Eighth Commandment: Luther’s explanation in the Small Catechism is that we should “explain everything in the kindest way” and not rashly believe evil of our neighbor. The western tribes very nearly committed fratricide because they assumed the worst before they asked. How much conflict in congregations, families, and the wider church would be averted by the simple discipline of inquiring in good faith before condemning? Second, on the zeal for pure worship: their alarm was not wrong in itself — idolatry is deadly serious, and they remembered Achan and Peor (22:17, 20). Zeal for the truth and charity toward the brother must travel together. The chapter models both: take false worship seriously and do not bear false witness against a brother. Note the resolution: they name the altar “Witness”: “it is a witness between us that the LORD is God” (22:34).
Joshua’s farewell (ch. 23). Old and near death, Joshua gathers Israel’s leaders and preaches. His sermon has two notes. The Gospel note is the returning refrain — the very heartbeat of the book: “you know in your hearts and souls, all of you, that not one word has failed of all the good things that the LORD your God promised concerning you. All have come to pass for you; not one of them has failed” (23:14). This is 21:45 sounded again, now as personal testimony from the dying leader: I have lived it; God keeps his word. Let your people hear it as a deathbed witness to God’s faithfulness — the kind of thing an old saint says to the next generation. The Law note is the solemn warning that if Israel turns to other gods and intermarries with the nations’ idolatry, the same God who kept every good promise will bring upon them the threatened evil, until they “perish quickly from off the good land” (23:15–16). The faithfulness of God cuts both ways: he keeps his promises of blessing and his warnings of judgment. This is exactly the covenant logic of Deuteronomy 28.
The covenant renewal at Shechem (ch. 24). The book climaxes at Shechem, where Joshua leads a great covenant-renewal ceremony. He begins — note this carefully — by preaching the Gospel of God’s grace, rehearsing the whole history of what God has done, from Abraham to the present, in the first person of the LORD: “I took your father Abraham… I gave him Isaac… I gave Esau… I sent Moses… I brought you out… I gave you a land on which you had not labored and cities that you had not built” (24:2–13). The relentless subject of every verb is I, the LORD. Israel’s entire existence is God’s gift. Then — and only then, after the indicative of grace — comes the imperative: “Now therefore fear the LORD and serve him in sincerity and in faithfulness… choose this day whom you will serve… But as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD” (24:14–15).
This is the famous “choose this day,” and a Lutheran leader must teach it as carefully as “choose life” in Deuteronomy 30, lest it become a charter for free-will, decision-theology religion.
Here is the key, and it is in the text itself. When the people confidently answer, “Therefore we also will serve the LORD” (24:18), Joshua stuns them: “You are not able to serve the LORD, for he is a holy God… If you forsake the LORD and serve foreign gods, then he will turn and do you harm” (24:19–20). He throws the people’s glib self-confidence back at them. The “choice” is not a celebration of human ability; Joshua immediately tells them they cannot, of themselves, do what they so easily promise. Teach this the Lutheran way (FC/SD II; Luther, Bondage of the Will): the command “choose” and “serve” is the Law in its most earnest, urgent form — genuine address, setting the alternatives before the people with all of God’s heart — but it does not imply the natural ability to fulfill it. The unregenerate will is bound (Rom. 8:7; John 6:44; AC XVIII). The command exposes the inability. So “choose this day” is not an invitation to neutral free will; it is God’s earnest summons that drives the helpless to the God who alone can give a heart to serve him — the very heart Deuteronomy 30:6 promised God himself would circumcise. The imperative is real; the power to obey it is gift. (And note: Joshua’s “as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD” is itself the confession of a man already gripped by grace, not a boast of the natural will.)
Where traditions differ — “choose this day” and free will. This verse is a favorite proof-text for Arminian and decision-oriented evangelical theology, which reads it as evidence that the human will, unaided, can and must choose for God — conversion hinging on the sinner’s free decision. The Lutheran Confessions reject this synergism: conversion is wholly God’s gracious work, the bound will cannot turn itself to God, and yet — equally — the Gospel is sincerely offered to all and those who resist are genuinely at fault (FC/SD II, XI). Lutherans equally reject the Calvinist resolution of double predestination (that God positively decrees the damnation of the non-elect). The line to hold is the same as in the Deuteronomy guide: God really commands “choose,” and means it with all his heart; the command reveals what we ought to do and thereby exposes that we cannot; and Joshua’s own “you are not able” (24:19) guards the text from the works-righteous and free-will misreadings. We preach “choose this day” not as flattery of the will but as Law that drives us to the Savior who works in us “to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Phil. 2:13).
The people renew the covenant, Joshua sets up a great stone “as a witness” (24:26–27 — another memorial, the book’s recurring instinct), and the assembly is dismissed. The book ends with three burials (24:29–33): Joshua dies at 110; the bones of Joseph, carried out of Egypt at last, are buried at Shechem (24:32 — a promise four hundred years old, finally kept, the last loose thread of Genesis tied off in the promised land); and Eleazar the priest dies. The generation that received the promise passes on, having seen every word of God come true.
Law and Gospel across these chapters. Gospel: God’s grace rehearsed in the first person (“I took… I gave… I brought,” 24:2–13); the unfailing-promises refrain on the dying leader’s lips (23:14); Joseph’s bones finally home in the land (24:32) — the kept promise of Genesis. Law: the warning that God’s faithfulness includes his threatened judgment (23:15–16); the earnest, exposing command “choose this day,” answered by “you are not able” (24:19). End the study where the book ends: a people standing on a kept promise, summoned to a loyalty they cannot produce in themselves, pointed beyond their own will to the God who gives what he commands — and beyond Joshua to the greater Joshua, Jesus, who not only commands “serve the LORD” but gives the new heart that can.
Closing Questions
- Israel almost went to war over an altar before anyone asked what it was for. Where are you tempted to assume the worst about a brother or sister before inquiring — and what would the Eighth Commandment have you do instead?
- “Not one word has failed of all the good things…” If you, like Joshua, were giving a deathbed testimony to the next generation about God’s faithfulness, what would you tell them?
- “Choose this day whom you will serve” — and then “you are not able.” Hold both. Why does God command what we cannot do, and where does that drive you to look?
- “As for me and my house, we will serve the LORD.” Having walked through the whole book, what is the one thing about the God of Joshua you most want your own household to know and serve?
Closing Prayer
O Lord, faithful God, not one of all your good promises has ever failed; you brought your people into their rest and gave them a land they did not earn, and you have given us a greater Joshua, your Son Jesus, who leads us into the rest that remains. We confess that of ourselves we are not able to serve you; give us the new heart that you command, and work in us both to will and to do what pleases you. Keep us and our households serving you all our days, and bring us at last to the Sabbath-rest of your people; through Jesus Christ our Lord, in whose name is our salvation. Amen.
A closing word for the leader. You have led your people from a fresh grave — “after the death of Moses” — to three more graves at the book’s end, and the whole way the LORD has been keeping promises: parting a river, toppling walls, fighting battles, dividing an inheritance, and refusing to let a single good word fall to the ground. Keep two things before your people as you finish. First, the Gospel of the unfailing promise — “not one… has failed” (21:45; 23:14) — which is the same faithfulness that meets us in Christ, in whom every promise is “Yes.” Second, the name over the whole book: Yehoshua, “the LORD saves,” Jesus — who does what Moses and the Law could never do, leading his people through the water and into the rest that remains (Heb. 4:8–9). Where Joshua’s conquest accuses with God’s terrible holiness, let it drive your people to the cross where that holiness was satisfied; where it promises, let the promise be Christ. Soli Deo Gloria.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.