Pastoral Care · Interim Ministry
Facilitator's Guide
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
For the interim pastor, vacancy pastor, circuit visitor, or trained lay leader guiding a Church Council through the ten-session course.
This guide is the companion to the ten session files. Read it in full before you meet with your first Council. Return to the session-specific notes below the week before each meeting.
Part One — Before You Begin
Who Should Lead This Course
This material assumes a leader who:
- Confesses the Lutheran faith and can rightly distinguish Law and Gospel.
- Is in good standing with their congregation and church body, and is acting with the knowledge and blessing of the district/synodical office.
- Has the time to meet weekly or bi-weekly with the Council for three to six months without interruption.
- Is not a candidate for the call at this congregation. The facilitator must be someone who will not be considered for the pastorate. This is non-negotiable. A facilitator who is privately hoping for the call cannot lead the congregation through honest discernment.
- Is in some form of accountability — a circuit visitor, district president, senior colleague, or supervisor — so that they are not the only set of eyes on a hard congregation.
If you are a lay leader, this course should be led under the oversight of the vacancy pastor or circuit visitor, and any session involving confession and absolution, the Lord’s Supper, or pastoral judgment on Scripture should be deferred to him.
Assessing the Congregation: The First Conversation
Before Session 1, meet with the Council president and one or two longtime members to understand the shape of the vacancy. This conversation is not the first session.
Use this checklist:
- How did the previous pastor leave — retirement, call elsewhere, health, conflict, removal, death?
- How long was the previous pastorate, and how is it remembered — with thanksgiving, ambivalence, or grief?
- Are there factions or unresolved conflicts in the congregation?
- Is there active church discipline, alleged misconduct, or a pending complaint?
- What is the financial state of the congregation? Can it afford to call?
- What is the membership trajectory over the last five years?
- Is there a parallel call process already underway with the district? At what stage?
- Are the Council members willing to commit to ten sessions of substantive work?
Any difficult finding shapes how you lead the course, but does not necessarily disqualify it:
| If you find… | Then… |
|---|---|
| The previous pastor left under conflict or was forced out | Slow Sessions 2–3 and 6. Plan extra time. Coordinate closely with the district. |
| Active clergy misconduct allegations | Do not proceed with this course. Refer to the district office for proper investigation and pastoral care. This course is not designed for that situation. |
| Significant factions / split congregation | Bring in a qualified intentional interim minister before continuing. Do not try to mediate factionalism on your own. |
| Financial inability to call | Address this honestly in Sessions 1 and 9. The course continues; the call process may not. |
| A “preferred candidate” already in mind | Name this with the Council in advance: this course is about the congregation, not about a particular candidate. The call process belongs to the district and the congregation together. |
| Council members not committed | Do not begin until you have substantive buy-in. A half-engaged Council will surface as drift by Session 3 and resentment by Session 5. |
Setting Expectations
At the first session — or in a brief introductory meeting beforehand — say clearly:
- “This course is ten sessions. We will not skip any. Council members are expected to be present every session barring genuine emergency.”
- “There is a worksheet every week. The session is much shorter and shallower if the homework is not done.”
- “I am not your next pastor, and I am not a consultant. I am here to bring Scripture and the Lutheran Confessions to bear on this congregation’s vacancy.”
- “What is shared in this room stays in this room, unless we together decide to take something to the wider congregation.”
- “The aim of this course is not ‘get a pastor faster.’ The aim is to receive the vacancy as a gift from God for repentance, renewal, and faithful preparation.”
- “If at any point I judge that this course is not the right tool, or that we need additional help from the district, I will say so.”
Get verbal agreement on each point.
Materials You Provide
- Printed copies of each session file, given the week before.
- A folder or notebook for each Council member to keep their worksheets.
- A Small Catechism per member (if not already on hand).
- The Book of Concord, available for reference in the room.
- The congregation’s constitution and bylaws.
- The district/synodical call process materials.
- The congregation’s most recent statistical report (membership, attendance, communing, baptisms, funerals, giving — five-year trend).
The Physical Setting
- A private room with a door that closes. Not the open church narthex.
- A table large enough to seat the Council with worksheets in front of them.
- Tissues within reach. (You will need them. Probably in Session 3 or 6.)
- A clock visible to you, not to them.
- Phones silenced — yours too.
- Coffee is welcome. Conducting the session over a meal is not — it dilutes the work.
Part Two — The Anatomy of a Session
Each session runs about 90 minutes. A rough timing budget:
| Time | Element | What you are doing |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00–0:05 | Opening prayer | Placing the Council under God’s Word. Don’t skip; don’t rush. |
| 0:05–0:30 | Review of last week’s homework | Listening, gentle pressure, naming what surfaced. |
| 0:30–0:40 | Scripture readings | Council members read aloud. Don’t lecture yet. |
| 0:40–1:20 | Teaching and discussion | The week’s theme. Mostly their conversation, not your monologue. |
| 1:20–1:25 | Assigning the next worksheet | Walk through it explicitly. Address objections. |
| 1:25–1:30 | Closing prayer and benediction | Send them out under blessing. |
Your single most common mistake will be talking too much. A useful rule: if you have spoken for more than a quarter of the session, you are probably talking too much. The course material is written. Your job is not to re-teach it. Your job is to apply it to this congregation — and that means asking more than telling.
Part Three — Core Facilitation Skills
1. Law and Gospel — Always Both
The single Lutheran distinctive of this course is the right use of Law and Gospel. Confusing them, or omitting one, ruins everything.
The Law names sin specifically. It does not soften, qualify, or excuse. It says, “The way this congregation treated its last pastor was sin. The gossip in the parking lot is sin. The faction-building over the music question is sin. The refusal to forgive one another is sin.”
The Gospel does not lecture. It announces. It says, “Christ has died for this congregation’s sin. You are baptized. The Lord has not removed the lampstand from this place. The Spirit who built this congregation is still at work.”
The order matters: Law first, Gospel after. Gospel without Law is sentimentality; Law without Gospel is despair.
When to bring Law:
- When the Council blames the previous pastor for what was its own failure.
- When old gossip is repeated as fact.
- When a faction is being formed around a particular candidate or a “way forward.”
- When a member treats the congregation as their property rather than Christ’s.
When to bring Gospel:
- Immediately after the Law has done its work.
- When the Council is in real contrition, not self-pity.
- When the congregation is tempted to despair (“we are dying”).
- When confession has been made and absolution is needed.
The rule of thumb: if you have just brought a heavy Law, you owe the room a Gospel before it ends. Do not let the Council leave a session crushed without also being raised.
2. Listening Before Solving
Most facilitators are temperamentally fixers. Resist it. The Holy Spirit, not your insight, will be the saving agent in this congregation.
Three habits:
- Silence is not failure. When the room grows quiet, do not rush to fill it. Let the silence do work.
- Reflect before interpreting. “What I heard you say is…” is as appropriate for you as for them.
- Ask one more question. When you think you understand, ask one more question. The truth is often in the second or third layer.
3. Holding the Room
You will sometimes need to interrupt — not to dominate, but to prevent harm.
Interrupt when:
- A member begins to speak contemptuously about the previous pastor, a present member, or an absent member. Stop it gently and immediately. “Let’s pause. What we just said about him — would we say it if he were sitting in the room?”
- The old conflict reappears as the current discussion. “You’re rehearsing the fight from three years ago. Let me redirect us.”
- A member has not spoken in twenty minutes. “[Name], I want to hear from you. What’s happening for you right now?”
- A member is visibly overwhelmed. “Let’s pause. We’re not going anywhere.”
4. Avoiding Triangulation
The Council, or individual members, will try — sometimes unconsciously — to recruit you to their side. Common signs:
- A member catching your eye while another speaks.
- A member asking, “Don’t you agree, Pastor?”
- A member approaching you after the session with private complaints about another.
- Phone calls and emails between sessions to “fill you in.”
The discipline: what is said about the congregation is said in the Council. If a member contacts you between sessions with substantive material, respond: “That matters. Please bring it to the next session so we can address it together. If it is something for private confession, let’s schedule that separately.” The exception is safety information — that you handle immediately.
Private pastoral conversations do have a place — for confession, for absolution, for individual spiritual care. But they should be named as such, not used as back-channels.
5. Naming Sin Without Crushing
Councils in vacancy often arrive expecting either (a) to be condemned for the conflict that produced the vacancy, or (b) to have their behavior validated. Neither is your job. Your job is to name what is happening, in the language of Scripture, without venom and without flinching.
A helpful sentence structure:
“What you described — when you said X — is the kind of speech the Eighth Commandment forbids. That is sin. The good news is that Christ has died for that sin, and this congregation can be made new under his forgiveness.”
Name the act, name the commandment, point to the cross. Practice this until it feels natural.
6. Confession and Absolution
If you are an ordained pastor, you have access to the most underused gift in Lutheran pastoral practice: individual private confession and absolution. Offer it — explicitly — from Session 2 onward, to Council members individually.
Many will refuse at first. Offer again. When a member is finally ready, hear the confession privately, speak the absolution clearly:
“In the stead and by the command of my Lord Jesus Christ I forgive you all your sins, in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.”
Do not editorialize. Do not water it down. Do not turn the absolution into more counsel. Speak the Word and then be quiet. The Holy Spirit does the work.
In Session 6, the course provides a corporate confession and absolution for the Council together. Even ordained leaders sometimes shrink from this. Do not. The Council needs to hear it.
If you are not ordained, refer members to the vacancy pastor for private confession at appropriate moments.
7. The Special Discipline of the Interim
Interim work has temptations distinct from ordinary pastoral care:
- Do not preach the call you wish you had received. If you are a retired or supply pastor, this congregation is not your last shot at significance.
- Do not “leave your mark.” A faithful interim leaves the congregation more dependent on Christ and less dependent on the pastor — including on you.
- Do not undermine the next pastor before he arrives. Speak well of the office, the call process, and the (as-yet-unknown) man God will send.
- Do not become the favorite. If members begin saying “we wish you would stay,” gently and consistently redirect: “What you’re feeling is real. But the Lord is sending you a pastor, and my job is to help you be ready for him.”
Part Four — Common Situations and How to Handle Them
“We just want to call a pastor and get back to normal.”
This is the most common Council instinct, and it is the one most likely to wreck the next pastorate. Treat it pastorally, not impatiently.
Response: “I hear you. Let me name what’s underneath that wish — exhaustion, grief, and a desire for things to feel settled. Those are real. But ‘getting back to normal’ is not what God is offering this congregation in the vacancy. He is offering renewal. If we call in haste, we will live with that call for many years. Let’s not skip what the Lord is doing in this season.”
“We didn’t do the homework.”
Likely causes: too much homework, resistance to a hard topic, or genuine bandwidth limits.
Response: “Tell me what got in the way.” Listen. If it is resistance, name it: “It sounds like Part B felt too vulnerable. That’s worth talking about.” If it is bandwidth, scale the homework down rather than skipping it. If it is one member refusing while the others tried, address that directly with the member, privately if needed.
Do not move on to new content until the previous session has been engaged in some substantive way.
One member dominates the room.
Common in Councils, especially when one member has institutional memory (“I’ve been here forty years”) or a strong personality.
Redirect: “[Other member], I want to hear your read on the same question.” If the dominant member interrupts, hold the line: “Let her finish.”
Between sessions, you may need to name it privately to the dominating member: “I’ve noticed you tend to take most of the conversational space. I’d like you to listen more than speak next session. Will you try?”
A faction emerges.
If you notice that two or three members are sitting together, voting together, and beginning to speak as a bloc, name it — not in accusation, but in honest description:
“I’m noticing a pattern. Three of you are consistently expressing the same view on this, and the rest of us are not engaging it. That may be the Spirit’s wisdom, or it may be something else. Let’s slow down.”
If a faction hardens — meeting separately, organizing votes, preparing to walk out if they don’t get their way — pause the course and consult your district office.
The previous pastor’s name keeps coming up.
This is normal in the early sessions and concerning in the later ones. By Session 6, the Council should be talking less about the previous pastor (positively or negatively) and more about the congregation and its own life.
If by Session 8 the previous pastor’s ghost is still in the room, you have unfinished grief work. Loop back to Sessions 2–3 quietly, perhaps as a special meeting, before pressing forward.
A new disclosure emerges mid-course.
A buried conflict, hidden misconduct, financial irregularity, or major secret about the previous pastorate. The course as written cannot proceed unchanged.
What to do:
- Stop the planned material. This week’s homework can wait.
- Name what has been disclosed, in plain language. Do not minimize.
- Decide what must be reported. Misconduct allegations go to the district immediately. Financial irregularity may require the auditor. Mandatory reporting laws apply where they apply.
- Decide whether the Council can continue the course at all. Sometimes the answer is: not yet. Reconciliation, investigation, or specialized help comes first.
- Consult your supervisor or district president within 48 hours.
A member becomes angry with you.
This will happen. You will be accused of taking sides, of moving too slowly, of moving too quickly, of not understanding “how things are done here,” of being a hireling.
Response: “Tell me more about that. I want to hear it.” Listen without defending. After they have spoken, respond honestly: “You’re right about X. About Y, here’s how I see it differently.” Do not back down from things you must say. Do not dig in on things you got wrong.
The Council wants to skip ahead to the call process.
Especially after Session 4 or 5, the Council may push to move to interviews and ballots. Resist firmly.
“I understand the urgency. The call process is the district’s work; the sessions ahead are yours. Skipping them does not get a pastor sooner — it gets a hastier call, which usually means a shorter and unhappier pastorate. We will finish what we started.”
The congregation is dying.
Some congregations going through vacancy are also going through decline so steep that the question is not “what pastor do we call?” but “can we still call?” or even “should we?”
This is a pastoral conversation of its own. The course is not designed to answer it, but the course will surface it. When it does, be honest, be patient, and bring in the district. The faithful question is not “how do we save this congregation?” but “what is the Lord calling this congregation to in this season?” — which may be calling a pastor, may be a parish partnership, may be merger, or may be a faithful closing. All of these are God’s work.
Part Five — Session-by-Session Facilitation Notes
Session 1 — The Vacancy Under God’s Word
- Watch for: how the Council describes the vacancy — as a problem to be solved, as a tragedy, as a relief, as a punishment. Each tells you something about the previous pastorate.
- Push on: the claim “we just need a pastor.” Treat it as a serious theological claim, not a logistical one. Ask: “Need a pastor for what? What do you believe a pastor is?” (You will return to this in Session 8.)
- Leave alone: trying to “solve” any specific congregational problem in Session 1. The first week sets the frame. You are not yet inside the room.
- Common reaction: mixed energy. Some Council members will be enthusiastic; some will be skeptical. Note this. It will shape the next two sessions.
Session 2 — Heritage and Thanksgiving
- Watch for: the “golden age” story (everything was great under Pastor X, twenty years ago) and the “we’ve never been good” story. Both are distortions.
- Push on: the homework. The written congregational history, even in rough form, becomes a touchstone for the rest of the course.
- Leave alone: trying to settle which version of the congregation’s story is “right.” Listen for the resonances and dissonances; both teach.
- Pastoral note: giving thanks for the previous pastor’s faithful service, even when his departure was painful, is essential. If the Council cannot give thanks, that itself is a finding.
Session 3 — Grief, Endings, and Honest Goodbyes
- Watch for: numbed grief, displaced anger (often onto the district or polity), or false closure (“we’re fine, we’ve moved on”).
- Push on: the goodbye ritual. If the previous pastor’s departure was rushed, ugly, or denied, the absence of a real goodbye is itself a wound. Provide one — even retroactively.
- Leave alone: any attempt to relitigate the circumstances of departure. That is not what this session is for. If it must be relitigated, it belongs in Session 6 (Reconciliation) or in district-led work outside this course.
- Be ready to: sit with tears. This is often the first session in which the Council members weep. Don’t fill the silence.
Session 4 — The Marks of the Church
- Watch for: the surprised relief on Council members’ faces when they hear that the Church is constituted by Word and Sacrament, not by a pastor’s personality or the building. For many, this is the most theologically liberating session of the course.
- Push on: the connection between this session and the call process. Calling a pastor is calling a man to a specific office — to preach the Word and administer the Sacraments — not hiring an executive or a personality.
- Leave alone: ecclesiology debates about polity. Stay with the Confessions; stay with the congregation in front of you.
Session 5 — The Priesthood of All Believers and Lay Vocation
- Watch for: the temptation to read “priesthood of all believers” as “we don’t really need a pastor.” This is a Reformed misuse. Lutherans hold both AC V (the Office) and the universal priesthood without collapsing one into the other.
- Push on: the Council’s own vocation in the vacancy. They are not merely “filling in.” They are exercising the offices to which Christ has called them.
- Leave alone: turning this into a lay-empowerment pep talk. The point is faithfulness in vocation, not a leadership conference.
Session 6 — Healing, Confession, and Reconciliation
- Watch for: generalized confession (“we have all sinned”) used to avoid specific confession (“I sinned by saying X about pastor Y”). Press toward specificity.
- Push on: the corporate confession. Lead it. Speak the absolution. Do not allow the Council to skip it because it feels awkward.
- Leave alone: trying to mediate every old conflict. The course provides a frame; the Holy Spirit does the work. Some conflicts may need separate sessions outside this course.
- Critical note: this is often the week where the course either becomes a real spiritual work or stalls into procedure. Pray hard before this session.
Session 7 — Discerning Mission in This Place
- Watch for: the trap of “vision casting” untethered from Word and Sacrament. The congregation’s mission is not whatever the Council can dream up; it is to be the Church — preaching, baptizing, communing, catechizing, serving — in this specific place.
- Push on: the actual neighborhood. Who lives within a mile of the church? What is the school like? Who is unchurched? The mission is to neighbors, not to demographics in a marketing report.
- Leave alone: any pressure to produce a fully formed strategic plan. This session prepares the congregational profile (Session 9), not a five-year roadmap.
Session 8 — The Office of the Holy Ministry
- Watch for: consumerist language about pastors (“we need someone who…”, “we want a pastor who…”). Without dismissing legitimate concerns, gently reorient: “What did Christ institute the Office of Ministry to do? Start there.”
- Push on: the distinction between AC V (the Office) and AC XIV (good order in calling). The man God will send is being called to an office that already has its job description: preach the Word, administer the Sacraments, forgive sins in Christ’s stead.
- Leave alone: prescribing a personality type. Faithful pastors come in many temperaments.
Session 9 — The Call Process and Prayerful Discernment
- Watch for: the temptation to treat the call process like a job search — managing candidates, comparing résumés, deciding “the best fit.” The call process is a churchly act of discernment, conducted under prayer and the Spirit’s leading, in cooperation with the district.
- Push on: the congregational profile. Make sure it reflects the work of the previous eight sessions — the heritage, the grief, the marks of the Church, the lay vocation, the reconciliation, the mission. Not a marketing document.
- Leave alone: specific candidates if the district has begun to put names forward. Process is your concern; candidacy is the district’s and the congregation’s together.
Session 10 — Receiving the New Pastor
- Watch for: premature relief (“we made it!”). The interim ends not when the call is issued but when the new pastor is installed and the congregation has actually received him — which takes months, not minutes.
- Push on: the written commitments the Council will make to the next pastor — to pray for him, to support him, to receive his preaching, to honor his office, to bring concerns to him directly rather than through the parking lot.
- Leave alone: romanticizing the new pastorate. Plan for the first year to be hard. Plan for grief over the old to keep surfacing. The honeymoon is short.
- Plan: a follow-up gathering at six months and twelve months after installation. Put it on the Council’s calendar before this course ends.
Part Six — The Leader’s Own Soul
Interim work absorbs things. Congregational grief, conflict, and exhaustion will sometimes touch your own grief, your own conflict, your own exhaustion. The cumulative weight of bearing other congregations’ transitions is real.
Practices for your own faithfulness:
- Pray for the Council by name, daily. Not “and bless all my counselees” — by name. The Holy Spirit, not you, does the saving work.
- Receive Word and Sacrament weekly yourself, at a different congregation. A leader who is not himself fed cannot feed others. Do not preside at the congregation you are facilitating without authorization.
- Make use of private confession. If you are a pastor, find a brother pastor. If you are a lay leader, find your pastor. Your sins are not invisible just because you are leading.
- Be in supervision or accountability. Hard congregations need a second mind. Do not be the only set of eyes.
- Maintain confidentiality, including with your spouse. Generic prayer requests are fine. Identifying details are not.
- Take a sabbath. You are not the savior of the congregations you serve. Christ is. Rest in that, and rest.
- Know when to refer. You are not equipped to handle every congregational pathology. The district is your friend.
Part Seven — A Closing Word
The congregation in front of you is not a project. It is a body of baptized Christians whom God has gathered around Word and Sacrament, and whom God is now leading through a season of waiting. Your part in their story is small, and that is good news. You are not their savior. You are a servant of the Word.
Bring them the Word — the Word that kills and the Word that makes alive. Bring them to the Sacrament. Speak honestly. Pray earnestly. Then let them call a pastor and receive him as Christ’s gift, and let God do what only God can do.
“And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ.” — Ephesians 4:11–12
Soli Deo Gloria.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.