Referral Guidelines — Forgiveness Counseling
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Forgiveness counseling intersects with some of the most volatile material in pastoral care: trauma, abuse, addiction, mental illness, and severe relational injury. Pastors and lay counselors must be prepared to recognize when a situation exceeds pastoral scope and to refer faithfully without abandoning spiritual care.
This document provides indicators, response guidance, and a framework for collaborative care.
1. The Theology of Referral
Referral is not a failure of faith or of pastoral care. It is faithful stewardship of vocation. Pastors are called to administer Word and Sacrament and to walk with souls; they are not trained physicians, licensed therapists, or psychiatrists. Sending a counselee to a qualified professional is itself an act of love, and the pastor’s role often continues alongside that professional care.
Refer early. Refer warmly. Stay engaged spiritually.
2. General Referral Indicators
Refer when one or more of the following are present:
- Licensed clinical therapy is needed.
- Psychiatric evaluation or medication review is needed.
- Medical evaluation is needed.
- Abuse — past or present — is disclosed.
- Trauma symptoms exceed the pastor’s competency.
- Addiction requires specialized treatment.
- Safety concerns (to self or others) are present.
- The counselee is not progressing despite faithful pastoral care.
- The pastor feels persistently out of depth.
3. Emergency Response
Suicidal Ideation
If the counselee expresses suicidal thoughts:
- Ask directly: “Are you thinking about ending your life?”
- Assess: Do they have a plan? Means? Timeline? Prior attempts?
- Do not leave the person alone.
- Remove or secure means if possible (firearms, medications).
- Contact:
- 988 (Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, U.S.)
- Local emergency services (911) if imminent risk
- The counselee’s existing therapist or psychiatrist, if any
- Arrange safe transport to an emergency room if active risk is present.
- Notify a trusted family member or emergency contact, with appropriate permission.
- Document the conversation, the assessment, and the steps taken.
Homicidal Ideation or Threats
- Take all threats seriously, including those framed as fantasy.
- Assess for plan, means, and target.
- If risk is imminent, contact law enforcement.
- Consult your jurisdiction’s duty-to-warn requirements.
- Document carefully.
Abuse Disclosure
- Listen without interrupting.
- Affirm the courage of disclosure.
- Do not promise blanket confidentiality.
- Know your state’s mandatory reporting requirements for:
- Child abuse and neglect
- Elder abuse
- Abuse of vulnerable adults
- Report as required by law, regardless of the offender’s identity.
- Safety-plan with the survivor before they leave the session.
- Refer to a trauma-informed therapist and, where applicable, to legal or advocacy resources.
Domestic Violence
- Do not invite the abuser to counseling sessions, individually or jointly.
- Do not counsel the survivor toward reconciliation.
- Do not require, recommend, or imply that forgiveness equals returning to the relationship.
- Refer to:
- National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233
- Local domestic violence shelters and advocates
- Trauma-informed therapists with DV expertise
- Safety-plan: where will they go, who can they call, what do they need to take, what is their code word?
Active Psychosis
Signs include:
- Disorganized speech or thought
- Hallucinations (auditory, visual)
- Paranoia or delusions
- Severe disconnection from reality
Response:
- Stay calm; do not argue with delusions or affirm them.
- Contact a family member or emergency contact with permission.
- Refer to psychiatric emergency services.
- Do not attempt to address spiritual content of delusions as if it were a theological question.
4. Mental Health Referrals
Refer to a Licensed Therapist When
- Symptoms of depression, anxiety, PTSD, or complex trauma are present.
- Panic attacks recur.
- Dissociation, flashbacks, or intrusive memories are described.
- Self-harm is disclosed.
- Eating disorders are suspected.
- Grief becomes prolonged or disabling (more than 6 months of significant functional impairment).
- Counselee requests therapy.
Refer to a Psychiatrist When
- Medication evaluation may be helpful.
- Severe mood disorder is suspected (major depression, bipolar disorder).
- Psychotic symptoms appear.
- A primary care physician recommends specialist involvement.
Refer to a Primary Care Physician When
- Sleep, appetite, or weight have significantly changed.
- Physical symptoms accompany emotional distress.
- The counselee has not seen a doctor in over a year.
- Hormonal, thyroid, or neurological issues may underlie symptoms.
5. Addiction Referrals
Refer to Specialized Treatment When
- Substance use is interfering with work, family, or safety.
- The counselee has attempted to stop and cannot.
- Withdrawal symptoms are present.
- Use endangers self or others (e.g., driving, parenting).
- Behavioral addictions (pornography, gambling, gaming) are pervasive and unmanageable.
Resources
- Medical evaluation for safe detox where needed
- Outpatient or inpatient addiction treatment programs
- Recovery groups (AA, NA, Celebrate Recovery, SA, etc.)
- Christian recovery counselors trained in addiction
Forgiveness work in the context of addiction usually requires parallel clinical care; do not attempt to substitute pastoral care for treatment.
6. Trauma Referrals
Refer to a trauma-informed therapist when:
- The counselee describes childhood abuse, sexual assault, combat trauma, or other significant traumatic events.
- Trauma symptoms include flashbacks, hypervigilance, avoidance, dissociation, or numbing.
- The counselee freezes, dissociates, or becomes overwhelmed during sessions.
- “Trying harder to forgive” is intensifying symptoms.
Trauma must usually be stabilized clinically before deep forgiveness work proceeds. A pastor can offer absolution and prayer throughout, but should not lead the trauma processing itself unless trained for it.
7. Marriage and Family Situations Requiring Referral
Refer to a licensed marriage and family therapist or specialized counselor when:
- Infidelity is recent and unresolved.
- Domestic violence is present (refer to a DV professional, not a marriage counselor).
- Substance abuse is active in the marriage.
- Severe contempt, stonewalling, or escalation patterns dominate.
- Child custody, legal separation, or divorce proceedings are underway.
- Parent-child estrangement involves clinical complexity.
Pastors may continue to walk with each individual spiritually while a licensed clinician addresses the relational system.
8. Local Support Recommendations
Each congregation and counselor should maintain an up-to-date local referral list, including:
- Christian licensed therapists and counselors
- Trauma-informed therapists (Christian and secular)
- Marriage and family therapists
- Psychiatrists accepting new patients
- Primary care physicians known to work well with mental health referrals
- Addiction treatment centers (outpatient, inpatient, detox)
- Domestic violence shelters and advocacy organizations
- Sexual assault advocacy services
- Suicide prevention and crisis lines
- Legal aid resources
- Pregnancy support and post-abortion care
- Grief support groups
- Spiritual direction networks
Build relationships with these providers before referrals are urgent. Knowing the clinician personally improves the warmth and effectiveness of the handoff.
9. Collaborative Care Principles
When the counselee is receiving care from multiple providers:
- Permission — secure written consent before communicating with another provider.
- Clarity of roles — pastor for spiritual care; therapist for clinical; physician for medical. Each respects the others’ scope.
- Communication — periodic, focused, and confidential. Avoid duplicating clinical work.
- No competition — never undermine another provider, even when disagreement exists. Raise concerns directly with the provider, not with the counselee.
- Sacramental care continues — Word, Absolution, and Supper remain the pastor’s distinct gift, regardless of other care being received.
10. Documenting and Following Up
When referring:
- Note the referral in your pastoral records.
- Provide the counselee with written contact information.
- Follow up within a week to ask whether they made the call.
- If they did not, gently inquire what got in the way; remove obstacles where possible.
- Continue pastoral care unless the counselee or the clinician requests otherwise.
11. When to End or Pause Counseling
Pause or end the forgiveness counseling track when:
- Safety concerns require stabilization before deeper work continues.
- A clinical issue must be addressed before forgiveness work is healthy.
- The counselee is not engaging or is being harmed by continuation.
- Dual relationship concerns arise.
- The pastor recognizes burnout or compromised judgment in themselves.
Pausing is not abandonment. Communicate clearly, offer continued pastoral connection (worship, prayer, occasional check-ins), and welcome the counselee to return when readiness and stability are present.
12. Final Word to the Pastor
You are not the Savior. You are a steward. The most loving thing you can do for some counselees is to refer them to someone better equipped, while you remain the one who absolves them, prays for them, and meets them at the altar. The Church has many members and many gifts; honor that body by refusing to carry alone what was never given to you alone.
“Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ.” — Galatians 6:2
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.