Pastoral Care · End of Life Care

Session 7 — Ethical and Practical Issues

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

1. Session Overview

This final session addresses the ethical and practical issues that surround the end of life. These are weighty matters that the dying person and their family must often navigate under emotional pressure: advance directives, treatment decisions, dignity, autonomy, medical ethics, and the boundaries between spiritual and clinical care.

This session is not a substitute for legal or medical counsel; it provides a pastoral framework that allows decisions to be made faithfully, with information and prayer, rather than under crisis-driven anxiety.

Purpose: to help the patient and family navigate end-of-life ethical and practical decisions with theological clarity, pastoral wisdom, and appropriate professional support.

Emotional focus: the relief of making decisions in advance rather than under duress; the difficulty of facing concrete realities; the dignity of agency.

Theological focus: the sanctity of life, the legitimacy of accepting death, the Christian rejection of euthanasia and assisted suicide, the goodness of comfort care, and the body’s worth even in decline.

Practical goals:

  • to clarify advance directives, living wills, and healthcare power of attorney,
  • to discuss CPR, DNR, ventilator, feeding tube, and dialysis decisions,
  • to address dignity and autonomy,
  • to clarify the boundary between pastoral and medical/legal counsel,
  • and to address requests for hastened death.

Expected outcomes: the patient and family have clearer plans, have engaged the difficult ethical questions with pastoral support, and feel better prepared for the decisions ahead.


2. Biblical Foundation

Primary Texts

  • Genesis 1:26–27; 2:7 — Human beings made in God’s image, given life by God’s breath
  • Deuteronomy 30:19–20 — “Choose life”
  • Job 1:21 — “The Lord gave, and the Lord has taken away”
  • Psalm 139:13–16 — God’s intimate knowledge of our days
  • Ecclesiastes 3:1–2 — “A time to be born, and a time to die”

Supporting Texts

  • 1 Corinthians 6:19–20 — “Your body is a temple”
  • Philippians 1:21–24 — Caught between life and death
  • 2 Timothy 4:6–8 — “The time of my departure has come”
  • John 10:11, 17–18 — The Good Shepherd lays down his life
  • Romans 14:7–8 — “Whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s”
  • Matthew 5:21–22 — On the sanctity of life
  • Romans 12:1 — Present your bodies as a living sacrifice

Themes

  • Life as God’s gift
  • The image of God in every human being
  • The legitimacy of accepting one’s mortality
  • The Christian rejection of taking human life
  • The difference between killing and allowing to die
  • Stewardship of the body and the days God gives

3. Confessional Lutheran Foundations

Small Catechism

  • Fifth Commandment — “You shall not murder.” Luther: “We should fear and love God so that we do not hurt or harm our neighbor in his body, but help and support him in every physical need.”
  • Lord’s Prayer, Seventh Petition — “Deliver us from evil.” Including a blessed end, in God’s time.
  • Confession — Examination of one’s life in light of one’s calling, including decisions made.

Augsburg Confession

  • Article XVI — Christians may rightly participate in civil and vocational structures, including medical and legal decisions, when those structures do not require sin.

Doctrinal Themes

  • The body is created good and redeemed in Christ.
  • Human life belongs to God, not to ourselves.
  • We are stewards of the days given to us.
  • The Christian is not obligated to use every medical means available; nor is the Christian permitted to actively end life.
  • The Theology of the Cross meets us at the bedside; suffering is not denied, but neither is it sought.

Pastoral Application

The pastor is not a medical or legal expert and should not pretend to be one. The pastor’s role is to help the patient and family think theologically, prayerfully, and humanely about the decisions that medical and legal experts present to them.


4. Counseling Themes

Emotional Issues

  • Anxiety about making “wrong” decisions
  • Guilt over choosing comfort over more treatment, or vice versa
  • Disagreement within the family about treatment goals
  • Fear of being kept alive in undignified conditions
  • Fear of “giving up too soon”
  • Desire to maintain control versus longing to release control

Relational Dynamics

  • The family member who insists on more treatment when the patient is at peace with stopping
  • The family member who pushes for hospice when the patient is not ready
  • Disagreement among adult children
  • The need for clarity about who has decision-making authority

Spiritual Struggles

  • “Is it murder to stop treatment?”
  • “Is it suicide to refuse the ventilator?”
  • “Am I a bad Christian for wanting it to be over?”
  • “Is it wrong to want to die?”
  • “What does God want me to do?”

Psychological Considerations

  • Decision fatigue impairs judgment under pressure
  • Advance directives made in calm are more reliable than crisis decisions
  • Pain and fear can produce momentary wishes that are not the patient’s settled desire
  • Caregivers under exhaustion may project their own readiness onto the patient (or resist it)

Pastoral Concerns

  • Help differentiate killing from allowing to die
  • Honor the patient’s wishes
  • Address requests for hastened death pastorally, not dismissively
  • Refer to legal and medical experts for actual decisions

5. Teaching Content

Life as God’s Gift

The Christian confession is that human life is God’s gift. We did not make ourselves. We were made by God, in his image, breathed into being by his breath (Genesis 2:7). Our bodies are not our possessions to dispose of at will; they are entrusted to us.

This conviction shapes everything that follows.

Choosing Life — But Not at Any Cost

Scripture calls God’s people to “choose life” (Deuteronomy 30:19). The Christian honors life as God’s gift. We do not seek death. We do not kill ourselves or others. The Fifth Commandment binds us.

And yet — Christians have always recognized that there is a time to die (Ecclesiastes 3:2). The body God gave is mortal. The same Christian tradition that forbids the taking of life also recognizes that we are not obligated to artificially extend dying indefinitely.

The classic Christian moral framework distinguishes:

  • Ordinary means — basic comfort, nourishment, hydration, and reasonably effective treatments — should generally be provided.
  • Extraordinary means — invasive, burdensome, or experimental treatments that offer minimal benefit — may legitimately be declined.

What is “ordinary” and what is “extraordinary” depends on the patient’s condition, the likely benefit, and the burdens involved. A treatment that is ordinary for a healthy person may be extraordinary for a patient at the end of life.

Allowing to Die Is Not the Same as Killing

This is one of the most important moral distinctions:

  • Killing is the intentional ending of life. This includes euthanasia and assisted suicide. The Christian tradition does not approve.
  • Allowing to die is the acceptance of mortality when treatments are no longer beneficial. Discontinuing burdensome treatment, choosing not to be resuscitated, declining a feeding tube near the end — these can be acts of faithful acceptance, not acts of self-killing.

Stopping chemotherapy when it is no longer working is not suicide. Choosing not to be put on a ventilator when one is dying of an incurable illness is not killing. Receiving pain medication that may have secondary effects on alertness is not killing.

The intention matters. The act matters. The context matters.

Advance Directives

An advance directive is a document that records your wishes about medical care in the event that you cannot speak for yourself. It is one of the most important gifts you can give your family.

There are several components:

  • Living will — your instructions about specific treatments (e.g., CPR, ventilator, feeding tube) when you are terminally ill or in a permanent vegetative state.
  • Healthcare power of attorney (also called health care proxy) — designation of a person to make medical decisions for you when you cannot. This person should know your values and be willing to advocate for you.
  • POLST or MOST — Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (varies by state) — a medical order that translates your wishes into actionable instructions.
  • DNR — Do Not Resuscitate order — a medical instruction that CPR not be performed.

Every adult should have these documents — not only the dying. Crises do not give warning.

These documents should be:

  • Discussed with family, especially the healthcare power of attorney
  • Shared with your primary physician
  • Kept where they can be found
  • Revisited periodically as health changes

The pastor can encourage but should not draft these documents; refer to elder-care attorneys or hospital social workers.

Specific Treatment Decisions

CPR (Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation)

CPR is dramatic. It is also less successful than television portrays. For frail, elderly, or terminally ill patients, CPR rarely results in meaningful recovery; it can result in broken ribs, prolonged ICU stays, and additional suffering before death.

A DNR order, in this context, is not a refusal of care. It is an acceptance that, when the heart stops, it is time.

Mechanical Ventilation

A ventilator can sustain breathing when the lungs cannot. For some conditions, it is a bridge to recovery. For others, it becomes a long-term life support without meaningful improvement.

Patients can specify in advance whether to be intubated, when to be removed, and under what conditions.

Feeding Tubes and Hydration

Artificial nutrition and hydration are widely misunderstood. Near the end of life, patients often naturally lose appetite and thirst. This is part of the dying process, not starvation. Forcing nutrition can cause more harm than good in late-stage dying.

Some patients and families want artificial nutrition because it feels like care; others recognize it as prolonging dying. There is no single right answer; it depends on context.

Dialysis

For patients with kidney failure, dialysis can sustain life for years. For patients with multiple serious conditions, dialysis may add burden without quality of life. Stopping dialysis is, for some patients, a faithful acceptance of mortality.

Requests for Hastened Death

Some patients say things like:

  • “I wish this were over.”
  • “I don’t want to keep doing this.”
  • “Can you give me something to end it?”

These statements deserve pastoral attention. They are usually not literal requests for assisted suicide. They are often expressions of:

  • Untreated pain
  • Untreated anxiety or depression
  • Existential weariness
  • Fear of being a burden
  • Loss of dignity in current circumstances
  • Loss of meaning

When patients receive excellent palliative care, fear of dying is addressed, family is supportive, and dignity is preserved, requests for hastened death usually diminish.

The pastor should:

  • Receive the statement compassionately.
  • Listen for what is beneath it.
  • Advocate for better pain and symptom management.
  • Engage emotional and spiritual support.
  • Engage family.
  • Not argue or lecture in the moment.
  • Walk faithfully alongside, even when the patient is expressing despair.

In jurisdictions where physician-assisted suicide is legal, the pastor will face this question more directly. The historic Christian conviction is that taking life — whether one’s own or another’s — is not the Christian path. The pastor articulates this conviction with humility, compassion, and pastoral wisdom, not as condemnation but as witness to a different way.

Dignity

Dignity is sometimes spoken of as something the dying lose. The Christian must speak more carefully.

A person retains dignity not because they look dignified, but because they are made in the image of God. The patient unable to feed themselves, unable to control their bodily functions, unable to recognize family — this person bears God’s image as fully as they did at any prior moment of their life. Their worth does not depend on their capacities.

This is one of the great Christian convictions over against contemporary culture’s tendency to equate dignity with autonomy and capability.

That said, the way we care for the dying can dignify or dishonor them:

  • Speaking to them, not over them
  • Calling them by name
  • Using gentle touch and respectful care
  • Maintaining their personal hygiene
  • Preserving privacy
  • Honoring their preferences
  • Including them in conversation when they can engage
  • Treating their body, even after death, with reverence

Dignity is preserved by how others treat the dying, not by whether the dying remain capable.

Autonomy and Christian Freedom

Contemporary medical ethics emphasizes patient autonomy — the patient’s right to make their own decisions. This is a real good. It honors the patient as a moral agent.

The Christian, however, recognizes that autonomy is not absolute. We belong to God, not to ourselves. Our choices about life and death are made before God, not in isolation.

This does not mean the patient’s voice does not matter. It matters enormously. It means the patient’s voice is heard within a community — family, Church, the wisdom of the Christian tradition — and is exercised before God.

Practically, this means:

  • The patient’s wishes should generally be honored.
  • Those wishes should be formed prayerfully, with counsel from family, pastor, and physician.
  • The wishes do not extend to taking life, but they may include accepting death.

The Limits of Pastoral Care

The pastor is not:

  • A lawyer who can draft an advance directive
  • A physician who can prescribe pain management
  • A medical ethicist who can pronounce a verdict on a particular case
  • A financial advisor

The pastor is:

  • A theologically trained guide
  • A faithful presence
  • A bearer of Word and Sacrament
  • An advocate for the patient before God and within the medical system

The pastor refers freely. The pastor stays present.

Final Practical Matters

In addition to medical and legal preparation, the patient and family should consider:

  • Will and estate plan — Distribution of assets; care of dependents
  • Funeral plan — Documented preferences (see Session 6)
  • Digital legacy — Passwords, online accounts, social media
  • Important documents — Location of birth certificate, insurance, deeds
  • Sentimental items — Stories, photographs, possessions to pass on
  • Letters and recordings — Words for the future
  • Forgiveness and reconciliation — (See Session 5)
  • Spiritual preparation — Confession, Communion, anointing (See Session 4)

This is a lot. Take it a piece at a time. Use trusted helpers — an attorney, a funeral director, the pastor, the hospice social worker. None of this needs to be done alone.


6. Reflection Questions

  1. Have you executed an advance directive? Do you have a designated healthcare power of attorney? Does your family know your wishes?
  2. What treatments would you want if there is a reasonable chance of recovery? What treatments would you decline?
  3. Are there specific scenarios — coma, severe dementia, vegetative state — for which you want to give clear instructions in advance?
  4. Have you discussed CPR and DNR with your physician and family?
  5. Are there moments when you have wished this were over? Can you tell me what is beneath that wish?
  6. What does dignity mean to you? What would dishonor your dignity? What would honor it?
  7. How do you understand the difference between killing and allowing to die? Does that distinction help you?
  8. Is there family disagreement about treatment that we should address now, while you can still speak?
  9. Have you executed a will and an estate plan? Are there practical matters still to settle?
  10. What is one ethical or practical question you have been carrying that we have not yet addressed?

7. Worksheet / Homework Assignment

“Faithful Decisions”

A. The Advance Directive Inventory

Answer honestly:

  • Do I have an advance directive? (yes / no / not sure)
  • Do I have a healthcare power of attorney? (yes / no / not sure)
  • Do my family and doctor know my wishes? (yes / no)
  • Have I revisited these documents in the last year? (yes / no)

If any answer is “no” or “not sure,” identify the next step:

  • Talk to my doctor about advance directives
  • Talk to an attorney
  • Contact a hospital or hospice social worker
  • Have a family conversation
  • Locate or update existing documents

B. The Treatment Preferences Conversation

With your healthcare power of attorney, walk through:

  • “If my heart stops and I have a terminal illness, I would / would not want CPR…”
  • “If I cannot breathe on my own, I would / would not want a ventilator…”
  • “If I cannot eat, I would / would not want a feeding tube long-term…”
  • “If I am in a permanent vegetative state, I would / would not want life-sustaining treatments…”
  • “The values that guide my decisions are…”
  • “What matters most to me in my final days is…”

Write this down. Sign and date it. Give a copy to your physician and to your family.

C. The Practical Matters Checklist

Identify which of the following are in place and which are not:

  • Will or estate plan
  • Funeral plan
  • List of accounts, passwords, important documents
  • Letters of love or instruction for specific people
  • Identified executor and family informants
  • Insurance documents accessible
  • Financial accounts and beneficiaries up to date

For each item that is not in place, name the next step and a deadline.

D. The Honest Pastoral Conversation

Bring to your pastor any of the following that is on your heart:

  • A wish you have had to die sooner — and what you think is beneath it
  • An ethical question you have been carrying alone
  • A family disagreement about treatment
  • A fear of losing dignity
  • A fear of being kept alive in a state you would not want

You do not have to resolve any of these on your own.

E. Prayer

Each evening this week, pray:

  • For wisdom in the decisions before you
  • For your healthcare power of attorney
  • For the medical team caring for you
  • For your family, that disagreements would yield to grace
  • For yourself, that you would receive God’s mercy in each moment

8. Review Section for Next Session

Homework Review

  • Did you complete the advance directive inventory? What was the next step?
  • Were you able to have the treatment preferences conversation? With whom?
  • What practical matters have you addressed? What remains?
  • Was there a pastoral conversation we still need?

Spiritual Reflection

  • How is your peace as you face these decisions?
  • Where did you sense God’s wisdom or presence this week?
  • What grief surfaced as you faced these realities?

Accountability Questions

  • Are the people who will speak for you fully informed?
  • Are there pieces of the puzzle still missing — legal, medical, family, spiritual?
  • Is there a conversation we still need to have?
  • Is there anything else God seems to be putting on your heart?

  • Allen Verhey — The Christian Art of Dying
  • Gilbert Meilaender — Bioethics: A Primer for Christians
  • Atul Gawande — Being Mortal
  • Ira Byock — Dying Well and The Best Care Possible
  • Lewis Smedes — My God and I, on aging and accepting limits
  • The Five Wishes advance directive (widely available)
  • Your state’s POLST or MOST resources

10. Closing Prayer

Almighty God, Lord of life and death, you have given us this day, and you alone know how many days remain. You are the giver of every breath; you are the one to whom every breath returns. We are not our own. We belong to you, in life and in death. Grant us wisdom in the decisions before us. Strengthen those who must speak for us when we cannot. Guide the physicians, nurses, attorneys, and caregivers who serve us. Save us from fear that distorts our choices, and from despair that hardens our hearts. Give us hands willing to receive what you give and to release what you take. Hold this beloved child of yours in dignity that does not depend on capacity, but on your image stamped upon every human soul. And when our hour comes, grant us, by your mercy, a peaceful end and a faithful death, in the sure and certain hope of the resurrection. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and forever. Amen.

Topics
Death and GriefMarriage and FamilyAnxiety, Fear, and Doubt
Scripture
Genesis 1:26–27Deuteronomy 30:19–20Job 1:21Psalm 139:13–16Ecclesiastes 3:1–21 Corinthians 6:19–20Philippians 1:21–242 Timothy 4:6–8John 10:11Romans 14:7–8Matthew 5:21–22Romans 12:1Genesis 2:7Deuteronomy 30:19Ecclesiastes 3:2
Confessions
SC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.