Pastoral Care · Depression Anxiety
Session 4 — Lament: The Honest Cry to God
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
2. Session Overview
Purpose
To recover the biblical practice of lament — the honest, raw, even protesting prayer of God’s people in the dark. Many counselees have been taught that “real” prayer is grateful, composed, or victorious. They lack a category for prayer that is angry, confused, or despairing. As a result, they often stop praying altogether when depression and anxiety are loudest. This session restores lament as a faithful and necessary form of prayer.
Emotional Focus
- Giving voice to grief, fear, anger, and confusion.
- Releasing the pressure to sound spiritual in prayer.
- Discovering that honesty is welcomed by God.
Theological Focus
- Lament as a biblical, Spirit-inspired form of prayer.
- The Psalter as the church’s school of honest prayer.
- Christ as the One who prayed lament from the cross.
Practical Goals
- Pray a lament Psalm aloud.
- Write a personal lament.
- Build lament into the counselee’s regular prayer practice.
Expected Outcomes
- Recovery of a prayer life that had likely gone silent or stilted.
- New permission to be honest with God.
- An entry point back into the Psalter.
3. Biblical Foundation
Primary Texts
- Psalm 13 — “How long, O Lord? Will you forget me forever?”
- Psalm 88 — A lament that ends in darkness.
- Lamentations 3:1–24 — The honest cry that turns, at last, to remembered mercy.
Supporting Texts
- Psalm 6
- Psalm 22
- Psalm 42–43
- Psalm 77
- Psalm 130
- Habakkuk 1:1–4
- Jeremiah 20:7–18
- Matthew 26:36–46
- Mark 15:33–34
Themes
- Honest speech before God
- The structure of biblical lament
- God’s invitation into raw prayer
- Christ’s own lament
4. Confessional Lutheran Foundations
Small Catechism
- Lord’s Prayer, Introduction — “With these words God tenderly invites us to believe that He is our true Father and that we are His true children, so that we may ask Him as dear children ask their dear father.”
- Seventh Petition — “Deliver us from evil” — including the inner evils of despair and dread.
Large Catechism
- LC III, 4–14 — Prayer is not a work we offer but a response God commands and invites.
- LC III, 121–124 — Even bold and trembling prayers are heard.
Augsburg Confession
- Article XX — Faith is not absence of struggle; it is trust amid struggle.
Pastoral Application
- The Lutheran tradition prays the entire Psalter — including its laments. The Daily Office and Liturgy of the Hours preserve psalms of sorrow, anger, and confusion as central to the church’s prayer life.
- Luther wrote, “I do not know how to pray — but the Psalter teaches me.”
5. Counseling Themes
Emotional Issues
- Grief that has not been allowed expression.
- Anger toward God that has been suppressed under “appropriate” piety.
- Shame at not being able to pray “well.”
Relational Dynamics
- The hidden gulf between public prayer life and private prayer life.
- The loneliness of feeling one cannot say in church what one feels in private.
Spiritual Struggles
- Belief that honest prayer is irreverent.
- Fear that anger toward God will be punished.
- The collapse of prayer altogether under depression’s weight.
Psychological Considerations
- The cognitive and energetic cost of suppression — keeping real feelings hidden takes enormous effort.
- The therapeutic effect of giving suffering words.
Pastoral Concerns
- Do not push the counselee to feel grateful or hopeful before they are ready.
- Hold space for unresolved laments. The Bible itself does.
6. Teaching Content
A Forgotten Language
About one third of the Psalms are laments. They are prayers of complaint, sorrow, fear, anger, and desperate appeal. They cry out to God in language that, if we encountered it in a modern church, we might consider inappropriate or even blasphemous.
“How long, O Lord? Will you forget me forever?” (Psalm 13:1)
“Why do you hide your face from me?” (Psalm 88:14)
“I am utterly bowed down and prostrate; all the day I go about mourning.” (Psalm 38:6)
“My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” (Psalm 22:1)
These prayers are in the Bible. The Holy Spirit inspired them. The church has prayed them for three thousand years. And yet many modern believers have lost the language of lament entirely. We have been taught that prayer should be grateful, composed, and victorious. We have not been taught that prayer can be — and often is — wounded, raw, and incomplete.
The result is that when depression or anxiety hits, many of us simply stop praying. We have no category for what we feel. We do not believe God wants to hear it. So we go silent, and the silence amplifies the suffering.
Lament restores prayer to those who have lost it. It says: God can take it. God invites it. God is not afraid of your honesty. He has been hearing it from His people for millennia.
The Shape of Biblical Lament
Most biblical laments follow a recognizable pattern (though not always in this order):
-
Address — “O Lord,” “My God,” “How long, O God.” The lament is spoken to God, not just about Him. This itself is an act of faith.
-
Complaint — Honest description of what is wrong. “I am weary with my moaning; every night I flood my bed with tears” (Ps. 6:6). The complaint may be about circumstances, about enemies, about the self, or about God.
-
Petition — A specific request. “Be gracious to me, O Lord, for I am languishing; heal me” (Ps. 6:2).
-
Expression of trust — A remembering of who God has been and is. “But I have trusted in your steadfast love” (Ps. 13:5).
-
Vow of praise — A promise to praise God, often before the rescue has come. “I will sing to the Lord, because he has dealt bountifully with me” (Ps. 13:6).
But notice: not every lament reaches every stage. Psalm 88 never gets to praise. It ends: “You have caused my beloved and my friend to shun me; my companions have become darkness.” That is the last verse. The Spirit allowed it to be so.
This means: a lament that does not end in resolution is still a lament. It is still prayer. It is still received.
Permission to Be Honest
Many counselees need explicit permission from a pastor to pray honestly. Permission to say:
- “I am terrified.”
- “I cannot feel You.”
- “I do not understand.”
- “I am angry.”
- “I cannot do this anymore.”
- “Where are You?”
This permission is not the pastor’s to give or withhold — God has already given it, in His own inspired Word. But many believers need to hear it from a pastor to believe it is real.
Hear it now: You are permitted to pray honestly. The Psalms are filled with prayers as raw as anything you feel. God invites this from you. He does not shame it. He does not punish it. He receives it as the prayer of a child to a Father.
Christ Our Lamenter
If we still doubt whether lament is appropriate, we look to the cross.
Jesus, hanging on the cross, prayed: “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” These were not new words. He was praying Psalm 22 — the great lament Psalm. He was praying the prayer of His people in the place where prayer seemed most impossible.
This means: the most faithful Person who ever lived prayed lament. The Son of God, in His humanity, modeled honest cry in the face of suffering. He did not pretend. He did not perform a smile. He cried out in the language of the Psalter, and the Father heard Him.
When you lament, you join Christ. When you pray Psalm 22, you pray with Christ. When you say “How long, O Lord?”, you stand in the company of the prophets, the apostles, and your Savior.
Why Lament Heals
Lament is not just permitted; it is healing.
- It externalizes the internal. What stays inside grows. What is spoken can begin to be metabolized.
- It maintains relationship. Even an angry prayer is still a prayer. The relationship is preserved by the speech, however raw.
- It refuses the lie that God can only hear our composed selves. It teaches us that we are loved as we are, not as we pretend to be.
- It joins us to the saints. The same prayers we pray today, others have prayed for millennia. We are not alone.
- It eventually opens to hope. Not always immediately. Not always in the same prayer. But over time, the lament makes room for the trust that follows.
A Word About Anger Toward God
Some counselees fear that anger toward God is a sin. The Psalms suggest otherwise. Psalm 44 accuses God of having “rejected and disgraced” His people. Psalm 88 ends with the complaint that God has caused the suffering. Jeremiah accuses God of having “deceived” him.
These are inspired words. They show us that God can absorb our anger. He is not threatened by it. What He asks is that we bring it to Him, rather than turning away from Him in silent withdrawal.
Anger turned toward God in prayer keeps the relationship alive. Anger turned away from God in silence destroys the relationship.
The Psalms train us to do the first.
How to Pray a Lament
There is no single right way. But here are some entry points.
-
Pray a lament Psalm aloud. Start with Psalm 13. Read it slowly, in the first person, as your own prayer. Do not rush past the hard verses.
-
Write your own lament using the biblical shape:
- Address God by name.
- Tell Him what is wrong, in plain language.
- Ask Him for what you need, specifically.
- Remember, if you can, one thing about who He has been.
- End however you can — even if the ending is unresolved.
-
Sing a lament. Lutheran hymnody is rich in laments and prayers from the depths. Try “Out of the Depths I Cry to Thee” (LSB 607) or “Why Should Cross and Trial Grieve Me?” (LSB 756).
-
Pray with the church. Use Compline, Vespers, or the Daily Office. Pray the appointed Psalms even when you do not feel them. The words carry you when you cannot carry yourself.
-
Let silence be lament. Sometimes the prayer is no words at all, just sitting with the weight in God’s presence. That is also prayer. The Spirit Himself intercedes “with groanings too deep for words” (Rom. 8:26).
What This Changes
If lament becomes part of your prayer life:
- You are no longer forced to choose between honesty and prayer.
- You no longer fall silent when prayer is most needed.
- You learn to speak with God in the dark, not just in the light.
- You join the company of the saints who have always prayed this way.
Prayer becomes wider. The voice of the praying self becomes more real. And, slowly, the inner life becomes less lonely.
7. Reflection Questions
- Were you ever taught — explicitly or implicitly — that prayer should sound a certain way? Where did that come from?
- What kinds of things do you not say to God in prayer? Why?
- When did you last pray in a way that felt completely honest? What was the situation?
- Read Psalm 13 slowly. Which verse most resonates with you? Which most unsettles you?
- Have you ever felt angry with God? Have you ever spoken that anger to Him? Why or why not?
- What does it do to your understanding of Christ to remember that He prayed lament from the cross?
- Are there any losses, fears, or angers in your life that you have not yet brought into prayer?
- Read Lamentations 3:1–24. How does the move from verses 1–20 to verses 21–24 land in you? Does it feel earned, premature, or somewhere in between?
- What might it look like for you to add lament to your prayer practice this week?
- Who else might benefit from learning that lament is faithful prayer?
8. Worksheet / Homework Assignment
Worksheet 4 — Learning to Lament
Part 1 — Praying a Psalm
Each day this week, pray one of the following Psalms aloud. Read slowly. Do not rush.
- Day 1: Psalm 13
- Day 2: Psalm 6
- Day 3: Psalm 42–43
- Day 4: Psalm 77
- Day 5: Psalm 130
- Day 6: Psalm 88
- Day 7: Psalm 22
After each one, write one sentence:
What this Psalm gave me words for: ________________________________
Part 2 — Writing Your Own Lament
This week, write a lament of your own. Use the structure below as a guide. You do not need every section, but try at least to address God, name the trouble, and ask for what you need.
Address: O Lord, _______________________________________________
Complaint: What is wrong? Speak plainly. Do not soften.
Petition: What do you need from God? Be specific.
Remembering: What is one true thing about God you can still say, even faintly?
Closing: End however you can. If you cannot say “Amen” with full confidence, you may simply say, “I bring this to You. Amen.”
Part 3 — A Sung Lament
This week, listen to or sing one of the following hymns. Read the text aloud first.
- “Out of the Depths I Cry to Thee” (LSB 607)
- “Why Should Cross and Trial Grieve Me?” (LSB 756)
- “If Thou But Trust in God to Guide Thee” (LSB 750)
- “Lord, Thee I Love with All My Heart” (LSB 708)
Which did you choose? ___________________________________
What stayed with you? ___________________________________
Part 4 — Permitting Anger
If you are carrying anger toward God, write it down. Not for anyone else’s eyes — for your own honesty before God.
The honest thing I want to say to God:
Now pray it. Aloud, if you can. God can take it.
Part 5 — Quiet Lament
Once this week, sit in silence for ten minutes. Bring your burden into the room with you. Do not speak. Do not perform. Simply sit in God’s presence with what you carry.
When did you do this? ___________________________________
What happened? ___________________________________
9. Review Section for Next Session
Homework Review
- Which Psalm spoke to you most this week? Why?
- Were you able to write your own lament? What did writing it feel like?
- What hymn did you choose, and what stayed with you?
- Did you give voice to anger or hidden grief that you had not voiced before?
- How was the silent time?
Progress Evaluation
- Has your prayer life shifted in any way this week?
- Did anything that was bottled up find expression?
- What resistance came up — to writing, to praying, to feeling?
Emotional Check-In
- How are you arriving today?
- What is the loudest emotion right now?
Spiritual Reflection
- Where did you sense God hearing you this week?
- Did any verse, hymn, or moment land as personal address?
Accountability Questions
- Were there feelings you almost wrote down but did not? (You don’t have to share what — just notice.)
- Is there a lament still waiting to be prayed?
10. Recommended Readings
Scripture
- The Psalms of Lament: 3, 6, 13, 22, 38, 42–43, 51, 69, 77, 88, 102, 130, 143
- Lamentations (especially chapter 3)
- Job 3, 7, 10
- Jeremiah 15:10–21; 20:7–18
- Habakkuk 1–3
Lutheran Sources
- Luther’s Preface to the Psalter
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Psalms: The Prayer Book of the Bible
- Treasury of Daily Prayer (CPH) — the appointed psalmody
- Hymn studies on “Out of the Depths” and “Why Should Cross and Trial Grieve Me?”
Pastoral Care Resources
- Michael Card, A Sacred Sorrow
- Mark Vroegop, Dark Clouds, Deep Mercy
- Walter Brueggemann, The Message of the Psalms (with discernment)
- Eugene Peterson, Answering God: The Psalms as Tools for Prayer
11. Closing Prayer
O Lord, our God, You who hear the cry of Your people — You who received the lament of David, of Jeremiah, of Job, and of Your own Son from the cross — receive now the cry of Your servant.
Where there has been silence, give us words. Where there has been polished prayer, give us honest prayer. Where there has been suppressed grief or anger, give us courage to bring it to You.
Teach us the language of the Psalms. Teach us to pray with the saints and the prophets. Teach us to cry out, even when we cannot resolve the cry.
And in the depth of our lament, remind us: Christ Himself prayed Psalm 22 from the cross, and the Father did not turn away. So You will not turn away from us.
In Jesus’ name, who is our Savior and our Brother in suffering, Amen.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.