Pastoral Care · Depression Anxiety

Session 2 — The Theology of the Cross and the Suffering Soul

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

2. Session Overview

Purpose

To introduce the counselee to the theology of the cross as the frame for understanding their suffering. Many counselees have been shaped, often unconsciously, by a theology of glory — the belief that faith should produce visible victory, that suffering signals divine displeasure, and that strong Christians do not struggle. This session dismantles that framework and replaces it with the historic Lutheran conviction that God reveals Himself precisely in suffering, weakness, and apparent hiddenness.

Emotional Focus

  • Releasing the burden of needing to appear strong or victorious.
  • Allowing suffering to be real without it being shameful.
  • Recognizing that mental anguish does not place one outside God’s love.

Theological Focus

  • The distinction between theology of glory and theology of the cross.
  • God revealed in hiddenness — Deus absconditus.
  • The suffering of Christ as solidarity, not distance.

Practical Goals

  • Identify where the counselee has internalized a theology of glory.
  • Begin to receive suffering as a place of meeting Christ, not avoiding Him.
  • Strengthen the counselee’s capacity to sit with what cannot be quickly fixed.

Expected Outcomes

  • A clearer theological vocabulary for what the counselee is experiencing.
  • Reduction of the shame that comes from believing “real Christians don’t struggle.”
  • Increased honesty in prayer and self-talk.

3. Biblical Foundation

Primary Texts

  • Isaiah 53:3 — “He was despised and rejected by men, a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief.”
  • 2 Corinthians 12:7–10 — Paul’s thorn in the flesh and the grace that is sufficient.
  • Mark 15:33–34 — Christ’s cry of abandonment from the cross.

Supporting Texts

  • Job 13:15
  • Psalm 22
  • Romans 8:18–28
  • 2 Corinthians 4:7–18
  • Hebrews 4:14–16
  • Hebrews 5:7–8

Themes

  • The Suffering Servant
  • The hiddenness of God in suffering
  • Christ’s solidarity with the afflicted
  • Grace sufficient in weakness
  • Glory revealed through, not in spite of, the cross

4. Confessional Lutheran Foundations

Small Catechism

  • Apostles’ Creed, Article II — “He suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died, and was buried.”
  • Lord’s Prayer, Seventh Petition — “Deliver us from evil,” including the inward evils of despair and assault.

Large Catechism

  • LC III, 113–119 — On the Seventh Petition: deliverance from “every evil of body and soul, possessions and reputation.”

Augsburg Confession

  • Article IV — Justification — Righteousness is by grace through faith, not by emotional strength.
  • Article XX — Faith and Good Works — Faith is not the absence of struggle; it is trust in Christ amid struggle.

Heidelberg Disputation (Luther, 1518)

  • Thesis 19: “That person does not deserve to be called a theologian who looks upon the invisible things of God as though they were clearly perceptible in those things which have actually happened.”
  • Thesis 20: “He deserves to be called a theologian, however, who comprehends the visible and manifest things of God seen through suffering and the cross.”
  • Thesis 21: “A theologian of glory calls evil good and good evil. A theologian of the cross calls the thing what it actually is.”

Pastoral Application

  • A theology of glory tells the depressed counselee: “Cheer up. Believe more. Praise harder.”
  • A theology of the cross tells the depressed counselee: “Christ is here, in this very darkness. He has been here before you. He has not abandoned this place.”

5. Counseling Themes

Emotional Issues

  • The shame of “not measuring up” as a Christian.
  • The exhaustion of pretending to be okay.
  • The grief of unmet expectations about what faith would feel like.

Relational Dynamics

  • The hidden loneliness of believers who feel they cannot speak honestly in their congregations.
  • The mismatch between the testimonies they hear and the life they live.

Spiritual Struggles

  • The belief that suffering signals God’s displeasure.
  • The sense that God is absent precisely when most needed.
  • The fear that one is “doing faith wrong.”

Psychological Considerations

  • Internalized perfectionism around emotional and spiritual life.
  • Cognitive distortions that read every dark thought as evidence of damnation.

Pastoral Concerns

  • Avoid speaking of suffering in ways that romanticize or aestheticize it.
  • Do not press the counselee to “find God in suffering” before they are ready. The theology of the cross is a place to stand, not a slogan to deliver.

6. Teaching Content

Two Theologies

In 1518, an Augustinian monk named Martin Luther presented a series of theses at Heidelberg. Among them, he drew a distinction that would shape the entire Lutheran tradition. He distinguished between two kinds of theologians: a theologian of glory and a theologian of the cross.

A theologian of glory looks for God in strength, success, victory, and the obvious markers of divine favor. If life is going well, God must be pleased. If life is going badly, God must be displeased. If you suffer, you must be doing something wrong. If you are depressed, you must lack faith. If you are anxious, you must not trust God enough.

A theologian of the cross looks for God where God has actually promised to be found — and God has promised to be found in the most unlikely of places: a manger, a stable, a cross, a tomb. God reveals Himself not in glittering success but in suffering love. God shows His glory not by avoiding the dust but by entering it.

Luther wrote: “A theologian of glory calls evil good and good evil. A theologian of the cross calls the thing what it actually is.”

This is liberating. It means we do not have to pretend. We do not have to call our depression a “season of joy.” We do not have to spin our anxiety into testimony. We can call the thing what it actually is — and we can find Christ there.

Where Is God in Your Suffering?

The theology of the cross insists that God is not absent from your suffering. He is hidden in it. There is a difference.

God’s hiddenness in suffering is not abandonment. It is the way He chooses to come close. He came down into our flesh. He took on our exhaustion. He wept at the tomb of His friend. He sweat blood in the garden. He cried from the cross, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”

That cry — that very cry — is the cry of a soul that knows what depression feels like. The Son of God Himself, in His humanity, experienced abandonment so profound that He could not feel the presence of His Father.

And yet the Father had not abandoned Him. The Father was most present in that moment of greatest hiddenness. The cross looks like absence, but it is the deepest presence of love that has ever existed.

Your depression and anxiety are not signs of God’s absence. They are places where God meets you in a particular way — not with the victorious flourish you might expect, but with the patient solidarity of a Savior who has been there.

The Sufficient Grace

In 2 Corinthians 12, Paul writes about a “thorn in the flesh” — some affliction whose nature he does not name. He prayed three times for it to be removed. It was not. Instead, he received a word from the Lord:

“My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.”

Notice what God did not say. God did not say:

  • “Try harder.”
  • “Pray better.”
  • “If your faith were stronger, this would be gone.”
  • “Discover the hidden sin and repent.”

God said: My grace is sufficient. The thorn stayed. The grace was enough.

Paul concludes: “For the sake of Christ, then, I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and calamities. For when I am weak, then I am strong.”

This is not pious posturing. It is theology of the cross. Paul has learned that the place of weakness is the place where Christ’s strength becomes most real. He does not love the thorn. He has come to know the Christ who meets him in the thorn.

Calling the Thing What It Is

A theology of glory cannot bear to call depression “depression.” It must rename it: a “season of pruning,” a “spiritual desert,” a “test of faith.” There is nothing wrong with any of these phrases as descriptions of meaning. There is something wrong with using them to deny the reality of mental illness.

You are permitted to say:

  • “I am depressed.”
  • “I am anxious.”
  • “I am exhausted.”
  • “I cannot pray right now.”
  • “I am afraid I will not survive this.”

Calling the thing what it is does not diminish faith. It is honesty before God. The Psalms are full of such honesty. Psalm 88, possibly the darkest text in the Bible, ends without resolution: “You have caused my beloved and my friend to shun me; my companions have become darkness.” That is the last verse. No “but God.” No upturn. Just darkness.

And yet Psalm 88 is in the Bible. The Holy Spirit inspired it. The Spirit wanted this prayer to be in the prayer book of the church forever — because God’s people need permission to pray in the dark.

What This Changes

If suffering is not a sign of God’s displeasure, then you do not have to fight your way out of it to be acceptable to Him. You are already accepted, in Christ, by grace, through faith.

If God is hidden in suffering rather than absent from it, then your depression and anxiety are not the end of the spiritual life. They are a strange chapter of it.

If grace is sufficient in weakness, then you do not need to wait until you are strong to receive it.

This does not mean we stop seeking healing. It means we stop treating healing as the precondition for God’s love.

Holding Both

The theology of the cross is not the celebration of suffering. Lutheran Christianity is not masochism. We do not believe that suffering is good in itself. We pray for healing. We pursue treatment. We long for the day when every tear is wiped from every eye.

But while we wait, we live by the cross. We trust that the same Christ who entered the depths has not left them. We trust that grace is enough for today. We trust that even when God seems hidden, He is keeping us.

This week, we will practice calling the thing what it is, and trusting that Christ is here.


7. Reflection Questions

  1. Did you grow up with explicit or implicit teaching that “good Christians” should not be depressed or anxious? Where did that come from?
  2. What does it feel like in your body when you read that “a theologian of the cross calls the thing what it actually is”?
  3. Where in your life have you been calling the thing something other than what it is, in order to seem more spiritual?
  4. What would it mean to say, out loud, “I am depressed” or “I am anxious,” without immediately softening it?
  5. When you think of Christ in Gethsemane or on the cross, does He feel like someone who understands your suffering, or someone who is distant from it?
  6. Have you prayed for God to remove your depression or anxiety? What has it been like when it has not been removed?
  7. What might it mean for grace to be sufficient — not glorious, not victorious, but sufficient — for your today?
  8. Where in your suffering have you sensed any whisper of God, even faintly?
  9. Are there people in your life who allow you to be honest about your struggle? Are there places where you cannot?
  10. What is one expectation about the Christian life that you may need to grieve in order to receive grace as it actually comes?

8. Worksheet / Homework Assignment

Worksheet 2 — Calling the Thing What It Is

Part 1 — Renaming

List three ways you have softened, spiritualized, or hidden what is actually happening for you. Then, beside each, write what the honest name would be.

Softened version Honest name
Example: “I’m just in a season of refining.” “I am depressed and have been for months.”

Part 2 — Where Is Christ?

Read 2 Corinthians 12:7–10 slowly, three times.

Write below where you might be tempted to think Christ is absent — and consider whether He might be hidden there instead.

A place where I feel He is absent: ________________________________

A possibility that He is hidden there: ________________________________

Part 3 — A Psalm in the Dark

Read Psalm 88 in full. Notice that it does not resolve.

Write your own honest sentence — one sentence — that could belong in such a Psalm. Do not soften it.


Now read Psalm 22 in full. Notice how Christ Himself quoted its opening verse from the cross.

Write down: What does it mean to you that Christ Himself prayed words of despair?


Part 4 — A Daily Practice

This week, once per day, say aloud (alone or in prayer):

“Lord Jesus, You are the Man of Sorrows. You are acquainted with grief. You are not afraid of mine. Be near to me today.”

Note any day this prayer felt different — easier, harder, or surprising.

Part 5 — One Honest Conversation

Identify one trusted person (spouse, friend, fellow believer, the pastor) with whom you could say one true sentence about your current state this week. Just one sentence. Plan it ahead of time if needed.

The person: ________________________________

The sentence I might say: ________________________________


9. Review Section for Next Session

Homework Review

  • Which softened phrases did you identify? Was it difficult to write the honest names?
  • Where did you sense Christ hidden in something you thought He had abandoned?
  • What was it like to read Psalm 88 without a resolution?
  • How did the daily prayer go?
  • Did you have the one honest conversation? What happened?

Progress Evaluation

  • Has anything shifted in how you think about your suffering this week?
  • What resistance came up?

Emotional Check-In

  • How are you arriving today?
  • What is heaviest right now?

Spiritual Reflection

  • Where did Christ feel near this week, however faintly?
  • Where did He feel far?
  • What Scripture stayed with you?

Accountability Questions

  • Did you find yourself slipping back into a theology of glory? When?
  • Is there anything from last week’s worksheet that we should revisit before moving forward?

Scripture

  • 2 Corinthians 12:1–10
  • Mark 14:32–42
  • Hebrews 4:14–16
  • Hebrews 5:7–10

Lutheran Sources

  • Gerhard O. Forde, On Being a Theologian of the Cross
  • Luther, Heidelberg Disputation, Theses 19–22
  • Hermann Sasse, “The Theology of the Cross” (selected essay)

Pastoral Care Resources

  • Kathryn Greene-McCreight, Darkness Is My Only Companion, on God’s hiddenness
  • Zack Eswine, Spurgeon’s Sorrows, on the comfort of being known
  • Henri Nouwen, The Wounded Healer, selected chapters

11. Closing Prayer

Lord Jesus Christ, Man of Sorrows, acquainted with grief — You did not despise the dust. You did not flinch from the cross. You cried out in the dark from the depths of human anguish, and Your Father did not abandon You even when You could not feel His presence.

Meet Your servant tonight in the very place that feels emptiest. Be hidden where You must be hidden, but be present. Teach us to call the thing what it is. Teach us not to be afraid of honesty before You. Teach us to trust that grace is enough — not glorious, not victorious, but enough — for this day.

We do not ask for a faith that pretends. We ask for a faith that clings. Hold us, even when we cannot hold You.

In Your strong name we pray, Amen.

Topics
Suffering and TrialAnxiety, Fear, and Doubt
Scripture
Isaiah 53:32 Corinthians 12:7–10Mark 15:33–34Job 13:15Psalm 22Romans 8:18–282 Corinthians 4:7–18Hebrews 4:14–16Hebrews 5:7–8Psalm 882 Corinthians 12:1–10Mark 14:32–42Hebrews 5:7–10
Confessions
LC IIISCLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.