Pastoral Care · Depression Anxiety
Referral Guidelines
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Depression and Anxiety Counseling Track
Foundational Principle
Pastoral care of the depressed and anxious is a sacred and essential ministry. It is also, by itself, often insufficient. Depression and anxiety frequently involve biological, neurological, traumatic, and relational dimensions that require professional treatment. The pastor’s role is to provide spiritual companionship and care; the therapist’s, physician’s, and psychiatrist’s roles are to provide clinical treatment. These callings are not competitors. They are colleagues.
A pastor who refers wisely is not abandoning their counselee. They are loving them well.
When Referral Is Required
The pastor should refer when any of the following are present:
Immediate / Emergency Referral
- Active suicidal ideation with plan or intent.
- Recent suicide attempt or active self-harm.
- Homicidal ideation toward another person.
- Psychosis (hallucinations, delusions, severe disorganization).
- Catatonia or severe psychomotor slowing.
- Severe dissociation or loss of contact with reality.
- Acute panic that does not resolve and impairs basic functioning.
- Imminent threat to safety from another person (domestic violence).
In any of these, contact emergency services or arrange immediate transport to a psychiatric emergency department. Do not delay.
Urgent (Within Days) Referral
- Persistent suicidal ideation without immediate plan.
- Severe depression with inability to perform self-care.
- New or worsening symptoms despite current treatment.
- Disclosure of abuse (recent or ongoing).
- Significant substance use or withdrawal symptoms.
- Pregnancy or postpartum period with severe symptoms.
- Disclosure of trauma that destabilizes the counselee.
Standard Referral
- Symptoms that persist or worsen despite pastoral care.
- A counselee already on psychiatric medication who has not seen their prescriber recently.
- A counselee who has never been clinically evaluated for symptoms suggestive of clinical depression or anxiety.
- A counselee whose depression is connected to long-standing trauma.
- A counselee whose suffering exceeds the pastor’s competency, time, or emotional capacity.
- A counselee whose case raises ethical or boundary concerns for the pastor.
When Pastoral Care Continues Alongside Referral
In most cases, referral does not end pastoral care; it complements it. The pastor remains the spiritual companion and steward of Word and Sacrament. Concurrent care should be the norm, not the exception.
Roles in Concurrent Care
- Pastor — spiritual formation, Word and Sacrament, lament and prayer, vocation, theological clarity, congregational connection.
- Therapist / Counselor — emotional processing, cognitive and behavioral strategies, trauma work, relational patterns.
- Psychiatrist / Prescriber — diagnosis, medication evaluation and management, biological treatment.
- Primary Care Physician — physical health, sleep, thyroid, hormonal, neurological screening.
- Specialists as needed — trauma, addiction, eating disorders, domestic violence.
Indicators That Suggest Specific Types of Referral
Refer to a Primary Care Physician When:
- The counselee has not had a recent physical exam.
- Symptoms began with a medication change.
- There are physical symptoms (fatigue, weight change, GI distress) that may have a medical cause.
- The counselee is on multiple medications that may interact.
- The counselee is in perimenopause, postpartum, or other significant hormonal transitions.
- Thyroid, vitamin D, B12, or other deficiencies have not been ruled out.
Refer to a Psychiatrist When:
- Symptoms are moderate to severe and persistent.
- A medication evaluation is appropriate.
- The counselee is already on psychiatric medication that may need adjustment.
- There is a history of bipolar features, psychosis, or significant medication complications.
- The counselee has not responded to first-line treatment.
- There is a complex psychiatric history.
Refer to a Licensed Therapist or Counselor When:
- The counselee would benefit from sustained weekly clinical care.
- Trauma is present.
- There are persistent relational or behavioral patterns the counselee wants to address.
- The counselee would benefit from cognitive-behavioral, EMDR, IFS, or other evidence-based modalities.
- The pastor’s available time or competency is exceeded.
Refer to a Christian Therapist When:
- The counselee specifically requests integration of faith and therapy.
- Theological themes are deeply entangled with clinical themes.
- Trust with secular providers is difficult for this counselee.
Note: A Christian therapist is not always better than a non-Christian one. Competence, fit, and ethical practice matter most. A faithful Christian can flourish with a non-Christian therapist who respects their faith; an incompetent Christian therapist can do real harm.
Refer to Specialized Care When:
- Substance use — Specialized addiction treatment, intensive outpatient programs, or residential care.
- Eating disorders — Specialized eating disorder treatment teams.
- Trauma — Trauma-informed therapists trained in EMDR, prolonged exposure, or somatic modalities.
- Domestic violence — Domestic violence advocates and safe-housing resources.
- Postpartum — Perinatal mental health specialists.
Emergency Response Guidance
Suicide Risk
When suicidality is present:
- Stay with the counselee. Do not leave them alone if risk is acute.
- Ask directly. Plan? Means? Timeline?
- Connect to emergency services if imminent.
- 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (U.S.) — call or text 988
- 911 for immediate threat
- Local psychiatric emergency department
- Notify a trusted family member or friend with the counselee’s permission, or without it if necessary to preserve life.
- Reduce access to means (firearms removed from home, medications secured).
- Develop a safety plan before the counselee leaves your presence:
- Warning signs
- Internal coping strategies
- People and places that provide distraction
- People to ask for help
- Professionals and crisis lines
- Steps to make the environment safe
- Follow up within 24 hours.
Abuse Disclosure
- Listen without interrupting.
- Believe the disclosure.
- Affirm the courage it took to speak.
- Be honest about reporting obligations.
- Connect with appropriate authorities and advocates.
- Continue pastoral presence and care.
Domestic Violence
- Prioritize safety, not reconciliation.
- Do not call the abusive partner without the survivor’s explicit consent and safety planning.
- Connect with a domestic violence advocate.
- Know local shelters and resources.
- Do not counsel the couple together while abuse is active.
Acute Substance Use Crisis
- Recognize signs of overdose, withdrawal, or intoxication.
- Call emergency services if there is medical danger.
- Refer to detox and treatment resources.
Building a Local Referral Network
Every pastor in this ministry should develop and maintain a current list of:
- Two or three trusted Christian therapists in the area.
- Two or three trusted licensed counselors (Christian or otherwise) known for ethical practice.
- At least one psychiatrist or psychiatric nurse practitioner accepting new patients.
- Local primary care physicians known for pastoral sensitivity.
- Local psychiatric emergency department(s).
- Local crisis lines and mobile crisis teams.
- Local substance use treatment programs (outpatient and residential).
- Local domestic violence resources and shelters.
- Local trauma-informed therapists.
- Local support groups (NAMI, Celebrate Recovery, grief groups, etc.).
This list should be reviewed and updated at least annually.
How to Make a Referral
Internally Prepare
- Be ready to name what you are recommending and why.
- Anticipate the counselee’s resistance or fear.
In the Conversation
- Frame referral as expansion of care, not replacement:
“I want to keep walking with you spiritually. And I also want you to have a doctor / therapist / psychiatrist on your team. This isn’t because you’ve failed. It’s because you deserve the best care available.”
- Offer specific names rather than vague suggestions.
- Help the counselee make the first call from your office if possible.
- Address financial and insurance barriers honestly. If the counselee cannot afford care, work to find sliding-scale, community mental health, or church-supported options.
Follow-Up
- Check in at the next session: “Did you reach out? How did it go?”
- Persist gently if barriers arise.
- Do not let referral become a closed door.
Collaborative Care Principles
Communication Between Providers
- With the counselee’s written permission, communicate with their treatment team.
- Use a simple release-of-information form.
- Keep communication brief, respectful, and focused on coordination.
- Avoid contradicting clinical recommendations from the pastoral role.
Respecting Scope
- The pastor does not diagnose.
- The pastor does not recommend medication changes.
- The pastor does not provide clinical psychotherapy.
- The pastor does provide spiritual care, Word and Sacrament, prayer, presence, and theological framing.
Avoiding Triangulation
- Do not allow the counselee to play providers against one another.
- If conflicts arise (e.g., a therapist advises something the pastor disagrees with), address it directly with the counselee and, with permission, with the other provider.
When Treatment Recommendations Conflict with Faith
- Most evidence-based mental health treatment does not conflict with Christian faith.
- If a specific recommendation raises legitimate concerns (e.g., advice to abandon faith community, advice toward immoral behavior), name it pastorally and work with the counselee to advocate for a different therapist or approach.
- Do not encourage the counselee to abandon treatment over minor cultural friction.
A Pastoral Theology of Referral
Some pastors hesitate to refer because they feel it is an admission of inadequacy. This is theologically misguided.
- God works through means. He gives bread through bakers, healing through physicians, comfort through neighbors, and mental health through therapists and medications.
- The doctrine of vocation teaches that secular callings are God’s masks (larva Dei). The therapist, psychiatrist, and physician are God’s hands at work.
- To refuse to refer is often to elevate the pastor’s role beyond what God has assigned to it.
- Saying “I am not the right person for this part of your care” is humility, not failure.
A pastor who refers wisely models for the counselee that receiving help is not weakness, that grace works through ordinary means, and that no one heals alone.
“Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up his fellow.” — Ecclesiastes 4:9–10
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.