Pastoral Care · Congregational Conflict
Session 4 — Leadership and Non-Anxious Presence
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
1. Session Overview
In a congregation under stress, the single most powerful variable for change is rarely a new program, a new policy, or a new committee. It is the emotional and spiritual presence of the leaders — pastor, council, lay leaders — within the system.
This session focuses on the kind of leadership that congregational conflict requires: rooted, calm, differentiated, courageous, and pastoral. Drawing on the family systems insights from Session 3 and the theological foundations from Session 2, we will examine what it means to lead well when the temperature is rising.
Emotional Focus
- Identifying the leader’s own anxiety triggers.
- Cultivating the inner steadiness required for non-anxious presence.
- Addressing the loneliness of leadership.
Theological Focus
- Pastoral office as service, not power.
- The cross-shaped nature of Christian leadership.
- The vocation of lay leaders alongside the pastor.
Practical Goals
- Define non-anxious presence in practical terms.
- Identify the temptations of anxious leadership.
- Begin developing a personal leadership rule of life.
Expected Outcomes
- Counselees can recognize anxious leadership in themselves and others.
- Counselees commit to specific practices of non-anxious presence.
- Pastor and lay leaders begin to articulate distinct, complementary callings.
2. Biblical Foundation
Primary Texts
- John 13:1–17 — Jesus washes the disciples’ feet. The Lord of the Church kneels in service.
- 1 Peter 5:1–11 — Elders are to shepherd God’s flock, “not domineering over those in your charge, but being examples.” Cast all anxieties on Him.
- Mark 10:35–45 — James and John seek glory; Jesus redefines leadership as servanthood.
Supporting Texts
- Exodus 18 — Jethro counsels Moses about shared leadership.
- Numbers 11:10–17 — Moses overwhelmed; God gives him seventy elders.
- Acts 6:1–7 — The apostles delegate; ministry is distributed.
- Hebrews 13:7, 17 — Honor your leaders; leaders give account.
- 2 Timothy 4:1–8 — Preach the Word; finish the race.
Themes
- Authority as servanthood.
- Shared leadership.
- The shepherd metaphor.
- The cost of leading under pressure.
3. Confessional Lutheran Foundations
Small Catechism
- The Office of the Keys — Christ’s authority to forgive and retain sins is exercised through the church and her called servants.
- Table of Duties — Bishops, Pastors, Preachers — qualities of pastoral leadership: temperate, gentle, not quarrelsome, an example to the flock.
- Table of Duties — Hearers — the people are not passive but called to receive, honor, and support faithful pastors.
Large Catechism
- Fourth Commandment — Honor in all relationships of authority.
Augsburg Confession
- Article V (Office of the Ministry) — God instituted the office of preaching to give the gospel and the sacraments.
- Article XIV — No one should publicly teach or administer the sacraments without a regular call.
- Article XXVIII — On the limits of ecclesial authority.
Apology of the Augsburg Confession
- Article XIV — Faithful ministers serve through Word and Sacrament; their authority is not lordship but ministry.
Doctrinal Themes
- Pastoral office is divinely instituted, not merely organizationally created.
- Pastoral authority is the authority of Christ exercised through called servants.
- Lay vocation in the Body is real and Spirit-given; the priesthood of all believers complements the pastoral office.
Pastoral Applications
- The pastor is not a CEO. The council is not the pastor’s boss in the corporate sense, nor the pastor’s subordinate.
- Each is called to the work proper to their vocation.
- Authority in the church is exercised through Word, Sacrament, and the love of Christ.
4. Counseling Themes
Emotional Issues
- Loneliness of leadership.
- Anxiety about performance, approval, and survival.
- Burnout symptoms.
- Imposter syndrome.
Relational Dynamics
- Pastor-council tension.
- Pastor-spouse strain.
- Lay leader-lay leader friction.
- Coalitions surrounding leaders.
Spiritual Struggles
- Loss of joy in ministry.
- Difficulty praying for opponents.
- Wondering whether one is in the right call.
- Cynicism toward the Body.
Psychological Considerations
- Trauma responses in leaders under prolonged stress.
- Compassion fatigue.
- Vicarious traumatization from hearing many stories of harm.
Pastoral Concerns
- The temptation to fight rather than shepherd.
- The temptation to flee rather than stay.
- The temptation to please rather than lead.
5. Teaching Content
What Is Non-Anxious Presence?
Edwin Friedman popularized the phrase “non-anxious presence” to describe the kind of leadership most needed in anxious systems. He did not mean no anxiety — every leader feels anxious at times. He meant a leader whose anxiety does not drive the system.
A non-anxious presence is someone who can:
- stay calm when others are reactive,
- stay connected when others want to cut off,
- stay clear when others demand fusion,
- stay present when others want to flee,
- stay honest when others want to placate,
- stay rooted when others want to wander.
This is not stoicism. It is not detachment. It is not coolness. It is a deep, grounded steadiness that comes from being rooted in something larger than the immediate emotional storm.
For the Christian leader, that “something larger” is Jesus Christ.
The Source of Non-Anxious Presence
Non-anxious presence is not a personality type or a technique. It flows from:
- Identity — knowing whose you are (a baptized child of God) before knowing what you do (a leader, a pastor, a council president).
- Means of Grace — receiving the Word and Sacraments as your own first, before offering them to others.
- Prayer — regular, slow communion with the Lord that calibrates the soul.
- Theology — clarity about God’s faithfulness, the Church’s belonging to Christ, and the gospel as the ultimate word.
- Practices — physical, emotional, and relational rhythms that support steadiness.
A leader running on adrenaline and approval will not be non-anxious. A leader rooted in Christ, soaked in the Word, sustained by Sabbath, and accompanied by trusted friends has a fighting chance.
Marks of Anxious Leadership
Watch for these patterns. They are not character flaws — they are predictable responses to systemic anxiety. Naming them is the first step toward freedom from them.
Reactivity
- Responding immediately rather than reflectively.
- Defending oneself before listening.
- Letting one critic dominate one’s mood.
- Making major decisions during high emotional moments.
Over-functioning
- Taking responsibility for problems that belong to others.
- Solving problems that others should solve.
- Speaking for groups rather than letting them speak.
- Carrying everyone’s emotions.
Under-functioning
- Avoiding decisions.
- Letting issues fester.
- Hiding behind committees or process.
- Disengaging emotionally.
Approval Seeking
- Shaping the message to please whichever audience is loudest.
- Avoiding the truth that may upset members.
- Making decisions based on who will complain.
- Inability to disappoint anyone.
Coercion
- Using authority to silence critics.
- Threatening resignation as a control move.
- Withholding pastoral care from opponents.
- Using the pulpit to fight private battles.
Cutoff
- Refusing to speak with certain members.
- Walling oneself off emotionally.
- Resigning prematurely.
- Quitting internally while remaining externally.
Marks of Non-Anxious Leadership
By contrast, non-anxious leadership shows itself in:
Presence
- Showing up to the hard meeting.
- Returning the difficult phone call.
- Sitting with the angry member without flinching.
- Listening longer than feels natural.
Patience
- Refusing to be rushed into bad decisions.
- Letting the system settle before acting.
- Tolerating the discomfort of unresolved issues.
Honesty
- Saying the true thing kindly.
- Naming what others avoid.
- Telling oneself the truth about one’s own role.
Boundaries
- Knowing what is mine to carry and what is not.
- Refusing to triangle.
- Maintaining day off and Sabbath.
Curiosity
- Asking real questions, not loaded ones.
- Seeking to understand before being understood.
- Wondering rather than concluding.
Hope
- Speaking the gospel into the conflict.
- Refusing despair as a final word.
- Trusting the slow work of God.
The Pastor and the Council
Healthy congregational leadership involves both the pastor and the lay leaders (council, elders, etc.). Their callings are distinct but complementary.
The Pastor’s Calling
- Preach the Word and administer the Sacraments.
- Provide spiritual care, teaching, and counsel.
- Lead in the Office of the Keys.
- Tend to the spiritual life of the congregation.
The Lay Leaders’ Calling
- Oversee the temporal life of the congregation (resources, property, governance).
- Support and partner with the pastor.
- Represent the congregation in decision-making.
- Care for one another and the wider membership.
When these callings are confused, conflict often follows:
- Pastors who try to run everything become exhausted and resented.
- Councils that try to run the pastor’s office overreach and damage the gospel ministry.
- Lay leaders who function as a “shadow pastorate” undermine the Office of Word and Sacrament.
- Pastors who avoid governance leave councils unsupported and anxious.
A healthy partnership requires:
- mutual respect for each calling,
- regular, direct communication,
- a clear distinction between confessional matters (which the pastor stewards) and organizational matters (which the council stewards),
- shared commitment to non-anxious leadership.
Sabotage and Persistence
Recall from Session 3 that systems often push back against differentiated leadership. Friedman called this sabotage.
When a pastor or lay leader begins to lead with clarity and calm:
- some members will accuse them of being “cold” or “uncaring,”
- others will accuse them of being “dictatorial,”
- still others will form coalitions to pressure them back into old patterns,
- crises may emerge that pull attention away from the work of differentiation.
Sabotage is predictable. Expect it. Do not retaliate. Do not panic. Do not withdraw. Simply continue to lead.
Friedman put it bluntly: “If you can persist beyond the initial reaction, the system will recalibrate.”
In Christian terms, persistence is rooted in faithfulness — not in stubbornness. We do not persist because we are right; we persist because we are called.
Pastoral Authority and Pastoral Vulnerability
The pastor stands in a peculiar place in the system:
- they carry the weight of the Office,
- they are uniquely powerful (in word, sacrament, and influence),
- they are uniquely vulnerable (to criticism, isolation, and exhaustion),
- their family is uniquely exposed to the system’s anxieties.
Pastoral authority is not the authority of personality. It is the authority of Christ exercised through called servants. The pastor does not need to defend their authority. The pastor needs to exercise their authority — humbly, faithfully, lovingly.
Authority misused becomes coercion. Authority abdicated becomes chaos. Authority exercised well looks like Jesus washing feet — bending low, serving carefully, speaking truthfully, refusing both grandiosity and false humility.
The Cross-Shaped Leader
Christian leadership in conflict is cross-shaped:
- it bears the wounds of the people without retaliation,
- it speaks truth even when truth is costly,
- it descends rather than ascends,
- it serves rather than dominates,
- it trusts the Father even when the system seems to be winning,
- it commits its spirit, again and again, into the Father’s hands.
You are not Christ. But you serve under Christ, in the shape of Christ, with the strength of Christ.
This is not a romantic vision. It will cost you. Pastors and lay leaders who lead this way often suffer. Many of the greatest pastors in history were resented in their lifetimes and recognized only after their deaths.
But you are not measured by results. You are measured by faithfulness — and you are loved by God before, during, and after every season of leadership.
A Personal Rule of Life
A non-anxious presence is sustained by daily, weekly, monthly, and yearly rhythms that keep the leader rooted. We close with a sketch of a personal rule:
Daily
- Morning and evening prayer.
- Scripture reading.
- Sabbath of mind: protected reflection time.
- Physical movement.
Weekly
- One full day off, completely off.
- Worship in which you receive rather than lead, when possible.
- Conversation with a trusted friend or peer.
- One meal at home with family, unhurried.
Monthly
- A pastoral supervision or peer group meeting.
- Time with a spiritual director or confessor.
- A walk or retreat hour without an agenda.
Yearly
- Two weeks of vacation, taken consecutively.
- A multi-day retreat.
- An annual self-assessment with a trusted other.
- Reading outside of ministry.
We will develop this in the homework. For now, simply notice: you cannot lead non-anxiously from a depleted, isolated, malnourished soul.
6. Reflection Questions
- When in the past month have I been most reactive in my leadership? What triggered me?
- Which mark of anxious leadership do I most recognize in myself — reactivity, over-functioning, under-functioning, approval seeking, coercion, or cutoff?
- Which mark of non-anxious leadership comes most naturally to me? Which is most difficult?
- What is my body telling me about the state of my leadership right now (sleep, appetite, tension)?
- How would I describe my current relationship with the council (or pastor)? What is one honest conversation I have been avoiding?
- Where am I confusing pastoral and lay callings — taking on what is not mine or failing to do what is?
- What sabotage have I experienced when I have tried to lead with greater clarity?
- What do I do when I receive criticism? Honestly.
- Who is praying for me by name in this season? Whom can I ask?
- What practices currently sustain my non-anxious presence? Which have I let slip?
- What would it look like, this week, to lead one conversation more like Christ washing feet?
- If I were to articulate one short prayer to root myself before difficult moments, what would it be?
7. Worksheet / Homework Assignment
Part A — Leadership Self-Assessment
For each of the following, rate yourself 1 (low) to 5 (high) over the past three months:
- Presence (showing up, staying engaged): _____
- Patience (not rushing decisions): _____
- Honesty (saying true things kindly): _____
- Boundaries (knowing what is mine): _____
- Curiosity (asking real questions): _____
- Hope (speaking the gospel into conflict): _____
- Sabbath (one day genuinely off weekly): _____
- Prayer (daily, sustained communion with the Lord): _____
- Friendship (life-giving relationships outside the conflict): _____
- Physical health (sleep, movement, rest): _____
Total: _____ / 50
Identify the two lowest scores. What is one small action you will take this week to address each?
Part B — Personal Rule of Life
Draft a one-page personal rule of life for this season. Use the daily/weekly/monthly/yearly framework from the teaching content. Make it realistic, not aspirational. Then share it with one trusted person.
Part C — Conversation You Have Been Avoiding
Identify one honest conversation you have been avoiding. Write a one-paragraph script of how you would begin it: “I’d like to talk with you about …” Include:
- The truth you need to say.
- The space you want to offer them to respond.
- The hope you carry for the relationship.
Commit (with your counselor or accountability partner) to having that conversation this week — or to a specific reason why this is not yet the right time.
Part D — Sabotage Inventory
List the past three times you experienced sabotage when you tried to lead with greater clarity. For each:
- What happened?
- How did I respond?
- Did I retaliate, withdraw, or persist?
- What would faithful persistence look like next time?
Part E — Prayer Journal
Continue daily prayer. Add a brief leadership prayer each morning. Suggested form:
Lord Jesus, You are the Head of the Church. I am Your servant, not its savior. Today, give me a non-anxious heart, a listening ear, a truthful tongue, and a quiet trust in You. Bless those You have placed in my care. Strengthen me to serve them faithfully. In Your name. Amen.
Notice how this prayer (or your own version) shapes the day.
Part F — Scripture Meditation
Read John 13:1–17 slowly each day this week. Each day, place yourself in the scene:
- What does Jesus’ posture teach me?
- Where am I Peter, resisting being served?
- Where am I called to bend low and serve?
- How does this reshape my image of leadership?
Part G — Reach Out
Identify one trusted peer (pastor, lay leader, friend, mentor) and reach out this week for a conversation. Tell them honestly how you are doing. Do not solve. Just connect.
8. Review Section for Next Session
Homework Review
- What did the self-assessment reveal?
- What is your draft personal rule of life? Whom did you share it with?
- Did you have the avoided conversation? If yes, what happened? If no, what stopped you?
- What did the sabotage inventory show?
Spiritual Reflection
- Where did you sense God’s presence as you considered your leadership?
- What Scripture remained meaningful?
- How did the leadership prayer change your week?
Emotional Check-In
- How are you doing emotionally?
- Are you sleeping? Resting?
- Did you connect with a trusted peer?
Accountability
- Did you maintain daily prayer?
- Did you take a Sabbath day?
- What support do you need from this counseling space going forward?
9. Recommended Readings
Biblical Resources
- John 13 (full chapter)
- 1 Peter 5
- Mark 10:35–45
Lutheran Theological Works
- Augsburg Confession, Articles V, XIV, XXVIII.
- Luther, On the Babylonian Captivity, sections on ministry.
- Harold Senkbeil, The Care of Souls, chapters on pastoral identity.
Pastoral Care Books
- Edwin Friedman, A Failure of Nerve — central reading for this session.
- Peter Steinke, Congregational Leadership in Anxious Times.
- Eugene Peterson, Working the Angles.
Emotional Health Resources
- Pete Scazzero, The Emotionally Healthy Leader.
- Ronald Heifetz, Leadership on the Line.
Practical Christian Books
- Andrew Purves, Pastoral Theology in the Classical Tradition.
10. Closing Prayer
Lord Jesus Christ, the Good Shepherd who lays down His life for the sheep,
We confess that we have often led from anxiety rather than from You. We have reacted when we should have rested. We have controlled when we should have trusted. We have hidden when we should have spoken. We have spoken when we should have listened. We have grown weary trying to be what only You can be.
Forgive us.
Teach us to lead in Your name and in Your shape — kneeling, serving, telling the truth, washing feet. Root our identity in Your love before our calling. Anchor our authority in Your authority. Sustain our work in Your prayer.
Strengthen every pastor in this congregation, every council member, every lay leader. Bless them with peace, sleep, friendship, and joy. Where they have been wounded, heal them. Where they have wounded others, lead them to confession and forgiveness. Where they are weary, give them rest.
May Your Church be served well in this generation, and may we, when our work is done, hear You say: “Well done, good and faithful servant.”
In Your name, who lives and reigns with the Father and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and forever.
Amen.
“Casting all your anxieties on him, because he cares for you.” — 1 Peter 5:7
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.