Pastoral Care · Congregational Conflict

Referral Guidelines — Congregational Conflict Counseling

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Why Referral Matters

A faithful counselor knows the difference between pastoral care and specialized care. Congregational conflict often surfaces issues — trauma, abuse, addiction, mental illness, legal jeopardy — that exceed the scope of any pastor or lay counselor, however gifted.

Failing to refer in such cases is not loyalty — it is harm. Referral is not a failure of ministry. It is one of the clearest expressions of ministry: knowing the limits of your office, honoring the gifts of others, and ensuring that the people in your care receive what they actually need.


Posture Toward Referral

Pastoral Humility

  • You are a generalist in a field full of specialists.
  • You hold a unique role no therapist can replace — but you are not a therapist.
  • Referring is an act of love, not abandonment.

Continuity of Care

  • Referral does not mean withdrawing pastoral presence.
  • Continue to pray, visit, and walk alongside, even as professionals do the specialized work.
  • Coordinate with consent: with appropriate releases, communicate with therapists, physicians, and social workers as part of an integrated care team.

Avoid Two Errors

  1. Over-referring — pushing every emotional difficulty out the door, abandoning pastoral care.
  2. Under-referring — clinging to cases that require expertise you don’t have, often out of pride or anxiety.

The goal is discerning, collaborative referral — neither reflexive nor reluctant.


When to Refer: General Indicators

Refer when any of the following are present:

Clinical and Medical Indicators

  • Persistent depression interfering with daily functioning.
  • Anxiety disorders, panic attacks, or PTSD symptoms.
  • Suicidal ideation, planning, or self-harm.
  • Homicidal ideation or violence.
  • Psychotic symptoms (delusions, hallucinations, severe disorganization).
  • Eating disorders.
  • Active substance use disorder.
  • Cognitive decline or dementia.
  • Unexplained physical symptoms.

Trauma Indicators

  • History of abuse (childhood or adult).
  • Sexual trauma.
  • Combat or first-responder trauma.
  • Religious or spiritual abuse with PTSD-level impact.
  • Complex trauma with dissociation.

Relational and Family Indicators

  • Domestic violence.
  • Severe marital conflict requiring specialized intervention.
  • Custody or family court matters.
  • Child welfare concerns.

Spiritual Indicators

  • Profound, sustained crises of faith requiring extended spiritual direction.
  • Patterns of religious scrupulosity or OCD with religious themes.
  • Manipulative or cultic religious experiences.
  • Active litigation or threat of litigation.
  • Allegations of clergy or staff misconduct.
  • Financial impropriety.
  • Denominational disciplinary proceedings.
  • Insurance or risk-management implications.

Specific Referral Categories

Mental Health Professionals

Refer to a licensed therapist (LPC, LCSW, LMFT, psychologist) when:

  • Symptoms persist beyond two to three pastoral conversations.
  • Issues involve trauma, attachment, or personality.
  • Couples or family therapy is needed.
  • Specialized therapy is indicated (EMDR, DBT, CBT, IFS, trauma-focused care).
  • The counselee asks for therapy.
  • You feel out of your depth.

Preferred referral characteristics:

  • Licensed in your state.
  • Christian-friendly or at minimum respectful of faith.
  • Experienced with clergy or congregational dynamics where possible.
  • Within reasonable travel distance or available by telehealth.

Psychiatrists and Primary Care Physicians

Refer when:

  • Medication evaluation is needed.
  • Symptoms have biological/medical components.
  • Sleep, appetite, or energy disturbances are severe.
  • The counselee is currently on psychiatric medication and is in crisis.

Emergency Services

Call immediately (911 or 988 — the U.S. Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) when:

  • A person is in imminent danger of harming themselves or others.
  • Active psychosis poses safety risks.
  • A medical emergency is occurring.
  • Acute intoxication endangers the person.

Stay with the person (in person or on the phone) until help arrives whenever safely possible.

Domestic Violence Resources

Refer to:

  • The National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233 (or text START to 88788).
  • Local women’s and family shelters.
  • Local law enforcement.
  • Specialized DV advocates and attorneys.

Do not attempt to mediate between abuser and victim. Do not insist on couples counseling where violence is present. Do not push for reconciliation while abuse is ongoing.

Addiction and Substance Use

Refer to:

  • Licensed substance use counselors.
  • Recovery programs (AA, NA, Celebrate Recovery, SMART Recovery).
  • Inpatient or outpatient treatment programs.
  • Medical detox where physical withdrawal is dangerous.

Trauma Specialists

Refer to therapists trained in:

  • EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing)
  • Somatic Experiencing
  • Trauma-Focused CBT
  • Internal Family Systems
  • Religious or spiritual trauma work

Spiritual Direction and Pastoral Supervision

Refer to:

  • Trained spiritual directors (especially for pastors and church leaders).
  • Pastoral counselors with theological training and clinical credentials.
  • Denominational pastoral care specialists.
  • Bishops, deans, or district presidents in confidential consultation.

Refer to:

  • Attorneys experienced in nonprofit, religious, or employment law.
  • Insurance carriers (denominational and congregational).
  • Mediators or arbitrators where formal dispute resolution is required.

Denominational Resources

Refer to:

  • Bishops, district presidents, or supervising clergy.
  • Denominational conflict transformation teams.
  • Interim ministry specialists.
  • Synod or district counselors and consultants.

How to Make a Referral Well

1. Prepare the Counselee

  • Frame referral as adding care, not withdrawing care.
  • “What you’re carrying is significant, and I want you to have the very best help. Let me connect you with someone who specializes in this. I’ll stay with you through it.”

2. Offer Concrete Options

  • Give two or three names whenever possible, not a single mandate.
  • Provide contact information, location, and (if known) cost or insurance information.
  • Offer to make the first contact with the counselee’s permission.

3. Bridge the Connection

  • With consent, send an introductory email to the referred professional.
  • Provide context appropriate to the situation, with attention to confidentiality.
  • Follow up within a week to see whether the connection was made.

4. Continue Pastoral Care

  • Do not drop the counselee.
  • Schedule a check-in to ask how the new relationship is going.
  • Pray for and with the counselee.
  • Coordinate care where appropriate.

5. Document Carefully

  • Note the referral in your records.
  • Note the rationale.
  • Note follow-up steps.

Emergency Response Guidance

Suicidal Ideation

  1. Stay calm and present. Do not leave the person alone.
  2. Ask directly: “Are you thinking about ending your life?”
  3. Ask about plan and means: Plan, timing, access to firearms or other lethal means.
  4. Reduce access to lethal means if you can do so safely.
  5. Call 988 (U.S. Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) or 911 if imminent.
  6. Stay until help arrives. Accompany to ER if appropriate.
  7. Follow up within 24 hours.

Abuse Disclosure

  1. Believe and stabilize. “Thank you for telling me. I’m glad you trusted me with this.”
  2. Do not investigate. That is not your role.
  3. Know your reporting obligations. Many states make clergy mandatory reporters.
  4. Report to authorities (child protective services, adult protective services, law enforcement) where required by law.
  5. Provide information about hotlines, shelters, and legal advocacy.
  6. Document carefully.
  7. Consult your supervisor, bishop, and insurance carrier as appropriate.
  8. Do not attempt mediation between abuser and victim.

Acute Crisis (Panic, Psychotic Break, Severe Dissociation)

  1. Speak slowly and softly.
  2. Reduce stimulation (turn off music, dim lights, close doors).
  3. Ground the person: name three things they can see, hear, touch.
  4. Avoid debating delusions.
  5. Call 988 or 911 as appropriate.
  6. Stay with the person until help arrives.

Threats of Violence

  1. Take all threats seriously.
  2. Document carefully.
  3. Notify law enforcement if there is credible threat.
  4. Notify insurance carrier and denominational officials.
  5. Increase building security if needed.
  6. Care pastorally for those who feel unsafe.

Local Support Recommendations

Each pastor and counselor should compile and maintain a local referral list, updated annually, that includes:

Mental Health

  • Three to five trusted Christian therapists.
  • Two to three trauma-trained therapists.
  • One or two psychiatrists.
  • One or two child/family therapists.
  • One or two marriage and family therapists.

Medical

  • Two or three primary care physicians known to be supportive.
  • A local hospital ER and crisis line.

Addiction

  • Local AA, NA, Celebrate Recovery contacts.
  • Inpatient and outpatient treatment centers.

Domestic Violence

  • Local DV hotline, shelter, and advocate.
  • Two attorneys: one for the counselee, one for the congregation/clergy as needed.

Denominational and Pastoral

  • Bishop or district president contact.
  • Synodical or denominational counselor.
  • Trusted peer pastors for consultation.

Spiritual

  • Two to three spiritual directors.
  • A retreat center.
  • A confessor or pastoral counselor for clergy.

Update this list annually. Visit a few of these providers personally so you can refer with confidence.


Collaborative Care Principles

Mutual Respect

  • Honor the expertise of other professionals.
  • Speak well of mental health, medical, and legal professionals from the pulpit.
  • Build relationships before crises arise.

Communication

  • Use signed release-of-information forms.
  • Share only what is necessary for care.
  • Receive what professionals share with discretion and confidentiality.

Team Care

  • Conceive of care as a team effort: therapist, physician, pastor, family, congregation.
  • No one professional carries the whole burden.
  • Christ is the great Shepherd; the team serves under His care.

Boundaries

  • Stay in your lane.
  • Refer rather than overreach.
  • Trust that the Spirit works through the whole team, not only through you.

When Referral Is Refused

Some counselees will resist referral. Respect their autonomy, but be honest:

  • Name your concerns clearly.
  • Explain what you can and cannot offer.
  • Document the refusal.
  • If safety is at risk, escalate (emergency services, mandatory reporting).
  • Continue pastoral care, but do not pretend to provide therapy or psychiatric care.

A Closing Word

The Good Shepherd does not work alone. He sends His servants in pairs, equips His Church with diverse gifts, and works through doctors, counselors, lawyers, social workers, and faithful friends. Wise pastors and counselors recognize this and gladly cooperate with the wider work of God’s mercy.

Refer freely. Refer humbly. Refer in love. And trust that the Lord who entrusted these souls to your care will continue to care for them through hands and skills beyond your own.

“Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ. … For each will have to bear his own load.” — Galatians 6:2, 5

“Where there is no guidance, a people falls, but in an abundance of counselors there is safety.” — Proverbs 11:14

Topics
Other Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Galatians 6:2Proverbs 11:14

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.