Pastoral Care · Congregational Conflict
Intake Guide — Congregational Conflict Counseling
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Purpose of This Intake
This intake guide is designed to be used at the beginning of a congregational conflict counseling engagement — whether the counselor is meeting with:
- a pastor in personal distress,
- a council or leadership board,
- a mediation team,
- an interim or transitional minister,
- a denominational official,
- or individual members affected by congregational conflict.
The goal of the intake is not to render a verdict on the conflict. It is to:
- gather context,
- name presenting issues honestly,
- map the emotional and relational system,
- identify safety concerns,
- clarify counseling goals,
- and establish a working covenant.
A thoughtful intake protects everyone involved — including the counselor — and prevents premature interventions based on partial information.
How to Use This Guide
- Adapt questions to the counselee (pastor, council, member, etc.).
- Do not race through the questions. The intake is counseling.
- Listen for what is not said as much as what is said.
- Pay attention to body language, hesitation, and emotional tone.
- Take notes carefully but minimally; review and expand after the session.
- Plan two intake sessions if the situation is complex.
Section 1 — Basic Information
Counselee(s)
- Full name(s):
- Role(s) in congregation (pastor, council member, lay leader, member, staff, spouse):
- Length of membership or ministry tenure:
- Contact information:
- Preferred method of communication:
Congregation
- Congregation name:
- Denomination / synod / district:
- Location:
- Approximate membership and worship attendance:
- Pastoral staffing (full-time, part-time, vacant, interim):
- Approximate age, length of ministry, and tenure of current pastor(s):
Other Stakeholders
- Council president / chair:
- Bishop / district president / supervising official:
- Any prior consultants, mediators, or counselors involved:
- Legal counsel involved (yes/no, role):
Section 2 — Presenting Conflict
Open-Ended Questions
- In your own words, what is happening in the congregation right now?
- When did you first notice that something was wrong?
- What event or moment do you consider the “beginning” of the current conflict?
- Who do you see as the primary parties involved?
- What is the conflict ostensibly about? What do you suspect it is really about?
- What has already been tried to address it?
- What outcomes have you hoped for? What outcomes do you fear?
- What is your role in the conflict — as you understand it?
Symptom Assessment
Check all that apply:
- Open arguments in meetings
- Coalitions or factions forming
- Loss of members or financial giving
- Anonymous letters, social media attacks, or gossip
- Threats of resignation (pastor or members)
- Council or staff dysfunction
- Worship-style or theological disputes
- Financial or governance concerns
- Disciplinary or grievance proceedings
- Allegations of misconduct
- Litigation or threat of litigation
- Denominational involvement
- Departure or removal of staff
- Significant decline in attendance or morale
Intensity Rating
On a scale from 1 to 5 (Speed Leas’s Levels of Conflict can be used as a frame):
- 1 — Problem to solve: differences of opinion, no personal animosity.
- 2 — Disagreement: self-protection begins; trust slips.
- 3 — Contest: someone must win; language hardens; “us vs. them” emerges.
- 4 — Fight or flight: factions are entrenched; goal shifts from winning to hurting or leaving.
- 5 — Intractable: destruction becomes the goal; outside intervention is essential.
Current level (counselee’s perception): _____ Counselor’s working assessment: _____
Section 3 — Congregational History
Pastoral History
- List the past three to five pastors (or as many as memory or records allow).
- For each: tenure dates, manner of departure (retirement, call, resignation, removal, scandal), and how the departure was experienced by the congregation.
- Were there long interim periods? Were they healthy or anxious?
Historic Conflicts
- What prior conflicts has the congregation experienced (in the last 20–30 years)?
- How were they resolved (or not)?
- Are there “ghost stories” — old conflicts that members still reference?
Recent Major Events
- Building projects (recent or proposed)
- Mergers, closures, or affiliations
- Significant deaths of long-standing members
- Worship changes
- Staff additions or losses
- Pandemic-era disruptions
- Denominational changes
Congregational Identity
- How does the congregation describe itself (mission, values, character)?
- How do outsiders describe it?
- How has its identity shifted over the past 10–20 years?
Section 4 — Emotional and Relational History
Emotional Climate
- How would you describe the emotional atmosphere of the congregation in the last six months?
- What words come to mind: anxious, angry, grieving, hopeful, fearful, weary, numb, divided, resigned?
- Are meetings calm, tense, explosive, avoidant?
Communication Patterns
- How do members typically address concerns: directly, indirectly, anonymously, publicly?
- Is gossip a problem? How widespread?
- Are there individuals or groups who function as informal “switchboards”?
Triangulation and Coalitions
- Are there identifiable factions or coalitions?
- Are there individuals who seem to mediate between (or play) multiple groups?
- Who tends to be “the messenger” rather than the speaker?
Trust Levels
- How would you rate trust between members? Between members and pastor? Between pastor and council? Between council and staff?
- When was trust last damaged in a significant way? By whom or by what?
Section 5 — Spiritual Background and Climate
Personal Spiritual Background (for individual counselees)
- Briefly, how did you come to faith?
- What is your Lutheran (or other) background?
- What spiritual disciplines sustain you?
- How is your prayer life currently?
- How would you describe your relationship with God in this season?
Spiritual Climate of the Congregation
- How would you describe the spiritual life of the congregation?
- Is worship attendance regular among leaders? Are leaders communing?
- Is the Word being preached and heard? Are the sacraments being received?
- Is prayer present in council and committee meetings?
- Are there signs of spiritual fatigue, cynicism, or disillusionment?
Theological Tensions
- Are there theological disputes underlying the conflict (liturgy, doctrine, social/cultural issues)?
- Is there clarity on what is confessional vs. adiaphora?
- Is Scripture being used to wound or to heal?
Section 6 — Current Stressors
Personal Stressors (for the counselee)
- How is your physical health?
- How is your sleep?
- How is your family handling this season?
- Are there other major life stressors (illness, death, financial strain, marriage strain)?
- Are you taking care of basic needs (rest, exercise, recreation, friendship)?
Pastoral Stressors (for clergy)
- How is your workload?
- Are you receiving supervision, peer support, or spiritual direction?
- Are you maintaining a day off and vacation?
- How is your spouse (if applicable) experiencing this?
- Are you considering resignation?
Congregational Stressors
- Financial pressure (deficit budget, declining giving)?
- Building or facility concerns?
- Staffing instability?
- Denominational tension?
- Community context shifts?
Section 7 — Counseling Goals
- What do you most hope this counseling will accomplish?
- What would “success” look like in three months? Six months? One year?
- What outcomes would you consider failure?
- What are you willing to do differently?
- Whom else do you believe needs to be part of this work?
- What support do you need to engage this process honestly?
Section 8 — Emergency and Safety Indicators
The counselor should screen carefully for the following. Any “yes” answer should prompt immediate follow-up and, when appropriate, professional referral or reporting.
Personal Safety
- Suicidal thoughts (passive or active)?
- Self-harm?
- Homicidal thoughts?
- Substance abuse?
- Severe depression, anxiety, or panic attacks?
- Recent significant loss or trauma?
Relational Safety
- Threats from members?
- Stalking or harassment?
- Domestic violence?
- Child abuse, neglect, or exploitation?
- Abuse of vulnerable adults?
- Sexual misconduct allegations involving clergy or staff?
Legal and Institutional Risk
- Active litigation or threat of litigation?
- Mandatory reporting obligations triggered?
- Denominational disciplinary proceedings?
- Financial impropriety?
Spiritual Safety
- Use of Scripture or authority to silence, coerce, or harm?
- Patterns of spiritual abuse?
- Cult-like dynamics (information control, isolation, fear-based loyalty)?
Section 9 — Counseling Covenant
Before proceeding with the counseling track, establish a written or verbal covenant including:
Confidentiality
- Confidentiality is the norm.
- Limits include: imminent harm to self or others, abuse of minors or vulnerable adults, and legal mandates.
- Information will not be shared across factions.
Boundaries
- Session times and locations are set.
- Between-session contact is for scheduling and emergencies, not extended counseling.
- Communication by text, email, or phone is limited.
Roles
- The counselor is not an advocate for one side.
- The counselor is not a substitute for therapy, legal counsel, or denominational authority.
- The counselee participates honestly and at their own pace.
Process
- Number of sessions anticipated.
- Pacing (weekly, biweekly).
- Homework, reading, and reflection expectations.
- Review and adjustment points.
Cost and Logistics
- Fees, if any.
- Location, format (in person, video), and duration.
- Cancellation policy.
Section 10 — Post-Intake Reflection (for the counselor)
Complete this section privately after each intake.
- What is the dominant emotion in the room?
- What is the dominant emotion in me after this conversation?
- Whose voice is most missing from this story?
- What pattern (triangulation, scapegoating, fusion, cutoff) am I noticing?
- Where am I tempted to take sides? Why?
- What referral resources may be needed?
- What is the next faithful step?
- With whom do I need to consult about this case?
A Closing Note
Intake is not a courtroom and not a checklist. It is a sacred listening. People often say more in their first hour than in the next ten — be present, be slow, be prayerful.
The information gathered here is a starting point, not a verdict. Hold it gently, hold it confidentially, and hold it before the Lord.
“If one gives an answer before he hears, it is his folly and shame.” — Proverbs 18:13
“Be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger; for the anger of man does not produce the righteousness of God.” — James 1:19–20
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.