Papers · Lutheranism and …

Lutheranism and the Non-Denominational Churches

Bible Churches, Fellowships, and the Question of a Confession

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“Follow the pattern of the sound words that you have heard from me, in the faith and love that are in Christ Jesus. By the Holy Spirit who dwells within us, guard the good deposit entrusted to you.” — 2 Timothy 1:13–14


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921) and cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, FC Ep, FC SD) with paragraph numbers as in the Kolb–Wengert and Tappert editions. The teaching of the non-denominational churches is quoted from statements they publish themselves, chiefly Calvary Chapel’s “What We Believe,” Vineyard USA’s Core Values & Beliefs (2016), and the doctrinal statement of Dallas Theological Seminary, which has shaped many independent Bible churches. These are representative examples and bind no congregation but those that adopt them. The Stone-Campbell documents are quoted from the Bethany Press edition of 1960, Charles Finney and Justin Martyr from the texts in the Christian Classics Ethereal Library.


What Is a Denomination, and What Does It Mean to Have None?

What is a denomination? Ask the people of the church out by the highway what kind of church theirs is, and very often they will say, “We’re just Christians.” A young couple from that church may sit in a Lutheran pastor’s study and ask why he wants to baptize their baby. A Lutheran grandmother may wonder why her grandson’s church so seldom has Communion. Both questions begin with the word. In Denominationalism I took the dictionary’s answer as my starting point: a named, organized body of congregations that share a confession of faith, a pattern of worship, a form of government, and usually a history. The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod is a denomination in that sense and so are the Southern Baptist Convention and the United Methodist Church. A non-denominational church, then, is a congregation that belongs to no such body. It has no synod above it, no common confession it must subscribe, and no name that ties it to a tradition.

That answer is harder to pin down than it sounds. Scott Thumma of the Hartford Institute for Religion Research, who has done more than anyone to count these churches, admits that the definition of an independent congregation “is somewhat suspect at best.” He asks, “What exactly defines a denominational versus nondenominational church, given the reality of loose networks, overlapping affiliations, fluid categories, and dynamic switching?”1 A church may have no denomination and still belong to a network that trains its pastors, supplies its curriculum, and plants its daughter congregations; it may have left a denomination last year; it may belong to a “movement” that looks from the outside much like a denomination with a lighter hand. In other words, the label tells us first what a church is not.

Almost every Lutheran congregation in America now lives beside these churches. Some of the people in our pews came to faith in one of them, and some of our own children worship in them now. I am glad to call their members brothers and sisters in Christ. I also write as a confessional Lutheran who believes the differences between us are worth stating honestly. In Denominationalism and its companion, “Just Jesus”: The Confession Behind the Claim, I have already said why denominations exist and why no church is without a confession. Here the question is narrower. I have tried to describe these churches from their own statements, as their own pastors would, and to say where the Lutheran Confessions agree with them and where they do not, and why. There is one difficulty. Unlike Rome or Canterbury, these churches have no catechism or articles that all of them acknowledge, so the pastor of any particular congregation may well say, “That is not quite what we teach.” He is the authority on his own congregation.

The essay takes up five questions:

  1. Where did these churches come from, and who are they today?
  2. What do Lutherans and these churches hold in common?
  3. Where do we differ, and what reasons does each side give?
  4. What might we learn from each other?
  5. What should a Lutheran say to a son or granddaughter who now worships in one of them?

I. A Family Without a Single Confession

The roots

The idea of a church without a denomination has American roots in the frontier revivals of the early nineteenth century. In 1804 a small group of Presbyterian ministers in Kentucky, Barton W. Stone among them, dissolved their own presbytery by publishing The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery. Its first item reads, “We will, that this body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of Christ at large; for there is but one Body, and one Spirit, even as we are called in one hope of our calling.”2 Five years later the Presbyterian minister Thomas Campbell published his Declaration and Address (1809). His first proposition is a beautiful one: “That the Church of Christ upon earth is essentially, intentionally, and constitutionally one.”3 His third gave the movement its rule. In order to restore that unity, “nothing ought to be inculcated upon Christians as articles of faith; nor required of them as terms of communion, but what is expressly taught and enjoined upon them in the word of God.”4 Campbell did not despise confessions. His seventh proposition grants that “doctrinal exhibitions of the great system of Divine truths” are “highly expedient,” but because they are “the effect of human reasoning,” they “ought not to be made terms of Christian communion.”5 The longing of Stone and Campbell to be Christians united by the Bible alone runs through the whole non-denominational world, even in churches that have never heard of them.

The second root is revivalism. The evangelist Charles G. Finney taught in his Lectures on Revivals of Religion (1835) that a revival “is not a miracle, or dependent on a miracle, in any sense. It is a purely philosophical result of the right use of the constituted means,” though he added that “means will not produce a revival, we all know, without the blessing of God.”6 His “new measures,” the protracted meeting and the public invitation to come forward among them, made the invitation a fixture of American evangelism, and Lutherans argued over them in their own synods. Most evangelicals who give an invitation today do not share Finney’s teaching on the human will. The practice came to them chiefly through later evangelists such as D. L. Moody and Billy Graham, whose preaching was not Finney’s theology.

The branches today

I will name six branches, with the warning that the lines between them are not sharp.

  1. Independent Bible churches. In the early twentieth century, as the older denominations divided over the authority of Scripture, many conservative congregations left them or were founded independent of them, and many called themselves Bible churches. Their pastors were often trained at schools such as Dallas Theological Seminary or Moody Bible Institute. Thumma found that the great majority of independent churches describe their outlook as evangelical, though a significant minority prefer the label fundamentalist.7

  2. The Stone-Campbell churches. The Churches of Christ and the independent Christian Churches still call themselves no denomination. They celebrate the Lord’s Supper every Sunday and teach that Baptism is “for the forgiveness of your sins” (Acts 2:38). Their heirs share the non-denominational ideal more than the evangelical non-denominational churches share their teaching, but the idea runs from them.

  3. Calvary Chapel. In 1965 Chuck Smith became the teaching pastor of a congregation of about twenty-five people in Costa Mesa, California. Calvary Chapel welcomed the young people of the Jesus Movement, the “hippies and surfers,” as its own history calls them, and baptized them by the hundreds in the Pacific Ocean. It became, by its own count, “an international family of over 1700 churches around the world,” now gathered in more than one network.8 Its statement of faith is arranged under five headings: “We are evangelical,” “We are continuationist” (holding that the gifts of the Holy Spirit are “available to and active in His church today”), “We are complementarian,” “We are pre-millennial,” and “We are pre-tribulational.”9 It is known for teaching through whole books of the Bible verse by verse.

  4. The Vineyard. The Vineyard grew out of the same world in the 1970s and took its shape under John Wimber in the early 1980s. It describes itself as “a God-initiated, global movement of churches committed to the theology and practice of the kingdom of God.”10 Today it is an association (Vineyard USA) that most observers would call a small denomination. Its charismatic practice belongs to the essay in this series on Pentecostalism.

  5. The seeker and megachurch movement. From the 1970s a number of pastors, most famously at Willow Creek Community Church near Chicago (founded in 1975), designed their weekend services for people who did not go to church. They set aside what they saw as barriers (unfamiliar language, ritual, and the expectation that a visitor would join or take part) and offered contemporary music, drama, and practical preaching. The country’s largest churches grew in that soil. Of the roughly 1,750 Protestant megachurches counted in 2020, most in fact belong to a denomination; about two in five call themselves non-denominational.11

  6. The house churches. Small congregations meet in homes, often under lay leaders and without buildings or paid staff. Their reasons are drawn from the New Testament, where Paul greets “the church in their house” (Romans 16:5), the first believers broke bread “in their homes” (Acts 2:46), and every member brought something to the assembly: “When you come together, each one has a hymn, a lesson, a revelation, a tongue, or an interpretation. Let all things be done for building up” (1 Corinthians 14:26).

How many are there? Pew’s Religious Landscape Study of 2023–24 found that about one American adult in fourteen calls himself a non-denominational Protestant, which makes them the second-largest family of Protestant churches after the Baptists and the only one that has grown since 2007. Thumma’s own census listed more than 60,000 such congregations.12

How Lutherans have met them

There have been no formal dialogues between Lutherans and these churches, and there cannot easily be any, since no one can speak for them as a whole. The meeting has happened instead in families and neighborhoods. It has also happened inside Lutheranism, since in the last fifty years many Lutheran congregations have borrowed the methods of the church growth and contemporary worship movements. That history should keep us humble, because the questions in this essay are questions Lutherans have had to put to ourselves.


II. What We Hold in Common

When I read the statements of faith of these churches, I find much that a Lutheran confesses too.

The non-denominational churches love the Scriptures, read them, memorize them, and expect to hear them preached. Calvary Chapel confesses, “We believe the Bible is the inspired, inerrant and authoritative Word of God. We believe the Bible is the final authority in every area it addresses for every individual Christian, as well as for the church collectively.”13 The Formula of Concord says that “the Holy Scriptures alone remain the only judge, rule, and standard, according to which, as the only test-stone, all dogmas shall and must be discerned and judged.”14 Calvary’s habit of teaching through whole books verse by verse, from its first months, is one any Lutheran pastor should honor. It is the habit of the Bereans, who “received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so” (Acts 17:11).

In addition, they confess the Triune God and the Christ of the creeds. Calvary Chapel confesses “one God who eternally exists as three persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit,” and that God the Son, “conceived of the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary,” lived a sinless life, “died a substitutionary death for all mankind, was raised from the dead the third day, ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of God.”15 Whether or not the Nicene Creed is said on Sunday morning, that is its faith. Many of these churches preach the cross with a directness that some of the old denominations have lost.

They confess grace. Calvary Chapel teaches “that salvation is by grace alone through faith alone in Him.” Dallas Theological Seminary’s statement holds that “no repentance, no feeling, no faith, no good resolutions, no sincere efforts, no submission to the rules and regulations of any church, nor all the churches that have existed since the days of the apostles can add in the very least degree to the value of the blood or to the merit of the finished work wrought for us by Him.”16 I could hardly ask for a stronger sentence. The Augsburg Confession teaches that men “cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith.”17 On justification a Lutheran pastor and a Bible church pastor will agree far more than they disagree.

They confess the one Church, which may seem strange in churches without a denomination. Calvary Chapel says, “We believe there is one church, the body of Christ, consisting of men and women from every tribe, tongue, people and nation.”18 The Vineyard confesses “the one, holy, universal Church.”19 The Augsburg Confession teaches that “one holy Church is to continue forever,” and we will come back to how that Church is known.20

Their zeal for the lost is plain to anyone who knows them. Thumma found that independent congregations emphasize evangelism and outreach more than evangelical denominational congregations do. He gave a reason: “as a result of not relying on a denominational identification these churches have to emphasize evangelistic efforts to a greater extent.”21 They plant churches, send missionaries, and teach their members to invite their friends. They expect every member to serve and gather their people into small groups for Bible study and prayer. They are often warm toward the visitor and more often racially mixed than the denominations around them; nearly half of independent congregations told Thumma that they were intentionally striving to be diverse “racially, ethnically, and socially,” against about a fifth of evangelical denominational churches.22 “Therefore welcome one another as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God” (Romans 15:7).

A Lutheran who has heard a Bible church pastor preach through Romans, or watched a non-denominational congregation welcome a family the rest of the town had forgotten, has seen the Holy Spirit at work through the Word. How does that square with the condemnations in our own Confessions? The Preface to the Book of Concord answers it. “It is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches,” it says, and it adds, “we have no doubt whatever that even in those churches which have hitherto not agreed with us in all things many godly and by no means wicked men are found.”23 In other words, the Confessions condemn not the believers who sit in other churches’ pews, but false teachings and those who stubbornly teach them.


III. Where We Part Ways

The differences are real, though they are not chiefly about music or buildings. I take up six.

1. Scripture and the Church’s Confession

The conviction behind these churches is that the Bible is enough. Their reasons are serious. The first is the sufficiency of Scripture, given “that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:17). If Scripture is complete, why add a human document to it? The second is unity; Campbell and Stone had watched Presbyterians divide over the fine points of the Westminster Confession and believed the creeds had become fences that kept Christians apart. The third is the danger of tradition. Jesus rebuked those who were “teaching as doctrines the commandments of men” (Matthew 15:9) and many non-denominational Christians have known churches where the confession was honored and the Bible went unread. The fourth is the visitor, who should not have to learn a sixteenth-century vocabulary before he can hear the Gospel.

The fifth reason is today the weightiest. These churches write short statements of faith on purpose. They distinguish the doctrines that define the Gospel (the Trinity, the person and work of Christ, salvation by grace through faith, the authority of Scripture) from questions on which they judge that faithful Christians read the Bible differently and may still worship together, such as the mode and subjects of Baptism, the millennium, and church government. Their silence on Baptism and the Supper is deliberate, so that a believer raised Baptist and one raised Presbyterian can belong to one congregation. Many have the motto on the wall: In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity. It is usually traced to a Lutheran, Peter Meiderlin, who wrote under the name Rupertus Meldenius in 1626 during the Thirty Years’ War.24 The Vineyard’s booklet shows the same thinking. Because the Bible is “a diverse collection of narrative stories, poetry, law, and letters, it is helpful to summarize its teaching in a concise form,” it says, and that was “the historical function that the ancient universal church creeds played.”25

Lutherans agree that Scripture alone is the rule and judge of all teaching. For that reason the Formula of Concord says that the Lutheran Confessions “are not judges, as are the Holy Scriptures, but only a testimony and declaration of the faith, as to how at any time the Holy Scriptures have been understood and explained in the articles in controversy in the Church of God by those then living.”26 A confession is the Church saying back to God what God has said to her, in the face of the questions and errors of her own day. Paul told Timothy to “follow the pattern of the sound words” and to “guard the good deposit entrusted to you” (2 Timothy 1:13–14). Arius quoted the Bible when he taught that the Son was a creature, so it was not enough for the Church to answer that she believed the Bible; she had to say what the Bible means, and the Nicene Creed is the result. A church that says it has no creed but the Bible still reads the Bible in a definite way. It baptizes infants or it does not, it understands the Lord’s Supper in some definite way, and it holds some view of the last things.

We also agree with Meiderlin’s motto, and so the question is not whether to distinguish essentials from non-essentials, but what counts as essential. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments,” and that ceremonies need not “be everywhere alike.”27 The Formula of Concord explains “enough”: churches will not condemn one another over ceremonies, “provided they are otherwise agreed with one another in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”28 Campbell would have agreed that ceremonies may differ. What he left free, the meaning of Baptism and the Supper, the Lutheran Church confesses as part of the Gospel itself, because in them the Gospel is given. That is why a Lutheran pastor and a non-denominational pastor can agree on much of what the Bible teaches and still not commune at one altar. Lutherans, too, sometimes keep their confession on the shelf. However, a written confession at least stands where a congregation can read it and be called back by it.

2. Baptism and the Lord’s Supper

Most non-denominational churches teach what Baptists teach about Baptism and the Supper. The essay on the Baptists in this series takes up believer’s baptism in full. They usually call them ordinances, acts Christ ordained, that is, commanded. The Vineyard’s statement reads, “We believe that Jesus Christ committed two ordinances to the Church: water baptism and the Lord’s Supper. Both are available to all believers.” Dallas Theological Seminary calls them “a scriptural means of testimony for the church in this age.”29 The reasons are obedience to Christ’s command and a deep concern to guard the Gospel of grace. The Dallas statement says that “no baptism or other ordinance however administered, can help the sinner to take even one step toward heaven,” and that no other act, “such as confession, baptism, prayer, or faithful service,” is “to be added to believing as a condition of salvation.”30 Behind that sentence lies a real pastoral fear of baptized names on a church roll with no living faith behind them, and Lutherans share that fear. In addition, some independent churches, especially those shaped by Reformed theology, speak of the ordinances as means of grace in which Christ is spiritually present, though they deny that Baptism regenerates or that Christ’s body and blood are present in the bread and wine.

Lutherans do not ask whether Baptism is an ordinance, since Christ commanded it, but whether His promise is attached to it. The Apology calls Sacraments “rites which have the command of God, and to which the promise of grace has been added.”31 A non-denominational pastor would grant the command and deny that grace is promised in the rite. That is the whole question. The Augsburg Confession grants that the Sacraments are “marks of profession among men,” and then says they are “not only” that, “but rather” “signs and testimonies of the will of God toward us, instituted to awaken and confirm faith in those who use them.”32 Scripture speaks that way. Peter preached Baptism “for the forgiveness of your sins,” with the promise of “the gift of the Holy Spirit” (Acts 2:38), and Paul writes that God “saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). Of the Supper Paul asks, “The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ?” (1 Corinthians 10:16). Taking Christ at His word, the Augsburg Confession teaches “that the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed to those who eat the Supper of the Lord.”33 I have written on the Supper in One Body at Many Altars and will not repeat it here.

The Stone-Campbell churches stand nearer to us than the rest of the family, since they confess that Baptism is for the forgiveness of sins. They still differ from us in refusing it to infants and in speaking of it not chiefly as God’s own work that faith receives, but as the obedience by which the believer receives forgiveness. Luther writes that “to be baptized in the name of God is to be baptized not by men, but by God Himself.”34

3. How a Sinner Comes to Faith

Most non-denominational churches call people to receive Christ personally and the sermon often closes with an invitation to respond. Their texts are well loved: “If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved” (Romans 10:9); “Behold, I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and eat with him, and he with me” (Revelation 3:20). In their own understanding the invitation does not mean that the sinner earns anything, but that he receives what God offers him. They teach that no one comes unless the Father draws him (John 6:44), that the Spirit convicts the world of sin, and that faith is the empty hand that receives a gift. They do not rest assurance on the decision either. The Dallas statement teaches that assurance “is not founded on any fancied discovery of their own worthiness or fitness, but wholly upon the testimony of God in His written Word,” and points the believer to such promises as “I write these things to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life” (1 John 5:13).35 Many Bible churches add the doctrine of eternal security, which the Baptist essay in this series weighs. Nor is the theology behind the invitation uniform. Some churches lean toward the Wesleyan view of the will and some, especially Bible churches shaped by the Reformed revival of recent decades, hold that the new birth comes before faith and is God’s work alone. The Dallas statement speaks of “a new life implanted by the Holy Spirit through the Word.”36

Lutherans also call sinners to repent and believe and we too want faith to be personal. We differ not over whether faith must be personal, but over the means by which the Spirit gives it. Luther writes in the Large Catechism, “For neither you nor I could ever know anything of Christ, or believe on Him, and obtain Him for our Lord, unless it were offered to us and granted to our hearts by the Holy Ghost through the preaching of the Gospel.”37 The Augsburg Confession says that “through the Word and Sacraments, as through instruments, the Holy Ghost is given, who works faith, where and when it pleases God, in them that hear the Gospel.”38 Romans 10 itself asks, “And how are they to hear without someone preaching?” and answers, “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:14, 17). Even Revelation 3:20, the best-loved invitation text, is spoken by the risen Christ to a church, the lukewarm congregation at Laodicea, as a call to repentance.

Both sides, then, point the doubter outside himself to the promise of God. The difference is that the Lutheran adds that God has attached that promise to Baptism, to the spoken absolution, and to the Supper, so that it is spoken to this person by name and placed in his hand. In practice Lutherans fail here too; a Baptism never remembered comforts no one, and a Lutheran can rest in the bare fact of his Baptism as carelessly as anyone rests in a prayer he once prayed. None of this means that those who came to Christ at an invitation did not come to Him. Where Christ is preached, the Holy Spirit works through that Word, and many thousands have believed through it. A former Bible church member now sitting in a Lutheran pew need not doubt that his conversion counts. The Word he heard that night was God’s Word, and his Baptism, whenever it came, is God’s own work.

4. The Congregation and the Office

The non-denominational congregation governs itself. Stone’s Last Will expressed the conviction in 1804, willing that “each particular church, as a body, actuated by the same spirit, choose her own preacher,” and “never henceforth delegate her right of government to any man or set of men whatever.”39 Today most are led by a plurality of elders to whom the pastor answers, some by a founding pastor with a board, and some by congregational vote, and many belong to networks that hold their pastors to account. They read in the New Testament of congregations with no synod over them and of elders whom “the Holy Spirit has made … overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood” (Acts 20:28). Many have watched denominations drift from the Bible and then use their property to keep faithful congregations in line, and they want no outside body between the local church and its Lord. The house churches press the priesthood of all believers furthest. Because Christ gave the Great Commission to disciples, and Peter calls the whole Church “a royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9), some of them let any believer baptize or lead the Lord’s Supper.

Lutherans will find more agreement here than they might expect. The Confessions require no particular form of church government. Lutheran churches have had bishops in Sweden, consistories in Germany, and congregational polity in America, and the Missouri Synod’s constitution makes the synod advisory to its congregations. The Treatise grounds the Church’s right to call her ministers in her possession of the Gospel: “wherever the Church is, there is the authority [command] to administer the Gospel. Therefore it is necessary for the Church to retain the authority to call, elect, and ordain ministers.”40 Lutherans also teach that any Christian may baptize in an emergency, and the Treatise itself says that “in a case of necessity even a layman absolves.”41

However, the office of preaching and administering the Sacraments is not merely the congregation’s arrangement, but Christ’s institution. The Augsburg Confession says, “That we may obtain this faith, the Ministry of Teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments was instituted.”42 The ascended Christ “gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry” (Ephesians 4:11–12). Therefore the Confession teaches “that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called.”43 What is the exception in Lutheran practice, some of these churches make the ordinary practice. Many also understand ordination not as a call into an office Christ instituted, but as the congregation’s recognition of a gift.

How congregations hold one another accountable is a matter of wisdom, and here every polity has its risks; synods have not always called their own pastors back either. The matter of doctrine is different. Congregations share the Church’s fellowship where they agree in the Gospel and the Sacraments, as the Augsburg Confession and the Formula teach, and that agreement is confessed not by each congregation alone, but together. An independent congregation can confess the Gospel rightly. What it lacks is a confession it shares and answers to with other congregations, so that when a pastor and his board fail together, there is often no one with the standing to call them back.

5. Worship

Non-denominational worship varies more than any other part of their life, from the plain hymn-singing of a small Bible church to the full band of a megachurch. The reasons are missionary. Paul was willing to “become all things to all people, that by all means I might save some” (1 Corinthians 9:22). He wanted the outsider who came into the assembly to understand, so that “the secrets of his heart are disclosed, and so, falling on his face, he will worship God and declare that God is really among you” (1 Corinthians 14:25). The New Testament gives no complete order of service and so these churches believe they are free to arrange worship in whatever way best reaches the people around them. They believe they are doing for their neighbors what the Reformation did for Luther’s, putting worship and song into the people’s own language. Many also seek what the Vineyard calls “intimate worship,” a sense of personal encounter with God in song and prayer.

Lutherans agree with much of this and should recognize their own history in it. Luther did put the service and its hymns into German. However, he changed not the shape of the service, but its language, and kept the Word read and preached, the Supper given, and the prayers of the Church, as the first Christians “devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:42). The Augsburg Confession teaches that ceremonies need not be everywhere alike, and that rites are to be kept which are “profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church,” without burdening consciences “as though such observance was necessary to salvation.”44 The Formula adds that in changing ceremonies “all frivolity and offense should be avoided, and especial care should be taken to exercise forbearance towards the weak in faith.”45 Those are the Confessions’ own tests. In Freedom and Form in Worship I argued that the form is free but always teaches something. A service shaped chiefly around the visitor’s experience can quietly teach that worship is not first the place where God comes to us with His gifts, but our work toward God, even when that is the opposite of what its pastor intends. A Lutheran congregation can just as easily turn the liturgy into a performance.

The difference becomes doctrinal when the Supper moves from the center of the Church’s life to its edges. In many non-denominational churches it is celebrated monthly or quarterly (the Stone-Campbell churches, with their weekly Supper, are the exception). Given their teaching, that follows. Lutherans must be honest here. The Apology says that “among us masses are celebrated every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals,”46 yet for generations many Lutheran congregations in America communed monthly or quarterly, and many are only now recovering the weekly Sacrament. Where the Supper is Christ’s body and blood given for the forgiveness of sins, its absence is a loss in any church, ours included.

6. The Last Things

Many non-denominational churches are premillennial: they expect Christ to return before a thousand-year reign on earth. Many of these, especially Bible churches and Calvary Chapels, also hold that the Church will be caught up to meet the Lord (the “rapture”) before a time of great tribulation on earth, a view usually joined to the system called dispensationalism. Others are historic premillennialists who expect the Church to pass through the tribulation, some hold a revised “progressive” dispensationalism, and the Vineyard speaks instead of the kingdom that “has come in the ministry of our Lord Jesus Christ” and “will be consummated in the glorious, visible, and triumphant appearing of Christ.”47 Calvary Chapel confesses “the pre-millennial return of Christ to the earth, to sit upon the throne of David and rule over the house of Jacob (Israel), and the entire cosmos, forever,” and that “the church will be delivered from the ‘hour of trial’ which will come upon all who dwell on the earth.”48

Their reasons are scriptural. The first is Revelation 20, where the saints “came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years,” and then, “The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended. This is the first resurrection” (Revelation 20:4–5). Two resurrections a thousand years apart, they say, mean a reign between them. They note that this was the hope of some of the earliest fathers. Justin Martyr wrote in the second century that he and others were “assured that there will be a resurrection of the dead, and a thousand years,” though he admitted that “many who belong to the pure and pious faith, and are true Christians, think otherwise.”49 They hold that “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Romans 11:29), so that God’s promises to Israel must yet be kept. Those who expect a rapture before the tribulation add Christ’s promise to the church at Philadelphia, “I will keep you from the hour of trial that is coming on the whole world” (Revelation 3:10), and Paul’s word that “God has not destined us for wrath” (1 Thessalonians 5:9). They do not expect to be spared the sufferings Christ promised His Church, but the wrath of the last days. They also love the imminence of His coming; the Dallas statement says of it, “for this we should be constantly looking.”50

The Augsburg Confession teaches that “at the Consummation of the World Christ will appear for judgment, and will raise up all the dead,” and it adds, “They condemn also others, who are now spreading certain Jewish opinions, that before the resurrection of the dead the godly shall take possession of the kingdom of the world, the ungodly being everywhere suppressed.”51 The people it had in view in 1530 were radical Anabaptists, some of whom expected to reign with Christ on earth and to see the ungodly put down.52 No dispensational teacher today expects the saints to seize the kingdom of this world by force, as some of those Anabaptists did, and it would break the Eighth Commandment to suggest that he does. “Jewish opinions” referred to a hope for an earthly messianic kingdom found in some Jewish teaching of the time; it describes a doctrine and should never be heard as a slur against the Jewish people. However, the article’s own teaching, that at Christ’s appearing He “will raise up all the dead” and judge, leaves no room for an earthly reign between a first resurrection of the righteous and a later one of the wicked. For that reason Lutherans have read it as answering every doctrine of an earthly millennium.

Jesus said that “an hour is coming when all who are in the tombs will hear his voice and come out, those who have done good to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil to the resurrection of judgment” (John 5:28–29). Premillennialists answer from verse 25, where the “hour” is one that “is now here,” and so may span an age. Lutherans read Revelation 20, a vision full of symbols, in the light of such plain sayings, and take the “first resurrection” as the new life of those who die in Christ and reign with Him now. In other words, we are living in the thousand years now, while Satan is bound and the Gospel goes out to the nations. The word Paul uses for “to meet” the Lord in the air (1 Thessalonians 4:17), apantēsis (“a meeting”), is the word Luke uses when the brothers from Rome “came as far as the Forum of Appius and Three Taverns to meet us” (Acts 28:15); they went out to meet Paul and came back with him into the city. In the same way, we believe, the saints are caught up to meet their returning King and come with Him.

This difference does not touch the article of justification and a Lutheran should not treat a premillennial Christian as though he had denied the Gospel. Both of us confess that Christ will return bodily and visibly, raise the dead, and judge the world, and both pray, “Come, Lord Jesus!” (Revelation 22:20). Whatever we hold about the order of the last things, both of us are promised that Christ will keep us by His Word until the last day. I took up the related question of the modern State of Israel in Should Israel Be a Country?


IV. Learning from Each Other

Lutherans have much to learn from these churches. They believe that people without Christ are lost and they act on it; they invite their neighbors, plant churches in new suburbs and old cities, and expect visitors on Sunday. Lutherans confess the same doctrine and too often act as though the next generation will arrive at our doors by birth and habit. A member of a Bible church will often know his Bible better than a lifelong Lutheran. In addition, these churches expect every Christian to have a gift to use, and many have learned to receive a stranger warmly and to gather people of different races into one congregation. Lutherans should covet that, since it grows from the Gospel.

What Lutherans have to give is not a better program, but the gifts God has placed in the Church’s hands. Some Christians raised in these churches carry a quiet uncertainty about whether they were sincere enough when they prayed. A Lutheran can tell them that God has placed His promise in water, in the spoken absolution, and in the body and blood given for them, so that faith has something outside itself to hold. Although some see the Book of Concord as a fence around Lutherans, it is a record of how the Church has read the Scriptures when the hardest questions were pressed, and it can steady any congregation that reads it. The liturgy, the church year, and the hymns of Luther and Gerhardt join a young congregation to the Church of every century. Luther’s theology of the cross, that God is often hidden in suffering and weakness, has helped many who were taught that faith always brings visible blessing and then met grief.


V. When Your Child Worships There

Many of us have a son, a daughter, or a grandchild in one of these churches. Be glad of what is there. Christ is preached, the Scriptures are read and loved, and the Holy Spirit works through that Word. Your child’s Baptism still stands, because it was God’s work and God does not take it back. If the church asks him to be baptized again, you may tell him gently that his first Baptism was already Christ’s own act and needs no repeating, and then leave the matter between him and his pastor without quarrel. When he comes home for Christmas, his church will probably welcome you to its Table, because most of these churches hold that the Table belongs to all believers. If your pastor asks him to speak with him before communing at yours, it is not a verdict that he is no Christian. It is the Lutheran practice of communing together those who confess together what the Sacrament is, a confession he may not yet share. Talk with him about the Bible he loves. Ask what his pastor is preaching. Pray for him and let him see that you are glad he follows Christ.


Conclusion

Thomas Campbell wrote in 1809 that “the Church of Christ upon earth is essentially, intentionally, and constitutionally one.” A confessional Lutheran believes that too. He believes it so firmly that he will not cover the differences over Baptism, the Supper, and the office with a short statement, because he holds that in these things the Gospel itself is given. He also believes it firmly enough to call the Bible church member down the road his brother in Christ.

What we can do now is keep reading the Scriptures together and speaking the truth in love. We can also wait together. Paul describes the whole Church as “waiting for our blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ” (Titus 2:13). Lutherans and non-denominational Christians do not yet agree about the order of the last things, but we are waiting for the same Lord. When He appears He will settle what we have not and will know His own in every congregation where His Word was preached.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture and the Lutheran Confessions

The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.

Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1921.

Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000.

The Non-Denominational Churches and Their Roots

Calvary Chapel. “History” and “What We Believe.” calvarychapel.com. Accessed November 18, 2026.

Campbell, Thomas. Declaration and Address, and Barton W. Stone and others, The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery. With an introduction by F. D. Kershner. St. Louis: Bethany Press, 1960.

Dallas Theological Seminary. “Doctrinal Statement.” dts.edu. Accessed November 18, 2026.

Finney, Charles G. Lectures on Revivals of Religion. 1835. Christian Classics Ethereal Library.

Vineyard USA. Core Values & Beliefs. Vineyard Resources, 2016.

Other Sources

Bird, Warren, and Scott Thumma. Megachurch 2020: The Changing Reality in America’s Largest Churches. Hartford, CT: Hartford Institute for Religion Research, 2020.

Blaising, Craig A., and Darrell L. Bock. Progressive Dispensationalism. Wheaton, IL: BridgePoint, 1993.

Justin Martyr. Dialogue with Trypho. In Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1. Christian Classics Ethereal Library.

Pew Research Center. “Religious Landscape Study: Religious Identity” and “Methodology for the 2023-24 Religious Landscape Study.” February 26, 2025.

Thumma, Scott. A Report on the 2020 Faith Communities Today Study of U.S. Nondenominational and Independent Churches. Hartford, CT: Hartford Institute for Religion Research, 2020.

Denominationalism and “Just Jesus”: The Confession Behind the Claim.

Freedom and Form in Worship.

One Body at Many Altars.

Should Israel Be a Country?

Footnotes

  1. Scott Thumma, A Report on the 2020 Faith Communities Today Study of U.S. Nondenominational and Independent Churches (Hartford, CT: Hartford Institute for Religion Research, 2020), 1 (page numbers of the PDF). ↩

  2. The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery (1804), in Thomas Campbell, Declaration and Address, and Barton W. Stone and others, The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, with an introduction by F. D. Kershner (St. Louis: Bethany Press, 1960), 17. ↩

  3. Thomas Campbell, Declaration and Address (1809), Proposition 1, in the Bethany Press edition, 44. The proposition continues, “consisting of all those in every place that profess their faith in Christ and obedience to him in all things according to the Scriptures.” ↩

  4. Campbell, Declaration and Address, Proposition 3, 45. ↩

  5. Campbell, Declaration and Address, Proposition 7, 46. The full phrase is “doctrinal exhibitions of the great system of Divine truths, and defensive testimonies in opposition to prevailing errors.” ↩

  6. Charles G. Finney, Lectures on Revivals of Religion, Lecture I (Christian Classics Ethereal Library text). The CCEL text appears to follow a later revised edition; the wording of the first edition (1835) has not been checked. ↩

  7. Thumma, Report, 2–4. Thumma writes that “the dominant theological perspective is evangelical Christian” and that “the vast majority of nondenominational churches would and should be categorized as evangelical,” and that a “significant portion” claim the label Fundamentalist. ↩

  8. Calvary Chapel, “History,” calvarychapel.com (accessed November 18, 2026). The figure is Calvary Chapel’s own and is undated on the page. The movement has been organized in more than one network since the 2010s; the “What We Believe” page is published by the Calvary Global Network. ↩

  9. Calvary Chapel, “What We Believe,” calvarychapel.com (accessed November 18, 2026). ↩

  10. Vineyard USA, Core Values & Beliefs (Vineyard Resources, 2016), “A People of the Kingdom of God.” ↩

  11. Warren Bird and Scott Thumma, Megachurch 2020: The Changing Reality in America’s Largest Churches (Hartford Institute for Religion Research, 2020), 2, 4, 32 (PDF page numbers). The survey received responses from 582 megachurches (weekly attendance of 2,000 or more), weighted to represent an estimated 1,750; 40 percent named themselves non-denominational, and 51 percent belonged to a network, fellowship, or association. ↩

  12. Pew Research Center, “Religious Landscape Study: Religious Identity,” February 26, 2025, and “Methodology for the 2023-24 Religious Landscape Study”: 36,908 adults surveyed July 17, 2023, to March 4, 2024; nondenominational Protestants 7 percent of U.S. adults, Baptists 12 percent. Pew counts as nondenominational only those who describe themselves explicitly as “nondenominational Protestant” or “nondenominational Christian.” Thumma, Report, 1: a 2019–2020 listing of “over 60,000” independent and non-denominational churches “representing at least 12 million adherents,” “still being finalized”; the National Congregations Study (2018–2019) estimates that 20 percent of congregations belong to no denomination. ↩

  13. Calvary Chapel, “What We Believe.” ↩

  14. FC Ep, Rule and Norm, 7. ↩

  15. Calvary Chapel, “What We Believe.” ↩

  16. Calvary Chapel, “What We Believe”; Dallas Theological Seminary, “Doctrinal Statement,” Article VII, “Salvation Only through Christ” (dts.edu, accessed November 18, 2026). ↩

  17. AC IV.1–2. ↩

  18. Calvary Chapel, “What We Believe.” ↩

  19. Vineyard USA, Core Values & Beliefs, Statement of Faith, “The Church: Instrument of the Kingdom.” ↩

  20. AC VII.1. ↩

  21. Thumma, Report, 4. ↩

  22. Ibid. The figures are 48 percent and 21 percent. ↩

  23. Preface to the Book of Concord (Triglotta, p. 19). The Preface speaks first of the controversy over the Lord’s Supper. ↩

  24. Peter Meiderlin, Paraenesis votiva pro pace ecclesiae ad theologos Augustanae confessionis (1626), published under the name Rupertus Meldenius. The tract closes with a call to unity in necessary things and liberty in others; the English motto in its familiar form developed from it. The attribution is the standard one (Schaff–Herzog; Deutsche Biographie). ↩

  25. Vineyard USA, Core Values & Beliefs, Foreword. ↩

  26. FC Ep, Rule and Norm, 8. ↩

  27. AC VII.2–3. ↩

  28. FC SD X.31; compare FC Ep X.7. ↩

  29. Vineyard USA, Core Values & Beliefs, Statement of Faith, “Baptism and the Lord’s Supper”; Dallas Theological Seminary, “Doctrinal Statement,” Article XIV, “The Sacraments or Ordinances.” ↩

  30. Dallas Theological Seminary, “Doctrinal Statement,” Article VII. ↩

  31. Ap XIII.3. ↩

  32. AC XIII.1. ↩

  33. AC X.1. Compare Matthew 26:26, “this is my body.” ↩

  34. LC IV.10. ↩

  35. Dallas Theological Seminary, “Doctrinal Statement,” Article XI, “Assurance.” Calvary Chapel’s statement cites Titus 3:5 and Ephesians 2:8–9 for the Spirit’s work and for salvation by grace. ↩

  36. Dallas Theological Seminary, “Doctrinal Statement,” Article VII. ↩

  37. LC II.38. ↩

  38. AC V.2–3. The Smalcald Articles say the same: “we ought and must constantly maintain this point, that God does not wish to deal with us otherwise than through the spoken Word and the Sacraments” (SA III.viii.10). ↩

  39. The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, in the Bethany Press edition, 18. ↩

  40. Tr 67. ↩

  41. Tr 67. ↩

  42. AC V.1. ↩

  43. AC XIV. ↩

  44. AC VII.3; AC XV.1–2. ↩

  45. FC Ep X.3. ↩

  46. Ap XXIV.1. ↩

  47. Vineyard USA, Core Values & Beliefs, Statement of Faith, “The Kingdom of God and the Final Judgment.” On progressive dispensationalism see Craig A. Blaising and Darrell L. Bock, Progressive Dispensationalism (Wheaton, IL: BridgePoint, 1993). ↩

  48. Calvary Chapel, “What We Believe,” citing Revelation 20:1–6, Luke 1:31–33, and Isaiah 9:6–7 for the first statement and 1 Thessalonians 4:16–17, 1 Corinthians 15:51–55, and Revelation 3:10 for the second. ↩

  49. Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 80, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1 (CCEL). ↩

  50. Dallas Theological Seminary, “Doctrinal Statement,” Article XVIII, “The Blessed Hope.” Article XIX distinguishes the tribulation of “Israel’s seventieth week,” during which “the church … will be in heaven.” Compare Titus 2:13 and, for the suffering all Christians share, John 16:33. ↩

  51. AC XVII.1–2, 5, from the Triglotta’s English translation of the Latin text. ↩

  52. The Triglotta’s Historical Introductions (§ 260, “Dachser and Hutt”) connect the condemnation with the followers of Hans Hut, who taught that “Judgment Day is imminent; then the Anabaptists will reign with Christ on earth.” ↩

Topics
Other Churches and TraditionsBaptism
Scripture
2 Timothy 1:13–14Acts 2:38Romans 16:5Acts 2:461 Corinthians 14:26Acts 17:11Romans 15:72 Timothy 3:17Matthew 15:9Titus 3:51 Corinthians 10:16Romans 10:9Revelation 3:20John 6:441 John 5:13Romans 10:14Acts 20:281 Peter 2:9Ephesians 4:11–121 Corinthians 9:221 Corinthians 14:25Acts 2:42Revelation 20:4–5Romans 11:29Revelation 3:101 Thessalonians 5:9John 5:28–291 Thessalonians 4:17Acts 28:15Revelation 22:20Titus 2:13Matthew 26:26Ephesians 2:8–9Revelation 20:1–6Luke 1:31–33Isaiah 9:6–71 Thessalonians 4:16–171 Corinthians 15:51–55John 16:33
Confessions
AC IVAC VIISD XEp XAp XIIIAC XIIIAC XLC IVLC IIAC VSA IIIAC XIVAC XVAp XXIVAC XVIILC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and the Non-Denominational Churches: Bible Churches, Fellowships, and the Question of a Confession.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/non-denominational/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.