Papers · Essays

Why Not Every Sunday?

The Lord's Supper and the Lord's Day in Lutheran Practice

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“On the first day of the week, when we were gathered together to break bread…” — Acts 20:7


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. Luther’s liturgical writings are quoted from the Philadelphia Edition of his Works, volume 6, his Brief Exhortation to Confession from the older (Henkel) translation printed at bookofconcord.org, and Ambrose’s On the Sacraments from the translation of T. Thompson.


The Question Before Us

If Christ instituted the Lord’s Supper, why do Lutherans not celebrate it every Sunday? The question comes to us from more than one direction. Sometimes a lifelong Lutheran asks it after visiting a congregation where the Sacrament is offered every week. Sometimes a newcomer asks it after reading the Augsburg Confession for the first time and finding there that the Lutheran churches of 1530 held “one communion every holy-day.”1 Sometimes a Roman Catholic or Episcopalian friend asks it with a puzzled look, because in his church the Supper is the Sunday service. And sometimes it is asked the other way around by a faithful member who has communed once a month all his life and wonders why anyone would want to change.

In an earlier paper, On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper, I set out the positive case for weekly communion. There we heard our Lord’s command to “do this” and Paul’s hosakis (“as often as,” 1 Corinthians 11:26). We heard the apostolic Church devote itself to “the breaking of bread” (Acts 2:42) and gather “on the first day of the week” to do it (Acts 20:7). We listened to the Didache, to Justin Martyr, to Basil, Chrysostom and Augustine. We heard Luther urge the people to “receive this venerable Sacrament often,” and Melanchthon confess in the Apology that among the Lutherans “masses are celebrated every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals.”2 We also traced how so many Lutherans, especially in America, came to commune only monthly or quarterly: through the scruples of Pietism, the doubts of Rationalism, the scarcity of pastors on the frontier, and the quarterly custom borrowed from Reformed neighbors. Then we saw how the Sacrament has been finding its way back to the Lord’s Day. I hold to those conclusions.

However, a history does not answer every objection. A person can agree that the early Church communed every Sunday and still have good reasons, or reasons that sound good, for not doing so now. Those reasons deserve a fair hearing. In this paper I want to take up the six that are heard most often: 1) “It will become routine and lose its specialness.” 2) “Frequency is a matter of Christian freedom and the Confessions do not command weekly communion.” 3) “It will make the service too long and visitors will not understand.” 4) “We do not have enough pastors.” 5) “The Word is enough; the Sacrament adds nothing to it.” 6) “Our tradition has always been monthly.” At each step we will state the objection as its best defenders would state it and then answer it from Holy Scripture, the Lutheran Confessions, the fathers and the Reformers.

One more thing should be said at the outset. The Lord’s Supper is a gift and not a law. A paper like this one could easily be turned against congregations that do not yet celebrate it every week and that would be a misuse of both the Sacrament and the Confessions. Luther would not compel anyone to the Table and neither will we. Yet he did not stop urging and neither should we.


I. The Lord’s Supper and the Lord’s Day

The words themselves

We begin with the words. The New Testament uses the Greek adjective kyriakos (“of or belonging to the Lord”) only twice.3 Once it names a meal: Paul writes to the Corinthians, “When you come together, it is not the Lord’s supper (kyriakon deipnon) that you eat” (1 Corinthians 11:20). Once it names a day: John writes, “I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day (kyriakē hēmera)” (Revelation 1:10). Thayer defines the first as “the supper instituted by the Lord” and the second as “the day devoted to the Lord, sacred to the memory of Christ’s resurrection.”4 It is interesting that the only two things the New Testament calls “the Lord’s” in this way are a supper and a day. The Church’s earliest manual of practice joins them in a single sentence: “But every Lord’s day gather yourselves together, and break bread, and give thanksgiving after having confessed your transgressions, that your sacrifice may be pure.”5

Paul’s rebuke in 1 Corinthians 11 also tells us something about the Corinthians’ assembly. He does not scold them for coming together without the Supper. He scolds them because their coming together was meant to be the Lord’s Supper and their quarrels and gluttony had made it something else. The whole passage assumes that when the congregation gathers, it gathers to eat: “So then, my brothers, when you come together to eat, wait for one another” (1 Corinthians 11:33). Likewise at Troas, Luke gives the purpose of the Sunday assembly in a single phrase: “we were gathered together to break bread” (Acts 20:7). In other words, the Lord’s Day and the Lord’s Supper were not two separate things that happened to fall together now and then. The day was the day of the meal.

What our Confessions describe

The Lutheran Confessions describe the same pattern. The Augsburg Confession says that “the Mass is retained among us, and celebrated with the highest reverence,” and it explains that “we hold one communion every holy-day, and, if any desire the Sacrament, also on other days, when it is given to such as ask for it.”6 The Apology says it again: “among us masses are celebrated every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals, in which the Sacrament is offered to those who wish to use it, after they have been examined and absolved.”7 The same articles are just as plain that this weekly Sacrament came with examination and absolution. “None are admitted except they be first examined,” says the Augsburg Confession, and in the next article, “it is not usual to give the body of the Lord, except to them that have been previously examined and absolved.”8 When the Confessions say “Mass” in these articles they mean the public Divine Service in which the people commune, not the private Mass they rejected.

The same article of the Augsburg Confession is honest about what was not done. It reports from the Tripartite History that “in olden times, even in churches most frequented, the Mass was not celebrated every day,” and that in Alexandria “every Wednesday and Friday the Scriptures are read, and the doctors expound them, and all things are done, except the solemn rite of Communion.”9 So the Reformers knew of services of the Word without the Sacrament and did not regard them as strange. What they described as their own practice was a Sunday and festival Sacrament, with the Word read and preached on other days.

Christ set no number

It must also be said plainly that our Lord attached no number to His command. Luther takes up this point in the Large Catechism. Someone says, “But the words are added, As oft as ye do it; there He compels no one, but leaves it to our free choice.” Luther answers, “That is true, yet it is not written that we should never do so.” Christ said “as oft as” because “He wishes to have the Sacrament free, not limited to special times, like the Passover of the Jews, which they were obliged to eat only once a year.”10 Therefore the question before us is not “Has Christ commanded weekly communion?” He has not. The question is what a congregation that loves the gift and loves its neighbor will choose to do with the freedom Christ has given.


II. “It Will Become Routine”

The objection

The first objection is the one most often spoken by the most reverent people. Something given every week, they say, will become ordinary. We do not celebrate an anniversary every Sunday. If the Supper is received every week, will we not begin to receive it without thinking? A monthly or quarterly celebration, on this view, protects the Sacrament’s dignity. People prepare for it and look forward to it and when the day comes it feels like an occasion.

This objection deserves respect. It comes from people who do not want to treat a holy thing lightly and Scripture shares their concern: “Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup” (1 Corinthians 11:28). Augustine was asked about it in his own day. He reported that some said “the Eucharist ought not to be taken every day,” because a man should “choose those days upon which he lives in more special purity and self-restraint.” He did not mock them. He compared them to the centurion who said, “I am not worthy that You should come under my roof,” and those who communed daily to Zacchaeus, who “received the Lord joyfully into his house.” His judgment was that “he that dares not take it every day, and he who dares not omit it any day, are both alike moved by a desire to do it honour.”11 We should be at least as charitable as Augustine.

What routine means

What do we mean by routine? Webster gives two senses. The first is “a round of business, amusements or pleasure, daily or frequently pursued.” The second is “any regular habit or practice not accommodated to circumstances.”12 The objection fears the second sense: a habit that goes on whether or not the heart is in it. Yet the Christian life is full of the first sense. We pray the Lord’s Prayer daily. We hear the Word read and preached every Sunday. We confess our sins at the start of every service. No one argues that the sermon should be preached once a month so that it will feel special, or that the absolution should be pronounced quarterly to protect its dignity.

Likewise, Augustine made this comparison in a sermon on the Lord’s Prayer. “The Eucharist is our daily bread,” he told the people preparing for Baptism. Then he added, “what I am handling before you now is daily bread; and the daily lessons which you hear in church, are daily bread, and the hymns ye hear and repeat are daily bread. For all these are necessary in our state of pilgrimage.”13 For Augustine the Supper belonged with the Word and the hymns as the ordinary food of pilgrims. Ordinary food is simply the food we cannot live without.

The need is daily

Luther grounds the frequency of the Supper in the need it answers. In the Large Catechism he calls it “a food of souls, which nourishes and strengthens the new man.” Baptism gives us new birth, “but… there still remains, besides, the old vicious nature of flesh and blood in man, and there are so many hindrances and temptations of the devil and of the world that we often become weary and faint, and sometimes also stumble. Therefore it is given for a daily pasture and sustenance, that faith may refresh and strengthen itself so as not to fall back in such a battle, but become ever stronger and stronger.” The devil, he says, “does not desist, until he finally wearies us,” and so “the consolation is here given when the heart feels that the burden is becoming too heavy, that it may here obtain new power and refreshment.”14

This changes the shape of the question. If the Supper were a ceremony whose value lay in its rarity, then rarity would protect it. However, the value of the Supper lies in what it gives: “This is My body and blood, given and shed for you, for the remission of sins.”15 Its worth does not rise or fall with the calendar. A hungry man is not helped by being fed less often so that his meals will feel like occasions. In other words, the Sacrament is special because of whose body and blood it is and not because of how seldom we receive it.

Rarity is also a routine

In addition, infrequent communion can become a routine in Webster’s second sense: a habit that goes on regardless of circumstances. Luther saw this happen. Those who stay away waiting until they feel prepared, he wrote, “tarry until they are prepared, so long that one week trails another, and one half year the other.” He warned that “if a person thus withdraw from this Sacrament, he will daily become more and more callous and cold, and will at last disregard it altogether.” The remedy he gives is to come and to examine the heart, because “the more this is done, the more will the heart be warmed and enkindled, that it may not become entirely cold.”16 The habit of absence is as real as the habit of presence and it is far more dangerous.

Chrysostom’s warning, heard carefully

John Chrysostom is sometimes quoted on both sides of this question, so we should hear him carefully. Preaching at Antioch, he complained of people who received the Sacrament “lightly and just as it happens, and rather from custom and form, than consideration and understanding.” Yet his complaint was aimed at those who came only at certain seasons. “When… the holy season of Lent sets in, whatever a man may be, he partakes of the mysteries, or, when the day of the Lord’s Epiphany comes. And yet it is not the Epiphany, nor is it Lent, that makes a fit time for approaching, but it is sincerity and purity of soul. With this, approach at all times; without it, never.” In the same homily he lamented the empty altar: “In vain is the daily Sacrifice, in vain do we stand before the Altar; there is no one to partake.”17

Chrysostom’s language about purity can sound as though the communicant must make himself worthy and here a Lutheran must read him with care. Our Confessions teach that the right preparation is faith in Christ’s words. “This, now, is the entire Christian preparation for receiving this Sacrament worthily,” Luther says, faith that believes the words “given and shed for you.”18 Yet Chrysostom’s main point stands and it cuts against the objection. Thoughtless communion is not cured by the calendar. A man who receives carelessly four times a year has not been made reverent by the long gaps between. The cure for routine is teaching, self-examination and confession, which is exactly why the Didache joins the Sunday breaking of bread to the confession of sins and the Apology joins the Sunday Sacrament to those who have been “examined and absolved.”


III. “Frequency Is a Matter of Freedom”

The objection

The second objection is the most theological and in one sense it is simply true. The Confessions do not command weekly communion. They teach that “it is not necessary that human traditions, that is, rites or ceremonies, instituted by men, should be everywhere alike.”19 They teach that church usages “ought to be observed which may be observed without sin,” while “consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation.”20 The Formula of Concord confesses that every congregation “has, according to its circumstances, the good right, power, and authority [in matters truly adiaphora] to change, to diminish, and to increase them.”21 Therefore, the argument runs, a congregation that celebrates monthly is using its freedom and no one may say otherwise.

The word at stake is adiaphoron (plural adiaphora), a Greek word meaning “a thing indifferent.” The Formula defines adiaphora as “ceremonies and church rites which are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word, but are introduced into the Church with a good intention, for the sake of good order and propriety.”22 The fathers spoke this way about frequency too. Augustine listed it among the things “different in different places and countries”: “some partake daily of the body and blood of Christ, others receive it on stated days.” Of such things he said “one is at liberty to comply with them or not as he chooses.”23 Luther agreed. In 1523, when he first wrote about reordering the services at Wittenberg, he said that if some desired the Sacrament on a day other than Sunday, Mass should be held “as devotion and time permit; for in this connection one cannot lay down either a law or a limit.”24

The Supper itself is not indifferent

We grant all of this and still have to make a distinction. The Lord’s Supper itself is not an adiaphoron, because it is commanded. Luther calls the words “Do this in remembrance of Me” “bidding and commanding words by which all who would be Christians are enjoined to partake of this Sacrament.”25 What is free is the time and the frequency, not the Supper. That is why Luther, in the very place where he concedes that Christ set no time, refuses to let the concession become an excuse. “Thus, you perceive, it is not left free in the sense that we may despise it.” Despising it, he says, is when “one allow so long a time to elapse and with nothing to hinder him yet never feels a desire for it.”26 He had already met the freedom argument among his own people, some of whom said the Sacrament was a matter of liberty and that faith was enough without it, and he warned that the road ends in despising both the Sacrament and the Word.27

Freedom is the servant of love

There is a second distinction. Christian freedom is real but it is never freedom for its own sake. Paul writes, “For you were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13). Luther applied this directly to worship in the preface to his German Mass. He begged that no one make his order “a law or cause anyone’s conscience to be distressed or bound by it.” In the same breath he said, “we must see to it that freedom is and shall ever be the servant of love and of the neighbor.”28 The Formula says the same when it describes the congregation’s right to change what is free. The right is to be used “without thoughtlessness and offense, in an orderly and becoming way, as at any time it may be regarded most profitable, most beneficial, and best for [preserving] good order… and the edification of the Church.”21

Therefore the freedom argument does not end the conversation; it starts it. If frequency is free, then a congregation has to ask which use of its freedom is “most profitable, most beneficial” for the people Christ has given it. Does the Sacrament strengthen faith? Then more opportunities to receive it serve the neighbor. Is the Sacrament a remedy for daily sin? Then a congregation that offers it once a month has chosen, in freedom, to offer it less often than it could. That may be the wisest choice for a time and a place but it is a choice and it can be examined in love.

What the Reformers did with their freedom

There is a third point. The Augsburg Confession and the Apology do not command weekly communion but they describe it. When the Lutheran Reformers were free to order their services however they judged best, they chose a celebration “every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals.” The same Reformers who set the Table every Lord’s Day also kept confession and absolution beside it, as we heard above. A congregation that recovers the first should recover the second as well, with private absolution offered and not required. A description is not a law. Yet it tells us how the men who wrote our Confessions used the freedom we are now invoking. Martin Chemnitz drew the same conclusion a generation later. In his Examination of the Council of Trent he reasoned from Christ’s “as often as” that the Lord wills His disciples to use the Supper frequently and he warned that ministers who frighten their people away from frequent reception are not faithful servants of Christ.29 It would be strange to quote the Reformers’ teaching on freedom against their own practice.

Calvin’s judgment belongs here as an honest aside. He was no friend of what he regarded as Roman ceremony and he did not think frequency should be compelled: “No one, indeed, ought to be forced.” Yet he wrote that the Supper “was not instituted to be received once a-year and that perfunctorily,” and that the Lord’s Table “ought to have been spread” for the congregation “each week, at least.”30 The magistrates of Geneva did not grant his wish and he lived with a less frequent celebration than he wanted. It is a curious fact of history that the quarterly custom many American Lutherans later absorbed from their Reformed neighbors was one that the great teacher of the Reformed Church himself regarded as a defect.

No law in either direction

The Formula of Concord closes its article on adiaphora with a word that applies to us. “The churches will not condemn one another because of dissimilarity of ceremonies when, in Christian liberty, one has less or more of them, provided they are otherwise agreed with one another in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”31 So the freedom cuts both ways. Weekly communion may not be imposed as a law that binds consciences and a congregation that communes monthly is not thereby unfaithful. However, monthly communion may not be defended as though freedom were a reason for any of us to stay away when the Table is set, which is the very use of freedom Luther refused. Luther’s warning there is spoken to the person who could come and does not. A member who comes each time his congregation offers the Supper is not despising it.


IV. “It Will Make the Service Too Long” and “Visitors Will Not Understand”

The length of the service

The third objection is practical and should be answered practically. Distributing the Sacrament takes time. Many people have commitments after church and older members may find it hard to sit or stand for long. A pastor who ignores this is being careless of his people.

Yet several things can be said. First, the early Church did not regard the length of the service as a reason to omit the Supper. Justin tells us that on Sunday “the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits,” and then the president preached, the people prayed, and the bread and wine were brought and distributed “to each.”32 At Troas the service went on even longer. Paul “prolonged his speech until midnight,” and after Eutychus was raised, Luke reports that Paul “had gone up and had broken bread and eaten” (Acts 20:7, 11). In other words, the Supper was not the part of the service people were willing to drop when time ran short.

Second, we should remember what the hour is for. The Apology teaches that “the worship and divine service of the Gospel is to receive from God gifts.”33 If the Divine Service is first of all God serving us, then the Sacrament is not an addition to the hour but one of the chief gifts the hour exists to give. Third, nearly everything else in the order of service is free. The Formula gives the congregation the right “to change, to diminish, and to increase” what is not commanded. The number of hymns, the length of the announcements, the way the distribution is ordered: all of these may be adjusted with good sense. What a congregation should not do is make the one commanded thing the first thing to go.

Visitors and newcomers

The other half of this objection is pastoral and it is also sincere. A visitor who has never been to a liturgical church, or who has been taught that communion is a bare memorial, may be confused by the Sacrament or uncomfortable at not receiving it. Should we not keep the Sunday service simpler for their sake?

Our Confessions take visitors and the uninstructed seriously. The Augsburg Confession says that “ceremonies are needed to this end alone that the unlearned be taught,” and that “the people are also advised concerning the dignity and use of the Sacrament, how great consolation it brings anxious consciences.”34 Luther opens his treatment of the Sacrament in the Large Catechism by saying that “it is not our intention to admit to it and to administer it to those who know not what they seek, or why they come.”35 So a visitor is not expected to commune on his first Sunday without instruction. How a congregation receives guests at the Table is a question of its own that the pastor will teach and we leave it there.

However, the presence of visitors is not a reason to hide the Sacrament from them. Paul expects that “an unbeliever or outsider” will enter the assembly, and that “the secrets of his heart are disclosed, and so, falling on his face, he will worship God and declare that God is really among you” (1 Corinthians 14:24–25). The Supper is part of how the Church proclaims Christ to those who watch: “as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes” (1 Corinthians 11:26). Luther called the public Sunday service “a public provocation to faith and to Christianity.”36 He meant that the Sunday service exists for those who are not yet believers as well as for those who are. A visitor who sees a congregation come forward to receive forgiveness has seen something true about the Gospel, even before he understands it. What he needs is a plain word of explanation and a welcome. Both can be given every Sunday.


V. “We Do Not Have Enough Pastors”

The real constraint

The fourth objection is the most honest of all and in many places it is the real reason. The Lord’s Supper requires a regularly called minister. The Augsburg Confession teaches “that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called.”37 Paul asks, “And how are they to preach unless they are sent?” (Romans 10:15). Many congregations are served by a pastor who divides his time among several parishes, or by an interim, or by supply preachers who are not able to preside at the altar. A congregation in that situation may want the Sacrament every week and simply not have the minister to give it.

Why not let a layman preside? The companion paper The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry takes up that question at length. In short, AC XIV rests on the ministry God Himself instituted, for “the ministry of the Word has God’s command and glorious promises,” and it also serves good order and the comfort of the hearers.38 The Confessions do allow that “in a case of necessity even a layman absolves,” and the Church has long allowed a layman to baptize a dying infant, but a case of necessity does not turn the ordinary Sunday into an emergency.39 It is enough here to say that a congregation without a pastor at the altar on a given Sunday has not done anything wrong. It is living under a real limit.

The Service of the Word is God’s true service

What, then, of the Sundays when the Sacrament cannot be offered? Here we must speak carefully, because the case for weekly communion can be made in a way that belittles the Word. That would be a serious mistake. A Sunday of the Word alone is not a second-class Sunday.

The Smalcald Articles teach that the Gospel “not merely in one way gives us counsel and aid against sin; for God is superabundantly rich [and liberal] in His grace.” It comes “first, through the spoken Word by which the forgiveness of sins is preached… in the whole world; which is the peculiar office of the Gospel. Secondly, through Baptism. Thirdly, through the holy Sacrament of the Altar. Fourthly, through the power of the keys, and also through the mutual conversation and consolation of brethren.”40 The spoken Word stands first in that list. “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:17). Where the Gospel is preached and the absolution spoken, Christ is present giving the forgiveness of sins, and those who believe it have it.

The Reformers knew this. We have already heard the Augsburg Confession point to the services of Alexandria, where the Scriptures were read and expounded on Wednesdays and Fridays “and all things are done, except the solemn rite of Communion.” Luther wrote in 1523 that the daily private masses should be abolished, “for the importance is in the Word and not in the masses.”41 In the Formula Missae he put the Word and the Supper side by side. It would be “most absurd for a minister of the Word… to publish the Word in public ministration where there is no hearer, and to cry aloud to himself alone amid rocks and woods,” and it is equally wrong to prepare the Supper “where there would be no guests who would eat and drink.”42 Both are gifts meant for people. Neither is a performance.

Therefore a congregation that hears the Word preached faithfully on a Sunday without the Sacrament has been fed. It has not received less of Christ’s forgiveness, for Christ’s forgiveness is not divided into portions. It has received the Gospel in one of the ways God gives it rather than in two.

Yet scarcity is not a virtue

Having said that, we must also say that a shortage of pastors is a reason to pray and not a reason to be content. Our Lord said, “The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few; therefore pray earnestly to the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers into his harvest” (Matthew 9:37–38). The earlier paper showed how the frontier “preaching service,” which began as a hardship, slowly became an expectation and then a preference. We should not let the same thing happen again. Where the limit is real, we accept it with gratitude for the Word. Where the limit has become a habit, we should recognize it as one.

Luther’s Brief Exhortation to Confession says something about pastors that applies here. The people come in freedom, he writes, but the pastors stand under orders: “we force no one, but permit ourselves to be urged, even as we are constrained to preach, and to administer the sacraments.”43 In other words, the obligation runs toward the minister. It is his duty to make the Sacrament available as often as he is able and it is the congregation’s freedom to ask for it. The Augsburg Confession also says the Sacrament was given on other days “when it is given to such as ask for it.”1 Midweek services, festival days, and the private communion of the sick and the homebound all belong to the same pastoral care. Justin tells us that already in the second century “to those who are absent a portion is sent by the deacons.”32 The Church has always looked for ways to bring the Supper to those who hunger for it.


VI. “The Word Is Enough”

The objection

The fifth objection is a theological one and Lutherans in particular are prone to it. We are a church of the Word. We believe that the preached Gospel gives the forgiveness of sins, life and salvation. If that is true, then what does the Sacrament add? Does not Melanchthon himself say in the Apology that “the effect of the Word and of the rite is the same”? If the effect is the same, then a congregation that hears the Gospel every Sunday lacks nothing when it communes once a month.

This objection is right about the Word and wrong about the Sacrament. The Apology does say that the effect is the same. It explains why: “just as the Word enters the ear in order to strike our heart, so the rite itself strikes the eye, in order to move the heart.” It then cites Augustine’s saying “that a Sacrament is a visible word.”44 The point is that the Sacrament gives the same Gospel the Word gives. There is no second forgiveness hidden in the Supper that the sermon lacks. Yet it does not follow that the Sacrament is unnecessary. It follows that God has given the same gift in more than one form because He is “superabundantly rich” toward us.

Luther names the objection

Luther met this exact objection and refused it. “Some pretend that it is a matter of liberty and not necessary, and that it is sufficient to believe without it; and thus for the most part they go so far that they become quite brutish, and finally despise both the Sacrament and the Word of God.”27 The two stand or fall together. Luther also answered those who denied that the Supper could forgive sins, since forgiveness was won on the cross. “Although the work is accomplished and the forgiveness of sins acquired on the cross, yet it cannot come to us in any other way than through the Word.” Then he added, “the entire Gospel and the article of the Creed: I believe a holy Christian Church, the forgiveness of sin, etc., are by the Word embodied in this Sacrament and presented to us.”45 The Sacrament is the Word, embodied and given.

What the Supper gives in its own way

What, then, does the Supper give in its own way? We may name three things.

First, the Supper gives the Gospel to each one personally. A sermon is spoken to all who hear it and every hearer must take its promise as his own. In the Sacrament the promise is placed into the hand and mouth of each communicant with the words “given and shed for you.” Luther says these words “are not preached to wood and stone, but to me and you,” and he urges each of us to “put yourself into this You, that He may not speak to you in vain.”46 For a troubled conscience that wonders whether the promise preached to everyone really includes him, this is no small thing.

Second, the Supper gives Christ’s true body and blood. “It is the true body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, in and under the bread and wine which we Christians are commanded by the Word of Christ to eat and to drink.”47 The companion paper One Body at Many Altars treats this presence fully. For our purpose it is enough to say that the Supper is a pledge. Luther calls it “a sure pledge and token, yea, the very same treasure that is appointed for me against my sins, death, and every calamity.”48 We do not need a pledge because God’s Word is unreliable. We need it because our faith is weak and God in His kindness gives the weak something to hold.

Third, the Supper makes the congregation one. “The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:16–17). The Word gathers the Church. The Supper shows and seals what the Word has gathered. Augustine told the newly baptized that in the Eucharist “the virtue which is apprehended there, is unity, that gathered together into His body, and made His members, we may be what we receive.”49

Therefore we need not choose between the Word and the Sacrament. We do not refuse a second gift because the first was sufficient and we do not despise the first because the second is precious. Christ gave both and commanded both. He said, “Go into all the world and proclaim the gospel to the whole creation” (Mark 16:15), and He said, “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19).


VII. “Our Tradition Has Always Been Monthly”

The objection

The sixth objection is the one most often heard and least often argued. “This is how we have always done it.” In one sense it is not an argument at all. Yet it would be unfair to dismiss it, because tradition matters to Lutherans. We kept the historic liturgy, the church year and the vestments when others set them aside. Augustine himself counseled Christians to follow the custom of the church where they found themselves. Ambrose had told him, “When I visit Rome, I fast on Saturday; when I am here, I do not fast,” and Augustine applied the same rule to the frequency of communion. Such a custom, “if it is clearly not contrary to the faith nor to sound morality, is to be held as a thing indifferent, and ought to be observed for the sake of fellowship with those among whom we live.”50 A member who has communed monthly all his life is not being stubborn when he values what formed his faith.

Our tradition is older than our grandparents

The answer is that our tradition is much older than the customs we remember. The prophet says, “Stand by the roads, and look, and ask for the ancient paths, where the good way is; and walk in it” (Jeremiah 6:16). When we ask for the ancient paths, we find the Didache gathering “every Lord’s day” to break bread and Justin describing a Sunday on which the Supper was distributed to all present. We find Cyprian of Carthage, in the third century, explaining the fourth petition of the Lord’s Prayer this way: “we ask that this bread should be given to us daily, that we who are in Christ, and daily receive the Eucharist for the food of salvation, may not… be separated from Christ’s body.”51

We find Ambrose of Milan, preaching to the newly baptized, asking the question as sharply as anyone has ever asked it: “If it is daily bread, why dost thou take it once a year, as the Greeks in the East are accustomed to do? Take daily what is to profit thee daily.” He went on: “He who has a wound needs a medicine. The wound is that we are under sin; the medicine is the heavenly and venerable sacrament.”52 Ambrose’s words also asked the hearers to “so live that thou mayest deserve to receive it daily,” and a Lutheran will read that with the same care we gave Chrysostom. However, the Augsburg Confession quotes Ambrose’s medicine with approval when it explains why the Mass is “to be used to this end, that there the Sacrament may be administered to them that have need of consolation; as Ambrose says: Because I always sin, I am always bound to take the medicine.”53

Then we find our own Confessions describing communion “every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals.” The monthly and quarterly customs came later, as the earlier paper showed. It is enough to recall that Luther’s remark in the preface to the Small Catechism about seeking the Sacrament “at least some four times a year” was a warning against those who despise the Sacrament, not a verdict on those who came whenever their church set the Table, and it was not a pattern he was recommending.54 In other words, a congregation that moves toward weekly communion is returning to the older practice of its own tradition.

Custom and peace

Yet Augustine’s counsel has real wisdom in it and it brings us to the most important practical point in this paper. Custom deserves respect for the sake of peace and of the weak. Augustine grieved over the “many disquietudes caused to weak brethren by the contentious pertinacity” of those who quarreled over such things.55 Luther shared the concern. When he published his Formula Missae in 1523, he explained that he had moved slowly, “always being hesitant and fearful on account of those souls weak in the faith from whom the old and accustomed is not to be taken away suddenly.”56 Three years later, in the German Mass, he said that one “ought not lightly start anything except under the compulsion of a very great need.”57 Luther knew the Sacrament belonged at the heart of the Lord’s Day and still he would not force a change on people who had not been taught.

Therefore the right answer to “We have always done it this way” is not “Then we will stop,” but “Then let us learn together why the Church did it another way for so long, and let us change only when we have understood.” A tradition is honored when it is explained and then the older practice and the more recent one can be weighed side by side.


Conclusion: What This Means for Us

Let me gather up what we have heard.

  1. Christ instituted the Supper with the words “do this” and “as often as,” and set no number. Yet the New Testament joins the Lord’s Supper to the Lord’s Day and our Confessions describe a Sunday and festival celebration as the Lutheran practice.

  2. The fear that frequent communion will become routine is a reverent fear. Yet the Supper is special because of what it gives and not because of how seldom it is given. The cure for careless reception is teaching and confession, not distance from the Table.

  3. Frequency is free. The Supper itself is commanded. Freedom is the servant of love and a congregation must ask which use of its freedom best serves the faith of its people.

  4. Length and visitors are real concerns to be met with good sense, plain explanation and a warm welcome. They are not reasons to remove the one commanded thing from the Lord’s Day.

  5. Where there is no pastor to preside, the Service of the Word is God’s true service and those who hear it in faith are fed. Yet the shortage of pastors is a reason to pray for workers, not to make a virtue of scarcity.

  6. The Sacrament gives the same Gospel as the Word, given to each personally, with Christ’s true body and blood as a pledge, uniting the congregation in one body. We need both and Christ gave both.

  7. Our tradition is older than our grandparents. The monthly custom is real and deserves respect but the longer tradition of the Church is the Supper on the Lord’s Day.

What does this mean for us? It means, first, that no congregation should be shamed for where it is. The Formula forbids churches to condemn one another over such matters and Paul tells us to welcome “the one who is weak in faith… but not to quarrel over opinions” (Romans 14:1). Luther would not compel anyone to the Sacrament: “no one should by any means be coerced or compelled, lest we institute a new murdering of souls.”58 A congregation that has communed monthly for generations has not been without Christ. It has been fed by His Word and by His Supper whenever it was offered.

It means, second, that change should come by teaching and not by decree. Luther knew that “it is not enough to teach and instruct only, but there is need also of daily exhortation, so here also there is need of continuing to preach.”59 Paul tells Timothy to preach the word “with complete patience and teaching” (2 Timothy 4:2). A pastor who longs for weekly communion should spend more time teaching what the Sacrament is than arguing about how often it should be offered. When people understand what the Supper gives, they will want it. Luther said that true Christians “will urge and impel themselves unto it,” and in the Brief Exhortation he said that it is the people who should “urge” the pastor and not the other way around.60 The goal is a congregation that asks for the Supper, not one that merely puts up with it.

It means, third, that the invitation is always open. Our Lord tells of a man who prepared a great banquet and “sent his servant to say to those who had been invited, ‘Come, for everything is now ready’” (Luke 14:17). That is what every celebration of the Supper says. It is spoken to the weary and burdened (Matthew 11:28), to those who feel their sin and to those who are troubled that they feel too little. “If, therefore, you are heavy-laden and feel your weakness, then go joyfully to this Sacrament and obtain refreshment, consolation, and strength.”61 Christ does not offer His body and blood grudgingly and He is not diminished by giving them often. “He invites and allures you,” Luther says.62

In other words, the question “Why not every Sunday?” is finally a question about how much of Christ’s gift we want. He gave the Supper on the night He was betrayed and rose on the first day of the week and His Church has set His Table on that day ever since. We may come to it in freedom, with patience toward one another, and with the joy of those who are hungry and have been told that there is bread. And we come in hope, because this Supper looks toward another one: “Blessed are those who are invited to the marriage supper of the Lamb” (Revelation 19:9).

Soli Deo Gloria.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)

The Lutheran Confessions

  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text as published at bookofconcord.org.)
  • The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
  • The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Augsburg Confession V, VII, XIV, XV, XXIV and XXV; Apology IV, XIII and XXIV; Smalcald Articles III.iv; Treatise 67; Large Catechism, “The Sacrament of the Altar”; Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration X.)

The Early Church

  • The Didache. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7.
  • Justin Martyr. First Apology. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
  • Cyprian of Carthage. On the Lord’s Prayer (Treatise 4). In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5.
  • Ambrose. “On the Mysteries” and the Treatise “On the Sacraments.” Translated by T. Thompson. Edited by J. H. Srawley. London: SPCK, 1919.
  • John Chrysostom. Homilies on Ephesians. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 13.
  • Augustine. Letter 54, to Januarius. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 1.
  • Augustine. Sermons on Selected Lessons of the New Testament, Sermon 7. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 6.

The Reformation

  • Luther, Martin. Works of Martin Luther. Vol. 6, Luther’s Liturgical Writings. Translated by Paul Zeller Strodach. Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1932. (Concerning the Ordering of Divine Worship in the Congregation, 1523; Formula Missae, 1523; The German Mass and Order of Service, 1526.)
  • Luther, Martin. Liturgy and Hymns. Luther’s Works, vol. 53. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1965.
  • Luther, Martin. A Brief Exhortation to Confession (1529). Appended to the Large Catechism in Kolb-Wengert.
  • Chemnitz, Martin. Examination of the Council of Trent. Part II. Translated by Fred Kramer. St. Louis: Concordia, 1978.
  • Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Translated by Henry Beveridge. Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845.

Companion Papers

  • MacDonald, Dylan. On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper.
  • MacDonald, Dylan. The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry.
  • MacDonald, Dylan. One Body at Many Altars.

Reference

  • Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
  • Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. New York: S. Converse, 1828.

Footnotes

  1. AC XXIV 34. ↩ ↩2

  2. See the companion paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper (June 2026). The quotations are LC V 39 and Ap XXIV 1. ↩

  3. The two occurrences of κυριακός in the New Testament are 1 Corinthians 11:20 and Revelation 1:10. ↩

  4. Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. κυριακός. Thayer also notes the phrase κυριακὴ κυρίου (“the Lord’s day of the Lord”) in Didache 14:1. ↩

  5. Didache 14, ANF, vol. 7. ↩

  6. AC XXIV 1, 34. ↩

  7. Ap XXIV 1. ↩

  8. AC XXIV 6; AC XXV 1. See also Ap XXIV 1, quoted above. ↩

  9. AC XXIV 41, citing Cassiodorus, Tripartite History IX.33. ↩

  10. LC V 46–47. ↩

  11. Augustine, Letter 54 (to Januarius) 3.4, NPNF¹, vol. 1. Augustine presents the view of those who abstain and the view of those who commune daily, and then gives his own counsel: that each should remain “united in the peace of Christ” and be free to do what he conscientiously regards as his duty. ↩

  12. Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “routine.” ↩

  13. Augustine, Sermon 7 on the New Testament (Sermon 57 in the Benedictine numbering) §7, NPNF¹, vol. 6. ↩

  14. LC V 23–27. ↩

  15. LC V 21. ↩

  16. LC V 53–56. ↩

  17. John Chrysostom, Homilies on Ephesians, Homily 3, NPNF¹, vol. 13. In the same homily Chrysostom insists that those who stand through the liturgy as baptized believers ought to partake, and he rebukes the one who is “qualified to partake, and yet art indifferent about it.” ↩

  18. LC V 36; cf. LC V 33–35 and 61–62. ↩

  19. AC VII 3. ↩

  20. AC XV 1–2. ↩

  21. SD X 9. ↩ ↩2

  22. SD X 1. ↩

  23. Augustine, Letter 54 (to Januarius) 2.2, NPNF¹, vol. 1. ↩

  24. Martin Luther, Concerning the Ordering of Divine Worship in the Congregation (1523), in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6 (Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1932), 63; cf. LW 53 (Concerning the Order of Public Worship). ↩

  25. LC V 45. ↩

  26. LC V 49. ↩

  27. LC V 41. ↩ ↩2

  28. Luther, The German Mass and Order of Service (1526), Preface, in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6, 170; cf. LW 53. ↩

  29. Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, Part II, trans. Fred Kramer (St. Louis: Concordia, 1978), in his treatment of the Sacrament of the Eucharist. The companion paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper quotes these passages; they are paraphrased here. ↩

  30. John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, trans. Henry Beveridge (Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845), IV.17.44 and 46. In IV.17.43 Calvin says the Supper might be celebrated “in the most becoming manner, if it were dispensed to the Church very frequently, at least once a-week.” ↩

  31. SD X 31. ↩

  32. Justin Martyr, First Apology 67, ANF, vol. 1. ↩ ↩2

  33. Ap IV 310 (Triglotta III 189). ↩

  34. AC XXIV 3, 7. ↩

  35. LC V 2. ↩

  36. Luther, The German Mass and Order of Service (1526), Preface, in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6, 173; cf. LW 53. ↩

  37. AC XIV. ↩

  38. AC V 1; Ap XIII 11–12. ↩

  39. Tr 67. The provision the Treatise states is lay absolution. It illustrates it with Augustine’s story of two Christians in a ship, one of whom baptized a catechumen, who then absolved his baptizer. Emergency Baptism by a layman is the Church’s long practice rather than the subject of a confessional article. ↩

  40. SA III.iv. ↩

  41. Luther, Concerning the Ordering of Divine Worship in the Congregation (1523), in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6, 63; cf. LW 53. ↩

  42. Luther, Formula of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (Formula Missae, 1523), “Concerning the Communion of the People,” in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6, 93; cf. LW 53. ↩

  43. Luther, A Brief Exhortation to Confession (1529), ¶ 31 in the Kolb-Wengert numbering. The quotation follows the older (Henkel) English translation printed at bookofconcord.org. ↩

  44. Ap XIII 5. ↩

  45. LC V 31–32. ↩

  46. LC V 65. ↩

  47. LC V 8. ↩

  48. LC V 22. ↩

  49. Augustine, Sermon 7 on the New Testament §7, NPNF¹, vol. 6. ↩

  50. Augustine, Letter 54 (to Januarius) 2.2–3, NPNF¹, vol. 1. ↩

  51. Cyprian, Treatise 4, On the Lord’s Prayer 18, ANF, vol. 5. ↩

  52. Ambrose, On the Sacraments V.4.25, in St. Ambrose: “On the Mysteries” and the Treatise “On the Sacraments,” trans. T. Thompson, ed. J. H. Srawley (London: SPCK, 1919), 126. Thompson’s edition treats the author of On the Sacraments as unknown; most scholars now accept it as Ambrose’s own catechetical lectures, taken down as he delivered them. ↩

  53. AC XXIV 33. ↩

  54. Luther, Preface to the Small Catechism. See the companion paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper, section VI. ↩

  55. Augustine, Letter 54 (to Januarius) 2.3, NPNF¹, vol. 1. ↩

  56. Luther, Formula Missae (1523), in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6, 84; cf. LW 53. ↩

  57. Luther, The German Mass and Order of Service (1526), Preface, in Works of Martin Luther, vol. 6, 173; cf. LW 53. ↩

  58. LC V 42. ↩

  59. LC V 44. ↩

  60. LC V 43; A Brief Exhortation to Confession, ¶ 30–31. ↩

  61. LC V 72. ↩

  62. LC V 52. ↩

Topics
The Lord's SupperChristian Freedom
Scripture
Acts 20:71 Corinthians 11:26Acts 2:421 Corinthians 11:20Revelation 1:101 Corinthians 11:331 Corinthians 11:28Galatians 5:131 Corinthians 14:24–25Romans 10:15Romans 10:17Matthew 9:37–381 Corinthians 10:16–17Mark 16:15Luke 22:19Jeremiah 6:16Romans 14:12 Timothy 4:2Luke 14:17Matthew 11:28Revelation 19:9
Confessions
AC XIVAC XXIVLC VAp XXIVAC XXVAC VIIAC XVSD XAp IVAC VAp XIIISA IIISCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Why Not Every Sunday?: The Lord's Supper and the Lord's Day in Lutheran Practice.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/why-not-every-sunday/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.