The Royal Priesthood and the Lord's Table
Why Not Every Member Presides at Holy Communion
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“This is how one should regard us, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God. Moreover, it is required of stewards that they be found faithful.” — 1 Corinthians 4:1–2 (ESV)
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. The Council of Trent is quoted in the Waterworth translation, and Luther’s Address to the Christian Nobility in that of Wace and Buchheim.
The Question Before Us
If all baptized Christians belong to the priesthood of believers, why can’t any member preside at Holy Communion? This is a fair question and it is usually asked by people who love the Sacrament. St. Peter tells ordinary believers that they are “a royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9). Luther taught that every Christian who comes out of the water of Baptism has been consecrated a priest. Lutherans also confess that the Supper does not depend on the holiness or the rank of the man who gives it, but on the Word of Christ. If the words make the Sacrament, and if every Christian is a priest, then why may a faithful elder or a council president not stand at the altar, speak the Words of Institution, and give the body and blood of Christ to the congregation? Some ask it for a practical reason as well. A small congregation without a pastor may go weeks or months without the Supper. Would it not be better for one of its own members to preside than for the people to go without?
The companion paper in this series, The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry, has already laid the groundwork for an answer. It shows from Scripture and the Confessions that the Church is the assembly of believers gathered by the Gospel and the sacraments (AC VII), that every baptized Christian is a priest of God with full access to the Father through Christ, that Christ Himself instituted the office of the ministry so that we may obtain faith (AC V), and that no one should publicly teach or administer the sacraments without a regular call (AC XIV). It also traces the debate among Lutherans (Höfling, Löhe, and Walther) and the answers of Rome, Canterbury, the Orthodox, and the free churches to the question of ministry in general. I agree with that paper and I will not repeat it here. I also return to what I wrote years ago on the priesthood of all believers: Luther came to this doctrine slowly, through Scripture and the fathers, and at its heart it is the doctrine of justification, that only Christ stands between the believer and the Father and that no earthly mediator is needed to obtain His forgiveness.1
This paper takes up a narrower question. What is it about the Lord’s Supper in particular that places its administration in the hands of the called and ordained pastor? I want to take up five questions in order: 1) What is the royal priesthood, and what does it actually do? 2) Why does the administration of the Supper belong to the public office? 3) What is that order for, and does the pastor have a power over the Sacrament that other Christians lack? 4) What happens in an emergency, and why is the Supper different from Baptism? 5) How have other Christians, and some Lutherans in our own day, answered the question, and what is the right remedy when a congregation has no pastor? We will close by asking what this means for us when we gather at the Lord’s Table.
I. The Royal Priesthood and What It Does
The words themselves
We begin with the word. When Peter calls the Church a “holy priesthood” (1 Peter 2:5) and a “royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9), the Greek word is hierateuma (ἱεράτευμα). Thayer defines it as “the office of priest” and “the order or body of priests,” and he adds that Christians are called this “because they have access to God and offer not external but ‘spiritual’ sacrifices.”2 Peter is quoting God’s word to Israel at Sinai, “you shall be to me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation” (Exodus 19:6). St. John takes up the same words in praise of Christ, who “made us a kingdom, priests to his God and Father” (Revelation 1:6).
The priesthood in these texts belongs to the whole people together. Peter does not say that each Christian is a priesthood unto himself; he says that the people, “like living stones,” are “being built up as a spiritual house, to be a holy priesthood” (1 Peter 2:5). Scripture also tells us what this priesthood does. Peter gives its purpose in the same verse: “to offer spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.” In verse 9 he adds, “that you may proclaim the excellencies of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light.”
The sacrifices of the priesthood
What are these spiritual sacrifices? Scripture names them. “I appeal to you therefore, brothers, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your spiritual worship” (Romans 12:1). “Through him then let us continually offer up a sacrifice of praise to God, that is, the fruit of lips that acknowledge his name. Do not neglect to do good and to share what you have, for such sacrifices are pleasing to God” (Hebrews 13:15–16). The priesthood of believers offers its bodies in daily obedience, its lips in praise and confession, and its hands in good works and generosity toward the neighbor.
The Apology of the Augsburg Confession makes the same point when it answers Rome on the sacrifice of the Mass. It distinguishes two kinds of sacrifice. The one is “the propitiatory sacrifice, i.e., a work which makes satisfaction for guilt and punishment.” The other is “the eucharistic sacrifice, which does not merit the remission of sins or reconciliation, but is rendered by those who have been reconciled, in order that we may give thanks.”3 There has been only one propitiatory sacrifice, the death of Christ, who “did this once for all when he offered up himself” (Hebrews 7:27). All the rest, the Apology says, are sacrifices of praise, “namely, the preaching of the Gospel, faith, prayer, thanksgiving, confession, the afflictions of saints, yea, all good works of saints.” And it continues, “such are the sacrifices of the New Testament, as Peter teaches, 1 Pet. 2:5: An holy priesthood, to offer up spiritual sacrifices.”4
In other words, the royal priesthood is not a sacrificing priesthood in the Old Testament sense, because there is nothing left to atone for. “For by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14). The Christian priest stands before God through Christ alone, prays for all people, praises God, confesses His name, and serves his neighbor in the place where God has put him. A father who leads his household in prayer, a mother who teaches her children the Creed, a Christian who confesses his sins to a brother and hears forgiveness (James 5:16), and members “teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs” (Colossians 3:16) are all exercising the priesthood of believers, and this is the daily life of the Church in the world.
What Luther said, and what he added
Luther recovered this teaching in 1520 and he did not hold back. In his Address to the Christian Nobility he wrote that whatever “issues from baptism may boast that it has been consecrated priest, bishop, and pope.” He even imagined a little company of pious laymen taken captive and carried away into a desert, without a priest consecrated by a bishop. If they “were there to agree to elect one of them… and were to order him to baptise, to celebrate the mass, to absolve, and to preach, this man would as truly be a priest, as if all the bishops and all the Popes had consecrated him.”5 In 1523, writing to the Christians of Bohemia in Concerning the Ministry, he listed the functions that belong to the priesthood of all believers: “to teach, to preach and proclaim the Word of God; to baptize; to consecrate or administer the Eucharist; to bind and loose sins; to pray for others; to sacrifice; and to judge all doctrine and spirits.”6
We should be honest with Luther. He did count the Supper among the things that belong to the whole priesthood. The Sacrament is the Church’s treasure and not the private property of the clergy. However, we should also read Luther to the end of his argument. In the very passage where he says that the baptized may boast of being priest, bishop, and pope, he adds, “although it does not beseem every one to exercise these offices.” And he gives the reason: “For, if a thing is common to all, no man may take it to himself without the wish and command of the community.”7 Even the captives in the desert did not each take up the Supper for himself. They agreed together, elected one of their number, and ordered him to do it. In Concerning the Ministry Luther makes the same distinction. What belongs to all by right may not be exercised publicly by any one person without the consent and call of the community, although in a case of real necessity a Christian may serve his neighbor with what belongs to all.8
In other words, the priesthood of all believers answers the question to whom the Sacrament belongs. It belongs to the whole Church. The office of the ministry answers a different question: who administers it publicly in the name of all? The two answers do not compete. The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope says that the Church “certainly has the right to elect and ordain ministers since it alone has the priesthood.”9 The priesthood does not do away with the call; the priesthood is the one that issues it.
II. The Congregation’s Meal
A meal for the gathered Church
Why does the Supper in particular belong to the public office? The first answer is found in the nature of the Supper itself. Our Lord did not give it as a private devotion. He gave it to the Twelve gathered around one table, and the apostolic Church celebrated it when the congregation came together. “And they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:42). “On the first day of the week, when we were gathered together to break bread” (Acts 20:7). When St. Paul writes to the Corinthians about the Supper, the phrase he keeps repeating is “when you come together” (1 Corinthians 11:17, 18, 20, 33, 34). He tells them, “So then, my brothers, when you come together to eat, wait for one another” (1 Corinthians 11:33).
The Supper also makes visible the unity of those who receive it. “The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:16–17). The Supper is the meal of the whole body of Christ in a place. The Formula of Concord describes the action Christ commanded in exactly these terms: “that in an assembly of Christians bread and wine are taken, consecrated, distributed, received, eaten, drunk, and the Lord’s death is shown forth at the same time.”10
Luther drew the practical conclusion in a letter of 1536 to Wolfgang Brauer, pastor at Jessen. A layman had asked whether he might commune himself and his household at home. Luther answered that the head of a household should teach his family the Word of God, but he should not take up the Supper on his own. His reason was that the Sacrament is a public confession and should be given by public, called ministers. He added that a public office in the church and a head of household with his family are two very different things.11 In other words, the Supper is the congregation’s meal. Whoever presides at it does not act for himself or for his own household. He acts publicly, in the name of the whole assembly and in the name of Christ who gives it.
The public office and the Supper
This is where the Augsburg Confession places it. Article XIV says, “Of Ecclesiastical Order they teach that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called.”12 The word that matters is publicly. Article XXVIII describes the power of the keys, or the power of bishops, as “a power or commandment of God, to preach the Gospel, to remit and retain sins, and to administer Sacraments,” and it says that “this power is exercised only by teaching or preaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments, according to their calling either to many or to individuals.”13 The Apology says that our pastors “are called to teach the Gospel and administer the Sacraments to the people.”14 The Supper is named every time the Confessions describe what the public office does. To administer the Sacrament to the congregation is to exercise that office.
Why should this be so? Paul gives the answer in the verse that stands at the head of this paper. “This is how one should regard us, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God. Moreover, it is required of stewards that they be found faithful” (1 Corinthians 4:1–2). The word translated “stewards” is oikonomos (οἰκονόμος). Thayer defines it as “the manager of a household,” a steward to whom the master “has intrusted the management of his affairs… and the duty of dealing out the proper portion to every servant and even to the children not yet of age.”15 Our Lord used the same word when He asked, “Who then is the faithful and wise manager, whom his master will set over his household, to give them their portion of food at the proper time?” (Luke 12:42). The food belongs to the master and it is meant for the whole household. Yet the master appoints a steward to give it out, so that every member of the household receives it rightly and at the proper time. That is what the pastor is at the Lord’s Table. He does not own the mysteries and he is not above the household; he is put in charge of giving out what belongs to Christ and to all.
Order at Corinth
The congregation at Corinth shows us what happens when the Supper is left without order. Paul writes, “When you come together, it is not the Lord’s supper that you eat. For in eating, each one goes ahead with his own meal. One goes hungry, another gets drunk” (1 Corinthians 11:20–21). The Corinthians had the bread and wine and they had the words. What they lacked was order, and so they came together “not for the better but for the worse” (1 Corinthians 11:17). Paul’s remedy was to hand on again what he had received from the Lord (1 Corinthians 11:23–26), to call them to examine themselves and discern the body (1 Corinthians 11:28–29), and to promise, “About the other things I will give directions when I come” (1 Corinthians 11:34). Three chapters later he states the rule for the whole of their worship: “For God is not a God of confusion but of peace” and “all things should be done decently and in order” (1 Corinthians 14:33, 40).
The early Church called the man who led the Supper the “president.” Justin Martyr, describing a baptism to the Roman emperor about the year 150, says that after the prayers “there is then brought to the president of the brethren bread and a cup of wine mixed with water; and he taking them, gives praise and glory to the Father of the universe.” When he has given thanks, “all the people present express their assent by saying Amen,” and the deacons give the bread and wine to each of those present and carry a portion to the absent.16 Justin’s word is proestōs (προεστώς), from proistēmi (προΐστημι), which Thayer defines as “to be over, to superintend, preside over.”17 It is the same verb Paul uses of “those who labor among you and are over you in the Lord” (1 Thessalonians 5:12) and of “the elders who rule well” (1 Timothy 5:17). Webster defines preside as “to be set over for the exercise of authority,” and he gives the example of a man who “presides over the senate.”18 In Justin’s account one man presides and the whole assembly answers “Amen.” The prayer of thanksgiving is spoken by one voice and it belongs to all. Paul assumes the same thing when he asks how an outsider can “say ‘Amen’ to your thanksgiving” if he does not understand it (1 Corinthians 14:16).
III. What the Order Is For
The Word makes the Sacrament
If only a called pastor administers the Supper, does that mean the pastor has a power over the Sacrament that other Christians lack? Rome answers yes. The Council of Trent taught that “to the apostles, and their successors in the priesthood, was the power delivered of consecrating, offering, and administering His Body and Blood.”19 It condemned anyone who says “that by those words, Do this for the commemoration of me (Luke xxii. 19), Christ did not institute the apostles priests; or, did not ordain that they, and other priests should offer His own body and blood.”20 It also condemned anyone who says that there is not “any power of consecrating and offering the true body and blood of the Lord… but only an office and bare ministry of preaching the Gospel.”21 We should state Rome’s teaching fairly. Trent wanted to guard the reverence due to the Sacrament and to tie the Eucharist to an office Christ instituted, and in that concern Lutherans and Roman Catholics are closer than is often supposed. Our disagreement lies in the reason. For Trent the priest has received in ordination a power to consecrate and to offer a sacrifice, and without that power there is no Eucharist.
The Lutheran Confessions answer differently. What makes the Sacrament is not a power in the minister but the Word of Christ. Luther writes in the Large Catechism, “It is the Word (I say) which makes and distinguishes this Sacrament, so that it is not mere bread and wine, but is, and is called, the body and blood of Christ.” He quotes Augustine: Accedat verbum ad elementum, et fit sacramentum, “If the Word be joined to the element, it becomes a Sacrament,” and he says that Augustine “has scarcely said anything better.”22 Augustine’s own words, in his tractates on John, are these: “The word is added to the element, and there results the Sacrament, as if itself also a kind of visible word.”23 The Large Catechism goes on: “Even though a knave takes or distributes the Sacrament, he receives the true Sacrament… For it is not founded upon the holiness of men, but upon the Word of God. And as no saint upon earth, yea, no angel in heaven, can make bread and wine to be the body and blood of Christ, so also can no one change or alter it, even though it be misused.”24
The Formula of Concord says it with great care. “Not the word or work of any man produces the true presence of the body and blood of Christ in the Supper, whether it be the merit or recitation of the minister, or the eating and drinking or faith of the communicants; but all this should be ascribed alone to the power of Almighty God and the word, institution, and ordination of our Lord Jesus Christ.”25 The words Christ spoke at the first Supper “endure, are valid, operate, and are still efficacious.”26 Then the Formula quotes John Chrysostom: “Christ Himself prepared this table and blesses it; for no man makes the bread and wine set before us the body and blood of Christ, but Christ Himself who was crucified for us. The words are spoken by the mouth of the priest, but by God’s power and grace, by the word, where He speaks: ‘This is My body,’ the elements presented are consecrated in the Supper.”27 It also quotes Luther: “it is not our work or speaking, but the command and ordination of Christ that makes the bread the body, and the wine the blood… and that through our service and office they are daily distributed.”28
Lutherans therefore reject what is called sacerdotalism, the teaching that the ordained priest possesses in himself a sacred power to make the Sacrament that others do not have. The pastor does not “confect” the body and blood of Christ by a power given to him at ordination. Christ is the host and Christ is the one who speaks. The pastor’s mouth speaks the words, and Luther’s phrase is exact: the Sacrament comes “through our service and office.”29
Then why the called pastor?
Someone will answer that this settles the matter the other way. If the Word makes the Sacrament and not the man, then why should it matter who speaks the Word? This is the strongest form of the question and it deserves a careful answer. The answer is that the Confessions never grounded AC XIV in a power to consecrate. They grounded it in two other things: the certainty of the people who receive the Sacrament and the unity and order of the Church.
The first is certainty. The Formula of Concord teaches that “nothing has the nature of a sacrament apart from the use instituted by Christ,” and that “if the institution of Christ be not observed as He appointed it, there is no sacrament.”30 It requires that the Words of Institution be “publicly spoken or sung before the congregation distinctly and clearly,” so that “obedience may be rendered to the command of Christ” and so that “the faith of the hearers… may be excited, strengthened, and confirmed by Christ’s Word.”31 The communicant kneeling at the rail needs to know that what he receives is the Supper Christ instituted, administered as Christ commanded, with His words and His elements, and given to him with the promise “given and shed for you.” He should not have to wonder who appointed the man at the altar, what he believes about the Sacrament, or whether he will do tomorrow what he did today. When the Church calls a man, it first examines him in doctrine and life (1 Timothy 3:1–7; Titus 1:5–9), it charges him publicly to administer the Sacrament according to the Gospel, and it holds him accountable to that charge. The Apology says that ministers “represent the person of Christ” on account of the call of the Church.32 In other words, the call is for the sake of the communicant. It lets a troubled conscience rest on Christ’s institution rather than on the private judgment or good intentions of whoever happened to step forward.
The second is unity and order. The Supper is the meal of “one body” (1 Corinthians 10:17), and the early Church saw at once that a Supper without order would soon divide the body it was meant to unite. Clement of Rome, writing to the quarrelling church at Corinth near the end of the first century, drew on the order of the Old Testament worship. God has commanded that His service be performed “not thoughtlessly or irregularly, but at the appointed times and hours. Where and by whom He desires these things to be done, He Himself has fixed by His own supreme will.”33 And he urged them, “Let every one of you, brethren, give thanks to God in his own order, living in all good conscience, with becoming gravity, and not going beyond the rule of the ministry prescribed to him.”34 Clement’s appeal to the Levitical order is an argument by analogy and the Apology warns us that we do not have “another priesthood like the Levitical.”35 However, his main point stands: the God who gives the gift also cares how and by whom it is given out.
Ignatius of Antioch, a few years later, is often quoted on this point, and the companion paper discusses his teaching on the bishop. “Let that be deemed a proper Eucharist, which is [administered] either by the bishop, or by one to whom he has entrusted it.” It is interesting to read the purpose he gives at the end of the same chapter: “so that everything that is done may be secure and valid.”36 Ignatius was writing against false teachers who held their own gatherings apart from the church, and his concern was the same certainty and unity we have been describing. Tertullian, writing in North Africa around the year 200, lists among the customs handed down in the churches that “we take also, in congregations before daybreak, and from the hand of none but the presidents, the sacrament of the Eucharist.”37 He gives this as received custom rather than as a command of Scripture, yet it shows what the churches of his day actually did.
The Council of Nicaea in 325 shows how seriously the early Church took the order of the Supper. It rebuked deacons who had begun to give the Eucharist to the presbyters, “whereas neither canon nor custom permits that they who have no right to offer should give the Body of Christ to them that do offer,” and it told the deacons to “remain within their own bounds.”38 Jerome, near the end of the fourth century, complained of a deacon who set himself above the presbyters, “men through whose prayers the body and blood of Christ are produced.”39 In his Dialogue against the Luciferians he says of a schismatic deacon that he “can neither duly celebrate the Eucharist, for he has no bishops or priests.”40 We would not use every phrase of Nicaea or Jerome. Their language of offering points toward the sacrifice of the Mass that the Apology rejects, and Jerome’s “produced” must be read in the light of Chrysostom’s confession that Christ Himself consecrates through His words. Yet on the question before us they bear a single witness: the Church of the first four centuries did not leave the administration of the Supper to anyone who chose to take it up.
Cyprian of Carthage, in the middle of the third century, wrote a whole letter against bishops who had departed from Christ’s institution by offering water alone in the cup. His rule was that “that priest truly discharges the office of Christ, who imitates that which Christ did.”41 Cyprian’s sacrificial language again goes beyond what we can confess. However, his concern is close to the concern of the Formula of Concord: the one who administers the Supper must do what Christ did and give what Christ gave, and the Church must be able to see that he does.
IV. Emergencies
What necessity permits
What happens when there is no pastor? The Lutheran Confessions do not pretend that the ordinary order can always be kept. The Treatise says that “in a case of necessity even a layman absolves, and becomes the minister and pastor of another; as Augustine narrates the story of two Christians in a ship, one of whom baptized the catechumen, who after Baptism then absolved the baptizer.”42 Luther said the same in 1520: “That is why in cases of necessity every man can baptise and absolve, which would not be possible if we were not all priests.”43
The early Church agreed. Tertullian wrote that, beside the bishop, presbyters, and deacons, “even laymen have the right” to baptize, “for what is equally received can be equally given.” Yet he added at once that laymen should not “assume to themselves the specific function of the bishop,” because “emulation of the episcopal office is the mother of schisms,” and that they should use this right “in cases of necessity.”44 Jerome wrote, “if necessity so be, we know that even laymen may, and frequently do, baptize.”45
What do the Treatise, Luther, Tertullian, and Jerome name as the acts of necessity? They name Baptism and absolution, and none of them names the Supper.
Why the Supper is different
Baptism may be needed in an emergency because Baptism is the beginning of the Christian life. Our Lord says, “Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved” (Mark 16:16), and the Augsburg Confession teaches that Baptism “is necessary to salvation.”46 When a newborn child is dying and no pastor can be reached, a Christian parent or nurse may baptize because the child stands at the door of life and the Church will not leave it closed. Absolution may be needed in an emergency because a dying sinner may be terrified of his sins, and any Christian can speak to him the Gospel of Christ’s forgiveness.
The Supper is different. It is given to those who have already been baptized and who already believe, to strengthen them in faith and to unite them with Christ and one another. Its gift is the forgiveness of sins, and that same forgiveness is given in the Gospel and in absolution. The Smalcald Articles say that the Gospel gives us counsel and aid against sin “not merely in one way,” because God “is superabundantly rich [and liberal] in His grace,” and they name the spoken Word, Baptism, the Sacrament of the Altar, and the keys.47 In the Supper Christ gives His own body and blood with His word, so that the forgiveness “may be my own and may benefit me, as a sure pledge and token.”48 The Formula of Concord distinguishes two kinds of eating. There is the sacramental eating with the mouth in the Supper and there is the spiritual eating, which “is nothing else than faith, namely, to hear God’s Word… to receive it with faith and appropriate it to ourselves.” This spiritual eating “occurs in no other way than with the Spirit and faith, in the preaching and meditation of the Gospel, as well as in the Lord’s Supper,” and it is “necessary at all times for salvation to all Christians.”49 Augustine, preaching on John 6, put it in a sentence: “To what purpose do you make ready teeth and stomach? Believe, and you have eaten already.”50
Luther drew this conclusion for the Bohemians in 1523. They had no bishops who would ordain evangelical pastors, and Luther told them it would be better to go without the Sacrament than to receive it at the cost of their consciences. “For it would be safer and more wholesome for the father of the household to read the gospel and… to baptize those who are born in his home.” And he gave the reason: “For the Eucharist is not so necessary that salvation depends on it. The gospel and baptism are sufficient, since faith alone justifies and love alone lives rightly.”51 Luther did not say this because he thought little of the Supper, and he was not commending a long absence from it. He would neither make the Supper a law that forces a conscience nor have it taken up without a call. He was the same man who urged Christians to “receive this venerable Sacrament often” and who warned against those who “pretend that it is a matter of liberty and not necessary, and that it is sufficient to believe without it.” Such people, he said, end by despising both the Sacrament and the Word of God, and those who withdraw from the Sacrament so long a time “are not to be considered Christians.”52 In other words, there is a great difference between going without the Supper because it cannot be had and staying away from it because it is not wanted. The first is a want that Christ supplies in His Word until the Sacrament can be given, and the second is contempt of His gift.
Baptism admits of an emergency because a soul may stand at the door with no other way in. The Confessions provide for lay Baptism and absolution in necessity and not for lay celebration of the Supper, and the reason is not that the Supper gives less. Christ has simply not bound it to necessity as He has bound Baptism, and the one who is without it still has Christ in the Word and in absolution. A Christian at the bedside of a dying friend may read the Gospel, pray, confess the faith with him, and speak Christ’s forgiveness. He should not try to preside at the Supper. He should send for the pastor, whose calling includes bringing the Sacrament to the sick and the dying. If the pastor cannot come in time, the dying man is not cut off from Christ, for he has Christ and His forgiveness in the Word and the absolution.
Tertullian’s exception
There is one early text that seems to say otherwise and we should treat it fairly. In his Exhortation to Chastity Tertullian asks, “Are not even we laics priests?” and he writes, “where there is no joint session of the ecclesiastical Order, you offer, and baptize, and are priest, alone for yourself. But where three are, a church is, albeit they be laics.”53 Some have taken this to mean that laymen in the early Church presided at the Eucharist when no clergy were present.
However, Tertullian wrote it after he had joined the Montanist movement, which set the private gifts of the Spirit against the order of the Church, and the passage belongs to that period of his life. His argument is also not about the Supper. He is arguing that laymen are bound by the same rule against a second marriage as the clergy, because in necessity they too may act as priests. In addition, the same Tertullian, both before and during his Montanist years, testifies to the ordinary practice of receiving the Eucharist “from the hand of none but the presidents” and warns that the emulation of the bishop’s office “is the mother of schisms.”54 At most the passage shows that one rigorous and divided teacher could imagine lay celebration in an extreme case. It does not show that the Church practiced it, and the Confessions do not appeal to it.
V. Lay Presiding Today and the Remedy of the Call
Other Christians
Christians outside the Lutheran Church have answered this question in different ways and we should describe them accurately. Rome, as we have heard, binds the Eucharist to a sacrificing priesthood with the power to consecrate. The Eastern Orthodox likewise reserve the Eucharist to the bishop and the presbyters he ordains. The Church of England kept the rule that only a priest ordained by a bishop may celebrate the Holy Communion, and Article XXIII of the Thirty-Nine Articles requires that no one minister the sacraments “in the Congregation, before he be lawfully called, and sent to execute the same,” which a Lutheran can read beside AC XIV with gladness.55 Within the Anglican Communion there has been debate on this point. In 2008 the synod of the Diocese of Sydney in Australia affirmed its conviction that lay and diaconal administration of the Lord’s Supper is consistent with Scripture. The Appellate Tribunal of the Anglican Church of Australia advised in 2010 that a diocese could not authorize this on its own, and the wider Anglican Communion has not accepted lay administration.56
At the other end are the free churches. Among the Plymouth Brethren the Lord’s Supper is observed every Lord’s Day at the “breaking of bread,” where there is no ordained minister and any of the brothers present may give thanks for the bread and the cup. Many Baptist and independent congregations allow a deacon or another member to lead the Supper. We should honor what these Christians are trying to protect. They have seen clericalism and they do not want the Lord’s Table to become the possession of a caste. They want every believer to know that he may draw near to God through Christ alone (Hebrews 10:19–22). Lutherans share that concern. However, the way to guard against clericalism is not to remove the called ministry but to keep it a ministry. The pastor is a steward and a servant (1 Corinthians 4:1), not a lord over the faith of the people (2 Corinthians 1:24).
Lutherans in our day
Lutherans have also faced this question in practice, especially in places where congregations are small, rural, or far from a pastor. In 1989 the convention of the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, meeting in Wichita, adopted Resolution 3-05B, which recognized a need for men to preach and administer the sacraments where no pastor was available and provided for licensed lay deacons to serve in Word and Sacrament ministry in exceptional circumstances or emergencies, under the oversight of the district president.57 Over the following years it became clear that some of these men had been serving congregations as their regular preachers and celebrants for many years. We cannot reconcile with AC XIV a standing arrangement in which a layman presides regularly without a call, and the Missouri Synod itself recognized the problem. In 2016 it adopted Resolution 13-02A, “To Regularize Status of Licensed Lay Deacons Involved in Word and Sacrament Ministry.” It directed those deacons who were preaching and administering the sacraments to apply, by July 1, 2018, to a seminary program, the Specific Ministry Pastor program, or a colloquy, so that they might be examined, called, and ordained, while providing that no congregation be left without a man to serve it in the meantime.58
The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America addressed the same question in its 1997 statement The Use of the Means of Grace. Principle 40 states that “an ordained minister presides in the service of Holy Communion” and gives as its reason “witness that this sacrament is a celebration of the Church, serving its unity.” It then provides that “where it is not possible for an extended period of time to provide ordained pastoral leadership, a synodical bishop may authorize a properly trained lay person to preside for a specified period of time and in a given location only.” The background note to that principle adds that the one who presides “makes clear that the rite is not the assembly’s own creation or possession.”59 In practice such persons are often called synodically authorized ministers.
We should speak charitably about these arrangements. They were made by church leaders who loved the Sacrament and did not want their people to go without it. They tried to keep the practice exceptional, supervised, and limited to a place and a time. In each case the body that made the provision also bore witness to the rule: the Missouri Synod by moving its lay deacons toward ordination, and the ELCA by writing that the ordained minister presides in witness to the unity of the Church.
The remedy is the call
Yet, the Confessions point us to a better remedy. If a congregation has a man who is fit to preach and to administer the Sacrament, and if the church needs him to do that work regularly, then the church should call and ordain him. AC XIV does not say that only seminary graduates may administer the sacraments. It says that no one should do so publicly “unless he be regularly called,” nisi rite vocatus. The Apology says that “the Church has the command to appoint ministers, which should be most pleasing to us, because we know that God approves this ministry, and is present in the ministry.”60 The Treatise teaches that “wherever there is a true church, the right to elect and ordain ministers necessarily exists,” and that when the ordinary channels fail, “the churches retain their own right.”61
This is exactly the counsel Luther gave the Bohemians in 1523. He did not tell them to let any member preside as the need arose. He told them to gather in prayer, to elect fit men from among themselves, to have their leading men lay hands on them, and to receive them as their bishops and pastors.62 Paul did the same when he left Titus in Crete “so that you might put what remained into order, and appoint elders in every town” (Titus 1:5).
To put it plainly, the question is not whether a faithful layman is worthy. Many are more godly than their pastors. Nor is it whether the Word would be effective in his mouth. The Word of Christ is effective in any mouth. The question is whether a man should take up publicly, in the name of the whole Church, an office that he has not been given. “And no one takes this honor for himself, but only when called by God, just as Aaron was” (Hebrews 5:4). If the man is fit and the need is real, then let the Church examine him, call him, and ordain him, and let him serve with the full comfort of a call. If he is not fit, or the need is only for a season, then let the congregation gather around the Word, pray, sing, confess the faith, and receive Christ’s forgiveness in the Word and the absolution. They lack nothing necessary for salvation (SD VII 61–62), though they do lack a gift Christ wants them to receive often. That is why the waiting must never become a habit. In the meantime a neighboring or supply pastor should be asked to bring them the Sacrament, and the congregation and the wider church should hurry to call a pastor as soon as it can. My earlier paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper tells how the scarcity of pastors on the American frontier hardened into a custom of infrequent communion.
Conclusion: What This Means for Us
Let me gather up what we have heard.
-
The royal priesthood belongs to every baptized Christian. It offers spiritual sacrifices of praise, prayer, confession, and good works, and it declares the praises of God in every vocation (1 Peter 2:5, 9; Romans 12:1; Hebrews 13:15–16; Ap XXIV 25–26).
-
The Supper belongs to the whole Church, yet it is the congregation’s meal, given “in an assembly of Christians” (SD VII 84). Whoever administers it does so publicly in the name of all, and that is the work of the called and ordained office (AC XIV; AC XXVIII 5–8).
-
The pastor has no power to make the Sacrament that other Christians lack. The Word of Christ makes the Sacrament (LC V 10; SD VII 74–78). The call exists for the certainty of the communicant and for the unity and order of the Church (1 Corinthians 14:33, 40).
-
In an emergency any Christian may baptize and speak Christ’s absolution. The Confessions provide for lay Baptism and absolution in necessity and not for lay celebration of the Supper. The pastor should be sent for, so that the sick and the dying may receive the Sacrament, and the Christian who cannot receive it in time still has Christ in the Word and in absolution.
-
Where the Church needs a man to do the work of the office, the remedy is to call and ordain him (AC XIV; Ap XIII 12; Tr 67).
What does this mean for us? It means, first, that the pastor at the altar is not a step above the people. Our Lord asked His disciples, “For who is the greater, one who reclines at table or one who serves? Is it not the one who reclines at table? But I am among you as the one who serves” (Luke 22:27). Paul wrote, “what we proclaim is not ourselves, but Jesus Christ as Lord, with ourselves as your servants for Jesus’ sake” (2 Corinthians 4:5). When the pastor stands at the altar he is doing what a steward does. He gives out what belongs to the Master and what is meant for the whole household. He receives the same body and blood, for the same forgiveness, as the youngest communicant at the rail.
It means, second, that the whole priesthood is gathered around the table. The Supper is not something the pastor does while the people watch. The congregation brings its prayers, its offerings, and its praise. It confesses the faith and sings the hymns. It answers the Great Thanksgiving with its “Amen,” as Christians did in Justin’s day. Every person at the rail is a priest of God, receiving Christ’s gifts and then going out to offer his body as a living sacrifice in his home and his work and his neighborhood (Romans 12:1).
It means, third, that we may come to the Sacrament with confidence. We do not have to ask whether the man at the altar is holy enough, because the Sacrament does not depend on his holiness. We do not have to ask whether he has some hidden power, because the power is in the Word of Christ. And we do not have to ask whether he was sent, because the Church has called him to give us this Sacrament as Christ instituted it. Christ is the host. He prepares the table, He blesses it, and He says to each of us, “This is my body, which is for you” (1 Corinthians 11:24). In other words, when we kneel at the rail we may believe that the gift is truly given, truly ours, and given exactly as our Lord commanded, until He comes (1 Corinthians 11:26).
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- Concordia Triglotta. Edited by F. Bente and W. H. T. Dau. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text as published at bookofconcord.org.)
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Augsburg Confession IX, XIV, XXVIII; Apology VII–VIII, XIII, XXIV; Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope 66–72; Large Catechism V; Solid Declaration VII.)
The Early Church
- Clement of Rome. First Epistle to the Corinthians. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Ignatius of Antioch. Epistle to the Smyrnaeans. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Justin Martyr. First Apology. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Tertullian. The Chaplet, On Baptism. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
- Tertullian. On Exhortation to Chastity. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4.
- Cyprian of Carthage. Epistles. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5.
- First Council of Nicaea. Canons. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 14.
- Jerome. Letters; Dialogue against the Luciferians. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 6.
- Augustine. Tractates on the Gospel of John. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 7.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation. Luther’s Works, vol. 44. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1966.
- Luther, Martin. Concerning the Ministry. Luther’s Works, vol. 40. Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1958.
- Luther, Martin. First Principles of the Reformation. Translated by Henry Wace and C. A. Buchheim. London: John Murray, 1883.
- Luther, Martin. Letter to Wolfgang Brauer. D. Martin Luthers Werke: Briefwechsel, vol. 7, no. 2281. Weimar, 1937.
Other Traditions
- The Canons and Decrees of the Sacred and Oecumenical Council of Trent. Translated by J. Waterworth. London: Dolman, 1848.
- The Book of Common Prayer (1662), with the Articles of Religion.
- Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. The Use of the Means of Grace: A Statement on the Practice of Word and Sacrament. Chicago: ELCA, 1997.
- The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod. Convention Proceedings, 1989 and 2016.
Reference
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.
Footnotes
-
Dylan MacDonald, “A Lutheran Understanding of the Priesthood of All Believers.” See also the companion paper The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry, sections II–V. ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. ἱεράτευμα. ↩
-
Ap XXIV 19 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Ap XXIV 25–26 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Martin Luther, Address to the Christian Nobility of the German Nation (1520), in First Principles of the Reformation, trans. Henry Wace and C. A. Buchheim (London: John Murray, 1883). Compare LW 44. ↩
-
Luther, Concerning the Ministry (1523), LW 40:21. ↩
-
Luther, Address to the Christian Nobility, trans. Wace and Buchheim. Compare LW 44. ↩
-
Luther, Concerning the Ministry (1523), LW 40. Luther distinguishes the public exercise of a right common to all, which requires the consent and call of the community, from its use in a case of necessity. This is a paraphrase. ↩
-
Tr 69 (Triglotta). ↩
-
SD VII 83–84 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Luther, letter to Wolfgang Brauer, pastor at Jessen (St. David’s Day, 1536), WA Br 7:338–339 (no. 2281); St. Louis Edition 10:2224–2227. ↩
-
AC XIV (Triglotta, Latin text). The Latin reads nisi rite vocatus. ↩
-
AC XXVIII 5–8 (Triglotta), citing John 20:21–23 and Mark 16:15. ↩
-
Ap XIII 9 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Thayer, s.v. οἰκονόμος. ↩
-
Justin Martyr, First Apology 65, ANF, vol. 1. The Sunday service of chapter 67 is quoted in On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper and in Freedom and Form in Worship. ↩
-
Thayer, s.v. προΐστημι, sense 2a, citing 1 Thessalonians 5:12 and 1 Timothy 3:4–5, 12; 5:17. ↩
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “preside,” sense 1. ↩
-
Council of Trent, Session XXIII (July 15, 1563), On the Sacrament of Order, chapter 1, in The Canons and Decrees of the Sacred and Oecumenical Council of Trent, trans. J. Waterworth (London: Dolman, 1848). ↩
-
Trent, Session XXII (September 17, 1562), On the Sacrifice of the Mass, canon 2. ↩
-
Trent, Session XXIII, On the Sacrament of Order, canon 1. ↩
-
LC V 10 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 80.3, NPNF¹, vol. 7, on John 15:3. ↩
-
LC V 15–17 (Triglotta). ↩
-
SD VII 74 (Triglotta). ↩
-
SD VII 75 (Triglotta). ↩
-
SD VII 76 (Triglotta), citing Chrysostom’s sermon on the betrayal of Judas (De proditione Judae), there called his “Sermon concerning the Passion.” ↩
-
SD VII 77 (Triglotta), quoting Luther from the Jena edition. ↩
-
SD VII 77 (Triglotta). Compare SD VII 78, where Luther says that Christ “has united His command and act with our speaking.” ↩
-
SD VII 85 (Triglotta). ↩
-
SD VII 79–81 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 28 (Triglotta). The passage is discussed in The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry, section I. ↩
-
Clement of Rome, First Epistle to the Corinthians 40, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Clement, First Epistle to the Corinthians 41, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Ap XIII 10 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Ignatius, Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 8, ANF, vol. 1. See The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry, section V. ↩
-
Tertullian, The Chaplet (De Corona) 3, ANF, vol. 3. In chapters 3–4 Tertullian lists these customs as examples of unwritten tradition. ↩
-
First Council of Nicaea (325), canon 18, NPNF², vol. 14. ↩
-
Jerome, Letter 146.1 (to Evangelus), NPNF², vol. 6. ↩
-
Jerome, Dialogue against the Luciferians 21, NPNF², vol. 6. ↩
-
Cyprian, Epistle 62.14 (to Caecilius), ANF, vol. 5 (numbered Epistle 63 in modern editions). ↩
-
Tr 67 (Triglotta). The story of the two Christians in the ship does not appear in Augustine’s surviving works; the Reformers knew it from the medieval canon law, where it was cited under Augustine’s name. ↩
-
Luther, Address to the Christian Nobility, trans. Wace and Buchheim. Compare LW 44. ↩
-
Tertullian, On Baptism 17, ANF, vol. 3. ↩
-
Jerome, Dialogue against the Luciferians 9, NPNF², vol. 6. ↩
-
AC IX 1 (Triglotta). See also LC IV 6, 35–37, and the companion paper Baptism and Falling Away. ↩
-
SA III.iv (Triglotta). ↩
-
LC V 22 (Triglotta). ↩
-
SD VII 61–62 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 25.12, NPNF¹, vol. 7, on John 6:28–29. ↩
-
Luther, Concerning the Ministry (1523), LW 40:9. ↩
-
LC V 39, 41–42 (Triglotta). On Luther’s urging of frequent communion, see On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper, section III. ↩
-
Tertullian, On Exhortation to Chastity 7, ANF, vol. 4. ↩
-
Tertullian, The Chaplet 3, ANF, vol. 3; On Baptism 17, ANF, vol. 3. On Baptism is generally dated before Tertullian’s Montanist period; The Chaplet (c. 211) and the Exhortation to Chastity are usually placed within it. ↩
-
Articles of Religion (1571), Article XXIII, “Of Ministering in the Congregation.” The full text is quoted in The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry, section V. ↩
-
Synod of the Anglican Diocese of Sydney, resolution of 2008; Appellate Tribunal of the Anglican Church of Australia, opinion of August 10, 2010, on lay and diaconal administration of Holy Communion, which held that a canon of the General Synod would be required. See “Australia Appellate Tribunal rejects move to allow deacons to preside at Eucharist,” Anglican Communion News Service, August 2010. ↩
-
The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, 1989 Convention (Wichita, Kansas), Resolution 3-05B. See “FAQs provide ‘Update on Licensed Lay Deacons,’” Reporter (LCMS, 2018), which summarizes the resolution as providing for men to “serve temporarily in Word and Sacrament ministries in these exceptional circumstances or emergencies.” ↩
-
The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, 2016 Convention (Milwaukee), Resolution 13-02A, “To Regularize Status of Licensed Lay Deacons Involved in Word and Sacrament Ministry.” See “Convention addresses licensed lay deacons in public ministry,” Reporter (LCMS, July 2016). ↩
-
Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, The Use of the Means of Grace: A Statement on the Practice of Word and Sacrament (Chicago: ELCA, 1997), Principle 40 and Background 40A. Background 40A is itself quoting the World Council of Churches’ Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (1982). ↩
-
Ap XIII 12 (Triglotta). ↩
-
Tr 66–67 (Triglotta). See also Tr 72. ↩
-
Luther, Concerning the Ministry (1523), LW 40. This is a paraphrase of Luther’s counsel in the closing part of the treatise; it is discussed more fully in The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry, section IV. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “The Royal Priesthood and the Lord's Table: Why Not Every Member Presides at Holy Communion.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/the-royal-priesthood-and-the-lords-table/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.