Should Israel Be a Country?
A Scriptural, Lutheran, and Civil Evaluation
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“Pray for the peace of Jerusalem! ‘May they be secure who love you! Peace be within your walls and security within your towers!’” — Psalm 122:6–7, ESV
I. The Question Before Us
Few questions stir up as much heat in a Bible class as this one. Some Christians believe that the modern State of Israel is the fulfillment of prophecy and that to oppose it is to oppose God. Others believe that the Church has simply replaced Israel (a view often called “replacement theology”) and that the modern state has nothing to do with the Bible at all. Still others have never thought about the question theologically and know only what they see on the evening news. Since October 7, 2023, and the war in Gaza that followed, the question has come up more and more often and it is usually asked with strong feeling.
The question “Should Israel be a country?” is really two questions and much of the confusion comes from running them together. The first is a theological question: Does Holy Scripture require, or forbid, a Jewish state in the land of Canaan? The second is a civil question: Judged by reason, justice, and the law of nations, should the State of Israel exist? (By “the law of nations” I mean the rules and customs by which the nations of the world deal with one another.) A Lutheran is well equipped to keep these two questions apart, because our Confessions teach that God rules the world in two distinct ways and that the Church must not confuse them.
In this paper I want to do three things: 1) define what we mean when we say “Israel”; 2) evaluate the theological and Scriptural arguments that are made for (and against) a Jewish state; and 3) evaluate the civil and political arguments on their own terms. I will start each time with Holy Scripture and then turn to what our Confessions say about it. I will also say at the outset where I end up. Scripture neither commands nor forbids the modern State of Israel, and therefore its existence must be judged the way every nation is judged, by the law God has written on every heart. Judged that way, I believe Israel should be a country. The same standard holds Israel to account and recognizes that the Palestinian people have the same rights.
II. What Do We Mean by “Israel”?
Before we argue about Israel, we need to know which Israel we are talking about. In Scripture and in common speech the word is used in at least four ways.
First, Israel is a man. After Jacob wrestled at the Jabbok, God gave him the name Israel (Genesis 32:28) and his twelve sons became the twelve tribes. Second, Israel is a people: the descendants of Jacob whom God brought out of Egypt, bound to Himself at Sinai, and planted in the land of Canaan. This is the Israel of the Old Testament, which became a kingdom under Saul, David, and Solomon, divided into a northern kingdom (Israel) and a southern kingdom (Judah), and was finally carried into exile.
Third, the New Testament uses the word in more than one sense. Most often it still means the Jewish people. Paul grieves for “my kinsmen according to the flesh. They are Israelites, and to them belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship, and the promises” (Romans 9:3–4). In Romans 11 “Israel” is the people distinct from the Gentiles. However, Paul also makes a distinction within Israel between the nation and the believing remnant: “not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel” (Romans 9:6). In at least one place he may use the name for the whole people of God gathered around the Messiah, Jew and Gentile together. He closes Galatians with a blessing “upon the Israel of God” (Galatians 6:16), which many interpreters (Luther among them) take to mean the whole Church, although others take it to mean believing Jews. The New Testament therefore speaks of ethnic Israel, of the believing remnant within it, and (at least by extension) of the Church.
Fourth, Israel is a modern nation-state: the State of Israel, declared on May 14, 1948, with its seat of government in Jerusalem, its parliament (the Knesset), and about ten million citizens, roughly a fifth of whom are Arab.
In other words, when a Christian says “God’s promises to Israel,” he may mean any of the first three, and when a newspaper says “Israel” it means the fourth. The great mistake in this debate is to assume, without argument, that whatever the Bible says about the first three applies directly to the fourth. That may be true or it may not be, but it has to be shown from Scripture rather than assumed.
III. How a Lutheran Asks the Question: The Two Kingdoms
Lutherans confess that God rules the world in two ways. With His right hand He rules the Church by the Gospel, forgiving sins and creating faith through Word and Sacrament. With His left hand He rules the world by the Law, through governments, families, and callings, restraining evil and preserving life. Both are God’s rule and both are good, but they work by different means and toward different ends.
The Augsburg Confession teaches that civil government is God’s own good work:
“Of Civil Affairs they teach that lawful civil ordinances are good works of God, and that it is right for Christians to bear civil office, to sit as judges, to judge matters by the Imperial and other existing laws, to award just punishments, to engage in just wars, to serve as soldiers, to make legal contracts, to hold property, to make oath when required by the magistrates, to marry a wife, to be given in marriage.” (AC XVI 1–2)1
The same Confession also warns the Church not to step into the office of the state:
“Therefore the power of the Church and the civil power must not be confounded. The power of the Church has its own commission to teach the Gospel and to administer the Sacraments. Let it not break into the office of another; let it not transfer the kingdoms of this world; let it not abrogate the laws of civil rulers; let it not abolish lawful obedience; let it not interfere with judgments concerning civil ordinances or contracts; let it not prescribe laws to civil rulers concerning the form of the Commonwealth.” (AC XXVIII 12–13)2
Notice the phrase “let it not transfer the kingdoms of this world.” The Reformers had in mind the medieval papacy, which claimed the right to give and take away crowns. The principle reaches further than that. The Church has no Word of God that awards a particular territory to a particular nation in our day and it should not speak as though it did. The Confession goes on at once to cite the words of Jesus for the same point: “My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, my servants would have been fighting, that I might not be delivered over to the Jews. But my kingdom is not from the world” (John 18:36). When someone asked Him to divide an inheritance, He answered, “Man, who made me a judge or arbitrator over you?” (Luke 12:14).
That does not leave the Church silent when governments do wrong. The Church preaches the whole Law of God and that Law speaks to rulers as well as to subjects. When a government or an armed movement murders the innocent, steals, oppresses the helpless, or bears false witness, the Church may and must say so on the authority of God’s Word, as Amos said it to Damascus, Gaza, Tyre, and Edom before he said it to Judah and Israel (Amos 1–2). It says so as the prophets did, to call to repentance, and it has a further word that no government can speak: forgiveness for every sinner who turns, whether he is a ruler, a soldier, or a militant. What the Church has no Word of God for is the settling of borders, sovereignty, and treaties. Although it can condemn the killing of the innocent on either side of a border, it has no Word of God that tells the nations where the border belongs.
We must also be careful about which hand we are speaking from. If a Christian says, “God has promised this land to the Jewish people, and therefore the State of Israel must exist,” he is speaking a word of the right hand, a divine promise, and he must be able to show that promise from Scripture. If a Christian says, “The State of Israel is a lawful government, recognized by the nations, protecting millions of people, and therefore it should exist,” he is speaking a word of the left hand, a judgment of reason and justice, and he must be able to show that from the facts. Luther made the same distinction in his treatise on temporal authority: the sword belongs to the world’s government and not to the Gospel, and confusing the two harms both.3 The two kinds of argument may arrive at the same answer, but they do not stand or fall together. Therefore we will take them one at a time.
IV. The Scriptural Case for a Jewish State
It is only fair to begin by stating the case for a theological claim on the land as strongly as its best defenders state it. Many sincere Christians who love the Scriptures hold it and they hold it because of real texts.
The land was promised forever. God promised Abram the land in sweeping terms: “To your offspring I give this land, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the river Euphrates” (Genesis 15:18). When He renewed the covenant, He called it everlasting: “And I will give to you and to your offspring after you the land of your sojournings, all the land of Canaan, for an everlasting possession, and I will be their God” (Genesis 17:8). If the possession is everlasting, the argument goes, it cannot have expired.
The nations will be judged by how they treat Abraham’s descendants. “I will bless those who bless you, and him who dishonors you I will curse, and in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed” (Genesis 12:3). Many American Christians read this verse as a standing instruction for the foreign policy of nations: bless the State of Israel and be blessed, oppose it and be cursed.
The prophets foretold a return. Ezekiel’s vision of the dry bones ends with a promise of national restoration: “Behold, I will take the people of Israel from the nations among which they have gone, and will gather them from all around, and bring them to their own land. And I will make them one nation in the land, on the mountains of Israel” (Ezekiel 37:21–22). Amos promises permanence: “I will plant them on their land, and they shall never again be uprooted out of the land that I have given them” (Amos 9:15). Isaiah speaks of a second gathering: “In that day the Lord will extend his hand yet a second time to recover the remnant that remains of his people… and gather the dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth” (Isaiah 11:11–12). Since the return from Babylon was only partial, it is argued, the second gathering must be the modern return to the land, which began in the late nineteenth century and became a state in 1948.
Jesus spoke of an end to Gentile rule over Jerusalem. “Jerusalem will be trampled underfoot by the Gentiles, until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled” (Luke 21:24). The word “until” suggests to many readers that Jerusalem would one day return to Jewish hands, as it did in 1967.
Paul writes that God is not finished with Israel. “I ask, then, has God rejected his people? By no means!” (Romans 11:1). Paul speaks of a mystery: “a partial hardening has come upon Israel, until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in. And in this way all Israel will be saved” (Romans 11:25–26). He adds, “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Romans 11:29).
Put together, these texts form the backbone of what is often called Christian Zionism. Christian hope for a Jewish return to the land is older than most people realize. It goes back to English Puritans and to nineteenth-century evangelical Anglicans such as Lord Shaftesbury, who pressed the British government to support a Jewish return as early as 1840 and helped form the climate in which the Balfour Declaration was issued in 1917. Its most popular modern form, especially in America, grew out of dispensationalism, a system of interpretation taught by John Nelson Darby in the nineteenth century and spread through the Scofield Reference Bible (1909). Classical dispensationalism held that God has two distinct peoples with two distinct destinies: an earthly people (Israel) with earthly promises of land and kingdom, and a heavenly people (the Church). On this reading the Church is a parenthesis in God’s plan for Israel, and the modern state is the stage on which the last events will be played out. Those events are the rapture (the sudden taking of believers from the earth to meet Christ), a seven-year tribulation of suffering on earth, and a literal thousand-year reign of Christ from Jerusalem, called the millennium. Since the 1990s many dispensationalists, called “progressive,” have dropped the language of two peoples with two destinies while still expecting a future for national Israel in the land.4
Christian Zionism and dispensationalism are not the same thing, however. Many Christians who support Israel hold none of the dispensational timetable. They believe only that the return of the Jewish people to the land is in some way God’s doing and carries prophetic significance, and their view has to be weighed on its own terms.
The question is argued within Judaism too. Many religious Jews see the state as the beginning of redemption. Others, such as the Satmar Hasidim, have opposed a Jewish state on religious grounds, holding that Israel must wait for the Messiah to bring the people back and must not take the land by human effort.5 Between these, many Orthodox Jews accept the state without giving it religious meaning, and the founders of the Zionist movement were largely secular. The theological question, in other words, does not divide simply between Jews and Christians.
V. How the Lutheran Church Reads These Promises
The Lutheran Church has always read the Old Testament as a book about Christ. Jesus Himself taught His disciples to read it that way: “beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, he interpreted to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself” (Luke 24:27). Paul gives the principle in one sentence: “For all the promises of God find their Yes in him” (2 Corinthians 1:20). All the promises includes the promise of the land. Therefore the Lutheran question is not “Has God kept His promises to Israel?” (He has, and He always will) but “How has God kept them, and in whom?”
A. The land promise was kept, and it was always held by faith
Scripture itself says the land promise was fulfilled. At the end of the conquest the book of Joshua says:
“Thus the LORD gave to Israel all the land that he swore to give to their fathers. And they took possession of it, and they settled there… Not one word of all the good promises that the LORD had made to the house of Israel had failed; all came to pass.” (Joshua 21:43, 45)
Under Solomon, Israel’s rule reached the geographical limits described in Genesis 15: “Solomon ruled over all the kingdoms from the Euphrates to the land of the Philistines and to the border of Egypt” (1 Kings 4:21). Much of that territory consisted of kingdoms that paid him tribute rather than land Israel settled, but the reach of the promise was there. After the exile the Levites prayed, recalling the covenant “to give to his offspring the land of the Canaanite, the Hittite, the Amorite, the Perizzite, the Jebusite, and the Girgashite,” and then confessed, “And you have kept your promise, for you are righteous” (Nehemiah 9:8). Scripture never speaks as though the land promise were still waiting to be kept for the first time.
In addition, Israel’s possession of the land was always tied to the covenant. Moses warned the people before they ever crossed the Jordan:
“And you shall be plucked off the land that you are entering to take possession of it. And the LORD will scatter you among all peoples, from one end of the earth to the other…” (Deuteronomy 28:63–64)
God also promised to bring them back when they returned to Him (Deuteronomy 30:1–5), and He did so after seventy years in Babylon, exactly as Jeremiah said: “When seventy years are completed for Babylon, I will visit you, and I will fulfill to you my promise and bring you back to this place” (Jeremiah 29:10). In other words, the land was a gift held in faith and in covenant faithfulness, never a title deed that could be claimed apart from the LORD who gave it. That is why the Old Testament can speak of the possession as “everlasting” and also of the people being “plucked off the land.” The everlasting element is God’s faithfulness to the promise, and Scripture goes on to show us where that faithfulness leads.
B. The promise was widened in Christ
The New Testament does not cancel the land promise. It enlarges it. Paul writes something about Abraham’s inheritance that no Old Testament verse says in so many words: “For the promise to Abraham and his offspring that he would be heir of the world did not come through the law but through the righteousness of faith” (Romans 4:13). Abraham was promised Canaan and he will inherit the world. Jesus says the same thing in the Beatitudes, taking a line from Psalm 37 that originally spoke of the land: “Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth” (Matthew 5:5).
The letter to the Hebrews tells us that Abraham himself understood the promise this way. He lived in the land “as in a foreign land, living in tents,” because “he was looking forward to the city that has foundations, whose designer and builder is God” (Hebrews 11:9–10). Of the patriarchs together it says:
“These all died in faith, not having received the things promised, but having seen them and greeted them from afar, and having acknowledged that they were strangers and exiles on the earth… But as it is, they desire a better country, that is, a heavenly one. Therefore God is not ashamed to be called their God, for he has prepared for them a city.” (Hebrews 11:13, 16)
Who, then, is Abraham’s “offspring” to whom the land was promised? Paul answers directly: “Now the promises were made to Abraham and to his offspring. It does not say, ‘And to offsprings,’ referring to many, but referring to one, ‘And to your offspring,’ who is Christ” (Galatians 3:16). Everyone who belongs to Christ by faith, Jew or Gentile, shares in that inheritance: “And if you are Christ’s, then you are Abraham’s offspring, heirs according to promise” (Galatians 3:29). The promise is not taken away from Abraham’s physical descendants. It is fulfilled in the one physical descendant of Abraham who is also the Son of God, and it is offered to every Jew and every Gentile who believes in Him.
This is not replacement, because nothing is taken from Israel and handed to strangers. The promise is kept in Israel’s own Messiah and the Gentiles are grafted into Israel’s root. Paul warns the Gentile believers in Rome against any pride on that score: “do not be arrogant toward the branches. If you are, remember it is not you who support the root, but the root that supports you” (Romans 11:18).
C. The prophecies of return
First, the prophets themselves connect the return to the coming of the Messiah. Ezekiel’s promise of a regathered nation goes on in the very next breath to say that “one king shall be king over them all” (Ezekiel 37:22), and a few verses later names Him: “My servant David shall be king over them” (37:24). That King is Jesus, the Son of David.
Second, the New Testament tells us how at least one of these prophecies was fulfilled. At the council of Jerusalem, when the apostles were debating whether Gentiles could be received into the Church without circumcision, James quoted Amos 9. Amos had promised, “In that day I will raise up the booth of David that is fallen and repair its breaches” (Amos 9:11). James saw that promise being kept in the conversion of the Gentiles:
“Simeon has related how God first visited the Gentiles, to take from them a people for his name. And with this the words of the prophets agree, just as it is written, ‘After this I will return, and I will rebuild the tent of David that has fallen; I will rebuild its ruins, and I will restore it, that the remnant of mankind may seek the Lord, and all the Gentiles who are called by my name.’” (Acts 15:14–17)
The same chapter of Amos that promises Israel will “never again be uprooted” is the chapter the apostles read as fulfilled in the Church’s mission to the nations. The final word of that promise, a people planted forever in a land from which they cannot be removed, is a picture of the new creation, where God’s people will dwell in safety and will never again be driven out.
Third, Isaiah’s “second time” is best read in its own setting. Isaiah’s language recalls the exodus from Egypt (Isaiah 11:16) and anticipates a new gathering of God’s people from every direction, from Assyria and Egypt to Elam, Shinar (Babylon), and the coastlands (11:11). That gathering begins with the restoration from exile and reaches its fulfillment in the Messiah. The chapter opens with the “shoot from the stump of Jesse” (11:1) and sees the nations themselves seeking the “signal” God raises up (11:10, 12). Paul quotes that very verse of Christ and the Gentiles: “The root of Jesse will come, even he who arises to rule the Gentiles; in him will the Gentiles hope” (Romans 15:12).
Someone could agree with all of this and still think God may yet do something more for the Jewish people in the land. A Christian may believe that, although the New Testament nowhere teaches it. What he may not do is bind another Christian’s conscience with it (that is, tell him God requires him to believe it when God has not said so), or use it to decide who should govern which land today.
None of this proves that God has nothing to do with the return of Jewish people to the land in modern times. God rules all of history, including the history of nations. However, it does mean that we cannot point to the events of 1948 and say with the authority of Scripture, “This is the fulfillment of Ezekiel 37.” The New Testament has already told us where to look for the fulfillment, and it points us to Christ and His Church.
D. Jesus’ answer to the disciples’ question
After His resurrection the disciples asked Jesus the very question this paper is asking: “Lord, will you at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?” He answered:
“It is not for you to know times or seasons that the Father has fixed by his own authority. But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you, and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth.” (Acts 1:7–8)
Jesus neither rebukes the question nor explains a timetable. He redirects His disciples from the restoration of a kingdom to the mission of the Gospel, beginning in Jerusalem and going outward to the whole world. That is the shape the rest of the book of Acts takes. Luke 21:24 should be read with the same modesty. Its first fulfillment was the destruction of Jerusalem by Rome in A.D. 70, which Jesus describes in the verses just before it. The phrase “until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled” tells us that the trampling has a limit set by God, but it does not tell us that the limit is a modern state, and it would be unwise to build a political doctrine on it.
E. Romans 9–11: God has not rejected His people
The strongest text in this debate is Romans 9–11 and Lutherans must read it honestly. Paul is anguished over his own people (Romans 9:2–3). He insists that God’s word has not failed (9:6) and that God has not rejected His people (11:1). He writes of the Jews who have not believed in Christ, “As regards the gospel, they are enemies for your sake. But as regards election, they are beloved for the sake of their forefathers. For the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Romans 11:28–29).
Christians have read “all Israel will be saved” (11:26) in three main ways. Some (including Luther and Calvin at points) have taken “all Israel” to mean the whole number of the elect, Jew and Gentile together, which fits Galatians 6:16. Others have taken it to mean the full number of elect Jews gathered through the whole age of the Church. Still others, including some Lutheran interpreters, expect a large turning of the Jewish people to Christ before the end. No article of our Confessions settles the question, although the Missouri Synod’s theologians have found the first reading the most probable and the expectation of a national conversion hard to square with Paul’s argument.6 On two points, however, there is no Lutheran freedom. No one is saved apart from Christ and no one comes to faith except through the Word, which is preached in this present age before Christ returns. Whatever God does among the Jewish people, He does through the preaching of the Gospel before Christ returns, and not by a second chance after it or by a separate covenant without Christ.
All three readings share something more important than where they differ. In every one of them, Israel is saved in the same way the Gentiles are saved: “The Deliverer will come from Zion, he will banish ungodliness from Jacob”; “and this will be my covenant with them when I take away their sins” (Romans 11:26–27). Paul speaks of forgiveness, the Deliverer, and faith, and he does not mention the land, borders, or a state anywhere in these three chapters. “For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; for the same Lord is Lord of all, bestowing his riches on all who call on him” (Romans 10:12). Romans 11 therefore teaches Christians to love the Jewish people, to pray for them, and to bring them the Gospel, “to the Jew first and also to the Greek” (Romans 1:16). It does not teach a political program.
F. Genesis 12:3 and the blessing of the nations
Genesis 12:3 deserves a word of its own, because it is so often quoted in political argument. Paul tells us what the blessing of the nations through Abraham means: “And the Scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the gospel beforehand to Abraham, saying, ‘In you shall all the nations be blessed’” (Galatians 3:8). The blessing of Genesis 12:3 is the Gospel, which came into the world through Abraham’s Seed. To “bless” Abraham in the fullest sense is to receive his Seed, Jesus Christ.
The verse still bears on how Christians treat Jewish people. God’s people have never been permitted to despise those whom God chose and loved (Deuteronomy 7:7–8; Romans 11:28). However, Genesis 12:3 does not tell a modern government how to vote in the United Nations, and to read it that way is to turn a Gospel promise into a law for foreign policy. It also hangs no curse over the Christian who disagrees with an Israeli policy, and promises no blessing to the one who supports it. The blessing of Abraham is already his and it came to him by faith, not by a position on foreign affairs: “so that in Christ Jesus the blessing of Abraham might come to the Gentiles, so that we might receive the promised Spirit through faith” (Galatians 3:14). In matters the Word leaves free, no one may bind his conscience with a threat God has not spoken.
G. What the Confessions say about earthly kingdoms before the end
The Augsburg Confession speaks to this subject more directly than many Lutherans realize. In the article on Christ’s return it confesses that at the end of the world “Christ will appear for judgment, and will raise up all the dead,” and then it adds a condemnation:
“They condemn also others who are now spreading certain Jewish opinions, that before the resurrection of the dead the godly shall take possession of the kingdom of the world, the ungodly being everywhere suppressed.” (AC XVII 5)7
The “Jewish opinions” in this article were held by Christians, radical preachers of the 1520s such as Hans Hut, and not by the Jews of Luther’s day. The Reformers called them “Jewish” because they looked for a worldly messianic kingdom rather than the kingdom Christ brings by His Word. (In 1534 radicals seized the German city of Münster and declared it the New Jerusalem, which later showed where such hopes could lead.) What the article explicitly condemns is the expectation that before the resurrection the godly will take possession of worldly rule and suppress the ungodly, the error usually called chiliasm (from the Greek chilioi, “thousand”).
Premillennialism (from pre, “before”) teaches that Christ will return before the thousand years of Revelation 20, raise believers first, reign on earth for a thousand years, and then raise everyone else. That makes two resurrections with an earthly kingdom between them (Revelation 20:4–6). Dispensational premillennialists, who hold this view along with the timetable described above, would therefore say that AC XVII does not touch them, since they expect Christ Himself to reign after His return. A form of this hope was held by some early fathers, Justin Martyr and Irenaeus among them, although the Church did not follow them. However, the article confesses a single appearing of Christ at which He “will raise up all the dead,” and Luther’s Small Catechism says the same: at the last day Christ “will raise up me and all the dead.” That leaves no room for an earthly kingdom set between two resurrections. A kingdom centered in Jerusalem after Christ’s return is not the precise opinion the condemnation names, but it is excluded by what the article confesses. The Missouri Synod’s Commission on Theology and Church Relations has said that “the eschatology presented in The Lutheran Confessions is clearly amillennialist (AC XVII).” (Eschatology is the teaching about the last things, and an amillennial reading takes the thousand years of Revelation 20 as a picture of Christ’s reign now rather than a future earthly kingdom.) The Commission has also called the dispensational teaching of a conversion of the Jews after the rapture “contrary to the Scriptural Gospel,” since it offers a second chance after Christ’s return.8
If you were taught this view, you are not being told that your faith in Christ is false. The error lies in a timetable and not in the Savior you trust. The Christ who will come once will raise all His saints together, you among them.
This article should not be made to say more than it says. AC XVII does not say that a Jewish state may not exist; it says nothing about modern states at all. It also does not condemn every Christian who supports Israel or who believes its founding has prophetic significance. A Christian who looks for no earthly kingdom of the godly before the resurrection is not a chiliast, whatever he thinks of 1948. What the article rules out is a particular way of reading the prophecies, the way that makes an earthly kingdom in the land part of God’s plan of salvation. Once that reading is set aside, the strongest form of the theological argument (that the State of Israel is a necessary fulfillment of prophecy, with a divine title to its territory) loses its foundation. God’s providence certainly governs the history of the Jewish people and of the modern state, as it governs the history of every nation. What Scripture does not authorize us to declare is that the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 fulfills a particular prophecy or carries a special divine mandate. On such matters Christians should not bind one another’s consciences.
H. A warning in the other direction
Lutherans must also hear a warning against the opposite error. To say that the promises are fulfilled in Christ is not to say that God despises the Jewish people, or that the Church may despise them. The history of the Church, including the history of our own church, contains terrible failures here. In 1523 Luther wrote warmly that Jesus Christ was born a Jew and urged Christians to treat Jews kindly so that they might come to faith. Twenty years later, in On the Jews and Their Lies (1543), he called on princes to burn synagogues and drive Jews from their homes.9 Those later writings were used by the Nazis four centuries later, and Lutheran church bodies in our own time have publicly rejected them, the Missouri Synod among them.10 We confess them as sins, we reject them, and we pray to be kept from them, because the same contempt can still take root in Christian hearts.
The doctrine that the land promise is fulfilled in Christ must never become an excuse for indifference to the safety of Jewish people, or for treating the Jewish state differently than any other nation simply because it is Jewish. Paul’s own word is that they are “beloved for the sake of their forefathers.” The Church’s identity in Christ does not erase the history or the identity of the Jewish people, any more than Paul ceased to be “an Israelite, a descendant of Abraham, a member of the tribe of Benjamin” (Romans 11:1) when he became an apostle. A Christian who denies that the State of Israel is a fulfillment of prophecy is still bound by the Fifth Commandment to help and befriend his Jewish neighbor in every bodily need, and to pray for his salvation. Nor may the Church show its repentance by keeping silent about Christ, as though the Jewish people had another way to the Father. Jesus is Israel’s Messiah before He is ours and the Gospel is theirs first (Romans 1:16). To withhold it would be a new contempt disguised as respect.
I. The theological conclusion
We can now answer the first question. Holy Scripture neither requires nor forbids the modern State of Israel. The promises to Abraham, including the land, have their Yes in Christ, who will give His people, Jew and Gentile, a new heaven and a new earth. The modern state is not the kingdom of God, nor is it the fulfillment we are told to look for. Neither is it an offense against God that the Church must oppose. It is one of the nations, of whom Paul said at Athens that God “made from one man every nation of mankind to live on all the face of the earth, having determined allotted periods and the boundaries of their dwelling place” (Acts 17:26). God rules it as He rules every nation, by His left hand, and it answers to Him under the law that binds them all.
That means the question of whether Israel should be a country must be answered in the left-hand kingdom, by the light God has given to all people.
VI. The Civil Question: By What Standard?
When Christians evaluate a nation, they do not need a special revelation. God has written His law on every human heart: “For when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do what the law requires, they are a law to themselves… They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness” (Romans 2:14–15). Reason, guided by that natural law, can recognize justice and injustice, lawful government and tyranny, a just war and murder. Our Confessions grant that human reason can achieve a real though limited civil righteousness (an outward uprightness in the affairs of this world), even though it can never justify a person before God. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “man’s will has some liberty to choose civil righteousness, and to work things subject to reason.”11
Scripture also tells us what government is for. The governing authority “is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain” (Romans 13:4). Government exists to protect life, to punish evil, and to keep the peace so that people “may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way” (1 Timothy 2:2). A nation is judged by whether it does these things. The Scriptures that tell us to honor governing authorities also tell us that God hears the cry of the sojourner: “You shall not wrong a sojourner or oppress him, for you were sojourners in the land of Egypt” (Exodus 22:21).
One principle governs everything that follows. The natural law does not have one standard for Jews and another for Arabs. Whatever justice requires for one people in that land, it requires for the other, and whatever it forbids to one it forbids to the other. In addition, a people’s rights do not rise or fall with the conduct of the organizations that claim to speak for it, whether an Israeli government or a Palestinian faction.
The civil question, then, has four parts. Is the State of Israel a lawful state? How did it come to be one? Does its present conduct affect its right to exist? What justice is owed to the Palestinian people? A short history is needed first.
A. A brief history
The modern movement to restore a Jewish homeland, called Zionism (after Zion, the hill of Jerusalem), took political form in the 1890s. Theodor Herzl, an Austrian journalist shaken by the antisemitism of Europe, published The Jewish State in 1896 and convened the First Zionist Congress in Basel in 1897. Jewish immigration to Ottoman Palestine increased, joining Jewish communities that had lived there continuously for centuries, especially in Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias, and Hebron.
In the First World War Britain conquered Palestine from the Ottoman Empire. On November 2, 1917, the British government issued the Balfour Declaration, which favored “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people,” with the condition that “nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine.”12 The League of Nations wrote that commitment into the British Mandate for Palestine in 1922.13 Under the Mandate Jewish immigration grew, Arab opposition grew with it, and violence broke out repeatedly between the two communities and against the British.
The Holocaust changed everything. Six million Jews were murdered in Europe and hundreds of thousands of survivors had nowhere to go. On November 29, 1947, the United Nations General Assembly adopted Resolution 181, recommending that Palestine be divided into a Jewish state and an Arab state, with Jerusalem under international administration.14 The Jewish leadership accepted the plan. The Arab leadership and the surrounding Arab states rejected it and civil war followed. On May 14, 1948, the day the British Mandate ended, the State of Israel declared its independence, promising “complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex.”15 The next day the armies of Egypt, Jordan, Syria, and Iraq, with forces from other states, entered the war.
When the fighting ended in 1949, Israel held more territory than the partition plan had given it. Jordan held the West Bank and East Jerusalem and Egypt held the Gaza Strip. About 700,000 Palestinian Arabs had fled or been driven from their homes, and Israel did not allow them to return. Palestinians call this al-Nakba, “the catastrophe.”16 In the years that followed, a comparable number of Jews left or were expelled from Arab and Muslim countries, most of them settling in Israel.17 Israel was admitted to the United Nations on May 11, 1949.18
In the Six-Day War of June 1967, Israel took the West Bank and East Jerusalem from Jordan, Gaza and the Sinai from Egypt, and the Golan Heights from Syria. Security Council Resolution 242 called for Israel’s withdrawal “from territories occupied in the recent conflict” and, at the same time, for respect for the right of every state in the area “to live in peace within secure and recognized boundaries free from threats or acts of force.”19 Israel returned the Sinai to Egypt in exchange for a peace treaty in 1979 and made peace with Jordan in 1994. In 1993 the Palestine Liberation Organization formally recognized “the right of the State of Israel to exist in peace and security,” and Israel recognized the PLO as the representative of the Palestinian people.20 Israel withdrew its settlements and soldiers from Gaza in 2005, and Hamas took control of Gaza in 2007. In 2020 the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Morocco, and Sudan agreed to normalize relations with Israel. On October 7, 2023, Hamas attacked southern Israel, killing about 1,200 people and taking some 250 hostages. The war in Gaza that followed brought immense destruction and loss of Palestinian life.
B. The case that Israel should be a country
Israel meets every ordinary test of statehood. The traditional definition in international law, set out in the Montevideo Convention of 1933, is that a state has a permanent population, a defined territory, a government, and the capacity to enter into relations with other states.21 Israel has all four. It has been a member of the United Nations for more than seventy-five years and is recognized by the large majority of the world’s nations, including (since 1979, 1994, and 2020) several of its Arab neighbors. Its borders are disputed in places, but so are the borders of many states whose existence no one questions.
The nations proposed it, Israel declared it, and the nations accepted it. The way Israel came to be needs to be described carefully, because it happened in three steps:
- The General Assembly’s Resolution 181 recommended partition. A recommendation of the General Assembly does not create a state or confer sovereignty over territory, and this one was never carried out as written.
- The State of Israel was established by its own declaration as the Mandate ended, and it held its ground in the war that followed.
- The nations recognized it. The United States did so within minutes of the declaration and the Soviet Union within days, many others followed, and the United Nations admitted Israel as a member a year later.
Israel’s present statehood does not rest on any one of these steps, least of all on the partition vote, but on all of them together and on seventy-five years of recognition since. The Jewish people’s historic connection to the land is not a theological claim alone. It is a fact of history and the Jewish presence there never entirely ceased.
The Jewish people have a right to self-determination, as other peoples do. Self-determination is the right of a people to govern itself rather than be ruled by others. After centuries of expulsion and persecution in Christian Europe and periodic persecution elsewhere, culminating in the Holocaust, the argument that the Jewish people needed a state where they could defend themselves is a strong one and the events of history have borne it out. The world’s Jews lived in many lands and in the 1930s and 1940s very few lands would receive them. Christians, whose own history bears much of the blame for that, should be the last to dismiss this argument. By the principle set down above, the Palestinian people have this right as well, a point I will return to.
The alternatives would not be more just. This is perhaps the decisive civil point. Israel today is home to about ten million people, most of whom were born there. Whatever injustices accompanied its founding, the people now living in it have a right to live, and the government that protects them is the only one they have. Those who say “Israel should not be a country” mean different things by it and they should be distinguished. Some mean the destruction of the Jewish state by force. Hamas’s founding charter of 1988 called for exactly that. Its political document of 2017 softened some of the charter’s language and called a Palestinian state on the lines of June 4, 1967 “a formula of national consensus,” but in the same article it rejected “any alternative to the full and complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea,” and it still refused to recognize Israel. The attack of October 7 showed what that refusal means.22 A call to destroy a nation by force is a call to murder.
Others, who belong to no single movement and hold a range of views, propose to replace the Jewish state with a single democratic state in which Jews and Palestinians would be equal citizens, protecting the lives and homes of both. That proposal is not a call to violence and it deserves to be heard on its own terms. However, it asks two peoples who have fought each other for a century to entrust their safety to a shared government that neither has consented to. It also asks the Jewish people to give up the one place in the world where their safety does not depend on the goodwill of others, within living memory of the Holocaust. No proposal has yet shown convincingly how such a state could be established and maintained without grave danger to both peoples. Romans 13 does not ask whether a government came into being without sin (few governments did), but whether it now bears the sword to protect the good and restrain the evil.
C. The case against, and the objections that must be heard
A fair evaluation must also hear the strongest objections. Christians who dismiss them without listening do not honor the Eighth Commandment, which teaches us to “defend him, [think and] speak well of him, and put the best construction on everything” when we speak of our neighbor (SC I, Eighth Commandment).
The displacement of 1948. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians lost their homes, villages, and land, and most were never allowed to return. Many of their descendants still live as refugees in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, the West Bank, and Gaza. This was a real injustice to real people and Palestinians are right to remember it.
The settler-colonial critique. Some scholars and activists argue that Zionism was a European colonial project that took land from its native people, and that a state born that way is illegitimate at its root. Some of them propose replacing Israel with a single state in which Jews and Arabs would be equal citizens.
The occupation. Since 1967 Israel has governed millions of Palestinians in the West Bank who are not its citizens and have no vote in the government that controls much of their lives. Israel has built settlements throughout the West Bank, which most of the world regards as a violation of international law. In 2024 the International Court of Justice gave an advisory opinion that Israel’s continued presence in the occupied Palestinian territory is unlawful.23 Critics argue that this permanent control of another people undermines Israel’s claim to be a just state.
Jewish religious objections. As noted above, some Jewish communities have rejected the state on religious grounds, and some secular Jews reject it on political ones. The objection to Israel is not simply an Arab or Muslim objection.
D. Weighing the arguments
How should a Christian weigh these claims? The key is a distinction the critics themselves often blur, between a state’s existence and its conduct. Every one of the objections above raises a serious question about justice, but only two of them actually argue that Israel should not exist: the settler-colonial critique and the religious objection of some Jewish communities. The others argue that Israel has done or is doing wrong, which is a different thing.
The religious objection is a claim about God’s will within Judaism. A Christian need not settle it, although he should respect it, and its holders as a rule seek no one’s harm; many of them live peaceably in Israel itself. In the left-hand kingdom it cannot outweigh the right of ten million people to the government that protects them.
On the question of origins, we should be honest about how nations come to be. Very few nations were founded without injustice. Our own country was founded on land taken from its native peoples, and the history of the European nations is a history of conquest. If injustice at a nation’s founding made its present existence illegitimate, almost no nation on earth could stand. The ordinary answer of Christian ethics and of the law of nations is that past wrongs call for repentance and restitution where possible, but not for the dissolution of a government that now protects the lives of its people. The remedy for injustice is justice, not a new injustice. In other words, the wrongs of 1948 are a reason for Israel to deal justly with Palestinian refugees and their descendants (by compensation, by recognition, and by a just settlement) rather than a reason for Israel to cease to exist.
On the question of conduct, the principle cuts the other way. If Israel’s existence is not a matter of prophecy, then its policies are not either. A Christian may, and sometimes must, criticize a particular Israeli government, policy, or military action, just as he would criticize the policies of his own nation, without thereby denying Israel’s right to exist. The settlements, the treatment of Palestinians under occupation, the conduct of war in Gaza, and the government’s obligations to its own Arab citizens all answer to the moral law that judges every other nation. The Augsburg Confession teaches that Christians must obey their rulers “save only when commanded to sin; for then they ought to obey God rather than men,” and Luther taught that a soldier may serve with a good conscience in a just war but is not bound to follow his prince into an unjust one.24 Romans 13 tells Israel, as it tells every government, that it bears the sword from God and what the sword is for.
Finally, the principle set down at the start of this section applies to the Palestinians as fully as to Israel. If the Jewish people have a right to live securely in a state of their own, the Palestinian people have a claim to self-determination as well: to live in security and dignity and to govern themselves as a people. This recognizes a legitimate political hope that belongs to a whole people, on the same footing as the Jewish one, rather than merely pleading for humane treatment. That claim belongs to the Palestinian people and it does not depend on the conduct of the organizations that act in their name, any more than Israel’s right to exist depends on the conduct of a particular Israeli government. The massacre of October 7 was murder and the Church must call it murder. It does not forfeit the claim of millions of Palestinians, most of whom had no part in it, to a just and secure life. Israel’s own leaders have accepted that principle at various times, most notably at Oslo in 1993, and many nations have now recognized a Palestinian state.25
What form Palestinian self-government should take, where the borders should run, and what security arrangements are needed are questions of prudence on which faithful Christians can and do disagree. Those questions belong to statesmen and citizens, not to the Church’s confession. In the same way, recognizing Israel’s continued sovereignty does not settle the legitimacy of every territory it controls, nor does it extinguish the claims of those displaced by its establishment.
Here Christians should also remember their brothers and sisters in the land. There are Arab Christian congregations throughout Israel and the Palestinian territories, among them Lutheran congregations of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy Land, alongside the far older and larger Orthodox and Catholic churches and the Anglican diocese, which shares the Lutheran church’s nineteenth-century origin.26 There are also Jewish believers in Jesus worshiping in Hebrew in Israel’s cities. Their presence reminds us that this conflict is not a conflict between God’s people and God’s enemies. There are believers on both sides of every wall.
Whatever the Church says about borders, it should first do what its Lord did: “And when he drew near and saw the city, he wept over it, saying, ‘Would that you, even you, had known on this day the things that make for peace!’” (Luke 19:41–42). Some who read this paper have family and friends in Israel, and some have family and friends in Gaza or the West Bank. The Christian who mourns for the murdered in Israel and for the dead in Gaza is not divided in his loyalties. He is following Christ.
VII. Conclusion
Should Israel be a country? My answer comes in two parts.
As a matter of theology, Scripture neither makes the State of Israel necessary to God’s plan nor condemns it. The promises to Abraham, including the land, find their Yes in Jesus Christ, the Seed of Abraham, through whom Jews and Gentiles alike become heirs of the world. The Augsburg Confession rejects the opinion “that before the resurrection of the dead the godly shall take possession of the kingdom of the world,” and it confesses one appearing of Christ at which He “will raise up all the dead.” A Lutheran therefore cannot make the modern State of Israel a necessary part of God’s saving plan, nor require fellow Christians to recognize its founding as the fulfillment of prophecy. A Lutheran also cannot treat the Jewish people with contempt, since they are “beloved for the sake of their forefathers” and the Gospel is “to the Jew first.”
As a matter of civil righteousness my answer is yes. Israel exists today as a sovereign state under the law of nations, which is an established legal fact, and its people have the same right as any people to life, to safety, and to govern themselves. Therefore I believe that keeping Israel as a Jewish state is the most just arrangement now available, although I hold that as a prudential judgment of reason and not as a word of God. Christians may weigh the same facts and differ about it without differing in faith. I offer it as a Christian reasoning with his neighbors about the common good (AC XVI; XVIII 1), not as a word the Church may bind on anyone’s conscience (AC XXVIII 12–13). The injustices that attended Israel’s founding and the injustices of its present policies call for repentance, justice, and peace, as they would in any nation, but they do not dissolve its right to exist. Justice also requires that the Palestinian people’s claim to security, dignity, and self-government be honored.
For Christians, that leaves tasks that belong to both kingdoms. In the left-hand kingdom we may support just policies, oppose unjust ones, and seek the welfare of every people in that land, as Jeremiah told the exiles to “seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the LORD on its behalf” (Jeremiah 29:7). The brother who weighs those policies differently from us still kneels beside us at the same altar. In the right-hand kingdom we pray “for all people, for kings and all who are in high positions” (1 Timothy 2:1–2), Israeli and Palestinian alike, and we bring the Gospel of Jesus Christ to Jew and Arab, Israeli and Palestinian, for “he himself is our peace, who has made us both one and has broken down in his flesh the dividing wall of hostility” (Ephesians 2:14). We pray for the peace of Jerusalem, knowing that the earthly city will never give the peace that only Christ gives, and that the Jerusalem above, which is our mother, is free (Galatians 4:26).
Select Bibliography
Scripture and Confessions
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
Luther
- Luther, Martin. Temporal Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523). In Luther’s Works, vol. 45. Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1962.
- ———. That Jesus Christ Was Born a Jew (1523). In Luther’s Works, vol. 45.
- ———. Whether Soldiers, Too, Can Be Saved (1526). In Luther’s Works, vol. 46. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1967.
- ———. On the Jews and Their Lies (1543). In Luther’s Works, vol. 47. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1971.
Church Statements
- Commission on Theology and Church Relations. The “End Times”: A Study on Eschatology and Millennialism. St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 1989.
- ———. A Lutheran Response to the “Left Behind” Series. St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 2004.
- The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod. 1983 convention, Resolution 3-09, “To Clarify Position on Anti-Semitism.”
- Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. Declaration of the ELCA to the Jewish Community. 1994.
History and Law
- Balfour Declaration. November 2, 1917.
- League of Nations. Mandate for Palestine. 1922.
- Convention on the Rights and Duties of States. Montevideo, 1933.
- United Nations General Assembly Resolutions 181 (II) (1947) and 273 (III) (1949).
- United Nations Security Council Resolution 242 (1967).
- Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel. 1948.
- Hamas. A Document of General Principles and Policies. 2017.
- International Court of Justice. Advisory Opinion of July 19, 2024.
- Morris, Benny. The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004.
Christian Zionism and Dispensationalism
- Blaising, Craig A., and Darrell L. Bock. Progressive Dispensationalism. Wheaton: BridgePoint, 1993.
- Lewis, Donald M. The Origins of Christian Zionism: Lord Shaftesbury and Evangelical Support for a Jewish Homeland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
- Weber, Timothy P. On the Road to Armageddon: How Evangelicals Became Israel’s Best Friend. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2004.
Footnotes
-
AC XVI 1–2 (Triglotta). The article continues: the Gospel “does not destroy the State or the family, but very much requires that they be preserved as ordinances of God” (AC XVI 5). ↩
-
AC XXVIII 12–13 (Triglotta). AC XXVIII 14–15 goes on to cite John 18:36 and Luke 12:14. ↩
-
Martin Luther, Temporal Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523), in Luther’s Works, vol. 45 (Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1962), 81–129. ↩
-
On the rise of dispensationalism and its influence on American attitudes toward the State of Israel, see Timothy P. Weber, On the Road to Armageddon: How Evangelicals Became Israel’s Best Friend (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2004). On the earlier British movement, see Donald M. Lewis, The Origins of Christian Zionism: Lord Shaftesbury and Evangelical Support for a Jewish Homeland (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010). On the progressive form, see Craig A. Blaising and Darrell L. Bock, Progressive Dispensationalism (Wheaton: BridgePoint, 1993). ↩
-
The classic statement is Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum, Vayoel Moshe (1961), drawing on the “three oaths” of the Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 110b–111a. ↩
-
Commission on Theology and Church Relations, The “End Times”: A Study on Eschatology and Millennialism (St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 1989), which lists four readings of Romans 11:26, says the reading “all the elect, both Jews and Gentiles” “seems most probable,” and says the readings that expect a national conversion “stand in conflict with Paul’s basic line of argumentation in Romans 9–11.” ↩
-
AC XVII 1–2, 5 (Triglotta). The sentence before the condemnation condemns the Anabaptists “who think that there will be an end to the punishments of condemned men and devils” (AC XVII 4). ↩
-
CTCR, The “End Times” (1989); see also A Lutheran Response to the “Left Behind” Series (St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 2004). ↩
-
Martin Luther, That Jesus Christ Was Born a Jew (1523), in Luther’s Works, vol. 45, 195–229; On the Jews and Their Lies (1543), in Luther’s Works, vol. 47 (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1971), 121–306. ↩
-
The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 1983 convention, Res. 3-09, “To Clarify Position on Anti-Semitism”: “we deplore and disassociate ourselves from Luther’s negative statements about the Jewish people.” See also the Lutheran World Federation, Seventh Assembly, Budapest (1984); and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, Declaration of the ELCA to the Jewish Community (1994). ↩
-
AC XVIII 1–2 (Triglotta). The article continues: “But it has no power, without the Holy Ghost, to work the righteousness of God.” ↩
-
Arthur James Balfour to Lord Rothschild, November 2, 1917. ↩
-
League of Nations, Mandate for Palestine, approved by the Council July 24, 1922. ↩
-
United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181 (II), Future Government of Palestine, November 29, 1947. The vote was 33 in favor, 13 against, with 10 abstentions. ↩
-
Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel, May 14, 1948. ↩
-
On the numbers and causes of the Palestinian refugee flight, see Benny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004). Estimates commonly range from about 600,000 to 760,000. ↩
-
Estimates of Jews who left Arab and Muslim lands between 1948 and the early 1970s commonly run from about 800,000 to 850,000. ↩
-
United Nations General Assembly Resolution 273 (III), May 11, 1949. ↩
-
United Nations Security Council Resolution 242, November 22, 1967. ↩
-
Letters of mutual recognition, Yasser Arafat to Yitzhak Rabin and Yitzhak Rabin to Yasser Arafat, September 9, 1993. ↩
-
Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (Montevideo, December 26, 1933), art. 1. ↩
-
Hamas, A Document of General Principles and Policies (May 1, 2017), arts. 19–20. ↩
-
International Court of Justice, Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, Advisory Opinion of July 19, 2024. ↩
-
AC XVI 6–7 (Triglotta); Martin Luther, Whether Soldiers, Too, Can Be Saved (1526), in Luther’s Works, vol. 46 (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1967), 87–137; cf. Temporal Authority, LW 45:124–126. ↩
-
By late 2025 the State of Palestine was recognized by roughly three-quarters of the member states of the United Nations, including, in September 2025, the United Kingdom, France, Canada, and Australia. ↩
-
The Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy Land has congregations in Jerusalem, Bethlehem, Beit Jala, Beit Sahour, Ramallah, and Amman. The Lutheran and Anglican churches in the land both grew from the joint Anglican–Prussian Bishopric of Jerusalem founded in 1841. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Should Israel Be a Country?: A Scriptural, Lutheran, and Civil Evaluation.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/should-israel-be-a-country/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.