Baptism and Confirmation
Why Lutherans Confirm Those Already Baptized
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you.” — Matthew 28:19–20
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. Luther’s Babylonian Captivity of the Church is quoted in the Steinhaeuser translation, the Council of Trent in the Waterworth translation, and one sermon not translated in LW is cited from the Weimar Edition (WA).
The Question Before Us
If Baptism makes us members of Christ’s Church, why do Lutherans confirm at all? The question is a fair one and it comes from several directions. A young person in a confirmation class asks it. A parent asks it when the class seems to be one more demand on a crowded family calendar. A Baptist friend asks it as an objection: “You baptize babies and then, years later, you have them stand up and confess the faith for themselves. Isn’t that just believer’s baptism without the water?” A Roman Catholic or an Orthodox friend asks it from the other side: “If confirmation is not a sacrament for you, why keep it at all?”
The question has real force. We confess with the Small Catechism that Baptism “works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this.”1 We teach that Baptism is the Sacrament “by which we are first received into the Christian Church.”2 If that is true, then a baptized infant is already a Christian, already a member of the body of Christ, already an heir of eternal life. What then could confirmation add? And if it adds nothing, why do Lutheran congregations still teach classes, hold examinations, and gather the congregation for a public rite?
In this paper I want to take up five questions in order: 1) What does Baptism give, and does it make a person a full member of the Church? 2) What is confirmation, and where did it come from? 3) How do Rome, the Orthodox churches, and the Church of England understand it, and why do Lutherans not count it a sacrament? 4) If God has not commanded it, what is it for? 5) What dangers attend confirmation, and how is it done well?
At each step we will listen first to Holy Scripture, then to the Lutheran Confessions, and then to the fathers of the early Church and the Reformers who help us hear Scripture rightly. We will close with what this means for us.
I. Baptism Makes Us Members of Christ’s Church
The words themselves
The companion paper Baptism and Falling Away treats at length what Baptism gives and why it saves.3 One point must be made plainly at the start. Baptism does not make a person a probationary Christian or a Christian in waiting. It makes him a member of Christ.
Paul uses two pictures for this. In Galatians he writes, “For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Galatians 3:27). The verb is endyō (“to put on, to clothe oneself”), the ordinary word for putting on a garment. In 1 Corinthians the picture is a body: “For in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body—Jews or Greeks, slaves or free—and all were made to drink of one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:13). A few verses later he says, “Now you are the body of Christ and individually members of it” (1 Corinthians 12:27). Baptism does not prepare a person to become a member of that body. It joins him to it.
What Scripture says
The Book of Acts shows the same thing in the life of the first congregation. On the Day of Pentecost Peter preached, “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off” (Acts 2:38–39). Luke then reports, “So those who received his word were baptized, and there were added that day about three thousand souls” (Acts 2:41). They were added on the day of their Baptism.
What follows is just as important for our question. “And they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:42). In other words, Baptism made them members of the Church and the Church at once began to teach them. That is the pattern of this whole paper.
Paul says the same when he describes Baptism as a death and a resurrection with Christ: “We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:4). Therefore Paul can list “one baptism” among the things that make the Church one: “one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all” (Ephesians 4:5–6).
What the Confessions say
Our Confessions say what Scripture says. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “through Baptism is offered the grace of God, and that children are to be baptized who, being offered to God through Baptism are received into God’s grace.”4 The Large Catechism begins its treatment of Baptism by calling it the Sacrament “by which we are first received into the Christian Church,” and it returns to the point at the end, where Luther speaks of “such external sign and ceremony for the Sacrament by which we are first received into the Christian Church.”5 Luther then says something that settles our question before we have even asked it: “every Christian has enough in Baptism to learn and to practise all his life; for he has always enough to do to believe firmly what it promises and brings: victory over death and the devil, forgiveness of sin, the grace of God, the entire Christ, and the Holy Ghost with His gifts.”6
The entire Christ and the Holy Ghost with His gifts are given in Baptism. This is why Luther, speaking of children in the Large Catechism’s treatment of the Lord’s Supper, can say simply, “since they are baptized and received into the Christian Church, they should also enjoy this communion of the Sacrament.”7 The baptized child is already “received into the Christian Church.” Whatever confirmation is, it cannot be the rite that makes a person a member.
II. What Is Confirmation, and Where Did It Come From?
The word
The English word comes from the Latin confirmare (“to make firm, to strengthen, to establish”). Webster’s 1828 dictionary gives eight senses of the noun. The first is “the act of confirming or establishing; a fixing, settling, establishing or making more certain or firm.” The eighth is the churchly one: “the act or ceremony of laying on of hands, in the admission of baptized person to the enjoyment of Christian privileges.” Webster adds that the person confirmed “takes upon himself the baptismal vows” and that the rite “is practiced in the Greek, Roman, and Episcopal churches.”8 The definition already contains the two ideas that have always pulled against each other in the history of this rite: 1) a strengthening given by God, and 2) a taking up of the baptismal vows by the one who was baptized.
The witness of the early Church
The New Testament knows of the laying on of hands. Our Lord “took them in his arms and blessed them, laying his hands on them” (Mark 10:16). The apostles laid hands on the seven (Acts 6:6), on the believers in Samaria (Acts 8:17), and on the disciples at Ephesus (Acts 19:6). However, the New Testament never describes a separate rite, given years after Baptism, by which baptized children are made full members of the Church.
The early Church did surround Baptism with other ceremonies. Around the year 200 Tertullian described them in order. “After this, when we have issued from the font, we are thoroughly anointed with a blessed unction,” he writes. “In the next place the hand is laid on us, invoking and inviting the Holy Spirit through benediction.”9 The anointing and the laying on of hands came immediately after the water, in the same service, as the closing ceremonies of one Baptism.
The church order known as the Apostolic Tradition, long attributed to Hippolytus of Rome, describes the same pattern in more detail in its chapters on Baptism (chapters 21–22 in the usual numbering). After the newly baptized come up from the water they are anointed by a presbyter. They then come into the assembly, where the bishop lays his hand on them with prayer, anoints and signs them on the forehead, and gives them the kiss of peace. From there they pray with the faithful for the first time and go on at once to the Eucharist.10 Some caution is needed, since recent scholarship doubts that Hippolytus wrote this document and regards it as material from several places and periods, edited over time. However, it agrees with Tertullian on the main point: the anointing and the laying on of hands belonged to the one rite of Baptism and led straight to the Lord’s Table.
Cyprian of Carthage, writing in the 250s, connected this laying on of hands with what Peter and John did in Samaria. The Samaritans, he says, “had obtained a legitimate and ecclesiastical baptism,” so they were not baptized again, “but only that which was needed was performed by Peter and John; viz., that prayer being made for them, and hands being imposed, the Holy Spirit should be invoked and poured out upon them, which now too is done among us, so that they who are baptized in the Church are brought to the prelates of the Church, and by our prayers and by the imposition of hands obtain the Holy Spirit, and are perfected with the Lord’s seal.”11
In the fourth century Cyril of Jerusalem explained the anointing to the newly baptized in the week after Easter. He told them it was no ordinary oil: “But beware of supposing this to be plain ointment. For as the Bread of the Eucharist, after the invocation of the Holy Ghost, is mere bread no longer, but the Body of Christ, so also this holy ointment is no more simple ointment, nor (so to say) common, after invocation, but it is Christ’s gift of grace.”12 Ambrose of Milan reminded his newly baptized that they had “received the seal of the Spirit; the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and strength, the spirit of knowledge and godliness, and the spirit of holy fear.”13
We should be honest that Cyprian and Cyril speak more highly of the anointing and laying on of hands than the Lutheran Confessions do. However, every one of them describes these ceremonies as part of Baptism itself, given in the same hour and followed at once by the Supper. None of them knows a rite years later for children baptized as infants. In addition, the same fathers speak of Baptism itself as giving the Spirit. Cyril opens the very lecture just quoted by telling the newly baptized, “Having been baptized into Christ, and put on Christ, you have been made conformable to the Son of God.”14 The early Church did not divide the gift of the Spirit between two sacraments separated by years.
Augustine, for his part, gave a sober account of the laying on of hands. Writing against the Donatists about the reception of those baptized outside the Church, he says that the laying on of hands “is not, like baptism, incapable of repetition; for what is it more than a prayer offered over a man?”15 That is how the Lutheran Reformers would speak of it.
How the rite became separate
How then did a ceremony at the close of Baptism become a separate rite years later? The Roman Catholic Church itself gives the answer. Its Catechism explains that “in the first centuries Confirmation generally comprised one single celebration with Baptism.” As infant Baptisms multiplied and rural parishes and dioceses grew, the bishop could not be present at every Baptism. “In the West the desire to reserve the completion of Baptism to the bishop caused the temporal separation of the two sacraments.”16 The separation arose from the practical difficulty of bringing a bishop to every font. The Eastern churches solved the same difficulty differently by allowing the priest who baptized to anoint at once, using oil consecrated by the bishop, so that Baptism, anointing, and first communion stayed together.
In the medieval West a baptized child might wait years for the bishop’s visit. Theologians came to explain the delayed rite as a strengthening for spiritual combat and an increase of the grace already given in Baptism, and by the late Middle Ages it was counted as one of seven sacraments. That is the confirmation the Reformers met.
III. Rome, the Orthodox, and Canterbury
The Roman Catholic teaching
The Council of Trent addressed confirmation in its Seventh Session (1547). Its first canon reads: “If any one saith, that the confirmation of those who have been baptized is an idle ceremony, and not rather a true and proper sacrament; or that of old it was nothing more than a kind of catechism, whereby they who were near adolescence gave an account of their faith in the face of the Church; let him be anathema.” The second canon defends the “virtue” of “the sacred chrism of confirmation,” and the third reserves the ordinary administration of confirmation to the bishop.17 The first canon aims directly at the evangelical view, which held that confirmation rightly understood was a catechism in which the young gave an account of their faith before the Church.
The present Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that “the reception of the sacrament of Confirmation is necessary for the completion of baptismal grace.” It says that confirmation “brings an increase and deepening of baptismal grace,” that it “renders our bond with the Church more perfect,” and that, like Baptism, it “imprints on the soul an indelible spiritual mark.”18 We should hear the rest of the Roman teaching just as carefully. The same Catechism says that without confirmation and the Eucharist, “Baptism is certainly valid and efficacious, but Christian initiation remains incomplete.” It also warns against calling confirmation the “sacrament of Christian maturity” in a way that would confuse adult faith with adult age, and it insists that “the baptismal grace is a grace of free, unmerited election and does not need ‘ratification’ to become effective.”19 Rome does not teach that the unconfirmed are not Christians. Where we differ is in the claim that God has attached to the chrism a grace that Baptism does not give.
The Orthodox teaching
The Orthodox churches call the rite chrismation and give it immediately after Baptism, even to infants, by the priest who baptizes, using the holy oil (myron) consecrated by the bishop. The words used at the anointing are ancient. A canon attached to the Council of Constantinople prescribes them for the reception of certain heretics: “when we seal them, we say, The Seal of the gift of the Holy Ghost.”20 The newly baptized and chrismated infant then receives Holy Communion.
There is much here that we should honor. The Orthodox have kept the unity of Baptism and its ceremonies that the early Church knew and they have never made a child’s place at the Table wait for a later rite. However, we cannot follow them in counting the chrismation a sacrament with a grace of its own, because, as we will see, Scripture gives no command and no promise for it.
The Anglican teaching
The Church of England holds a position close to our own. Article XXV of the Thirty-Nine Articles speaks of “those five commonly called Sacraments, that is to say, Confirmation, Penance, Orders, Matrimony, and extreme Unction,” which “are not to be counted for Sacraments of the Gospel,” because “they have not any visible sign or ceremony ordained of God.”21 We should be careful about how far our agreement goes. The article sets Penance and Orders aside along with confirmation, and there our own Confessions speak more freely. The Apology says that “Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance, are truly Sacraments,” and that “if ordination be understood as applying to the ministry of the Word, we are not unwilling to call ordination a sacrament.”22 On confirmation, however, the two agree.
The 1662 Book of Common Prayer explains its purpose in a preface to the rite. None is to be confirmed “but such as can say the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, and the Ten Commandments; and can also answer to such other Questions, as in the short Catechism are contained,” so that children “being now come to the years of discretion, and having learned what their Godfathers and Godmothers promised for them in Baptism, they may themselves, with their own mouth and consent, openly before the Church, ratify and confirm the same.”23 The bishop then prays to the God “who hast vouchsafed to regenerate these thy servants by Water and the Holy Ghost, and hast given unto them forgiveness of all their sins,” and he asks God to “daily increase in them thy manifold gifts of grace; the spirit of wisdom and understanding; the spirit of counsel and ghostly strength; the spirit of knowledge and true godliness” (the list Ambrose used, from Isaiah 11:2). He then lays his hand on each one, praying that God will “defend” this child “that he may continue thine for ever.”24
This is a careful rite. The prayer itself confesses that the candidates were already regenerated and forgiven in Baptism, and Cranmer’s confirmation is largely a catechetical and confessional rite, much like what the Lutheran Reformers proposed. Lutherans differ chiefly in two matters. The first is the rubric at the end: “there shall none be admitted to the holy Communion, until such time as he be confirmed, or be ready and desirous to be confirmed.”25 Lutherans have generally tied admission to the Supper to instruction and examination by the pastor, and have not made the bishop’s laying on of hands the door to the Table. The second is that the Anglican rite, by keeping confirmation for the bishop alone, preserved more of the medieval form. These are differences of order and practice, not a disagreement about whether confirmation is a sacrament of the Gospel.
Why Lutherans do not count confirmation a sacrament
The Lutheran answer begins with a definition. The Apology says, “If we call Sacraments rites which have the command of God, and to which the promise of grace has been added, it is easy to decide what are properly Sacraments… . For it does not belong to human authority to promise grace.” Then Melanchthon applies it: “Confirmation and Extreme Unction are rites received from the Fathers which not even the Church requires as necessary to salvation, because they do not have God’s command. Therefore it is not useless to distinguish these rites from the former, which have God’s express command and a clear promise of grace.”26
Confirmation is 1) received from the fathers, an ancient and honorable custom; 2) not necessary to salvation; and 3) without God’s command. Melanchthon does not forbid it. He refuses to put it alongside Baptism and the Supper.
Luther had made the same point ten years earlier in The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520). “I wonder what could have possessed them to make a sacrament of confirmation out of the laying on of hands,” he wrote. The apostles laid hands on people for many purposes, to bless, to heal, to ordain. “But we read nowhere that Christ ever gave a promise concerning confirmation.” Yet Luther did not throw the rite away. “Hence it is sufficient to regard confirmation as a certain churchly rite or sacramental ceremony, similar to other ceremonies, such as the blessing of holy water and the like.” He even wished for something better: “Would to God we had in the Church such a laying on of hands as there was in apostolic times, whether we called it confirmation or healing!”27
What about Acts 8 and 19, where the Spirit comes when the apostles lay on hands? In both places the Spirit’s coming is marked by visible, extraordinary gifts. At Ephesus “the Holy Spirit came on them, and they began speaking in tongues and prophesying” (Acts 19:6). In Samaria Simon the sorcerer “saw that the Spirit was given through the laying on of the apostles’ hands” and tried to buy the power (Acts 8:18–19). Luke is describing the apostles’ own ministry at turning points in the spread of the Gospel. He gives no command that every baptized person must receive a second rite and he attaches no promise to any later laying on of hands by anyone else. Augustine himself observed that the Spirit is no longer given “amid the testimony of temporal sensible miracles” as in those first days.28 Hebrews 6:2 names “the laying on of hands” among the elementary doctrines but gives no instruction about what the rite is or who must receive it.
Therefore confirmation falls under the “rites or ceremonies, instituted by men,” about which the Augsburg Confession says it is not necessary “that human traditions … should be everywhere alike.”29 Article XV adds the rule for all such usages: “those ought to be observed which may be observed without sin, and which are profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church,” but “concerning such things men are admonished that consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation.”30 Confirmation belongs here. It is a good order of the Church and it may be kept with a clear conscience, but it may not be made necessary for salvation or allowed to take anything away from Baptism.
IV. Why Lutherans Confirm Anyway
If confirmation is not a sacrament and adds nothing to Baptism, why keep it? The Lutheran Church keeps it not for the sake of the ceremony but for the sake of three goods the rite serves, which rest on God’s commands to teach, to confess, and to examine oneself. Confirmation is one good way to serve them, though not the only way, and a parent who has taught his child the faith has not disobeyed God because the rite was missed.
1) Teaching is commanded, in the home and in the congregation
The Great Commission joins teaching to Baptism in a single sentence. “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you” (Matthew 28:19–20). The main verb is mathēteusate (“make disciples”). The two participles baptizontes (“baptizing”) and didaskontes (“teaching”) tell how disciples are made. A disciple (mathētēs, “learner, pupil”) is someone who is being taught. Baptism makes the disciple and teaching follows for the rest of his life.
This did not begin with the New Testament. Moses commanded Israel, “These words that I command you today shall be on your heart. You shall teach them diligently to your children, and shall talk of them when you sit in your house, and when you walk by the way, and when you lie down, and when you rise” (Deuteronomy 6:6–7). Paul tells fathers to “bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord” (Ephesians 6:4). He urges Timothy to “continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed, knowing from whom you learned it and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings, which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus” (2 Timothy 3:14–15).
The word catechism itself comes from the Greek katēcheō (“to instruct by word of mouth”). Luke wrote his Gospel so that Theophilus might know the certainty of the things he had been taught (katēchēthēs, Luke 1:4), and Paul uses the same verb for the one who receives instruction and the one who gives it (Galatians 6:6).31 Webster defines a catechism as “a form of instruction by means of questions and answers, particularly in the principles of religion.”32
When a deacon of Carthage named Deogratias wrote to Augustine for help in teaching beginners, Augustine sent him a whole treatise. He told him to tell the story of salvation from creation to the present day of the Church and to keep the love of God in Christ at its center. “Take this love, therefore, as the end that is set before you, to which you are to refer all that you say, and, whatever you narrate, narrate it in such a manner that he to whom you are discoursing on hearing may believe, on believing may hope, on hoping may love.”33
The Small Catechism exists because Luther found the baptized untaught. His preface describes what he saw on the Saxon visitation of 1528: “Nevertheless, all maintain that they are Christians, have been baptized and receive the [common] holy Sacraments. Yet they … cannot … recite either the Lord’s Prayer, or the Creed, or the Ten Commandments.”34 They were baptized and they were communing but they had not been taught. Luther did not answer by doubting their Baptism. He answered by teaching them. He begged his fellow pastors “to have pity on the people who are entrusted to you, and to help us inculcate the Catechism upon the people, and especially upon the young.”35
Luther placed the first duty in the home. Each chief part of the Small Catechism carries a heading such as “As the head of the family should teach them in a simple way to his household.”36 The Large Catechism says the same in its Short Preface: “it is the duty of every father of a family to question and examine his children and servants at least once a week and to ascertain what they know of it, or are learning, and, if they do not know it, to keep them faithfully at it.”37 At the end of his treatment of the Supper he repeats it: “let every father of a family know that it is his duty, by the injunction and command of God, to teach these things to his children, or have them learn what they ought to know.”38
The congregation and its pastor share that charge. The same Short Preface calls the catechism “instruction for children,” containing “what every Christian must needs know,” and it asks that the young “attend the preaching, especially during the time which is devoted to the Catechism, that they may hear it explained.”39 The confirmation class, then, is the congregation doing its part of what parents and pastor were both told to do. It does not replace the home. It supports what the home has begun and fills in where the home has not been able to teach.
When a child is brought to the font the Church receives him as a member and takes on the duty to teach him, with his parents and sponsors. Confirmation instruction is the Church keeping its side of that promise.
2) The baptized confess the faith with their own mouths
Scripture joins faith in the heart to confession with the mouth. “If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved” (Romans 10:9–10). Our Lord says, “Everyone who acknowledges me before men, I also will acknowledge before my Father who is in heaven” (Matthew 10:32). Paul reminds Timothy of the day he “made the good confession in the presence of many witnesses” (1 Timothy 6:12).
When an infant is baptized, the confession of faith is spoken on his behalf by sponsors and parents. That confession is truly his, because the faith it confesses is the faith into which he was baptized. However, it is fitting that a child who has been taught should one day speak the same confession with his own mouth, before the same congregation that received him at the font. This is what the Anglican preface means by “with their own mouth and consent, openly before the Church,” and it is the reason the Pietist Philipp Jakob Spener gave for keeping confirmation: because the infant could not speak the promise himself and another spoke it for him, it is fitting for both the child and the Church that it be spoken publicly.40
The confession made at confirmation does not complete Baptism or make it valid. A baptized child who dies before confirmation dies a Christian. In other words, the child confesses the faith because he has been given it and not the other way around.
3) The baptized are prepared for the Lord’s Supper
Paul writes, “Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself” (1 Corinthians 11:28–29). The Small Catechism asks, “Who, then, receives such Sacrament worthily?” and answers, “Fasting and bodily preparation is, indeed, a fine outward training; but he is truly worthy and well prepared who has faith in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins.”41 The Large Catechism adds that the words of institution are words “which every one who desires to be a Christian and go to the Sacrament should know. For it is not our intention to admit to it and to administer it to those who know not what they seek, or why they come.”42
God commands each communicant to examine himself. The examination of communicants by the pastor is not a divine command but the Church’s practice, a good one that helps the communicant keep the command he has been given. The Lutheran Reformers inherited that practice and cleansed it of the burden of listing every sin. The Augsburg Confession says plainly, “Confession in the churches is not abolished among us; for it is not usual to give the body of the Lord, except to them that have been previously examined and absolved.” In the article on the Mass it says, “For none are admitted except they be first examined.”43 The Apology says the same.44 Luther himself, in his Formula of Mass of 1523, asked that those who wished to commune give an account of what they believed about the Sacrament before they came.45
This is why Lutheran confirmation has so often been joined to first communion in practice, though never in doctrine. The examination of the young is the same examination our Confessions describe for every communicant, given for the first time. What makes a person ready for the Table is not age but faith in Christ’s words, and neither Scripture nor the Confessions appoint a day. Confirmation serves the Supper and the Supper does not serve confirmation.
How old must a child be before he is examined and admitted? That question deserves its own treatment and receives it in the companion paper Infant Faith and the Lord’s Table. In the sixteenth century children were often admitted around the age of twelve or younger and no single age was required.46 Lutherans in North America have in recent decades separated first communion from the rite of confirmation in many places, admitting children to the Table after instruction and confirming them later. The principle in every case is the one Paul gives, that each communicant examine himself and discern the body. The examination is the Church’s way of teaching toward the Table and not a test that the Lord’s own may fail by sickness or disability, as the companion paper also explains in speaking of the aged and the disabled.
V. How Lutherans Have Confirmed
Luther’s examination
Luther never wrote a rite of confirmation. He urged instead the examination of communicants, as in the Formula of Mass (1523). In a Lenten sermon of March 15, 1523, he is reported to have said that confirmation should not be held as the bishops wanted it, though he would not find fault if every pastor examined the faith of the children to see whether it was good and sincere, laid hands on them, and confirmed them.47 (The authenticity of the sentence has been questioned, though it fits what Luther says elsewhere.) The emphasis falls on the examination of faith and Luther nowhere claims that the laying on of hands conveys a gift that Baptism lacks.
Bucer and the Ziegenhain Order
The first public rite of evangelical confirmation came not from Wittenberg but from Strasbourg. In 1539 Landgrave Philip of Hesse asked Martin Bucer for help with the Anabaptists in his territory, who charged that the churches baptized infants and never called them to a personal faith or a disciplined life. Bucer’s answer was the Ziegenhain Order of Church Discipline (1539). Under that order children who had been catechized were presented by their pastor before the congregation. They made a public confession of faith, pledged themselves to Christ and to the discipline of the Church, and received the laying on of hands with prayer. Then they were admitted to the Lord’s Supper.48
Bucer’s rite took catechesis seriously and answered the Anabaptist charge that infant Baptism produced nominal Christians. However, by attaching the gift of the Spirit and admission to the full life of the congregation to the laying on of hands, it could suggest that something was missing in Baptism until the confirmand had promised to live under discipline.
Melanchthon and Chemnitz
Melanchthon, who wrote the Apology’s sentence on confirmation, spoke of the rite in later editions of his Loci Communes as a useful custom consisting of the examination of the young in doctrine, their confession of faith, and prayer for them with the laying on of hands.49 For Melanchthon it was an adiaphoron (“a thing indifferent,” neither commanded nor forbidden) and a good one.
The fullest Lutheran account came from Martin Chemnitz in his Examination of the Council of Trent. Chemnitz answered Trent’s first canon on confirmation by describing a godly confirmation in six parts. 1) The baptized child, having come to the years of discretion and having been instructed, is brought before the congregation and reminded briefly of his Baptism: that he was baptized, how and into what, and what the Triune God gave and promised him there, including the covenant of grace, the renunciation of Satan, and the confession of faith. 2) The child makes his own public profession of this doctrine and faith. 3) He is questioned on the chief parts of Christian doctrine and answers, and if he does not understand some part he is better instructed. 4) He is reminded that this confession requires him to renounce all heathen, heretical, fanatical, and ungodly opinions. 5) He is earnestly admonished from the Word of God to remain in his baptismal covenant and in this doctrine and faith, to grow in them, and to show them by his life. 6) Public prayer is made for him, that God by His Holy Spirit would govern, preserve, and strengthen him in this confession, and to that prayer the laying on of hands may be added without superstition. Chemnitz adds that such a prayer is not in vain, because it rests on God’s promises concerning the gift of perseverance.50
Every part of Chemnitz’s rite points back to Baptism. The child is reminded of what God gave him, confesses what he was baptized into, and is prayed for that he may remain in it. Nothing in it claims to add to Baptism a gift it lacked. This is the classic Lutheran pattern.
Pietism and after
During the age of Lutheran Orthodoxy confirmation was used in some territories and not in others. Around 1700 it became nearly universal in the German Lutheran lands and the Pietist movement had much to do with that, although it did not invent the rite. Philipp Jakob Spener, who introduced confirmation in Frankfurt and promoted it widely, held that it was not a sacrament but a useful and edifying ceremony to be used in Christian freedom.51 The Pietists brought a deep concern for the instruction of the young, for prayer, and for a living faith. However, Pietism also moved the center of the rite. Confirmation became more and more a renewal of the baptismal covenant by the confirmand, with the weight resting on his vow and on the sincerity of his heart. The Rationalists of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries moved it again, toward an intellectual mastery of doctrine and a ceremony of coming of age.
Historians have tried to sort this variety into types. The classic list, which Arthur Repp gave in his standard study for American Lutherans, names four types in the sixteenth century: the catechetical (Luther’s examination for the Supper), the hierarchical (Bucer’s public rite tied to church discipline and membership), the sacramental (in which the laying on of hands was held to convey the Spirit), and the traditional (which kept more of the medieval form, as in the Brandenburg church order of 1540). To these Repp adds two later types, the pietistic and the rationalistic.52 Repp himself warned that “one of the most striking features of the 16th-century development of confirmation and preparation for the first Communion is the almost total lack of uniformity.”53 More recent scholarship has questioned whether the types were ever as distinct as the list suggests and has found that most sixteenth-century orders shared the same basic elements: catechetical instruction, a confession of faith, prayer for the children, and admission to first communion.54
The affirmation of Baptism
In the twentieth century the Lutheran Book of Worship (1978) placed confirmation under a general rite called “Affirmation of Baptism,” which may also be used when members are received from other congregations or return after a time away. The name itself is good Lutheran theology. Confirmation affirms what God has already done in Baptism. It does not supply what Baptism left undone. As one Lutheran theologian put it, confirmation may be kept “so long as neither the instruction nor the rite conveys the impression that what was once potential (in baptism) is now actual (in confirmation).”55
VI. The Dangers
Confirmation as graduation
For many young people, and sometimes for their parents, confirmation has become a graduation. The class is completed, the certificate is signed, the family celebrates, and the confirmand is seldom seen again. A confirmation that ends a young person’s life in the congregation has done the opposite of what it was meant to do.
Luther saw the same attitude among adults of his own day, who read the Catechism once and then threw “the book into a corner.” Against them he set his own example: “I am also a doctor and preacher … yet I do as a child who is being taught the Catechism, and every morning, and whenever I have time, I read and say, word for word, the Ten Commandments, the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, the Psalms, etc. And I must still read and study daily, and yet I cannot master it as I wish, but must remain a child and pupil of the Catechism, and am glad so to remain.”56 If the Reformer remained a pupil of the Catechism all his life, then no confirmand has graduated from it at fourteen.
The goal of the Church’s teaching is that “we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine” (Ephesians 4:14). That maturity comes through a lifetime of hearing the Word, receiving the Supper, and praying with the people of God, as the first Christians did after their Baptism (Acts 2:42). Confirmation is the beginning of adult life in the congregation and not the end of the Church’s teaching.
Confirmation as a second, better Baptism
The second danger is more serious because it touches the Gospel. It is the assumption that confirmation is the real thing and Baptism only a preliminary. People speak of being “confirmed into the church” or “becoming a full member” at confirmation. Some think of confirmation as the moment when a child’s faith becomes his own, as though the faith given in Baptism belonged to someone else. In the Pietist form of the rite the danger takes the shape of the confirmand’s vow. When the weight of the day rests on his promise to be faithful, the comfort of God’s promise in Baptism can be pushed to the side.
Against all this we must say what Scripture and the Confessions say. Baptism gives “the entire Christ, and the Holy Ghost with His gifts.”57 The baptized child “put on Christ” at the font (Galatians 3:27). He was “baptized into one body” (1 Corinthians 12:13). There is “one baptism” (Ephesians 4:5) and there is no second one. The confirmand’s promises are good and serious. However, they are a response to God’s promise and not a foundation beside it. The Affirmation of Baptism in Evangelical Lutheran Worship has the right shape: asked whether he intends to continue in the covenant God made with him in Holy Baptism, the confirmand answers, “I do, and I ask God to help and guide me.”58 That is a confession leaning on God’s help and not a vow that holds up his standing before God. A young person will break his confirmation vows, as all of us have broken ours. When he does, he will not find comfort in what he promised at fourteen but in what God promised him at the font.
Other dangers
There are lesser dangers as well. Confirmation can become a merely intellectual exercise in which memorizing answers is mistaken for faith, a family custom kept because grandparents expect it, or a requirement used to sort people into first-class and second-class Christians. Many congregational constitutions speak of “confirmed members” and tie voting and office to that membership. That is good order for adult responsibilities in the congregation and not a ranking before God, for every baptized child is a member of Christ’s body. Each of these dangers is answered the same way, by teaching that confirmation serves Baptism and the Supper and has no worth apart from them. We should also not overcorrect. Some have argued that because confirmation is not commanded it should be abolished. Our Confessions do not take that position. The Apology calls it a rite “received from the Fathers,” and Article XV permits such rites as “profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church.”59 Chemnitz, writing against Trent, did not ask Lutherans to give up confirmation but to do it rightly.
Conclusion: What This Means for Us
Let me gather up what we have heard.
-
Baptism makes us members of Christ’s Church. It clothes us with Christ, joins us to His body, and gives the entire Christ and the Holy Spirit with His gifts.
-
Confirmation is not a sacrament. It has neither God’s command nor a promise of grace. The ceremonies the early Church practiced after Baptism belonged to Baptism itself and the separate rite grew up in the West for practical reasons.
-
Rome and the Orthodox count confirmation (or chrismation) a sacrament. The Church of England does not, and on confirmation Lutherans agree with Article XXV, though our Confessions do not refuse the name of Sacrament to Absolution or to ordination rightly understood. We honor what is good in Roman and Orthodox practice without accepting that God has bound a grace to it.
-
Lutherans confirm anyway because the rite serves three things God has commanded: the teaching of the baptized in the home and in the congregation, the confession of the faith with one’s own mouth, and the self-examination of those who come to the Lord’s Supper. Confirmation is one good way to serve them, though not the only way.
-
Confirmation is done well when it points back to Baptism and forward to the Supper. It is done badly when it becomes a graduation or a second, better Baptism.
What does this mean for us? It means, first, that confirmation is the Church keeping its baptismal promise. When a child was brought to the font, the congregation received him and promised, with his parents and sponsors, to teach him. The confirmation class is that promise being kept. Parents should see it that way, not as one more activity on the calendar but as part of what they promised at the font. Congregations should support the pastor and the parents in it with their prayers and their example.
It means, second, something for those being confirmed. You became a Christian and a member of the Church at the font, on the day of your Baptism. What you are doing is learning what God gave you there and confessing it with your own mouth before the people who have watched you grow. When you kneel and the pastor prays over you, the Church is praying what Chemnitz said such a prayer should ask: that God by His Holy Spirit would govern, preserve, and strengthen you in this confession. That prayer rests on God’s promise and it is not in vain.
It means, third, something for adults. Some who read these words were confirmed long ago and remember little of it. Some were never confirmed at all. Your Baptism is enough. If you have never been instructed in the Catechism, or if what you learned has faded, there is no shame in learning it now. If you have wandered from the faith since your confirmation, the companion paper Baptism and Falling Away speaks to you: the way back is not a new rite but a return, in repentance and faith, to the Baptism that has been waiting for you all along.
Lastly, it means that the catechism is for all of life. “Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom” (Colossians 3:16). The Ten Commandments, the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, Baptism, Confession, and the Supper are not lessons we finish and set aside. Luther says that “every Christian has enough in Baptism to learn and to practise all his life.”60 Confirmation is one good and joyful day in that life of learning.
God began a good work in us at the font and He has not stopped. Our confirmation did not finish it and our failures since have not undone it. “And I am sure of this, that he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 1:6).
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Ev. Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (English text at bookofconcord.org.) (Especially: Augsburg Confession VII, IX, XV, XXIV, and XXV; Apology XIII and XXIV; Small Catechism, Preface, Baptism, and the Sacrament of the Altar; Large Catechism, Prefaces, Baptism, and the Sacrament of the Altar.)
The Early Church
- Tertullian. On Baptism. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
- Cyprian. Epistle 72 (73), To Jubaianus. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5.
- The Apostolic Tradition. In Paul F. Bradshaw, Maxwell E. Johnson, and L. Edward Phillips, The Apostolic Tradition: A Commentary. Hermeneia. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2002.
- Cyril of Jerusalem. Mystagogical Catecheses. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 7.
- Ambrose. On the Mysteries. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 10.
- First Council of Constantinople. Canons. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 14.
- Augustine. On the Catechising of the Uninstructed. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 3.
- Augustine. On Baptism, Against the Donatists. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 4.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520). Translated by A. T. W. Steinhaeuser. In Works of Martin Luther, vol. 2. Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1915. Also in Luther’s Works, vol. 36. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
- Luther, Martin. An Order of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (1523). In Luther’s Works, vol. 53. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1965.
- Luther, Martin. D. Martin Luthers Werke: Kritische Gesamtausgabe. Vol. 11. Weimar: Böhlau, 1900.
- Chemnitz, Martin. Examination of the Council of Trent. Translated by Fred Kramer. Vol. 2. St. Louis: Concordia, 1978.
- Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent. Translated by J. Waterworth. London: Dolman, 1848.
- The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (1571).
- The Book of Common Prayer (1662).
- Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997.
History of Confirmation
- Burnett, Amy Nelson. The Yoke of Christ: Martin Bucer and Christian Discipline. Kirksville, MO: Sixteenth Century Journal Publishers, 1994.
- Heinilä, Kimmo. Konfirmaatio ja vahvistaminen: Luterilaiset konfirmaatiokäytännöt ja -käsitykset vahvistamisen näkökulmasta reformaatiosta 2000-luvun alkuun. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2019. (English abstract.)
- Lull, Timothy F. “Confirmation: The Theological Issues for Lutherans.” Word & World 11, no. 4 (1991): 362–368.
- Repp, Arthur C. Confirmation in the Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1964.
- Rietschel, Georg, and Paul Graff. Lehrbuch der Liturgik. 2nd ed. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1951–1952.
- Lutheran Book of Worship. Minneapolis: Augsburg; Philadelphia: Board of Publication, Lutheran Church in America, 1978.
- Evangelical Lutheran Worship. Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 2006.
Reference
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.
Footnotes
-
SC IV, Second Part. ↩
-
LC IV 2. ↩
-
See especially Part I of Baptism and Falling Away, “Does Baptism Really Save?” ↩
-
AC IX 1–2. ↩
-
LC IV 2, 64. ↩
-
LC IV 41. ↩
-
LC V 87. ↩
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “confirmation,” senses 1 and 8. ↩
-
Tertullian, On Baptism 7–8, ANF, vol. 3. ↩
-
The Apostolic Tradition 21–22. See Paul F. Bradshaw, Maxwell E. Johnson, and L. Edward Phillips, The Apostolic Tradition: A Commentary, Hermeneia (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2002), which sets out the textual witnesses and gives the case against Hippolytan authorship and a single date of composition. ↩
-
Cyprian, Epistle 72 (73), To Jubaianus 9, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 3.3 (Catechetical Lectures 21.3), NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
Ambrose, On the Mysteries 7.42, NPNF², vol. 10. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 3.1 (Catechetical Lectures 21.1), NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
Augustine, On Baptism, Against the Donatists III.16.21, NPNF¹, vol. 4. The context is the reconciliation of those baptized among the Donatists. ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997), §1290. ↩
-
Council of Trent, Session VII (1547), On Confirmation, Canons 1–3, trans. J. Waterworth (London: Dolman, 1848). ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§1285, 1303, 1304. ↩
-
Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§1306, 1308. ↩
-
First Council of Constantinople, Canon 7, NPNF², vol. 14. Scholars date this canon somewhat later than 381, though the formula itself is old. On the Eastern practice, compare Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§1289–1290, 1292. ↩
-
The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (1571), Article XXV, “Of the Sacraments.” ↩
-
Ap XIII 4, 11. ↩
-
The Book of Common Prayer (1662), “The Order of Confirmation,” preface. ↩
-
The Book of Common Prayer (1662), “The Order of Confirmation.” ↩
-
The Book of Common Prayer (1662), “The Order of Confirmation,” final rubric. ↩
-
Ap XIII 3, 6. ↩
-
Luther, The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), 5.1–5.3, trans. A. T. W. Steinhaeuser, in Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1915), vol. 2; Project Wittenberg edition. Compare LW 36:91–92. ↩
-
Augustine, On Baptism, Against the Donatists III.16.21, NPNF¹, vol. 4. ↩
-
AC VII 3. ↩
-
AC XV 1–2. ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. κατηχέω, μαθητεύω, and μαθητής. ↩
-
Webster (1828), s.v. “catechism.” ↩
-
Augustine, On the Catechising of the Uninstructed 4.8, NPNF¹, vol. 3. On the full narration from creation to the present times of the Church, see 3.5 and 6.10. ↩
-
SC Preface 3. ↩
-
SC Preface 6. Compare SC Preface 11, where Luther says that those unwilling to learn the Catechism should not “be admitted to the Sacrament.” ↩
-
SC I, heading. The same heading stands over the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, Baptism, and the Sacrament of the Altar. ↩
-
LC Short Preface 4. ↩
-
LC V 87. ↩
-
LC Short Preface 1–2, 26. ↩
-
On Spener’s reasoning, see Georg Rietschel and Paul Graff, Lehrbuch der Liturgik, 2nd ed. (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1951–1952), 651–652; and Arthur C. Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church (St. Louis: Concordia, 1964), 68–70. ↩
-
SC, The Sacrament of the Altar, fourth question. ↩
-
LC V 2. ↩
-
AC XXV 1; AC XXIV 6. ↩
-
Ap XXIV 1, 49. ↩
-
Luther, An Order of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (Formula Missae, 1523), LW 53. ↩
-
Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church, summarizing the sixteenth-century church orders. ↩
-
Luther, Sermon for Laetare Sunday, March 15, 1523, WA 11:66. Compare Kimmo Heinilä, Konfirmaatio ja vahvistaminen (Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2019), 58, who notes that the authenticity of the sentence has been doubted. ↩
-
Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church, 30–31, 36–37. On the Hessian orders of 1539 (Ziegenhain and Kassel), see also Amy Nelson Burnett, The Yoke of Christ: Martin Bucer and Christian Discipline (Kirksville, MO: Sixteenth Century Journal Publishers, 1994). ↩
-
Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church, 47–48. Compare Ap XIII 6, which Melanchthon also wrote. ↩
-
Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, trans. Fred Kramer, vol. 2 (St. Louis: Concordia, 1978), 211–213, on Session VII, Concerning Confirmation. ↩
-
Rietschel and Graff, Lehrbuch der Liturgik, 651; Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church, 68–70. On the spread of the rite around 1700 and the Pietist contribution to it, see Heinilä, Konfirmaatio ja vahvistaminen, 98–100. ↩
-
Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church, 22, 44–55. The older three-part classification (catechetical, hierarchical, sacramental) goes back to nineteenth-century German scholarship; Repp added the traditional type. ↩
-
Repp, Confirmation in the Lutheran Church, 55. ↩
-
Heinilä, Konfirmaatio ja vahvistaminen, English abstract and 43–44. ↩
-
Timothy F. Lull, “Confirmation: The Theological Issues for Lutherans,” Word & World 11, no. 4 (1991): 365. ↩
-
LC Longer Preface 5, 7–8. ↩
-
LC IV 41. ↩
-
Evangelical Lutheran Worship (Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 2006), Affirmation of Baptism, 236. ↩
-
Ap XIII 6; AC XV 1. ↩
-
LC IV 41. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Baptism and Confirmation: Why Lutherans Confirm Those Already Baptized.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/baptism-and-confirmation/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.