Books · Women and the Pastoral Office
The Reformation Inheritance — Luther, Calvin, and the Protestant Orthodox Tradition
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Presenting the Argument
Martin Luther
Martin Luther’s understanding of the orders of ministry is thoroughly complementarian. In his commentary on Genesis, Luther writes: “Moses makes mention of the female sex only as being added to the male, and as being created not for herself, but for man, and for this purpose: to be a companion and helper of the man.”⁴⁰ More specifically, in his treatment of the office of ministry (Predigtamt — the preaching office), Luther understands the ordained preacher as the bearer of the divine word in a publicly authoritative capacity. While Luther emphasizes the priesthood of all believers, he is equally emphatic that the public office of preaching and sacramental administration is restricted to those called and ordained by the church — and the church has always restricted this to men.
Luther’s commentary on 1 Timothy 2:11–12 makes his position explicit: “He shows that women shall not preach in the congregation where men are present who are endowed with the gift of teaching… This is the order of creation, that the woman shall be under the man and be silent.”⁴¹ In other words, for Luther, the restriction on women’s ordination is not a concession to culture; it is a theological application of the created order.
John Calvin
Calvin’s position on women’s ordination is unambiguous and theologically grounded. In his commentary on 1 Corinthians 14:34, Calvin writes: “Paul’s injunction is that women shall not be permitted to speak in the assembly… This is not a law of men or human custom but of God himself; and it is universal and perpetual.”⁴² Calvin explicitly distinguishes the universal prohibition from a merely cultural or local custom, insisting that it reflects a divine ordinance rooted in the creation order.
In his commentary on 1 Timothy 2:11–15, Calvin writes at length on the creation-order grounding: “He assigns two reasons why women ought to be subject to men: because not only did God enact this law at the beginning, but He also inflicted it on woman as a punishment when she had sinned… Let the man, therefore, perform the duty of the head in governing the woman.”⁴³
The Westminster Standards and the Reformed Tradition
The Westminster Confession of Faith (1647) and the Augsburg Confession (1530) alike presuppose male-only ordination, though neither explicitly addresses the question. The historic Reformed and Lutheran confessions, without exception, were formulated with the assumption that ordained ministry is restricted to men. That is to say, the burden of proof lies with those who would deviate from this universal confessional heritage.
The Reformers’ Continuity with the Patristic Tradition
It is worth pausing to notice that Luther and Calvin, despite their polemical criticism of medieval Catholicism on many points, maintained complete continuity with the catholic tradition on the question of women’s ordination. The Reformation’s principle of sola Scriptura (Scripture alone) did not lead the Reformers to question the traditional position; it led them to confirm it. This continuity is itself theologically significant.
⁴⁰ Martin Luther, Table Talk, WATR 1:197, cited in Susan C. Karant-Nunn and Merry E. Wiesner-Hanks, eds., Luther on Women: A Sourcebook (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003), 30. ⁴¹ Luther, Lectures on 1 Timothy, in Luther’s Works, vol. 28, 276–277. ⁴² Calvin, Commentary on the First Epistle to the Corinthians, 468. ⁴³ Calvin, Commentaries on the Epistles to Timothy, Titus, and Philemon, 67–68.
Refutation of the Argument
The Reformers Were Children of Their Time
The egalitarian response to the Reformation inheritance typically follows the same trajectory as the response to the patristic consensus: Luther and Calvin were men of the sixteenth century, shaped by patriarchal social assumptions that they read uncritically back into Scripture. Moreover, egalitarians argue, the Reformers changed the church on many fronts — rejecting sacerdotalism, mandatory celibacy for clergy, purgatory, and much of the medieval sacramental system — on the grounds of Scripture. If they had read Scripture with truly fresh eyes on the question of gender, they might well have reached different conclusions.
The Reformation’s Implicit Egalitarian Logic
Some egalitarian theologians argue that the Reformation’s own theological principles — the priesthood of all believers, the primacy of Scripture, the rejection of unbiblical tradition — contain an implicit logic that points toward women’s ordination, even if the Reformers themselves did not follow this logic to its conclusion. On this view, the Reformation was an unfinished work, and the ordination of women represents the faithful application of Reformation principles to a question the Reformers did not fully address.⁴⁴
⁴⁴ Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza, In Memory of Her: A Feminist Theological Reconstruction of Christian Origins (New York: Crossroad, 1983), 33–34.
Rebuttal
Rebuttal of the Cultural Conditioning Argument Applied to the Reformers
The claim that Luther and Calvin simply absorbed their cultural assumptions without critical examination is contradicted by their actual practice. The Reformers challenged centuries of tradition on justification by faith, the nature of the sacraments, the authority of the pope, the veneration of saints, the existence of purgatory, and dozens of other issues — often at enormous personal cost. These were not men who accepted inherited positions uncritically.
Their maintenance of the traditional position on women’s ordination was therefore a positive choice — a deliberate decision that the biblical and patristic testimony supported the traditional practice. To dismiss their position as cultural conditioning is to make a claim not supported by the evidence of their actual exegetical and theological method.
Rebuttal of the “Unfinished Reformation” Argument
The argument that Reformation principles logically entail women’s ordination, even if the Reformers did not see this, requires demonstration rather than assertion. One must show, from Scripture and theological reasoning, that the principle of the priesthood of all believers, properly understood, entails the eligibility of women for the ordained ministry. But the Reformers themselves were explicit that this doctrine does not entail the eligibility of all believers for the public, ordained ministry. Luther distinguishes sharply between the universal spiritual priesthood (which women share fully) and the public office of ministry (which requires ordination by the church and is restricted to men). The distinction is internally consistent, not an unresolved contradiction.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.