Books · Women and the Pastoral Office

A Final Word from the Author: A Pastoral Letter to the Reader

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Dear friend,

If you have read this far, I want to speak to you plainly — not as a scholar wrapping up a final footnote, but as a pastor who knows that ideas carry weight, and that weight is felt first in the heart before the mind has had time to process it.

I know this has not been easy reading for everyone who picked it up. Some of you came to it already persuaded of its conclusions and found here a confirmation of what you had long believed. But others of you came with genuine questions — or with wounds. You may be a woman who has felt the undeniable pull of a calling — a deep, persistent sense that God was drawing you toward preaching, toward leading, toward shepherding his people. You may have given years of faithful service to the church, only to find your gifts constrained by a boundary you did not choose and may not fully understand. If that describes you, I want you to know that I see that. And I want to say, as gently and as honestly as I can: your pain is real, and it deserves to be honored, not dismissed.

The church has not always handled this well. There have been men who cited Scripture with coldness where warmth was needed, who wielded the text like a blunt instrument rather than a surgeon’s tool, who were more concerned with winning an argument than with the person sitting across from them. If you have been on the receiving end of that kind of theology — theology without tenderness — then I am sorry. That is not the spirit in which these arguments are offered, and it is not the spirit in which they ought to be received.

But I also want to be honest with you, because I believe you deserve honesty more than you deserve comfort that does not hold.

We live in a world that has made self-expression the highest good — a world that tells us the deepest longings of the human heart are the most reliable guide to what is right and true. That world tells us that if something feels like a calling, it must be one; that if a door is closed to us, the closing is necessarily unjust; that the accumulated wisdom of Scripture, the fathers, and the Reformers must yield to the felt experience of the present moment. I understand why that vision is appealing. I also believe it is deeply mistaken — and that the church has paid a heavy price for accepting it.

The Christian life has never promised that obedience would be painless. It has promised something far more costly and far more glorious: that in the surrender of our own designs to the will of God, we find not the diminishment of our humanity but its completion. The Son of God himself, co-equal with the Father in every divine perfection, submitted to the Father’s will — not because he was less than the Father, but because love, rightly ordered, gives itself freely within the structure of its relationships. That pattern runs through all of Scripture. It runs through marriage, through the church, through the very architecture of creation itself.

That is the vision this book has labored to set before you — not a vision of hierarchy for hierarchy’s sake, or of tradition for tradition’s sake, but of a created order that reflects the beauty of the Triune God, in which differentiation and equality coexist without contradiction, in which to receive one’s particular place and vocation from the hand of God is not a defeat but a freedom.

I know that does not make the surrender easy. I will not pretend that it does.

What I ask of you — what Scripture asks of you, what the great cloud of witnesses across the centuries asks of you — is this: bring your questions and your pain honestly before God. Do not suppress them, and do not let anyone tell you they are unspiritual. But bring them to the Word. Sit with the texts long enough that they cease to be obstacles and become, instead, windows. Read the fathers not as adversaries but as brothers and sisters who loved Christ before us — and who paid, in many cases, far higher prices than we have for their faithfulness to him. Ask, with open hands, whether the shape of the life that Scripture describes might be — even in its constraints, even in its surrenders — a more beautiful and more fully human life than the one the world is offering you.

I believe it is. I have staked my own life and ministry on that belief, and I offer this book as one small piece of evidence for it.

We need women in the church — not in spite of this argument but because of it. We need women who teach, who disciple, who pray, who counsel, who suffer, who lead in the myriad ways that Scripture celebrates and history confirms. The women of the New Testament were not auxiliary figures; they were witnesses, patrons, prophets, and co-laborers in the gospel. The argument of this book does not diminish that witness. It seeks, rather, to honor it by insisting that the church receive its ordering from its Lord — the One who loved the women who followed him, and who calls all of us, in our particular vocations, to the same costly and joyful obedience.

May God grant us all the grace to follow where he leads — even, and especially, when the path is not the one we would have chosen for ourselves.

In Christ, with hope and with love,

Dylan MacDonald

Topics
Vocation and Daily Life

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.