Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 17—Article XVII: The Return of Christ to Judgment

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Stand for a moment beside an open grave. The charts and timelines that fill so many Christian bookshelves have nothing to say there, because they were never able to help at a moment like this. What helps is a promise the church has confessed for two thousand years, in words a grieving family can hold: I believe in the resurrection of the body, and the life everlasting. He will come again. Behind the creed stands the word Jesus spoke to a grieving sister on the way to her brother’s tomb: “I am the resurrection and the life. Whoever believes in me, though he die, yet shall he live” (John 11:25, ESV).

That is where this chapter begins, because the hope Article XVII confesses is the hope spoken at a grave. For all that has been written about the “end times” (the prophecy charts, the confident predictions that always fail, the novels and the conferences), the Augsburg Confession says something simple and short. At the end of the world Christ will come again, He will raise the dead, and He will judge. That is nearly the whole of it, and it is nearly all in the language of the creed you already know: “he will come again to judge the living and the dead… I look for the resurrection of the dead, and the life of the world to come.”

This chapter, then, is not the chapter about Revelation, or the millennium, or the rapture; it is the chapter about Christian hope. That hope is not, finally, a timeline to be decoded. The Christian’s hope is the returning Christ who has already redeemed us, the same crucified and risen Lord, coming again to finish what He began. This chapter completes the one before it. Article XVI taught us to serve our neighbor faithfully in this present, passing world (chapter 16), and Article XVII tells us why we can: we serve faithfully in this passing world because we belong to the coming Kingdom. The whole movement of the chapter is from fear of the end to longing for the One who comes. Many readers come to it with one question above all, the question of what happens to those we love when they die, and the Bible’s answer to it is given in §5.


1. What the Article Says

What does the Augsburg Confession say about the end of the world? Why does it say so little, and why does it condemn anyone at all? Article XVII is brief and most of it is simply the creed:

Also they teach that at the Consummation of the World Christ will appear for judgment, and will raise up all the dead; He will give to the godly and elect eternal life and everlasting joys, but ungodly men and the devils He will condemn to be tormented without end. They condemn the Anabaptists, who think that there will be an end to the punishments of condemned men and devils. They condemn also others who are now spreading certain Jewish opinions, that before the resurrection of the dead the godly shall take possession of the kingdom of the world, the ungodly being everywhere suppressed. (AC XVII.1–5)

The positive confession is threefold and it is the shared faith of the whole church. Christ will appear in glory. He will raise up all the dead in a real, bodily resurrection. He will judge, giving the godly “eternal life and everlasting joys” and condemning the ungodly and the devils. The official teaching of the Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Reformed, and Anglican churches agrees with all of it, because it is simply what every Christian confesses in the creed.

Then come two condemnations, both aimed at the radical fringe of the Reformation rather than at the main body of the church. The first rejects universalism, the teaching “that there will be an end to the punishments of condemned men and devils” (AC XVII.4). Against it, the article reaffirms that the judgment is eternal. The second rejects chiliasm—from the Greek chilioi, “a thousand”—the expectation that “before the resurrection of the dead the godly shall take possession of the kingdom of the world” (AC XVII.5), an earthly, political reign of the godly set up in this world before the resurrection of the dead. That second condemnation uses a sixteenth-century phrase, “certain Jewish opinions,” which needs careful explanation, and we take it up in §3. Its target is a Christian expectation of a this-worldly kingdom, not the Jewish people.

What is most striking about Article XVII is how little it says. It confesses the core, fences off two errors, and stops, without building a system or setting a date. That reticence is a model for us to follow.


2. Biblical Theology

The New Testament’s word for the Lord’s return is parousia. Thayer’s lexicon gives its first meaning as “presence” and its second as “the coming, arrival, advent,” and it says that in the New Testament the word is used “especially of the advent, i. e. the future, visible, return from heaven of Jesus, the Messiah, to raise the dead, hold the last judgment, and set up formally and gloriously the kingdom of God.” That is very nearly Article XVII in one entry of a Greek dictionary! The New Testament speaks often of that coming, and it is easy to forget that it speaks of it almost always to comfort and to steady God’s people.

The comfort of the grieving. The most famous “end times” passage in the Bible was written to console mourners. The Thessalonians grieved for believers who had died, afraid they had somehow missed the Lord’s return, and Paul writes to reassure them: “the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a cry of command… And the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive… will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord… Therefore encourage one another with these words” (1 Thessalonians 4:16–18). Notice the purpose, encourage one another. This text was written for a graveside. The event it describes is also loud (a “cry of command,” an archangel’s voice, a trumpet), and Lutherans read it as the one public return of Christ, not a separate coming before it (§6).

The resurrection of the body. Paul’s great resurrection chapter grounds our hope in Christ’s own: “Christ has been raised from the dead, the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep… The last enemy to be destroyed is death… we shall all be changed” (1 Corinthians 15:20, 26, 51). The Christian hope is not the escape of the soul from the body but the raising and transforming of the body, and with it the renewal of all creation, “new heavens and a new earth in which righteousness dwells” (2 Peter 3:13). At the ascension the disciples were told, “This Jesus… will come in the same way as you saw him go into heaven” (Acts 1:11).

The judgment, and its double outcome. The return is also judgment. “When the Son of Man comes in his glory… he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats… And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life” (Matthew 25:31–46). Jesus says that “an hour is coming when all who are in the tombs will hear his voice and come out, those who have done good to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil to the resurrection of judgment” (John 5:28–29; cf. Daniel 12:2). Scripture does not let us keep the comfort without the sobriety, for the same return that raises the faithful to joy is the judgment of the world. The Judge, however, is the Savior, and the King’s first word in that scene is a welcome: “Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world” (Matthew 25:34). The scene does not set up a second way of salvation beside faith. The kingdom was prepared before any of them had done anything, and the righteous are surprised by their own works: “Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink?” (Matthew 25:37). Their works are the fruit of faith, and the Judge sees and honors them, but the kingdom itself is His gift. The Apology teaches the same when it says that good works are rewarded but do not merit the forgiveness of sins (Ap IV.194, paraphrased).

The disputed apocalyptic texts. The texts on which the various end-times systems are built must be read for what they are. Revelation 20, with its “thousand years,” is the crux that divides the millennial views (§6). It belongs to a kind of visionary writing, called apocalyptic, that speaks in symbols (as Daniel does). Lutherans, with Augustine, have declined to read it as a literal timeline. Others read it differently, as §6 explains. Jesus’ own teaching about the end, given on the Mount of Olives (Matthew 24), warns of tribulation and signs, and it comes to rest on the note that governs all Christian expectation: “concerning that day and hour no one knows… Therefore, stay awake” (Matthew 24:36, 42). The Lord’s own counsel is to watch.

Whom are you waiting for? Scripture’s answer is never a date or a scheme. It is a Person, “the Lord himself,” whose return is the comfort of the grieving and the hope of the church.


3. Historical Context

Article XVII’s positive content stirred no controversy between Rome and Wittenberg. The Confutation accepted it, because it is simply the creed, and Melanchthon’s Apology records that “the Seventeenth Article the adversaries receive without exception” (Ap XVII.1). The article’s edges are its two condemnations, both aimed at the radical ferment of the 1520s and 1530s.

The condemnation of universalism. The article names “the Anabaptists,” but the view it had in mind was held by a few radicals of the 1520s (Hans Denck is the name usually given), who taught that hell is not eternal and that in the end even the condemned and the devils would be restored. The idea is very old and is commonly traced to Origen’s apokatastasis (“restoration”). AC XVII rejects it and reaffirms eternal judgment. The Anabaptists and Mennonites of today are not universalists and hold the historic Christian hope.

The condemnation of chiliasm, and the “Jewish opinions” phrase. The second condemnation rejects the expectation of an earthly, political messianic kingdom set up before the resurrection, in which “the godly shall take possession of the kingdom of the world.” The danger was not theoretical. Radical apocalyptic movements were attempting to bring in God’s kingdom by force, an impulse that would erupt in the violent seizure of Münster (1534–1535), just after the Confession. The peaceful Anabaptists, Menno Simons above all, repudiated Münster, and their Mennonite heirs reject it still.

The article calls these “certain Jewish opinions.” The phrase is sixteenth-century polemical language. The Reformers used the label for one particular hope, an earthly and political kingdom of the godly set up before the resurrection, which they associated with the expectation of a messianic kingdom within history. The phrase is not a description of Judaism as a whole or of the Jewish people, and it should never be heard as one. The real target of AC XVII was a Christian chiliasm, among the radicals of the Reformers’ own day, that looked for such a kingdom before the resurrection.

The millennium in the early church. The early church did not speak with one voice about the “thousand years” of Revelation 20, as §4 shows. The decisive turn came with Augustine, whose City of God read the thousand years as the present church age, with Christ reigning through the Gospel. This amillennial reading (the prefix a- means “no”: no separate earthly thousand-year kingdom still to come) became the settled Western tradition the Reformers inherited.

The modern origin of “rapture” theology. Much of what many Christians today assume is simply “the Bible’s view of the end” (a rapture of the church before a seven-year tribulation, and a literal thousand-year reign centered on national Israel) is in fact a nineteenth-century system. Its history, and the respect owed to those who hold it, are taken up in §6.


4. Early Church Witness

On the core of this article (the return, the resurrection, the judgment) the Fathers speak with one voice, and it is the creed’s voice. On the millennium they did not.

Justin Martyr (c. 155), in his Dialogue with Trypho, professes a premillennial hope (an earthly reign of the righteous) and in the same breath acknowledges that “many who belong to the pure and pious faith” think otherwise. That admission matters, because it shows that the millennium was a matter of disagreement among faithful Christians from the very beginning, long before the church, and later the Lutheran Confession, spoke to it.

Irenaeus (c. 180) held the premillennial hope more firmly, expecting a literal earthly reign (Against Heresies 5.32–36). His is an early witness that the literal reading had real and widespread support. Papias before him, and Tertullian and Lactantius after him, held it as well. It never became the confession of the whole church but it is not to be waved away.

Augustine (c. 426) read Revelation 20’s thousand years as the present age of the church, with Christ already reigning through Word and Sacrament and the saints already reigning with Him, and he rejected the “carnal” millenarianism (another name for chiliasm) he himself had once held (City of God 20). It was Augustine’s amillennial reading that became the settled Western tradition, carried into the medieval church, Rome, and the Reformation.

I draw two conclusions from this. On the core there is a genuine consensus of the Fathers, for the church has always confessed the return, the resurrection, and the judgment with one voice. On the millennium the Fathers disagreed and Justin tells us they always had. We must therefore neither pretend the early church was uniformly amillennial (that would erase Justin and Irenaeus) nor claim premillennialism as the “original faith” the church later abandoned (Justin shows it was contested from the start). The lesson is the humility the Fathers themselves modeled. We confess the creed firmly, and with it the Confession’s rejection of an earthly kingdom before the resurrection, but we hold the details of the timeline loosely.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The Confession’s teaching is the creed unfolded and its pastoral aim is to comfort.

Christ will come again, bodily and in glory. “At the Consummation of the World Christ will appear for judgment” (AC XVII.1). The return is personal, bodily, and visible (Acts 1:11). It is the crucified and risen Lord whom Article III already confessed: “The same Christ shall openly come again to judge the quick and the dead” (AC III.6). He is now coming to finish what He began.

He will raise all the dead. “[He] will raise up all the dead” (AC XVII.2). The Christian hope is the resurrection of the body, not merely the survival of the soul, and with it the renewal of creation (2 Peter 3:13). All the dead are raised, the just and the unjust (John 5:28–29; Daniel 12:2), in one general resurrection. Every Lutheran child learns the same confession in the Small Catechism, where the Holy Spirit “at the last day will raise up me and all the dead, and will give to me and to all believers in Christ everlasting life. This is most certainly true” (SC II.6). The Large Catechism adds that until that day the Spirit keeps the church in the forgiveness of sins through the Word and the Sacraments, and that when our flesh has been laid in the grave He will finish His work all at once and raise us to a life entirely and perfectly holy (LC II.54–59, paraphrased).

The judgment, spoken quietly. “He will give to the godly and elect eternal life and everlasting joys, but ungodly men and the devils He will condemn to be tormented without end” (AC XVII.2–3). Here the Confession affirms eternal judgment. A pastor speaks of it quietly. Christians do not rejoice in judgment; we rejoice that Christ bore judgment for us. The whole comfort of the Gospel is that the judgment we deserved has fallen on Christ, so that whoever hears His word and believes “does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life” (John 5:24). In other words, the believer will meet on the Last Day the same Lord who was judged in his place. If you fear that your faith is too weak to stand on that day, I want you to hear that the promise rests on Christ and not on the strength of your believing, for of the Lord’s Servant it is written, “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3). (This book teaches what the Confession and Scripture say about judgment; it makes no pronouncement about the eternal destiny of any particular person, which belongs to God alone. That reticence concerns our neighbor’s case and not your own. Of yourself you may be sure, because God has spoken His promise to you by name in your Baptism and speaks it again in the absolution.)

Against universalism. The article rejects the teaching “that there will be an end to the punishments of condemned men and devils” (AC XVII.4). The Lord Himself sets the two outcomes side by side, “eternal punishment” and “eternal life” (Matthew 25:46), and the church may not make the one temporary without unsettling the other. To empty the judgment of its finality would also make light of what Christ bore on the cross. There is a hope that differs from what the article rejects. It may be called a chastened hope, by which we mean the longing that as many as possible would be saved. God Himself shares that longing, for He “desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth,” and Christ Jesus “gave himself as a ransom for all” (1 Timothy 2:4, 6). That longing sends the church to pray and to preach now, while there is time. It is not a hope that the judgment will be undone after death, for “just as it is appointed for man to die once, and after that comes judgment, so Christ, having been offered once to bear the sins of many, will appear a second time, not to deal with sin but to save those who are eagerly waiting for him” (Hebrews 9:27–28).

Against chiliasm: the amillennial reading. The article rejects the expectation of an earthly kingdom before the resurrection. AC XVII does not interpret Revelation 20, but the reading of that chapter which agrees with its rejection, and which Lutheran teachers have held with Augustine, is the one now called amillennial. It takes the “thousand years” as the present age of Christ’s reign through the Gospel, not a future earthly political order to be seized or built. In other words, Christ is reigning now, and the church does not wait for a better earthly kingdom before He returns. Christ’s kingdom is “not of this world” (John 18:36), a text the Confession itself cites for this very distinction (AC XXVIII.14), and the Apology calls that kingdom “spiritual” (Ap XVI.2). That is the distinction behind the two kingdoms of Article XVI.

The intermediate state: “What happens when I die?” The time between a believer’s death and the resurrection is what theologians call the intermediate state. What happens then is the question people bring to a chapter like this. Scripture’s comfort is that those who die in Christ are at once with Him. To the dying thief Jesus said, “today you will be with me in paradise” (Luke 23:43), and Paul could say that his desire was “to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better” (Philippians 1:23). The dead in Christ are neither lost nor nowhere; they are with the Lord, at rest, awaiting the resurrection of the body when Christ returns. The one we lay in the ground was joined to Christ in Baptism and that promise does not lapse at death: “if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his” (Romans 6:5). The Confessions assume the same. Even while rejecting the invocation of the saints, for which it finds no testimony in Scripture, the Apology concedes that the saints in heaven “pray for the Church in general” (Ap XXI.9), which could not be said of those who had ceased to be. The Christian hope therefore has two moments, the immediate comfort of being with Christ at death and the final, fuller hope of the bodily resurrection at His coming.

Reticence is the model. Above all, the Confession’s brevity teaches restraint. It declines to build a system, because “concerning that day and hour no one knows” (Matthew 24:36) and because the last things are given to us for comfort and for watchfulness.


6. Comparative Theology

On the last things the historic church overwhelmingly agrees.

Start with the vast common ground. The whole historic church (Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican) confesses the same creedal core. Christ will return bodily and in glory, all the dead will be raised, and all will be judged, to eternal life or eternal loss (Catechism of the Catholic Church [CCC] §§668–682, 988–1060; Westminster Confession 32–33; and the creeds everywhere). The Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England say it in a single clause, confessing that the risen Christ ascended into heaven, “and there sitteth, until he return to judge all Men at the last day” (Art. IV), and the Methodist Articles of Religion keep the same clause (Art. III). The famous divisions over the “end times” are almost never about this. They are about the systems built around it: the meaning of the millennium, the state of the dead, and the fate of the lost.

The four millennial views. The classic disagreement concerns the “thousand years” of Revelation 20, and there are four main readings (see Table 17.1): amillennial (the thousand years is the present church age); postmillennial (a long era of gospel triumph, righteousness, and peace before Christ returns); historic premillennial (Christ returns before a literal earthly reign, with no separate rapture before the tribulation); and dispensational premillennial (a rapture of the church before a seven-year tribulation, and a literal reign centered on national Israel).

Before we weigh them, one thing should be said, because it lowers the temperature of a discussion that often runs hot. Christians who confess the same Creed have disagreed about the millennium for centuries, as the Fathers themselves did (§4). This disagreement does not divide faithful Christians from faithless ones. The Lutheran Confession nevertheless takes a side. AC XVII rejects the expectation of an earthly kingdom of the godly before the resurrection, and a Lutheran pastor teaches that rejection as doctrine. The condemnation falls on a teaching and passes no judgment on the faith of the Christians who hold it. The historic Lutheran reading is the one now called amillennial. It agrees with AC XVII’s rejection of chiliasm (§5) and reads Revelation 20 with Augustine. This is offered not as “the real Christians’ position” but as the historic Lutheran reading, held with conviction and with respect for those who read differently.

Dispensationalism, respectfully. Many readers of this book grew up with dispensational premillennialism, with the Scofield Reference Bible, Hal Lindsey’s The Late Great Planet Earth, the Left Behind novels, and prophecy conferences and charts. That heritage has shaped devout, Christ-loving people. It is a nineteenth-century system, developed by John Nelson Darby in the 1830s and spread by the Scofield Bible after 1909, and it is not the faith of the ancient church or of the Reformation. That is history, not ridicule.

Dispensational teachers distinguish two stages in Christ’s coming: a coming for His church, which is caught up to meet Him before the tribulation, and a later coming with His saints, visibly and in glory, to reign on the earth. (Earlier writers often called the first stage “secret,” and many today do not.) Its scholarly teachers, such as Walvoord and Ryrie at Dallas Theological Seminary, have stated it with care, and the “progressive” dispensationalists of recent decades have softened its separation of Israel and the church. Its teachers rest the timing of the rapture on promises that the church will be spared the coming wrath: “God has not destined us for wrath, but to obtain salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ” (1 Thessalonians 5:9), and “I will keep you from the hour of trial that is coming on the whole world” (Revelation 3:10).

Lutherans believe both promises, and they hear in them God’s pledge that His people will be kept through tribulation and never come under His wrath, rather than a promise that they will be taken out of the world before it. In 1 Thessalonians, “wrath” (orgē, “anger, wrath”) is God’s final judgment, “the wrath to come” from which Jesus delivers us (1 Thessalonians 1:10). Paul had already told the same readers not to “be moved by these afflictions,” because “we are destined for this” (1 Thessalonians 3:3). Affliction and wrath are two different things. The believer will never come under God’s wrath because Christ has borne it: “Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God” (Romans 5:9). In Revelation 3:10 the Lord says tērēsō ek (“I will keep from”), a phrase the New Testament uses in only one other place, Jesus’ prayer for His disciples: “I do not ask that you take them out of the world, but that you keep them from the evil one” (John 17:15). There they are kept in the world, not taken out of it. The hour of trial comes “to try those who dwell on the earth,” Revelation’s usual name for the unbelieving world (Revelation 6:10; 13:8), while the saints remain on the earth in those days (Revelation 13:7) and are seen at last “coming out of the great tribulation” (Revelation 7:14). Dispensational teachers take those saints to be believers converted after the rapture, and both sides argue the point with care.

Lutherans also take 1 Thessalonians 4 as describing the one public return itself, with its “cry of command” and its “trumpet” (1 Thessalonians 4:16), and find in Scripture one return of Christ, not two stages of it. Scripture speaks of one general resurrection of the just and unjust together (John 5:28–29). Premillennialists point to Revelation 20:5, “The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended. This is the first resurrection.” With Augustine, the Lutheran reading understands that “first resurrection” as the new life Christ gives believers now, over which “the second death has no power” (Revelation 20:6), and not as a separate bodily resurrection a thousand years before the rest. On the Lutheran reading, the New Testament also does not divide Israel and the church into two peoples with two destinies but makes them “one new man” in Christ (Ephesians 2:14–16). The difference is real and it lies within the shared creedal hope.

The intermediate state. On what happens between death and resurrection, the historic traditions again largely agree that the soul is consciously with Christ, awaiting the resurrection of the body (Luke 23:43; Philippians 1:23); this is the Lutheran, Reformed, and Anglican view. The Eastern Orthodox likewise teach that the departed are conscious and await the resurrection; they pray for them, and they do not accept the Western doctrine of purgatory. Rome adds purgatory, a final purification of those who die in God’s grace (CCC §§1030–1032), which is taken up with masses for the dead in chapter 24 (Article XXIV) and is not resolved here. A minority, chiefly the Seventh-day Adventists, teach that death is an unconscious sleep of the whole person until the resurrection (Fundamental Belief 26), a view outsiders often call “soul sleep.” Adventists also teach a pre-Advent “investigative judgment,” Christ’s ministry in the heavenly sanctuary, which they date from 1844 on the basis of Daniel 8:14; most other Christians read those texts differently.

The fate of the lost. The historic and confessional teaching is punishment without end, in the Confession’s words “tormented without end” (AC XVII.3), which is what is usually meant today by “eternal conscious punishment.” Jesus uses the same word, eternal, for both the punishment and the life (Matthew 25:46). Two alternatives are held by some sincere Christians today. Conditional immortality (or annihilationism) holds that the wicked are finally destroyed rather than everlastingly tormented; Seventh-day Adventists hold it, as do some evangelicals and some Anglicans (John Stott inclined to it). AC XVII does not name this view, but its confession that the ungodly will be “tormented without end” excludes it as well. Universalism holds that all will finally be reconciled to God through Christ, the judgment purifying rather than ending. It is commonly traced to Origen, a version of it held by his later followers was condemned in the sixth century, and some theologians teach it today. Those who hold them are usually moved by a concern for God’s justice or His mercy. The Confessions nevertheless retain the traditional understanding, because it is what the Lord’s own words teach (Matthew 25:46) and what the church has consistently confessed in its creeds and councils, and because the point of the doctrine is to send us to the Christ who bore it.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

The wrong answers to Christ’s return are the two errors this chapter has resisted. One is to deny the hope, living as though this world were all there is, with neither return, nor resurrection, nor judgment, nor anything beyond the grave to hope for or to reckon with. The other is to obsess over the hope, becoming so consumed with predicting and dating it that faith turns into anxious speculation and the “blessed hope” (Titus 2:13) becomes a source of fear. Both, in the end, take the eyes off Christ, and the cure for both is the same: keep your eyes on Christ, not the calendar.

What, then, does Christ’s return mean for today? It means that you should live ready. You do not make yourself ready by watching harder. Christ keeps you ready through the Word and the Sacraments, the same means by which He first brought you to faith. If you are baptized, you already belong to the coming King. At the altar He gives you His body and blood for the forgiveness of sins, and as often as you eat and drink you “proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes” (1 Corinthians 11:26). He has promised to drink it “new with you in my Father’s kingdom” (Matthew 26:29), and so every Supper is a foretaste of that feast. If the thought of that day frightens you, I want to send you where He has promised to be found: to His Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution your pastor speaks in His name, and to His Supper. Because Christ will surely come, you are set free to live faithfully, serving your neighbor in the ordinary callings of this passing world (Article XVI), knowing that no faithful work done in Him is wasted; to hope joyfully, grieving, but not “as others do who have no hope” (1 Thessalonians 4:13); and to love boldly, spending yourself for others without fear, because your future is secure in the One who is coming. This is the difference between a curiosity about future events and a confidence in Christ’s future promise. The first fills bookshelves and leaves people afraid, while the second changes how you live on a Tuesday.

Articles XVI and XVII therefore belong together and their pairing is one of the great balances in the Confession. Article XVI said, serve your neighbor faithfully in this present age. Article XVII says, do so because your true King is coming. Between them they steer past two opposite errors: treating this world as though it were ultimate (and so idolizing it) and treating it as though it were meaningless (and so abandoning it). You serve this world diligently because Christ is Lord now and you long for the day He returns to make all things new.

That returns us, at the last, to the graveside where we began. When everything else has been stripped away (the charts and the arguments), what remains is the one thing that was ever able to help there: the Christian waits not for catastrophe, but for Christ. He will come again.

Whom are you waiting for? We wait for the Lord Himself, who has already redeemed us and who is coming to raise us and to make all things new. With the church of every age we answer His promise in the Bible’s last prayer: “Amen. Come, Lord Jesus!” (Revelation 22:20).


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article XVII confesses, in almost the words of the creed, that at the end of the world Christ will come again, will raise all the dead, and will judge, granting eternal life to the godly and elect, those who belong to Christ by faith, and eternal punishment to the ungodly. It condemns universalism (“an end to the punishments”) and chiliasm (an earthly kingdom of the godly before the resurrection). The chapter’s center is that the Christian’s hope is not a timeline to decode but the returning Christ who has already redeemed us, and its counsel is to keep our eyes on Christ, not the calendar. The historic Lutheran reading of the millennium is amillennial. The Confession does not leave the expectation of an earthly kingdom before the resurrection open, yet it condemns a teaching, not the many Christians who confess the same Creed and read Revelation 20 differently. The Confessions retain eternal judgment, taught soberly, for Christians do not rejoice in judgment; we rejoice that Christ bore judgment for us. Those who die in Christ are with Him now, awaiting the bodily resurrection.

8.2 Tables

Table 17.1—The Four Millennial Views

View The “thousand years” (Rev 20) Order of events Held by (representative)
Amillennial The present church age; Christ reigns now through the Gospel Millennium = now (the church age) → return → general resurrection → judgment → new creation Lutheran (the historic reading; cf. AC XVII’s rejection of chiliasm); Roman Catholic (CCC §676 rejects millenarianism); Eastern Orthodox; much of the Reformed tradition. Rooted in Augustine
Postmillennial A long era of gospel triumph, righteousness, and peace before Christ returns Millennium (gospel triumph) → return → judgment Many Puritans; Jonathan Edwards; much 19th-c. American Protestantism (Hodge, Warfield); some Reformed today
Historic premillennial A literal earthly reign after Christ’s return Return → millennium → judgment (one people of God; no separate pretribulational rapture) Early Fathers (Papias, Justin, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Lactantius); George Eldon Ladd and some modern evangelicals
Dispensational premillennial A literal 1000-year reign centered on national Israel Pretribulational rapture (Christ comes for the church) → 7-yr tribulation → return with the saints → millennium → judgment (Israel/church distinction) Many American evangelicals and Baptists; the Assemblies of God (Fundamental Truths 13–14) and much of the Pentecostal movement; Darby (1830s); the Scofield Bible (1909)

Christians who confess the same Creed have disagreed about the millennium for centuries (§4, §6); AC XVII nevertheless rejects any earthly kingdom of the godly before the resurrection (§6). The Lutheran reading is amillennial; the other views are represented from their own proponents.

Table 17.2—The Intermediate State and the Fate of the Lost

Question Lutheran (with the Reformed and Anglicans) Other teaching
Between death and resurrection? Consciously with Christ, awaiting the bodily resurrection (Luke 23:43; Phil 1:23) Also conscious and awaiting the resurrection; prays for the departed; no purgatory (Eastern Orthodox); purgatory, a final purification of those who die in God’s grace (Roman Catholic, CCC §§1030–1032; see chapter 24); an unconscious sleep of the whole person until the resurrection (Seventh-day Adventist)
The fate of the lost? Punishment without end (“tormented without end,” AC XVII; Matthew 25:46) Annihilation / conditional immortality, the wicked finally destroyed (Adventist; some evangelicals and Anglicans; not named in AC XVII but excluded by its “without end”); universalism, all finally reconciled through Christ (condemned by AC XVII.4)
The final hope? The resurrection of the body and the new heavens and new earth (2 Peter 3:13) (shared across the historic traditions)

Taught soberly; the book makes no pronouncement about any individual’s eternal destiny.

Table 17.3—Rapture Theology: Where It Came From

The system Dispensational premillennialism: a rapture of the church before the tribulation (pretribulational), a 7-year tribulation, a literal 1000-year reign centered on national Israel
Origin John Nelson Darby (Plymouth Brethren), 1830s
Spread The Scofield Reference Bible (1909); Dallas Theological Seminary (Chafer, Walvoord, Ryrie); popularly, Hal Lindsey, The Late Great Planet Earth (1970); the Left Behind novels (1995–2007)
Age A nineteenth-century system, not the faith of the ancient church or the Reformation
Held by Much of modern American evangelicalism; many Baptists (the Baptist Faith and Message takes no millennial position); the Assemblies of God officially; much of the Pentecostal movement

Stated as history, not ridicule; the scheme is held by millions of sincere Christians.

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

The Second Coming (parousia, “coming, arrival”); the resurrection of the body; the last judgment; chiliasm / millenarianism; amillennial / postmillennial / premillennial (historic and dispensational); the rapture; the intermediate state; conditional immortality / annihilationism; universalism (apokatastasis, “restoration”).

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XVII and Ap XVII; the Small Catechism, Creed, Third Article (SC II.6); the Large Catechism on the Third Article (LC II.54–59); the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds (the resurrection and the life everlasting).
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb, and James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (eschatology; the rejection of chiliasm).
  • Augustine, City of God 20 (the amillennial reading); Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 80–81; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 5.32–36 (the early premillennial voices).
  • For the landscape of views, from their own proponents: Robert G. Clouse, ed., The Meaning of the Millennium: Four Views.
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§668–682, 988–1060, 1030–1032 (purgatory); the Westminster Confession 32–33; the Baptist Faith and Message (Art. X); the Assemblies of God Statement of Fundamental Truths (13–14); the Seventh-day Adventist 28 Fundamental Beliefs; a citable Orthodox eschatology (e.g., Ware).
Topics
Resurrection and Last ThingsOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
John 11:251 Thessalonians 4:16–181 Corinthians 15:202 Peter 3:13Acts 1:11Matthew 25:31–46John 5:28–29Daniel 12:2Matthew 25:34Matthew 25:37Matthew 24:36John 5:24Isaiah 42:3Matthew 25:461 Timothy 2:4Hebrews 9:27–28John 18:36Luke 23:43Philippians 1:23Romans 6:51 Thessalonians 5:9Revelation 3:101 Thessalonians 1:101 Thessalonians 3:3Romans 5:9John 17:15Revelation 6:10Revelation 13:7Revelation 7:141 Thessalonians 4:16Revelation 20:5Revelation 20:6Ephesians 2:14–16Daniel 8:14Titus 2:131 Corinthians 11:26Matthew 26:291 Thessalonians 4:13Revelation 22:20
Confessions
AC XVIIAp IVAp XVIIAC IIILC IIAC XXVIIIAp XVIAp XXISCLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.