Chapter 8—Article VIII: What the Church Is (Hypocrites and the Efficacy of the Sacraments)
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
The news comes in an email or a phone call. The pastor who baptized your children, who stood at your mother’s grave and spoke Christ’s forgiveness over you in your worst week, has fallen. It was fraud, abuse, or some long-hidden hypocrisy, and now it is public. Underneath the grief comes a colder question, one many Christians have felt and few have said aloud: Was any of it real? If the man was a fraud, was my baptism empty? Was the absolution just words? Was the Supper I received from his hands nothing at all?
Article VIII answers that question and it is one of the most comforting sentences in the Confession. The short version is this: Christ’s gifts are trustworthy because they depend on His faithfulness, not the minister’s. The water was joined to God’s Word, the baptism was God’s own act, and it stands. I want to be clear from the start that this is not a chapter about bad pastors, though it will have to mention them. It is a chapter about a faithful Christ, and the one question it keeps asking is simply this one: Can Christ still be trusted when His servants fail?
1. What the Article Says
Article VIII is one of the shortest articles in the Confession and it exists to protect Article VII from a misunderstanding. Article VII has just said that the Church is “the congregation of saints” (the assembly of believers). An obvious objection follows: but the visible church clearly contains people who are no saints at all, hypocrites and scoundrels, even in the pulpit. Doesn’t that ruin the definition? And if the man distributing the gifts is a fraud, are the gifts themselves spoiled? Article VIII answers:
Although the Church properly is the congregation of saints and true believers, nevertheless, since in this life many hypocrites and evil persons are mingled therewith, it is lawful to use Sacraments administered by evil men, according to the saying of Christ: The Scribes and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat, etc. Matt. 23:2. Both the Sacraments and Word are effectual by reason of the institution and commandment of Christ, notwithstanding they be administered by evil men. They condemn the Donatists, and such like, who denied it to be lawful to use the ministry of evil men in the Church, and who thought the ministry of evil men to be unprofitable and of none effect. (AC VIII)
In other words, the Church on earth always has hypocrites mixed in with the believers, even in the pulpit. Baptism, the Supper, and the preached Word are still Christ’s gifts and still do their work, because Christ commanded them, whatever the man handing them over may be. The Donatists, who said otherwise, were wrong.
The article makes two points.
First, the Church in this life is a mixed body. “Many hypocrites and evil persons are mingled” with the assembly of saints. Their presence in the pew (or the pulpit) does not falsify the Church or mean you have wandered into a false one. Scripture told us to expect this, since the weeds grow with the wheat and the net gathers good and bad together (§2). The true believers are there, but human eyes cannot always tell them from those merely going through the motions.
Second, the Word and Sacraments are effectual by Christ’s institution, not by the minister’s holiness. Because Baptism, absolution, and the Supper are “effectual by reason of the institution and commandment of Christ,” their power does not depend on the minister’s character. It rests on Christ, who commanded and instituted them. Notice the word lawful. The article says it is lawful to receive the Sacraments even from evil men, because what you receive is not theirs to corrupt. Jesus Himself gave the warrant. “The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat,” He said, and the crowds were to do what those men taught from that seat even though their lives were a scandal (Matthew 23:2–3, ESV).
Then the article draws its one boundary line, against the Donatists, an ancient party who held that sacraments administered by unworthy clergy were worthless and had to be redone (§3). Against them the Confession stands with the ancient Church: the gift is Christ’s, and Christ is not made unfaithful by an unfaithful servant.
The article has therefore already answered the question this chapter asks, and the answer is yes, because the certainty of the Gospel rests on the faithfulness of Christ, not on the consistency of His servants.
2. Biblical Theology
The Confession is reading a New Testament that is candid about two things: the Church in this age is a mixed field, and God’s gifts do not depend on the goodness of the people who hand them over.
The wheat and the weeds grow together. Jesus tells of a field sown with good seed, into which an enemy sows weeds by night. The servants want to gather the weeds at once, but the master says no, lest they root up the wheat along with them. “Let both grow together until the harvest,” He tells them, and in His own interpretation “the harvest is the end of the age” (Matthew 13:24–30, 36–43). Jesus Himself says that “the field is the world” (Matthew 13:38), and the Apology holds to His reading: “The field, He says, is the world, not the Church” (Ap VII–VIII.19). For the Church’s outward appearance the Apology turns to the net that “gathered fish of every kind” (Matthew 13:47), good and bad together until the shore. The lesson concerns timing. In this present age the field holds both and premature human sorting is neither commanded nor safe.
The Lord knows those who are His, and the great house holds mixed vessels. “God’s firm foundation stands, bearing this seal: ‘The Lord knows those who are his,’ and, ‘Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity.’ Now in a great house there are not only vessels of gold and silver but also of wood and clay” (2 Timothy 2:19–20). In other words, the Lord (not our inspection) infallibly knows His own, while the “great house,” the visible church, openly contains vessels of honor and dishonor side by side. That is why the true believers are, in the old Lutheran word, hidden: present, but known for certain only to God.
What did Jesus tell the crowds about the scribes and Pharisees? “The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat,” Jesus says, “so do and observe whatever they tell you, but not the works they do. For they preach, but do not practice” (Matthew 23:2–3). Article VIII leans on this directly. The Lord Himself tells the crowds to receive what is rightly delivered from the office, even when the men in it are hypocrites. This is no soft word about hypocrisy, for the same chapter thunders “woe” upon it seven times. The word Jesus uses for them is hypokritēs, which is defined as “an actor, stage-player” and, in biblical Greek, “a dissembler, pretender, hypocrite” (Thayer’s Greek Lexicon). The sin of the messenger does not cancel the truth of the message God sent through him. Article VIII protects the gifts from the minister’s life, not from his false teaching. Of the man who preaches another gospel the Apology says, “Impious teachers are to be deserted [are not to be received or heard], because these do not act any longer in the place of Christ, but are antichrists” (Ap VII–VIII.48; Matthew 7:15).
The growth is God’s, not the minister’s. When the Corinthians took sides (“I follow Paul,” “I follow Apollos”), Paul wrote: “I planted, Apollos watered, but God gave the growth. So neither he who plants nor he who waters is anything, but only God who gives the growth” (1 Corinthians 3:6–7). The ministers are servants and the life comes from God. Paul even rejoices that “whether in pretense or in truth, Christ is proclaimed” (Philippians 1:18), and Article VIII applies the same reasoning to the Word and the Sacraments. Behind both stands the promise that “if we are faithless, he remains faithful— for he cannot deny himself” (2 Timothy 2:13).
However, “Let both grow together” does not forbid the Church from ever addressing open, unrepented sin; Paul himself commands a congregation to discipline a manifest, impenitent offender, “so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord” (1 Corinthians 5:5). Disciplining visible sin is a different matter from claiming that the Church can become a spotless body by rooting out every hidden hypocrite, or that an unworthy minister voids the gifts. The Church may address the scandal it can see. It cannot run the final harvest early and it need not, because the Lord knows those who are His.
3. Historical Context
Who were the Donatists? Article VIII condemns them by name, and their story is worth a few sentences because it makes the doctrine concrete.
Early in the fourth century the emperor Diocletian launched the last and fiercest persecution of the Church (303–305). Among its demands was that Christians hand over the sacred Scriptures to be burned. Some clergy complied and were branded ever after as traditores (“those who handed over”). When the persecution passed, a bitter question remained: what about the sacraments performed by clergy who had caved? The rupture came at Carthage around 311, when a new bishop, Caecilian, was consecrated by a man rumored to have been a traditor. A rival party rejected the consecration as worthless, elected its own bishop, and rallied behind a leader named Donatus, which is why they are called “the Donatists.” Their claim was clear and, on its surface, principled. A sacrament is only as good as the holiness of the minister, so sacraments from tainted clergy are void and must be redone. Behind it lay a longing for a spotless church, uncontaminated by the compromised.
The Church in the West said no. A council at Arles (314) rejected the demand to redo such sacraments, and the matter was fought out for a century until an imperial hearing at Carthage (411) ruled against the Donatists. What matters for us is the instinct behind the schism: that the worth of Christ’s gift rises and falls with the worth of the person who hands it over.
4. Early Church Witness
The man who answered the Donatists was Augustine, bishop of Hippo, and his reply became the settled mind of the Western Church. That is why Article VIII can present itself not as a Reformation novelty but as the ancient catholic position.
Augustine asked whose the sacrament is. When a minister baptizes, who is really doing the baptizing? Augustine answered: Christ. The minister’s hand is on the water, but the act is Christ’s, and the holiness of the sacrament is Christ’s holiness, not the minister’s. Hence “Peter may baptize, but this is He that baptizes; … Judas may baptize, still this is He that baptizes” (Tractates on the Gospel of John 6.7). Therefore the Donatist fear has no ground. A bad minister sins against his office and answers to God for it, but he cannot reach past his own hands to spoil what belongs to Christ.
Augustine described the Church as a corpus permixtum, a “mixed body” of wheat and weeds that will not be sorted until the harvest; a church demanding visible purity now has mistaken which age it is living in. He also drew a distinction the Reformation would receive with care. A baptism given even in schism (by a breakaway group, outside the Church’s unity) was truly valid, Christ’s own baptism, though the one who received it there did not have its benefit until he was reconciled to the Church. The Lutheran Confessions keep the first point and tie the second not to visible membership but to faith, and they cite Augustine himself for it: “the faith of the Sacrament, and not the Sacrament, justifies” (Ap XIII.23; see the sidebar below). In other words, the Sacrament is truly Christ’s gift and faith is what receives it and lays hold of its forgiveness.
The ancient witness on this question is mostly Western and centers on Augustine. On the point at issue, however, the ancient Church did reach a consensus that a sinful minister cannot void Christ’s gift, and Augustine is its clearest voice. He is worth hearing because he pointed away from the minister and toward Christ.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
The Confession takes up Augustine’s settlement and states it clearly.
The Church is a mixed body, and that is not a scandal. AC VIII grants freely that “many hypocrites and evil persons are mingled” with the assembly of saints. The Apology (which defends Articles VII and VIII together) grants the point at once. Its opponents had pressed the threshing floor where wheat and chaff lie together and the net with good and bad fish (Ap VII–VIII.1), and the Apology concedes that “in this life hypocrites and wicked men have been mingled with the Church” (Ap VII–VIII.3). Christ Himself, it says, “speaks of the outward appearance of the Church” when He likens the kingdom to a net that “gathered fish of every kind” (Matthew 13:47) and to the ten virgins (Ap VII–VIII.19). The hypocrites belong to the Church only outwardly, by sharing in its Word, confession, and Sacraments (the Apology says “according to the outward fellowship of the signs of the Church”), not as living members of the body (Ap VII–VIII.3, 12). Theologians sometimes speak of the “invisible” church, but the better Lutheran word is hidden. The Church is not, the Apology insists, “a Platonic state” (Ap VII–VIII.20), an ideal that exists only on paper. It is the visible assembly gathered around Word and Sacrament, within which the true believers are hidden, “covered by a multitude of evils” in this age (Ap VII–VIII.19), and known with certainty only to God (2 Timothy 2:19). If you fear that you are one of the weeds, you are not asked to sort yourself, for the sorting is Christ’s at the harvest. Go back to your Baptism, where He put His name on you, and say with Luther, “Nevertheless I am baptized” (LC IV.44). (The fuller doctrine of the Church and its marks belongs to chapter 7; here we need only enough for Article VIII.)
The gifts are effectual by Christ’s institution. At the heart of the article is the confession that “both the Sacraments and Word are effectual by reason of the institution and commandment of Christ, notwithstanding they be administered by evil men.” The Apology gives the reason. By the call of the Church, ministers “represent the person of Christ, and do not represent their own persons,” so that “when they offer the Word of God, when they offer the Sacraments, they offer them in the stead and place of Christ” (Ap VII–VIII.28). Jesus said it first: “The one who hears you hears me” (Luke 10:16). Luther’s Large Catechism says the same. At the font, Baptism performed “by human hands” is “nevertheless truly God’s own work,” because God’s Word is joined to the water (LC IV.10, 18). At the altar he meets our very question, and answers that even if “a knave takes or distributes the Sacrament,” it is the true Sacrament, “for it is not founded upon the holiness of men, but upon the Word of God” (LC V.16). Therefore your baptism is God’s Word attached to water and attached to you. It stands as long as God’s Word stands, and God’s Word stands forever. (Baptism itself is the subject of chapter 9, the Lord’s Supper of chapter 10, and the right use of the Sacraments of chapter 13.)
Sidebar—Two different questions: valid and beneficial. This chapter says the Sacrament is effective even from an unworthy minister, while chapter 5 (Article V) warned against thinking a Sacrament works automatically, like a charm, apart from faith. I find it helpful to see that the two do not collide, because they answer two different questions. (1) Is the Sacrament valid despite an unworthy minister? Yes. Its validity rests on Christ’s institution, not the minister’s holiness (this chapter’s point, against the Donatists). (2) Does the Sacrament benefit the recipient apart from faith? No. The gift is truly offered and truly present, but it is received to blessing through faith (AC XIII, and Article V’s point; see chapter 13). The medieval phrase ex opere operato (“from the work worked”), which Rome still uses, covers the first point: in Rome’s words the sacrament works “by the power of God” and not “by the righteousness of either the celebrant or the recipient” (CCC §1128). It also claims more, that the Sacrament confers grace by the act performed so long as the one receiving it puts no obstacle in the way. The Lutheran Confessions confess the first point, that the gift is really and truly Christ’s whatever the minister is. They reject the phrase because of the second, which the scholastic teachers the Apology answers used to mean that we are justified “by a ceremony, without a good disposition of the heart, i.e., without faith” (Ap XIII.18; AC XIII.3). Rome’s Catechism also says that the benefit depends on the one who receives it (CCC §1128); §6 says where we still differ. Therefore Article VIII does not make the Sacrament a machine that works whether we believe or not, and Article V does not make our assurance depend on the minister. The chapter says both: the Sacrament is valid because Christ instituted it, and it benefits those who receive it in faith.
In short, the gift is Christ’s, effectual by His own institution, and no man’s unworthiness (the minister’s or the recipient’s) can make Christ unfaithful to His Word. The gift remains true even when it is wrongly received (LC IV.53; LC V.17), though only faith receives it to blessing. That faith is itself the Spirit’s gift through the same Word and Sacraments (AC V), not a second worthiness you must bring. If you fear that your faith is too weak to receive it, remember that Christ’s faithfulness does not hang on yours: “if we are faithless, he remains faithful— for he cannot deny himself” (2 Timothy 2:13). What that means for a shaken conscience is the work of §7.
6. Comparative Theology
On this article there is more agreement across the traditions than on almost any other in this book, because all the traditions inherited the ancient Church’s rejection of Donatism. Therefore this comparison looks for the one place where they differ.
Roman Catholic. Rome stands firmly against the Donatists. A minister who is personally unworthy, but who celebrates the sacrament “in accordance with the intention of the Church,” still truly gives it, because he acts in persona Christi (“in the person of Christ”) (Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1128, 1584; Trent, Session VII, canons 11–12). The Apology speaks in nearly the same terms, of ministers who “represent the person of Christ” (Ap VII–VIII.28). We welcome this agreement on validity.
Rome and the Confession still differ over what receives the gift, a difference set out with Article V (chapter 5). The Confession rejects any teaching that the Sacrament profits by the outward act without faith (AC XIII.3; Ap XIII.18) and insists that what receives the gift is faith in Christ’s promise. Other differences, such as the number of the sacraments and the doctrine of the priesthood, belong to other chapters.
Eastern Orthodox. The Orthodox likewise reject any Donatist voiding of the mysteries, since a sinful priest does not empty a sacrament whose reality is Christ’s. As one Orthodox priest put it, recalling Augustine’s answer to the Donatists, the sacraments “are not the gift of the celebrant, but of Jesus Christ.”1 Orthodoxy prefers the language of mystery to Western scholastic categories. It ties the mysteries to the canonical Church and governs the reception of converts from other communions by the principle of oikonomia (a pastoral relaxation of the strict rule for the sake of a person’s salvation).2 That is a question about where the Church’s boundary lies.
Reformed and Presbyterian. On this point these traditions agree with the Lutheran confession almost verbatim. The Westminster Confession teaches that a sacrament’s efficacy does not depend “upon the piety or intention of him that doth administer it, but upon the work of the Spirit, and the word of institution” (ch. 27.3) and that the visible church is a mixed body (ch. 25).
Anglican. The Thirty-Nine Articles (1571), the Church of England’s historic confession, devote an entire article to our very point, Article XXVI, “Of the Unworthiness of the Ministers, which hinders not the effect of the Sacrament.” Its text confesses that “in the visible Church the evil be ever mingled with the good”; that evil ministers act “not … in their own name, but in Christ’s”; that the grace is not “diminished from such as by faith and rightly do receive the Sacraments,” which “be effectual, because of Christ’s institution and promise, although they be ministered by evil men”; and that “it appertaineth to the discipline of the Church, that inquiry be made of evil Ministers.” (The Methodist Articles of Religion, John Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, do not carry this article.) This is the shared inheritance of the main Reformation churches (Lutheran, Reformed, and Anglican), straight from Augustine.
The one live difference concerns the shape of the visible church rather than whether the gifts work. First, a strand of the Reformed tradition (the Scots Confession, 1560, and the Belgic Confession, 1561) counts church discipline as a third mark of the Church alongside Word and Sacrament, while Calvin himself named two (Institutes 4.1.9). (On the marks, see chapter 7.) This gives the question of a visibly faithful membership a sharper edge for them than for Lutherans, even while they stand with us entirely against Donatism. Second, and more pointedly, the historic Anabaptist movement (and, without the ban and separation, much of the modern Baptist world) cherishes the ideal of a regenerate church membership. This is a visible church of professing, baptized believers, kept faithful by believer’s baptism and congregational discipline, and in the Anabaptist case by the “ban” with its shunning and by separation from the world (Schleitheim Confession, 1527, arts. II and IV; Dordrecht Confession, 1632, arts. XVI–XVII). It is an admirable desire, born of a protest against nominal membership.
I want to state this distinction carefully. Although the historic Anabaptist movement and many modern Baptist traditions desire a regenerate church membership, that concern is not identical to the Donatist claim condemned in Article VIII. The Donatists questioned the validity of the ministry and sacraments administered by unworthy ministers. Most Baptist traditions do not. When a Baptist church baptizes someone who was baptized as an infant, it does so because it does not count infant baptism as baptism, and the worthiness of the minister has nothing to do with it (see chapter 9). Wanting a holy, committed church is a different question from the Donatist one. It concerns the purity of the membership rather than the validity of the gifts, and “Donatist” must never be used as an insult against brothers and sisters pursuing holiness. Where the Confession gently presses back is only this: the Church in this age will be a mixed body, however carefully it guards its rolls, because no human eye can finally sort wheat from weeds, and for Lutherans the comfort of the Sacraments rests on Christ’s institution, never on the achieved purity of the congregation.
The traditions agree far more than they differ here. With the rarest of exceptions, the Christian traditions stand together against Donatism because they stand together on this: the gift is Christ’s. Nearly the whole Church, East and West, Catholic and Protestant, confesses it.
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
Now we return to you, and to the news with which this chapter began.
The comfort Article VIII offers you is sure: what God did in your baptism, God did. The pastor’s fall is a real grief and a real wrong, but it reaches only as far as the man. It cannot reach back and un-baptize you, because your baptism was never his work to begin with. It was God’s Word joined to water and it stands. The absolution you heard was Christ’s own word spoken through a man’s mouth. The Confession calls absolution “the voice of God… pronounced by God’s command” (AC XXV.3–4). The man has failed, but the Word has not. That means you do not need to be baptized again and neither do your children. The sins he absolved are forgiven. The Supper you received from his hands was Christ’s body and blood given for you, because Christ’s words made it so and not the hands that held the cup. You may grieve the man without doubting the gift.3
Two cautions belong here.
The first is that trusting Christ’s promise is not the same as excusing the minister’s sin. Article VIII comforts the conscience without minimizing the seriousness of pastoral misconduct. A minister who abuses his office sins gravely against Christ and against the people entrusted to him, and he bears that guilt. Therefore the Church rightly grieves, disciplines, and protects. This doctrine hushes none of that. It only refuses to let his sin take away your assurance. The Confession’s word is lawful, not required. It settles your conscience about what you have received, and it does not bind you to go on receiving from a man who has wronged you. You are free to be fed by another shepherd while the Church does its duty with this one. If he repents, the same forgiveness he once spoke is Christ’s to give him too, but that is mercy for a sinner, not a way back into the pulpit, and it lays no burden on those he wronged.
The second is that this chapter is not against pastors. It should leave you trusting Christ more without trusting the pastoral office less. The office is honored here by being put in its place. The minister is Christ’s servant and through him Christ gives His gifts.
Article VIII is comfort not only for the layperson shaken by a scandal, but for every pastor who hands over gifts he knows he does not deserve to touch. The pastor need not be worthy of the Gospel he preaches (thank God, because none is). He is called to live under it and to deliver faithfully what Christ instituted, but the power of what he delivers was always Christ’s.
When the news shakes you, go where Christ has promised to give Himself to you: hear His Word preached, return to your Baptism, ask for the absolution, and come to His Supper. The anxious question can then be laid down for good. Can Christ still be trusted when His servants fail? Yes. The Christian’s confidence rests not in the character of the minister, but in the character of Christ, who attached His promise to His Word and Sacraments.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article VIII completes Article VII. Having defined the Church as the assembly of believers, the Confession guards that definition against two misreadings: that the visible presence of hypocrites unchurches the assembly, and that an unworthy minister voids the gifts. It answers that the Church in this life is a mixed body (the wheat and the weeds grow together until the harvest, Matthew 13; “the Lord knows those who are his,” 2 Timothy 2:19), and that the Word and Sacraments are “effectual by reason of the institution and commandment of Christ, notwithstanding they be administered by evil men” (AC VIII; Matthew 23:2).
Against the Donatists, the ancient North African party who held that sacraments from unworthy clergy were void, the Confession stands with the ancient Church and with Augustine’s answer. When anyone baptizes, it is Christ who baptizes, so the gift is His and cannot be spoiled by the servant.
A necessary distinction keeps this consistent with Article V. The Sacrament is valid because Christ instituted it (yes, despite an unworthy minister), and it is beneficial to those who receive it in faith. Nearly every tradition agrees against Donatism: Rome on the minister acting in persona Christi (language close to the Apology’s own, Ap VII–VIII.28), Orthodoxy on the mystery being Christ’s own, and the Reformed and Anglicans almost verbatim (Westminster’s “not upon the piety or intention of him that doth administer,” and Article XXVI of the Thirty-Nine Articles). The live difference is not whether the gifts work but the shape of the visible church. The “regenerate church membership” ideal of the Anabaptist and much of the Baptist world is a concern about the purity of membership, not the Donatist claim about the validity of the ministry, and it must never be confused with it.
The pastoral point is comfort, held with two cautions (it does not excuse ministerial sin, and it does not diminish the office). What God did in your baptism, God did, because the certainty of the Gospel rests on the faithfulness of Christ, not on the consistency of His servants.
8.2 Table
Table 8.1—Does the Minister’s Worthiness Matter? The Donatist Question Across Traditions
| Tradition | Does an unworthy minister invalidate the gift? | Presses a visibly “pure” membership? |
|---|---|---|
| Donatist (historic) | Yes—void; must be redone | Yes (a church of the uncompromised) |
| Lutheran | No—effectual by Christ’s institution | No (mixed body; two marks) |
| Roman Catholic | No—ex opere operato; in persona Christi | No |
| Eastern Orthodox | No (within the Church)—the mystery is Christ’s | No |
| Reformed / Presbyterian | No—“not upon the piety or intention of him that doth administer” | Somewhat—some confessions (Scots, Belgic) make discipline a third mark |
| Anglican | No—Thirty-Nine Articles, Art. XXVI | No |
| Baptist | No—the ordinance is Christ’s, not the administrator’s | Yes—regenerate church membership |
| Anabaptist / Mennonite | No—Schleitheim disciplines unfaithful members and shepherds; it does not void their acts | Yes—the ban and separation |
Confidence: high on the Lutheran, Roman Catholic, Reformed/Presbyterian, and Anglican rows; moderate on the Orthodox, Baptist, and Anabaptist rows. Orthodoxy ties sacramental validity to the canonical Church, a question about the Church’s boundary, not the minister’s worthiness. The two columns are distinct questions and must not be collapsed into a single “pure vs. impure” scale.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Ex opere operato—“from the work worked,” the medieval and Roman term for the Sacrament’s working; the Confessions affirm the gift’s objectivity but reject the phrase, which the scholastics used to mean benefit without faith (AC XIII.3; Ap XIII.18).
- Sacrament—a rite commanded by Christ, to which God has joined the promise of grace.
- Word and Sacrament—the means through which the Holy Spirit gives faith and forgiveness (AC V).
- The marks of the church—the signs by which the Church is found: the Gospel purely taught and the Sacraments rightly administered (AC VII; see chapter 7).
8.4 Further reading
- The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC VIII; Apology VII–VIII (“Of the Church”); Large Catechism IV.10, 16–22 (Baptism as God’s own work) and V.15–17 (a wicked minister and the true Sacrament).
- Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3.
- Augustine, On Baptism, Against the Donatists; Peter Brown, Augustine of Hippo: A Biography; W. H. C. Frend, The Donatist Church (for a fair account of the movement).
- For the comparisons, from their own sources: Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1128, 1584 and Trent Session VII; the Westminster Confession (ch. 25, 27–28) and the Thirty-Nine Articles (Art. XXVI); the Scots Confession (ch. 18) and the Belgic Confession (art. 29); the Schleitheim (1527) and Dordrecht (1632) confessions for the Anabaptist “gathered church.”
Footnotes
-
Vladimir Berzonsky, “Sinful Priests and Sacred Mysteries,” Orthodox Church in America, July 7, 2002, https://www.oca.org/reflections/berzonsky/sinful-priests-and-sacred-mysteries. ↩
-
The Standing Conference of Canonical Orthodox Bishops in America (SCOBA), Guidelines for Orthodox Christians in Ecumenical Relations (1966), directs the priest to receive a convert by one of the three modes of Trullo canon 95 (baptism, chrismation, or confession of faith) and requires baptism of one not baptized “in a Christian church whose baptism could be accepted in the Orthodox Church by the principle of oikonomia”; quoted in John H. Erickson, “The Reception of Non-Orthodox into the Orthodox Church: Contemporary Practice,” St Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 41 (1997): 1–17, at 2. Erickson adds that practice “varies considerably from one Orthodox Church to another” (1). Ware defines economy in canon law as “a departure from the rules of the Church, so as to assist the salvation of particular persons”: Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, new ed. (London: Penguin, 1993), 311 n. 1. ↩
-
No one is to be rebaptized (LC IV.55). Receiving the Sacraments from unworthy ministers is no sin, because they act in Christ’s stead (Ap VII–VIII.28–29). The absolution is “the voice of God” (AC XXV.3–4). The Supper rests on Christ’s words: “No matter whether you are worthy or unworthy, you have here His body and blood by virtue of these words which are added to the bread and wine” (LC V.16–18). ↩
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.