Books · Letters to a Young Pastor

Know When to Leave

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

November 2026


Dear Young Pastor,

Do not decide to leave in the middle of a crisis and do not decide alone. The first hard season will come. A faction forms, a council meeting runs late with raised voices, and the call lists (the congregations looking for a pastor) suddenly look very attractive. Every faithful ministry has stretches where the people are difficult and the fruit is invisible. Paul did not give up on the Corinthians, troublesome as they were. A pastor who leaves every time the work gets hard never learns what God might have done through him once the hard season had passed.

Knowing when your time in a place is truly finished begins with what a call is. Our Confessions teach that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments “unless he be regularly called” (AC XIV). God calls through His Church, so the call came to you from outside yourself and was never a private arrangement between you and your ambition. Therefore it ordinarily ends the way it began, through the Church, whether by another call or by the process your church body has for this. You must not treat a resignation letter as a private matter between you and your frustration. Your feelings are a poor guide here, since they rise and fall with your sleep, your health, and last Sunday’s attendance. The Lord has given you surer means: a call from another congregation that comes through the proper channels, the counsel of brother pastors and of your bishop or dean, and prayer that goes on longer than feels necessary.

There are signs worth bringing to those brothers. Sometimes the work you were called to do is simply finished. The building project is done, the hard transition has been made, the congregation has healed, and what it needs next is a different kind of pastor than you are. Sometimes the congregation can no longer hear the Word from you, although it would hear the same Word from someone else. When the conflict in a parish is no longer about the Gospel but about you, it is time to ask honest questions. Sometimes, too, a pastor has simply stayed too long, out of habit or because he cannot imagine the congregation without him. He rarely sees it, because staying never feels like a decision.

Other signs concern your own heart and belong first to repentance. You may find that you are preaching to the congregation you wish you had instead of the one you have. You may notice that you no longer pray for your people by name, or that you dread certain faces on Sunday morning and have stopped asking God to change your heart toward them. Those are reasons to repent before they are reasons to go anywhere else. Rest, confess your sins, and hear the absolution. Then see whether the urge to leave is still there.

Scripture also shows us what a good leaving looks like. When Paul said farewell to the elders at Ephesus he did not slip away quietly or leave in anger. He told them the truth, warned them about what was coming, and then said, “And now I commend you to God and to the word of his grace, which is able to build you up and to give you the inheritance among all those who are sanctified” (Acts 20:32). Then “he knelt down and prayed with them all. And there was much weeping on the part of all; they embraced Paul and kissed him” (Acts 20:36–37). If you do conclude that your time is ending, leave like that. Do not take a faction with you. Tell the congregation the truth as kindly as you can, thank them, and commend them to God and to the word of His grace.

Please remember, whichever way it goes, that you do not leave as a man with a debt to settle. You will have gotten some things wrong in that place and Christ has forgiven them. The word of His grace, which Paul said “is able to build you up,” is able to build up the departing pastor as well as the people he leaves behind. You do not have to stay to make up for your failures and you do not have to leave carrying them.

Then, once you have gone, let them go. Do not keep pastoring them from a distance or answer every phone call from the members who wish you had stayed. If they come to you complaining about the new pastor, send them back to him. Speak well of him, in public and in private, and do not let anyone draw you into comparisons. Pray for him by name. Their next pastor will need room to become their pastor and you owe him that.

You will often hear it said that a pastor should never resign on a Monday. It is common advice among pastors and I believe it is sound, because the day after Sunday is the worst day to judge a ministry. Wait until you can see clearly, take counsel, and then do what is faithful, whether that means staying or going.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
Church and Ministry
Scripture
Acts 20:32Acts 20:36–37
Confessions
AC XIV

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.