Books · Letters to a Young Pastor
What Is a Pastor?
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
A Foundation for the Letters
November 2026
Dear Young Pastor,
What is a pastor? You may think seminary settled that question for you. However, the congregation you serve will answer it in more ways than your professors did. One member expects a preacher and another expects a chaplain who appears whenever someone is in the hospital. The council may expect a manager and the wider community a civic leader. The family in crisis will want a counselor who is available at any hour of the night. Each of these expectations holds a piece of the truth, yet none of them, taken alone, is what the Church has meant by the word.
The thirty letters that follow are short and practical and every one of them assumes an answer to that question, which this letter tries to give. The Scriptures, the Confessions, the early Fathers, and the Lutheran teachers who came after them have a good deal to say about it and I have drawn on all four: what the calling is, what the work is, what does not belong to you, how a ministry goes well or badly, and how it ends. It is longer than the other letters so you may want a second cup of coffee.
The Calling
The word pastor is simply the Latin word for a shepherd. Behind it stands the Greek poimēn (“shepherd”), a herdsman’s word that the New Testament also uses for the overseers of the Christian congregations in Ephesians 4:11, where the ESV speaks of “the shepherds and teachers.” Before the title belonged to you it belonged to Christ. “I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep” (John 10:11). Peter calls Him “the Shepherd and Overseer of your souls” (1 Peter 2:25). Every pastor is therefore an under-shepherd and the flock is His.
The office belongs to Him as well. On the evening of the resurrection Jesus said to His disciples, “Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, even so I am sending you.” Then John records that “he breathed on them and said to them, ‘Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld’” (John 20:21–23). For this reason the Augsburg Confession teaches that God instituted the ministry of teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments so that we might obtain faith (AC V 1). The Apology goes a step further. It says that “the ministry of the Word has God’s command and glorious promises,” and that the Church’s command to appoint ministers “should be most pleasing to us, because we know that God approves this ministry, and is present in the ministry” (Ap XIII 11–12). God established the office before He put anyone into it.
How does a man come to hold it? Seminary probably taught you to speak of an inner call and an outer call. The inner call is the desire for the work and Scripture honors that desire: “If anyone aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a noble task” (1 Timothy 3:1). However, the Lutheran Church has never rested the ministry on that desire. The Augsburg Confession says that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he is rite vocatus. The Latin means “rightly called” and the Triglotta renders the phrase “unless he be regularly called” (AC XIV). Either way, the call in view is the external call of the Church. The Lord complained through Jeremiah about men who went without one: “I did not send the prophets, yet they ran” (Jeremiah 23:21). The desire alone cannot bear that weight, because desire can be mistaken and it rises and falls with your health, your family, and the last council meeting, while the call of the Church stands outside of you.
Martin Chemnitz made the practical point in his Enchiridion, the handbook he prepared for examining pastors. One reason he gives for requiring a legitimate call is the minister’s own need to be certain that God has placed him where he is and will work through him. That certainty is his comfort when the work turns hard. After a bruising week you will get little help from remembering how strongly you once felt drawn to ministry and a great deal of help from remembering that the Church called you, in good order, through people who prayed over the decision.
The Church has the right to issue that call because Christ gave the office to the Church. The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope was written when the bishops of the day refused to ordain evangelical pastors. It says that in such a case the churches keep their own right: “For wherever the Church is, there is the authority [command] to administer the Gospel. Therefore it is necessary for the Church to retain the authority to call, elect, and ordain ministers” (Tr 66–67). Two paragraphs later, appealing to Peter’s words about the royal priesthood (1 Peter 2:9), it concludes that the true Church “certainly has the right to elect and ordain ministers since it alone has the priesthood” (Tr 69). You should know that not every church answers the question this way. Roman Catholic, Orthodox, and Anglican Christians tie ordination to bishops in the historic succession and they hold that conviction seriously. Some Lutheran churches have kept the succession as well, as a matter of good order. Our Confessions do not make it necessary for a valid ministry and you should be able to say why without contempt for those who believe otherwise.
The priesthood of all believers belongs in this picture too. Young pastors sometimes treat it as a threat to the office and laymen as a reason to do without one. Luther held the two together. In his Open Letter to the Christian Nobility (1520) he insisted that every baptized Christian is a priest, “though it is not seemly that every one should exercise the office. Nay, just because we are all in like manner priests, no one must put himself forward and undertake, without our consent and election, to do what is in the power of all of us.” The priesthood belongs to every Christian. The public office is exercised by those whom the Church calls to it and they serve in Christ’s stead. The Apology says that when ministers offer the Word and the Sacraments, “they offer them in the stead and place of Christ” (Ap VII/VIII 28). In other words, the man in the pulpit speaks for Christ because Christ sent him there through the Church’s call.
Lutherans have not always agreed on how to describe that relationship and you should know that before you take a side. In the nineteenth century C. F. W. Walther, the first president of the Missouri Synod, in his theses on Church and Ministry, taught that God confers the office through the congregation’s call, since the keys were given to the Church. Wilhelm Löhe, a Bavarian pastor who trained and sent pastors to America, placed more weight on the office as Christ’s gift handed on through ordination by those already serving in it, so that the office stands before the congregation for its good. Both held that the ministry is instituted by God and that no man appoints himself. Learn your own church body’s way of speaking about this and hold it charitably, since faithful Lutherans have stood on both sides.
Augustine kept office and priesthood together in a sermon he preached on the anniversary of his ordination: “What I am for you terrifies me; what I am with you consoles me. For you I am a bishop; but with you I am a Christian. The former is a duty; the latter a grace. The former is a danger; the latter, salvation” (Augustine, Sermon 340.1, as quoted in Lumen Gentium 32, a document of the Second Vatican Council). He was speaking as a bishop. I believe his words belong to the parish pastor just as much, because the Treatise, following Jerome, teaches that bishop and pastor are one office by divine right and that the difference between the two grades is a human arrangement (Tr 61–65). You will need both halves of his sentence, the first to keep you serious about the office and the second to remind you of something older than your ordination. You were baptized before you were ever called and in that Baptism Christ made you His own long before the Church made you its pastor.
The Responsibilities
The Augsburg Confession describes the work of the office in one sentence: “This power is exercised only by teaching or preaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments, according to their calling either to many or to individuals” (AC XXVIII 8). That phrase “to many or to individuals” covers most of what you will do. You speak the Word to the congregation on Sunday and the same Word to one person at a hospital bed later in the week.
If I could send you to one passage to read again and again in this office, it would be Colossians 1:24–29. There Paul calls himself a minister of the church “according to the stewardship from God that was given to me for you, to make the word of God fully known” (Colossians 1:25). Then he says what that looks like: “Him we proclaim, warning everyone and teaching everyone with all wisdom, that we may present everyone mature in Christ. For this I toil, struggling with all his energy that he powerfully works within me” (Colossians 1:28–29). The stewardship was given “for you,” for the people, while the energy that carries the work is Christ’s, working in Paul. You will not have enough of your own.
Preaching comes first because faith comes by hearing. Paul could not imagine doing anything else: “For necessity is laid upon me. Woe to me if I do not preach the gospel!” (1 Corinthians 9:16). In his farewell to the elders of Ephesus he could say, “I did not shrink from declaring to you the whole counsel of God” (Acts 20:27). The whole counsel includes the Law that wounds and the Gospel that heals and it includes the texts you would rather skip. Alongside the Word stand the Sacraments. Our Lord sent His apostles out “baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19) and on the night He was betrayed He gave His Supper to His Church. You administer both according to Christ’s institution and your church’s confession and practice. They are His gifts and you are the steward who hands them out.
The Office of the Keys is the third part of the same work. The Smalcald Articles define it this way: “The keys are an office and power given by Christ to the Church for binding and loosing sin, not only the gross and well-known sins, but also the subtle, hidden, which are known only to God” (SA III vii 1). In practice you announce forgiveness in the Divine Service and offer private confession and absolution, even if few people ask for it at first. On rare occasions it also means the harder work of binding. The Smalcald Articles describe the true Christian excommunication this way: “manifest and obstinate sinners are not admitted to the Sacrament and other communion of the Church until they amend their lives and avoid sin,” and they add that “ministers ought not to mingle secular punishments with this ecclesiastical punishment” (SA III ix). Binding is always done for the sake of the sinner’s return.
Teaching runs through all of this. Paul told Timothy, “Until I come, devote yourself to the public reading of Scripture, to exhortation, to teaching” (1 Timothy 4:13). You will teach the Catechism to children and adults and more than once to the same people. Gregory the Great, borrowing from Gregory of Nazianzus, warned that “one and the same exhortation does not suit all” (Pastoral Rule III, Prologue). The doctrine stays the same while the way you bring it to the grieving widow and the confident teenager will differ.
Then there is the care of souls, which German Lutherans call Seelsorge. Paul reminded the Ephesian elders that he had been “teaching you in public and from house to house” (Acts 20:20). Gregory called the government of souls “the art of arts” (Pastoral Rule I.1). It is learned slowly, in living rooms and nursing homes. Prayer belongs here too. When the apostles handed the daily distribution to others, they kept prayer and the ministry of the Word for themselves (Acts 6:4). Pray for your people by name and pray for the ones who trouble you most.
You also guard the doctrine. The overseer “must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it” (Titus 1:9). The Augsburg Confession counts the judging of doctrine and the rejecting of doctrines contrary to the Gospel among the duties of the office and adds that this is done without human force, by the Word alone (AC XXVIII 21–22). You will use it more often in a Bible class or a quiet conversation than in public controversy.
Lastly, you are to be an example. The Table of Duties in the Small Catechism gathers the passages “For Bishops, Pastors, and Preachers” from 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1: “A bishop must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober,” and so on (SC, Table of Duties). It is interesting how little of that list concerns skill and how much concerns the man’s life. Paul told Timothy, “Keep a close watch on yourself and on the teaching. Persist in this, for by so doing you will save both yourself and your hearers” (1 Timothy 4:16). No man keeps such a watch by his own strength and the same Lord who put you in the office keeps forgiving the man who holds it.
What Is Not the Pastor’s
Your calendar will soon fill with work that nobody wrote into your letter of call. You may be expected to run the congregation like a chief executive, raise the money, provide therapy, speak to the issues of the day, do all the visiting, rule the council, and save a declining parish by your own energy. Someone has to do some of these tasks. Very few of them are yours by divine call.
Gregory the Great saw this temptation fourteen hundred years ago. He warned against pastors who forget that they “have been put over their brethren for their souls’ sake” and who give themselves to secular business instead. His counsel was measured: “Secular employments, therefore, though they may sometimes be endured out of compassion, should never be sought after out of affection for the things themselves” (Pastoral Rule II.7). In the same chapter he warned pastors not to neglect the bodily needs of their people either. Therefore you will care about the building and the budget and you will help the family whose rent is due. However, you will not let those things become the work you love. The apostles drew the same line when they had seven men chosen to serve tables (Acts 6:2–4), as Letter 14, The Church Council Is Not Your Enemy, describes.
The Confessions draw a second line, between the power of the Church and the power of the state. The power of the Church, says the Augsburg Confession, “does not interfere with civil government; no more than the art of singing interferes with civil government” (AC XXVIII 10). Therefore the two “must not be confounded” (AC XXVIII 12). The article then cites our Lord’s own refusal when a man asked Him to settle a family inheritance: “Man, who made me a judge or arbitrator over you?” (Luke 12:14). You will preach the whole Law, including the commandments that touch public life, and you will speak plainly where God’s Word speaks plainly. Telling your people which candidate to support or how to vote on a bill is a different thing. It borrows the authority of the pulpit for a judgment that belongs to Christians in their civic vocations.
Therapy is another such boundary. The care of souls applies God’s Law and Gospel to a person’s conscience and no one else is called to do it. Clinical treatment of depression, addiction, or trauma is a different vocation that requires training you do not have. When a member needs that help, refer him to it and keep visiting, praying, and absolving.
You are also not the congregation’s only teacher or its only visitor. The Smalcald Articles say that the Gospel comes to us through preaching, Baptism, the Sacrament of the Altar, and the keys, “and also through the mutual conversation and consolation of brethren” (SA III iv). The father who teaches the Catechism at his table and the member who sits with a dying neighbor are doing God’s work in their own callings. Your task is to equip them for it, as Letter 19, Leave the Congregation Better Than You Found It, describes.
Nor are you lord of the council or of the congregation. Paul wrote, “Not that we lord it over your faith, but we work with you for your joy” (2 Corinthians 1:24). John Chrysostom drew the consequence: “For Christians above all men are not permitted forcibly to correct the failings of those who sin,” since “in our case the wrong-doer must be made better, not by force, but by persuasion” (On the Priesthood II.3).
Lastly, you are not the congregation’s savior. Letter 1 says that at length so I will leave it there.
When It Is Working
How will you know whether your ministry is faithful? The world will answer with attendance, offerings, and new members. Those numbers are worth watching because they are people. Yet the numbers rise and fall for many reasons that have nothing to do with faithfulness and the Church has never measured a ministry by them.
The Augsburg Confession describes the Church as the assembly where the Gospel is purely taught and the Sacraments are rightly administered (AC VII 1). Those are the first marks of a ministry that is working. Beyond them, look for 1) consciences that are comforted, so that people leave the Divine Service and the sickroom knowing that their sins are forgiven; 2) people who are catechized and can give a simple account of what they believe; 3) the sick, the homebound, and the grieving visited, by you and by others; 4) members serving faithfully in their own vocations at home, at work, and in the community; and 5) love among the members, including patience with one another when they disagree. John wrote, “I have no greater joy than to hear that my children are walking in the truth” (3 John 4). A congregation that is at peace and growing in the truth is a ministry that is working, whatever its size.
Much of that fruit will be invisible to you. The Word works slowly and often out of sight, which is why Scripture speaks so much about perseverance. “And let us not grow weary of doing good, for in due season we will reap, if we do not give up” (Galatians 6:9). The promise attaches to the labor and leaves the harvest in God’s hands.
When the work does go well, be careful. Gregory gave the last book of his Pastoral Rule to the preacher who has done everything well, warning that he “should return to himself, lest either his life or his preaching lift him up” (Pastoral Rule IV). Give thanks for the good days and pray through them as you prayed through the hard ones.
When It Is Not Working
Some ministries do go wrong and it is foolish to pretend otherwise. The signs are usually plain enough. Conflict stops resolving and simply moves from one issue to the next. The pastor stops praying except in public and stops studying except to prepare the next sermon, or he finds an exhaustion that rest no longer touches. His preaching can turn into grievance, so that the sermon is aimed at a few people in the pews and the rest of the congregation knows it. Sometimes a congregation has decided it will not hear the Word at all.
Be careful how you read that last sign. Jesus told the Twelve to “shake off the dust from your feet” where they were not received (Matthew 10:14). Those words were spoken in mission, to hearers who rejected the Gospel outright. A congregation that resists a sermon on stewardship has not done that. Paul never gave up on the Corinthians. Scripture does warn that “the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching,” and the next words are for the pastor: “But as for you, always be sober-minded, endure suffering, do the work of an evangelist, fulfill your ministry” (2 Timothy 4:3–5). Suffering for faithfulness is part of the office.
The honest question is which kind of difficulty you are facing. When people resist the Word itself, you keep preaching it with patience. When they are resisting your manner, your impatience, or your private agenda, the problem is yours to repent of. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, in Life Together, warned a pastor against making himself his congregation’s accuser, before other people and even in his prayers, because the congregation was not entrusted to him for that. He was not forbidding lament. Bringing your grief and frustration to God is another matter and the psalms give you the words for it.
What should you do when it is not working? First, seek counsel. The “mutual conversation and consolation of brethren” (SA III iv) is meant for pastors too. Talk with a brother pastor you trust, and with your bishop or dean, before the trouble becomes a crisis. Second, rest and eat. When Elijah sat under the broom tree and said, “It is enough; now, O LORD, take away my life” (1 Kings 19:4), the Lord did not begin with a lecture. An angel woke him twice to eat and drink and only then did Elijah go on toward Horeb (1 Kings 19:5–8). Third, be patient. Many hard seasons pass and a pastor who leaves in the middle of one never learns what God might have done on the other side of it. Paul heard the Lord say, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Corinthians 12:9).
Sometimes, after all of that, the right answer will still be to go. Even then, do not decide it by your feelings alone. Bring it to the brothers who know you and to the counsel your church body provides and let the Church have its say in the ending as it did in the beginning. Letter 29, Know When to Leave, speaks to that decision.
Moving On
Every pastor leaves his congregation in the end, by a new call, by retirement, or by death. If God calls through His Church, then a pastor neither grabs at a call nor runs from one. Gregory of Nazianzus, who fled after he was ordained against his wishes and then came back, concluded that he had to hold the balance between two fears, “neither desiring an office not given to me, nor rejecting it when given. The one course marks the rash, the other the disobedient, both the undisciplined” (Oration 2.112). Ordinarily a call ends the way it began, through the Church, whether by another call or by the process your church body has for retirement and resignation. A man who was regularly called does not end his call by a private decision made in frustration. In practice, do not campaign for a call and do not use one as leverage with your present congregation. When a call comes, pray over it, take counsel from people who can see your ministry from outside, and decide where you can best serve the Church.
When you do go, go cleanly. Paul’s farewell to the Ephesian elders is the pattern. He reminded them that he had served among them openly and had taken nothing for himself: “I coveted no one’s silver or gold or apparel” (Acts 20:33). Leave the records in order, tell the truth kindly, thank the people, and commend them to God.
Retirement is the same letting go stretched over the rest of your life. Simeon, holding the infant Christ in the temple, prayed, “Lord, now you are letting your servant depart in peace, according to your word; for my eyes have seen your salvation” (Luke 2:29–30). Many Lutheran orders of service sing his song after Communion and it fits the end of a ministry just as well.
Letting go well asks two things of you. First, once you have gone, let the people go and give your successor room to become their pastor, as Letter 29 explains. Second, hand the people back to Christ. They were His before you came and they remain His after you go, as Letter 30, One Day, Someone Else Will Stand in Your Pulpit, describes. A retired pastor may find that the second half of Augustine’s sentence comes back into its own. He sets the office down and remains a Christian. He can sit in a pew, hear the Word, and receive the Sacrament from another man’s hands with real gladness.
A Closing Word
Gregory the Great finished his Pastoral Rule by confessing that in describing the pastor he had been “as an ill-favoured painter pourtraying a handsome man,” pointing others “to the shore of perfection” while he was himself “still tossed among the waves of transgressions.” He asked his reader to hold him up by prayer (Pastoral Rule IV). I can make no better claim for this letter or for the thirty that follow. The office I have described is larger than any man who holds it, including the one writing to you.
That is why it is good news. The office was instituted by Christ, the call comes through His Church, the Word and the Sacraments carry His power, and the people belong to Him. You are asked to be faithful with what He has given you for as long as He leaves you where He has put you. Read the letters with that in mind and take from them whatever helps.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
Sources
- Augustine, Sermon 340.1, as quoted in the Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium 32 (English text, vatican.va).
- John Chrysostom, On the Priesthood II.3, trans. W. R. W. Stephens, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series, vol. 9 (1889).
- Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 2 (In Defence of His Flight to Pontus) 112, trans. C. G. Browne and J. E. Swallow, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, vol. 7 (1894).
- Gregory the Great, Pastoral Rule I.1, II.7, III Prologue, and IV, trans. James Barmby, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, vol. 12 (1895).
- Martin Luther, An Open Letter to the Christian Nobility (1520), trans. C. M. Jacobs, Works of Martin Luther, vol. 2 (Philadelphia, 1915).
- Martin Chemnitz, Ministry, Word, and Sacraments: An Enchiridion (paraphrased).
- C. F. W. Walther, Church and Ministry (paraphrased).
- Wilhelm Löhe, writings on the ministry (paraphrased).
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Life Together (paraphrased).
- The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the Concordia Triglotta (1921), with Tappert paragraph numbers. Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.