Books · The Divine Liturgy

The Pastor's Movement, Direction, and Hand Positions

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

A Choreography of the Rite

The exposition of the Divine Service has so far traced the structure of the rite, the ceremonial gestures of pastor and congregation, the vestments and colors of the seasons, and the vessels and material elements. One further dimension deserves treatment in its own right: the pastor’s movement through the rite — where he stands, which direction he faces, what he does with his hands, when he moves from one place to another. The Divine Service is, among other things, a choreographed liturgical action, and the pastor’s bodily comportment within it both expresses and confesses what the rite is doing.

This dimension is not always given explicit attention in seminary training or in pastoral practice; pastors often learn their gestures by imitation rather than by careful instruction. The result is sometimes uncertain or inconsistent practice. A more deliberate awareness of the pastor’s bodily action serves both pastor and congregation — the pastor because he can comport himself more thoughtfully, the congregation because they can read the rite’s bodily language with greater understanding.

The Theological Framework

Before treating specific positions and gestures, the theological framework must be established. The pastor at the altar is not a private individual moving about in idiosyncratic ways. He is the holder of the office of the holy ministry, functioning in persona Christi — in the person of Christ — at certain moments, and in persona ecclesiae — in the person of the church — at others. His bodily movement embodies these dual functions.

When the pastor speaks to the people in Christ’s name — pronouncing the Absolution, reading the Gospel, speaking the Verba, giving the Benediction — he stands as Christ’s representative, with his action directed toward the people who are receiving the gospel and the gifts. When the pastor leads the people in prayer — at the Collect, the Prayer of the Church, the eucharistic prayer, the Lord’s Prayer — he stands as the people’s representative, with his action directed with the people toward God. The direction the pastor faces, the position of his hands, and the movements he makes through the rite are bodily expressions of these dual functions.

Direction: Ad Orientem and Versus Populum

The most fundamental question of pastoral direction is whether the pastor faces the altar (with his back to the people) or faces the people (with his back to the altar). The two arrangements have different histories and different theological implications.

Ad Orientem (Facing the Altar / Facing East). The historic Christian practice was for the pastor to face the same direction as the people — toward the altar at the east end of the church. This is called ad orientem (“toward the east”) because most ancient and medieval churches were oriented (the very word derives from this) with their altars at the east end, toward the rising sun and the direction of Christ’s expected return (Matthew 24:27; Acts 1:11). The pastor and people together faced east, looking toward Christ.

The theological logic of ad orientem is straightforward: in prayer, the pastor and the people are oriented together toward God. The pastor is not the focus of attention; he is leading the people toward the One they all address. The arrangement physically embodies the truth that worship is offered to God, not exchanged between pastor and people. The pastor’s back to the congregation is not a sign of disregard but a sign of solidarity — he stands with the people, facing the same direction they face, leading their prayer toward God.

Ad orientem was the universal Western practice from at least the fourth century until the mid-twentieth century. Luther retained it; the Lutheran Kirchenordnungen assume it; the Common Service tradition operated within it. Most pre-Vatican-II Roman Catholic Masses were celebrated ad orientem, as were most Lutheran services through the 1960s.

Versus Populum (Facing the People). The alternative arrangement, versus populum (“toward the people”), has the pastor stand on the far side of the altar with his face toward the congregation. The pastor and people thus face each other across the altar. This arrangement became widespread in Roman Catholic practice after Vatican II (though Vatican II did not require it) and has since spread to many Protestant traditions, including many Lutheran congregations.

The theological logic of versus populum is also straightforward: the pastor’s role in distributing Christ’s gifts is more visible when the people can see his face and his hands. The communicants can see the bread broken, the chalice presented, the consecration enacted. The pastor’s verbal proclamation is more easily heard when he faces the people. The Eucharist as a meal — Christ presiding at His table, the people gathered around — is more visibly enacted.

The Lutheran Position. The Lutheran Confessions take no position on the question, and both arrangements are adiaphora. Lutheran practice today is mixed. Many LCMS congregations retain ad orientem, particularly for the eucharistic prayer; others have moved to versus populum. WELS and ELS tend toward more traditional ad orientem practice; the ELCA tends more toward versus populum. The choice is best made on the basis of architectural considerations, pastoral preference, and congregational tradition.

Some congregations use a hybrid approach: the pastor faces the people for proclamation (readings, sermon, Absolution, Salutation, Verba in some traditions, Benediction) and faces the altar for prayer (Collect, eucharistic prayer, post-communion collect). This approach preserves the theological logic of both arrangements — pastor as proclaimer facing the people, pastor as prayer-leader facing God with the people.

Hand Positions

The pastor’s hands are theologically and ceremonially significant throughout the rite. Several distinct hand positions appear at different moments.

The Orans Position. The orans position (Latin orans, “praying”) is the ancient priestly prayer posture: both arms raised slightly outward from the body, hands open with palms facing forward or upward, elbows bent, fingers slightly separated. The position is attested in early Christian art — especially the catacomb frescoes of the second through fourth centuries, where worshipers are depicted in orans posture. It is the universal Christian gesture of prayer addressed to God, and it preserves the biblical priestly posture: “I desire then that in every place the men should pray, lifting holy hands” (1 Timothy 2:8).

The orans position is used by the pastor during:

  • The Collect of the Day
  • The Prayer of the Church (or portions of it)
  • The Preface and proper preface
  • The eucharistic prayer (where the rite includes one)
  • The Lord’s Prayer
  • The Post-Communion Collect

The position embodies prayer: the hands are open (receiving), raised (toward heaven), and outward (offering). Some pastors hold the orans throughout an extended prayer; others raise hands at the opening, lower them during the body of the prayer, and raise them again at the conclusion. Both forms are traditional.

Hands Folded. Hands folded — palms together, fingers pointing upward, thumbs crossed or one thumb resting on the other — is the standard reverent position when not actively gesturing. This is the position of attention, of reception, of reverent silence. The pastor stands with hands folded during the readings (when not reading), during the Sermon if seated, during the singing of certain elements of the rite, during the procession, and during moments of reverent pause. The hands-folded position is the “default” liturgical posture when no other gesture is being made.

A close variant is hands joined at the breast — palms together held against or near the chest. This is sometimes used during the Sanctus and the Agnus Dei as a posture of humble reception, distinguished from the simple folding by the proximity of the hands to the heart.

Hands Extended in Greeting. When the pastor greets the people, his hands move from folded to extended outward — arms slightly bent, palms open at chest height, hands toward the people. The gesture is welcoming. It is used at:

  • The Salutation (“The Lord be with you”) before the Collect
  • The Salutation before the Gospel
  • The Salutation before the Preface
  • The Pax Domini (“The peace of the Lord be with you always”)
  • The Salutation before the Benediction

The gesture is the bodily form of welcome — the pastor’s hands offer to the people what his words declare.

Hands Raised in Blessing. A more elaborate version is the full blessing position: both hands raised over the heads of the congregation, palms downward, fingers extended, in the ancient priestly gesture of blessing. This is the posture of Aaron blessing the people in Leviticus 9:22: “Aaron lifted up his hands toward the people and blessed them.” The position is used by the pastor for:

  • The Aaronic Benediction at the close of the rite (the principal use)
  • The Absolution (in some traditions, with one or both hands raised)
  • The blessing of the elements at the consecration (in some traditions)
  • Some forms of the Pax Domini

The hands raised in blessing — palms downward — distinguish this from the orans posture (palms upward toward God). The blessing flows downward from God through the pastor to the people; the orans rises upward from pastor and people toward God. The downward palms confess that what comes through the hands is not the pastor’s gift but God’s, descending upon the people through the office of the ministry.

Hands Over the Elements. During the Verba, the pastor’s hands take specific positions over the bread and wine. At “This is my body,” the right hand makes the sign of the cross over the host or bread (the index and middle fingers extended together, tracing a cross in the air just above the element). At “This is my blood,” the right hand makes the sign of the cross over the chalice. The left hand may rest on the host or the base of the chalice; or it may rest on the altar; or both hands may be held over the elements simultaneously, with the right hand performing the sign of the cross while the left supports.

After the consecration, the pastor’s hands may take the elevation position: both hands grasping the host (typically thumbs underneath, fingers on top, or one hand cradling and one supporting), lifting it slightly above the altar for the people to see. The same elevation may be performed for the chalice — both hands on the cup, raising it to eye level or slightly above.

The Receiving Posture. When the pastor himself receives the body and blood, his hands take a receiving posture: left hand under right hand, palms up, in the ancient Christian manner of receiving. For self-communion, the pastor places the host directly in his own mouth from his right hand. For the chalice, the pastor holds the chalice with both hands as he drinks, the same posture in which any communicant might hold the cup.

Hands at the Sides. When the pastor walks in procession, sits in his sedilia (chair), or stands without gesturing, his hands may simply rest at his sides. This is the natural rest position and requires no theological commentary; it is what hands do when they are not doing something else.

A Walkthrough of the Pastor’s Bodily Action

The following walkthrough traces the pastor’s position, direction, and hand positions through the Divine Service. The treatment assumes a Lutheran rite celebrated with traditional ceremonial; modifications for simpler practice should be obvious.

The Entrance

The pastor enters the chancel as part of the entrance procession, typically following the crucifer and torch bearers (or preceding the choir, depending on local custom). His hands are folded at chest level as he walks; his posture is upright and deliberate, the pace measured rather than hurried. Upon arriving at the chancel, the pastor bows to the altar — a profound bow from the waist — before ascending to his position. The bow is the bodily acknowledgment of the holy space and the altar at which he will minister.

The pastor’s position for the opening rite depends on the configuration of the chancel and the form of the service. In a traditional ad orientem arrangement, he stands at the foot of the altar steps or at the steps themselves, facing the altar. In a versus populum arrangement, he stands behind the altar, facing the congregation across it.

Invocation, Confession, and Absolution

For the Invocation, the pastor faces either the altar (ad orientem) or the people (versus populum). His right hand makes the sign of the cross over himself; in versus populum or when explicitly blessing the people, the gesture may be traced as a wide cross over the congregation. The voice and the hand work together: the words “In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit” accompany the four points of the cross.

For the Confession of Sins, the pastor turns to face the people for the invitation. His hands are slightly extended, palms open at chest level, gesturing welcome and invitation: “Let us draw near with a true heart…” He then turns to face the altar with the people (in ad orientem) or remains facing the people (in versus populum) for the corporate confession itself. During the corporate confession, his hands are typically folded at chest level, joining the people in penitence. Some pastors slightly bow during the confession, expressing with the body the contrition the words declare.

For the Absolution, the pastor faces the people directly — in both ad orientem and versus populum arrangements. His right hand is raised in blessing — palm forward, fingers extended upward — as he speaks: “Almighty God in His mercy has given His Son to die for you… I therefore forgive you all your sins in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.” At the trinitarian conclusion, his right hand traces a large sign of the cross in the air over the congregation. Some pastors raise both hands; others use only the right. The right-hand-raised gesture is the universal gesture of authoritative blessing, attested in ancient Christian art and continuous in Christian liturgical practice.

The Service of the Word

For the Introit, the pastor stands at the altar (ad orientem) or behind it (versus populum). His hands are folded if he is not chanting; if he chants the Introit, his hands may hold the service book or rest lightly on the altar.

For the Kyrie, the pastor faces the altar in the orans position — leading the people in the cry for mercy. In versus populum, he typically maintains the orans posture facing the people, since the orans is the prayer posture rather than the blessing posture. The orans says, “We are praying”; it does not say, “I am blessing you.”

For the Gloria, the pastor’s hands return to a more relaxed position — folded or at the sides — while the congregation sings the Hymn of Praise. The Gloria is the people’s song; the pastor joins them rather than leads them in the same way he leads the Kyrie.

For the Salutation before the Collect, the pastor turns to face the people. His hands are extended outward, palms open at chest height, in the universal gesture of greeting. At the people’s response “And with thy spirit,” the pastor’s hands return to folded or move directly to the orans position for the Collect.

For the Collect of the Day, the pastor adopts the orans position — both arms raised, hands open and slightly outward, palms facing upward or forward — and chants or speaks the Collect. The Collect is the most extended prayer in the Service of the Word, and the orans is its appropriate gesture. The pastor faces the altar (ad orientem) or maintains the orans facing the people (versus populum). At the conclusion of the Collect, the pastor’s hands return to folded.

For the Old Testament Reading, Epistle, and other readings, the reader (whether pastor or lay reader) stands at the lectern, facing the people, with hands holding the lectionary or resting on the lectern. The pastor, if not reading, stands with hands folded.

For the Gospel, if the pastor reads the Gospel (rather than a deacon or assisting minister), he moves from his usual position to the place of Gospel reading — either the lectern, the pulpit, or a position in the midst of the people. The Gospel Book may be processed with him, accompanied by torches. The pastor faces the people for the announcement and the reading. His hands may make the sign of the cross over the Gospel Book before reading; during the reading, his hands hold the book or rest on it; after the reading, in some traditions, he kisses the Gospel Book.

For the Creed, the pastor faces the altar (joining the people in their corporate confession of faith). His hands are folded. At the words “and was made man” (or “and became truly human”), he bows.

For the Hymn of the Day, the pastor’s hands are folded or at sides; if he is moving to the pulpit for the sermon, this is the time to do so. The Hymn covers the transition.

For the Sermon, the pastor stands in the pulpit, facing the people. His hands are free to gesture during preaching. Most pastors do not maintain a single hand position during the sermon; the natural movements of speaking govern the hands. The Sermon may begin with the Salutation, an invocation, or a direct address; many pastors begin with the sign of the cross and the trinitarian invocation, in which his hand traces the cross over himself.

For the Offertory, the pastor returns to the altar (descending from the pulpit). As the offerings (both the monetary collection and the bread and wine) are brought forward by ushers or elders, the pastor receives them — hands extended to take the vessels and the offering plates. The bread and wine are placed on the corporal at the center of the altar. The pastor’s hands then prepare the elements: placing the host or hosts on the paten, pouring the wine from the flagon into the chalice, arranging the vessels for the consecration. His direction during the preparation is typically facing the altar; his hands work with the vessels.

For the Prayer of the Church, the pastor adopts the orans position — facing the altar (ad orientem) or maintaining the orans facing the people (versus populum). He leads the petitions in this position; the people respond after each petition with the appointed response (“Hear our prayer” or “Lord, have mercy”). The orans is sustained throughout the prayer, embodying the church’s corporate intercession.

The Service of the Sacrament

For the Preface (Sursum corda), the pastor faces the people. His hands move through several positions corresponding to the words:

  • At “The Lord be with you” — hands extended toward the people, palms open at chest level
  • At “Lift up your hearts” — hands raised higher, palms upward (the gesture itself enacting the lifting)
  • At “Let us give thanks unto the Lord, our God” — hands joined or beginning to rise into the orans position

At the people’s responses, the pastor’s hands remain in the corresponding position until he speaks again. The dialogue is bodily as well as verbal — pastor’s hands and people’s voices working together.

For the Proper Preface, the pastor turns toward the altar (ad orientem) or maintains his position (versus populum), with hands raised in the orans position throughout the chanting or speaking of the preface. The proper preface is a prayer of thanksgiving and praise; the orans is its appropriate gesture. The pastor’s voice carries the theological content; his hands carry the prayerful disposition.

For the Sanctus, the pastor bows — a profound bow during “Holy, holy, holy” — and may stand upright again during the Benedictus qui venit (“Blessed is He that cometh”). His hands during the Sanctus are typically folded over the chest in the reverent posture, though some pastors maintain the orans throughout. Traditions vary; both are defensible.

For the Lord’s Prayer (where it occurs at this position in the rite), the pastor stands in the orans position, facing the altar or the people. The Lord’s Prayer is the church’s prayer, and the orans is its posture.

For the Verba (Words of Institution), the pastor’s hands and direction are central to the rite. The detailed handling of the Verba varies by tradition.

In ad orientem practice: the pastor faces the altar, with the elements before him. He bows slightly over the elements as he begins the Verba. At “This is my body,” his right hand traces the sign of the cross over the host (or over the bread if it is loaf bread). His left hand may rest on the host or on the altar. At the conclusion of the host consecration, he may elevate the host — raising it with both hands above the altar, holding it briefly so the people can see it, then lowering it. He may bow or genuflect after the elevation. The same sequence — sign of the cross, elevation, bow or genuflection — is repeated for the chalice at “This is my blood.” Throughout the Verba, the pastor’s voice is the principal medium; his hands serve and confess what the voice declares.

In versus populum practice: the pastor faces the people across the altar. His gestures over the elements are visible to the congregation: the sign of the cross, the elevation, the bow. The communicants can see his hands and his face throughout. The gestures are theologically the same; only the spatial arrangement differs.

For the Pax Domini, the pastor turns to face the people. His right hand is raised, palm forward, making the sign of the cross over the congregation as he speaks “The peace of the Lord be with you always.” The people respond “Amen.” In some traditions, the pastor extends both hands toward the people, palms open at chest level, in a wider gesture of blessing.

For the Agnus Dei, the pastor’s hands are folded over the chest in the reverent posture, possibly with a slight bow. The Agnus Dei is the congregation’s preparation for the Distribution.

For the Distribution, the pastor moves from the altar to the rail. He carries the paten with the hosts (or a ciborium) to the rail, where the communicants kneel. He distributes the host to each communicant — either placing it on the tongue or in the hand — while speaking the words “Take, eat; this is the true body of our Lord Jesus Christ, given into death for your sins.” In some traditions, he makes a small sign of the cross over each communicant as he gives the host. He moves along the rail, distributing to each in turn. After the host is distributed, he returns to the altar and prepares for the chalice; either he distributes the chalice himself or it is distributed by an assisting minister.

The pastor’s hands during the Distribution are working hands — holding the paten, taking the host between thumb and forefinger, placing it on the tongue or in the palm, then taking the next host. The chalice is held with one hand (or both) as it is presented to each communicant. The pastor’s face turns to each communicant in turn as he speaks the words of distribution; the action is intensely personal as well as liturgical — the gift is delivered face-to-face, hand-to-mouth or hand-to-hand, with the words spoken to this communicant about Christ for this communicant.

After all have communed, the pastor returns to the altar. He may consume any remaining elements (the consecrationist practice) or set them aside for reservation. He performs the ablutions — rinsing the chalice with water (which he then consumes or pours into the sacrarium), wiping the vessels, replacing the pall and veil. His hands work methodically through the cleansing; his direction is at the altar.

For the Nunc Dimittis, the pastor stands at the altar with hands folded or in orans, leading or joining the congregation in the canticle. At the Gloria Patri he may bow or make the sign of the cross.

For the Post-Communion Collect, the pastor adopts the orans position, facing the altar (ad orientem) or the people (versus populum). The Post-Communion Collect is the rite’s final prayer of thanksgiving, and the orans is its posture.

For the Salutation and Benedicamus, the pastor faces the people, hands extended in the greeting position. “The Lord be with you… Bless we the Lord. Thanks be to God.”

For the Benediction (Aaronic Blessing), the pastor stands facing the people with both hands raised — palms downward, fingers extended — over the congregation. This is the most prominent single gesture of the entire rite. As he speaks the three petitions, his hands may move gently through three positions, or remain steady in the blessing position:

  • At “The Lord bless you and keep you” — hands extended at face level, palms down, fingers slightly spread
  • At “The Lord make His face shine upon you and be gracious unto you” — hands held steady or making a slight forward motion toward the people
  • At “The Lord lift up His countenance upon you and give you peace” — hands held steady or extending slightly further

At the conclusion (“Amen”), he traces a large sign of the cross over the congregation with his right hand, his left hand at his breast or at his side. The people respond with the sign of the cross over themselves and the corporate “Amen.”

For the Closing Hymn and Recession, the pastor’s hands return to folded as he prepares to leave the chancel. Before leaving, he turns and bows once more to the altar — the same profound bow with which he entered, now in farewell. He then reverses the procession, walking out in the same posture as he entered — upright, deliberate, hands folded at chest level.

Variations and Hybrid Practice

The above treatment describes a relatively traditional ceremonial practice. Many congregations use less elaborate gestures; some use more. Several principles apply.

Consistency: whatever gestures are used should be used consistently from Sunday to Sunday, so that the congregation can read them. A pastor who maintains the orans during the Collect every Sunday teaches the people, over time, what the Collect is. A pastor who varies his gestures unpredictably gives the people nothing to read.

Purposefulness: each gesture should serve the rite. Random or distracting movements weaken the liturgical action. The pastor’s hands should not wander; his direction should not shift without reason; his body should be where the rite needs it.

Reverence: the pastor’s bodily comportment should reflect what the rite is doing. Casual posture during the consecration; theatrical gestures during the Benediction; idle hands during the Verba — all of these undercut the rite. The body of the pastor confesses what his voice declares, and inconsistency between voice and body teaches the people to discount one or the other.

Skill: gestures can be done well or badly. The bow that is timed correctly differs from the bow that is rushed; the orans that is held steady differs from the orans that wobbles. The sign of the cross traced confidently over the congregation differs from the sign of the cross sketched apologetically. The pastor’s ceremonial action is a skill that improves with practice, observation, and reflection. Seminaries do not always train pastors well in this skill; the wise pastor seeks instruction from older pastors who do the rite well, and watches himself in the practice of the rite.

The pastor’s body, like the pastor’s voice, is an instrument of the office. The Lutheran tradition has not legislated specific gestures but has commended substantial, deliberate, reverent action that serves the gospel rather than distracting from it. The choreography of the rite is not theatrical performance; it is the bodily expression of what the liturgy is. Where it is done well, it serves the worshiper’s reception of the gospel. Where it is done casually or thoughtlessly, it does not — and the pastor who shrugs at these matters as “mere ceremony” has not understood that the body is part of how the gospel comes to the people.

A Note on Versus Populum and Ad Orientem in Contemporary Practice

A final note on the question of direction. Contemporary Lutheran practice in the LCMS is divided. The 2006 Lutheran Service Book provides rubrics that accommodate both ad orientem and versus populum arrangements without privileging either. The ELCA’s Evangelical Lutheran Worship is more explicit in commending versus populum. WELS and ELS practice tends toward ad orientem more consistently.

The case for ad orientem in the eucharistic prayer is that the prayer is offered to God; the pastor’s facing God with the people embodies this direction. The case for versus populum is that the consecration is a gift from God to the people and is more visibly delivered when the pastor faces the recipients. Both are theologically defensible. The 1962 Vatican II reform that moved Roman Catholic Masses to versus populum was based on the recovery-of-the-meal argument; subsequent reflection (notably by Cardinal Ratzinger before his elevation as Benedict XVI) has argued that the recovery may have come at theological cost.

Within the Lutheran tradition, the question is unresolved and probably will remain so. Both arrangements are valid; both can be done reverently and theologically; both have advocates among confessional Lutheran liturgical theologians. What matters more than the spatial arrangement is the theological clarity of what the rite is doing: the proclamation of the gospel through Word and Sacrament, the giving of Christ to the people, the people’s reception of His gifts in faith, and the response of thanksgiving. Whether the pastor faces east with the people or faces the people across the altar, these realities remain the substance of the rite — and the pastor’s bodily comportment in either arrangement should make them visible.

Topics
Church and MinistryWorship and LiturgyThe Lord's SupperSuffering and Trial
Scripture
Matthew 24:27Acts 1:111 Timothy 2:8Leviticus 9:22

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.