Books · The Divine Liturgy

Pastoral and Practical Questions Concerning the Sacrament

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Elements, Accommodations, and Custom

The exposition of the Service of the Sacrament has thus far focused on the rite as celebrated in its normal course. A series of pastoral and practical questions inevitably arise alongside the rite, however, and these deserve treatment in their own right. What is to be done with consecrated elements remaining after the Distribution? Should the bread be leavened or unleavened? Must the cup contain wine, or may it contain grape juice? How does the church accommodate the recovering alcoholic and the celiac communicant? Should the pastor commune himself first or last? These questions are not peripheral; the wisdom or unwisdom of their resolution shapes the integrity of the Sacrament in the congregation’s life.

The Reverent Treatment of Unused Elements — Theological Foundations and Practical Procedures

After the Distribution is complete, the pastor inevitably faces the question of what is to be done with any consecrated bread and wine that remain. This is not a trivial concern. Lutheran theology confesses that the body and blood of Christ are truly present in the consecrated elements; the question of what to do with the remaining elements is therefore a question about the proper reverence due to Christ Himself.

Two Theological Positions Within Lutheran Tradition

Two principal Lutheran positions have been advanced on this question, both with confessional and historical roots.

The “Consecrationist” View. The first position holds that the sacramental union begins with the consecration (the speaking of the Verba) and continues thereafter — that the remaining elements after the Distribution are still the body and blood of Christ. On this view, the pastor and the congregation must treat the remaining elements with continuing reverence: consume them at the altar, reserve them carefully for distribution to the sick and shut-in, or reverently dispose of them in a manner that honors their character. This position is associated with Lutheran orthodoxy of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries (Johannes Quenstedt, Abraham Calov, Johann Gerhard) and is preserved in much confessional LCMS, WELS, and ELS practice today.

The “Receptionist” View. The second position holds that the sacramental union exists in the use of the Sacrament — that is, in the consecration-distribution-reception sequence prescribed by Christ — and not in any standalone existence of the elements outside this sacramental action. On this view, what remains after the Distribution returns to ordinary bread and wine, requiring no special treatment. This position has roots in certain Reformation-era Lutheran theologians (notably the Wittenberg Concord of 1536, which spoke of the presence as occurring “in usu”) and has been preserved by some modern Lutheran theologians.

The Confessional Lutheran Lean. The Lutheran Confessions, while not definitively resolving this debate, lean toward a robust real-presence position that has historically informed consecrationist practice. The Formula of Concord (Solid Declaration VII) emphasizes the objective reality of Christ’s presence in the consecrated elements, established by His Word. Luther’s own practice — preserved in the Formula Missae and continued by his colleagues — was to consume remaining elements at the altar after the Distribution, treating them as still the body and blood. Despite the theological debate, virtually all confessional Lutheran traditions practice reverence with the remaining elements; the disagreement is over how to theorize the reverence, not whether to practice it. The pastoral wisdom is to err on the side of reverence regardless of one’s theoretical position.

Option 1: Consumption at the Altar — The Historic Lutheran Practice

The most common and historically grounded Lutheran practice is for the pastor (assisted by other ministers, where appropriate) to consume any remaining consecrated elements at the altar immediately after the Distribution.

The Action. When the last communicant has received, the pastor returns to the altar with any remaining hosts and the chalice with remaining wine. He consumes the remaining hosts directly. He drinks the remaining wine. Where the quantity is substantial, assisting ministers (other pastors, ordained deacons, or in some traditions trained elders) may assist in the consumption. The action is reverent but not dramatic; the goal is simply that nothing consecrated remains unaccounted for at the conclusion of the Distribution.

Theological Logic. This practice has two principal theological logics. First, it sidesteps the consecrationist/receptionist debate entirely: if nothing remains, the question of the elements’ status after the rite does not arise. Second, it follows Luther’s own custom and the practice of the early Lutheran Kirchenordnungen, which simply assume that the celebrant will consume what remains. It is the most theologically conservative practice and the one most consistent with the Reformation reform.

Pastoral Considerations. Where consumption at the altar is the practice, the pastor should plan the quantity of consecrated bread and wine carefully to avoid an unreasonably large remainder. Most experienced Lutheran pastors estimate the number of communicants and consecrate accordingly, leaving a modest remainder. Substantial leftover quantities create both practical difficulty (consuming a large amount of wine, in particular, is unwise) and pastoral difficulty (the impression that the consecration was unduly large). The general principle: consecrate modestly, with a small remainder that is easily consumed.

Pastoral Modeling. The pastor who consumes the elements visibly at the altar after the Distribution teaches the congregation, by his action, that what remains is what Christ has said it is. The visible action confesses the real presence in a way that words alone cannot.

Option 2: Reservation for the Sick and Homebound

A second option, supported by ancient Christian practice and preserved in many Lutheran congregations, is to reserve a portion of consecrated elements for distribution to those who could not attend the service — the sick, the homebound, the dying, the imprisoned. This practice is attested as early as Justin Martyr (c. 150 AD): “to those who are absent a portion is sent by the deacons” (First Apology 67).

The Practice. A small number of consecrated hosts is set aside in a pyx — a small covered container, typically gold or silver-plated, designed for transport. The pastor takes the pyx to the sick or homebound communicant, typically that same day or within a few days of the Sunday service. At the bedside, hospital, or care facility, the pastor reads a brief order of service — confession, absolution, Scripture, prayer — and administers the host (and, where practical, a small amount of wine) to the communicant with the appropriate distribution words. The communicant thus participates, retrospectively, in the Sunday eucharistic gathering of the congregation.

Storage of Reserved Elements. Reserved consecrated hosts are typically kept in a secure, reverent location:

  • A small locked cabinet or aumbry in the sacristy
  • A pyx kept in a vested case within the sacristy
  • In some higher-church traditions, a small tabernacle (though tabernacles are rare in Lutheran practice)

The location should be set apart, reverent, and accessible only to the pastor and authorized assistants. The reserved elements should not be displayed for adoration (which Lutheran theology rejects, as discussed below) or treated as a separate object of devotion apart from their use.

The Wine Question. Consecrated wine is more difficult to reserve than consecrated bread for practical reasons: it can spoil over even a few days, it can leak from any vessel, and it cannot be stored compactly. Many Lutheran congregations therefore reserve only the host for the homebound and consecrate fresh wine at the bedside (using elements brought separately from the Sunday consecration). Other congregations carry a small amount of consecrated wine in a sealed flask. Practice varies.

The Alternative — Fresh Consecration at the Bedside. Many LCMS pastors prefer not to reserve consecrated elements at all, instead bringing ordinary bread and wine to the bedside or hospital and consecrating them there. The pastor reads a brief order, speaks the Verba over the elements at the bedside, and administers the body and blood to the communicant. This practice has the theological advantage of avoiding the question of how long the sacramental union persists; the consecration occurs fresh at the moment of bedside distribution, with the full rite. The disadvantage is that the bedside celebration is less obviously a participation in the Sunday gathering of the congregation. Both practices have warrant; both are within the LCMS pastoral tradition. The LCMS Pastoral Care Companion (2007) provides detailed guidance for both forms of distribution to the sick.

Time Frame for Reservation. Where reservation is practiced for distribution to the sick, the consecrated elements are typically reserved only briefly — until the next opportunity for distribution, usually within the same week. Lutheran practice has never embraced the Roman Catholic practice of perpetual reservation (consecrated elements kept indefinitely in a tabernacle, used for Eucharistic adoration, processions, exposition through the year), which Lutheran theology rejects as detaching the Sacrament from its instituted use.

Option 3: Reservation for the Next Service — Generally Discouraged

A third theoretical option is the reservation of consecrated elements from one Sunday’s service for use at the next Sunday’s service — saving the labor of consecrating again. This practice is generally discouraged in Lutheran tradition for several reasons.

The Theological Concern. If the sacramental union begins with the consecration and continues, when does it end? At what point do consecrated elements cease to be the body and blood of Christ? The Lutheran tradition has not definitively answered this question, but the prudent pastoral position has been to consume or reverently dispose of consecrated elements within a relatively short time rather than to maintain them for extended periods. Reserving for the next Sunday’s service introduces theological complexity (the elements are reserved for a week, possibly in less-than-ideal conditions) and pastoral confusion (the next Sunday’s communicants would receive a mixture of newly-consecrated and previously-consecrated elements, with implications no Lutheran theological tradition has fully worked out).

The Practical Concern. Consecrated bread reserved for a week may not remain in good condition. Wafers can dry out; loaf bread can become stale, hard, or moldy. The risk of compromised elements is not trivial — the worshiper at the next Sunday’s Eucharist deserves bread that is recognizably bread, not week-old fragments.

The Confessional Concern. The Roman Catholic practice of perpetual reservation has been historically associated with Eucharistic adoration, processions, and other devotions that Lutheran theology rejects as detaching the Sacrament from its instituted use. The Sacrament was instituted to be eaten and drunk — “Take, eat… Drink ye all of it.” Reservation that becomes an object of adoration apart from the eating and drinking departs from the dominical institution. Even brief reservation that imitates the structure of perpetual reservation risks blurring this distinction.

The Standard Lutheran Practice. Consecrated elements are generally not reserved from one Sunday for the next. They are either consumed at the altar or reserved briefly for the sick (in which case they should be used within the same week, not stored for the next Sunday’s communion). The next Sunday’s Sacrament is celebrated with newly-consecrated elements.

Option 4: Reverent Disposal — The Sacrarium and Alternative Methods

Despite careful planning, occasions arise when neither immediate consumption nor reservation is the appropriate course. The pastor may have consecrated more than expected; assisting ministers may be unavailable; the elements may need to be disposed of for practical reasons. In such cases, reverent disposal — disposal that honors the character of what is being disposed of — is the Lutheran approach.

The principal mechanism for reverent disposal is the sacrarium.

The Sacrarium — What It Is, How It Works

The sacrarium (Latin “sacred place”; also called a piscina in older terminology) is a special drain located in the sacristy of the church — or, in some configurations, near the altar itself — that leads directly to the earth rather than into the regular plumbing system. The drain typically empties into:

  • A gravel-filled pit beneath or beside the building
  • The soil directly beneath the church
  • A small chamber outside the building that allows water to soak into the ground

The sacrarium ensures that any liquid passing through it returns to the earth rather than entering the general waste-water stream.

Why a Sacrarium? The theological reasoning is straightforward: things that have come into contact with the body and blood of Christ — water used to rinse the chalice, water used to wash the hands that have handled consecrated elements, water in which baptismal linens have been laundered — should not be discharged into ordinary sewers. The earth, into which the body of Christ Himself was laid, is the appropriate destination for water that has been in contact with the Sacrament. This is not a magical conviction but a confession of reverence: that what has touched the holy should not be casually disposed of.

The historical precedent for the sacrarium is medieval Western. The earliest sacraria (or piscinae) were stone basins built into the wall of the sanctuary or sacristy, draining through the church wall into the soil outside. Many medieval English churches preserve their original piscinae; some Reformation-era Lutheran churches in Germany and Scandinavia included them as standard sacristy features. The decline of sacrarium use in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries reflected the broader Pietist and Rationalist devaluation of sacramental piety; the twentieth-century recovery of sacramental reverence has prompted many Lutheran congregations to install sacraria in modern church construction.

What Should Go in the Sacrarium

The sacrarium is appropriate for:

  • Water used to rinse the chalice after the Distribution, when this water has contacted any traces of consecrated wine. This is the most common use.
  • Water used to wash the corporal, purificator, or pall — particularly the first rinse, which may carry traces of consecrated elements. The altar guild typically performs this first rinse over a sacrarium-equipped sink before regular laundering.
  • Water from the lavabo — the pastor’s ceremonial hand-washing before the consecration. (This is more debated; some hold that lavabo water need not go to the sacrarium since it has not yet touched consecrated elements, but most practice errs on the side of reverence.)
  • Water used to wash any other vessel that has held consecrated elements — for example, the ciborium or pyx.
  • Baptismal water after the rite, where the water has been blessed (in those traditions that bless the baptismal water with the Flood Prayer).
  • Holy water (in traditions that maintain holy water for blessings; this is rare in Lutheran practice).
  • Remaining consecrated wine that cannot be consumed and that the pastor determines should be reverently disposed of rather than reserved. This is a sensitive use and varies by tradition; the pastoral preference is for consumption, but in extremis the sacrarium is the appropriate route.
What Should NOT Go in the Sacrarium

The sacrarium is not appropriate for:

  • Ordinary cleaning water from the sacristy floor, the bathroom, or other parts of the church building.
  • Industrial waste, chemicals, paint solvents, or other substances that should not enter the soil.
  • Coffee, food waste, kitchen water, or other ordinary discard from parish kitchens or fellowship halls.
  • Cleaning chemicals or bleach — these contaminate the soil and defeat the sacrarium’s purpose.
  • Anything that has not come into contact with the sacred elements (with the exception of baptismal water and holy water in traditions that use them).

The sacrarium is specifically for water that has touched the Sacrament (or, by extension, baptismal water that has been blessed). To use it as a general drain is to undermine its specific theological function — and, practically, to contaminate the soil that should remain a fitting destination for sacred water.

Specific Practices for Each Element

Consecrated Wine. Should remaining consecrated wine be poured directly into the sacrarium? Practice varies. The historic Lutheran approach is to consume the remaining wine rather than dispose of it; this is the consecrationist instinct. Where consumption is impractical (a substantial remainder, pastoral circumstance, or the pastor’s health requiring restraint), some congregations pour the remaining wine into the sacrarium; others reserve the wine briefly for emergency use; others consume what can be consumed and reverently pour the rest. The general principle: wine is not poured into the regular sewer system; if it must be disposed of, the sacrarium is the appropriate route.

Consecrated Bread. Consecrated bread (hosts or loaf) should not be discarded in ordinary trash. Where consumption at the altar is impractical, the traditional options are:

  • Reservation for the sick — the most common practice
  • Consumption by the pastor later — eating reserved hosts before the next service, or as part of the pastor’s own devotional life
  • In some traditions, burning the bread and burying the ashes — a practice attested in some Eastern Christian traditions and rarely used in the West
  • Burial in the church grounds — physically placing the bread in the soil, returning it to the earth from which the wheat grew

What is not done: hosts thrown into the regular trash, or mixed with ordinary bread for casual consumption, or fed to animals (a particular abuse in some unfortunate historical instances).

Crumbs and Small Fragments. During the rite and the Distribution, small fragments may fall onto the corporal, the altar, or the floor. These are gathered by:

  • Brushing fragments on the paten or altar onto the corporal with the fingers or a small brush
  • Consuming the gathered fragments
  • Treating the corporal as itself bearing fragments — when laundered, the first rinse goes to the sacrarium
  • If fragments fall on the floor, picking them up reverently and consuming them (or placing them on the corporal)

The principle: nothing consecrated is treated as ordinary waste, no matter how small.

Alternative Methods Where No Sacrarium Exists

Many older Lutheran church buildings — particularly those built before the late twentieth century — do not have a sacrarium. The recovery of consecrationist piety and sacramental reverence in recent decades has prompted some congregations to install sacraria in older buildings; others have adopted alternative methods.

Burial in the Church Grounds. Some congregations bury remaining elements (consecrated wine after consumption is impractical, or ablution water) in a designated spot on the church grounds — typically a quiet corner of the property where the burial would not be disturbed. The practice mimics the function of the sacrarium without requiring building modification. A small ceremony, in which the pastor or a trusted lay member pours or buries the elements with a brief prayer, can accompany this.

Pouring on the Ground Outside the Church. Some congregations pour ablution water or other sacred liquids on a discreet area of the church grounds — onto plants, soil, or gravel — rather than through a sacrarium. The ground itself receives the water, accomplishing the same function as the sacrarium without the architectural requirement. A small designated area of the church garden or grounds may serve this purpose permanently.

The Garden or Courtyard. Some congregations have designated a garden or courtyard area as the place for sacred disposal. Plants are watered with the ablution water; the practice has a quiet pastoral elegance, returning the water that has touched the Sacrament to the soil that produces the wheat and grapes from which the Sacrament’s elements come. In Reformation-era and Scandinavian Lutheran tradition, this has sometimes taken the form of a “communion garden” — a small enclosed space on the church grounds maintained for this purpose.

A Sacrarium Bowl. Where no permanent sacrarium can be installed, some congregations use a portable sacrarium bowl — a basin into which sacred water is poured during the rite, and which is then carried outside and poured onto a designated patch of ground. This serves the function of a permanent sacrarium without the architectural requirement.

What is not done in any Lutheran tradition: the casual discharge of consecrated elements or sacred water into the regular sewer system, the throwing of consecrated bread into trash, or the treatment of any element that has been part of the Sacrament as ordinary refuse.

Detailed Practical Sequence at the End of the Distribution

The following sequence describes a typical careful Lutheran practice for handling unused elements at the end of the Distribution:

  1. Returning to the altar. After the last communicant has received, the pastor returns to the altar with the paten (any remaining hosts) and the chalice (any remaining wine).

  2. Consumption of remaining elements. The pastor consumes any remaining hosts directly, placing them on his tongue or in his mouth. He drinks any remaining consecrated wine. If the quantity is too substantial for one person, an assisting minister assists. If hosts remain after consumption is exhausted, they are placed in the pyx for reservation; if wine remains after drinking is exhausted, the chalice is set aside for ablution.

  3. Rinsing of the chalice (the ablutions). A small amount of water is poured into the chalice; the chalice is gently swirled to capture any remaining wine residue from the rim and interior; the rinse water is then consumed by the pastor (the traditional “ablutions”) or poured into the sacrarium. Where the pastor’s health or circumstance does not permit consumption, the sacrarium is the appropriate destination.

  4. Brushing of the paten. The paten is brushed lightly with the fingers or a small soft brush, sweeping any crumbs or fragments onto the corporal; these are then consumed.

  5. Folding and storage of the corporal. The corporal is carefully folded inward (to keep any remaining crumbs contained) and placed in the burse for storage and subsequent laundering.

  6. Vessel cleaning. The vessels are returned to the credence table or sacristy. After the service (or during the post-Communion hymn), the vessels are washed in the sacristy. The first rinse of vessels that have held consecrated elements goes through the sacrarium; subsequent rinses with soap and clean water can use ordinary plumbing.

  7. Corporal, purificator, and pall laundering. These linens are typically laundered before re-use. Traditional practice has been: a first rinse by hand (with the rinse water disposed of through the sacrarium), then ordinary laundering. Many congregations have a small group of altar guild members trained for this work.

  8. Restoration of the vested set. Once cleaned, the chalice and paten are re-vested (pall, corporal, purificator, veil, burse) and stored in the sacristy or aumbry until the next use.

This sequence accomplishes the goals of reverence, practical hygiene, and pastoral consistency. It is not elaborate; once learned, it takes only a few minutes after the Distribution.

Variation by Lutheran Denomination

The four major Lutheran traditions in North America have somewhat different patterns of practice, though all share the underlying commitment to reverence.

Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (LCMS). The LCMS official position, articulated in the 1983 Commission on Theology and Church Relations report Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper, encourages “reverent disposition” of remaining elements without mandating a specific practice.⁴¹ The pastoral instinct of LCMS practice is consecrationist: the remaining elements are treated as the body and blood of Christ and handled accordingly. The most common LCMS practices are consumption at the altar (the predominant approach) and reservation for the sick (also widely practiced). Reservation for the next service is rare. Sacrarium use is increasingly common in newer LCMS church buildings; older buildings often use alternative disposal methods. The 2007 LCMS Lutheran Service Book: Pastoral Care Companion provides extensive practical guidance for handling consecrated elements in pastoral situations including visits to the sick. The general LCMS preference is to either consume at the altar or to bring fresh elements to the homebound and consecrate at the bedside, minimizing the question of post-service reservation.

Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS). WELS practice closely parallels LCMS practice. WELS generally favors consecrationist disposition, with consumption at the altar as the predominant practice. The WELS Christian Worship (1993 and 2021) materials commend reverent handling of remaining elements without mandating specific procedures. WELS pastoral practice is somewhat more uniform than LCMS practice in favoring consumption over reservation, reflecting the WELS commitment to clear, consistent confessional practice. WELS pastoral training emphasizes the consumption-at-altar approach and the consecration-at-bedside approach for visits to the sick, with reservation reserved for unusual pastoral circumstances. Sacrarium use is common in newer WELS church buildings.

Evangelical Lutheran Synod (ELS). ELS practice closely parallels WELS practice. The smaller size of the ELS and the strong fellowship relationship with WELS means that ELS pastoral practice is generally similar to WELS. Consumption at the altar is the predominant practice; reservation for the sick is accepted but less common; the broader Lutheran consecrationist instinct shapes the approach. Sacrarium use varies; older Norwegian-heritage ELS buildings often use traditional alternative disposal methods (burial in the church grounds, the church garden), while newer buildings typically include modern sacraria.

Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA). ELCA practice is more variable than the three confessional Lutheran bodies. Some ELCA congregations maintain consecrationist practice closely paralleling LCMS practice; others have moved toward more receptionist approaches in which the remaining elements are treated less distinctly. ELCA pastoral practice is influenced by the broader liturgical-renewal movement, which has generally favored reservation for distribution to the sick (often in tabernacles or aumbries) as a recovery of patristic and Catholic practice. Sacrarium use is widespread in ELCA buildings, particularly in newer construction following the liturgical-renewal sensibility. The ELCA’s full-communion agreements with other denominations (Episcopal, Reformed, etc.) have introduced additional variations in practice. In general, ELCA practice falls within the range of historic Lutheran options but with more openness to practices closer to the Roman Catholic or Anglican patterns — including, in some congregations, the use of a tabernacle for reserved elements and a more developed reservation practice.

Convergence on Reverence. Despite these variations, all four traditions share the underlying commitment that consecrated elements deserve reverent treatment. None of them permits casual disposal, mingling with ordinary food, or trash disposal of remaining elements. The theological convictions about the real presence of Christ in the consecrated elements unite the traditions even where their specific procedures differ. A pastor from any of these traditions, observing a careful celebration in another tradition, would recognize the same fundamental commitment to handling the elements with the reverence due to what Christ has said they are.

The Altar Guild — Practical Care of the Sacred

Many Lutheran congregations have an altar guild — a group of laypersons (often women in traditional configuration, though increasingly mixed) who are responsible for the care of the vessels, linens, and paraments. The altar guild is typically trained in the proper handling of consecrated elements, the laundering of altar linens, and the maintenance of the sacrarium and other elements. A well-trained altar guild is one of the most valuable assets a congregation can have for the reverent care of the Sacrament.

Altar guild responsibilities typically include:

  • Setting up the altar before the service (placing the corporal, vesting the chalice and paten, lighting candles)
  • Preparing the bread and wine
  • Assisting at the credence table during the rite
  • Cleaning and storing the vessels after the service
  • Laundering the corporal, purificator, and pall (with first rinse going to the sacrarium)
  • Maintaining the seasonal paraments
  • Polishing the silver and brass vessels
  • Caring for the candles, especially the Paschal candle
  • Decorating the church for festivals

Training of altar guild members is itself a pastoral task. The work is not merely housekeeping; it is liturgical service. Members who understand why they do what they do — why the first rinse goes to the sacrarium, why the corporal is folded inward, why the chalice is polished — serve more devotedly and grow themselves in sacramental piety through their work.

A Final Theological Note

The Lutheran tradition’s care for the unused elements is not a fussy preoccupation with minor matters. It is the bodily expression of what the Lutheran tradition confesses about the Sacrament. Christ is truly present, in His body and blood, under the bread and wine. To handle the consecrated elements with reverence is to confess that presence. To handle them casually is to deny — by action, if not by word — what the Verba have declared.

This is why even congregations and pastors who hold the receptionist theological position typically practice consecrationist-like reverence: the action of casual disposal would be a poor confession of what the Sacrament is, regardless of one’s theoretical position on the precise moment when the sacramental union begins or ends. The Lutheran instinct is to err on the side of reverence — to consume rather than discard, to reserve briefly rather than dispose, to use the sacrarium rather than the sewer.

In an age when the broader American Protestant world has largely lost the doctrine of the real presence, the Lutheran tradition’s continued care for the consecrated elements is one of the most visible signs of its sacramental confession. The bread and wine, after the Verba have been spoken over them in the assembly, are not what they were before. The pastor — and the altar guild, and the congregation — who treat them with the reverence due to what Christ Himself has said they are are confessing the real presence in the most direct way available: not by argument but by action.

What is not done in confessional Lutheran practice: the casual mingling of remaining elements with ordinary bread and wine, the disposal of remaining elements in ordinary trash or sinks, or the treatment of the remainder as common food. The Lutheran sacramental realism — Christ truly present under the elements — requires continuing reverence at minimum, even where the precise theological status of the “moment” of presence is debated.

Leavened Bread versus Unleavened Bread

Christ’s institution of the Sacrament took place at the Passover meal (Matthew 26:17–29 and parallels), at which only unleavened bread (Hebrew matzah, מַצָּה) could be eaten according to Jewish law (Exodus 12:15–20; 13:7). The historical question of what kind of bread Christ used is therefore answered with virtual certainty: unleavened bread.

The Western Christian tradition has, since the early medieval period, used unleavened bread (typically pressed wafer hosts) for the Eucharist, in continuity with this dominical practice. The Eastern Orthodox tradition has used leavened bread (Greek artos, ἄρτος, in its developed eucharistic sense), on the theological ground that the leavened bread represents the risen and glorified Christ — the Lord of the New Covenant rather than the Old. This difference contributed to the polemics surrounding the Great Schism of 1054, where it became one of the contested matters between the Roman and Constantinopolitan churches.

The Lutheran Confessions treat the choice of bread as adiaphora — neither commanded nor forbidden, left to evangelical liberty. Luther himself used wafer bread, following the Western custom, but expressed no objection to the use of leavened bread where local custom or pastoral circumstance required. The Augsburg Confession does not legislate on this matter; the Formula of Concord notes only that the bread must be ordinary bread of the kind used as common food, not specially-prepared substance designed to lend the rite a quasi-magical character.

Modern LCMS practice overwhelmingly uses wafer bread. This has practical advantages: wafers are easily distributed at the altar rail, do not produce crumbs that complicate post-Distribution handling, store readily, and follow the Western catholic custom. Some LCMS congregations use leavened bread (typically a loaf broken by the pastor at the fractio panis, the breaking of the bread), and this is fully permissible — indeed, some pastoral arguments favor leavened bread on the grounds of its more obvious “breadiness” and its symbolism of the risen Christ. WELS, ELS, and most ELCA congregations follow the same general pattern (wafer bread predominant, leavened bread occasionally used).

The substance of the Sacrament is the bread that Christ blessed and the wine He used — that is, ordinary bread (whether leavened or unleavened) and natural wine. The form (wafer vs. loaf) is incidental to the sacramental reality, even though pastoral wisdom may favor one form over the other in particular congregations.

Wine versus Grape Juice

A more theologically significant question concerns the use of wine versus grape juice. The biblical and historical evidence is unambiguous: Christ used wine (Greek oinos, οἶνος — fermented wine, not grape juice) at the institution of the Sacrament. The Greek word oinos in the New Testament always refers to fermented wine, never to grape juice. The Passover cups were filled with wine. Christ’s first miracle was the changing of water into wine (John 2:1–11) — not into grape juice; if grape juice had been the substance, the steward’s astonishment at the quality of the late-served wine (John 2:10) would have been nonsensical. The Pauline rebuke of the Corinthian abuses of the Lord’s Supper included drunkenness at the eucharistic meal (1 Corinthians 11:21) — an abuse only possible because the cup contained alcohol-bearing wine.

The substitution of grape juice for wine in the Sacrament is a late-nineteenth-century American Protestant innovation. The historical origin is Dr. Thomas Bramwell Welch, a Methodist communion steward and dentist in Vineland, New Jersey, who in 1869 developed a pasteurization process that prevented grape juice from fermenting. Welch produced “Dr. Welch’s Unfermented Wine” for use in Methodist communion services, motivated by the temperance movement’s opposition to all alcoholic beverages. The product was adopted by Methodist, Baptist, and other temperance-influenced American Protestant denominations over the following decades. By the mid-twentieth century, grape juice was the standard communion element in most American evangelical churches.

The Lutheran tradition has resisted this innovation. The LCMS, WELS, ELS, and ELCA all officially use natural fermented wine for the Sacrament. The Lutheran position rests on three considerations.

First, dominical fidelity. Christ used wine; the church uses what Christ used. The Verba say “this cup is the New Testament in My blood.” The cup Christ blessed contained wine. To use a different substance is to depart from the institution.

Second, sacramental theology. The Sacrament is constituted by the divine Word joined to a specific physical element. Christ’s institution specified bread and wine. To substitute grape juice for wine is to alter one of the elements; this raises the serious question of whether the resulting rite is the Sacrament Christ instituted at all. Some confessional Lutheran theologians have argued that “communion” celebrated with grape juice is not the Sacrament at all but a memorial meal without sacramental efficacy.

Third, the historical witness. The unbroken practice of the church catholic for nineteen hundred years used wine. The use of grape juice is a recent and theologically motivated departure rooted in the nineteenth-century American temperance movement, not in any biblical or confessional warrant. The Lutheran tradition has no reason to follow this departure and good reason to resist it.

This does not mean the Lutheran tradition is indifferent to the pastoral concerns of those for whom wine poses a difficulty. The next section addresses this directly.

Pastoral Accommodations: Alcoholics and Celiac Disease

Two pastoral concerns regularly arise in modern Lutheran congregations: (1) members in recovery from alcoholism for whom the consumption of any alcohol is a serious danger, and (2) members with celiac disease or severe gluten intolerance for whom the consumption of wheat-based hosts can cause significant medical harm. Both deserve careful pastoral and theological treatment.

The Recovering Alcoholic. The question is whether and how a recovering alcoholic may receive the Sacrament without compromising sobriety. Several pastoral solutions have developed in confessional Lutheran practice:

  1. Communion under one kind (host only). The recovering alcoholic receives the consecrated bread but not the cup. Lutheran sacramental theology holds that Christ is fully present under either element — the body and blood are inseparably united with the risen Christ — so reception of one kind alone communicates the full benefit of the Sacrament. This was the general practice imposed on the laity in the medieval West, which the Reformation rightly rejected as the universal norm; but the Reformation never denied that individual pastoral circumstances might warrant reception under one kind. The Lutheran restoration of both kinds was a restoration of the proper norm, not the abolition of pastoral discretion. This is the principal LCMS pastoral approach to the recovering alcoholic.

  2. Intinction. The host is dipped in the wine and given to the communicant in a manner that conveys only a trace of wine. While intinction is not the LCMS norm (which distinguishes the distribution of bread and the distribution of the cup), some congregations permit intinction for those who cannot drink from the chalice. The trace amount of wine in intinction is generally not problematic even for many recovering alcoholics; pastoral consultation between communicant, sponsor (where applicable), and pastor is warranted.

  3. The “tiny sip.” A few drops of wine on the tongue is unlikely to trigger relapse in most cases of alcoholism, though this varies by individual and addiction profile. Where the communicant, sponsor, and physician agree that a tiny amount poses no realistic threat, this is a workable option.

  4. De-alcoholized wine. Some congregations have experimented with a de-alcoholized grape product (a wine from which the alcohol has been distilled off after fermentation). This raises theological questions about whether such a substance is “wine” in the dominical sense. The substance was once wine, by Christ’s standard; its current alcohol-free state is a post-fermentation manipulation. Most confessional Lutheran congregations have not adopted this practice for the principal cup but may use it as an accommodation cup for specific communicants.

The general LCMS pastoral approach is to favor option (1) — reception under the form of bread alone — as the most theologically clear accommodation. The recovering alcoholic is not deprived of the Sacrament; they receive Christ fully under the form of bread.

The Celiac Communicant. For those with celiac disease — an autoimmune condition in which gluten causes serious intestinal damage — the consumption of wheat-based hosts can cause significant medical harm. The pastoral options:

  1. Communion under one kind (cup only). The celiac communicant receives the wine but not the bread. As with the alcoholic, Lutheran sacramental theology holds that Christ is fully present under either element. Reception of the cup alone communicates the full benefit of the Sacrament. This is the most theologically straightforward accommodation.

  2. Gluten-free hosts. Many congregations now offer gluten-free wafers alongside the regular wheat hosts. These are typically made from rice or other non-wheat grains. The theological question — whether a non-wheat host is properly “bread” — is debated. The Roman Catholic Church requires that the host contain at least a minimal amount of wheat (specifically wheat starch with extremely low gluten content). The Lutheran tradition has been somewhat more flexible, with most LCMS, WELS, and ELS congregations permitting gluten-free hosts where pastoral need exists, though preferring traditional wheat hosts as the norm. The argument for gluten-free hosts is that ordinary bread in many cultures is not wheat-based; the argument against is that the apostolic and traditional bread of the Eucharist has been wheat-based since the apostolic age.

  3. Low-gluten wheat hosts. Specially-prepared wheat hosts with reduced gluten content (often called “low-gluten” hosts) are available and tolerated by many (though not all) celiac patients. These preserve the wheat substance of the host while reducing the gluten risk. For many celiac communicants this is the preferred accommodation: they receive a host that is still recognizably wheat bread.

The general LCMS pastoral approach is to use option (1) — reception under the form of the cup alone — for the severe celiac case, and option (3) — low-gluten wheat hosts — where the condition is less severe and the communicant prefers to receive under both kinds.

In both alcoholism and celiac cases, the pastoral principle is the same: no one should be denied the Sacrament because of medical circumstance, and Lutheran sacramental theology amply supports reception under one kind when pastoral circumstance requires. The Sacrament is given to comfort and strengthen sinners, including those whose bodies have been weakened by sin, illness, or the wreckage of human history. To withhold the gift on the ground that the recipient cannot tolerate one of the elements would be a pastoral and theological failure.

The Pastor’s Reception — First or Last?

A question of liturgical order that occasions some discussion is whether the pastor should receive the Sacrament first (before distributing to the congregation) or last (after the congregation has received). Both practices have ancient precedent and theological warrant.

The Pastor Communing First. The historic Lutheran practice — reflected in Luther’s own custom, preserved in the German Kirchenordnungen, transmitted through the Common Service tradition, and observed today in most LCMS, WELS, and ELS congregations — is for the pastor to commune himself first. The pastor consecrates the elements, then receives the body and blood, and then distributes to the assisting ministers and to the congregation.

The theological rationale for this practice is multiple. First, the pastor stands in the office of Christ at the altar; as Christ at the Last Supper took, blessed, and ate before distributing to His disciples (the verb order in the Verba — labōn, eucharistēsas, edōken — implies the celebrant’s prior reception in some readings), so the pastor in the public office of Christ receives first. Second, the pastor’s own communion confirms what he is about to do: he himself receives what he proclaims, so that no one may charge him with offering something he himself does not receive. Third, the practice symbolizes that the pastor is a fellow communicant with the people — he eats and drinks the same body and blood that the people eat and drink, not a separate or superior food. Fourth, the practical necessity: in a congregation of any size, the pastor cannot wait until after all communicants have received before himself receiving, lest the rite be unnecessarily prolonged or the pastor be tempted to slighting reception under the pressure of needing to attend to the assembly.

The Pastor Communing Last. Some traditions (notably the Roman Catholic Church since Vatican II in some practices, certain Anglican traditions, and many ELCA practices) have the celebrant receive last, after the congregation has been served. The rationale is the model of pastoral servanthood: the shepherd feeds the sheep before he eats himself. There is biblical precedent: Jesus serves His disciples at the Last Supper, and the imagery of the shepherd who lays down his life for the sheep (John 10:11) suggests that the pastor’s eating after the people emphasizes this servant character. Christ’s washing of the disciples’ feet (John 13:1–17) likewise foregrounds the servant model of pastoral leadership.

The LCMS, WELS, and ELS traditions favor the historic Lutheran practice (pastor communing first), though no Lutheran confessional document mandates this practice — it is, like the use of leavened or unleavened bread, adiaphora. The choice between the two practices is best made on the basis of pastoral and theological logic in each congregation, with strong preference in confessional Lutheran circles for the historic practice. ELCA and LBW-tradition congregations more commonly have the celebrant commune last; both practices are within the broader Lutheran liturgical family.


⁴¹ Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper: A Report of the Commission on Theology and Church Relations of the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (St. Louis: CTCR, 1983), section IV.C.

Topics
The Lord's SupperChurch and Ministry
Scripture
Matthew 26:17–29Exodus 12:15–20John 2:1–11John 2:101 Corinthians 11:21John 10:11John 13:1–17

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.